In vitro assay for reiterative transcription during transcriptional initiation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

Regulation of the gyr operon of Mycobacterium tuberculosis by overlapping promoters, DNA topology, and reiterative transcription

DNA gyrase introduces negative supercoils into DNA to maintain topological homeostasis. The genes encoding gyrase, gyrB and gyrA, form a dicistronic operon in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) and other actinobacteria. Earlier work indicated that DNA relaxation stimulates the expression of the gyr genes, a phenomenon termed relaxation-stimulated transcription (RST). The present study addresses the underlying mechanism of gyr operon regulation. The operon is regulated by overlapping and divergently oriented promoters located upstream of gyrB. The principal promoter, P_gyrB1, drives transcription of the operon, while a weak "reverse" promoter, P_gyrR, transcribes in opposite direction. We demonstrate that P_gyrR plays a role in fine tuning gyr gene expression by reiterative transcription (RT), a regulatory mechanism hitherto not found in Mtb. In vitro transcription assays showed that RT at P_gyrR depended on the negatively supercoiled state of the DNA template. The principal promoter, P_gyrB1, was also sensitive to DNA supercoiling, but it was stimulated by DNA relaxation. Moreover, RNA polymerase binding to the promoter was efficient at P_gyrB1 when template DNA was relaxed, whereas binding to P_gyrR was preferred when DNA was supercoiled. Thus, a collaboration between RST and RT governs the regulation of the gyr operon; the differing sensitivity of the two overlapping promoters to superhelix density explains how gyrase expression responds to changes in supercoiling to determine the efficiency of transcription initiation.

Transcription start site sequence and spacing between the -10 region and the start site affect reiterative transcription-mediated regulation of gene expression in Escherichia coli

Reiterative transcription is a reaction catalyzed by RNA polymerase, in which nucleotides are repetitively added to the 3' end of a nascent transcript due to upstream slippage of the transcript without movement of the DNA template. In Escherichia coli, the expression of several operons is regulated through mechanisms in which high intracellular levels of UTP promote reiterative transcription that adds extra U residues to the 3' end of a nascent transcript during transcription initiation. Immediately following the addition of one or more extra U residues, the nascent transcripts are released from the transcription initiation complex, thereby reducing the level of gene expression. Therefore, gene expression can be regulated by internal UTP levels, which reflect the availability of external pyrimidine sources. The magnitude of gene regulation by these mechanisms varies considerably, even when control mechanisms are analogous. These variations apparently are due to differences in promoter sequences. One of the operons regulated (in part) by UTP-sensitive reiterative transcription in E. coli is the carAB operon, which encodes the first enzyme in the pyrimidine nucleotide biosynthetic pathway. In this study, we used the carAB operon to examine the effects of nucleotide sequence at and near the transcription start site and spacing between the start site and -10 region of the promoter on reiterative transcription and gene regulation. Our results indicate that these variables are important determinants in establishing the extent of reiterative transcription, levels of productive transcription, and range of gene regulation.

Transcription elongation complex stability: the topological lock

Transcription machinery from a variety of organisms shows striking mechanistic similarity. Both multi- and single subunit RNA polymerases have evolved an 8-10-base pair RNA-DNA hybrid as a part of a stably transcribing elongation complex. Through characterization of halted complexes that can readily carry out homopolymeric slippage synthesis, this study reveals that T7 RNA polymerase elongation complexes containing only a 4-base pair hybrid can nevertheless be more stable than those with the normal 8-base pair hybrid. We propose that a key feature of this stability is the topological threading of RNA through the complex and/or around the DNA template strand. The data are consistent with forward translocation as a mechanism to allow unthreading of the topological lock, as can occur during programmed termination of transcription.

Assays for transcription factor activity

Transcription factors interact at promoters to modulate the transcription of genes. This chapter describes three in vitro methods that can be used to monitor their activity: transcript assays, abortive initiation assays, and potassium permanganate footprinting. These techniques have been developed using bacterial systems, and can be used to study the kinetics of transcription initiation, and hence to unravel regulatory mechanisms.

