Acoustic cavitation nuclei survive the apparent ultrasonic destruction of Albunex microspheres

Acoustic droplet vaporization in biology and medicine

This paper reviews the literature regarding the use of acoustic droplet vaporization (ADV) in clinical applications of imaging, embolic therapy, and therapeutic delivery. ADV is a physical process in which the pressure waves of ultrasound induce a phase transition that causes superheated liquid nanodroplets to form gas bubbles. The bubbles provide ultrasonic imaging contrast and other functions. ADV of perfluoropentane was used extensively in imaging for preclinical trials in the 1990s, but its use declined rapidly with the advent of other imaging agents. In the last decade, ADV was proposed and explored for embolic occlusion therapy, drug delivery, aberration correction, and high intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) sensitization. Vessel occlusion via ADV has been explored in rodents and dogs and may be approaching clinical use. ADV for drug delivery is still in preclinical stages with initial applications to treat tumors in mice. Other techniques are still in preclinical studies but have potential for clinical use in specialty applications. Overall, ADV has a bright future in clinical application because the small size of nanodroplets greatly reduces the rate of clearance compared to larger contrast agent bubbles and yet provides the advantages of ultrasonographic contrast, acoustic cavitation, and nontoxicity of conventional perfluorocarbon contrast agent bubbles.

Optimization of ultrasound and microbubbles targeted gene delivery to cultured primary endothelial cells

Ultrasound and microbubbles targeted gene delivery (UMTGD) is a promising technique for local gene delivery. As the endothelium is a primary target for systemic UMTGD, this study aimed at establishing the optimal parameters of UMTGD to primary endothelial cells. For this, an in vitro ultrasound (US) setup was employed in which individual UMTGD parameters were systematically optimized. The criteria for the final optimized protocol were: (1) relative high reporter gene expression levels, restricted to the US exposed area and (2) induction of not more than 5% cell death. US frequency and timing of medium replacement had a strong effect on UMTGD efficiency. Furthermore, US intensity, DNA concentration and total duration of US all affected UMTGD efficiency. Optimal targeted gene delivery to primary endothelial cells can be accomplished with Sonovue microbubbles, using 20 microg/ml plasmid DNA, a 1 MHz US exposure of Ispta 0.10 W/cm(2) for 30 s with immediate medium change after UMTGD. This optimized protocol resulted in both an increase in the number of transfected cells (more than three fold) and increased levels of transgene expression per cell (170%).

The antivascular action of physiotherapy ultrasound on a murine tumor: role of a microbubble contrast agent

This study investigated whether a microbubble-containing ultrasound contrast agent had a role in the antivascular action of physiotherapy ultrasound on tumor neovasculature. Ultrasound images (B-mode and contrast-enhanced power Doppler [0.02 mL Definity]) were made of 22 murine melanomas (K1735(22)). The tumor was insonated (I(SATA) = 1.7 W cm(-2), 1 MHz, continuous output) for 3 min and the power Doppler observations of the pre- and postinsonation tumor vascularities were analyzed. Significant reductions (p = 0.005 for analyses of color-weighted fractional area) in vascularity occurred when a contrast-enhanced power Doppler study occurred before insonation. Vascularity was unchanged in tumors without a pretherapy Doppler study. Histologic studies revealed tissue structural changes that correlated with the ultrasound findings. The underlying etiology of the interaction between the physiotherapy ultrasound beam, the microbubble-containing contrast agent and the tumor neovasculature is unknown. It was concluded that contrast agents play an important role in the antivascular effects induced by physiotherapy ultrasound.

Intravascular inertial cavitation activity detection and quantification in vivo with Optison

Inertial cavitation (IC) is an important mechanism by which ultrasound (US)-induced bioeffects can be produced. It has been reported that US-induced in vitro mechanical bioeffects with the presence of ultrasound contrast agents (UCAs) are highly correlated with quantified IC "dose" (ICD: cumulated root-mean-squared broadband noise amplitude in the frequency domain). The ICD has also been used to quantify IC activity in ex vivo perfused rabbit ear vessels. The in vivo experiments reported here using a rabbit ear vessel model were designed to: (1) detect and quantify IC activity in vivo within the constrained environment of rabbit auricular veins with the presence of Optison and (2) measure the temporal evolution of microbubble IC activity and the ICD generated during insonation treatment, as a function of acoustic parameters. Preselected regions-of-interest (ROI) in the rabbit ear vein were exposed to pulsed focused US (1.17 MHz, 1 Hz PRF). Experimental acoustic variables included peak rarefaction pressure amplitude ([PRPA]: 1.1, 3.0, 6.5 or 9.0 MPa) and pulse length (20, 100, 500 or 1000 cycles). ICD was quantified based on passive cavitation detection (PCD) measurements. The results show that: (1) after Optison injection, the time to onset of measurable microbubble IC activity was relatively consistent, approximately 20 s; (2) after reaching its peak value, the IC activity decayed exponentially and the half-life decay coefficient (t(1/2)) increased with increasing PRPA and pulse length; and (3) the normalized ICD generated by pulsed US exposure increased significantly with increasing PRPA and pulse length.

