Cytogenetic study of 33 ependymomas

Chromosomal anomalies and prognostic markers for intracranial and spinal ependymomas

Ependymomas are neoplasms that can occur anywhere along the craniospinal axis. They are the third most common brain tumor in children, representing 10% of pediatric intracranial tumors, 4% of adult brain tumors, and 15% of all spinal cord tumors. As the heterogeneity of ependymomas has severely limited the prognostic value of the World Health Organization grading system, numerous studies have focused on genetic alterations as a potential basis for classification and prognosis. However, this endeavor has proven difficult due to variations of findings depending on tumor location, tumor grade, and patient age. While many have evaluated chromosomal abnormalities for ependymomas as a whole group, others have concentrated their efforts on specific subsets of populations. Here, we review modern findings of chromosomal analyses, their relationships with various genes, and their prognostic implications for intracranial and spinal cord ependymomas.

Expression profiling of ependymomas unravels localization and tumor grade-specific tumorigenesis

BACKGROUND

Ependymomas derive from ependymal cells that cover the cerebral ventricles and the central canal of the spinal cord. The molecular alterations leading to ependymomal oncogenesis are not completely understood.

METHODS

The authors performed array-based expression profiling on a series of 34 frozen ependymal tumors with different localizations and histologic grades. Data were analyzed by nonsupervised and supervised clustering methods along with Gene Ontology and Pathway Analyzer tools.

RESULTS

Class discovery experiments indicated a strong correlation between profiles and tumor localization as well as World Health Organization (WHO) tumor grades. On the basis of supervised clustering, intracranial ependymomas were associated with high expression levels of Notch, Hedgehog, and bone morphogenetic protein pathway members. In contrast, most of the homeobox-containing genes manifested high expression in extracranial ependymomas. The results also revealed that WHO grade 2 ependymomas differed from WHO grade 3 ependymomas by genes implicated in Wnt/beta-catenin signaling, cell cycle, E2F transcription factor 1 destruction, angiogenesis, apoptosis, remodeling of adherens junctions, and mitotic spindle formation.

CONCLUSIONS

Taken together, the tumor localization-related gene sets mainly implicated in stem cell maintenance, renewal, and differentiation suggest the dysregulation of localized cancer stem cells during ependymoma development. The WHO grade differentiating pathways suggested that alteration of the Wnt/beta-catenin signaling pathway is a key event in the tumorigenesis of WHO grade 3 ependymomas. On the basis of the current data, the authors suggest a developmental scheme of ependymomas that integrates tumor localization and tumor grades, and that pinpoints new targets for the development of future therapeutic approaches.

The genetic and epigenetic basis of ependymoma

INTRODUCTION

Although ependymoma is the third most common pediatric brain tumor, we know little about the genetic/epigenetic basis of its initiation, maintenance, or progression. This is due in part to the heterogeneity of the disease, as well as the small sample size of the cohorts analyzed in most studies.

METHODS

Many of the genetic aberrations identified to date are large genomic regions, making the differentiation between passenger and driver genes difficult. The finding of a balanced karyotype in a significant subset of pediatric posterior fossa ependymomas increases the difficulty of identifying targets for rationale therapy.

CONCLUSION

The paucity of in vitro and in vivo model systems for ependymoma compound the difficulties outlined above. In this review, we discuss the published literature on ependymoma genetics and epigenetics and discuss possible future directions for the field.

Biological background of pediatric medulloblastoma and ependymoma: a review from a translational research perspective

Survival rates of pediatric brain tumor patients have significantly improved over the years due to developments in diagnostic techniques, neurosurgery, chemotherapy, radiotherapy, and supportive care. However, brain tumors are still an important cause of cancer-related deaths in children. Prognosis is still highly dependent on clinical characteristics, such as the age of the patient, tumor type, stage, and localization, but increased knowledge about the genetic and biological features of these tumors is being obtained and might be useful to further improve outcome for these patients. It has become clear that the deregulation of signaling pathways essential in brain development, for example, sonic hedgehog (SHH), Wnt, and Notch pathways, plays an important role in pathogenesis and biological behavior, especially for medulloblastomas. More recently, data have become available about the cells of origin of brain tumors and the possible existence of brain tumor stem cells. Newly developed array-based techniques for studying gene expression, protein expression, copy number aberrations, and epigenetic events have led to the identification of other potentially important biological abnormalities in pediatric medulloblastomas and ependymomas.

