Strain differences in binding properties of estrogen receptors in immature and adult BALB/c and MRL/MP-lpr/lpr mice, a model of systemic lupus erythematosus

Complex sex-biased antibody responses: estrogen receptors bind estrogen response elements centered within immunoglobulin heavy chain gene enhancers

Nuclear hormone receptors including the estrogen receptor (ERα) and the retinoic acid receptor regulate a plethora of biological functions including reproduction, circulation and immunity. To understand how estrogen and other nuclear hormones influence antibody production, we characterized total serum antibody isotypes in female and male mice of C57BL/6J, BALB/cJ and C3H/HeJ mouse strains. Antibody levels were higher in females compared to males in all strains and there was a female preference for IgG2b production. Sex-biased patterns were influenced by vitamin levels, and by antigen specificity toward influenza virus or pneumococcus antigens. To help explain sex biases, we examined the direct effects of estrogen on immunoglobulin heavy chain sterile transcript production among purified, lipopolysaccharide-stimulated B cells. Supplemental estrogen in B-cell cultures significantly increased immunoglobulin heavy chain sterile transcripts. Chromatin immunoprecipitation analyses of activated B cells identified significant ERα binding to estrogen response elements (EREs) centered within enhancer elements of the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus, including the Eµ enhancer and hypersensitive site 1,2 (HS1,2) in the 3' regulatory region. The ERE in HS1,2 was conserved across animal species, and in humans marked a site of polymorphism associated with the estrogen-augmented autoimmune disease, lupus. Taken together, the results highlight: (i) the important targets of ERα in regulatory regions of the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus that influence antibody production, and (ii) the complexity of mechanisms by which estrogen instructs sex-biased antibody production profiles.

Estrogen in cardiovascular disease during systemic lupus erythematosus

PURPOSE

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a chronic inflammatory autoimmune disease that disproportionately affects women during their childbearing years. Cardiovascular disease is the leading cause of mortality in this patient population at an age when women often have low cardiovascular risk. Hypertension is a major cardiovascular disease risk factor, and its prevalence is markedly increased in women with SLE. Estrogen has traditionally been implicated in SLE disease progression because of the prevalence of the disease in women; however, its role in cardiovascular risk factors such as hypertension is unclear. The objective of this review is to discuss evidence for the role of estrogen in both human and murine SLE with emphasis on the effect of estrogen on cardiovascular risk factors, including hypertension.

METHODS

PubMed was used to search for articles with terms related to estradiol and SLE. The references of retrieved publications were also reviewed.

FINDINGS

The potential permissive role of estrogen in SLE development is supported by studies from experimental animal models of lupus in which early removal of estrogen or its effects leads to attenuation of SLE disease parameters, including autoantibody production and renal injury. However, data about the role of estrogens in human SLE are much less clear, with most studies not reaching firm conclusions about positive or negative outcomes after hormonal manipulations involving estrogen during SLE (ie, oral contraceptives, hormone therapy). Significant gaps in knowledge remain about the effect of estrogen on cardiovascular risk factors during SLE. Studies in women with SLE were not designed to determine the effect of estrogen or hormone therapy on blood pressure even though hypertension is highly prevalent, and risk of premature ovarian failure could necessitate use of hormone therapy in women with SLE. Recent evidence from an experimental animal model of lupus found that estrogen may protect against cardiovascular risk factors in adulthood. In addition, increasing evidence suggests that estrogen may have distinct temporal effects on cardiovascular risk factors during SLE.

IMPLICATIONS

Data from experimental models of lupus suggest that estrogens may have an important permissive role for developing SLE early in life. However, their role in adulthood remains unclear, particularly for the effect on cardiovascular disease and its risk factors. Additional work is needed to understand the effect of estrogens in human SLE, and preclinical studies in experimental models of SLE may contribute important mechanistic insight to further advance the field.

