The effect of neocortical lesions on the number of cells in neonatal or adult feline caudate nucleus: comparison to fetal lesions

Translating striatal activity from brain slice to whole animal neurophysiology: A guide for neuroscience research integrating diverse levels of analysis

An important goal of this review is highlighting research in neuroscience as examples of multilevel functional and anatomical analyses addressing basic science issues and applying results to the understanding of diverse disorders. The research of Dr. Michael Levine, a leader in neuroscience, exemplifies this approach by uncovering fundamental properties of basal ganglia function and translating these findings to clinical applications. The review focuses on neurophysiological research connecting results from in vitro and in vivo recordings. A second goal is to utilize these research connections to produce novel, accurate descriptions for corticostriatal processing involved in varied, complex functions. Medium spiny neurons in striatum act as integrators combining input with baseline activity creating motivational "events." Basic research on corticostriatal synapses is described and links developed to issues with clinical relevance such as inhibitory gating, self-injurious behavior, and relative reward valuation. Work is highlighted on dopamine-glutamate interactions. Individual medium spiny neurons express both D₁ and D₂ receptors and encode information in a bivalent manner depending upon the mix of receptors involved. Current work on neurophysiology of reward processing has taken advantage of these basic approaches at the cellular and molecular levels. Future directions in studying physiology of reward processing and action sequencing could profit by incorporating the divergent ways dopamine modulates incoming neurochemical signals. Primary investigators leading research teams should mirror Mike Levine's efforts in "climbing the mountain" of scientific inquiry by performing analyses at different levels of inquiry, integrating the findings, and building comprehensive answers to problems unsolvable without this bold approach.

A critical maturational period of reduced brain vulnerability to injury. A study of cerebral glucose metabolism in cats

We have developed a feline cerebral hemispherectomy model as an analog to the surgical procedure used in pediatric intractable epilepsy. Previous work with this model has shown a remarkable plasticity associated with an early period of brain development, which we have defined using morphological, cerebral metabolic and behavioral methods. However, the important functional-metabolic bracketing of this period has not yet been performed. We have conducted the present study to answer questions raised by our previous findings using [14C] 2-deoxy-D-glucose autoradiography but only including animals lesioned at day 10 postnatally (P10) or in adulthood. The questions were; (a) is there any age better than P10 for an optimal metabolic outcome?, and (b) can we determine a cutoff point for the beneficial effects of the young age-at-lesion? Twenty-one adult cats were studied. Seven cats served as intact controls, five received a left hemineodecortication at P30, three at P60, three at P90 and three at P120, respectively. Histological analysis indicated that the extent of the lesion was similar between the age groups. Local glucose metabolic rates (LCMR(glc)) were measured in 50 structures bilaterally and used to calculate overall LCMR(glc) for seven grouped sites within the cerebral cortex, thalamus, basal ganglia, mesencephalic tegmentum (and tectum), limbic system and cerebellum. Results indicated a widespread bilateral depression of LCMR(glc) in all age-at-lesion groups. The depression in overall LCMR(glc) across all structures measured in each hemisphere was significant (P<0.05) for the P120 group relative to intacts for both ipsilateral (left) and contralateral (right) sides of the brain. The ipsilateral thalamus was the region most effected by the injury, with significant losses for all age-at-lesion groups. In addition, while there were widespread depressions for all lesion groups, these losses were significant for the P120 group in five groups of structures ipsilaterally (thalamus, basal ganglia, tectum, limbic system, cerebellum) and in three contralaterally (thalamus, tectum, cerebellum). In contrast, significant depressions for the earlier age-at-lesion groups (P30, P60, P90) were found only in the ipsilateral thalamus and bilaterally in the tectum. These results, together with our previous results for the P10 group, indicate a relative sparing of LCMR(glc) after hemineodecortication during the first 60 days of life, with gradually decreasing plasticity thereafter, such that there is some residual sparing at 90 days of age, and afterwards an almost complete loss of metabolic plasticity, with lesions at P120 producing a dismal outcome. These results complement earlier morphological and behavioral studies and support the concept of a 'Critical Maturational Period' of reduced vulnerability to developmental injury.

Soma size of substantia nigra neurons increases after a prenatal neocortical lesion in cats

Seeking an explanation for an increase in volume of the caudate nucleus in adult cats that had sustained a fetal unilateral neocortical lesion, we investigated possible morphological changes in the reciprocally interconnected substantia nigra. In fetal-lesioned cats the cross-sectional area of neuronal somata in substantia nigra, pars reticulata was 33% larger than in control cats (P<0.05), while in pars compacta there was a marked tendency to an increase (25%, P<0.06). This size increase might have caused the survival of a larger number of caudate nucleus neurons during development, and thus contributed to the reported increase in caudate nucleus volume.