Identification of tumor-specific molecular signatures in intracranial ependymoma and association with clinical characteristics

PURPOSE

To delineate clinically relevant molecular signatures of intracranial ependymoma.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We analyzed 24 primary intracranial ependymomas. For genomic profiling, microarray-based comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) was used and results were validated by fluorescent in situ hybridization and loss of heterozygosity mapping. We performed gene expression profiling using microarrays, real-time quantitative reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction, and methylation analysis of selected genes. We applied class comparison analyses to compare both genomic and expression profiling data with clinical characteristics.

RESULTS

A variable number of genomic imbalances were detected by array CGH, revealing multiple regions of recurrent gain (including 2q23, 7p21, 12p, 13q21.1, and 20p12) and loss (including 5q31, 6q26, 7q36, 15q21.1, 16q24, 17p13.3, 19p13.2, and 22q13.3). An ependymoma-specific gene expression signature was characterized by the concurrent abnormal expression of developmental and differentiation pathways, including NOTCH and sonic hedgehog signaling. We identified specific differentially imbalanced genomic clones and gene expression signatures significantly associated with tumor location, patient age at disease onset, and retrospective risk for relapse. Integrated genomic and expression profiling allowed us to identify genes of which the expression is deregulated in intracranial ependymoma, such as overexpression of the putative proto-oncogene YAP1 (located at 11q22) and downregulation of the SULT4A1 gene (at 22q13.3).

CONCLUSION

The present exploratory molecular profiling study allowed us to refine previously reported intervals of genomic imbalance, to identify novel restricted regions of gain and loss, and to identify molecular signatures correlating with various clinical variables. Validation of these results on independent data sets represents the next step before translation into the clinical setting.

Loss of chromosome 1 in myxopapillary ependymoma suggests a region out of chromosome 22 as critical for tumour biology: a FISH analysis of four cases on touch imprint smears

OBJECTIVE

Ependymomas are glial tumours. They constitute approximately 5-10% of intracranial tumours and are tumours which can recur. Predictive factors of outcome in ependymomas are not well established. Karyotypic studies are relatively scarce and loss of chromosome 22 has been described to correlate with recurrence. We are unaware of any reports involving chromosome 1 aberrations in the malignant progression of ependymomas.

METHODS

Cytogenetic analysis of four myxopapillary ependymomas was performed using double target fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH), focusing on chromosomes 1 and 22.

RESULTS

One patient's tumour had recurred. FISH was performed on 500 nuclei/tumours. All four cases showed a loss of chromosome 22q while only one showed an additional loss of chromosome 1p, and this was the one that recurred.

CONCLUSIONS

We support the presence of a tumour suppressor gene on 1p associated with relapse in myxopapillary ependymomas and suggest that status of chromosome 1p by FISH may indicate a high-risk group of patients harbouring this tumour. More studies of this type are needed towards this direction as our results refer to a minimal number of individuals analysed.

Low frequency of chromosomal imbalances in anaplastic ependymomas as detected by comparative genomic hybridization

We screened 26 ependymomas in 22 patients (7 WHO grade I, myxopapillary, myE; 6 WHO grade II, E; 13 WHO grade III, anaplastic, aE) using comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). 25 out of 26 tumors showed chromosomal imbalances on CGH analysis. The chromosomal region most frequently affected by losses of genomic material clustered on 13q (9/26). 6/7 myE showed a loss on 13q14-q31. Other chromosomes affected by genomic losses were 6q (5/26), 4q (5/26), 10 (5/26), and 2q (4/26). The most consistent chromosomal abnormality in ependymomas so far reported, is monosomy 22 or structural abnormality 22q, identified in approximately one third of Giemsa-banded cases with abnormal karyotypes. Using FISH, loss or monosomy 22q was detected in small subpopulations of tumor cells in 36% of cases. The most frequent gains involved chromosome arms 17 (8/26), 9q (7/26), 20q (7/26), and 22q (6/26). Gains on 1q were found exclusively in pediatric ependymomas (5/10). Using FISH, MYCN proto-oncogene DNA amplifications mapped to 2p23-p24 were found in 2 spinal ependymomas of adults. On average, myE demonstrated 9.14, E 5.33, and aE 1.77 gains and/or losses on different chromosomes per tumor using CGH. Thus, and quite paradoxically, in ependymomas, a high frequency of imbalanced chromosomal regions as revealed by CGH does not indicate a high WHO grade of the tumor but is more frequent in grade I tumors.

