Elevation of serum creatine kinase as the only manifestation of an intragenic deletion of the dystrophin gene in three unrelated families

DMD deletions underlining mild dystrophinopathies: literature review highlights phenotype-related mutation clusters and provides insights about genetic mechanisms and prognosis

DMD gene pathogenic variations cause a spectrum of phenotypes, ranging from severe Duchenne muscular dystrophy, the Becker milder cases, the intermediate or very mild muscle phenotypes invariably characterized by high CK, and the ultrarare fully-asymptomatic cases. Besides these phenotypes, X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy is also caused by DMD mutations. Males carrying DMD deletions with absent or very mild phenotypes have been sparsely described. We performed a horizon scan on public datasets to enroll males with the above phenotypes and carrying DMD deletions to delineate myopathic genotype-phenotype relationships. We inventoried 81 males, who were divided into the following clinical categorization: fully-asymptomatic males aged >43 years (A, N = 22); isolated hyperCKemia (CK, N = 35); and mild weakness (any age) with or without high CK (WCK, N = 24). In all cases, deleted intervals were exons 2 to 55, and no downstream exons were ever involved, apart from an exon 78 deletion in a WCK patient. All deletions were in-frame apart from the known exception to the rule of exon 2 and exon 78. We correlated the mild phenotypes (A and CK) to deleted exons, intronic breakpoints, exon-exon junctions, 3' isoforms rule, and protein epitopes, and we found that some genetic profiles are exclusively/mainly occurring in A/CK phenotypes, suggesting they are compatible with a quasi-normal muscular performance. We discussed diverse pathogenic mechanisms that may contribute to mild dystrophinopathic phenotypes, and we tried to address some "critical" genetic configurations or exon content needed to preserve a semi-functional DMD gene.

Development and Validation of an Outpatient Clinical Predictive Score for the Diagnosis of Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy/Becker Muscular Dystrophy in Children Aged 2-18 Years

Introduction

There is no bedside clinical examination-based prediction score for Duchenne muscular dystrophy/Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD/BMD) in children with neuromuscular diseases (NMDs) presenting with proximal limb-girdle weakness.

Methods

We compared the details of 200 cases of lower motor neuron type of weakness and had some proximal limb-girdle muscle weakness and divided them into 2 groups: with/without a confirmed diagnosis of DMD/BMD. We determined the predictive factors associated with a diagnosis of DMD/BMD using multivariate binary logistic regression. We assessed our proposed prognostic model using both discrimination and calibration and subsequently used the bootstrap method to successfully validate the model internally.

Results

A total of 121 patients had DMD/BMD and the rest of the patients had other diagnoses. Male gender, presence of Gower's sign, valley sign, toe walking, calf pseudohypertrophy, and tongue hypertrophy were independent predictors for a confirmed diagnosis of DMD/BMD and included in the final CVT2MG score (Calf pseudohypertrophy, Valley sign, Toe walking, Tongue hypertrophy, Male gender, and Gower's sign). The final model showed good discrimination (AUC = 87.4% [95% CI: 80.5-92.3%, P < 0.001]) and calibration (P = 0.57). A score of 6 or above appeared to be the best cutoff for discriminating between the DMD/BMD group and the rest of the group with both sensitivity and specificity of 98%. The interrater reliability was almost perfect between two pediatric neurologists and strong between a pediatric neurologist and a pediatric neurology trainee resident (k = 0.91 and 0.87).

Conclusion

The CVT2MG score has good sensitivity and specificity in predicting a confirmed diagnosis of DMD/BMD in subsequent tests.

Evaluation of Cardiac, Autonomic Functions in Ambulant Patients with Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is an X-linked genetic disorder caused by dystrophin gene mutation resulting in muscle weakness, motor delays, difficulty in standing, and inability to walk by 12 years. As disease progresses, it leads to cardiac and respiratory failure. Evaluation of cardiac autonomic status and echocardiography in DMD patients at a young age can be a potential biomarker to assess disease progression. This study aimed to investigate the younger DMD population of 5-11years of age with mild to moderate cardiac involvement for early detection using non-invasive and cost-effective tools. Genetically confirmed male DMD patients, aged 5-11 years (n = 47), screened from the outpatient department of a tertiary neuroscience institution were subjected to heart rate variability and echocardiographic analysis, and values were correlated with their clinical variables. DMD patients showed a significantly higher difference in HR, interventricular septum, E m/s, and E-wave to A-wave (E/A) ratio than normal values (p < 0.001). Significantly higher HR indicates initial sinus tachycardia and decreased IVD (d), and increased E m/s and E/A ratio mark the onset of cardiac symptoms in DMD patients even though its chamber dimension remains normal and are associated with cardiac muscle fibrosis.

Myalgic Becker Muscular Dystrophy Due to an Exon 15 Point Mutation: Case Series and Literature Review

ABSTRACT

Dystrophinopathies result from mutations to the DMD gene. We report 5 boys in 3 families with heterogenous phenotypes due to a point mutation in the DMD gene: a hemizygous tyrosine-to-cysteine change in exon 15 (c.1724T>C) resulting in an amino acid substitution of leucine to proline at codon 575. This mutation has been reported before, with at least 3 prior patients presenting with similar clinical findings of myalgia, myoglobinuria, and occasional muscle cramping. The mutation on DMD c.1724T>C (p.Leu575Pro) is listed in the Clinvar database as a variant of unknown significance. Our report provides contributing evidence that this alteration should be classified as pathogenic.

WGS and RNA Studies Diagnose Noncoding DMD Variants in Males With High Creatine Kinase

Objective

To describe the diagnostic utility of whole-genome sequencing and RNA studies in boys with suspected dystrophinopathy, for whom multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification and exomic parallel sequencing failed to yield a genetic diagnosis, and to use remnant normal DMD splicing in 3 families to define critical levels of wild-type dystrophin bridging clinical spectrums of Duchenne to myalgia.

