Appendicitis: Continuing Diagnostic Challenge

Clinical and Ultrasonographic Diagnosis of Acute Appendicitis

Appendicitis is one of the most common acute abdominal conditions encountered in the Emergency Department. It is a surgical condition that can affect any person of any age and often with varying clinical presentations. In the majority of cases, the diagnosis is straightforward. However in some, the diagnosis requires a heightened clinical suspicion. The application of adjuvant laboratory tests and diagnostic imaging helps to reduce the associated complications, morbidity and mortality of delayed diagnosis.

Appendix not seen: the predictive value of secondary inflammatory sonographic signs

BACKGROUND

Acute appendicitis is the most prevalent emergency surgical diagnosis in children. Although traditionally a clinical diagnosis, the diagnosis of acute appendicitis is uncertain in approximately 30% of pediatric patients. In attempts to avoid a misdiagnosis and facilitate earlier definitive care, imaging modalities such as ultrasonography have become important tools. In many pediatric studies, the absence of a visualized appendix with no secondary sonographic features has been reported as a negative study result, and a study where the appendix is not seen but demonstrates secondary features is often deemed equivocal. With ultrasound appendiceal detection rates reported at 60% to 89%, the dilemma of the nonvisualized appendix or equivocal study is frequently faced by clinicians.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to assess the value of the nonvisualized appendix on ultrasound and the association of secondary sonographic findings in pediatric patients with acute right lower quadrant pain undergoing ultrasound, in whom acute appendicitis was a diagnostic consideration.

METHODS

Retrospective case review of 662 consecutive children (age < 18 years) presenting to a pediatric emergency department with clinically suspected appendicitis, who had graded compression sonographic studies during the 24-month study period, was performed.

RESULTS

The appendix could not be visualized in 241 studies (37.7%). An alternate diagnosis was identified via sonography in 47 patients (19.5%). Twenty-five patients (12.9%) were taken for surgery where 17 (8.8%) had acute appendicitis confirmed via pathology. The specificity of moderate-to-large amounts of free fluid is 98%, phlegmon at 100%, pericecal inflammatory fat changes at 98%, and any free fluids with prominent lymph nodes at 81%. The odds ratio of appendicitis increases from 0.56 to 0.64 to 2.3 and 17.5, respectively, when there were 2 and 3 ultrasonographic inflammatory markers identified.

CONCLUSIONS

Although uncommonly seen, large amounts of free fluid, phlegmon, and pericecal inflammatory fat changes were very specific signs of acute appendicitis. In the absence of a distinctly visualized appendix, the presence of multiple secondary inflammatory changes provides increasing support of a diagnosis of acute appendicitis.

The presentation of appendicitis in preadolescent children

PURPOSE

We describe the clinical presentation of appendicitis in preadolescent children and differences in symptoms among age-stratified subgroups.

METHODS

This is a retrospective analysis of a prospectively collected de-identified data set of patients 3 years or older and patients younger than 12 years presenting to a pediatric emergency department during a 21-month period with symptoms suspicious for appendicitis. The rates of appendicitis, perforation, negative appendectomy, as well as sensitivities, specificities, and positive likelihood ratios for historical and clinical variables associated with appendicitis were calculated for the entire cohort and for 3 age-stratified subgroups.

RESULTS

Of 379 children, 121 (32%) had appendicitis, 75 (62%) were male, 24 (20%) had a perforated appendix, and 16 (12%) had a negative appendectomy. The perforation rate was highest (53%) in the youngest subset of patients (3-5.99 years). Patients with appendicitis presented with inability to walk (82%), maximal right lower quadrant tenderness (82%), nausea (79%), pain with percussion, hopping, coughing (79%), and anorexia (75%). Fewer patients with appendicitis presented with a history of vomiting (66%), fever (47%), or diarrhea (16%), and these findings were not associated with the diagnosis. The youngest subset of patients (3-5.99 years) presented to the emergency department with fever; however, within this age subset, there was no significant difference in temperatures between patients with and without appendicitis. Fever was an indicator for perforation. Psoas, Rovsing, and obturator signs were infrequent but very specific for appendicitis (0.86-0.98 depending on age).