Molecular cytogenetic analysis in the study of brain tumors: findings and applications

Classic cytogenetics has evolved from black and white to technicolor images of chromosomes as a result of advances in fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) techniques, and is now called molecular cytogenetics. Improvements in the quality and diversity of probes suitable for FISH, coupled with advances in computerized image analysis, now permit the genome or tissue of interest to be analyzed in detail on a glass slide. It is evident that the growing list of options for cytogenetic analysis has improved the understanding of chromosomal changes in disease initiation, progression, and response to treatment. The contributions of classic and molecular cytogenetics to the study of brain tumors have provided scientists and clinicians alike with new avenues for investigation. In this review the authors summarize the contributions of molecular cytogenetics to the study of brain tumors, encompassing the findings of classic cytogenetics, interphase- and metaphase-based FISH studies, spectral karyotyping, and metaphase- and array-based comparative genomic hybridization. In addition, this review also details the role of molecular cytogenetic techniques in other aspects of understanding the pathogenesis of brain tumors, including xenograft, cancer stem cell, and telomere length studies.

Structural genomic abnormalities of chromosomes 9 and 18 in myxopapillary ependymomas

Myxopapillary ependymomas (MPEs) are low-grade neuroepithelial tumors typically occurring in the conus-cauda equina-filum terminale region. Limited molecular and cytogenetic analysis of MPEs has not demonstrated consistent abnormalities. In an attempt to clarify the chromosomal status of these tumors and identify commonly aberrant regions in the genome we have combined 3 molecular/cyto/genetic methods to study 17 MPEs. Comparative genomic hybridization of 7/17 tumors identified concurrent gain on chromosomes 9 and 18 as the most frequent finding. The majority of the 17 tumors were also studied using microsatellite analysis with marker spanning the whole chromosomes 9 and 18 and interphase-FISH with centromeric probes for both chromosomes. Our combined results were consistent with concurrent gain in both chromosomes 9 and 18 in 11/17 cases, gain of either chromosome 9 or 18 and imbalance in the other chromosome in 3/17 tumors and allelic imbalances of chromosomes 9 or 18 in 3/17 and 1/17 tumors, respectively. Other abnormalities observed included gain of chromosomes 3, 4, 7, 8, 11, 13, 17q, 20, and X and loss of chromosomes 10 and 22. Our findings represent some steps towards understanding the molecular mechanisms involved in the development of MPE.

Complex cytogenetic abnormalities including telomeric associations and MEN1 mutation in a pediatric ependymoma

Ependymomas are neuroectodermal tumors of the brain and spinal cord. Some recurrent cytogenetic aberrations have been reported in these tumors, including alterations involving chromosomes 22, 6, and 11. However, consistent molecular alterations have not been identified in ependymal tumors. We studied a recurrent ependymoma in a 3-year-old patient by standard cytogenetic and molecular analysis of TP53 and MEN1 genes. In the present case, we found many of the cytogenetic features previously described as being recurrent in ependymomas, including unstable telomeric alterations. Furthermore, we detected a novel acquired heterozygous mutation in the MEN1 gene. The chromosomal instability produced by the telomeric alterations and the mutation in the MEN1 gene could be important events in the tumorigenesis of ependymomas.