Methods

Exome, genome, and/or muscle RNA sequencing was performed for 7 males with elevated creatine kinase. PCR of muscle-derived complementary DNA (cDNA) studied consequences for DMD premessenger RNA (pre-mRNA) splicing. Quantitative Western blot was used to determine levels of dystrophin, relative to control muscle.

Results

Splice-altering intronic single nucleotide variants or structural rearrangements in DMD were identified in all 7 families. Four individuals, with abnormal splicing causing a premature stop codon and nonsense-mediated decay, expressed remnant levels of normally spliced DMD mRNA. Quantitative Western blot enabled correlation of wild-type dystrophin and clinical severity, with 0%-5% dystrophin conferring a Duchenne phenotype, 10% ± 2% a Becker phenotype, and 15% ± 2% dystrophin associated with myalgia without manifesting weakness.

Conclusions

Whole-genome sequencing relied heavily on RNA studies to identify DMD splice-altering variants. Short-read RNA sequencing was regularly confounded by the effectiveness of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay and low read depth of the giant DMD mRNA. PCR of muscle cDNA provided a simple, yet informative approach. Highly relevant to genetic therapies for dystrophinopathies, our data align strongly with previous studies of mutant dystrophin in Becker muscular dystrophy, with the collective conclusion that a fractional increase in levels of normal dystrophin between 5% and 20% is clinically significant.

EMQN best practice guidelines for genetic testing in dystrophinopathies

Dystrophinopathies are X-linked diseases, including Duchenne muscular dystrophy and Becker muscular dystrophy, due to DMD gene variants. In recent years, the application of new genetic technologies and the availability of new personalised drugs have influenced diagnostic genetic testing for dystrophinopathies. Therefore, these European best practice guidelines for genetic testing in dystrophinopathies have been produced to update previous guidelines published in 2010.These guidelines summarise current recommended technologies and methodologies for analysis of the DMD gene, including testing for deletions and duplications of one or more exons, small variant detection and RNA analysis. Genetic testing strategies for diagnosis, carrier testing and prenatal diagnosis (including non-invasive prenatal diagnosis) are then outlined. Guidelines for sequence variant annotation and interpretation are provided, followed by recommendations for reporting results of all categories of testing. Finally, atypical findings (such as non-contiguous deletions and dual DMD variants), implications for personalised medicine and clinical trials and incidental findings (identification of DMD gene variants in patients where a clinical diagnosis of dystrophinopathy has not been considered or suspected) are discussed.

Significance of Asymptomatic Hyper Creatine-Kinase Emia

OBJECTIVES

Whether asymptomatic hyper-CKemia (AHCE) should prompt a thorough work-up for muscle disease or not is controversially discussed. This review aims at summarizing and discussing recent findings concerning the cause, frequency, evolution, and work-up of conditions manifesting as AHCE and normal or abnormal electromyography (EMG) respectively muscle biopsy.

METHODS

Systematic PubMed search.

RESULTS

There are numerous primary (hereditary) and acquired myopathies that manifest with permanent, recurrent, or temporary AHCE with/without myopathic EMG or muscle biopsy. AHCE particularly occurs at onset of these conditions, which include dystrophinopathies, myotilinopathies, calpainopathy, caveolinopathy, dysferlinopathy, central core disease, multicore disease, desminopathy, MD1, MD2, hypoPP, malignant hyperthermia susceptibility, Pompe disease, McArdle disease, myoadenylate deaminase-deficiency, CPT2-deficiency, mitochondrial disorders, or myopathy with tubular aggregates. Most likely, other primary myopathies manifest with AHCE as well, without having been reported. Patients with AHCE should be taken seriously and repeated CK determination must be conducted. If hyper-CKemia is persisting or recurrent, these patients should undergo an EMG and eventually muscle biopsy. If noninformative, genetic work-up by a panel or whole exome sequencing should be initiated, irrespective of the family history. Patients with AHCE should avoid excessive exercise, require sufficient hydration, require counseling with regard to the risk of malignant hyperthermia, and should inform anesthesiologists and surgeons about their condition before elective surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Recurrent AHCE should be taken seriously and managed with conventional work-up. If noninformative, genetic work-up should follow irrespective of the family history.

CRISPR for Neuromuscular Disorders: Gene Editing and Beyond

This is a review describing advances in CRISPR/Cas-mediated therapies for neuromuscular disorders (NMDs). We explore both CRISPR-mediated editing and dead Cas approaches as potential therapeutic strategies for multiple NMDs. Last, therapeutic considerations, including delivery and off-target effects, are also discussed.

What is the level of dystrophin expression required for effective therapy of Duchenne muscular dystrophy?

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a fatal X-linked muscle wasting disease. The disease is due to mutations in the DMD gene that encodes for a large intracellular protein called dystrophin. Dystrophin plays a critical role in linking the internal cytoskeleton of the striated muscle cell with the extracellular matrix as well as having cell signalling functions. In its absence muscle contraction is associated with cycles of damage, repair, inflammation and fibrosis with eventual loss of muscle and replacement with fat. Experiments in animal models of DMD have generated a number of different approaches to the induction of dystrophin including viral vector mediated delivery of a recombinant dystrophin gene, antisense oligonucleotide mediated exon-skipping to restore the open reading frame in the dystrophin mRNA, read-through of premature stop mutations, genome modification using CRISPR-Cas9 or cell based transfer of a functional dystrophin gene. In all cases, it will be important to understand how much dystrophin expression is required for a clinically effective therapy and this review examines the data from humans and animal models to estimate the percentage of endogenous dystrophin that is likely to have significant clinical benefit. While there are a number of important caveats to consider, including the appropriate outcome measures, this review suggests that approximately 20% of endogenous levels uniformly distributed within the skeletal muscles and the heart may be sufficient to largely prevent disease progression.

