An appraisal of some current thoughts on cytolytic T-lymphocyte killing mechanisms

How do CTL control virus infections? Evidence for prelytic halt of herpes simplex

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) induce in target cells a rapid, prelytic fragmentation of target cell DNA, accompanied by apoptosis. In contrast, complement and (with a few exceptions) chemical and physical means of inducing cytolysis induce necrosis, without DNA fragmentation. The function of the unusual DNA fragmentation induced by CTL remains to be elucidated. The major recognized function of CTL is in halting virus infections. Earlier, we proposed that CTL might halt virus infections prelytically, by fragmenting viral and cellular nucleic acids, and that in this case, cytolysis per se might be a less important function of CTL. We report here experiments designed to detect prelytic halt of virus replication. We employed in vivo-like conditions: fibroblast targets (difficult to lyse) were infected with herpes simplex virus (HSV), then incubated at low E/T cell ratios overnight. At the highest E/T ratios which produced less than 10% CTL-induced lysis, plaque-forming unit yield was reduced by about 50%. At higher E/T ratios which lysed 1/6 to 1/3 of the infected target cells, 3/4 to 9/10 of the virus production was prevented. The discrepancy between the level of lysis and the reduction in virus yield is evidence for significant CTL-induced prelytic halt of HSV replication. At present, it is unclear whether the antiviral effect observed involves an activity of CTL distinct from their lytic ability, such as their DNA fragmenting ability.

Structure and evolution of the cytotoxic cell proteinase genes CCP3, CCP4 and CCP5

A family of serine proteinases is believed to be important in cell-mediated cytotoxicity. Presented here are the genomic sequences for three murine members of this cytotoxic cell proteinase (CCP) family: the CCP3, CCP4 and CCP5 genes. All three of these genes have introns inserted at the same codon sites and the same exon distribution of the active site residues. These characteristics are also shared with the CCP1 and CCP2 genes, the charter members of the CCP gene family. Phylogenetic analysis using intron and exon sequences suggests that all five genes arose by various duplication events. This analysis also indicates that the recently described HuCCPX and CCP2 genes originated from recombination events between genes of different lineages. A phylogenetic and Southern analysis of the recombinant HuCCPX gene suggests that the human genome contains an additional CCP gene that has yet to be described. Finally, evidence is presented suggesting that the cDNA clone originally describing the CCP5 gene was derived from an alternately spliced transcript.

An inhibitor specific for the mouse T-cell associated serine proteinase 1 (TSP-1) inhibits the cytolytic potential of cytoplasmic granules but not of intact cytolytic T cells

We have investigated a proteinase inhibitor, designed according to the preferred amino acid sequence that is cleaved by the murine T-cell specific serine proteinase 1 (TSP-1) for its effect on the cytolytic potential of cloned cytotoxic T-cell lines (CTLL) and of cytoplasmic granules, derived from these cells. Pretreatment of effector cells with H-D-Pro-Phe-Arg-chloromethyl-ketone (PFR-CK) prior to the cytotoxicity assay did not result in inhibition of cytolytic activity of three independent CTLL and did not effect their granule-associated TSP-1 activity after extraction with Triton X-100. Furthermore, PFR-CK did not interfere with cytolysis of target cells by CTLL when present for the entire incubation period. In contrast, PFR-CK inhibited in a dose-dependent manner both TSP-1 activity and the hemolytic/cytolytic potential of isolated cytoplasmic granules after their pretreatment with high-salt concentration. We interpret these results to mean that cytolysis of target cells by CTLL involves the granule-associated proteinase TSP-1, which probably becomes active upon exocytosis following effector-target cell interactions.

Mechanisms of lymphocyte-mediated lysis

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and natural killer (NK) cells use multiple mechanisms to destroy their target cells. Pore formation resulting in osmotic lysis of the target is one mechanism; the pore-forming protein (perforin) responsible for this activity has been purified. Antigenically and functionally it resembles proteins of the membrane attack complex of complement. The other known mediators of cytotoxicity appear to be closely interrelated. Tumor necrosis factor (TNF), lymphotoxin (LT), and leukalexin are the three members of this group that have been purified, although their mechanisms of action are still unknown. CTLs fragment the DNA of target cells, as do TNF, LT, and leukalexin; this may be one of the mechanisms of action of these mediators. CTLs and NK cells do not self lyse. The basis of this phenomenon is unclear, although recent advances have shed some light on the problem.

