Canine model of abdominal aortic aneurysm treated by endovascular graft implantation

Abdominal aortic aneurysm model in swine with bovine pericardium patch

Background

Aneurysm repair using endovascular techniques has grown in importance as materials have improved. Studies of endovascular prostheses require experimental models that reproduce anatomic and pathophysiological characteristics of human aneurysms.

Objectives

To describe a porcine model of abdominal aortic aneurysm.

Methods

This prospective cohort study used eleven Large White female pigs with a mean age of 12 weeks in two study phases. In phase I, the aneurysm was produced with a bovine pericardium patch by retroperitoneal surgery conducted under general anesthesia. In phase II, 15 days later, the animals underwent arteriography and were then euthanized before specimens were removed for histological analysis.

Results

Formation of parietal thrombus was observed in all animals. Microscopic analysis showed calcifications around thrombus in 82% of the animals. There was lymphoplasmacytic infiltration in the graft and adjacent area, with fibrosis in nine animals. Three pigs had substantial myointimal thickening, and eight had microcalcifications. Mortality was zero, and there were no ruptures, ischemia, or surgery site infections.

Conclusions

This is a unique model, using inexpensive, biocompatible material. Bovine pericardium is easy for the surgeon to handle and has very similar characteristics to autologous tissue in terms of integration with the cell wall.

Basic Science Review: Characterization of Endoleak Following Endovascular Repair of Abdominal Aortic Aneurysms

Aneurysm models have been developed to study the pathobiology of abdominal aortic aneurysm and to evaluate the efficacy of endovascular therapy. The purpose of this review is to describe the use and limitations of current animal and experimental models for the characterization of endoleak following endovascular repair of abdominal aortic aneurysms.

Aneurysm Sac Pressure after EVAR: The Role of Endoleak

OBJECTIVE

The relation between endoleak and aneurysm sac pressure is not completely clear. This review evaluates the effect of endoleaks on aneurysm sac pressure and summarizes the present knowledge regarding aneurysm sac pressure after EVAR.

METHODS

A systematic search of literature was carried out using MEDLINE, EMBASE and Web of Science. Studies were included if aneurysm sac pressure measurements as well as systemic pressure measurements were performed during or after EVAR. Mean pressure indices (MPI), ratio mean aneurysm sac pressure to mean systemic pressure), in the absence of endoleaks and in the presence of different type of endoleaks were compared.

RESULTS

Stent-graft deployment does not seem to result in immediate reduction of aneurysm sac in the absence of an endoleak. Aneurysm sac pressure is elevated in the presence of an endoleak. However, the MPIs differ widely between studies both in the absence and presence of an endoleak.

CONCLUSION

MPI is not specific to the type of endoleak. This implies that the same type of endoleak does not necessarily pose the same MPI and by this the same hazard of aneurysm rupture, because the aneurysm sac pressure is directly related to the aneurysm wall stress.

Normal morphometry of the thoracic aorta in the german shepherd dog: a computed tomographic study

Computed tomographic images of the thoracic aorta of 14 German shepherd dogs were examined in order to determine the morphometry of the thoracic aorta. Examinations were carried out in the transverse plane at both intervertebral and mid-vertebral levels of each thoracic vertebra between T(5) and T(13). The dorsoventral and transversal diameters as well as cross-section area of the thoracic aorta were measured. The widest transversal diameter was observed at T(4-5), whereas the largest dorsoventral diameter was detected at T(5). The maximum cross-section area was detected at T(4-5). When dorsoventral and transversal diameters were compared between males and females, the aortic diameter was found to be smaller in males than in females. Although the shape of the thoracic aorta was transversal oval in the majority of the examined females, the shape of the thoracic aorta was dorsoventral oval in the majority of the males. There were significant differences between all levels measured for transversal (P < 0.001), dorsoventral (P < 0.001) diameters and cross-section area (P < 0.001) of the thoracic aorta. And there was a significant correlation between the three parameters examined. However, the correlation coefficient was highest in females.

An animal model for type II endoleaks with use of a tsuzumi drum-shaped stent-graft

PURPOSE

To create an animal model of type II endoleaks after endoluminal deployment of a specially designed stent-graft (SG).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Five swine were used. A tsuzumi drum-shaped SG consisting of a covered Z stent with its diameter narrowed at the center was deployed in the midthoracic aorta. In this way, a residual space (RS) was created between the aortic wall and the graft to simulate an aneurysm sac. A 5-F catheter was placed into the RS, and then aortography, RS angiography, and pressure measurements were performed. Follow-up was performed at 3 and 10 days after the procedure. Mean pressure indexes (MPIs) were calculated as the ratio of the mean RS pressure to the aortic pressure. Histologic examination was also performed.