Mutation-Based Therapeutic Strategies for Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy: From Genetic Diagnosis to Therapy

Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD/BMD) are X-linked muscle disorders caused by mutations of the DMD gene, which encodes the subsarcolemmal protein dystrophin. In DMD, dystrophin is not expressed due to a disruption in the reading frame of the DMD gene, resulting in a severe phenotype. Becker muscular dystrophy exhibits a milder phenotype, having mutations that maintain the reading frame and allow for the production of truncated dystrophin. To date, various therapeutic approaches for DMD have been extensively developed. However, the pathomechanism is quite complex despite it being a single gene disorder, and dystrophin is expressed not only in a large amount of skeletal muscle but also in cardiac, vascular, intestinal smooth muscle, and nervous system tissue. Thus, the most appropriate therapy would be complementation or restoration of dystrophin expression, such as gene therapy using viral vectors, readthrough therapy, or exon skipping therapy. Among them, exon skipping therapy with antisense oligonucleotides can restore the reading frame and yield the conversion of a severe phenotype to one that is mild. In this paper, I present the significance of molecular diagnosis and the development of mutation-based therapeutic strategies to complement or restore dystrophin expression.

Genotype-phenotype correlation in Becker muscular dystrophy in Chinese patients

Large deletions and duplications are the most frequent causative mutations in Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD), but genetic profile varied greatly among reports. We performed a comprehensive molecular investigation in 95 Chinese BMD patients. All patients were divided into three subtypes: normal muscle strength (type 1) in 18 cases, quadriceps myopathy (type 2) in 20 cases, and limb-girdle weakness (type 3) in 57 cases. Nineteen cases (20.0%) had small mutations and 76 cases (80.0%) had major rearrangements, including 67 cases (70.5%) of exonic deletions and 9 cases (9.5%) of exonic duplications. We identified 50 cases (65.8%) of in-frame mutations, and 26 cases (34.2%) of frame-shift mutations. The frequency of deletion in exons 13-19 was 30.6% in type 1 patients, 9.7% in type 2 patients, and 10.4% in type 3 patients. The frequency of deletion in exons 45-55 was 28.6% in type 1 patients, 40.8% in type 2, and 50.0% in type 3 patients. All major rearrangements of DMD gene in type 1 patients were also observed in type 3 patients. Our study suggested that frame-shift mutation was not rare in Chinese BMD patients. Although no difference was observed on the forms of DMD gene mutations among the three types of patients, the mutation in proximal region of DMD gene has higher frequency for patients without weakness. Effect of exon skipping for DMD depends on the size and location of the mutation. Additional studies are required to determine whether exon-skipping strategies in proximal region of DMD gene could yield more functional dystrophin.

Hyperckemia and myalgia are common presentations of anoctamin-5-related myopathy in French patients

INTRODUCTION

Patients with anoctamin-5 (ANO5) mutations may present not only with limb-girdle muscular dystrophy type 2L or adult-onset Miyoshi-type myopathy but also with asymptomatic hyperCKemia, exercise intolerance, or rhabdomyolysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data from 38 patients in France with ANO5 mutations with and without muscle weakness on first examination were compared.

RESULTS

Twenty patients presented without muscle weakness. Median age at symptom onset or discovery of hyperCKemia was 23 years. Creatine kinase levels ranged from 200 to 40,000 U/L. Electromyography showed a myopathic pattern in 5 patients, and muscle imaging showed involvement of posterior calf muscles in 10 patients. Mild cardiac involvement was observed in 2 patients. Sixteen patients remain free of weakness after a median follow-up period of 5 years.

DISCUSSION

Asymptomatic, sometimes mild hyperCKemia or exercise intolerance is a presentation of ANO5-related myopathy and may remain isolated or precede muscle weakness by many years. Muscle Nerve 56: 1096-1100, 2017.

Genetics and emerging treatments for Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy

Mutations in the DMD gene result in Duchenne or Becker muscular dystrophy due to absent or altered expression of the dystrophin protein. The more severe Duchenne muscular dystrophy typically presents around ages 2 to 5 with gait disturbance, and historically has led to the loss of ambulation by age 12. It is important for the practicing pediatrician, however, to be aware of other presenting signs, such as delayed motor or cognitive milestones, or elevated serum transaminases. Becker muscular dystrophy is milder, often presenting after age 5, with ambulation frequently preserved past 20 years and sometimes into late decades.

Current concepts in dystrophinopathies

Dystrophinopathies comprise a group of hereditary muscle disorders characterized by progressive wasting and weakness of skeletal muscle, as a result of degeneration of muscle fibers, and can be distinguished by the mode of transmission, age at onset and pattern of muscle weakness. The range of phenotypes associated with the region Xp21 has been expanding since identification of the gene in 1987. The mild end of the spectrum includes the phenotype of the muscle cramps with myoglobinuria and isolated quadriceps myopathy, while at the severe end, there are progressive muscle diseases that are classified as Duchenne / Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD/BMD).

The muscular dystrophies

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

With transition to the genetic era, the number of muscular dystrophies has grown significantly, but so too has our understanding of their pathogenic underpinnings. Clinical features associated with each muscular dystrophy still guide us to the diagnosis. However, improved diagnostic abilities refine and expand phenotypic and genotypic correlates. This article discusses the epidemiology, clinical features, and diagnosis of these disorders.

RECENT FINDINGS

Some important recent advancements include (1) a much greater understanding of the pathogenetic pathways underlying facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy and myotonic dystrophy type 1; (2) the publication of diagnostic and treatment guidelines for Duchenne muscular dystrophy; and (3) further clarification of the many genetic muscle disorders presenting a limb-girdle pattern of weakness.

SUMMARY

Muscular dystrophies are genetic, progressive, degenerative disorders with the primary symptom of muscle weakness. Duchenne, Becker, facioscapulohumeral, and myotonic muscular dystrophies are most prevalent and tend to have distinctive features helpful in diagnosis. The limb-girdle, Emery-Dreifuss, and oculopharyngeal muscular dystrophies are less common but often may also be diagnosed on the basis of phenotype. Researchers hope to help patients with future discoveries effective in slowing or halting disease progression, reversing or preventing underlying mechanisms, and repairing previously damaged muscle.