The growth of the feline brain from fetal into adult life. II. A morphometric study of subcortical nuclei

As a continuation of the morphometric studies on the preceding paper, here we report on the rate of growth of the caudate nucleus (n.), thalamus, red n., and the substantia (s.) nigra using, with few exceptions, the same cohort of cats. The same previously used brains (n=64 cats) were allocated to the following age groups: fetal (E) 59 days, postnatal (P) days 1, 7, 15, 30, 45, 60, 90, 120, and 180. Sixteen additional cats, interspersed within the groups, were substituted for the red n. and s. nigra studies. There were six subjects per group (except for E59, n=4). Using a projection microscope and cytochrome oxidase-stained coronal sections, a combined (left plus right sides) total of 4693, 3822, 1636, and 1180 sections were drawn for the caudate, thalamus, s. nigra, and red n., respectively. With computer assistance, the drawings were digitized to calculate mean cross-sectional areas and then the mean volume of each structure per group. The growth time tables for the caudate n., thalamus and s. nigra were fairly synchronous. In terms of percentage of the adult volume, for the left side (both sides grew at a similar rate), the three structures grew at a fast pace between E59 and P30. Thus, at E59 their respective percentages relative to adult volume were 23.7, 29.8 and 22.6% and by P30 the percentages were within adult range (85.2, 115.1 and 87.5%, respectively). Starting at P30, for the thalamus and at P45 for the caudate n., there was a consistent tendency to an overgrow which ranged between 4.3 and 30.9% (at P180, P<0.5) for the caudate and between 0.3 and 15.1% for the thalamus. In addition, starting at P30, the right thalamus tended to be consistently larger than the left by a margin ranging between 0.5 and 11.2% (P120, P<0.05). The red n. grew at a different, slower pace. Starting from a fetal volume equivalent to an 18.6% of adult size, its volume was only a 61.0% of the adult value at P30 and came within range of adulthood size only by P60 (81. 3%). Neither the s. nigra nor the red n. showed any consistent tendency to overgrow or to asymmetry. These findings are discussed in the context of the literature. Furthermore, we discuss general conclusions and considerations pertaining to both papers as well as draw comparisons with the maturational time tables of other developmental landmarks in cats. Finally, in a comparison with growth of human brain structures, we point at the limitations and complexities involved in studying human material and, noting interspecies similarities, we propose that the present data from an advanced gyrencephalic mammal may form the bases for a model of structures maturation in humans.

Developmental neuroplasticity in a model of cerebral hemispherectomy and stroke

Cerebral hemispherectomy, a last resort treatment for childhood epilepsy, is a standard procedure which dramatically illustrates the resilience of the brain to extensive damage. If this operation, also mimicking long-term, extensive unilateral capsular stroke, is performed in postnatal cats of up to 60 days of age, there is a remarkable recovery/sparing of neurological functions that is not seen when the lesion occurs during late fetal life or in adulthood. A long-term effect at all ages is loss of neurons in bilateral brain areas remote from the resection site. This is pronounced in adult cats and shows intriguing, paradoxical features in fetal animals, but is substantially attenuated in neonatal cats. Similarly, large-scale reinnervation of subcortical sites (sprouting) by neurons of the remaining, intact hemisphere is prominent in young cats, but not in fetal or adult animals. These and other restorative processes (described herein) in young postnatal animals are matched by relatively higher rates of local cerebral glucose utilization, supporting the notion that they underlie the improved behavioral outcome. Thus, during a critical, defined stage of maturation, presumably common to higher mammals including humans, the brain entirely remodels itself in response to extensive but focal injury. Perhaps the molecular environment allowing for rescue of neurons and enhanced reinnervation at a specific developmental stage could be recreated in subjects with brain lesions at less favorable ages, thereby helping to restore circuitry and spare neurons. However, replacement via transplantation of neurons eliminated by the damage appears to be crucial in attempts to further preserve cells located remotely but yet destined to die or decrease in size. This article presents abundant evidence to show that there is a surprisingly comprehensive long-term morphological remodeling of the entire brain after extensive unilateral damage and that this occurs preferentially during a discrete period of early life. Additional evidence strongly suggests that the remodeling underlies the outstanding behavioral and functional recovery/sparing following early cerebral hemispherectomy. We argue that this period of reduced brain vulnerability to injury also exists in other higher mammals, including man, and suggest ways to enhance restorative processes after stroke/hemispherectomy occurring at other ages.