Transfection effect of microbubbles on cells in superposed ultrasound waves and behavior of cavitation bubble

The combination of ultrasound and ultrasound contrast agents (UCAs) is able to induce transient membrane permeability leading to direct delivery of exogenous molecules into cells. Cavitation bubbles are believed to be involved in the membrane permeability; however, the detailed mechanism is still unknown. In the present study, the effects of ultrasound and the UCAs, Optison on transfection in vitro for different medium heights and the related dynamic behaviors of cavitation bubbles were investigated. Cultured CHO-E cells mixed with reporter genes (luciferase or beta-gal plasmid DNA) and UCAs were exposed to 1 MHz ultrasound in 24-well plates. Ultrasound was applied from the bottom of the well and reflected at the free surface of the medium, resulting in the superposition of ultrasound waves within the well. Cells cultured on the bottom of 24-well plates were located near the first node (displacement node) of the incident ultrasound downstream. Transfection activity was a function determined with the height of the medium (wave traveling distance), as well as the concentration of UCAs and the exposure time was also determined with the concentration of UCAs and the exposure duration. Survival fraction was determined by MTT assay, also changes with these values in the reverse pattern compared with luciferase activity. With shallow medium height, high transfection efficacy and high survival fraction were obtained at a low concentration of UCAs. In addition, capillary waves and subsequent atomized particles became significant as the medium height decreased. These phenomena suggested cavitation bubbles were being generated in the medium. To determine the effect of UCAs on bubble generation, we repeated the experiments using crushed heat-treated Optison solution instead of the standard microbubble preparation. The transfection ratio and survival fraction showed no additional benefit when ultrasound was used. These results suggested that cavitation bubbles created by the collapse of UCAs were a key factor for transfection, and their intensities were enhanced by the interaction of the superpose ultrasound with the decreasing the height of the medium. Hypothesizing that free cavitation bubbles were generated from cavitation nuclei created by fragmented UCA shells, we carried out numerical analysis of a free spherical bubble motion in the field of ultrasound. Analyzing the interaction of the shock wave generated by a cavitation bubble and a cell membrane, we estimated the shock wave propagation distance that would induce cell membrane damage from the center of the cavitation bubble.

The effects of albumin-coated microbubbles in DNA delivery mediated by therapeutic ultrasound

The application of therapeutic ultrasound (TUS) in combination with contrast agents (USCA) to mediate gene delivery relies on the understanding of the bioeffects involved. The objective of this study was to evaluate the various bioeffects generated by albumin-coated microbubbles: Optison, an USCA, when applied with TUS operated for 10-30 min, on cells and on DNA transfection. This study reveals that Optison microbubbles were still acoustically active after long-term TUS application of 30 min. Optison enhances TUS-gene transfection by increasing the number of plasmids in the cells and also by distributing the plasmids to more cells, without significant decrease in cell viability. Optison also interacts with the DNA to further enhance transfection in a mechanism not necessarily involving cavitation. However, Optison affects mainly the cell cytoplasmatic membrane, without interfering with DNA intracellular trafficking. Using high-resolution scanning electron microscopy (HRSEM), the bioeffects on cell membrane induced by TUS-Optison were observed, demonstrating that Optison lead to a rougher surface, characterized by depressions that are reversible within 24-h post TUS. These effects are different from those observed when only TUS was applied. The findings from this study suggest that albumin-coated microbubbles enhances transfection when using TUS for 10-30 min, and that microbubbles play a major role in elevating cell transfection level and efficiency.

