Teratogenesis of calcium valproate in rats

Modified Xenopus laevis approach (R-FETAX) as an alternative test for the evaluation of foetal valproate spectrum disorder

In compliance to animal welfare 3Rs principle there is a great demand for refined tests alternative to classical mammal teratogenicity tests. We propose a refined alternative amphibian method (R-FETAX) to evaluate chemical induced embryotoxicity. The human foetal valproate spectrum disorder (FVSD) characteristics are morphological defects (including cranio-facial, neural tube defects) and behavioural alterations due to valproate (VPA) exposure in pregnancy. Vertebrate assays to evaluate FVSD include classical and alternative mammal (implying adult sacrifice), and non-mammal developmental models (zebrafish, amphibians, chick). Among these latter only zebrafish assays report in the same test both morphological and behavioural examinations. Compared to zebrafish, the amphibian Xenopus laevis excels having a more comparable organ development and morphology to mammalian systems. We used X. laevis embryos exposed during developmental specific windows to VPA therapeutic concentrations. Different VPA effects were observed depending on the exposure window: concentration-related embryo-lethal and teratogenic effects (neural tube, facial, tail defects) were observed in groups exposed at the organogenetic phylotypic stages. Neurobehavioral deficits were described using a functional swimming test at the highest VPA concentration exposure during the phylotypic stages and at any concentration during neurocognitive competent stages. Malformations were compared to those obtained in a mammalian assay (the rat post-implantation whole embryo culture method, WEC), that we used in the past to evaluate VPA teratogenicity. R-FETAX and WEC data were modelled and their relative sensitivity was calculated. We suggest the amphibian R-FETAX as a refined windowed alternative test for the evaluation of chemicals inducing both morphological and behavioural anomalies, including VPA.

A Systematic Review to Compare Chemical Hazard Predictions of the Zebrafish Embryotoxicity Test With Mammalian Prenatal Developmental Toxicity

Originally developed to inform the acute toxicity of chemicals on fish, the zebrafish embryotoxicity test (ZET) has also been proposed for assessing the prenatal developmental toxicity of chemicals, potentially replacing mammalian studies. Although extensively evaluated in primary studies, a comprehensive review summarizing the available evidence for the ZET's capacity is lacking. Therefore, we conducted a systematic review of how well the presence or absence of exposure-related findings in the ZET predicts prenatal development toxicity in studies with rats and rabbits. A two-tiered systematic review of the developmental toxicity literature was performed, a review of the ZET literature was followed by one of the mammalian literature. Data were extracted using DistillerSR, and study validity was assessed with an amended SYRCLE's risk-of-bias tool. Extracted data were analyzed for each species and substance, which provided the basis for comparing the 2 test methods. Although limited by the number of 24 included chemicals, our results suggest that the ZET has potential to identify chemicals that are mammalian prenatal developmental toxicants, with a tendency for overprediction. Furthermore, our analysis confirmed the need for further standardization of the ZET. In addition, we identified contextual and methodological challenges in the application of systematic review approaches to toxicological questions. One key to overcoming these challenges is a transition to more comprehensive and transparent planning, conduct and reporting of toxicological studies. The first step toward bringing about this change is to create broad awareness in the toxicological community of the need for and benefits of more evidence-based approaches.

Adverse effect of valproic acid on an in vitro gastrulation model entails activation of retinoic acid signaling

Valproic acid (VPA), an antiepileptic drug, is a teratogen that causes neural tube and axial skeletal defects, although the mechanisms are not fully understood. We previously established a gastrulation model using mouse P19C5 stem cell embryoid bodies (EBs), which exhibits axial patterning and elongation morphogenesis in vitro. Here, we investigated the effects of VPA on the EB axial morphogenesis to gain insights into its teratogenic mechanisms. Axial elongation and patterning of EBs were inhibited by VPA at therapeutic concentrations. VPA elevated expression levels of various developmental regulators, including Cdx1 and Hoxa1, known transcriptional targets of retinoic acid (RA) signaling. Co-treatment of EBs with VPA and BMS493, an RA receptor antagonist, partially rescued axial elongation as well as gene expression profiles. These results suggest that VPA requires active RA signaling to interfere with EB morphogenesis.

Teratology study of amide derivatives of branched aliphatic carboxylic acids with 4-aminobenzensulfonamide in NMRI mice

BACKGROUND

Valproic acid (VPA), widely used to treat epilepsy, bipolar disorders, and migraine prophylaxis, is known to cause neural tube and skeletal defects in humans and animals. Aminobenzensulfonamide derivatives of VPA with branched aliphatic carboxylic acids, namely 2-methyl-N-(4-sulfamoyl-phenyl)-pentanamide (MSP), 2-ethyl-N-(4-sulfamoyl-phenyl)-butyramide (ESB), 2-ethyl-4-methyl-N-(4-sulfamoyl-phenyl)-pentanamide (EMSP), and 2-ethyl-N-(4-sulfamoyl-benzyl)-butyramide (ESBB), have shown more potent anticonvulsant activity than VPA in preclinical testing. Here, we investigated the teratogenic effects of these analogous compounds of VPA in NMRI mice.

METHODS

Pregnant NMRI mice were given a single subcutaneous injection of either VPA at 1.8 or 3.6 mmol/kg, or MSP, ESB, EMSP, or ESBB at 1.8, 3.6, or 4.8 mmol/kg on gestation day (GD) 8. Cesarean section was performed on GD 18, and the live fetuses were examined for external and skeletal malformations.

RESULTS

Compared with VPA, which induced neural tube defects (NTDs) in fetuses at 1.8 and 3.6 mmol/kg, the analog derivatives induced no NTDs at dose levels up to 4.8 mmol/kg (except for a single case of exencephaly at 4.8 mmol/kg MSP). Skeletal examination showed several abnormalities mainly at the axial skeletal level with VPA at 1.8 mmol/kg. Fused vertebrae and/or fused ribs were also observed with MSP, ESB, EMSP, and ESBB, they were less severe and seen at a lower incidence that those induced by VPA at the same dose level.

CONCLUSIONS

In addition to exerting more potent preclinical antiepileptic activity, teratology comparison indicates that aminobenzensulfonamide analogs are generally more weakly teratogenic than VPA.