Effects of a restricted unilateral neocortical lesion upon cerebral glucose and oxidative metabolisms in fetal and neonatal cats

The present study was designed to measure cerebral glucose and oxidative metabolisms and to assess relationships with previously identified morphological changes in adult cats with a unilateral, restricted neocortical lesion sustained either during fetal life or neonatally. Local cerebral metabolic rates for glucose (LCMR(glc)) were measured using the [14C]2-deoxy-D-glucose (2 DG) autoradiography method and oxidative capacity was determined using cytochrome oxidase histochemistry (C.O.). Only glucose metabolism in the fetal-lesioned cats was affected substantially. There was a global decrease (31.0% relative to controls) of the LCMR(glc) for both cerebral hemispheres while focal decreases were seen mainly in thalamic and neostriatal nuclei (and reaching declines of over 50%). Cats with a neonatal lesion showed only a tendency to such declines (19.5% and 22.0% for the right and left hemispheres, respectively). C.O. values were not affected significantly either globally or locally in any of the age-at-lesion groups. In previous work using fetal animals with similar lesions, morphological evidence of subcortical neuropile degeneration was not observed; instead, a marked decrease in size of the ipsilateral remaining neocortex and a pronounced distortion of gyri and sulci patterns bilaterally were found. In this context, we propose that in the fetal-lesioned cats, there was a widespread lesion-induced decrease in corticofugal (and transcortical) synaptic inputs which was responsible for a decline in functional (synaptic) activities, and that this, in turn, caused a downturn in glucose utilization. In the neonatal cats minor degeneration, coupled with lack of reinnervation, would account for the tendency to 2 DG declines. These results indicate that the long-term metabolic response of the fetal brain to injury is also less adaptive than that of the neonatal brain. Since standard methods are available to measure cerebral metabolism in humans, our studies in animal models may help understanding the long term physiological consequences of developmental focal brain damage in patients as well as to predict the relationships between cerebral metabolism and the underlying long-term morphological effects of such lesions.

Stereological evaluation of substantia nigra cell number in normal and hemispherectomized monkeys

The assessment of the anatomical consequences of cortical lesions on subcortical visual relays is necessary to further understand residual visual capacities. Unbiased stereological techniques were used to evaluate cell numbers in the substantia nigra (SN), a structure involved in the control of saccadic eye movements. Cell numbers were very similar in the ipsi- and contralateral SN of the hemispherectomized animal (329,926 vs. 310,248). These numbers are close to what was observed in the normal monkey (300,130 and 320, 859). In one case, part of the striatum was lesioned in addition to the cerebral hemisphere. Noticeable effects were observed in the SN ipsilateral to the cortical lesion: volume was reduced by 30.5% while the number of neurons, compared to the contralateral side, dropped by 43.2% (186,644 vs. 328,757). These results suggest that due to its anatomical sparing following hemispherectomy the SN, in addition to other subcortical structures, is in a prime position to modulate the spared saccadic behaviors seen after massive cortical injuries.

Cerebral metabolism following neonatal or adult hemineodecortication in cats: effect on oxidative capacity using cytochrome oxidase histochemistry

In order to determine the degree and extent of changes in cerebral oxidative capacity following cerebral hemineodecortication, adult cats which had undergone surgery early postnatally (mean age: 11.4 days) or during adulthood were studied using cytochrome oxidase histochemistry. A total of 18 animals were employed and 50 brain regions were quantified bilaterally using optical densitometry. Although many subcortical regions exhibiting extensive degenerative features revealed lower levels of cytochrome oxidase (C.O.) activity, this reduction was relatively unremarkable compared to intact controls. Nevertheless, it was interesting that this decrease (down to 66-89%) of normal was more pronounced in neonatal-lesioned cats, reaching significance in a number of ipsilateral thalamic nuclei, compared to adult-lesioned animals (91-100% of normal), suggesting a contribution of glial cells to the density of C.O. staining in the latter cats. Regions of the brain spared from degeneration exhibited a bilateral increase in C.O. activity which may reflect the demands for energy to support the anatomical reorganization which is prevalent in these animals. Surprisingly, such increases were more robust within spared regions of the adult-lesioned brain, reaching significance in four ipsilateral and nine contralateral areas with the density of the reaction attaining levels over 125% of control. This may indicate different demands for oxidative metabolism in the adult-lesioned cats. These results enhance our understanding of the mechanism(s) underlying the greater extent of functional sparing or recovery in cats sustaining injury to the cerebral cortex early vs. late in life. In addition, the findings complement our previous companion report on glucose metabolism supporting the concept of energy compartmentalization, which reflects the dynamic interaction between anatomical and functional changes in this age-at-lesion model of recovery.