Safety of ultrasound contrast agents

The use of ultrasound contrast agents has increased over recent years. The Contrast Media Safety Committee (CMSC) of the European Society of Urogenital Radiology (ESUR) decided to review the safety of ultrasound contrast agents in humans and to draw up guidelines. A comprehensive literature search and review was carried out. The resulting report was discussed by the CMSC of ESUR and at the 11th European Symposium on Urogenital Radiology in Santiago de Compostela, Spain, in 2004. Ultrasound contrast agents approved for clinical use are well tolerated, and serious adverse reactions are rarely observed. Adverse events are usually minor (e.g. headache, nausea, altered taste, sensation of heat) and self-resolving. These symptoms may not be related to the ultrasound contrast materials as they have also been observed in placebo-control groups. Intolerance to some components may occur. Generalized allergy-like reactions occur rarely. Ultrasound contrast agents are generally safe. The ultrasound scanning time and the acoustic output should be kept to the lowest level consistent with obtaining diagnostic information. Adverse reactions should be treated symptomatically.

Quantification of optison bubble size and lifetime during sonication dominant role of secondary cavitation bubbles causing acoustic bioeffects

Acoustic cavitation has been shown to deliver molecules into viable cells, which is of interest for drug and gene delivery applications. To address mechanisms of these acoustic bioeffects, this work measured the lifetime of albumin-stabilized cavitation bubbles (Optison) and correlated it with desirable (intracellular uptake of molecules) and undesirable (loss of cell viability) bioeffects. Optison was exposed to 500 kHz ultrasound (acoustic pressures of 0.6-3.0 MPa and energy exposures of 0.2-200 J/cm2) either with or without the presence of DU145 prostate cancer cells (10(6) cells/ml) bathed in calcein, a cell-impermeant tracer molecule. Bubble lifetime was determined using a Coulter counter and flow cytometer, while bioeffects were evaluated by flow cytometry. The lifetime of Optison cavitation nuclei was found to decrease and bioeffects (molecular uptake and loss of cell viability) were found to increase with increasing acoustic energy exposure. These bioeffects correlated well with the disappearance of bubbles, suggesting that contrast agent destruction either directly or indirectly affected cells, probably involving unstabilized cavitation nuclei created upon the destruction of Optison. Because Optison solutions presonicated to destroy all detectable bubbles also caused significant bioeffects, the indirect mechanism involving secondary cavitation bubbles is more likely.

The relation between cavitation and platelet aggregation during exposure to high-intensity focused ultrasound

Our previous study showed that high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) is capable of producing "primary acoustic hemostasis" in the form of ultrasound (US)-induced platelet activation, aggregation and adhesion to a collagen-coated surface. In the current study, 1.1 MHz continuous-wave HIFU was used to investigate the role of cavitation as a mechanism for platelet aggregation in samples of platelet-rich plasma. A 5 MHz passive cavitation detector was used to monitor cavitation activity and laser aggregometry was used to measure platelet aggregation. Using spatial average intensities from 0 to 3350 W/cm2, the effects of HIFU-induced cavitation on platelet aggregation were investigated by enhancing cavitation activity through use of US contrast agents and by limiting cavitation activity through use of an overpressure system. Our results show that increased cavitation activity lowers the intensity threshold to produce platelet aggregation and decreased cavitation activity in the overpressure system raises the intensity threshold for platelet aggregation.

A comparison of the hemolytic potential of Optison and Albunex in whole human blood in vitro: acoustic pressure, ultrasound frequency, donor and passive cavitation detection considerations

This project tested the hypothesis that a "second-generation" ultrasound (US) contrast agent (Optison), offering extended echogenicity over that of its "first-generation" predecessor (Albunex), would have the greater potential for sonolysis of human erythrocytes in vitro. Whole human blood, obtained from apparently healthy donors, was anticoagulated and subsequently exposed in vitro to US in the presence of one of each or neither of the two US contrast agents. The US exposures were for 30 s and involved frequency (1.0, 2.2 and 3.4 MHz) and amplitude (approximately 2.8 to 0.38 MPa P(-)) regimens; pulse duration (200 micros) and interpulse interval (20 ms) were held constant. The data supported the hypothesis, with an overall ratio of approximately 2.5 for relative extent of background-corrected US-induced hemolysis of the Optison/Albunex regimens. Passive cavitation detection analyses corroborated the results obtained with hemolysis.