In vitro effects of folate derivatives on valproate-induced neural tube defects in mouse and rat embryos

The anticonvulsant drug valproic acid (VPA), produces neural tube defects in mouse and rat embryos treated in vivo or in vitro. The mechanism for the drug's embryotoxic effect is unknown, but 5-formyltetrahydrofolate has been reported to decrease the incidence of VPA-induced neural tube defects in mice treated in vivo. In the present study we have examined the ability of 5-formyltetrahydrofolate, tetrahydrofolate, 5-methyltetrahydrofolate and folic acid to protect against VPA-induced neural tube defects in CD-1 mouse or CD rat embryos grown in a whole embryo culture system. Mouse embryos with 2-5 somite pairs were cultured for 48 hr beginning on gestation day 8; presomite stage rat embryos were cultured beginning on gestation day 9 (for both species gestation day 0 was taken as the day a vaginal sperm plug was found). VPA at 1.2 mm (rats) or 1.8 mm (mice) produced a high incidence of open neural tubes. None of the folate derivatives in concentrations up to 100 mug/ml was able to decrease the incidence of VPA-induced defects in either species. These data suggest that folate is not involved in the mechanism of VPA-induced neural tube defects.

Teratogens inducing congenital abdominal wall defects in animal models

Congenital abdominal wall defects are common anomalies which include gastroschisis, omphalocele and umbilical cord hernia. Recent reports indicate that gastroschisis is increasing in prevalence, whereas omphalocele has remained steady, suggesting that environmental factors may play a part in their pathogenesis. The aim of this study is to review animal teratogen studies resulting in abdominal wall defects to investigate their possible causes. Each report was examined not only for the teratogens causing the defects, but also to carefully identify the defect occurring and its correlation with the known clinical anomalies. We found many discrepancies between the nomenclature used by animal teratology investigators and that used by clinicians. We were able to confirm the induction of gastroschisis by 22 teratogens, omphalocele by 9 teratogens and umbilical cord hernia by 8. There is no doubt that environmental factors may be responsible, at least in part, for all three of the clinical abdominal wall defects. Future studies should take care to appreciate the differences between these anomalies and describe them in detail, so that accurate and meaningful conclusions can be obtained.

Tetramethylcyclopropyl analogue of the leading antiepileptic drug, valproic acid: evaluation of the teratogenic effects of its amide derivatives in NMRI mice

BACKGROUND

Although valproic acid (VPA) is used extensively for treating various kinds of epilepsy, it causes hepatotoxicity and teratogenicity. In an attempt to develop a more potent and safer second generation to VPA drug, the amide derivatives of the tetramethylcyclopropyl VPA analogue, 2,2,3,3-tetramethylcyclopropanecarboxamide (TMCD), N-methyl-TMCD (MTMCD), 4-(2,2,3,3-tetramethylcyclopropanecarboxamide)-benzenesulfonamide (TMCD-benzenesulfonamide), and 5-(TMCD)-1,3,4-thiadiazole-2-sulfonamide (TMCD-thiadiazolesulfonamide) were synthesized and shown to have more potent anticonvulsant activity than VPA. Teratogenic effects of these CNS-active compounds were evaluated in Naval Medical Research Institute (NMRI) mice susceptible to VPA-induced teratogenicity by comparing them to those of VPA.

METHODS

Pregnant NMRI mice were given a single sc injection of either VPA or TMC-amide derivatives on gestation day 8.5, and then the live fetuses were examined to detect any external malformations on gestation day 18. After double-staining for bone and cartilage, their skeletons were examined.

RESULTS

In contrast to VPA, which induced NTDs in a high number of fetuses at 2.4-4.8 mmol/kg, TMCD, TMCD-benzenesulfonamide, and TMCD-thiadiazolesulfonamide at 4.8 mmol/kg and MTMCD at 3.6 mmol/kg did not induce a significant number of NTDs. TMCD-thiadiazolesulfonamide exhibited a potential to induce limb defects in fetuses. Skeletal examination also revealed that fetuses exposed to all four of the tetramethylcyclopropanecarboxamide derivatives developed vertebral and rib abnormalities less frequently than those exposed to VPA. Our results established that TMCD, MTMCD, and TMCD-benzenesulfonamide are distinctly less teratogenic than VPA in NMRI mice.

CONCLUSIONS

The CNS-active amides containing a tetramethylcyclopropanecarbonyl moiety demonstrated better anticonvulsant potency compared to VPA and a lack of teratogenicity, which makes these compounds good second-generation VPA antiepileptic drug candidates.

Valproic Acid is Known to Cause Hypospadias in Man but does not Reduce Anogenital Distance or Causes Hypospadias in Rats

The use of valproic acid during human pregnancy increases the risk of hypospadias in the offspring. Rats exposed in utero to valproic acid did not develop hypospadias and even had a slightly increased anogenital distance in males 3-4 days after birth. A classical antiandrogenic drug, flutamide, caused hypospadias as well as a reduction of the anogenital distance in males. At the age of 3 months, rats exposed in utero with either valproic acid or flutamide showed a reduced testicular weight and hypoplasia of tubules, which seemed not to be related to the antiandrogenic activity of flutamide as it did not correlate with the presence of hypospadias. The mechanism through which valproic acid causes hypospadias in man and affects testicular development in rat is unknown. Hypospadias caused by valproic acid in man is apparently not due to anti-androgenic properties of the drug.

Altered axial skeletal development

The axial skeleton is routinely examined in standard developmental toxicity bioassays and has proven to be sensitive to a wide variety of chemical agents. Dysmorphogenesis in the skull, vertebral column and ribs has been described in both human populations and in laboratory animals used to assess potential adverse developmental effects. This article emphasizes vertebrae and rib anomalies both spontaneous and agent induced. Topics discussed include the morphology of the more common effects; incidences in both human and experimental animal populations; the types of anomalies induced in the axial skeleton by methanol, boric acid, valproic acid and others; the postnatal persistence of common skeletal anomalies; and the genetic control of the development of the axial skeleton. Tables of the spontaneous incidence of axial anomalies in both humans and animals are provided.

Syndromes and Disorders Associated with Omphalocele (III): Single Gene Disorders, Neural Tube Defects, Diaphragmatic Defects and Others

Omphalocele can be associated with single gene disorders, neural tube defects, diaphragmatic defects, fetal valproate syndrome, and syndromes of unknown etiology. This article provides a comprehensive review of omphalocele-related disorders: otopalatodigital syndrome type II; Melnick-Needles syndrome; Rieger syndrome; neural tube defects; Meckel syndrome; Shprintzen-Goldberg omphalocele syndrome; lethal omphalocele-cleft palate syndrome; cerebro-costo-mandibular syndrome; fetal valproate syndrome; Marshall-Smith syndrome; fibrochondrogenesis; hydrolethalus syndrome; Fryns syndrome; omphalocele, diaphragmatic defects, radial anomalies and various internal malformations; diaphragmatic defects, limb deficiencies and ossification defects of skull; Donnai-Barrow syndrome; CHARGE syndrome; Goltz syndrome; Carpenter syndrome; Toriello-Carey syndrome; familial omphalocele; Cornelia de Lange syndrome; C syndrome; Elejalde syndrome; Malpuech syndrome; cervical ribs, Sprengel anomaly, anal atresia and urethral obstruction; hydrocephalus with associated malformations; Kennerknecht syndrome; lymphedema, atrial septal defect and facial changes; and craniosynostosismental retardation syndrome of Lin and Gettig. Perinatal identification of omphalocele should alert one to the possibility of omphalocele-related disorders and familial inheritance and prompt a thorough genetic counseling for these disorders.