Perforin-dependent and -independent pathways of cytotoxicity mediated by lymphocytes

There is little doubt at the present time that both perforin-dependent and -independent pathways are important in mediating the cytotoxicity associated with lymphocytes. The cell distribution of perforin, initially thought to include both CTL and NK cells, now must be viewed with caution because all previous biochemical studies on CTL have been conducted with cell lines propagated in long-term cultures in the presence of T cell growth factors (IL-2 and perhaps some still undefined factors). Under these conditions, CTL are known to assume a broader, NK-like specificity in target cell killing and may thus differ significantly from primary CTL generated in the body. Accordingly, perforin does not seem to be present in primary CTL activated directly through mixed lymphocyte reactions. It remains to be shown how primary CTL lyse target cells in vivo. Initial studies conducted in several laboratories have already provided some clues. It now seems that even in cultured, perforin-containing CTL, the perforin pathway is not an obligatory mechanism required for target cell killing. Other pathways, possibly involving TNF/lymphotoxin-like molecules, may play a direct role in this type of cytotoxicity. Other still unidentified factors now also need to be sought, including membrane polypeptides that may develop cytotoxicity directly upon cell contact and binding. Although from the studies reviewed here it is clear now that perforin has a more limited role in cell killing than originally proposed, it is still intriguing that it should share structural and functional homologies with complement proteins, drawing paradoxical analogies between two systems (the cellular and the humoral immune systems) which have evolved to become specialized to carry out separate immunological tasks. The cloning of the genes for perforin and for all the C proteins that comprise the MAC should reveal important information on how these genes originated and then diverged during evolution. The cellular distribution of other granule products, such as serine esterases, also must be viewed with caution. A serine esterase activity was initially thought to be CTL-specific. This information stimulated an intensive research activity in many laboratories that resulted in both the purification of a serine esterase family and the cloning of several serine esterase transcripts. It is becoming clear from recent evidence that this group of enzymes is not truly CTL-specific and therefore would not be expected to develop any function rendered absolutely necessary for cytolysis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Serine esterase and hemolytic activity in human cloned cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Target cell lysis by most murine cytotoxic T lymphocytes appears to be mediated by a complement (C9)-like protein called perforin, contained in high-density cytoplasmic granules. These granules also contain high levels of serine esterase activity, which may also play a role in cytolysis. Analysis of 17 cloned human cytotoxic T lymphocytes revealed the presence of serine esterase that is very similar to its murine counterpart in substrate and inhibitor specificities, pH optimum, and molecular mass; dot blot hybridization with synthetic oligonucleotides corresponding to the active sites of two known murine CTL esterases suggests homology to the murine enzyme HF. However, serine esterase was present at only approximately 10% of the level found in murine CTLs, and was not secreted during CTL-target cell interaction; moreover, hemolytic activity could not be detected in any of the seven cell lines tested. The results suggest that the human CTLs examined here kill their target cells by a mechanism different from that used by most cloned murine CTLs.

Cloning and chromosomal assignment of a human cDNA encoding a T cell- and natural killer cell-specific trypsin-like serine protease

A cDNA clone encoding a human T cell- and natural killer cell-specific serine protease was obtained by screening a phage lambda gt10 cDNA library from phytohemagglutinin-stimulated human peripheral blood lymphocytes with the mouse Hanukah factor cDNA clone. In an RNA blot-hybridization analysis, this human Hanukah factor cDNA hybridized with a 1.3-kilobase band in allogeneic-stimulated cytotoxic T cells and the Jurkat cell line, but this transcript was not detectable in normal muscle, liver, tonsil, or thymus. By dot-blot hybridization, this cDNA hybridized with RNA from three cytolytic T-cell clones and three noncytolytic T-cell clones grown in vitro as well as with purified CD16+ natural killer cells and CD3+, CD16- T-cell large granular lymphocytes from peripheral blood lymphocytes (CD = cluster designation). The nucleotide sequence of this cDNA clone encodes a predicted serine protease of 262 amino acids. The predicted protein has a 22-amino acid presegment, a 6-amino acid prosegment, and an active enzyme of 234 amino acids with a calculated unglycosylated molecular weight of 25,820. The active enzyme is 71% and 77% similar to the mouse sequence at the amino acid and DNA level, respectively. The human and mouse sequences conserve the active site residues of serine proteases--the trypsin-specific Asp-189 and all 10 cysteine residues. The gene for the human Hanukah factor serine protease is located on human chromosome 5. We propose that this trypsin-like serine protease may function as a common component necessary for lysis of target cells by cytotoxic T lymphocytes and natural killer cells.