Regulation of pyrG expression in Bacillus subtilis: CTP-regulated antitermination and reiterative transcription with pyrG templates in vitro

The regulation of pyrG expression in a group of low GC Gram-positive bacteria was previously shown to be mediated by a novel form of transcription attenuation in which low levels of intracellular CTP induce reiterative addition of G residues at position +4 in the 5' end of the pyrG mRNA, which is encoded as pppGGGC. . . . The poly(G) sequences formed under these conditions act to prevent attenuation by base pairing with the C- and U-rich 5' strand of a downstream terminator stem-loop located in the pyrG leader. In this work we document the reconstitution of this regulatory system in vitro using only the native pyrG DNA template, RNA polymerase and appropriate concentrations of ribonucleotides. CTP-regulated reiterative transcription producing 5'-poly(G) tracts and regulation of transcription termination at the pyrG attenuator by CTP were demonstrated. Mutations in the native pyrG template that altered reiterative transcription and attenuation in vivo resulted in alternations in expression in the in vitro transcription system that were predicted by the mechanism described above. These findings provide strong experimental support for the proposed reiterative transcription/antitermination mechanism and confirm that no trans-acting regulatory protein is required for pyrG regulation.

An alternate mechanism of abortive release marked by the formation of very long abortive transcripts

The Esigma70-dependent N25 promoter is rate-limited at promoter escape. Here, RNA polymerase repeatedly initiates and aborts transcription, giving rise to a ladder of short RNAs 2-11 nucleotides long. Certain mutations in the initial transcribed sequence (ITS) of N25 lengthen the abortive initiation program, resulting in the release of very long abortive transcripts (VLATs) 16-19 nucleotides long. This phenomenon is completely dependent on sequences within the first 20 bases of the ITS since altering sequences downstream of +20 has no effect on their formation. VLAT formation also requires strong interactions between RNA polymerase and the promoter. Mutations that change the -35 and -10 hexamers and the intervening 17 base pair spacer away from consensus decrease the probability of aborting at positions +16 to +19. An unusual characteristic of the VLATs is their undiminished levels in the presence of GreB, which rescues abortive RNAs (</=15 nucleotides) associated with backtracked initial transcribing complexes. This suggests that VLATs are produced via a mechanism distinct from backtracking, which we propose entails polymerase molecules hyper forward translocating during the promoter escape transition. We discuss how certain features in the ITS, when combined with the N25 promoter, may lead to hyper forward translocation and abortive release at VLAT positions.

Systematic mutagenesis of the thymidine tract of the pyrBI attenuator and its effects on intrinsic transcription termination in Escherichia coli

The pyrBI attenuator of Escherichia coli is an intrinsic transcription terminator composed of DNA with a hyphenated dyad symmetry and an adjacent 8 bp T:A tract (T-tract). These elements specify a G+C-rich terminator hairpin followed by a run of eight uridine residues (U-tract) in the RNA transcript. In this study, we examined the effects on in vivo transcription termination of systematic base substitutions in the T/U-tract of the pyrBI attenuator. We found that these substitutions diminished transcription termination efficiency to varying extents, depending on the nature and position of the substitution. In general, substitutions closer to the dyad symmetry/terminator hairpin exhibited the most significant effects. Additionally, we examined the effects on in vivo transcription termination of mutations that insert from 1 to 4 bases between the terminator hairpin and U-tract specified by the pyrBI attenuator. Our results show an inverse relationship between termination efficiency and the number of bases inserted. The effects of the substitution and insertion mutations on termination efficiency at the pyrBI attenuator were also measured in vitro, which corroborated the in vivo results. Our results are discussed in terms of the current models for intrinsic transcription termination and estimating termination efficiencies at intrinsic terminators of other bacteria.

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase recognition of a sigma70-dependent promoter requiring a -35 DNA element and an extended -10 TGn motif

Escherichia coli sigma70-dependent promoters have typically been characterized as either -10/-35 promoters, which have good matches to both the canonical -10 and the -35 sequences or as extended -10 promoters (TGn/-10 promoters), which have the TGn motif and an excellent match to the -10 consensus sequence. We report here an investigation of a promoter, P(minor), that has a nearly perfect match to the -35 sequence and has the TGn motif. However, P(minor) contains an extremely poor sigma70 -10 element. We demonstrate that P(minor) is active both in vivo and in vitro and that mutations in either the -35 or the TGn motif eliminate its activity. Mutation of the TGn motif can be compensated for by mutations that make the -10 element more canonical, thus converting the -35/TGn promoter to a -35/-10 promoter. Potassium permanganate footprinting on the nontemplate and template strands indicates that when polymerase is in a stable (open) complex with P(minor), the DNA is single stranded from positions -11 to +4. We also demonstrate that transcription from P(minor) incorporates nontemplated ribonucleoside triphosphates at the 5' end of the P(minor) transcript, which results in an anomalous assignment for the start site when primer extension analysis is used. P(minor) represents one of the few -35/TGn promoters that have been characterized and serves as a model for investigating functional differences between these promoters and the better-characterized -10/-35 and extended -10 promoters used by E. coli RNA polymerase.