Assessment of developmental toxicity of vorinostat, a histone deacetylase inhibitor, in Sprague-Dawley rats and Dutch Belted rabbits

BACKGROUND

The developmental toxicity potential of vorinostat (suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid [SAHA], ZOLINZA), a potent inhibitor of histone deacetylase (HDAC), was assessed in Sprague-Dawley rats and Dutch Belted rabbits. HDAC inhibitors have been shown to mediate the regulation of gene expression, induce cell growth, cell differentiation, and apoptosis of tumor cells. Range-finding studies established oral dose levels of 5, 15, or 50 mg/kg/day and 20, 50, or 150 mg/kg/day in rats and rabbits, respectively.

METHODS

Animals were dosed on Gestation Days 6-20 or 7-20, respectively, with litter/fetal parameters evaluated on GD 21 and 28, respectively. Separate studies evaluated toxicokinetic parameters at the mid- and high-dose levels.

RESULTS

There was no maternal toxicity observed at the highest dose levels; however, hematology and serum biochemistry changes were characterized in the range-finding studies. Vorinostat did not induce morphological malformations in either rat or rabbit fetuses. In rats, drug-related developmental toxicity was observed only in the high-dose group and consisted of markedly decreased fetal weight and increases in fetuses with a limited number of skeletal variations. In rabbits, drug-related developmental toxicity was also observed only in the high-dose group and consisted of slightly decreased fetal weight and increases in fetuses with a short 13th rib and incomplete ossification of metacarpals. Maternal exposures to vorinostat based on AUC and Cmax values were comparable at the high-dose levels of both species. Rabbits tolerated higher dosages probably due to more extensive metabolism. Maternal concentrations of vorinostat were approximately 1,000-fold above the known in vitro HDAC inhibitory concentration.

CONCLUSIONS

Review of previous work with valproic acid, another HDAC inhibitor, suggest that the developmental toxicity profiles of these 2 compounds are not the result of HDAC inhibition but involve other mechanisms.

Molecular approaches to developmental malformations using analogous forms of valproic acid

The teratogenic potential of valproic acid has been well established both in experimental models and in human clinical studies. Evidence from many previous studies has shown that VPA is an appropriate drug model for studying chemical structure-teratogenicity relationships. Using molecular techniques of DNA microarray (GeneChip system) or quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction with low teratogenic VPA analogs as comparative control drugs, we attempted to identify the genes involved with the molecular mechanisms of VPA teratogenicity in the neural tube and the axial skeleton of the mouse embryo. The recent development of DNA microarray enables a genome-wide approach to the identification of genes correlated with the teratogenicity of chemicals (teratogenomics). The VPA-induced changes in gene expression seen during mouse embryogenesis provides information for understanding how VPA disrupts normal embryonic development, and also provides leads for the development of safer medicines.

The effects of valproic acid, vitamin E and folic acid on ribs of rat fetuses in the prenatal period

The present study was undertaken to determine histopathologic differences in the ribs of Wistar-albino rat fetuses prenatally exposed to valproic acid (VPA), folic acid (FA) and vitamin E (Vit E), and to compare their differential developmental susceptibility and morphological association with skeletal anomalies. VPA (300 mg/ kg), FA (300mg/kg) and Vit E (250mg/kg) were administered to rats on each of gestation days (GD) 7-9. Fetuses were collected on GD 21 and their ribs were examined for malformations. The fetuses were divided into four groups: blind-trial group, VPA group (vpa), VPA and Vit E group (vpa+vit e), valproic and FA group (vpa+fa). In each group; drug procedure, surgical procedure and histological methods were performed. Later, weights and lengths of fetuses in each group were compared and analyzed by one-way Anova test. As a result, maLformations in fetuses were determined and photographed by Nikon SMZ-2 steromicroscopy, using 2 x objective. Administration of single doses of VPA (300 mg/kg) resulted in weight and length loss between blind-trial and vpa group. However, length and weight differences between the other groups were not significant. The objective of the present study is to analyze morphological and histopathologic changes which may occur in a high-risk experimental model after the administration of VPA. In addition, protective roles of the administration of FA and Vit E are assessed.

Teratology study of derivatives of tetramethylcyclopropyl amide analogues of valproic acid in mice

BACKGROUND

Although valproic acid (VPA) is used extensively for treating various kinds of epilepsies, it is well known that it causes neural tube and skeletal defects in both humans and animals. The amide and urea derivatives of the tetramethylcylcopropyl VPA analogue, N-methoxy-2,2,3,3-tetramethylcyclopropanecarboxamide (N-methoxy-TMCD) and 2,2,3,3-tetramethylcyclopropanecarbonylurea (TMC-urea), were synthesized and shown to have a more potent anticonvulsant activity than VPA. The objective of this study was to investigate the teratogenic effects of these compounds in NMRI mice.

METHODS

Pregnant NMRI mice were given a single subcutaneous injection of either VPA, N-methoxy-TMCD, or TMC-urea at 1.8 and 3.6 mmol/kg on gestation day (GD) 8. Cesarean section was performed on GD 18. First, the live fetuses were examined to detect any external malformations, then their skeletons were double-stained for bone and cartilage and subsequently examined.

RESULTS

Significant increases in fetal losses and neural tube defects were observed with administration of VPA at 3.6 mmol/kg when compared to the vehicle control. In contrast, upon cesarean section, there were no significant differences between either N-methoxy-TMCD or TMC-urea and the control groups for any parameter. Skeletal examination revealed that a number of the abnormalities were induced by VPA dose-dependently at high rates of incidence. These abnormalities were mainly at the axial skeletal level. However, lower frequencies of skeletal abnormality were observed with N-methoxy-TMCD and TMC-urea than with VPA.

CONCLUSIONS

In addition to their more potent antiepileptic activity, these findings clearly indicate that N-methoxy-TMCD and TMC-urea are distinctly less teratogenic than VPA in NMRI mice.