Immunohistochemical markers for prognosis of ependymal neoplasms

Intracranial ependymomas are the third most common primary brain tumor in children. Although clinical and histological criteria for ependymoma prognosis are recognized, studies have reported contradictory results. Prognostic significance based on immunohistochemistry of ependymomas has been reported in a few studies. One-hundred and twelve patients with intracranial ependymomas were examined retrospectively for immunoexpression of various tumor-associated antigens and apoptosis. The results demonstrated significant preponderance of expression of the tenascin, vascular endothelial growth factor protein (VEGF), epidermal growth factor (EGFR) and p53 protein in high-grade tumors. Also high-grade ependymomas revealed more prominent labeling indices (LI) for proliferative marker Ki-S1 and apoptotic index (AI), and lower LI for cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors p27/Kipl and pl4ARF. For low-grade ependymomas the progression-free survival time (PFS) was found to be significantly shorter for Ki-S1 LI > 5%, and for tenascin, VEGF and EGFR positivity. For high-grade ependymomas PFS was found to be significantly reduced for p27 LI < 20%, p14ARF LI < 10%, for p53 positivity, and for AI < 1%. The CART modeling process exhibited five final groups of ependymoma patients (1) low-grade and tenascin-negative; (2) low-grade and tenascin-positive; (3) high-grade and p53-negative with p14 LI > 0%; (4) high-grade with combination of either p53 positivity and p14 LI > 10% or p53 negativity and p14 LI < 10%; (5) high-grade and p53-positive with pl4 LI < 10%. In summary, some immunohistochemical variables were found to be the strong predictors of ependymoma recurrence and they seem to be useful for assessing individual tumor prognosis in routinely processed biopsy specimens together with tumor grade. For histologically benign ependymomas immunohistochemical study should be focused on Ki-S1, tenascin, EGFR and VEGF evaluation, whereas p53 expression and number of p27, p14 and ISEL-positive nuclei will be of value in determining PFS from high-grade ependymomas.

Analysis of the NF2 gene in oligodendrogliomas and ependymomas

Allelic losses of chromosome 22 are commonly found in ependymomas and oligodendrogliomas, suggesting that at least one tumor suppressor gene on chromosome 22 must be inactivated during the multistep process of tumorigenesis in these glial tumors. The neurofibromatosis 2 gene (NF2) located at 22q12, is a candidate tumor suppressor gene potentially involved in the pathogenesis of gliomas. Because there have been only a few studies of the NF2 gene in glial tumors other than astrocytoma, we screened the entire 17 NF2 exons for mutations in a series of 47 nonastrocytic tumors, including 40 oligodendrogliomas and 7 ependymomas. Only one mutation was detected, a 59-base pair insertion in exon 3 from a spinal anaplastic ependymoma. These results concur with previous findings proposing preferential inactivation of the NF2 gene in a subgroup of ependymomas, and suggest that the NF2 gene is not the target of chromosome 22 aberrations in oligodendrogliomas.

Genetic abnormalities detected in ependymomas by comparative genomic hybridisation

Using comparative genomic hybridisation, we have analysed genetic imbalance in a series of 86 ependymomas from children and adults. Tumours were derived from intracranial and spinal sites, and classified histologically as classic, anaplastic or myxopapillary. Ependymomas showing a balanced profile were significantly (P<0.0005) more frequent in children than adults. Profiles suggesting intermediate ploidy were common (44% of all tumours), and found more often (P<0.0005) in tumours from adults and the spinal region. Loss of 22q was the most common specific abnormality, occurring in 50% of spinal (medullary) ependymomas and 26% of tumours overall. Genetic profiles combining loss of 22q with other specific abnormalities--gain of 1q, loss of 6q, loss of 10q/10, loss of 13, loss of 14q/14--varied according to site and histology. In particular, we showed that classic ependymomas from within the cranium and spine have distinct genetic profiles. Classic and anaplastic ependymomas with gain of 1q tended to occur in the posterior fossa of children and to behave aggressively. Our extensive data on ependymomas demonstrate significant associations between genetic aberrations and clinicopathological variables, and represent a starting point for further biological and clinical studies.

Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) in diagnostic and investigative neuropathology

Over the last decade, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) has emerged as a powerful clinical and research tool for the assessment of target DNA dosages within interphase nuclei. Detectable alterations include aneusomies, deletions, gene amplifications, and translocations, with primary advantages to the pathologist including its basis in morphology, its applicability to archival, formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) material, and its similarities to immunohistochemistry. Recent technical advances such as improved hybridization protocols, markedly expanded probe availability resulting from the human genome sequencing initiative, and the advent of high-throughput assays such as gene chip and tissue microarrays have greatly enhanced the applicability of FISH. In our lab, we currently utilize only a limited battery of DNA probes for routine diagnostic purposes, with determination of chromosome 1p and 19q dosage in oligodendroglial neoplasms representing the most common application. However, research applications are numerous and will likely translate into a growing list of clinically useful markers in the near future. In this review, we highlight the advantages and disadvantages of FISH and familiarize the reader with current applications in diagnostic and investigative neuropathology.