17β-Estradiol protects against the progression of hypertension during adulthood in a mouse model of systemic lupus erythematosus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a chronic inflammatory autoimmune disorder with a high prevalence of hypertension and cardiovascular disease. Because SLE predominantly affects women, estrogen is commonly implicated as a contributor to SLE disease progression. Using an established mouse model of SLE (female NZBWF1), we tested whether estrogen has a causal role in the development of hypertension in adulthood. Thirty-week-old SLE and control mice (NZW/LacJ) underwent either a sham or ovariectomy (OVX) procedure. 17β-Estradiol (E2; 5 μg/mouse, twice/week, subcutaneously) was administered to a subset of OVX mice. Mean arterial pressure (in mm Hg) was increased in SLE mice (134±4 versus 119±3 in controls). Contrary to our hypothesis, OVX exacerbated the hypertension in female SLE mice (153±3; P<0.05 versus SLE sham), and repletion of E2 prevented the OVX-induced increase in blood pressure (132±2). The prevalence of albuminuria was increased in SLE mice compared with controls (37% versus 0%). OVX increased the prevalence in SLE mice (70% versus 37% in SLE shams). Repletion of E2 completely prevented albuminuria in OVX SLE mice. Renal cortical tumor necrosis factor α was increased in SLE mice compared with controls and was further increased in OVX SLE. The OVX-induced increase in renal tumor necrosis factor α expression was prevented by repletion of E2. Treatment of OVX SLE mice with the tumor necrosis factor α inhibitor, etanercept, blunted the OVX-induced increase in blood pressure (140±2) and prevalence of albuminuria (22%). These data suggest that 17β-estradiol protects against the progression of hypertension during adulthood in SLE, in part, by reducing tumor necrosis factor α.

The ethyl acetate extract of alfalfa sprout ameliorates disease severity of autoimmune-prone MRL-lpr/lpr mice

Previous study showed that soy isoflavone supplement alleviates disease severity in autoimmune-prone mice. As the ethyl acetate extract of alfalfa sprout (AS) has selective oestrogenic and anti-inflammatory activity, this study evaluated the effects of alfalfa sprout ethyl acetate extract (ASEA) on disease severity of systemic lupus erythematosus, using autoimmune-prone female MRL- lpr/lpr mice. In Experiment 1, five groups of 12-week-old female mice were per oral treated with vehicle (control), lyophilized AS (550 mg wt/kg BW), ASEA (ASEA, 25 mg/kg BW), coumestrol (CUM, 0.075 mg/kg BW) and tamoxifen (TAM, 0.375 mg/kg BW) as the positive control. The onset of proteinuria was delayed, and the life span was significantly longer in the ASEA and TAM groups but neither in the AS nor in the CUM groups, compared to the control. To examine the changes in the immunological parameters related to disease process, three more groups of MRL- lpr/lpr female mice (control, ASEA and TAM) were fed in a similar manner for 6 weeks in the Experiment 2. Flow cytometric analysis of splenocytes showed a significantly lower percentage of activated T cells in the ASEA and TAM groups. The ex-vivo interferon-γ and interleukin (IL)-4 production from splenocytes and tumour necrosis factor-α and IL-1β production from peritoneal exudate cells were also significantly lower in the ASEA group compared with the control. The ASEA group also had less severe glomerulonephritis. Thus, ASEA attenuated cytokine and inflammatory responses of self-reactive lymphocytes, decreased the disease severity, increased survival and life span of the autoimmune-prone MRL- lpr/lpr mice, suggesting a potential of ASEA in the treatment of autoimmune diseases.

Do Genetic Alterations in Sex Steroid Receptors Contribute to Lacrimal Gland Disease in Sjögren's Syndrome?