Comparative sensitivity of human and bovine erythrocytes to sonolysis by 1-MHz ultrasound

This project tested the hypothesis that human erythrocytes, being larger than bovine erythrocytes, would be the more sensitive to sonolysis induced by inertial cavitation. The rationale behind this hypothesis was an earlier demonstration that, among sized populations of erythrocytes, an inverse relation existed between erythrocyte volume and mechanically-induced shear forces in the surrounding medium; viz, the larger the cell, the less shear force required to rupture the cell's membrane. At low erythrocyte densities (i.e., approximately 5% hematocrit) the hypothesis was supported; at high cell densities (i.e., approximately 35% hematocrit) it was not supported. The data are consistent with an ultrasound (US)-induced symmetric implosion of affected gas nuclei as causing the effect at low cell densities; under such conditions there is ample spacing among cells for US-induced symmetric growth and collapse of gas nuclei and the concomitant production of radially-expanding shock waves (which lyse the cells); at high cell densities there is not sufficient spacing among cells for US-induced symmetric growth and collapse of bubbles and an alternative mechanism, possibly asymmetric bubble collapse, becomes operational.

Destruction of contrast microbubbles and the association with inertial cavitation

The destruction of insonified Sonazoid microbubbles and its association with inertial cavitation in vitro utilizing an active acoustic detector was investigated. The experimental observation indicated that contrast microbubbles could be damaged at moderate acoustic pressures of 0.6-1.6 MPa (0.4-1.0 in mechanical index, MI). A damaged bubble could be dissolved into the medium on the order of 1 ms, implying that the destruction at moderate pressures is a relatively slow (relative to inertial bubble collapse), nonviolent dissolution process following the disruption of encapsulating surface materials. Inertial cavitation events in the presence of contrast microbubbles were observed using multiple highly intense ultrasound (US) pulses (>1.6 MPa). This observation suggested that intense US might disintegrate contrast microbubbles, and fragments of disintegrated microbubbles could be activated by an upcoming highly intense imaging pulse. The above results imply that inertial cavitation is unlikely to take place in the presence of Sonazoid contrast microbubbles when exposed to diagnostic US with an MI <1.

Cavitation nucleation agents for nonthermal ultrasound therapy

The use of a nucleation-promoting agent can greatly enhance therapeutically useful nonthermal bioeffects. A blank agent (saline), Optison ultrasound contrast agent, a stabilized perfluoropentane droplet suspension (SDS), and retained air space were compared as nucleation agents in whole blood. Fresh canine whole blood with added agent was exposed in 1.3-ml disposable pipette bulbs to lithotripter shock waves (2-Hz rate; +24.4, -5.2 MPa peak pressure amplitudes). Cavitation activity was assessed by measuring hemolysis. The droplet suspension performed nearly as well as retained air when added at a concentration sufficient to provide a roughly equal volume of gas after vaporization. Optison also yielded nucleation, but a concentration of 10%-20% was needed for large enhancement of hemolysis comparable to 5% SDS. Exposure at room temperature, which was less than the 29 degrees C boiling point of perfluoropentane, eliminated the enhancement of the hemolysis effect relative to the blank. Application of 100-kPa excess pressure during exposure reduced but did not eliminate the nucleation ability of Optison, SDS, or retained air. However, this small pressure (relative to the peak positive pressure of the shock waves) eliminated the hemolysis induced with the blank agent. The stabilized perfluoropentane droplet suspension appears to be a good nucleation agent for nonthermal ultrasound therapy applications.

Sonoporation of monolayer cells by diagnostic ultrasound activation of contrast-agent gas bodies

Human (A431 epidermoid carcinoma) cells were grown as monolayers on 5 microm thick Mylar sheets, which formed the upper window for a 1-mm thick, 23-mm diameter disc-shaped exposure chamber. A 3.5-MHz curved linear-array transducer was aimed upward at the chamber, 7 cm away, in a 37 degrees C water bath. The chamber contained phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) with 10 mg/mL fluorescent dextran and 1% Optison ultrasound (US) contrast agent. Significant fluorescent cell counts, indicative of membrane damage (i.e., sonoporation), up to about 10% of cells within a 1-mm diameter field of view, were noted for spectral Doppler and two-dimensional (2-D) scan mode with or without a tissue-mimicking phantom. The effect was only weakly dependent on pulse-repetition frequency or exposure duration, but was strongly dependent on contrast agent concentration below 2%. Thus, diagnostic US activation of contrast-agent gas bodies can produce cell membrane damage.

