Stem cell transplants in utero for genetic diseases: treatment and a model for induction of immunologic tolerance

Primary Immunodeficiencies

Primary immunodeficiencies (PIDs), once considered to be very rare, are now increasingly recognized because of growing knowledge in the immunological field and the availability of more sophisticated diagnostic techniques and therapeutic modalities [161]. However in a database of >120,000 inpatients of a general hospital for conditions suggestive of ID 59 patients were tested, and an undiagnosed PID was found in 17 (29%) of the subjects tested [107]. The publication of the first case of agammaglobulinemia by Bruton in 1952 [60] demonstrated that the PID diagnosis is first done in the laboratory. However, PIDs require specialized immunological centers for diagnosis and management [33]. A large body of epidemiological evidence supports the hypothesis of the existence of a close etiopathogenetic relation between PID and atopy [73]. In particular, an elevated frequency of asthma, food allergy (FA), atopic dermatitis and enteric pathologies can be found in various PIDs. In addition we will discuss another subject that is certainly of interest: the pseudo-immunodepressed child with recurrent respiratory infections (RRIs), an event that often requires medical intervention and that very often leads to the suspicion that it involves antibody deficiencies [149].

Long-Term Acceptance of Renal Allografts following Prenatal Inoculation with Adult Bone Marrow

BACKGROUND

The aim was to investigate if intravascular in utero injection of adult bone marrow into swine fetuses could lead to macrochimerism and tolerance to the donor.

METHODS

Outbred Yorkshire sows and boars screening negative for MHC allele SLA of MGH miniature swine were bred. A laparotomy was performed on the sows at 50 days gestation to expose the uterus. Bone marrow harvested from SLA miniature swine was T-cell depleted and injected intravascularly into seventeen fetuses. Flow cytometry was performed to detect donor cells (chimerism) in the peripheral blood after birth. Mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) assays were used to assess the response to donor MHC. Previously frozen skin grafts from the bone marrow donor were placed on the offspring from the first litter. Donor-matched renal transplant from SLA donors were performed on chimeric swine, with and without a short 12-day course of cyclosporine, and one nonchimeric littermate.

RESULTS

Nine inoculated offspring demonstrated donor cell chimerism in the peripheral blood and lymphohematopoietic tissues. All animals with detectable chimerism within the first three weeks were consistently nonreactive to donor MHC in vitro. Animals challenged with donor skin grafts displayed prolonged graft survival without producing antidonor antibodies. All chimeric animals accepted donor-matched kidney allografts, even one without cyclosporine. The kidney in the nonchimeric littermate rejected by day 21.

CONCLUSIONS

Transplantation of allogeneic adult bone marrow into immunocompetent fetal recipients resulted in chimerism. In utero inoculation led to operational tolerance to the donor's major histocompatibility antigens and long-term acceptance to organ allografts.

Heterogeneity in fetal immunocompetence during the second trimester of gestation. Implications for treatment of nonimmune genetic disorders by in utero transplantation

OBJECTIVE

To address the role that alloreactivity may play and better define the window for histoincompatible stem cell transplantation in utero.

SUBJECTS, MATERIAL AND METHODS

We studied 9 fetal blood specimens obtained by cardiocentesis during elective abortions in the second trimester by multicolor flow cytometry and in vitro stimulation.

RESULTS

Lymphocytes ranged from adult levels (3/9) to >90% leukocytes. Six specimens had T cells within adult range. T cells in the other specimens were reduced, while B cells were conversely elevated. This variability did not correlate with gestational age, or leukocyte composition. Following 4 h of mitogenesis, fetal CD4+ and CD8+ T cells from 1 of 5 specimens showed a response similar to that of maternal T cells, while the other 4 specimens showed a diminished response (0.3 +/- 0.2-fold). This heterogeneity did not correlate with gestational age, or lymphocyte subset distribution. Following 18 h of in vitro mitogenesis, fetal T cells from 2 specimens showed a response similar to that of maternal T cells (0.8 +/- 0.2-fold). Despite that, one specimen gave a 3-fold greater response in a one-way mixed lymphocyte reaction vs. maternal cells compared to the other specimen.