CONCLUSIONS

Nausea, right lower quadrant tenderness, inability to walk, and elevated white blood cell and neutrophil counts are sensitive indicators of appendicitis in preadolescent children. Although peritoneal signs are infrequently elicited, when present, they substantially increase the likelihood of appendicitis. Fever, vomiting, and diarrhea are not associated with appendicitis in preadolescent children.

Clinical prediction rule to distinguish pelvic inflammatory disease from acute appendicitis in women of childbearing age

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to develop a clinical prediction rule to distinguish pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) from acute appendicitis in women of childbearing age.

METHODS

We reviewed medical records over a 4-year period of female patients of childbearing age who had presented with abdominal pain at an urban emergency department and had either appendicitis (n = 109) or PID (n = 72). A prediction rule was developed by use of recursive partitioning based on significant factors for the discrimination.

RESULTS

The significant factors to favor PID over appendicitis were (1) no migration of pain (odds ratio [OR], 4.2; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.5-11.5), (2) bilateral abdominal tenderness (OR, 16.7; 95% CI, 5.3-50.0), and (3) absence of nausea and vomiting (OR, 8.4; 95% CI, 2.8-24.8). The prediction rule could rule out appendicitis from PID with sensitivity of 99% (95% CI, 94-100%) when classified as a low-risk group by the following factors: (1) no migration of pain, (2) bilateral abdominal tenderness, and (3) no nausea and vomiting.

CONCLUSION

We developed a prediction rule for childbearing-aged women presenting with acute abdominal pain to distinguish acute appendicitis from PID based on 3 simple, clinical features: migration of pain, bilateral abdominal tenderness, and nausea and vomiting. Prospective validation is needed in other settings.

Surgery for ovarian masses in infants, children, and adolescents: 102 consecutive patients treated in a 15-year period

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Ovarian pathology, although rare in children, must be included in the differential diagnosis of all girls who present with abdominal pain, an abdominal mass, or precocious puberty.

METHODS

To improve clinical appreciation of these lesions, the authors reviewed the presentation, evaluation, and outcome of all patients with ovarian pathology surgically treated at their institution since 1985.

RESULTS

One hundred two girls (aged 9.8 +/- 5.5 years; range, 2 days to 20 years) underwent 106 separate ovarian operations (43 salpingo-oophorectomies, 21 oophorectomies, 33 ovarian cystectomies, and 9 ovarian biopsies). Of those presenting with acute abdominal pain (n = 59), 25 (42%) had ovarian torsion (14 associated with a mature teratoma), and only 1 (2%) had a malignant tumor. In contrast, of those presenting with an abdominal mass (n = 23), 6 (26%) had malignancies. There was no age difference between those with benign disease (9.9 +/- 5.6 years; n = 96) and those with malignant tumors (8.6 +/- 3.9 years, n = 10). Nine children had 10 operations for presumed malignant tumors (3 dysgerminomas, 2 immature teratomas with foci of yolk sac tumor, 2 juvenile granulosa cell tumors, 1 yolk sac tumor, and 1 Sertoli-Leydig cell tumor). These patients all had unilateral salpingo-oophorectomy, 4 had chemotherapy, and all are now disease free at 8.4 +/- 4.1 years follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Ovarian pathology remains a rare indication for surgery in girls less than 20 years of age. Because most of these lesions are benign, ovarian-preserving operations should be performed whenever feasible.

Patterns of appendicitis at a forward-deployed United States Army Hospital: the Korea experience(2)(2)

Appendicitis is both a common surgical condition in a young military active duty population and a diagnosis that is notoriously easy to miss. We reviewed all cases of appendicitis that presented to the 121st General Hospital, which is an army facility in Seoul, South Korea, during an 18-month period. Our patient population consisted of 37,000 soldiers as well as dependants and other patients eligible for care. Of 79 patients operated on for suspected acute appendicitis, 60 (76%) had either acute suppurative or perforated appendicitis. The appendix was normal in 16 patients (20%), whereas 3 patients (4%) had a normal appendix with other surgical pathology. We found a perforation rate of 24%, and of these patients, 53% had prior visits to a health care provider in which an incorrect diagnosis or no treatment was given. Only 3 patients with simple acute appendicitis had been previously seen (7%). Patients were transported to the hospital in different ways, but we were unable to find any correlation among modes of transport to the hospital and perforation rates. We believe that timely diagnosis and referral for appendicitis could be improved through focused education of all primary care providers on this disorder.