RESULTS

RSs with two or three pairs of intercostal arteries were successfully created in all cases. Aortography showed two type II endoleaks in five swine just after SG deployment and four type II endoleaks at 10 days. RS angiography showed circulation between the RS and the intercostal arteries in all cases. The mean MPI was 69.4% +/- 10.4% just after SG deployment and increased to 87.8% +/- 5.2% at 10 days. By gross examination, RS patency was retained.

CONCLUSIONS

A swine model of type II endoleaks was successfully created endoluminally. This model does not require direct surgery to the aorta and its side branches and promises to be useful to study the mechanism of and therapy for type II endoleaks.

Treatment of type II endoleaks with a novel polyurethane thrombogenic foam: Induction of endoleak thrombosis and elimination of intra-aneurysmal pressure in the canine model

OBJECTIVE

The clinical significance and treatment of retrograde collateral arterial perfusion of abdominal aortic aneurysms after endovascular repair (type II endoleak) have not been completely characterized. A canine abdominal aortic aneurysm model of type II endoleak with an implanted pressure transducer was used to evaluate the use of polyurethane foam to induce thrombosis of type II endoleaks. The effect on endoleak patency, intra-aneurysmal pressure, and thrombus histology was studied.

METHODS

Prosthetic aneurysms with an intraluminal, solid-state, strain-gauge pressure transducer were created in the infrarenal aorta of 14 mongrel dogs. Aneurysm side-branch vessels were reimplanted into the prosthetic aneurysm of 10 animals by using a Carrel patch. Type II (retrograde) endoleaks were created by excluding the aneurysm from antegrade perfusion with an impermeable stent graft. Thrombosis of the type II endoleak was induced by implantation of polyurethane foam into the prosthetic aneurysm sac of four animals. Six animals with type II endoleaks were not treated. In four control animals, no collateral side branches were reimplanted, and therefore no endoleak was created. Intra-aneurysmal and systemic pressures were measured daily for 60 to 90 days after the implantation of the stent graft. Endoleak patency and flow were assessed during surgery and at the time of death by using angiographic imaging and duplex ultrasonography. Histologic analysis of the intra-aneurysmal thrombus was also performed.

RESULTS

Intra-aneurysmal pressure values are indexed to systemic pressure and are represented as a percentage of the simultaneously obtained systemic pressure, which has a value of 1.0. All six animals with untreated type II endoleaks maintained patency of the endoleak and side-branch arteries throughout the study period. Compared with control aneurysms that had no endoleak, animals with patent type II endoleaks exhibited significantly higher intra-aneurysmal pressurization (systolic pressure: patent type II endoleak, 0.702 +/- 0.283; control, 0.172 +/- 0.091; P < .001; mean pressure: endoleak, 0.784 +/- 0.229; control, 0.137 +/- 0.102; P < .001; pulse pressure: endoleak, 0.406 +/- 0.248; control, 0.098 +/- 0.077; P < .001; P < .001 for comparison for all groups by analysis of variance). Treatment of the type II endoleak with polyurethane foam induced thrombosis of the endoleak and feeding side-branch arteries in all four animals with type II endoleaks. This resulted in intra-aneurysmal pressures statistically indistinguishable from the controls (systolic pressure, 0.183 +/- 0.08; mean pressure, 0.142 +/- 0.09; pulse pressure, 0.054 +/- 0.04; not significant). Angiography and histology documented persistent patency up to the time of death (mean, 64 days) for untreated type II endoleaks and confirmed thrombosis of polyurethane foam-treated endoleaks in all cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Untreated type II endoleaks were associated with intra-aneurysmal pressures that were 70% to 80% of systemic pressure. Treatment with polyurethane foam resulted in a reduction of intra-aneurysmal pressure to a level that was indistinguishable from control aneurysms that had no endoleak.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Endovascular repair of abdominal aortic aneurysms is dependent on the successful exclusion of the aneurysm from arterial circulation. Type II endoleaks originate from retrograde flow into the aneurysm sac. This study demonstrates the use of polyurethane foam to induce thrombosis in a canine model of a type II endoleak, thereby reducing intra-aneurysmal pressure to levels similar to levels in animals without endoleaks. This approach may be a strategy for future treatment of type II endoleaks.