CONCLUSION

We determine that fetal immunocompetence differs greatly during the second trimester and assessment of host vs. donor reactivity prior to in utero transplantation is likely to potentiate more favorable outcomes.

T-cell-depleted CD34+ cell transplantation from an HLA-mismatched donor in a low-birthweight infant with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency

The best strategy of hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) transplantation for low-birthweight (LBW) infants with severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) remains to be determined. To avoid the toxicity of drugs used for the transplantation and the risk of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), the authors performed allogeneic bone marrow HSC transplantation with a combination of CD34 selection and T-cell depletion in a LBW infant with X-linked SCID. The authors analyzed the process of T-cell reconstitution after the transplantation in this patient. The patient was born at 30 weeks and 2 days' gestational age via cesarean section. He was diagnosed as having SCID at birth. The patient received a transplant of 1 million CD34+ cells/kg body weight. Immunologic reconstitution was investigated by means of phenotypic analysis of T cells and genetic analysis of coding joint T-cell receptor rearrangement excision circle expression. Increases in donor-derived NK cells and T cells were observed 2 and 3 months after the transplantation, respectively. The patient had no infectious complications or GVHD despite the presence of SCID and prematurity-associated immunodeficiency. Analysis of T-cell regeneration pathways revealed that T cells reconstituted mainly via the thymus-dependent pathway. T-cell-depleted CD34+ cell transplantation would be a safe and useful therapy for LBW infants with SCID.

Donor cell expansion is delayed following nonablative in utero transplantation to treat murine mucopolysaccharidosis type VII

To block development of progressive childhood diseases, in utero transplantation (IUTx) requires immediate and significant donor peripheral blood (PB) cell amplification. To date, negligible and nontherapeutic donor PB cell levels have been observed postnatally, except in patients with immunodeficiency diseases. Donor cell fate in utero still is not clear. Ease of identifying and quantifying beta-glucuronidase (GUSB)-expressing donor cells in GUSB-null mucopolysaccharidosis type VII (MPSVII) mouse recipients allowed us to evaluate temporal donor cell engraftment and amplification post-IUTx. Like humans, MPSVII mice are unable to catabolize lysosomal glycosaminoglycans and progressively develop severe storage disease unless they are treated early in life.IUTx recipients were nonablated MPSVII fetuses and genetically stem cell-deficient, and hence myeloablated, W(41)/W(41) MPSVII fetuses. Donor GUSB+ cells were identified and counted in histochemical tissue sections. Quantitative results were confirmed by flow cytometry, enzyme analysis, and histopathology. Whereas GUSB+ cells engraft in most tissues in utero, significant amplification does not occur until the first postnatal week in the nonablated MPSVII hosts. In contrast, genetically myeloablated MPSVII recipients display widely distributed donor cell replacement accompanied by extensive amplification in utero. In both models, storage is alleviated in adult tissues with significant donor cell repopulation. To become therapeutic, IUTx must overcome the limitations of donor cell expansion in the highly competitive fetal environment. Fortunately, nonablative mechanisms to amplify cells in utero are coming on line.

Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation for severe combined immunodeficiency in the neonatal period leads to superior thymic output and improved survival

All genetic types of severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) can be cured by stem cell transplantation from related donors. The survival rate approaches 80%, and most deaths result from opportunistic infections acquired before transplantation. It was hypothesized that the survival rate and kinetics of immune reconstitution would be improved for infants receiving transplants in the neonatal period (first 28 days of life), prior to the development of infections. A 19.2-year retrospective/prospective analysis compared immune function in 21 SCID infants receiving transplants in the neonatal period with that in 70 SCID infants receiving transplants later. Lymphocyte phenotypes, proliferative responses to mitogens, immunoglobulin levels, and T-cell antigen receptor excision circles (TRECs) were measured before transplantation and sequentially after transplantation. Of 21 SCID infants with transplantations in the neonatal period, 20 (95%) survive. Neonates were lymphopenic at birth (1118 +/- 128 lymphocytes per cubic millimeter). Infants receiving transplants early developed higher lymphocyte responses to phytohemagglutinin and higher numbers of CD3(+) and CD45RA(+) T cells in the first 3 years of life than those receiving transplants late (P <.05). TRECs peaked earlier and with higher values (P <.01) in the neonatal transplantations (181 days to 1 year) than in the late transplantations (1 to 3 years). SCID recipients of allogeneic, related hematopoietic stem cells in the neonatal period had higher levels of T-cell reconstitution and thymic output and a higher survival rate than those receiving transplants after 28 days of life. An improved outcome for this otherwise fatal syndrome could be achieved with newborn screening for lymphopenia so that transplantation could be performed under favorable thymopoietic conditions.

