Effect of cardiac graft rejection on semilunar valve function: implications for heart valve transplantation

Partial Heart Transplantation: Early Experience With Pediatric Heart Valve Replacements That Grow

Heart valve replacement in children is fraught with long-term morbidity and mortality rates, largely because conventional implants lack the capacity to grow with the child. Partial heart transplantation presents a potential solution by transplanting only specific segments of a donor heart, thereby providing a living and growing heart valve implant. This approach harnesses the full spectrum of cardiac tissues, which, when freshly procured and supported by immunosuppression, can integrate as functional and potentially growth-capable tissue. This state-of-the-art review discusses the history and development of partial heart transplantation, its indications, recent clinical experiences, regulation, and future directions.

Indications and Practical Considerations for Partial Heart Transplantation

Partial heart transplantation is a new approach to deliver growing heart valve substitutes for children. The rationale for partial heart transplantation is that the valves contained in heart transplants grow. Partial heart transplants differ from heart transplants because only the part of the heart containing the necessary valve is transplanted, while the native ventricles are preserved. Preserving the native ventricles eliminates the risk of graft ventricular dysfunction and allows for utilization of donor hearts with ventricular dysfunction. Here we outline practical considerations for partial heart transplantation, including indications, sources for donor hearts, graft procurement, graft preservation, implantation, recipient immunosuppression, and reimbursement. This invited expert review is intended to help clinical teams implement partial heart transplantation.

Surgical Protocol for Partial Heart Transplantation in Growing Piglets

Partial heart transplantation is a new approach to deliver growing heart valve implants. Partial heart transplants differ from heart transplants because only the part of the heart containing the necessary heart valve is transplanted. This allows partial heart transplants to grow, similar to the valves in heart transplants. However, the transplant biology of partial heart transplantation remains unexplored. This is a critical barrier to progress of the field. Without knowledge about the specific transplant biology of partial heart transplantation, children with partial heart transplants are empirically treated like children with heart transplants because the valves in heart transplants are known to grow. In order to progress the field, an animal model for partial heart transplantation is necessary. Here, we contribute our surgical protocol for partial heart transplantation in growing piglets. All aspects of partial heart transplantation, including the donor procedure, the recipient procedure, and recipient perioperative care are described in detail. There are important nuances in the conduct of virtually all aspects of open heart surgery that differs in piglets from humans. Our surgical protocol, which is based on our experience with 34 piglets, will allow other investigators to leverage our experience to seek fundamental knowledge about the nature of partial heart transplants. This is significant because the partial heart transplant model in piglets is complex and very resource intensive.

Partial heart transplantation: Growing heart valve implants for children

Heart valves serve a vital hemodynamic function to ensure unidirectional blood flow. Additionally, native heart valves serve biological functions such as growth and self-repair. Heart valve implants mimic the hemodynamic function of native heart valves, but are unable to fulfill their biological functions. We developed partial heart transplantation to deliver heart valve implants that fulfill all functions of native heart valves. This is particularly advantageous for children, who require growing heart valve implants. This invited review outlines the past, present and future of partial heart transplantation.

Partial Heart Transplant in a Neonate With Irreparable Truncal Valve Dysfunction

Importance

The treatment of neonates with irreparable heart valve dysfunction remains an unsolved problem because there are no heart valve implants that grow. Therefore, neonates with heart valve implants are committed to recurrent implant exchanges until an adult-sized valve can fit.

Objective

To deliver the first heart valve implant that grows.

Design, Setting, and Participants

Case report from a pediatric referral center, with follow-up for more than 1 year. Participants were a recipient neonate with persistent truncus arteriosus and irreparable truncal valve dysfunction and a donor neonate with hypoxic-ischemic brain injury.

Intervention

First-in-human transplant of the part of the heart containing the aortic and pulmonary valves.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Transplanted valve growth and hemodynamic function.

Results

Echocardiography demonstrated adaptive growth and excellent hemodynamic function of the partial heart transplant valves.

Conclusions and Relevance

In this child, partial heart transplant delivered growing heart valve implants with a good outcome at age 1 year. Partial heart transplants may improve the treatment of neonates with irreparable heart valve dysfunction.

Donor supply for partial heart transplantation in the United States

BACKGROUND

Congenital heart disease (CHD) is the most common cause of birth defects worldwide. Valvular defects are a common form of CHDs, and, at this time, treatment options for children with unrepairable valve disease are limited. Issues with anticoagulation, sizing, and lack of growth in valve replacement options can lead to high mortality rates and incidence of reoperations. Partial heart transplantation, or transplantation of fresh valve allografts, has recently been described as a strategy to provide a durable and non-thrombogenic alternative to conventional prostheses and provide growth potential in pediatric patients.

METHODS

The United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) database was queried to analyze the number of pediatric donor hearts that were not recovered but had viable valves (n = 3565) between January 2010 and September 2021. Recoverable valves were grouped by donor age: infants (age < 1 year), toddlers (age ≥1 and <3 years), and children (age ≥3 and <18 years). Demographic characteristics of donors were analyzed between age groups.

RESULTS

Infants, toddlers, and children had a total of 344, 465, and 2756 hearts with recoverable valves, respectively, over the study period, representing an average of 29, 39, and 230 hearts with recoverable valves per year.

CONCLUSION

The results of our study identify the minimum donor supply for partial heart transplantation. The actual number is likely higher because it includes hearts not entered in the UNOS database and domino transplants from orthotopic heart transplant recipients. Partial heart transplantation is logistically feasible as there are recoverable valves available for all age groups, fulfilling a clinical need in pediatric patients with unrepairable valve disease.

Partial Heart Transplantation in Adult Cardiac Surgery

Many young adults require heart valve replacements. Current options for valve replacement in adults include mechanical valves, bioprosthetic valves, or the Ross procedure. Of these, mechanical and bioprosthetic valves are the most common options, although mechanical valve usage predominates in younger adults due to durability, while bioprosthetic valve usage predominates in older adults. Partial heart transplantation is a new method of valvular replacement that can deliver durable and self-repairing valves and allow adult patients freedom from anticoagulation therapy. This procedure involves transplantation of donor heart valves only, permitting expanded utilization of donor hearts as compared with orthotopic heart transplantation. In this review, we discuss the potential benefits of this procedure in adults who elect against the anticoagulation regimen required of mechanical valve replacements, although it has not yet been clinically established. Partial heart transplantation is a promising new therapy for the treatment of pediatric valvular dysfunction. This is a novel technique in the adult population with potential utility for valve replacement in young patients for whom anticoagulation therapy is problematic, such as women who wish to become pregnant, patients with bleeding disorders, and patients with active lifestyles.

Partial heart transplantation can ameliorate donor organ utilization

BACKGROUND

The treatment of babies with unrepairable heart valve dysfunction remains an unsolved problem because there are no growing heart valve implants. However, orthotopic heart transplants are known to grow with recipients.

AIM

Partial heart transplantation is a new approach to delivering growing heart valve implants, which involves transplantation of the part of the heart containing the valves only. In this review, we discuss the benefits of this procedure in children with unrepairable valve dysfunction.

CONCLUSION

Partial heart transplantation can be performed using donor hearts with poor ventricular function and slow progression to donation after cardiac death. This should ameliorate donor heart utilization and avoid both primary orthotopic heart transplantation in children with unrepairable heart valve dysfunction and progression of these children to end-stage heart failure.