[Phenotypic heterogeneity and phenotype-genotype correlations in dystrophinopathies: Contribution of genetic and clinical databases]

The objective of this work was to study the natural history of dystrophinopathies and the genotype-phenotype correlations made possible by the development of the clinical part of the French DMD database. The collection of 70,000 clinical data for 600 patients with an average longitudinal follow-up of 12years enabled clarification of the natural history of Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies and clinical presentations in symptomatic females. We were able to specify the phenotypic heterogeneity of motor, orthopedic and respiratory involvements (severe, standard and intermediary form), of the cardiac disorder (severe, standard or absent cardiomyopathy, absence of correlation between motor and cardiac involvements), and of brain function (mental deficiency in the patients with Becker muscular dystrophy, psychopathological disorders in dystrophinopathies). Phenotypic variability did not correlate with a specific mutational spectrum. We propose a model of phenotypic analysis based on the presence or not of muscular and cardiac involvements (described by age at onset and rate of progression) and brain involvement (described by the type and the severity of the cognitive impairment and of the psychological disorders). The methodology developed for the DMD gene can be generalized and used for other databases dedicated to genetic diseases. Application of this model of phenotypic analysis for each patient and further development of the database should contribute substantially to clinical research providing useful tools for future clinical trials.

Exon skipping quantification by quantitative reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction in Duchenne muscular dystrophy patients treated with the antisense oligomer eteplirsen

Restoration of the open reading frame of the DMD gene and dystrophin protein production in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) can be achieved by exon skipping using antisense oligomers (AOs) targeted to splicing elements. Several such RNA-based gene therapy approaches are in clinical development in which all studies to date have assessed AO efficacy by semiquantitative nested reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). Precise evaluation of dystrophin protein levels is complex and hindered by the large size and low abundance of dystrophin; thus an accurate and standardized measurement of DMD exon skipping at the RNA level remains important to assess and compare patient responses in DMD exon skipping clinical trials. Here we describe the development of a Taqman quantitative (q)RT-PCR assay to quantify exon skipping and highlight its use to determine the levels of exon skipping in DMD patients treated intramuscularly with a morpholino AO to skip exon 51, eteplirsen (AVI-4658). The muscle biopsies of these patients were previously thoroughly characterized, providing a valuable benchmark for the evaluation of novel methodology. We demonstrate that levels of dystrophin protein restoration, and thus patient response, correlate accurately with the RNA level. Furthermore, this sensitive assay detects revertant exon 51 skipped fibers in untreated biopsies, providing an important baseline to precisely quantify treatment success. This study represents the first quantitative assessment of exon skipping in a clinical trial setting. We present a standardized and reproducible method to assess patient response that will complement protein studies in future preclinical and clinical exon skipping-based gene therapy studies for DMD.

Assessing pathogenicity for novel mutation/sequence variants: the value of healthy older individuals

Improvement in DNA technology is increasingly revealing unexpected/unknown mutations in healthy persons and generating anxiety due to their still unknown health consequences. We report a 44-year-old healthy father of a 10-year-old daughter with bilateral coloboma and hearing loss, but without muscle weakness, in whom a whole-genome CGH revealed a deletion of exons 38–44 in the dystrophin gene. This mutation was inherited from her asymptomatic father, who was further clinically and molecularly evaluated for prognosis and genetic counseling (GC). This deletion was never identified by us in 982 Duchenne/Becker patients. To assess whether the present case represents a rare case of non-penetrance, and aiming to obtain more information for prognosis and GC, we suggested that healthy older relatives submit their DNA for analysis, to which several complied. Mutation analysis revealed that his mother, brother, and 56-year-old maternal uncle also carry the 38–44 deletion, suggesting it an unlikely cause of muscle weakness. Genome sequencing will disclose mutations and variants whose health impact are still unknown, raising important problems in interpreting results, defining prognosis, and discussing GC. We suggest that, in addition to family history, keeping the DNA of older relatives could be very informative, in particular for those interested in having their genome sequenced.

Overview on DMD exon skipping

Antisense-mediated exon skipping to restore the disrupted dystrophin reading frame is currently in clinical trials for Duchenne muscular dystrophy. This chapter describes the rationale of this approach and gives an overview of in vitro and in vivo experiments with antisense oligonucleotides and antisense genes. Finally, an overview of clinical trials is given and outstanding questions and hurdles are discussed.

Dystrophin quantification and clinical correlations in Becker muscular dystrophy: implications for clinical trials

Duchenne muscular dystrophy is caused by mutations in the DMD gene that disrupt the open reading frame and prevent the full translation of its protein product, dystrophin. Restoration of the open reading frame and dystrophin production can be achieved by exon skipping using antisense oligonucleotides targeted to splicing elements. This approach aims to transform the Duchenne muscular dystrophy phenotype to that of the milder disorder, Becker muscular dystrophy, typically caused by in-frame dystrophin deletions that allow the production of an internally deleted but partially functional dystrophin. There is ongoing debate regarding the functional properties of the different internally deleted dystrophins produced by exon skipping for different mutations; more insight would be valuable to improve and better predict the outcome of exon skipping clinical trials. To this end, we have characterized the clinical phenotype of 17 patients with Becker muscular dystrophy harbouring in-frame deletions relevant to on-going or planned exon skipping clinical trials for Duchenne muscular dystrophy and correlated it to the levels of dystrophin, and dystrophin-associated protein expression. The cohort of 17 patients, selected exclusively on the basis of their genotype, included 4 asymptomatic, 12 mild and 1 severe patient. All patients had dystrophin levels of >40% of control and significantly higher dystrophin (P = 0.013), β-dystroglycan (P = 0.025) and neuronal nitric oxide synthase (P = 0.034) expression was observed in asymptomatic individuals versus symptomatic patients with Becker muscular dystrophy. Furthermore, grouping the patients by deletion, patients with Becker muscular dystrophy with deletions with an end-point of exon 51 (the skipping of which could rescue the largest group of Duchenne muscular dystrophy deletions) showed significantly higher dystrophin levels (P = 0.034) than those with deletions ending with exon 53. This is the first quantitative study on both dystrophin and dystrophin-associated protein expression in patients with Becker muscular dystrophy with deletions relevant for on-going exon skipping trials in Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Taken together, our results indicate that all varieties of internally deleted dystrophin assessed in this study have the functional capability to provide a substantial clinical benefit to patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy.