Neonatal bone marrow transplantation for severe combined immunodeficiency

AIMS

To evaluate outcome following neonatal bone marrow transplantation (BMT) for severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) when there is a family history of a previously affected sibling, and to compare results with those published for in utero BMT.

METHODS

A retrospective review of cases referred and transplanted between 1987 and 1999, focusing on infectious and graft versus host disease (GvHD) complications after BMT, and T and B lymphocyte function. Thirteen patients received 18 stem cell transplants: four whole marrow, one cord blood, 10 parental T cell depleted (TCD) haplo-identical, and three TCD unrelated donor BMT. Nine were conditioned with busulphan and cyclophosphamide.

RESULTS

All are alive and well (six months to 11.5 years after BMT). Six had grade I-II acute GvHD and two chronic GvHD (now resolved). Three had a top up BMT for poor T cell function, one had a third BMT for graft failure and chronic GvHD, and one had a third BMT for graft failure. Twelve have good in vitro proliferation to T cell mitogens, and all have normal serum IgA levels. Three receive intravenous immunoglobulin; for one of these, it is less than one year since BMT. Nine are above the 2nd centile, and 10 of 12 old enough to be assessed have normal neurodevelopment.

CONCLUSION

These results are better than those published for in utero BMT for SCID. Early postnatal BMT should be the preferred option in neonatal SCID.

Microchimerism does not induce tolerance and sustains immunity after in utero transplantation

BACKGROUND

To date, over 40 in utero transplants have been performed in humans; the only successes were documented in the treatment of severe combined immunodeficiency syndromes. Hemoglobinopathies and metabolic disorders are candidate diseases for this approach; however, when applied clinically, the results have been discouraging. To address the role of the fetal immune system in the outcome of in utero transplantation, we have developed a murine model of in utero transplantation in immunologically intact murine recipients and have studied chimerism and tolerance/immunity to allogeneic donor cells through the lives of the animals.

METHODS

We have performed experiments in which purified murine sca-1+/lin- cells and c-kit+/lin- cells of C57BL/6 (H2b) mice were injected into Balb/c (H2d) fetal recipients at early gestational ages. Chimerism was tested by highly sensitive semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction assay and tolerance/immunity to donor cells was studied by in vivo (skin grafts, responses to postnatal boosts) and in vitro (mixed lymphocyte culture, cytotoxicity, and cytokine release) assays.

RESULTS

One hundred percent (10/10) of mice transplanted with c-kit+ cells and 44% (4/9) of mice transplanted with sca+ cells showed circulating donor cells within the first 6 months of life (P=0.031). Mice in the sca+ group rejected donor skin grafts at a mean time of 9.1+/-0.2 days, whereas mice in the c-kit+ group rejected donor skin grafts at a mean time of 15.1+/-0.7 days (P=0.001). The difference between the transplanted groups and non-transplanted controls was also significant (P<0.05). All mice transplanted with sca+/lin- cells showed greater response to donor cells than to third-party cells at all effector to target ratios (P=0.002). Differences in response to donor alloantigen between sca+ and c-kit+ groups were significant (P=0.003). Cytokine quantification demonstrated higher TH1 than TH2 cytokine release in all groups, and the response to donor cells was higher in the sca+ compared with c-kit+ mice (P=0.031).

CONCLUSION

These results demonstrate a low level of chimerism and tolerance in mice transplanted in utero with sca+/lin- and c-kit+/lin- cells. The possibility of active in utero immunization to donor cells is supported by accelerated skin graft rejection in mice transplanted with sca+ cells and enhanced in vitro immune responses in mice with persistent microchimerism.