Installing Guest Molecules at Specific Sites within Scaffold Protein Crystals

Characterization of Guest DNA Transport and Adsorption within Host Porous Protein Crystals

Nucleic acid transport through protein-based pores is a well-characterized phenomenon due in part to advancements in nanopore sequencing. A less studied area is nucleic acid transport through extended protein-based channels, where the additional surface area and increased contact time allow for the study of prolonged binding interactions. Porous protein crystals composed of "CJ", a putative polyisoprenoid-binding protein from Campylobacter jejuni, represent a favorable, highly ordered material for studying DNA transport and binding/unbinding along protein-based channels. These crystals adopt a hexagonal prism habit and contain a densely packed hexagonal array of 13 nm diameter axial nanopores that run from the top to the bottom of the crystal. After cross-linking, the crystals are easily manipulated for experimentation. An adsorption isotherm between host crystals and guest double-stranded 8 base pair DNA (8mer) revealed a high equilibrium adsorption constant of 206 ± 30 L/g. Fluorescence confocal microscopy tracked the loading of guest DNA into host crystals predominately along the major axial crystal nanopores. Four different computational models based on the finite volume (FV) method were assessed to model the transport process for guest 8mer and 15mer dsDNA loading into empty host crystals in terms of fundamental parameters, such as the intrapore diffusion constant. Fitting the models to the data revealed that the most basic FV model sufficed to describe the observed loading behavior, characterized by a single effective diffusion coefficient. Leveraging Fick's first law, we more directly fit a numerical range for the observed intrapore diffusion coefficient as a function of time, position within the crystal, and relative guest concentration. This new transport analysis strategy was applied to both out-of-equilibrium loading and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) experiments. The intrapore diffusion constants are comparable between 8mer and 15mer dsDNA and were found to be 2 orders of magnitude faster for DNA loading into empty crystals than that observed in FRAP experiments, which averaged (10 ± 4) × 10-11 cm2/s.

Tuning Chemical DNA Ligation within DNA Crystals and Protein-DNA Cocrystals

Biomolecular crystals can serve as materials for a plethora of applications including precise guest entrapment. However, as grown, biomolecular crystals are fragile in solutions other than their growth conditions. For crystals to achieve their full potential as hosts for other molecules, crystals can be made stronger with bioconjugation. Building on our previous work using carbodiimide 1-ethyl-3-(3-(dimethylamino)propyl)carbodiimide (EDC) for chemical ligation, here, we investigate DNA junction architecture through sticky base overhang lengths and the role of scaffold proteins in cross-linking within two classes of biomolecular crystals: cocrystals of DNA-binding proteins and pure DNA crystals. Both crystal classes contain DNA junctions where DNA strands stack up end-to-end. Ligation yields were studied as a function of sticky base overhang length and terminal phosphorylation status. The best ligation performance for both crystal classes was achieved with longer sticky overhangs and terminal 3'phosphates. Notably, EDC chemical ligation was achieved in crystals with pore sizes too small for intracrystal transport of ligase enzyme. Postassembly cross-linking produced dramatic stability improvements for both DNA crystals and cocrystals in water and blood serum. The results presented may help crystals containing DNA achieve broader application utility, including as structural biology scaffolds.

High-throughput structure determination of an intrinsically disordered protein using cell-free protein crystallization

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) play a crucial role in various biological phenomena, dynamically changing their conformations in response to external environmental cues. To gain a deeper understanding of these proteins, it is essential to identify the determinants that fix their structures at the atomic level. Here, we developed a pipeline for rapid crystal structure analysis of IDP using a cell-free protein crystallization (CFPC) method. Through this approach, we successfully demonstrated the determination of the structure of an IDP to uncover the key determinants that stabilize its conformation. Specifically, we focused on the 11-residue fragment of c-Myc, which forms an α-helix through dimerization with a binding partner protein. This fragment was strategically recombined with an in-cell crystallizing protein and was expressed in a cell-free system. The resulting crystal structures of the c-Myc fragment were successfully determined at a resolution of 1.92 Å and we confirmed that they are identical to the structures of the complex with the native binding partner protein. This indicates that the environment of the scaffold crystal can fix the structure of c-Myc. Significantly, these crystals were obtained directly from a small reaction mixture (30 µL) incubated for only 72 h. Analysis of eight crystal structures derived from 22 mutants revealed two hydrophobic residues as the key determinants responsible for stabilizing the α-helical structure. These findings underscore the power of our CFPC screening method as a valuable tool for determining the structures of challenging target proteins and elucidating the essential molecular interactions that govern their stability.