Restoration of the dystrophin-associated glycoprotein complex after exon skipping therapy in Duchenne muscular dystrophy

We previously conducted a proof of principle; dose escalation study in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) patients using the morpholino splice-switching oligonucleotide AVI-4658 (eteplirsen) that induces skipping of dystrophin exon 51 in patients with relevant deletions, restores the open reading frame and induces dystrophin protein expression after intramuscular (i.m.) injection. We now show that this dystrophin expression was accompanied by an elevated expression of α-sarcoglycan, β-dystroglycan (BDG) and--in relevant cases--neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) at the sarcolemma, each of which is a component of a different subcomplex of the dystrophin-associated glycoprotein complex (DAPC). As expected, nNOS expression was relocalized to the sarcolemma in Duchenne patients in whom the dystrophin deletion left the nNOS-binding domain (exons 42-45) intact, whereas this did not occur in patients with deletions that involved this domain. Our results indicate that the novel internally deleted and shorter dystrophin induced by skipping exon 51 in patients with amenable deletions, can also restore the dystrophin-associated complex, further suggesting preserved functionality of the newly translated dystrophin.

AAV-microdystrophin therapy improves cardiac performance in aged female mdx mice

Dystrophin deficiency leads to lethal dilated Duchenne cardiomyopathy. A promising therapy is to deliver a highly abbreviated microdystrophin gene to the heart using adeno-associated virus (AAV). Microdystrophin has been shown to mitigate dystrophin-deficient skeletal muscle disease. However, it is not clear whether microdystrophin is equally effective in treating Duchenne cardiomyopathy. To evaluate microdystrophin therapy in the heart, we injected 5 × 10(12) viral genome particles/mouse of AAV-9 ΔR4-23/ΔC microdystrophin vector via tail vein to ~16-20-month-old (average 18.7-month-old) female mdx mice, a manifesting model of Duchenne cardiomyopathy. Cardiac transduction and heart function were examined at 2-8 months after gene transfer. We observed robust myocardial microdystrophin expression. Electrocardiography (ECG) and left ventricular catheter hemodynamic assays also revealed significant improvement. Furthermore, AAV-microdystrophin therapy prevented dobutamine-stress induced acute cardiac death. We demonstrate for the first time that AAV microdystrophin therapy significantly ameliorates functional deficiency in a phenotypic model of Duchenne cardiomyopathy. Our results support further exploration of microdystrophin therapy to treat Duchenne cardiomyopathy.

Systemic administration of PRO051 in Duchenne's muscular dystrophy

BACKGROUND

Local intramuscular administration of the antisense oligonucleotide PRO051 in patients with Duchenne's muscular dystrophy with relevant mutations was previously reported to induce the skipping of exon 51 during pre-messenger RNA splicing of the dystrophin gene and to facilitate new dystrophin expression in muscle-fiber membranes. The present phase 1-2a study aimed to assess the safety, pharmacokinetics, and molecular and clinical effects of systemically administered PRO051.

METHODS

We administered weekly abdominal subcutaneous injections of PRO051 for 5 weeks in 12 patients, with each of four possible doses (0.5, 2.0, 4.0, and 6.0 mg per kilogram of body weight) given to 3 patients. Changes in RNA splicing and protein levels in the tibialis anterior muscle were assessed at two time points. All patients subsequently entered a 12-week open-label extension phase, during which they all received PRO051 at a dose of 6.0 mg per kilogram per week. Safety, pharmacokinetics, serum creatine kinase levels, and muscle strength and function were assessed.

RESULTS

The most common adverse events were irritation at the administration site and, during the extension phase, mild and variable proteinuria and increased urinary α(1)-microglobulin levels; there were no serious adverse events. The mean terminal half-life of PRO051 in the circulation was 29 days. PRO051 induced detectable, specific exon-51 skipping at doses of 2.0 mg or more per kilogram. New dystrophin expression was observed between approximately 60% and 100% of muscle fibers in 10 of the 12 patients, as measured on post-treatment biopsy, which increased in a dose-dependent manner to up to 15.6% of the expression in healthy muscle. After the 12-week extension phase, there was a mean (±SD) improvement of 35.2±28.7 m (from the baseline of 384±121 m) on the 6-minute walk test.

CONCLUSIONS

Systemically administered PRO051 showed dose-dependent molecular efficacy in patients with Duchenne's muscular dystrophy, with a modest improvement in the 6-minute walk test after 12 weeks of extended treatment. (Funded by Prosensa Therapeutics; Netherlands National Trial Register number, NTR1241.).

Pseudometabolic presentation of dystrophinopathy due to a missense mutation

Exercise intolerance with myalgia, muscle stiffness, and recurrent rhabdomyolysis due to mutations in the DMD gene can mimic metabolic myopathies leading to delayed or inaccurate diagnoses. In this retrospective chart review, we report 3 unrelated boys with exertional myalgia, muscle stiffness, myoglobinuria, and normal neurological examination due to an identical point mutation in the DMD gene: a hemizygous T-to-C change in exon 15 (c.1724T>C) resulting in an amino acid substitution of leucine to proline at codon 575. Two of the 3 boys had normal dystrophin immunostaining and Western blot analysis in muscle. This missense mutation has been reported twice before, with at least 1 patient exhibiting rhabdomyolysis. Our report, however, is the first to describe in detail the clinical findings associated with this specific mutation. Further studies and clinical reports are needed to better understand the pathogenicity of the mutation.