Appendicitis in pregnancy: new information that contradicts long-held clinical beliefs

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to elicit a better understanding of the presentation of acute appendicitis in pregnancy and to clarify diagnostic dilemmas reported in the literature.

STUDY DESIGN

We retrospectively reviewed 66,993 consecutive deliveries from 1986 to 1995 by a computer program. Selected records were reviewed for gestational age; signs and symptoms at presentation; complications including preterm contractions, preterm labor, and appendiceal rupture; and histologic diagnosis of appendicitis.

RESULTS

Of 66, 993 deliveries, 67 (0.1%) were complicated by a preoperative diagnosis of probable appendicitis. Acute appendicitis was confirmed histologically in 45 (67%) of the 67 cases, for an incidence of 1 in 1493 pregnancies in this population. Distribution of suspected appendicitis in pregnancy was as follows: first trimester, 17 cases (25%); second trimester, 27 (40%); and third trimester, 23 (34%). Right-lower-quadrant pain was the most common presenting symptom regardless of gestational age (first trimester, 12 [86%] of 14 cases; second trimester, 15 [83%] of 18 cases; and third trimester, 10 [78%] of 13 cases). The mean maximal temperature for proven appendicitis was 37.6 degrees C (35.5 degrees C-39.4 degrees C), in comparison with 37.8 degrees C (36.7 degrees C-38.9 degrees C; not significant) for those with normal histologic findings. The mean leukocyte count in patients with proven appendicitis was 16.4 x 10(9)/L (8.2-27.0 x 10(9)/L), in comparison with 14.0 x 10(9)/L (5. 9-25.0 x 10(9)/L) for patients with normal histologic findings. At the time of surgery, perforation had occurred in 8 cases. Of 23 patients at > or =24 weeks' gestational age, 19 (83%) had contractions and an additional 3 patients (13%) had preterm labor with documented cervical change. One patient was delivered in the immediate postoperative period because of abruptio placentae.

CONCLUSION

Pain in the right lower quadrant of the abdomen is the most common presenting symptom of appendicitis in pregnancy regardless of gestational age. Fever and leukocytosis are not clear indicators of appendicitis in pregnancy and preterm labor is a problem after appendectomy, but preterm delivery is rare.

Abdominal pain during pregnancy

In evaluating the pregnant patient with abdominal pain, the physician is presented with a wide range of diagnostic possibilities, including disorders that can occur in nonpregnant individuals and disorders that are unique to pregnancy. The development of modern laboratory testing methods and diagnostic imaging techniques has led to a decline in the morbidity and mortality from many of these disorders. With an understanding of the physiologic changes occurring during pregnancy, a careful history and physical examination, and judicious use of laboratory tests and imaging studies, the physician should be able to determine the cause of the patient's pain in the great majority of cases and, in the words of Babler, avoid "the mortality of delay."

Evaluation of ultrasonography and clinical diagnostic scoring in suspected appendicitis

BACKGROUND

Several diagnostic aids have been developed to improve diagnosis in suspected appendicitis including ultrasonography and clinical diagnostic scoring. The aim of this study was to elaborate a new scoring system and to measure its accuracy in the preoperative diagnosis of appendicitis, comparing it with the available scoring systems.

METHODS

The clinical, radiological and ultrasonographic data of 192 patients with suspected appendicitis were collected prospectively.

RESULTS

Only six of the 12 variables analysed were shown to have prognostic significance. Using Bayesian methodology, a weight was given to each criterion and two overall scores were calculated (ultrasonographic and classical scores). A cut-off point was identified to separate patients who needed surgery and those for observation. The ultrasonographic score showed an 81 per cent sensitivity and a 96 per cent specificity, compared with 60 and 73 per cent respectively for the classical score.

CONCLUSION

Ultrasonography increases the diagnostic accuracy in patients with suspected acute appendicitis.

The analysis of clinical outcomes: getting started in benchmarking

BACKGROUND

Computerized clinical outcomes measurement systems are now routinely available to help physicians and hospital administrators assess and improve the quality of care in their organizations. The Voluntary Hospitals of America, Pennsylvania (VHA/PA), used MedisGroups data to help understand the processes of care that contributed to different clinical outcomes at different network hospitals.