Porous protein crystals: synthesis and applications

Large-pore protein crystals (LPCs) are an emerging class of biomaterials. The inherent diversity of proteins translates to a diversity of crystal lattice structures, many of which display large pores and solvent channels. These pores can, in turn, be functionalized via directed evolution and rational redesign based on the known crystal structures. LPCs possess extremely high solvent content, as well as extremely high surface area to volume ratios. Because of these characteristics, LPCs continue to be explored in diverse applications including catalysis, targeted therapeutic delivery, templating of nanostructures, structural biology. This Feature review article will describe several of the existing platforms in detail, with particular focus on LPC synthesis approaches and reported applications.

Diverse crystalline protein scaffolds through metal-dependent polymorphism

As protein crystals are increasingly finding diverse applications as scaffolds, controlled crystal polymorphism presents a facile strategy to form crystalline assemblies with controllable porosity with minimal to no protein engineering. Polymorphs of consensus tetratricopeptide repeat proteins with varying porosity were obtained through co-crystallization with metal salts, exploiting the innate metal ion geometric requirements. A single structurally exposed negative amino acid cluster was responsible for metal coordination, despite the abundance of negatively charged residues. Density functional theory calculations showed that while most of the crystals were the most thermodynamically stable assemblies, some were kinetically trapped states. Thus, crystalline porosity diversity is achieved and controlled with metal coordination, opening a new scope in the application of proteins as biocompatible protein-metal-organic frameworks (POFs). In addition, metal-dependent polymorphic crystals allow direct comparison of metal coordination preferences.

Ligand Presentation Inside Protein Crystal Nanopores: Tunable Interfacial Adhesion Noncovalently Modulates Cell Attachment

Protein crystals with sufficiently large solvent pores can non-covalently adsorb polymers in the pores. In principle, if these polymers contain cell adhesion ligands, the polymer-laden crystals could present ligands to cells with tunable adhesion strength. Moreover, porous protein crystals can store an internal ligand reservoir, so that the surface can be replenished. In this study, we demonstrate that poly(ethylene glycol) terminated with a cyclic cell adhesion ligand peptide (PEG-RGD) can be loaded into porous protein crystals by diffusion. Through atomic force microscopy (AFM), force-distance correlations of the mechanical interactions between activated AFM tips and protein crystals were precisely measured. The activation of AFM tips allows the tips to interact with PEG-RGD that was pre-loaded in the protein crystal nanopores, mimicking how a cell might attach to and pull on the ligand through integrin receptors. The AFM experiments also simultaneously reveal the detailed morphology of the buffer-immersed nanoporous protein crystal surface. We also show that porous protein crystals (without and with loaded PEG-RGD) serve as suitable substrates for attachment and spreading of adipose-derived stem cells. This strategy can be used to design surfaces that non-covalently present multiple different ligands to cells with tunable adhesive strength for each ligand, and with an internal reservoir to replenish the precisely defined crystalline surface.

Displaying a Protein Cage on a Protein Crystal by In-Cell Crystal Engineering

The development of solid biomaterials has rapidly progressed in recent years in applications in bionanotechnology. The immobilization of proteins, such as enzymes, within protein crystals is being used to develop solid catalysts and functionalized materials. However, an efficient method for encapsulating protein assemblies has not yet been established. This work presents a novel approach to displaying protein cages onto a crystalline protein scaffold using in-cell protein crystal engineering. The polyhedra crystal (PhC) scaffold, which displays a ferritin cage, was produced by coexpression of polyhedrin monomer (PhM) and H1-ferritin (H1-Fr) monomer in Escherichia coli. The H1-tag is derived from the H1-helix of PhM. Our technique represents a unique strategy for immobilizing protein assemblies onto in-cell protein crystals and is expected to contribute to various applications in bionanotechnology.

Engineering of an in-cell protein crystal for fastening a metastable conformation of a target miniprotein

Protein crystals can be utilized as porous scaffolds to capture exogenous molecules. Immobilization of target proteins using protein crystals is expected to facilitate X-ray structure analysis of proteins that are difficult to be crystallized. One of the advantages of scaffold-assisted structure determination is the analysis of metastable structures that are not observed in solution. However, efforts to fix target proteins within the pores of scaffold protein crystals have been limited due to the lack of strategies to control protein-protein interactions formed in the crystals. In this study, we analyze the metastable structure of the miniprotein, CLN025, which forms a β-hairpin structure in solution, using a polyhedra crystal (PhC), an in-cell protein crystal. CLN025 is successfully fixed within the PhC scaffold by replacing the original loop region. X-ray crystal structure analysis and molecular dynamics (MD) simulation reveal that CLN025 is fixed as a helical structure in a metastable state by non-covalent interactions in the scaffold crystal. These results indicate that modulation of intermolecular interactions can trap various protein conformations in the engineered PhC and provides a new strategy for scaffold-assisted structure determination.

