Implication of soluble and membrane HLA class I and serum IL-10 in liver graft acceptance

Detailed Analysis of Simultaneous Renal and Liver Allografts in the Presence of DSA

Liver allografts protect renal allografts from the same donor from some, but not all, preformed donor specific alloantibodies (DSA). However, the precise mechanisms of protection and the potential for more subtle alterations/injuries within the grafts resulting from DSA interactions require further study.

Methods

We reevaluated allograft biopsies from simultaneous liver-kidney transplant recipients who had both allografts biopsied within 60 d of one another and within 30 d of DSA being positive in serum (positive: mean florescence intensity ≥5000). Routine histology, C4d staining, and specialized immunohistochemistry for Kupffer cells (KCs; CD163) and a C4d receptor immunoglobulin-like transcript-4 were carried out in 4 patients with 6 paired biopsies.

Results

Overt antibody-mediated rejection was found in 3 of 4 renal and liver allografts. One patient had biopsy-confirmed renal and liver allograft antibody-mediated rejection despite serum clearance of DSA. All biopsies showed KC hypertrophy (minimal: 1; mild: 2; moderate: 1; severe: 2) and cytoplasmic C4d KC staining was easily detected in 2 biopsies from 2 patients; minimal and negative in 2 biopsies each. Implications of which are discussed. Control 1-y protocol liver allograft biopsies from DSA- recipients showed neither KC hypertrophy nor KC C4d staining (n = 6).

Conclusions

Partial renal allograft protection by a liver allograft from the same donor may be partially mediated by phagocytosis/elimination of antibody and complement split products by KCs, as shown decades ago in controlled sensitized experimental animal experiments.

Acute rejection correlates with expression of major histocompatibility complex class I antigens on peripheral blood CD3(+)CD8(+) T-lymphocytes following skin transplantation in mice

This study investigated major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I) antigen expression on peripheral blood T-cells after transplantation to assess its potential as an early marker of acute graft rejection (AGR). Using a mouse model with or without immunosuppressive treatment, the expression of MHC-I antigens on CD3(+)CD8(+) T-lymphocytes was assessed by flow cytometry following syngeneic graft (n = 138) or allograft (n = 138) skin transplantation. The occurrence of AGR was assessed by examining the degree of lymphocyte and monocyte infiltration in transplant biopsies. During AGR, expression of MHC-I antigens increased significantly compared with pre-transplant levels in the allograft group, even with immunosuppressive treatment. The highest expression of MHC-I antigens occurred 5 - 6 days before macroscopic rejection. These results suggest that expression of MHC-I antigens on peripheral blood CD3(+)CD8(+) T-lymphocytes could be used as an early marker for predicting AGR.

Expression of HLA Molecules on Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes: A Useful Monitoring Parameter in Cardiac Transplantation

During the rejection process of cardiac allografts, the expression of HLA antigens increases on various graft tissues, ie, the myocardium and the interstitial structures. However, in this type of transplant there is a paucity of knowledge about HLA expression on recipient cells, such as peripheral blood mononuclear cells. In the present study expression of HLA class I and class II antigens was monitored on peripheral blood lymphocytes prior to and during a 12-month follow-up, using flow cytometry. In our series, the frequency of acute rejection episodes was greater from the fourth to the ninth month after transplantation, coinciding with a reduction in cyclosporine blood levels. At the same time, expression of HLA class I and class II antigens significantly increased among recipients suffering from more severe acute rejection episodes compared with those showing acceptance of their grafts (P < .01). In conclusion, acute rejection episodes in cardiac transplantation were associated with up-regulation of HLA molecules on recipient peripheral blood cells. Monitoring the expression of HLA molecules on peripheral blood lymphocytes may represent an easy, noninvasive practice to individualize immunosuppressive therapy.

Analysis of KIR2D receptors on peripheral blood lymphocytes from liver graft recipients

KIR2D receptors are killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIRs) specific for HLA-C epitopes, that are expressed on NK cells as well as on minor peripheral blood T-cell subsets, and are able to control NK and T cells activity. The present work explores NK, and particularly CD8(+) T cells expressing KIR2D2L1/S1 (CD158a) or KIR2D2L2/3/S2 (CD158b) receptors in liver graft alloresponse. Flow cytometry was used to analyse peripheral blood mononuclear cells stained with anti-CD158a and anti-CD158b antibodies from 110 liver recipients and 46 healthy controls, previous to and along the first month after transplantation. Pre-transplantation data shows that both CD158a and CD158b molecules can be detected on NK and T cells from all patients and controls, but both KIR2D(+)NK cells are significantly under-represented in patients respect to controls (P<0.001), and CD3(+)CD8(+)CD158a(+) cells decreased particularly in patients suffering from acute rejection (4.03+/-1.33 cells/microL) compared with controls (7.8+/-2.4 cells/microL). Following transplantation, KIR2D(+)CD8(+) T-cell repertoires increased through the first month, mainly in recipients with a good graft acceptance. In summary, monitoring of KIR2D(+)CD8(+) T cells, particularly KIR2DL1/S1(+)CD8(+) T cells at pre-transplant, and both KIR2DL1/S1(+) and KIR2DL2/3/S2(+) T-cell subsets at early post-transplant period, could offer useful information for clinical follow-up of liver grafts.