METHOD

A physician subcommittee decided early on (1) to focus on the best outcomes rather than the poorest and (2) to determine the variations in processes of care that might have led to either superior or inferior clinical outcomes. For two common procedures, appendectomy and cesarean section, the subcommittee identified variation within comparative outcomes data, evaluated that variation, and studied and communicated to the rest of the hospital network the process that produced the best outcomes.

CONCLUSION

These pilot projects set the stage for current clinical benchmarking within the VHA/PA system. The committee of physicians learned that each hospital develops its own approach to common clinical conditions. These approaches become standardized at each hospital in the form of institutional attitudes, beliefs, policies, and procedures. The methods of evaluation and treatment by hospital staff can significantly alter the clinical outcomes for the populations served.

Clinical application of infrared thermography in the diagnosis of appendicitis

To determine the clinical usefulness of infrared skin temperatures in diagnosing appendicitis, the authors conducted a prospective study of 86 adult and pediatric emergency department (ED) patients presenting during a 4-month study period with acute right lower abdominal pain. Skin temperature readings (FirstTemp digital thermometer, Intelligent Medical Systems, Inc, Carlsbad, CA) were taken from the right lower abdominal quadrant and a corresponding position on the left. An unpaired t test was used to determine if there was a significant difference between the right and left lower quadrants in patients with appendicitis. Discharged patients were followed up by telephone to determine any subsequent morbidity. A total of 23 patients had appendicitis confirmed by surgery; 63 subjects had other medical diagnoses. There was no significant skin temperature differential between the lower abdominal quadrants in either patient group (0.0 degree C vs 0.1 degree C; P > .5). Three patients had a skin temperature on the right that was at least 1 degrees C warmer than on the left; none of these patients had appendicitis. The results suggest that infrared thermography is not a sensitive diagnostic test for acute appendicitis in the ED population.

Differentiating acute appendicitis from pelvic inflammatory disease in women of childbearing age

A retrospective study was performed to evaluate the usefulness of various historical, clinical, and laboratory findings in differentiating acute appendicitis from pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) in women of childbearing age. The records of all female patients presenting to the emergency department with abdominal pain who were found to have histologically proven appendicitis (n = 80) or PID confirmed on endocervical culture (n = 71) were reviewed. Clinically useful indicators favoring appendicitis included the presence of anorexia and the onset of pain later than day 14 of the menstrual cycle. Indicators favoring PID included a history of vaginal discharge, urinary symptoms, prior PID, tenderness outside the right lower quadrant, cervical motion tenderness, vaginal discharge on pelvic examination, and positive urinalysis. Despite these indicators, differentiating acute appendicitis from PID remains difficult.

Clinical validity of ultrasound in children with suspected appendicitis

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To determine the accuracy of diagnosing appendicitis in the pediatric population by using graded compression ultrasonography.

DESIGN

Retrospective case review.

SETTING

University-affiliated community hospital with an emergency department census of approximately 19,000 pediatric visits per year.

TYPE OF PARTICIPANTS

Ninety-eight children (age less than 13 years) with clinically suspected appendicitis who had graded compression sonographic studies during the 24-month study period.

INTERVENTIONS

Medical records were reviewed for patient demographics, presenting signs and symptoms, sonographic findings, surgical results, and hospital course. Patients who did not undergo surgery were followed up by telephone for a minimum of two months.

RESULTS

Ninety-eight children (42 boys and 56 girls; age range, 2 to 12 years; mean age, 8.0 years) with clinical signs and symptoms of acute appendicitis were examined sonographically. Of the 26 patients whose appendicitis was verified at surgery, ultrasound was positive in 22, with an overall sensitivity of 85%. Of the 72 patients who did not have appendicitis, ultrasound was negative in 68, with a specificity of 94%. Two patients with false-positive ultrasound went to surgery and were found to have acute ileitis and perforated Meckel's diverticulum. The overall diagnostic accuracy was 91.8% (90 of 98).

CONCLUSION

Use of ultrasound to diagnose acute appendicitis was performed with a sensitivity of 85% and a specificity of 94%. This allows the same accuracy in children as has been reported with adults.