Differences in D2 dopamine receptor binding in the neostriatum between cats hemidecorticated neonatally or in adulthood

In order to study differences in response to neocortical injury sustained at different ages at the neurotransmitter level, we examined the density in D2 dopamine receptors in the neostriatum of cats hemidecorticated neonatally (N = 4) or in adulthood (N = 4), as well as in intact brains (N = 6). Receptor densities were measured using quantitative autoradiography and [3H]-spiperone binding in 12 regions of the neostriatum and nucleus accumbens septi. We found that the anterior lateral caudate nucleus on both sides of the brain contained a higher D2 receptor density in neonatal-lesioned as compared to adult-lesioned brains. Ipsilateral to the lesion, the increase was 101% (P < 0.05) and contralaterally it amounted to 77% (P < 0.05). Moreover, this region of the ipsilateral caudate nucleus of neonatal-lesioned cats tended to be more densely labeled than that of intact brain by 58% (P < 0.1). D2 receptor densities in adult-lesioned cats did not differ from that of intact controls. Comparison of these data with those of a former morphological study using the same animals suggested that this bilateral elevation of D2 receptor density in neonatally lesioned brains represents a higher mean density of binding sites per neuron. The elevation in the neonatal-lesioned cats might be a response of the striatum to neuroplastic changes in the striatal neuropil, including the corticostriatal afferents, since such changes are different in neonatal- as compared to adult-lesioned cats.

A critical period for reduced brain vulnerability to developmental injury. II. Volumetric study of the neocortex and thalamus in cats

Groups of young adult cats with a left hemineodecortication at postnatal (P) ages (in days) 5-15 (P10), 30 (P30) 60 (P60), 90 (P90), 120 (P120) and in adulthood, were used to measure the volume of the thalamus, bilaterally, and of the remaining neocortex (right hemisphere). The same subjects were employed for the behavioral studies reported in the preceding paper. There was a bilateral, age-dependent, thalamic volume decrease. Ipsilateral to the resection, the thalamic shrinkage was the largest for the adult-lesioned cats (by 56.7%) and it was the smallest for the P30 group (43.4%), with a tendency towards a greater atrophy as the age at lesion increased. A similar pattern of atrophy was seen for the contralateral thalamus but the volume reduction was much less pronounced such that it was significant only for the four older age-at-lesion groups (ranging from 18.2% to 11.2% for the P120 and P90 groups respectively). Once again, the shrinkage was the smallest for the P30 group (5.3%). The remaining neocortex also shrunk in these animals, but the volume decrease was significant only for the adult-lesioned (17.8%) and the P120 group (15.4%), while the P30 group had practically no shrinkage (2.4%). The frontal cortex had no atrophy or it was minimal but the shrinkage gradually increased caudally such that all lesioned groups had some size reduction of the occipital cortex. The present results, together with the main conclusion of the preceding paper, indicate that there is a critical maturation period (CMP) of reduced forebrain vulnerability to neocortical injury which, in cats, tends to end between 30 to 60 days postnatally. The implications for developmental brain damage in other higher mammal species as well as the possible morphological ontogenetical underpinnings of this period are discussed.

A critical maturational period of reduced brain vulnerability to developmental injury. I. Behavioral studies in cats

Groups of cats with resection of the neocortex of the left cerebral hemisphere at postnatal (P) ages (in days) 5-15 (P10), 30 (P30), 60 (P60), 90 (P90), 120 (P120), and in adulthood, were compared using a comprehensive battery of 16 neurobehavioral tests administered when they were at least 6 months post-lesion. For all behaviors, except 3 (including the paw contact placing reaction which never recovered), the performance was significantly better for the cats lesioned between P10 and P30 compared to cats lesioned at older ages. For 10 of the behaviors, the transition from age-at-lesion P30 to P60 was rather abrupt and characterized by a significant increment in impairments. However, cats with the resection at ages P90 and P120 still showed some behavioral advantage over the adult-lesioned animals. Overall, for most of the behaviors tested, there was a significant linear trend for an increase in the magnitude of impairments across the entire age-at-lesion range. We previously reported that cats with a unilateral frontal cortical lesion sustained during the late fetal life showed substantial behavioral impairments, while animals with a similar resection sustained early postnatally exhibited minimal abnormalities. These findings, together with the present results, indicate that the long-term behavioral outcome of neocortical injury is best when the lesion is sustained during a discrete period of the life of the cat. This period extends from about fetal age 55 days (the oldest lesion age in our fetal studies) to about P60, as shown in the present paper. For these reasons, we propose that there is a Critical Maturational Period (CMP) for optimal post injury brain and behavioral restoration. We hypothesize that this span of reduced vulnerability is linked to specific developmental morphological events which occur during the same time period. Since, as discussed, such ontogenetic events also occur in other mammal species (albeit at different chronological ages), we further propose that the timing of the CMP as delineated in cats, can be extrapolated to other higher mammals species including humans.