The status of exon skipping as a therapeutic approach to duchenne muscular dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is associated with mutations in the dystrophin gene that disrupt the open reading frame whereas the milder Becker's form is associated with mutations which leave an in-frame mRNA transcript that can be translated into a protein that includes the N- and C- terminal functional domains. It has been shown that by excluding specific exons at, or adjacent to, frame-shifting mutations, open reading frame can be restored to an out-of-frame mRNA, leading to the production of a partially functional Becker-like dystrophin protein. Such targeted exclusion can be achieved by administration of oligonucleotides that are complementary to sequences that are crucial to normal splicing of the exon into the transcript. This principle has been validated in mouse and canine models of DMD with a number of variants of oligonucleotide analogue chemistries and by transduction with adeno-associated virus (AAV)-small nuclear RNA (snRNA) reagents encoding the antisense sequence. Two different oligonucleotide agents are now being investigated in human trials for splicing out of exon 51 with some early indications of success at the biochemical level.

Local restoration of dystrophin expression with the morpholino oligomer AVI-4658 in Duchenne muscular dystrophy: a single-blind, placebo-controlled, dose-escalation, proof-of-concept study

BACKGROUND

Mutations that disrupt the open reading frame and prevent full translation of DMD, the gene that encodes dystrophin, underlie the fatal X-linked disease Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Oligonucleotides targeted to splicing elements (splice switching oligonucleotides) in DMD pre-mRNA can lead to exon skipping, restoration of the open reading frame, and the production of functional dystrophin in vitro and in vivo, which could benefit patients with this disorder.

METHODS

We did a single-blind, placebo-controlled, dose-escalation study in patients with DMD recruited nationally, to assess the safety and biochemical efficacy of an intramuscular morpholino splice-switching oligonucleotide (AVI-4658) that skips exon 51 in dystrophin mRNA. Seven patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy with deletions in the open reading frame of DMD that are responsive to exon 51 skipping were selected on the basis of the preservation of their extensor digitorum brevis (EDB) muscle seen on MRI and the response of cultured fibroblasts from a skin biopsy to AVI-4658. AVI-4658 was injected into the EDB muscle; the contralateral muscle received saline. Muscles were biopsied between 3 and 4 weeks after injection. The primary endpoint was the safety of AVI-4658 and the secondary endpoint was its biochemical efficacy. This trial is registered, number NCT00159250.

FINDINGS

Two patients received 0.09 mg AVI-4658 in 900 microL (0.9%) saline and five patients received 0.9 mg AVI-4658 in 900 microL saline. No adverse events related to AVI-4658 administration were reported. Intramuscular injection of the higher-dose of AVI-4658 resulted in increased dystrophin expression in all treated EDB muscles, although the results of the immunostaining of EDB-treated muscle for dystrophin were not uniform. In the areas of the immunostained sections that were adjacent to the needle track through which AVI-4658 was given, 44-79% of myofibres had increased expression of dystrophin. In randomly chosen sections of treated EDB muscles, the mean intensity of dystrophin staining ranged from 22% to 32% of the mean intensity of dystrophin in healthy control muscles (mean 26.4%), and the mean intensity was 17% (range 11-21%) greater than the intensity in the contralateral saline-treated muscle (one-sample paired t test p=0.002). In the dystrophin-positive fibres, the intensity of dystrophin staining was up to 42% of that in healthy muscle. We showed expression of dystrophin at the expected molecular weight in the AVI-4658-treated muscle by immunoblot.

INTERPRETATION

Intramuscular AVI-4658 was safe and induced the expression of dystrophin locally within treated muscles. This proof-of-concept study has led to an ongoing systemic clinical trial of AVI-4658 in patients with DMD.

FUNDING

UK Department of Health.

Exon-skipping therapy for Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a lethal muscle disorder caused by mutations in the DMD gene for which no mutation-targeted therapy has been available thus far. However, exon-skipping mediated by antisense oligonucleotides (AOs), which are short single-strand DNAs, has considerable potential for DMD therapy, and clinical trials in DMD patients are currently underway. This exon-skipping therapy changes an out-of-frame mutation into an in-frame mutation, aiming at conversion of a severe DMD phenotype into a mild phenotype by restoration of truncated dystrophin expression. Recently, stable and less-toxic AOs have been developed, and their higher efficacy was confirmed in mice and dog models of DMD. In this review, we briefly summarize the genetic basis of DMD and the potential and perspectives of exon skipping as a promising therapy for this disease.

Genetic treatments in muscular dystrophies

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The search for a cure for Duchenne muscular dystrophy and other muscular dystrophies is progressing rapidly despite significant challenges posed by some genes and the complexity of targeting all skeletal muscles. This review focuses on three areas in which experimental clinical studies are in progress.

RECENT FINDINGS

Two Phase I/IIa gene-therapy trials using adeno-associated viral vectors have recently started, one in limb-girdle muscular dystrophy and one in Duchenne muscular dystrophy. They will assess the safety of the intramuscular administration of the relevant adeno-associated viral vectors, and local efficacy. Two more Phase I/IIa studies are underway in Duchenne muscular dystrophy, focused on the intramuscular administration of antisense oligonucleotides to induce exon skipping. A third study is evaluating efficacy and tolerability of a drug which induces read-through of stop codons in Duchenne muscular dystrophy patients carrying nonsense mutations.

SUMMARY

These studies should provide proof of principle of these experimental approaches in humans. It is likely that further refinement will be required before extending their use to the wider community of patients with muscular dystrophy. In the meantime it is important to prepare accurate registries of molecularly characterized patients to facilitate their recruitment in future studies.