Isochromosome 1q as an early genetic event in a child with intracranial ependymoma characterized by molecular cytogenetics

Data concerning cytogenetic features of childhood ependymoma are rare. In this article, a gain of 1q was identified as the sole alteration in a primary childhood infratentorial ependymoma by comparative genomic hybridization (CGH). A recurrence of this brain tumor was studied using multiplex-fluorescence in situ hybridization (M-FISH) in addition to CGH and G-banding analysis. In accordance with the primary tumor, a gain of 1q corresponding to an isochromosome 1q was observed indicating an early event in the tumor development. Furthermore, M-FISH classified several other rearranged chromosomes including 6q and 17p that have previously been found to be involved in the development and progression of childhood ependymoma.

Gain of 1q and loss of 22 are the most common changes detected by comparative genomic hybridisation in paediatric ependymoma

Ependymomas are the third most common brain tumour in the paediatric population. Although cytogenetic and molecular analyses have pinpointed deletions of chromosomes 6q, 17, and 22 in a subset of tumours, definitive patterns of genetic aberrations have not been determined. In the present study, we analysed 40 ependymomas from paediatric patients for genomic loss or gain using comparative genomic hybridisation (CGH). Eighteen of the tumours (45%) had no detectable regions of imbalance. In the remaining cases, the most common copy number aberrations were loss of 22 (25% of tumours) and gain of 1q (20%). Three regions of high copy number amplification were noted at 1q24-31 (three cases), 8q21-23 (two cases), and 9p (one case). Although there was no association with the loss or gain of any chromosome arm or with benign versus anaplastic histologic characteristics, the incidence of gain of 7q and 9p and loss of 17 and 22 was significantly higher in recurrent versus primary tumours. This study has identified a number of chromosomal regions that may contain candidate genes involved in the development of different subgroups of ependymoma.

Chromosomal abnormalities subdivide ependymal tumors into clinically relevant groups

Ependymoma occurs most frequently within the central nervous system of children and young adults. We determined relative chromosomal copy-number aberrations in 44 ependymomas using comparative genomic hybridization. The study included 24 intracranial and 20 spinal cord tumors from pediatric and adult patients. Frequent chromosomal aberrations in intracranial tumors were gain of 1q and losses on 6q, 9, and 13. Gain of 1q and loss on 9 were preferentially associated with histological grade 3 tumors. On the other hand, gain on chromosome 7 was recognized almost exclusively in spinal cord tumors, and was associated with various other chromosomal aberrations including frequent loss of 22q. We conclude that cytogenetic analysis of ependymomas may help to classify these tumors and provide leads concerning their initiation and progression. The relationship of these aberrations to patient outcome needs to be addressed.

Advances in biology and treatment of childhood brain tumors

Childhood brain tumors are collectively the most common solid neoplasm and the leading cause of cancer-related death in children. They are a diverse group of diseases and outcome is extremely variable. Current treatment is dependent on histology, location, and in some instances, patient age. Advances in treatment have led to improved survival for some patients, but for many the outcome remains dismal despite aggressive treatment. A growing body of work is aimed at improving the outcome for children with brain tumors not only through clinical trials, but also by focusing on the biologic underpinning of these diseases that have been poorly understood.

Fluorescence in situ hybridization determination of 22q12-q13 deletion in two intracerebral ependymomas

The sole cytogenetic abnormalities encountered in two childhood anaplastic intracerebral ependymomas were an isodicentric chromosome 22 in one case and an unbalanced chromosome 22 translocation associated with a partial deletion in the other. Fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis showed that the common 22q arm loss did not involve the rhabdoid region but included the EWS and NF2 loci. These results, in conjunction with data in the literature, suggest that the most frequently recurrent genomic loss in ependymomas does not involve the proximal 22q11.2 chromosome region but is localized distally to the hSNF5/INI1 locus. A tumor-suppressor gene, independent of the NF2 gene, which seems to be exclusively involved in intramedullary spinal cord ependymomas, might be implicated in the genesis of these intracranial tumors.