Aneurysm Sac Pressure Monitoring: Effect of Technique on Interpretation of Measurements

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study is to determine the accuracy of measuring pressure with a fluid filled pressure device (needle) and a non-fluid filled pressure device (catheter) inside a thrombosed aneurysmal sac after exclusion from circulation by endovascular grafting.

METHODS

In a static environment, consisting of a syringe to which a pressure monitoring kit was connected, experiments were performed to study the influence of the type of device (either needle or catheter) and the effect of the characteristics of the medium on the accuracy and reproducibility of pressure measurements. The pressures obtained with the needle in the different kinds of media were compared with those obtained in blood. Similar experiments were performed using a pressure catheter. Subsequently, pressure measurements were performed in a dynamic and physiological environment. This environment consisted of an artificial circulation in which an aneurysm, constructed of porcine aorta and filled with human aortic thrombus, was mounted. The pressures were compared and analyzed by Bland-Altman plots.

RESULTS

Under static conditions, the pressure levels obtained by a needle in blood, starch solution and thrombus were similar. Under identical conditions, pressures obtained by a catheter in starch solution were significant lower than the pressures measured in blood (P<0.05). Under dynamic pressure conditions the reproducibility of pressures obtained with the needle inserted in the human thrombus was very poor.

CONCLUSION

A needle pressure measuring device, inserted into media like human fibrin thrombus, does not yield accurate and reproducible results. A catheter with a tip-sensor rather than a needle is superior to study the pressure in the aneurysm sac after EVAR.

Characterization of retrograde collateral (type II) endoleak using a new canine model

OBJECTIVE

The clinical significance of retrograde collateral arterial perfusion of abdominal aortic aneurysms after endovascular repair (type II endoleak) has not been completely characterized. In this study a canine model was used to analyze intra-aneurysmal pressure, thrombus histologic characteristics, endoleak patency, and radiographic appearance of type II endoleaks originating from single and multiple aneurysm side branches.

METHODS

Prosthetic aneurysms with an intraluminal solid-state strain-gauge pressure transducer were created in the infrarenal aorta of 14 mongrel dogs. A single collateral side branch was reimplanted in 4 animals, multiple side branches were reimplanted in 6 animals, and no side branches were reimplanted in 4 control animals. Intra-aneurysmal and systemic pressure was measured for 60 to 90 days after creation of the type II endoleak. Endoleak patency and flow were assessed with duplex ultrasound scanning and cine-magnetic resonance angiography. Histologic analysis of the intra-aneurysmal thrombus was also performed.

RESULTS

Stent-graft exclusion reduced intra-aneurysmal pressure significantly in all animals, as compared with systemic pressure (P < .001). All intra-aneurysmal pressure values are indexed to the systemic pressure, and are represented as a percentage of the simultaneously obtained systemic pressure, which has a value of 1.0. Type II endoleaks originating from multiple side branches exhibited significantly increased intra-aneurysmal systolic pressure, mean pressure, and pulse pressure, as compared with endoleaks derived from either a single side branch (systolic pressure: multiple, 0.70 +/- 0.28 vs single, 0.50 +/- 0.19; P < .001; mean pressure: multiple, 0.78 +/- 0.23 vs single, 0.59 +/- 0.22, P < .001; pulse pressure: multiple, 0.41 +/- 0.25 vs single, 0.17 +/- 0.15, P < .001) or excluded control aneurysms that had no side branches and no endoleak (systolic pressure, 0.17 +/- 0.09; mean pressure, 0.14 +/- 0.10; pulse pressure, 0.098 +/- 0.08; P < .001). Cine-magnetic resonance angiograms and duplex ultrasound scans documented persistent patency of multiple branch endoleaks up to the time of euthanasia. In contrast, single side branch endoleaks thrombosed within 3 days (P < .001). Thrombus in the aneurysm sac in close proximity to the endoleak contained intact red blood cells and limited fibrin. Thrombus distant from the endoleak demonstrated extensive fibrin deposition and degraded red blood cells.