A pathway branching in transcription initiation in Escherichia coli

In transcription initiation, all RNA polymerase molecules bound to a promoter have been conventionally supposed to proceed into elongation of transcript. However, for Escherichia coli RNA polymerase, evidence has been accumulated for a view that only its fraction can proceed into elongation and the rest is retained at a promoter in non-productive form: a pathway branching in transcription initiation. Proteins such as GreA and GreB affect these fractions at several promoters in vitro. To reveal the ubiquitous existence of the branched mechanism in E. coli, we searched for candidate genes whose transcription decreased by disruption of greA and greB using a DNA array. Among the arbitrarily selected 11 genes from over 100, the atpC, cspA and rpsA passed the test by Northern blotting. The Gre factors activated transcription initiation from their promoters in vitro, and the results demonstrated that the branched mechanism is exploited in vivo regulation. Consistently, decrease in the level of the GreA in an anaerobic stationary condition accompanied a decrease in the levels of transcripts of these genes.

The anti-initial transcribed sequence, a portable sequence that impedes promoter escape, requires sigma70 for function

The anti-sequence, a portable element extending from +1 to +15 of the transcript, is sufficient to prevent promoter escape from a variety of strong final sigma70 promoters. We show here that this sequence does not function with even the strongest final sigma32 promoter. Moreover, a particular class of substitutions in final sigma70 that disrupt interaction between Region 2.2 of final sigma70 and a coiled-coiled motif in the beta'-subunit of RNA polymerase antagonizes the function of the anti-element. This same group of mutants prevents lambdaQ-mediated anti-termination at the lambdaP(R') promoter. At this promoter, interaction of final sigma70 with the non-template strand of the initial transcribed sequence (ITS) is required to promote the pause prerequisite for anti-termination. These mutants prevent pausing because they are defective in this recognition event. By analogy, we suggest that interaction of final sigma70 with the non-template strand of the anti-ITS is required for function of this portable element, thus explaining why neither final sigma32 nor the Region 2.2 final sigma70 mutants mediate anti-function. Support for the analogy with the lambdaP(R') promoter comes from preliminary experiments suggesting that the anti-ITS, like the lambdaP(R') ITS, is bipartite.

A long T. A tract in the upp initially transcribed region is required for regulation of upp expression by UTP-dependent reiterative transcription in Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, pyrimidine-mediated regulation of upp expression occurs by UTP-sensitive selection of alternative transcriptional start sites, which produces transcripts that differ in the ability to be elongated. The upp initially transcribed region contains the sequence GATTTTTTTTG (nontemplate strand). Initiation can occur at either the first or the second base in this sequence (designated G6 and A7, with numbering from the promoter -10 region). High intracellular UTP levels favor initiation at position A7; however, the resulting transcripts are subject to reiterative transcription (i.e., repetitive UMP addition) within the 8-bp T. A tract in the initially transcribed region and are aborted. In contrast, low intracellular UTP levels favor initiation at position G6, which results in transcripts that can, in part, avoid reiterative transcription and be elongated normally. In this study, we examined the regulatory requirement for the long T. A tract in the upp initially transcribed region. We constructed upp promoter mutations that shorten the T. A tract to 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, or 2 bp and examined the effects of these mutations on upp expression and regulation. The results indicate that pyrimidine-mediated regulation is gradually reduced as the T. A tract is shortened from 7 to 3 bp; at which point regulation ceases. This reduction in regulation is due to large-percentage increases in upp expression in cells grown under conditions of pyrimidine excess. Quantitation of cellular transcripts and in vitro transcription studies indicate that the observed effects of a shortened T. A tract on upp expression and regulation are due to increases in the fraction of both G6- and A7-initiated transcripts that avoid reiterative transcription and are elongated normally.