Comparative analysis of antisense oligonucleotide sequences for targeted skipping of exon 51 during dystrophin pre-mRNA splicing in human muscle

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene that result in the absence of functional protein. In the majority of cases these are out-of-frame deletions that disrupt the reading frame. Several attempts have been made to restore the dystrophin mRNA reading frame by modulation of pre-mRNA splicing with antisense oligonucleotides (AOs), demonstrating success in cultured cells, muscle explants, and animal models. We are preparing for a phase I/IIa clinical trial aimed at assessing the safety and effect of locally administered AOs designed to inhibit inclusion of exon 51 into the mature mRNA by the splicing machinery, a process known as exon skipping. Here, we describe a series of systematic experiments to validate the sequence and chemistry of the exon 51 AO reagent selected to go forward into the clinical trial planned in the United Kingdom. Eight specific AO sequences targeting exon 51 were tested in two different chemical forms and in three different preclinical models: cultured human muscle cells and explants (wild type and DMD), and local in vivo administration in transgenic mice harboring the entire human DMD locus. Data have been validated independently in the different model systems used, and the studies describe a rational collaborative path for the preclinical selection of AOs for evaluation in future clinical trials.

Dystrophin levels as low as 30% are sufficient to avoid muscular dystrophy in the human

Mutations in the dystrophin gene give rise to Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies (DMD and BMD), in which both skeletal and cardiac muscles are affected, but also to X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy (XLDC), a condition characterised by exclusive cardiac involvement. XLDC patients with mutations at the 5' end of the gene typically have a cardiac specific severe transcriptional pathology, with absent dystrophin in the heart, while reduced levels of virtually normal dystrophin transcript and protein are present in the skeletal muscle. We now report the identification of a new XLDC family and the detailed characterisation of the levels of dystrophin protein present in skeletal muscle of this family, and of three previously studied XLDC families. We found that dystrophin levels comprised between 29% and 57% were sufficient to avoid muscle weakness in these XLDC families. This information will be of help for the development of therapeutic approaches aimed at restoring dystrophin levels sufficient to prevent the muscle pathology in DMD.

Potential of oligonucleotide-mediated exon-skipping therapy for Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Many of the mutations associated with Duchenne muscular dystrophy can potentially be rescued by exon-skipping therapy, targeting selected exons of prespliced mRNA for the dystrophin gene with antisense oligonucleotides, thereby restoring reading frames. The recent development of antisense oligonucleotides with higher stability and lower toxicity, such as morpholinos, has made it possible to restore dystrophin efficiently in dystrophic mice in vivo with no obvious side effects. There seems little doubt that such exon-skipping therapy is destined to proceed to the clinical application stage in patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy. One of the remaining issues to be addressed is the skipping of multiple exons because such multi-exon skipping therapy could expand the potential patient target population to include 80% of those with duplication mutations and 90% of those with deletion mutations. At present, this multi-exon skipping strategy is being investigated in dystrophic dogs as well as dystrophic mice. There are several challenges that still need to be overcome, including the low uptake of antisense oligonucleotides into the heart and the need to design efficient, nontoxic, cost-effective oligonucleotides. This review summarizes recent progress in exon-skipping therapy and discusses future perspectives with regard to human clinical trials.

[Family study allows more optimistic prognosis and genetic counselling in a child with a deletion of exons 50-51 of the dystrophin gene]

INTRODUCTION

In frame deletions of exons encoding the central rod domain of dystrophin have been associated with a highly variable phenotype, including asymptomatic individuals. The lack of family history impairs accurate genetic counselling.

OBSERVATION

We report on a 4-year-old child suffering from transient episodes of limping at the age of 2 and several episodes of fall since the age of 3. Clinical examination did not show muscle weakness. CPK levels were increased (1300 UI). EMG was normal. Muscle histology showed a rhabdomyolysis without features of muscular dystrophy. Immunolabelling for dystrophin, merosin and dysferlin were normal. Western blot analysis of muscular proteins showed reduced-size dystrophin bands and a slightly reduced intensity for dystrophin, alpha and gamma-sarcoglycan. Multiplex PCR of the dystrophin gene showed an in-frame deletion of exons 50-51, predicted to be associated to a Becker type of dystrophinopathy. Intragenic markers and quantitative PCR suggested maternal inheritance. This was confirmed by testing the maternal grand-parents, revealing that the asymptomatic 69-year-old grand father was a carrier. Three additional healthy males, whose ages ranged from 28 to 55 years and who were asymptomatic, also carried the mutation. The proband became spontaneously asymptomatic and cardiac echography was normal. In light of these data, genetic counselling was more reassuring and the mutation carrier maternal aunt, who was pregnant, decided to continue the pregnancy.

CONCLUSION

This case report emphasizes the importance of family molecular analysis, especially in males from the maternal lineage, for genetic counselling of dystrophinopathies associated to atypical features or to an isolate increase of muscular enzymes level in a young boy with no positive family history.

Entries in the Leiden Duchenne muscular dystrophy mutation database: an overview of mutation types and paradoxical cases that confirm the reading-frame rule

The severe Duchenne and milder Becker muscular dystrophy are both caused by mutations in the DMD gene. This gene codes for dystrophin, a protein important for maintaining the stability of muscle-fiber membranes. In 1988, Monaco and colleagues postulated an explanation for the phenotypic difference between Duchenne and Becker patients in the reading-frame rule: In Duchenne patients, mutations induce a shift in the reading frame leading to prematurely truncated, dysfunctional dystrophins. In Becker patients, in-frame mutations allow the synthesis of internally deleted, but largely functional dystrophins. Currently, over 4700 mutations have been reported in the Leiden DMD mutation database, of which 91% are in agreement with this rule. In this study we provide an update of the mutational variability in the DMD gene, particularly focusing on genotype-phenotype correlations and mutations that appear to be exceptions to the reading-frame rule.

Therapeutic restoration of dystrophin expression in Duchenne muscular dystrophy

It is 20 years since the discovery of the genetic defect causing Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). This X-linked progressive and fatal myopathy is due to the absence of a functional version of a critical sub-sarcolemmal protein called dystrophin that appears to act both as a structural and as a signalling molecule in the muscle fibre. A number of molecular approaches have been developed to restore the expression of dystrophin in DMD patients. Pre-clinical experiments have demonstrated the potential of delivery of recombinant versions of the DMD gene using viral or non-viral vectors and importantly several of these systems are compatible with vascular delivery, an essential feature as all muscles are affected in this condition. Other studies have shown that antisense oligonucleotides can modify the splicing of the primary transcript to provide an internally truncated but still functional protein. Alternatively, in approximately 10-20% of cases it is possible to chemically persuade the translational machinery to read-through a pre-mature stop codon. The pre-clinical results of the last 4 years have encouraged the development of clinical trials for all of the above.