BACKGROUND: Defects in sex steroid receptors have been linked to the onset, progression and severity, as well as the sex-related prevalence, of a variety of autoimmune disorders, including lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis and diabetes. We hypothesize that defects in estrogen receptor alpha (ESR1), estrogen receptor beta (ESR2) and/or the androgen receptor (AR) may also contribute to the development of lacrimal gland autoimmune sequelae in Sjögren's syndrome. To begin to test this hypothesis, we examined whether mutations exist in the coding regions of ESR1, ESR2 and AR transcripts in lacrimal tissues of mouse models of Sjögren's syndrome. METHODS: Lacrimal and submandibular glands were collected from adult MRL/MpJ-Tnfrsf6(lpr), nonobese diabetic and/or BALB/c mice. Tissues were pooled according to sex and experiment and processed for cDNA generation. PCR primers were designed to amplify 566-875 base pair segments of the entire open reading frame of each receptor. Segments were amplified, purified and then sequenced. Receptor sequences were assembled and compared to each other and to known NCBI sequences. RESULTS: Our results show that almost all ESR1, ESR2 and AR sequences in exocrine tissues of male and female autoimmune and non-autoimmune mice were identical to those of NCBI standards. There was a G-->A shift at position 998 of the ESR2 complete coding sequence in all tissue samples when compared to NCBI reference sequence U81451.1, but this polymorphism was not found in other ESR2 reference sequences. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings indicate that defects in the coding region of sex steroid receptors do not contribute to the pathogenesis of lacrimal gland disease in mouse models of Sjögren's syndrome.

Tearful relationships? Sex, hormones, the lacrimal gland, and aqueous-deficient dry eye

Sex and the endocrine system exert a significant influence on the physiology and pathophysiology of the lacrimal gland. The purpose of this article is to briefly review the nature and magnitude of these interactions between sex, hormones and lacrimal tissue, and to address how they may relate to the pathogenesis of aqueous-deficient dry eye. Towards this end, this article has a 3-fold approach: first, to summarize the influence of androgens, estrogens, glucocorticoids, mineralocorticoids, retinoic acid, prolactin, alpha-melanocyte stimulating hormone, adrenocorticotropic hormone, luteinizing hormone, follicle-stimulating hormone, growth hormone, thyroid-stimulating hormone, arginine vasopressin, oxytocin, thyroxine, parathyroid hormone, insulin, glucagon, melatonin, human chorionic gonadotropin and cholecystokinin on the structure and function of the lacrimal gland; second, to discuss the mechanism of action of each hormone on lacrimal tissue; and third, to discuss the clinical relevance of the endocrine-lacrimal gland interrelationship, with a particular focus on each hormone's role (i.e. if relevant) in the development of aqueous-tear deficiency.

Spotlight on the role of hormonal factors in the emergence of autoreactive B-lymphocytes

Pathogenic autoimmunity requires a combination of inherited and acquired factors. In as much as hormones influence the sexual dimorphism of the immune system, it is possible that they can initiate or accelerate an autoimmune process, and contribute to gender-biased autoimmune disorders. Not only natural hormones, but also endocrine disruptors, such as environmental estrogens, may act in conjunction with other factors to override immune tolerance to self-antigens. In lupus, murine and human studies demonstrate that female sex hormones are implicated in disease pathogenesis. In the B cell compartment, both prolactin and estrogen are immunomodulators that affect maturation, selection and antibody secretion. Their impact may be based on their capacity to allow autoreactive B cells to escape the normal mechanisms of tolerance and to accumulate in sufficient numbers to cause clinically apparent disease. Both hormones lead to the survival and activation of autoreactive B cells, but they skew B cell maturation towards different directions, with prolactin inducing T cell-dependent autoreactive follicular B cells and estrogen eliciting T cell-independent autoreactive marginal zone B cells. Differential modulation of the cytokine milieu by hormones may also affect the development and activation of specific mature B cell subsets. This novel insight suggests that targeted manipulation of these pathways may represent a promising avenue in the treatment of lupus and other gender-biased autoimmune diseases.

Possible mechanisms of gender bias in SLE: a new hypothesis involving a comparison of SLE with atopy

The prevalence of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is far higher in females than in males, and numerous investigations of this gender bias have been performed from several perspectives. Sex hormones, particularly estrogens, may be significant in causing the gender discrepancy. This article discusses the possible importance of estrogens in regulating the expression of and responsivity to autoantigens in SLE and in atopic disorders, which are associated with hyperreactivity to exogenous antigens. Estrogens seem to play an important role in the overexpression of endogenous autoantigens, such as human endogenous retroviruses (HERV), and this may be related to the existence of a gender bias in the incidence of SLE but not atopy.