Finally, a sense of closure? Animal models of human ventral body wall defects

Malformations concerning the ventral body wall constitute one of the leading categories of human birth defects and are present in about one out of every 2000 live births. Although the occurrence of these defects is relatively common, few detailed experimental studies exist on the development and closure of the ventral body wall in mouse and human. This field is further complicated by the array of theories on the pathogenesis of body wall defects and the likelihood that there is no single cause for these abnormalities. In this review, we summarize what is known concerning the mechanisms of normal ventral body wall closure in humans and mice. We then outline the theories that have been proposed concerning human body wall closure abnormalities and examine the growing number of mouse mutations that impact normal ventral body wall closure. Finally, we speculate how studies in animal models such as mouse and Drosophila are beginning to provide a much-needed mechanistic framework with which to identify and characterize the genes and tissues required for this vital aspect of human embryogenesis.

Structural Effects and Neurofunctional Sequelae of Developmental Exposure to Psychotherapeutic Drugs: Experimental and Clinical Aspects

The advent of psychotherapeutic drugs has enabled management of mental illness and other neurological problems such as epilepsy in the general population, without requiring hospitalization. The success of these drugs in controlling symptoms has led to their widespread use in the vulnerable population of pregnant women as well, where the potential embryotoxicity of the drugs has to be weighed against the potential problems of the maternal neurological state. This review focuses on the developmental toxicity and neurotoxicity of five broad categories of widely available psychotherapeutic drugs: the neuroleptics, the antiepileptics, the antidepressants, the anxiolytics and mood stabilizers, and a newly emerging class of nonprescription drugs, the herbal remedies. A brief review of nervous system development during gestation and following parturition in mammals is provided, with a description of the development of neurochemical pathways that may be involved in the action of the psychotherapeutic agents. A thorough discussion of animal research and human clinical studies is used to determine the risk associated with the use of each drug category. The potential risks to the fetus, as demonstrated in well described neurotoxicity studies in animals, are contrasted with the often negative findings in the still limited human studies. The potential risk fo the human fetus in the continued use of these chemicals without more adequate research is also addressed. The direction of future research using psychotherapeutic drugs should more closely parallel the methodology developed in the animal laboratories, especially since these models have already been used extremely successfully in specific instances in the investigation of neurotoxic agents.

Amidic modification of valproic acid reduces skeletal teratogenicity in mice

BACKGROUND

The antiepileptic drug valproic acid (VPA) is well known to cause neural tube and skeletal defects in both humans and animals. The amidic VPA analogues valpromide (VPD) and valnoctamide (VCD) have much lower teratogenicity than VPA inducing exencephaly in mice. The objective of this study was to investigate the teratogenic effects of VPA, VPD, and VCD on the skeleton of NMRI mice.

METHODS

Pregnant NMRI mice were given a single subcutaneous injection of VPA (400 and 800 mg/kg), VPD (800 mg/kg), or VCD (800 mg/kg) on the morning of gestation day (GD) 8. Cesarean section was carried out on GD 18. Live fetuses were double-stained for bone and cartilage and their skeletons were examined.

RESULTS

Significant increases in fetal loss and exencephaly rate were observed with VPA at 800 mg/kg compared to the vehicle control. There were no significant differences between either VPD or VCD and the control groups for any parameter at cesarean section. A number of abnormalities were dose-dependently induced at high incidences by VPA in both the cartilage and bone of vertebrae, ribs and sternum. In contrast, lower frequencies of abnormality were exhibited with VPD and VCD than VPA in all skeletons affected by VPA.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings clearly indicate that VPD and VCD are distinctly less teratogenic than VPA in the induction of not only neural tube defects, but also skeletal abnormalities. A structure-teratogenicity relationship of VPA on the skeleton is suspected.

A new rapid radiological procedure for routine teratological use in bone ossification assessment: a supplement for staining methods

BACKGROUND

Presently, bone ossification is assessed by the study of single-stained fetal bones (alizarin red-S) or double-stained bones and cartilaginous structures (alcian blue followed by alizarin red-S). Both methods, especially double-staining, are labor-intensive, time-consuming, and provide qualitative information regarding skeleton ossification. Quantitative evaluation of ossification is more difficult and is usually based on determination of calcium and other minerals in the bone by means of atomic absorption spectrometry. Here we introduce a simple new method that allows quantitative determination of skeleton ossification before routine staining examination.

METHODS

Fetuses delivered by laparotomy on the 16th and 21st day of gestation as well as 1-day-old rat pups were examined. The fetuses and pups were prenatally subcutaneously exposed to sodium valproate or to physiological saline. Lateral, prone, and supine digital radiograms of each fetus were taken using the Digora-Soredex digital radiography system and the Planmeca Intra intraoral X-ray machine. According to the best visualization, the data concerning vertebra were analyzed. All the fetuses were then routinely double-stained using alcian blue and alizarin red-S.

RESULTS

Malformations of axial skeleton (rib, sternum, and thoracic and sacral vertebra) were found in valproate-treated groups. Unlike cartilage malformations, the bone changes were detected in similar frequency in radiological and staining methods. Differences in densities according to the degree of ossification in the vertebral arches and bodies at different levels of the vertebral column, between drug-treated and negative control groups were noted.

CONCLUSIONS

The preliminary results suggest that digital radiography examination is a useful method in determining delaying of skeleton ossification not detectable by other methods. It balances qualitative and quantitative aspects of the presently used methods and is also simple, objective, fast, and relatively inexpensive.

Comparative study of sodium valproate-induced skeletal malformations using single or double staining methods

The teratogenic activity of xenobiotics is usually investigated by examining visceral and skeletal abnormalities of term fetuses. Although the rodent fetal skeleton is only partially ossified, the single stain for bone is the most commonly used method in routine teratology testing, while the double stain for evaluation of both bone and cartilage is often used only in basic research. The present work compares data obtained from rat fetuses using the two methods after exposure to the teratogenic agent sodium valproate at specific embryonic stages of development. Pregnant rats were treated with 400mg/kg sodium valproate and sacrificed at term of pregnancy. Even if both methods were able to identify sodium valproate as a teratogenic molecule, correct and complete interpretation of data was possible only by using the double stain. Our results show the inability of the single stain to correctly discriminate between major and minor abnormalities.