Proximal dystrophin gene deletions and protein alterations in becker muscular dystrophy

Alterations in production of cytoskeletal protein dystrophin caused by in-frame gene mutations lead to the Becker muscular dystrophy. In this study we analyzed genotype-phenotype correlation in a group of Becker muscular dystrophy patients with deletions affecting the proximal part of dystrophin gene, encompassing exons 3-13. Four patients with deletions affecting N terminal dystrophin domain had early onset and faster progression of the disease, while three patients with deletions in the proximal part of dystrophin's rod domain had a more benign disease course. Our study suggests that proximal gene deletions in Becker muscular dystrophy have various phenotypic effects depending on the affected domain of protein dystrophin.

Redirecting Splicing to Address Dystrophin Mutations: Molecular By-pass Surgery

Mutations in the dystrophin gene that prevent synthesis of a functional protein lead to Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), the most common serious childhood muscular dystrophy. The major isoform is produced in skeletal muscle and the size of the dystrophin gene and complexity of expression have posed great challenges to the development of a therapy for DMD. Considerable progress has been made in the areas of gene and cell replacement, yet it appears that any potential therapy for DMD is still some years away. Other approaches are being considered, and one that has generated substantial interest over the last few years is induced exon skipping. Antisense oligonucleotides have been used to block abnormal splice sites and force pre-mRNA processing back to the normal patterns. This approach is re-interpreted to address the more common dystrophin mutations, where normal splice sites are targeted to induce abnormal splicing, resulting in specific exon exclusion. Selected exon removal during processing of the dystrophin pre-mRNA can by-pass nonsense mutations or restore a disrupted reading frame arising from genomic deletions or duplications. Attributes of the dystrophin gene that have hampered gene replacement therapy may be regarded as positive features for induced exon skipping, which may be regarded as a form of by-pass surgery at the molecular level. In humans, antisense oligonucleotides have been more generally applied to down-regulate specific gene expression, for the treatment of acquired conditions such as malignancies and viral infections. From interesting in vitro experiments several years ago, the dystrophin exon-skipping field has progressed to the stage of planning for clinical trials.

Absence of neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) as a pathological marker for the diagnosis of Becker muscular dystrophy with rod domain deletions

Immunohistochemistry using antibodies to dystrophin is the pathological basis for the diagnosis of Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD and BMD). While the sarcolemma of DMD muscle is negative, BMD muscle generally shows variable labelling because of the translation of a partially functional dystrophin that is localized to the sarcolemma. In rare cases, however, this labelling is equivocal and similar to that observed in controls making diagnosis difficult. We report here that in such instances immunolabelling with antibodies to the neuronal form of nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) can be useful in suspecting a dystrophinopathy with a mutation in the 'hot-spot' rod domain and help to direct molecular analysis. nNOS localizes to the sarcolemma of mature muscle fibres via several components of the dystrophin-associated protein complex (DAPC) including dystrophin but sarcolemmal nNOS is lost when dystrophin levels are very low or absent because of deletions in critical regions of the rod domain. We report three cases who presented with only mild or no muscle weakness but had elevated serum creatine kinase activity and dystrophin immunolabelling indistinguishable from normal, making a pathological diagnosis difficult. All three cases had a complete absence of sarcolemmal nNOS and were subsequently found to have an in-frame deletion in the common rod domain exons (in these cases 48, 45-51, 47-53) compatible with a BMD. In addition, we observed that nNOS appears to be developmentally regulated with the antibody used and was often absent from the sarcolemma of immature fibres. These findings demonstrate the value of including antibodies to nNOS in routine immunohistochemical studies and that absence of nNOS can be a more sensitive marker than up-regulation of utrophin for diagnosis of BMD. Immaturity of fibres, however, needs to be taken into account, especially in neonates.

Dystrophin and mutations: one gene, several proteins, multiple phenotypes

A large and complex gene on the X chromosome encodes dystrophin. Many mutations have been described in this gene, most of which affect the expression of the muscle isoform, the best-known protein product of this locus. These mutations result in the Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies (DMD and BMD). However, there are several other tissue specific isoforms of dystrophin, some exclusively or predominantly expressed in the brain or the retina. Mutations affecting the correct expression of these tissue-specific isoforms have been associated with the CNS involvement common in DMD. Rare mutations also account for the allelic disorder X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy, in which dystrophin expression or function is affected mostly or exclusively in the heart. Genotype definition of the dystrophin gene in patients with dystrophinopathies has taught us much about functionally important domains of the protein itself and has provided insights into several regulatory mechanisms governing the gene expression profile. Here, we focus on current understanding of the genotype-phenotype relation for mutations in the dystrophin gene and their implications for gene functions.

X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy and the dystrophin gene

X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy (XLDC) represents a well known genetic disease, allelic to Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies and caused by dystrophin gene mutations. XLDC is a rare disease and only few families have been fully characterised. In several of them, the dystrophin mutations show a different pattern of expression in cardiac compared to skeletal muscle. In the families with the most severe cardiac phenotype, the cardiac muscle is usually unable to produce dystrophin, due to a specific effect that the mutation(s) have on the gene transcription in this tissue. The skeletal muscle escapes the dystrophic changes by maintaining dystrophin synthesis via exon skipping or alternative splicing that the heart is not able to put in place. In this paper we have reviewed the families with X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy reported so far; in addition we provided novel transcription data on two families we previously described. The aim of this review is to attempt a genotype-phenotype correlation and speculate on common pathogenic mechanisms underlying this disease.