TGF-beta1 gene polymorphism in liver graft recipients

Cytokines are known to be important mediators during liver graft outcome and their gene polymorphism could affect the overall expression and secretion of cytokines. In this retrospective study, we analyzed the effect of TGF-beta1 polymorphism in 150 liver allograft recipients. Genotyping PCR-SSP were performed for TGF-beta1 gene (codon 10T/C and 25C/G). TGF-beta1 polymorphism at codon 10 and 25 correlate borderline with liver graft acceptance and when the combination between codon 10 and 25 was analyzed, it revealed that T/T G/C genotype and the TC haplotype were significantly associated with graft acceptance (p<0.05). TGF-beta1 high secretor phenotype was also increased in the acute rejection group close to significance (p=0.06). In conclusion, these findings show a correlation between TGF-beta1 gene polymorphism and liver graft acceptance.

HBV and HCV infections and acute rejection differentially modulate CD95 and CD28 expression on peripheral blood lymphocytes after liver transplantation

Hepatitis B virus (HBV) and hepatitis C virus (HCV) generally reinfect liver graft early posttransplantation and lead to poorer graft and patient survivals. In the present study the influence of acute rejection (AR), HBV and HCV infections, and human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class-I compatibility on the expression of CD28 (in 237 liver recipients) and CD95 (in 114 liver recipients) on peripheral blood cells were evaluated by flow cytometry during the first month after transplantation. HBV/HCV infections induced strong CD95 upregulation on CD3+ lymphocytes. Maximal CD95 upmodulation was found in infected recipients showing partial HLA class-I compatibility. AR and virus reinfection could be distinguished because CD28 was upregulated on CD4+ lymphocytes only in recipients with AR, irrespective of their status regarding HBV/HCV infections. In conclusion, cytometric co-evaluation of CD95 and CD28 expression on peripheral blood lymphocytes could be useful to discriminate AR from cellular activation induced by viral reinfection of the liver graft.

Soluble HLA class I molecules exert differentiated influence on renal graft condition

The function of soluble HLA (sHLA) antigens in the process of immunoregulation and especially in graft tolerance versus rejection has not yet been established. It has been suggested that donor-derived sHLA may exert an immunotolerant influence on the graft. We sought to determine the role of sHLA class I in kidney graft survival by evaluating the influence of these molecules on allotypic lymphocytotoxic antibodies and the concentration of gamma interferon (INF-gamma). Analysis of sHLA was performed indirectly utilizing their ability to inhibit lymphocytotoxic reaction dependent on complement activation. To demonstrate the inhibitory properties of sHLA, we modified the NIH microcytotoxic test. Furthermore, we determined the concentration of INF-gamma in all sera samples for comparison with the intensity of the cytotoxic test. The comparison of the intensity of cytotoxic test inhibition with the concentration of INF-gamma revealed that high concentrations of this cytokine were associated with stronger inhibition of the cytotoxic test, thus with higher concentrations of sHLA class I molecules in recipient sera. We observed that high concentrations of sHLA class I molecules in recipient sera significantly inhibited cytotoxic reactions, which could contribute to a protective influence of sHLA on renal grafts. On the other hand, the observed increase of INF-gamma concentration might be caused by sHLA themselves, which would produce a detrimental influence on a transplanted organ. Therefore we concluded that the role of sHLA class I molecules in renal graft condition remains ambiguous.

Liver recipients harbouring anti-donor preformed lymphocytotoxic antibodies exhibit a poor allograft survival at the first year after transplantation: experience of one centre

In this retrospective study, we analyzed the effect of the presence of anti-donor preformed alloantibodies in 268 liver allograft transplants. Crossmatches were performed by complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) assay and HLA antibody screening by flow cytometry (FlowPRA). Positive anti-donor crossmatch was detected in 5.2% of transplants. Acute rejection frequency in +CDC crossmatch patients was not different from that observed in -CDC crossmatch patients. None of the patients transplanted with +CDC crossmatch developed chronic rejection, but they showed a significantly lower allograft survival rate, and the majority of them had allograft failures before the end of the first post-transplant year, mainly within the 3 first months. Indeed, positive FlowPRA determination was concordant with data from the CDC assay. In conclusion, these findings show a direct correlation between the presence of anti-donor preformed antibodies and a poor allograft survival in liver transplant.