Morphological alterations induced by sodium valproate on somites and spinal nerves in rat embryos

The antiepileptic drug valproic acid is a well-known teratogenic agent; its main target organ is the neural tube, though skeletal malformations have also been described. In our recent work, respecifications of vertebrae were described in rat fetuses after treatment with 400 mg/kg of sodium valproate at specific somitogenic stages. The observed malformations were stage-dependent. Morphological segmental respecification was observed at the level of segments in formation at the moment of exposure and at the level of more posterior segments. Recently, specific alterations in the development of cranial nerves and ganglia were described in mouse embryos after in vitro exposure to VPA. The aim of the present work was to analyze dysmorphogenetic effects of VPA on embryonic metameric structures: somites, spinal and cranial nerves, and ganglia. Sodium valproate (400 mg/kg) was subcutaneously injected at specific gestational times corresponding to embryonic stages: presomitic or at about 2, 6, 10, 14, 18, or 22 somites. Females were sacrificed on the day 12 post coitum, and embryos were examined. Morphological examination of somites was performed by staining with acridine orange. Morphological examination of nerves and ganglia was performed by immunostaining, using monoclonal antibodies to the 160-kD neurofilament protein. No abnormalities were observed in the cranial nerves and ganglia. Specific and stage-dependent alterations were observed both at the level of the somites and at the level of the spinal nerves. The following characteristic malformations were observed: fusions, duplications, and reductions of somites and corresponding spinal nerves and ganglia. Our morphological data suggest a morphogenetic action of VPA at the level of the axial segments, with a possible respecification of the identity of the interested segments and their derivatives.

Teratogenic effects of vigabatrin in TO mouse fetuses

Vigabatrin (VGB) is a relatively recently introduced antiepileptic drug that enhances the brain levels of gamma aminobutyric acid (GABA). Few data on its teratogenic effects appear to have been reported. Our objective was to determine if VGB was teratogenic in the TO mouse. Single doses of 300-600 mg/kg of VGB dissolved in saline were administered intraperitoneally (IP) to groups of TO mice on one of gestation days (GD) 7-12. The controls were saline treated or untreated. No maternal toxic effects were observed in the 300 or 450 mg/kg groups, and the 600 mg/kg dose was totally lethal to the mothers. Fetuses were collected on GD 18. Both 300 and 450 mg/kg doses induced a consistently significant intrauterine growth retardation irrespective of the developmental stage at administration. VGB did not augment the spontaneous incidence of neural tube defects characteristic of this strain, but accelerated destruction of the brain in spontaneous exencephalic embryos. Mandibular and maxillary hypoplasia, arched palate, cleft palate (two cases), limb defects (one case), and exomphalos were observed in the malformed fetuses. The high incidence of exomphalos appears to be a unique result of VGB treatment. Alizarin red-S/alcian blue-stained, skeletons revealed hypoplasia of mid facial bones, stage-dependent increase in the frequency of cervical and lumbar ribs, rib fusion, and sternal and vertebral malformations in the drug-treated fetuses. Middle and distal phalanges of the forepaw and mid phalanges and tarsals of the hindpaw failed to ossify in a significant number of experimental fetuses. Homeotic shift in terms of presacral vertebral number and a high incidence of lumbar and cervical ribs in the treated group are suggestive of treatment-related alterations in gene expression. In view of the paucity of human and animal data on the reproductive toxicologic effects of VGB, the results of the present study assume particular importance and suggest that VGB should be used in pregnancy with extreme caution.

Sodium valproate augments spontaneous neural tube defects and axial skeletal malformations in TO mouse fetuses [corrected]

The TO mouse exhibits a low incidence (3.65%) of spontaneous exencephaly at birth. The objectives of this study were to determine if sodium valproate (VPA) would augment this background frequency of exencephaly and to characterize its gross and histologic bases. Single doses of 200, 400, or 600 mg/kg of VPA were administered on one of gestation days (GD) 7 to 10 and fetuses were collected on GD 18. Significant augmentation of the background incidence of exencephaly was observed in the GD 7 and 8 treatment groups. Absence of the skull vault, hemorrhage, and degeneration of the exposed brain, polyhydramnios, and a female excess characterized the abnormality. Exencephalic embryos were markedly growth retarded. In addition to craniofacial and urogenital anomalies, severe axial skeletal malformations were found to be consistently associated with exencephaly. Morphometric evaluation of the alizarin red-stained skeleton confirmed significant skeletal growth inhibition. Histologic sections of GD 10 embryos revealed early onset of treatment-related growth retardation. Arrest of closure appeared to affect intermittent segments of the neural tube. The closure defect sometimes only involved the surface ectoderm of the dorsal midline. The unclosed neural tube was at times covered by a continuous layer of surface ectoderm. Cell death per se was not pronounced in the neuroepithelium. The mesenchyme was generally sparse and edema was obvious in embryos with partial closure. Growth inhibition of the optic and otic primordia was marked by pronounced cell death in these structures as well as in the otic and trigeminal ganglia and in the pharyngeal arch mesenchyme. Evidence for neural crest cell migration was also recorded. These data indicate that VPA interacts with genetic susceptibility, augments the frequency of exencephaly, and also induces other malformations in the TO mouse. The widespread malformations of the cranifacial structures are suggestive of the preferential effect of VPA on the neural crest or its derivatives.

Screening for reproductive toxicity in Fundulus heteroclitus by genetic expression profiling

Abstract Potentially teratogenic agents enter the environment at a rate that greatly exceeds current capabilities to effectively evaluate their reproductive toxicities. This is due, in part, to costly, labour-intensive methodologies involving mammalian embryonic screening assays that are currently in use worldwide. Therefore, we sought to develop a rapid, less expensive screening system with which to identify molecular biomarkers of teratogenicity using a non-mammalian system. Embryos of the topminnow, Fundulus heteroclitus, offer several advantages in terms of reproductive toxicity screening efficiency as compared with mammalian embryonic systems. These embryos are easily manipulated and develop normally at ambient temperature in air, water, or air-saturated mineral oils, making them readily adapted for field studies. In the present study, developing f. heteroclhs embryos were exposed to teratogenic concentrations of sodium valproate (VPA) or arsenic acid (arsenate), and the frequency and types of induced malformations were evaluated. Using in situ transcription and antisense RNA (aRNA) amplification procedures (IST/aRNA), we attempted to correlate the teratogenic outcomes to specific alterations in the expression of a panel of developmentally regulated genes. Preliminary studies identified treatment concentrations of arsenate and VPA that induced abnormal development in 95 % of the surviving embryos. Among the F. heteroclitus embryos, the structural defects most commonly induced by these compounds were cardiac and neural tube malformations. The genetic expression profiles revealed a number of genes whose expression levels were significantly altered by exposure to the test compounds. Molecular analysis of f. heteroclitus embryonic development represents a novel, inexpensive approach to screen for potential teratogens, and identify genes whose expression patterns may be used as biomarkers, or indicators, of teratogenicity.

Assessment of the effectiveness of animal developmental toxicity testing for human safety

Evaluations of studies for four well-known human developmental toxicants clearly suggest that a margin of exposure of 1/100th the NOAEL for the most sensitive animal species tested provides adequate safety for the human conceptus. The lowest reported human teratogenic exposures occurred at doses at least one log above the estimated "safe" or acceptable daily exposure based on the most sensitive animal species, that is, 1/100th animal NOAEL. (The MOE ranged from < 1 to 10.). The data and analyses are consistent with the conclusion that, regardless of the type of in utero effect produced in animals, the margin of safety of 100 is likely to protect the human conceptus in utero from developmental perturbation, and it is a scientifically reasonable and conservative default number.