CONCLUSION

The canine model may be used to reliably measure intra-aneurysmal pressure in the presence of patent and thrombosed type II endoleaks. In this model 2 or more side branches are necessary to maintain persistent patency of type II endoleaks. These endoleaks are associated with significantly elevated intra-aneurysmal pressure, that is, 70% to 80% of systemic pressure. These results suggest that persistent type II endoleaks have clinical significance.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Endoleaks originating from retrograde flow in the side branch vessels of the aneurysm generate significant levels of intra-aneurysmal pressure, that is, 70% to 80% of systemic pressure. At least 2 patent side branch vessels appear to be necessary to cause persistent patency of type II endoleak in the canine model. Further studies will be necessary to enable more complete characterization of retrograde endoleaks and to extend these findings to allow clinical application. However, these results suggest that persistently patent type II endoleaks are clinical significance and may require more intensive follow-up intervention.

Small Intestinal Submucosa Aneurysm Sac Embolization for Endoleak Prevention after Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Endografting: A Pilot Study in Sheep

PURPOSE

To percutaneously create an improved abdominal aortic aneurysm model of endoleak after endograft placement and to explore efficacy of small intestinal submucosal embolization of the residual aneurysmal sac for prevention of endoleaks.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Abdominal aortic aneurysm was created transluminally by over-dilation of a Palmaz stent in 12 sheep. Approximately 20% undersized endografts suspended between two stent-graft adapters were used to bridge the aneurysm in a manner that two lumbar pairs remained patent within the residual aneurysm sac. Size of the residual aneurysm sac was increased by placement of an undersized stent-graft consisting of damaged lyophilized small intestinal submucosal sheets sandwiched between two Zilver stents. In six sheep, residual aneurysm sacs were embolized by combining small intestinal submucosal sponge and small intestinal submucosal sheet pieces. The other six sheep served as the control group. Angiography performed immediately after the procedure was compared with follow-up angiography before the animals were killed at 1, 3, and 7 months. Gross and histologic examinations were also obtained.

RESULTS

Aortic ruptures (n = 3) and dissections (n = 2) during aneurysm creation responded well to endograft placement. Eleven endografts were placed successfully, one was misplaced. The mean diameter of aneurysmal sac was 16 mm in the study and 15.2 mm in the control group. In the study group, in four sheep, the sac and seven pairs of lumbar arteries were occluded by embolization and remained obstructed by organized thrombus during the entire study. There were no type II endoleaks. Four type III new endoleaks developed without antegrade filling of lumbar arteries. In the control group, five animals had type I and II endoleaks at the initial studies. Only one sheep exhibited completely organized thrombosis of the aneurysmal sac and without endoleaks. In the other four sheep with partially organized sac thrombosis, endoleaks were unchanged. One type III endoleak occurred in this group.

CONCLUSION

The combination of small intestinal submucosal sponge and small intestinal submucosal sheet pieces is a promising embolic material for occlusion of the residual sac after endovascular abdominal aortic aneurysm repair and for prevention of type II endoleaks.

Endotension as a Result of Pressure Transmission through the Graft following Endovascular Aneurysm Repair—An In vitro Study

BACKGROUND

endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) significantly reduces, but does not abolish aneurysm sac pressure, possibly because of trans-fabric transmission.

OBJECTIVE

to investigate how blood pressure is transmitted through different types of grafts into the aneurysm sac.

DESIGN

experimental study, in vitro.

METHODS

a latex aneurysm was inserted into an in vitro circulation model. The systemic mean pressure (SPmean) was varied from 50 to 120 mmHg. The grafts used for aneurysm exclusion were: thin wall polyethylene (PE), thick wall polyethylene (PE) and thin wall ePTFE. Mean aneurysm sac pressure (ASPmean) was measured, as was pulse pressure (ASPpulse).

RESULTS

at an SPmean of 70 mmHg, the ASPmean was 34 +/- 0.8 mmHg (polyethylene knitted, thick wall), 30 +/- 1.0 mmHg (polyethylene woven, thin wall), and 17 +/- 0.6 mmHg (thin wall ePTFE). The ASPmean increased with SPmean, the relationship depending on the graft material. Stiffer grafts were associated with lower ASPmean and ASPpulse (p<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

the relationship between aneurysm sac mean pressure and systemic pressure (SP) depends on the graft material. These data highlights the need for further studies regarding endotension.