Protein Assembly by Design

Proteins are nature's primary building blocks for the construction of sophisticated molecular machines and dynamic materials, ranging from protein complexes such as photosystem II and nitrogenase that drive biogeochemical cycles to cytoskeletal assemblies and muscle fibers for motion. Such natural systems have inspired extensive efforts in the rational design of artificial protein assemblies in the last two decades. As molecular building blocks, proteins are highly complex, in terms of both their three-dimensional structures and chemical compositions. To enable control over the self-assembly of such complex molecules, scientists have devised many creative strategies by combining tools and principles of experimental and computational biophysics, supramolecular chemistry, inorganic chemistry, materials science, and polymer chemistry, among others. Owing to these innovative strategies, what started as a purely structure-building exercise two decades ago has, in short order, led to artificial protein assemblies with unprecedented structures and functions and protein-based materials with unusual properties. Our goal in this review is to give an overview of this exciting and highly interdisciplinary area of research, first outlining the design strategies and tools that have been devised for controlling protein self-assembly, then describing the diverse structures of artificial protein assemblies, and finally highlighting the emergent properties and functions of these assemblies.

Measuring interactions of DNA with nanoporous protein crystals by atomic force microscopy

Crosslinked porous protein crystals are a new biomaterial that can be engineered to encapsulate, stabilize, and organize guest molecules, nanoparticles, and biological moieties. In this study, for the first time, the combined interactions of DNA strands with porous protein crystals are quantitatively measured by high-resolution atomic force microscopy (AFM) and chemical force microscopy. The surface structure of protein crystals with unusually large pores was observed in liquid via high-resolution AFM. Force-distance (F-D) curves were also obtained using AFM tips modified to present or capture DNA. The modification of AFM tips allowed the tips to covalently bind DNA that was pre-loaded in the protein crystal nanopores. The modified tips enabled the interactions of DNA molecules with protein crystals to be quantitatively studied while revealing the morphology of the buffer-immersed protein crystal surface in detail, thereby preserving the structure and properties of protein crystals that could be disrupted or destroyed by drying. The hexagonal space group was manifest at the crystal surface, as were the strong interactions between DNA and the porous protein crystals in question. In sum, this study furthered our understanding of how a new protein-based biomaterial can be used to bind guest DNA assemblies.

Application of Crystalline Matrices for the Structural Determination of Organic Molecules

While single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SC-XRD) is one of the most powerful structural determination techniques for organic molecules, the requirement of obtaining a suitable crystal for analysis limits its applicability, particularly for liquids and amorphous solids. The emergent use of preformed porous crystalline matrices that can absorb organic compounds and stabilize them via host-guest interactions for observation via SC-XRD offers a way to overcome this hindrance. A topical and current discussion of SC-XRD in organic chemistry and the use of preformed matrices for the in crystallo analysis of organic compounds, with a particular focus on the absolute structure determination of chiral molecules, is presented. Preformed crystalline matrices that are covered include metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) as used in the crystalline sponge method, metal-organic polyhedra (MOPs, coordination cages), porous organic materials (POMs)/porous organic molecular crystals (POMCs), and biological scaffolds. An outlook and perspective on the current technology and on its future directions is provided.

Development of imaging scaffolds for cryo-electron microscopy

Following recent hardware and software developments, single particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) has become one of the most popular structural biology tools. Many targets, such as viruses, large protein complexes and oligomeric membrane proteins, have been resolved to atomic resolution using single-particle cryo-EM, which relies on the accurate assignment of particle location and orientation from intrinsically noisy projection images. The same image processing procedures are more challenging for smaller proteins due to their lower signal-to-noise ratios. Consequently, though most cellular proteins are less than 50kDa, so far it has been possible to solve cryo-EM structures near that size range for only a few favorable cases. Here we highlight some of the challenges and recent efforts to break through this lower size limit by engineering large scaffolds to rigidly display multiple small proteins for imaging. Future design efforts are noted.

Porous crystals as scaffolds for structural biology

Molecular scaffolds provide routes to otherwise inaccessible organized states of matter. Scaffolds that are crystalline can be observed in atomic detail using diffraction, along with any guest molecules that have adopted coherent structures therein. This approach, scaffold-assisted structure determination, is not yet routine. However, with varying degrees of guest immobilization, porous crystal scaffolds have recently been decorated with guest molecules. Herein we analyze recent milestones, compare the relative advantages and challenges of different types of scaffold crystals, and weigh the merits of diverse guest installation strategies.