Impact of HLA-C on acute rejection in liver transplantation

Although liver transplants show a special tolerogenic behaviour, rejection remains an important problem that involves several immunological mechanisms, some of which are unknown. Our study sought to analyze the influence of HLA-C polymorphism on short-term liver graft acceptance by HLA-C genotyping of 100 orthotopic liver transplant recipient-donor pairs. Recipients were statified according to the occurrence of acute rejection. HLA-Cw*06 allele appeared to be underrepresented among recipients without versus those with acute rejection or those in control groups. With regard to HLA-C allelic compatibility, the frequency of acute rejection or those in episodes decreased with fewer HLA-C mismatches. These findings suggest the participation of HLA-C molecules in liver graft alloresponses, involving HLA-C genotyping, as well as compatibility.

Human leukocyte antigen-C in short- and long-term liver graft acceptance

In liver transplantation, rejection is still an important problem, and the role of human leukocyte antigens (HLA) has not been clearly established. At present, the possible involvement of HLA-C antigen in liver transplantation is still unexplored. The aim of this work was to analyze the influence of HLA-C polymorphism on the outcome of liver transplantation. For this purpose, genotyping of 100 orthotopic liver transplant recipient-donor pairs for HLA-C was performed with polymerase chain reaction-sequence-specific primers (PCR-SSPs). Liver recipients were stratified according to the occurrence of acute rejection. Patients without acute rejection were found to have a lower frequency of the HLA-Cw*06 allele compared with those with acute rejection or the control group. Moreover, when the role of HLA-C dimorphism was analyzed, natural killer (NK)1-alloantigens were found to be predominant in recipients without acute rejection. When the match of HLA-C single alleles and NK-alloantigens between donor and recipient was analyzed, it appeared that the frequency of acute rejection gradually decreased with decrease of the number of allele mismatches. Graft survival was increased when the number of mismatches in both HLA-C or NK-alloantigens was lower. In conclusion, the HLA-C locus may play a role in liver graft alloreactivity or allotolerance and, therefore, may be useful to avoid acute rejection and to achieve graft acceptance, resulting in a better final outcome in liver transplantation.

HLA-G Molecules: from Maternal–Fetal Tolerance to Tissue Acceptance

Over the past few years, HLA-G, the non-classical HLA class I molecule, has been the center of investigations that have led to the description of its specific structural and functional properties. Although located in the HLA class I region of chromosome six, the HLA-G gene may be distinguished from other HLA class I genes by its low polymorphism and alternative splicing that generates seven HLA-G proteins, whose tissue-distribution is restricted to normal fetal and adult tissues that display a tolerogeneic function toward both innate and acquired immune cells. We review these points, with special emphasis on the role of HLA-G in human pathologies, such as cancer, viral infection, and inflammatory diseases, as well as in organ transplantation.

CD28/CTLA-4 and CD80/CD86 costimulatory molecules are mainly involved in acceptance or rejection of human liver transplant

CD28/CTLA-4 interactions with their specific B7-ligands (CD80 and CD86) have decisive roles in antigenic and allogenic responses. Recently, experimental transplant studies demonstrated that donor-specific tolerance is achieved by blocking these interactions. The present study analyzes the expression of these co-stimulatory molecules in peripheral blood cells from 74 liver recipients and in 16 liver biopsies, which were classified into acute-rejection (AR, n = 27) and nonacute-rejection (NAR, n = 47) groups, as well as their influence on the in vitro response of in vivo allosensitized cells. The results clearly indicate that in human liver transplant too, B7 and CD28/CTLA-4 expression on B and CD4(+) peripheral lymphocytes respectively, contributes to graft acceptance or rejection, and appears to be of crucial importance in modulating the host alloresponse and specific-CTL generation. In the NAR-group, costimulatory molecule expression remained at basal levels after transplant, whereas in the AR-group these molecules were significantly upregulated on days of AR. CTLA-4 was observed in the infiltrating lymphocytes in most of the biopsies, but CD80 or CD86 were not. Moreover, specific cytotoxicity from the in vivo primed cells was clearly suppressed in the NAR-patients with low co-stimulatory molecule expression, whereas this activity was not modified but rather stimulated in the AR-group. Together, these findings indicate that intervention of CD28/CTLA-4/B7 signaling could be therapeutically useful in clinical transplantation.