Sex ratio and rheumatic disease: excerpts from an Institute of Medicine report

Some autoimmune diseases have high female/male (F/M) ratios. Definitions and classifications of autoimmune diseases differ, as do the F/M ratios themselves. The sex ratio of lupus is the single most prominent, little explored clinical fact that may lead to understanding of how lupus and other autoimmune diseases occur. The objective of this study was to evaluate evidence for causes of high F/M ratios of autoimmune and non-immunologic diseases. This was done by a literature review. Some thyroid, rheumatic and hepatic diseases consistently have high F/M ratios; other autoimmune diseases have low ratios. Because F/M ratios reflect disease incidence, not disease severity, an intrinsic biologic cause for the F/M ratios (such as estrogen) would be likely to act through a threshold or permissive mechanism rather than through quantitative immunomodulation. Sex differences related to environmental exposure, X-inactivation, imprinting, X or Y chromosome genes and intrauterine influences are other possible explanations for sex differences of incidence. The epidemiology of the sex discrepant autoimmune diseases, young, female, suggests that an explanation for sex discrepancy lies in differential exposure, vulnerable periods or thresholds, rather than in quantitative aspects of immunomodulation.

Effect of 17beta-estradiol and voluntary exercise on lymphocyte apoptosis in mice

During the perimenopause, women may begin estrogen replacement therapy (ERT) and physical activity programs to reduce the symptoms of the climacteric. High-intensity exercise increases lymphocyte apoptosis, and estrogen is also known to have immune modulatory effects. The present study determined whether (1) estrogen exposure in vivo, and (2) low-intensity, voluntary exercise affect thymic and splenic lymphocyte apoptosis in adult female mice. 'Middle-aged' (>1 year), ovarian-intact female B6D2F(1) mice were implanted with 17beta-estradiol (E) pellets (L: 3 microg/day or H: 12 microg/day) or placebo (P: 0 microg/day). Mice were given 1 week to recover from implantation surgery after which they were randomized to wheel-running or no-wheel-running conditions. Twenty one days later, mice were sacrificed and thymus and spleen removed for determination of percent apoptosis and percent necrosis by flow cytometry, serum E levels by RIA, and tissue and body weights. Estrogen-treated, ovarian-intact mice accumulated less cumulative wheel-running activity than mice implanted with placebo (P<.001). E exposure was associated with lighter thymuses (P<.05), higher thymocyte apoptosis (P<.001), and higher serum E levels (P<.001), effects which were not modified by voluntary exercise. In contrast, splenocyte apoptosis and spleen weights did not differ by estrogen treatment or exercise. The results suggest that in vivo exposure to supplemental estrogen is associated with greater spontaneous apoptosis of thymocytes and reduced thymus weights in older ovarian-intact mice. The clinical significance for thymic (cellular) immunity in perimenopausal women given HRT remains to be determined.

Invited review: sex ratio and rheumatic disease

Human illnesses affect men and women differently. In some cases (diseases of sex organs, diseases resulting from X or Y chromosome mutations), reasons for sex discrepancy are obvious, but in other cases no reason is apparent. Explanations for sex discrepancy of illness occur at different biological levels: molecular (e.g., imprinting, X-inactivation), cellular (sex-specific receptor activity), organ (endocrine influences), whole organism (size, age), and environmental-behavioral, including intrauterine influences. Autoimmunity represents a prototypical class of illness that has high female-to-male (F/M) ratios. Although the F/M ratios in autoimmune diseases are usually attributed to the influence of estrogenic hormones, evidence demonstrates that the attributed ratios are imprecise and that definitions and classifications of autoimmune diseases vary, rendering at least part of the counting imprecise. In addition, many studies on sex discrepancy of human disease fail to distinguish between disease incidence and disease severity. In April 2001, the Institute of Medicine of the National Academy of Sciences published Exploring the Biological Contributions to Human Health: Does Sex Matter? (Wizemann T and Pardue M-L, editors). This minireview summarizes the section of that report that concerns autoimmune and infectious disease. Some thyroid, rheumatic, and hepatic autoimmune diseases have high F/M ratios, whereas others have low. Those that have high ratios occur primarily in young adulthood. Gonadal hormones, if they play a role, likely do so through a threshold or permissive mechanism. Examples of sex differences that could be caused by environmental exposure, X inactivation, imprinting, X or Y chromosome genetic modulators, and intrauterine influences are presented as alternate, theoretical, and largely unexplored explanations for sex differences of incidence. The epidemiology of autoimmune diseases (young, female) suggests that an explanation for sex discrepancy of these illnesses lies in differential exposure, vulnerable periods, or thresholds. Biologists have an opportunity to inform medical scientists about sex differences that explain different attack rates in specific diseases, and physicians offer biologists experiments of nature to test theories of sex.