Effects of nonbulky DNA base damages on Escherichia coli RNA polymerase-mediated elongation and promoter clearance

DNA base damage products either formed spontaneously or as a result of exposure to various genotoxic agents were examined for their effects on Escherichia coli RNA polymerase-mediated transcription in vitro. Uracil, O6-methylguanine (O6-meG), and 8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG) were placed at specific sites downstream from the transcriptional start site on the transcribed strand of a duplex template under the control of the strong tac promoter. In vitro, single-round transcription experiments carried out with purified E. coli RNA polymerase revealed efficient bypass at the three lesions examined and subsequent generation of full-length runoff transcripts. Transcript sequence analysis revealed that E. coli RNA polymerase inserted primarily adenine into the transcript opposite to uracil, uracil opposite to O6-meG, and either adenine or cytosine opposite to 8-oxoG. Thus, a uracil in the DNA template resulted in a G-to-A transition mutation in the lesion bypass product whereas O6-meG produced a C-to-U transition mutation and 8-oxoG generated either the correct transcriptional product or a C-to-A transversion mutation. When 8-oxoG was placed within close proximity to the transcriptional start site (within the region required for effective promoter clearance), a reduced of full-length, runoff transcript was observed, indicative of lower promoter clearance. Taken together, these results demonstrate that the DNA base damages studied here may exert significant in vivo effects on gene expression and DNA repair with respect to the production of mutant proteins (transcriptional mutagenesis), or decreased levels of expressed proteins.

Regulation of carAB expression in Escherichia coli occurs in part through UTP-sensitive reiterative transcription

In Escherichia coli, expression of the carAB operon is subject to cumulative repression, which occurs by ArgR-mediated repression at a downstream promoter, P2, and by pyrimidine-mediated regulation at an upstream promoter, P1. In this study, we show that pyrimidine-mediated regulation occurs in part through a mechanism involving UTP-sensitive reiterative transcription (i.e., repetitive addition of U residues to the 3' end of a nascent transcript due to transcript-template slippage). In this case, reiterative transcription occurs at the end of a run of three T x A base pairs in the initially transcribed region of the carAB P1 promoter. The sequence of this region is 5'-GTTTGC (nontemplate strand). In the proposed regulatory mechanism, increased intracellular levels of UTP promote reiterative transcription, which results in the synthesis of transcripts with the sequence GUUUU(n) (where n = 1 to >30). These transcripts are not extended downstream to include structural gene sequences. In contrast, lower levels of UTP enhance normal template-directed addition of a G residue at position 5 of the nascent transcript. This addition precludes reiterative transcription and permits normal transcript elongation capable of producing translatable carAB transcripts. Thus, carAB expression, which is necessary for pyrimidine nucleotide (and arginine) biosynthesis, increases in proportion to the cellular need for UTP. The proposed mechanism appears to function independently of a second pyrimidine-mediated control mechanism that involves the regulatory proteins CarP and integration host factor.

Regulation of upp expression in Escherichia coli by UTP-sensitive selection of transcriptional start sites coupled with UTP-dependent reiterative transcription

Expression of the upp gene of Escherichia coli, which encodes the pyrimidine salvage enzyme uracil phosphoribosyltransferase, is negatively regulated by pyrimidine availability. In this study, we demonstrate that this regulation occurs mainly by UTP-sensitive selection of alternative transcriptional start sites, which produces transcripts that differ in the ability to be productively elongated. The upp initially transcribed region contains the sequence GATTTTTTTTG (nontemplate strand). Transcription is initiated primarily at the first two bases in this sequence, designated G6 and A7 (counting from the promoter -10 region). High intracellular levels of UTP favor initiation at position A7; however, the resulting transcripts are subject to reiterative transcription (i.e., repetitive nucleotide addition) within the run of T residues in the initially transcribed region. The resulting AUUUUn (where n = 1 to >50) transcripts are not extended to include downstream upp sequences. In contrast, low intracellular levels of UTP strongly favor initiation at position G6, which results in transcripts that generally do not engage in reiterative transcription and thus can be normally elongated. This mechanism ensures that high levels of uracil phosphoribosyltransferase are produced only under conditions of pyrimidine limitation. The mechanisms that account for UTP-sensitive start site selection and different fates of upp transcripts, as well as the general use of UTP-dependent reiterative transcription in gene regulation, are discussed in detail.