Valproic acid-induced placental and teratogenic effects in rats

Studies on teratogenicity and pathology of the cenceptus were conducted in Sprague-Dawley rats treated with 600, 800, and 1,000 mg/kg valproic acid po on day 13 of pregnancy. Each of the three doses was maternotoxic and caused (1) resorptions and/or abortions, reduction in the number of live fetuses per litter and mean fetal weight, and defects of the tail, rib and phalanx; and (2) degenerative changes in the labyrinth (thrombosis, angiectasis in the maternal lacunar network, necrosis of cytotrophoblasts and suppressed proliferation of fetal capillaries), reduced diameter nearing obliteration of umbilical vessels, with or without karyorrhexis of embryonic tissues. The lesions in the placental labyrinth were specific but, in the embryonic tissues, they were generalized. It was postulated that the vascular lesions in the labyrinth and umbilicus may have influenced embryonic development by reducing maternoembryonic gaseous and nutritional exchange.

Calcium valproate-induced uterine adenocarcinomas in Wistar rats

Calcium valproate is an anticonvulsant agent with pharmacokinetic properties similar to sodium valproate and valproic acid. Potential carcinogenesis of calcium valproate was evaluated in B6C3F1 mice and Wistar rats given 125, 250 and 500 mg/kg in the diet for 104 weeks. Survival in treated rats increased in a dose-related pattern despite a tumorigenic response in females. Adenocarcinomas of the uterus and cervix were increased in treated rats when compared to controls. The incidence of uterine neoplasia was 8, 20, 14 and 32% in the control, 125, 250 and 500 mg/kg groups, respectively. Neoplasia in treated rats were detected against a higher than expected background of adenocarcinomas in concurrent controls, since 8% incidence in controls was substantially above the laboratory historical database value of 0.6%. Tumors varied from epithelial masses confined to the endometrium, to transmural, highly desmoplastic neoplasms that invaded the serosa lining and the peritoneal cavity. These tumors metastasized in treated rats but not in controls. The statistically significant (P less than 0.01) increase in uterine adenocarcinomas found in females given 500 mg/kg of calcium valproate contrasts the absence of this tumor type in a previous rat carcinogenicity bioassay with valproic acid. Subcutaneous fibrosarcomas were significantly increased in valproic acid-treated males, but no uterine tumors were reported in females. It is puzzling that a true carcinogenic potential would be expressed by markedly different target organs as obtained with the acid and calcium salt of this moiety.

Studies on valproate-induced perturbations of neurulation in the explanted chick embryo

The effect of the anticonvulsant sodium valproate on in vitro neurulation of the chick embryo, explanted after a 25-h in ovo incubation period, is described. Sodium valproate, at concentrations of 0.5-1.5 mM did not appear to have any profound effect on embryo growth when assessed by light microscopy. However scanning electron microscopy revealed a dose-dependent increase in the incidence of open anterior and posterior neuropores after 20 h of in vitro development (Stage 11). Concentrations of sodium valproate which were greater than 1.5 mM markedly increased the number of gross malformations, which were manifested as a complete disruption of the neural tube along its entire length. Failure of neuropore closure could not be attributed to a drug-induced neurodevelopmental delay as these defects were still apparent following 27 h of in vitro culture, a time coincident with the onset of embryo torsion.

Valproic acid-induced neural tube defects in mouse and human: aspects of chirality, alternative drug development, pharmacokinetics and possible mechanisms

Administration of the antiepileptic drug valproic acid (VPA) during early pregnancy can result in a 1-2% incidence of spina bifida aperta, a closure defect of the posterior neural tube in the human. The predominant defect produced by VPA in the mouse is exencephaly, a closure defect of the anterior neural tube. Recent experiments demonstrate that an appropriate dosing regimen (consecutive doses of VPA on day 9 of gestation) can also result in a low incidence of spina bifida aperta, and a high incidence of spina bifida occulta in the mouse as a potential animal model. Relatively high doses and concentrations of VPA are needed in the mouse to produce neural tube defects, the human appears to be more sensitive in this regard. Maximal concentrations and not AUC (area under the concentration-time curve) values correlate with the incidence of neural tube defects in the mouse which could in part be explained by saturation of plasma protein binding, increased free drug available for placental transfer and the embryonic neuroepithelium acting as a "deep compartment". It is likely that the parent drug and not a metabolite is the proximate teratogen. Structure-activity relationships show a strict structural requirement for high teratogenic potency: the molecule must contain an alpha-hydrogen atom, a carboxyl function, branching on carbon atom 2 with two chains containing 3 carbon atoms each for maximum activity. If these two carbon chains are different, then enantiomers are present such as the R- and S-enantiomers of 2-n-propyl-4-pentenoic acid (4-en-VPA), 2-n-propyl-4-pentynoic acid (4-yn-VPA) and 2-ethylhexanoic acid. These enantiomers were synthesized and shown to be significantly different in regard to teratogenic potency. Pharmacokinetic studies indicate that both enantiomers of each compound reach the embryo to the same degree. Therefore, the intrinsic teratogenic activity of the enantiomers differ, suggesting a stereoselective interaction between the drugs and a chiral structure within the embryo, is involved in the mechanism of action. In sharp contrast to the teratogenic effect, the anticonvulsant activity and neurotoxicity of this compound class show broad structural specificity, opening the possibility for development of novel antiepileptic agents with low teratogenic potency such as 2-n-propyl-2-pentenoic acid (2-en-VPA). The molecular mechanism of the teratogenicity of VPA is quite unknown; of the several hypothesis suggested, the interaction of VPA with embryonic folate metabolism is discussed here.