Structural analysis of biological targets by host:guest crystal lattice engineering

To overcome the laborious identification of crystallisation conditions for protein X-ray crystallography, we developed a method where the examined protein is immobilised as a guest molecule in a universal host lattice. We applied crystal engineering to create a generic crystalline host lattice under reproducible, predefined conditions and analysed the structures of target guest molecules of different size, namely two 15-mer peptides and green fluorescent protein (sfGFP). A fusion protein with an N-terminal endo-α-N-acetylgalactosaminidase (EngBF) domain and a C-terminal designed ankyrin repeat protein (DARPin) domain establishes the crystal lattice. The target is recruited into the host lattice, always in the same crystal form, through binding to the DARPin. The target structures can be determined rapidly from difference Fourier maps, whose quality depends on the size of the target and the orientation of the DARPin.

Porous protein crystals as scaffolds for enzyme immobilization

Porous protein crystals provide a template for binding and organizing guest macromolecules. Peroxidase, oxidase, and reductase enzymes immobilized in protein crystals retained activity in single-crystal and bulk assay formats. Several binding strategies, including metal affinity and physical entrapment, were employed to encourage enzyme adsorption into the protein crystals and to retain the enzymes for multiple recycles. Immobilized enzymes had lower activity compared to free enzyme in solution, in part due to diffusion limitations of substrate within the crystal pores. However, the immobilized enzymes were long-term stable and showed increased thermal tolerance. The potential applications of enzyme-laden crystals as sensing devices, delivery capsules, and microreactors motivate future development of this technology.

Protein encapsulation in the hollow space of hemocyanin crystals containing a covalently conjugated ligand

Encapsulation of guest molecules into the vacant space of biomacromolecular crystals has been utilized for various purposes including functioning as a protein container to protect against physical stress and structural determination of the guest. Todarodes pacificus hemocyanin (TpHc) is a hollow cylindrical decameric protein complex with an inner space 110 Å in diameter and 160 Å in height. In the crystal, TpHc forms a straw-like bundle and contains one reactive Cys (Cys3246) in the inner domain of each protomer. Here, we conjugated biotin onto Cys3246 of TpHc followed by incubation with streptavidin. The streptavidin was immobilized into the inner space of TpHc due to its interaction with biotin. Moreover, the complex containing TpHc and streptavidin was crystallized under the same conditions used for unmodified TpHc. In order to expand this methodology for a variety of proteins, we conjugated the ligand nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) chelated to a Ni²⁺ ion (Ni²⁺-NTA) to TpHc. We found that His-tagged green fluorescent protein (GFP) was encapsulated into the Ni²⁺-NTA-conjugated TpHc via the interaction between the His-tag and the Ni²⁺-NTA group. X-ray crystallography demonstrated that the crystal packing of the complex containing TpHc and GFP was identical to that of the unmodified TpHc. Our guest immobilization method is distinct from previous approaches that are dependent on diffusion of the guest into the host crystal. Thus, our findings may accelerate the development of proteinaceous crystal engineering.

Encapsulation of biomacromolecules by soaking and co-crystallization into porous protein crystals of hemocyanin

Encapsulation of guest molecules into the hollow spaces of crystals has been applied for a variety of purposes such as structure determination, separation, and catalysis of the guest. Although host-guest studies have been developed mainly in crystals of small molecules, those of biomacromolecules have recently been applied. In those reports, a huge hollow space in the protein crystal is commonly used for encapsulation of the guest. Our previous study revealed that cylindrical hemocyanins stack inside the crystal as a linear hollow structure. The diameter of the linear hollow is approximately 110 Å, which is large enough for most proteins to pass through. In the present study, we evaluated the potential of hemocyanin crystals as a host to encapsulate biomacromolecules. Confocal microscopy revealed that hemocyanin crystals encapsulate proteins of molecular mass up to 250 kDa, i.e., 27 kDa green fluorescence protein, 105 kDa allophycocyanin, 220 kDa C-phycocyanin, and 250 kDa phycoerythrin, and DNAs up to 200-bp long, whereas 440 kDa ferritin not. Further analysis revealed that hemocyanin crystals prefer a negatively charged guest rather than a positive charge to encapsulate. Moreover, a photobleaching experiment showed that the guest does not move once entrapped. This knowledge of the host-guest study using the hollow hemocyanin crystal should be of significance for further application of hollow proteinaceous crystals as a host.

Synthesis of luminescent lanthanide complexes within crosslinked protein crystal matrices

Eu(TTA)₃phen was synthesized inside of crosslinked protein crystals. And we characterized the volumetric changes quantitatively induced by DMSO.