Membrane estrogen and glucocorticoid receptors--implications for hormonal control of immune function and autoimmunity

Membrane steroid receptors (mSRs) have recently re-emerged as candidates for mediating steroid effects which do not fit the paradigm of nuclear transcription factor mechanisms. We have studied two steroid-binding classes of mSRs, and have noted striking similarities in their characteristics (immunocytochemical appearance, biochemical properties, proteolytic sensitivity, signaling pathways, regulation, and molecular origins). These observations strengthen the conclusion that mSRs can be modified versions of intracellular steroid receptors. The membrane estrogen receptors (mERs) we studied are involved in estrogen-induced release of prolactin. Membrane glucocorticoid receptors (mGRs) in both mouse and human lymphoma cells are necessary for the initiation of glucocorticoid-induced therapeutic apoptosis which is related to the developmental phenomenon of thymic involution. Diseases of autoimmunity such as systemic lupus erythematosus and arthritis are related to estrogen status. Since both of these mSRs have recently been found in both normal and cancerous lymphoid cells, actions of these mSRs may have important consequences for functions and diseases of the immune system. Therefore, the study of these forms of steroid receptors may present novel therapeutic opportunities for the use of steroids and steroid analogs.

Sex hormones as immunomodulators in health and disease

In addition to their effects on sexual differentiation and reproduction, sex hormones influence the immune system. This results in a gender dimorphism in the immune function with females having higher immunoglobulin levels and mounting stronger immune responses following immunization or infection than males. The greater immune responsiveness in females is also evident in their increased susceptibility to autoimmune diseases. However, a clear understanding of the myriad of effects that sex hormones have on the immune system is lacking. Studies in normal mice show that estrogen treatment induces polyclonal B cell activation with increased expression of autoantibodies characteristic of autoimmune diseases. Several mechanisms appear to contribute to the break in tolerance and the increase in plasma cell activity including a reduction of the mass of the bone marrow and the thymus, the emergence of sites of extramedullary hematopoiesis and altered susceptibility of B cells to cell death. In addition, sex hormone levels in both humans and experimental models correlated with the activity of their cytokine-secreting cells indicating that sex hormones influence the cytokine milieu and suggesting that altered sex hormonal levels in autoimmune patients contribute to the skewed cytokine milieu characteristic of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). While sex hormones alone do not cause autoimmune disease, abnormal hormone levels may provide the stage for other factors (genetic, infectious) to trigger disease. Understanding the physiology of the interaction between sex hormones and immune function and its potential pathological consequences may provide insight into the autoimmune diseases and new directions for their treatment.

Estrogen and progesterone receptors in murine models of systemic lupus erythematosus

Estrogens are believed to play a role in the etiology of both human and murine systemic lupus erythematosus (lupus; SLE), presumably through the agency of their cellular receptor proteins. There is now considerable interest in the molecular mechanism of action of estrogens in immune tissues, particularly with regard to autoimmune disorders, which are generally more prevalent in women. In this laboratory, an attempt is being made to characterize estrogen receptors in murine models of SLE and to try and relate this to estrogen receptor function in vivo. The initial aim was to compare binding properties of estrogen receptors in brain, reproductive and immune tissues of BALB/c and MRL/MP-lpr/lpr mice. The latter strain spontaneously develops an autoimmune disease resembling human systemic lupus erythematosus (lupus; SLE). It is hypothesized that estradiol, through its receptors, mediates the progression of murine SLE, and that in autoimmune disease, the estrogen receptor is functionally and/or structurally changed. Initial studies suggest that there are differences in estrogen receptors between BALB/c mice, which do not get autoimmune disease, and two strains that do, MRL/MP-lpr/lpr and NZB/W mice. In MRL mice, these differences may be reflected in impaired priming of the progesterone receptor.