Erosion of artificial endothelia in vitro by pulsed ultrasound: acoustic pressure, frequency, membrane orientation and microbubble contrast agent dependence

The erosion of cells from fibroblast monolayers simulating the vascular endothelium by 20 micros pulses of ultrasound at 500 Hz PRF was studied in relation to the peak negative acoustic pressure (P-; 0.0-2.5 MPa), ultrasound (US) frequency (1.0, 2.1 or 3.5 MHz), orientation of the monolayer (i.e., simulating the sites of ultrasound entry/exit from a blood vessel) and the presence or absence of a microbubble contrast agent (3 Vol% Albunex). The a priori hypotheses were that erosion of the monolayers would: 1. arise due to insonation treatment, 2. arise as a consequence of cavitation activity and, thus, increase with increasing P- at constant frequency, and decrease with increasing frequency at constant P-, 3. be significantly increased by the presence of a microbubble contrast agent, and 4. have a weak dependence on monolayer orientation. The data support these hypotheses. Under the most severe exposure conditions used, most of the affected cells appeared to have been lysed; however, a substantial number of viable cells were dislodged from the monolayer surface.

Effect of high-intensity focused ultrasound on whole blood with and without microbubble contrast agent

Using human whole blood samples with and without contrast agent (CA), we evaluated the effect of exposures to focused, continuous wave (CW) 1.1-MHz ultrasound for durations of 10 ms to 1 s at spatial average intensities of 560 to 2360 W/cm2. Cavitation was monitored with a passive cavitation detector and hemolysis was determined with spectroscopy. In whole blood alone, no significant cavitation, heating or hemolysis was detected at any exposure condition. Conversely, cavitation and hemolysis, but not heating, were detected in whole blood with CA. A CA concentration as low as 0.28 microL CA per mL whole blood at an intensity of 2360 W/cm2 for 1 s resulted in measurable cavitation and a 6-fold increase in hemolysis compared to shams. Cavitation and hemolysis increased proportional to the concentration of CA and duration of exposure. In samples containing 4.2 microL CA per mL whole blood exposed for 1 s, a threshold was seen at 1750 W/cm2 where cavitation and hemolysis increased 10-fold compared to exposures at lower intensities. HIFU exposure of whole blood containing CA leads to significant hemolysis in vitro and may lead to clinically significant hemolysis in vivo.

Sonolysis of Albunex-supplemented, 40% hematocrit human erythrocytes by pulsed 1-MHz ultrasound: pulse number, pulse duration and exposure vessel rotation dependence

The hypotheses tested were that sonolysis of erythrocytes in the presence of a gas-based ultrasound contrast agent in vitro will be related quantitatively to the duration and number of ultrasound pulses applied using a constant pulse repetition period and, at least qualitatively, to the total exposure duration (i.e., the product of pulse number x pulse duration). An objective was to determine the influence of sample rotation during insonation on the amount of hemolysis produced under these conditions. Human erythrocytes, suspended to 40% hematocrit in autologous plasma containing 3.6% (V:V) Albunex, were exposed/sham-exposed to 1-100 pulses of 1-MHz ultrasound (6.2 MPa peak positive, 3.6 MPa peak negative acoustic pressures; I(SPTP) approximately 800 W/cm2) using a 1-s pulse repetition period. Pulse durations ranged from 20-20,000 micros; samples were either stationary or rotated (200 rpm) during insonation. Hemolysis was independent of vessel rotation treatment at all tested pulse durations and pulse numbers. Levels of hemolysis statistically greater than in sham-exposed samples were obtained with > or = 50 pulses of 20 micros duration, and > or = 1 pulse of 200, 2000 or 20,000 micros duration. Hemolysis increased with increasing pulse number and pulse duration. Approximately equivalent levels of hemolysis were produced by different pulse number x pulse duration combinations, yielding the same total exposure duration.

Remnants of Albunex nucleate acoustic cavitation

Mice were injected with 0.1 mL Albunex and exposed to 200 pulses from a piezoelectric lithotripter at times ranging from 5 min to 24 h following injection. Each pulse was approximately 1.5 sinusoidal oscillations at a fundamental frequency of approximately 0.1 MHz with pressure amplitude of approximately 2 MPa. Although the contrast agent ceases to be an effective scatterer of diagnostic ultrasound after a few minutes in the circulation, the modest lithotripter exposures caused significant hemorrhaging in bladder, mesentery and intestine for periods of up to 4 h after injection. The results demonstrate either that highly stable bubbles much smaller than resonance size or air-containing fragments of the shells of Albunex serve as effective nuclei for acoustic cavitation.