Lack of attenuation of valproic acid-induced effects by folinic acid in rat embryos in vitro

The anticonvulsant drug valproic acid (VPA) is suspected to be a developmental toxicant in humans, inducing primarily neural tube defects. The mechanism for this effect is unknown, but it has been suggested that the drug may act via a deficiency of the vitamin folic acid. We examined this possibility by concurrent treatment of rat embryos in a whole embryo culture system with VPA and folinic acid (FA), a folic acid derivative. Groups of CD rat embryos were treated with various concentrations of VPA, various concentrations of FA, or a combination of a teratogenic dose of VPA plus various levels of FA. At the end of the 44 hour culture period, each embryo was evaluated for viability (presence of a heartbeat), yolk sac circulation, presence of any malformations, morphological score, crown-rump and head lengths, as well as DNA and protein contents. The anticonvulsant did not decrease viability but did decrease yolk sac circulation and all growth and developmental endpoints in a dose-responsive manner. There was also a dose-related increase in the incidence of open neural tubes. The addition of FA alone had no significant effect on growth and development. When various concentrations of FA were added simultaneously with a teratogenic dose of VPA, there was no decrease in the incidence of open neural tubes. Growth and developmental endpoints were altered in a somewhat random fashion but were never increased to the control level. The lack of attenuation by FA was not due to instability of the compound in the culture system, nor was there a difference in the amount of FA present in the exocoelomic fluid of VPA-treated and control embryos.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Lack of teratogenicity of trans-2-ene-valproic acid compared to valproic acid in rats

The teratogenicity of trans-2-ene-valproic acid (300 and 400 mg/kg) was compared with that of valproic acid (VPA; 300 mg/kg) and controls (corn oil) administered by gavage to Sprague-Dawley CD rats on embryonic (E) days 7-18. At the 300 mg/kg dose, trans-2-ene-VPA produced no change in maternal weight, number of implantations, proportion of resorptions, proportion of malformations, or fetal weight. By contrast, the same dose of VPA (300 mg/kg) reduced maternal weight during gestation, increased malformations (12.0% vs. 0.7% in controls), and reduced fetal body weight by 25.1%. An even higher dose of trans-2-ene-VPA (400 mg/kg) produced a reduction in maternal body weight during treatment and reduced fetal body weight (by 7.9%), but did not increase resorptions or malformations in the fetuses. On day E18, maternal serum drug concentrations of VPA were higher in the VPA-treated group compared with those of trans-2-ene-VPA in the trans-2-ene-VPA-treated groups at 1 hr posttreatment. At 6 hr posttreatment the reverse was seen. trans-2-ene-VPA may be absorbed more rapidly and distributed differently than VPA. Overall, the data support the view that trans-2-ene-VPA at equal or higher doses than VPA is not teratogenic in rats.

Developmental toxicity of valproic acid

Valproic acid is a very effective anticonvulsant agent widely used in the management of various forms of epilepsy. Administration of the drug during pregnancy results in increased incidence of congenital abnormalities in both humans and experimental animals. In recent years, a significant number of research efforts have attempted to define the contributory role of valproic acid to the impairment of normal prenatal growth and development. The present report summarizes current knowledge that has emerged from clinical and research studies. The specific topics include: the placental transfer of valproic acid; the teratogenic potential; structure-teratogenicity and dose-response relationships; species and strain differences; biochemical changes evoked by the drug in the fetus.

Preclinical toxicology of the anticonvulsant calcium valproate

The oral toxicity of the anticonvulsant calcium valproate with selected comparisons to valproic acid and sodium valproate was evaluated in mice, rats and Beagle dogs. Median lethal doses of the three forms of valproate in rodents ranged from 1100 to 3900 mg/kg. Clinical signs in acute studies and reductions in body weight or body weight gain and food consumption at high doses in rats and dogs during 2-, 13- and 52-week studies were considered to be central nervous system related. In the 13-week study in rats (calcium valproate at 200, 400, 800, 1200 and 1600 mg/kg and sodium valproate at 1200 mg/kg), reduced plasma globulin levels and low white blood cell counts due to suppressed neutrophil maturation were noted at doses of 800 mg/kg and higher. Platelet counts were reduced at 1200 and 1600 mg/kg. Testicular atrophy occurred at 1200 and 1600 mg/kg. In dogs given calcium valproate at 100, 200 and 400 mg/kg for 13 weeks, testicular atrophy was seen at 400 mg/kg and mild hepatocellular changes at all doses. In rats given calcium valproate at 125, 250 and 500 mg/kg for 1 year, reduced plasma protein and globulin levels and a dose-dependent increased incidence and severity of atrophic pancreatitis were noted at 250 and 500 mg/kg. Calcium valproate, given for 1 year to dogs at doses of 50, 100 and 200 mg/kg, was well tolerated. These studies indicated that calcium valproate has a toxicity profile similar to other forms of valproate.

Valproic acid developmental toxicity and pharmacokinetics in the rhesus monkey: an interspecies comparison

This study was undertaken to assess the developmental toxicity and drug distributional and metabolic characteristics of prenatal valproic acid (VPA) exposure in rhesus monkeys. Oral administration of 20-600 mg/kg/day VPA (approximately 1-15 X human therapeutic dose) to 33 animals on variable gestational days (GD) during organogenesis resulted in dose-dependent developmental toxicity manifested as increased embryo/fetal mortality, intrauterine growth retardation, and craniofacial and skeletal defects. Biphasic plasma elimination curves were observed for total and free VPA on the first (GD 21) and last (GD 50) days of treatment in the 100- and 200-mg/kg/day dose groups. VPA exhibited dose-independent elimination kinetics at the plasma concentrations observed in this study. There was no significant change in pharmacokinetic parameters (maternal plasma elimination rate, area under the curve, peak plasma concentration) between the first and last days of treatment at either dose level. Placental transfer studies indicated that embryos were exposed to half the free VPA concentrations present in maternal plasma on GD 37. Comparisons of interspecies sensitivity to VPA-induced developmental toxicity in the mouse, rat, monkey, and man are made.

Teratogen update: valproic acid

Valproic acid use during pregnancy results in an absolute risk for spina bifida of 1-2%. This increased risk is comparable to the recurrence risk for neural tube defects and warrants informed counselling and access to prenatal diagnosis. There is no substantial evidence that valproic acid use increases the risk for other specific major malformations above the increased risk due to maternal epilepsy. Valproic acid may cause a characteristic pattern of minor facial malformations. Further definition and confirmation are required, and the magnitude of the risk needs to be determined. There are inadequate data to assess the magnitude, if any, of the risks for postnatal growth abnormalities and developmental disabilities associated with the use of valproic acid during pregnancy. Birth-defect monitoring programs and international collaboration among the staffs of monitoring programs played a major role in determining that valproic acid is a human teratogen.