Lupus: why women?

Estrogens are believed to play a role in the etiology of both human and murine systemic lupus erythematosus (lupus, SLE), presumably through the agency of their cellular receptor proteins. There is now considerable interest in the molecular mechanism of action of estrogens in immune tissues, particularly with regard to autoimmune disorders, which are generally more prevalent in women. In this laboratory, an attempt is being made to characterize estrogen receptors in murine models of SLE, namely NZB/W and MRL/MP-lpr/lpr mice, and to try to relate this to estrogen receptor function in vivo. It is hypothesized that estradiol (E(2)), through its receptors, mediates the progression of murine SLE and that in autoimmune disease, the estrogen receptor is functionally or structurally changed, or both. Initial studies suggest there are differences in estrogen receptors between BALB/c mice, which do not get autoimmune disease, and two strains that do, MRL/MP-lpr/lpr and NZB/W mice. There is evidence that in at least one model of SLE, the normal regulation of estrogen action by progesterone may be impaired. In several laboratories, attempts are being made to relate estrogen action to immune function and to autoimmune diseases. The study of estrogen action on the immune system may lead to the development of treatments that attenuate the immunostimulant effects of E(2) in autoimmune diseases such as SLE.

Evidence for pleomorphism of estrogen receptor capacity and affinity in liver and thymus of immature BALB/c and (NZBxNZW) F1 mice, a model of systemic lupus erythematosus

Binding properties of estrogen receptors in liver, thymus and uterus of BALB/c and (NZBxNZW) F1 mice were compared. (NZBxNZW) F1 mice spontaneously develop an autoimmune disease resembling human systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). It is hypothesized that estradiol, through its receptors, mediates the progression of murine SLE. High-speed cytosols were prepared from liver, thymus and uterus and incubated with the synthetic estrogen 3H-moxestrol (NEN). Scatchard plots were derived from binding isotherms obtained. Rectilinear Scatchard plots were obtained from all tissues, which is consistent with the presence of only one class of binding sites, or of more than one class but with the same affinity. There were, however, strain differences in that the affinity of the binding reaction was significantly higher in cytosols from BALB/c liver in males and females. In thymus, the situation was reversed in that the affinity was significantly higher in cytosols from (NZBxNZW) F1 mice. Thymic cytosols from BALB/c mice contained significantly more estrogen receptors per mg cytosol protein than did those from (NZBxNZW) F1 mice. The exacerbation of murine SLE may be due, at least in part, to these properties of estrogen receptors in liver and thymus.

Impaired estrogen priming of progesterone receptors in uterus of MRL/MP-lpr/lpr mice, a model of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE)

Estrogens exacerbate the autoimmune disease SLE and progesterone is immunoprotective. Estrogens increase synthesis of progesterone receptors (PR) and it is hypothesized that this physiological balance may be impaired in SLE. To test this, cytosolic PR were measured in hypothalamus, thymus and uterus from 6-week-old female ovariectomized BALB/c and MRL/MP-lpr/lpr mice 48 h after s.c. injection of estradiol benzoate (3.2 microg/0.1 ml; OB) in peanut oil or 0.1 ml peanut oil alone. PR were measured using [(3)H]ORG 2058, which does not bind to corticosteroid-binding globulin (CBG), and bound and free ligand were separated using minicolumns of Sephadex LH20 at 0 degrees C. PR were measured in cytosols from hypothalamus and uterus of oil-treated BALB/c mice, but were undetectable in thymus, whereas receptors were measurable in all three tissues of MRL mice. There was a significantly greater priming effect of OB on PR in uterus of BALB/c mice, but not in hypothalamus, and PR became detectable in thymus cytosols from BALB/c mice. Also, the apparent affinity of the binding reaction between [(3)H]ORG 2058 and PR was significantly higher than those measured in other tissues in hypothalamic cytosols of both strains. These results suggest that there is an impairment of estrogen priming of progesterone receptors in uterus and perhaps thymus of MRL mice.