A Canine Model for Studying Endoleak after Endovascular Aneurysm Repair

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to create an animal model of endoleak after stent-graft placement for abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) in which a large aneurysmal sac would be preserved for the testing of techniques for its percutaneous occlusion.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Infrarenal AAAs were created in nine dogs by anastomosis of an isolated segment of the inferior vena cava to the right side of the abdominal aorta in combination with a large anterior patch from the external jugular vein. One hour later, animals underwent percutaneous implantation of polytetrafluoroethylene-covered Z stent endografts with three 3-mm-diameter holes through the fabric. Aortograms were obtained before and after surgery, after endograft placement, and at the time of animal sacrifice at 1 week or 1, 2, 3, or 6 months. Pressures within the aorta and the aneurysm sac were recorded before animal sacrifice. Gross and histologic evaluations of the specimens were then carried out.

RESULTS

Immediately after endograft placement, all nine animals had artificial type III endoleaks with angiographic filling of lumbar arteries and veins. One animal died of surgical complications within 2 days of surgery and is not included in our data analysis. One aneurysm ruptured at 1 week. At completion of the study, six endografts were patent and two were occluded. The aneurysm sac had enlarged by approximately 50% in seven animals. At follow-up, type I endoleak was present in three animals, type II endoleak was present in three, and the artificial type III endoleak was present in all six animals with patent endografts. The pressure differential between aorta and aneurysm sac was 36 mm Hg, with a mean aortic pressure of 87 mm Hg +/- 13.3 and a mean aneurysmal sac pressure of 51 mm Hg +/- 28.1. The aneurysmal sac exhibited early thrombus formation at 1 week, which progressed to complete thrombosis in 1-6 months.

CONCLUSIONS

The model is technically feasible but would be useful in testing occlusive techniques for residual aneurysm sacs only in the acute phase after endograft placement. It would be not reliable for chronic evaluation because of rapidly progressive thrombosis in most aneurysm sacs and occasional complete thrombosis of the AAA and endograft.

Intra-aneurysmal pressure after incomplete endovascular exclusion

PURPOSE

An endoleak results from the incomplete endovascular exclusion of an aneurysm. We developed an experimental model to analyze hemodynamic changes within the aneurysm sac in the presence of an endoleak, with and without a simulated open collateral branch.

METHODS

With a latex aneurysm model connected to a pulsatile pump, pressures were measured simultaneously within the system (systemic pressure) and the aneurysm sac (intrasac pressure). The experiments were performed without endoleak (control group) and after creating a 3.5-mm (group 1), 4.5-mm (group 2), and 6-mm (group 3) diameter orifice in the endograft, simulating an endoleak. Pressures were also registered with and without a patent aneurysm side branch.

RESULTS

In each endoleak group, the intrasac diastolic pressure (DP) and mean pressure (MP) were significantly higher than the systemic DP and MP (P =.01, P =.006, and P =.001, respectively), although the pressure curve was damped. The presence of an open side branch significantly reduced the intrasac DP and MP.

CONCLUSION

In this model, intrasac pressures were significantly higher than systemic pressures in the presence of all endoleaks, even the smallest ones. Intrasac pressures higher than systemic pressure may pose a high risk for aneurysm rupture. Although patent side branches significantly reduce these pressures, the aggressive management of an endoleak should be pursued.

Experimental techniques and models in the study of the development and treatment of abdominal aortic aneurysm

BACKGROUND

It is still unclear what initiates aneurysmal dilatation and what determines whether or not an aneurysm will continue to expand and rupture. Early detection and operative repair of an abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) still remains the only effective means of reducing the high mortality rate associated with the condition. Endovascular techniques are being developed in an attempt to reduce the mortality rate associated with elective repair. A variety of animal models and experimental techniques have been described in the investigation of the pathophysiology of AAA and in the development of improved endovascular surgical and pharmacological therapies. This article discusses these models and techniques, their advantages and some of the problems encountered in extrapolating experimental findings to the human condition.

METHODS

This review is based on a search of the Medline database from 1966 to March 1998 using recognized key words and text words. A further search was then conducted on references quoted within selected relevant publications.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

Treatment of rodent aortas with intraluminal elastase or periaortic calcium chloride creates reproducible aneurysms that have certain similarities to the human pathology; such aneurysms have been favoured in the investigation of the pathophysiology of aneurysm expansion. However, these models lack several of the prominent features of the human lesion, such as atherosclerosis and intraluminal thrombosis. The development of gene knockout mice may lead to a more analogous aneurysm formation, with associated atherosclerosis. Many large animal models have been used in the development of endovascular techniques but, in general, these do not mimic the human pathophysiology and fail to predict medium- and long-term complications.