Teratogenicity and developmental toxicity of valproic acid in rats

The teratogenicity and developmental toxicity of valproic acid (VPA) was investigated in Sprague-Dawley CD rats at doses of 0, 150, 200, 300, 400, and 600 mg/kg administered by gavage on days 7-18 of gestation. The VPA-600 dose was maternally toxic, causing death in two of four dams. This dose produced 100% embryonic resorption. The VPA-400 dose was maternally toxic in as much as maternal weight gain was reduced, but no deaths occurred. At this dose five of fifteen litters were completely resorbed, and 52% of all embryos were resorbed. Among survivors, 49% were malformed (68% having skeletal defects and 41% visceral defects). Fetal weight was reduced by 43% in this group. Most of the defects were ectrodactyly, hydronephrosis, cardiovascular defects, hypoplastic bladder, rib and vertebral defects, and other defects of the limbs and tail. The VPA-300 dose (nine litters) produced fewer defects, larger fetuses, and no increase in resorptions. The defects at this dose were primarily cariovascular, rib, and vertebral. The VPA-200 dose (12 litters) produced no reduction in fetal weight, no increase in resorptions, and few defects. The defects noted were hydronephrosis, cardiovascular abnormalities, and rib defects, primarily wavy ribs. Additional litters were prepared using doses of 150 and 200 mg/kg and were allowed to deliver and grow until 70 days. These doses produced no reduction in maternal weight gain, no reduction in litter size, birth weight, or sex ratio of the offspring. These doses produced no reduction in offspring weight to day 70, no increase in mortality, and only rare cases (two offspring of each dose) of tail defects.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Teratogenesis of calcium valproate in rabbits

The calcium salt of valproic acid (Valontin) has been proposed for use in the treatment of absence, myoclonic, and tonic clonic seizures of the primarily generalized type. The present study was conducted to determine the teratogenic potential of calcium valproate in rabbits. Groups of 20 Dutch-belted rabbits were given oral doses of 50, 150, or 350 mg/kg on days 6-18 of gestation. A reference group was given 350 mg/kg sodium valproate and control groups were untreated or given vehicle alone. Animals were observed daily and body weights were recorded on gestation days 0, 6, 13, 18, and 30. Litter and fetal parameters were evaluated following uterotomies on day 30. No drug-related clinical signs or deaths occurred. Postimplantation loss and the incidence of malformed vertebrae and ribs, rudimentary or absent pollices, and extra vertebrae and ribs were increased at 350 mg/kg with both calcium and sodium salts of valproic acid. At the 150-mg/kg dose level, calcium valproate markedly increased the incidence of supernumerary ribs. No teratogenic or embryotoxic effects were seen with calcium valproate at 50 mg/kg. These data indicate that the sodium and calcium salts of valproic acid exhibit teratogenic potential in rabbits.

Weak acids may act as teratogens by accumulating in the basic milieu of the early mammalian embryo

Among the eleven drugs or chemicals which are well-documented human teratogens, eight (or their main metabolites) are weak acids whereas none is a weak base. Moreover, 23 out of 32 acids tested have been found to be teratogenic in at least one animal species. The acidic property of drugs may therefore be an important determinant of teratogenicity. We demonstrate here that the intracellular pH (pHi) of the mouse and rat embryo is higher than that of maternal plasma, as determined by the relative accumulation of dimethadione. The antiepileptic drug valproic acid and its pharmacologically active unsaturated metabolite accumulate in embryonic tissue to higher concentrations than in maternal plasma, whereas the essentially neutral amide of valproic acid (valpromide) or ethosuximide do not accumulate in the embryo; we further demonstrate in the rat that the pHi of the embryo decreases with advancing gestation; in general agreement with the pH partition hypothesis, the exposure of the embryo to valproic acid also decreases significantly during that period. Furthermore, the amides of two weak acid teratogens, valpromide and methoxyacetamide, and the imide ethosuximide, are much less teratogenic than their acid counterparts. Our results suggest that weakly acidic drugs, by virtue of their physico-chemical nature, accumulate in the early embryo with its relatively high pHi.

Therapeutic levels of sodium valproate inhibit mitotic indices in cells of neural origin

Sodium valproate (VPA) inhibited the mitotic index of neuroblastoma (Neuro-2A) and glioma (C6) cells with an IC50 of 0.5 and 1.0 mM, respectively. Continued exposure of these cell lines to 1 mM VPA induced differentiation and increased adhesiveness. These observations are characteristic of putative teratogens and this implication for VPA is discussed.

Teratogenic valproic acid concentrations: infusion by implanted minipumps vs conventional injection regimen in the mouse

The dosage-regimen-dependent teratogenicity as well as plasma and tissue levels of the antiepileptic drug valproic acid (VPA) were studied in the mouse by comparing various injection regimens and infusion of the drug via implanted osmotic minipumps. Concentrations of 225-248 micrograms VPA/ml maternal plasma (about 2X above the therapeutic concentration range) and 70-75 micrograms VPA/g gestational material (on gestation Day 8) resulted in a significant incidence of neural tube defects (exencephaly in the mouse). Similar effects were produced if those concentrations were reached several times after multiple injections or by steady-state application via implanted pumps. A single injection was less effective than multiple injections, although drug accumulation did not occur. The doses (or area under the concentration-time curve values) did not correlate with the teratogenic response of the different administration regimens: much higher (factor 10) doses were needed with the infusion regimen to produce exencephaly rates comparable to those obtained with the injection regimen. The pattern of embryotoxicity was also schedule dependent: steady-state concentrations produced predominantly embryolethality and fetal weight retardation, while intermittent injections produced a high incidence of exencephaly (up to 60% of live fetuses). The dose of VPA (and the areas under the concentration-time curves) correlated with the embryolethality and fetal weight retardation of the drug, while the peak or steady-state concentrations reached in mother and gestational material correlated with the incidence of neural tube defects.

Maternal toxicity: a possible etiological factor in embryo-fetal deaths and fetal malformations of rodent-rabbit species

Data from animal teratology studies were surveyed to determine whether embryo-fetal mortality and fetal malformations result from a primary action of the agent on the conceptus or if they are secondary to maternal toxicity--a consequence of administration with high dose levels of test chemicals. A fairly strong association between embryo-fetal mortality and maternal toxicity was revealed by analysis of data from hamsters, mice, rats, and rabbits in 234 studies of chemical and physical agents, of which 83 were conducted at both maternotoxic and nonmaternotoxic doses, 94 only at maternotoxic doses, and 49 at nonmaternotoxic doses. In the above studies, only nine chemicals (four each in hamsters and rabbits and one in rats) were reported to induce embryo-fetal deaths at apparently nonmaternotoxic doses. These findings tend to suggest a contributory role for maternal toxicity in the induction of embryo-fetal deaths. The previously reported hypothesis that certain fetal defects in mice may perhaps be caused by maternal toxicity was also found to be true in a review of data on hamsters, rats, and rabbits. Salient maternal toxicity-associated fetal malformations were exencephaly, encephalocele, micro- or anophalmia, and fused ribs in hamsters and defective (fused, missing, or extra) ribs, vertebrae, and sternebrae, ex-, an-, or microphthalmia, and cleft palate in rats and rabbits. These malformations occurred at low frequencies, generally with no readily apparent dose-response relationship. Presumptive evidence indicates that embryo-fetal deaths, and the above-mentioned fetal malformations in experimental animals, which in published literature are presently attributed to chemical induction for a large number of chemicals, may be a consequence of maternal toxicity per se.