Reply to Comments on "Rethinking the Minamata Tragedy: What Mercury Species Was Really Responsible?"

In-situ precipitation zero-valent Co on Co2VO4 to activate oxygen vacancies and enhance bimetallic ions redox for efficient detection toward Hg(II)

Despite the widespread utilization of variable valence metals in electrochemistry, it is still a formidable challenge to enhance the valence conversion efficiency to achieve excellent catalytic activity without introducing heterophase elements. Herein, the in-situ precipitation of Co particles on Co2VO4 not only enhanced the concentration of oxygen vacancies (Ov) but also generated a greater number of low-valence metals, thereby enabling efficient reduction towards Hg(II). The electroanalysis results demonstrate that the sensitivity of Co/Co2VO4 towards Hg(II) was measured at an impressive value of 1987.74 μA μM-1 cm-2, significantly surpassing previously reported results. Further research reveals that Ov acted as the main adsorption site to capture Hg(II). The redox reactions of Co2+/Co3+ and V3+/V4+ played a synergistic role in the reduction of Hg(II), accompanied by the continuous supply of electrons from zero-valent Co to expedite the valence cycle. The Co/Co2VO4/GCE presented remarkable selectivity towards Hg(II), with excellent stability, reproducibility, and anti-interference capability. The electrode also exhibited minimal sensitivity fluctuations towards Hg(II) in real water samples, underscoring its practicality for environmental applications. This study elucidates the mechanism underlying the surface redox reaction of metal oxides facilitated by zero-valent metals, providing us with new strategies for further design of efficient and practical sensors.

A novel "turn-on" fluorescent probe based on thiocarbamoyl-DHP for Hg2+ detection in water samples and living cells

In this study, two fluorescent sensing probes, dihydropyridine (DHP) derivatives (DHP-CT1 and DHP-CT2) bearing phenoxy thiocarbonyl group, have been developed for Hg2+ detection. The tandem trimerization-cyclization of methylpropiolate with ammonium acetate gave 1.4-DHP and 1,2-DHP derivatives, which were reacted with O-phenylcarbonochloridothioate to produce DHP-CT1 and DHP-CT2, respectively. DHP-CT1 exhibits superior sensitivity and selectivity of fluorescence enhancement towards Hg2+ in aqueous media. The fluorescence intensity shows a good linear relationship with the concentration of Hg2+ in the range of 0-10 µM providing the extremely low LOD of 346 nM (69.4 ppb). The fluorescence enhancement is caused by the Hg2+ promoted hydrolysis of the thioamide bond releasing the fluorescent 1,4-DHP that was confirmed by NMR and HRMS. The quantitative analysis of Hg2+ in water samples using DHP-CT1 probe was demonstrated in aqueous solution and paper-based sensing strips. Furthermore, DHP-CT1 was also applied for monitoring intracellular Hg2+ in living RAW264.7 macrophages through fluorescence cell imaging.

Molecular Fates of Organometallic Mercury in Human Brain

Mercury is ubiquitous in the environment, with rising levels due to pollution and climate change being a current global concern. Many mercury compounds are notorious for their toxicity, with the potential of organometallic mercury compounds for devastating effects on the structures and functions of the central nervous system being of particular concern. Chronic exposure of human populations to low levels of methylmercury compounds occurs through consumption of fish and other seafood, although the health consequences, if any, from this exposure remain controversial. We have used high energy resolution fluorescence detected X-ray absorption spectroscopy to determine the speciation of mercury and selenium in human brain tissue. We show that the molecular fate of mercury differs dramatically between individuals who suffered acute organometallic mercury exposure (poisoning) and individuals with chronic low-level exposure from a diet rich in marine fish. For long-term low-level methylmercury exposure from fish consumption, mercury speciation in brain tissue shows methylmercury coordinated to an aliphatic thiolate, resembling the coordination environment observed in marine fish. In marked contrast, for short-term high-level exposure, we observe the presence of biologically less available mercuric selenide deposits, confirmed by X-ray fluorescence imaging, as well as mercury(II)-bis-thiolate complexes, which may be signatures of severe poisoning in humans. These differences between low-level and high-level exposures challenge the relevance of studies involving acute exposure as a proxy for low-level chronic exposure.

Rapid, ultrasensitive, highly selective detection of toxic Hg(II) ions in seabass, swordfish and water samples

A novel fluorescent probe bearing triphenylamine, thiophene and thiosemicarbazide (TPA-TSC) was developed, and its distinct features were investigated. TPA-TSC demonstrated excellent selectivity towards Hg²⁺ ions, with a limit of detection (0.14 nM) among the lowest reported to date. It also exhibited a turn-off response by forming stable complex for a brief period (<30 s). Job plot analysis and high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) revealed that TPA-TSC bound to Hg²⁺ with a 2:1 stoichiometry in an aqueous environment, remarkably the probe successfully detected Hg²⁺ ions in seabass, swordfish and different samples of water. In all, TPA-TSC offers a promising method for accurately determining the quality of seafood and water samples polluted with Hg²⁺.

Ecological perspectives on water, food, and health security linkages: the Minamata case in Japan

Extant studies address water, food, and health security issues considerably separately and within narrow disciplinary confines. This study investigates the links among these three issues from an ecological viewpoint with a multidisciplinary approach in a modified Millennium Ecosystem Assessment framework developed by the United Nations. The modified framework includes water, food, and health security considerations as the three constituents of human well-being from an ecological (more specifically, ecosystem services) viewpoint. This study examines the links through published data associated with the Minamata incident, which was a historic and horrific methylmercury-induced water, food, and health poisoning crisis in Japan. The results show that when heavy metal pollution changes one component (marine water) of the provisioning ecosystem services, this change subsequently affects another component (seafood) of the services. This then defines the linkages among water, food, and health security as the three constituents of human well-being within the modified framework. The links can have immediate and far-reaching economic, social, legal, ethical, and justice implications within and across generations. This study provides important evidence for emerging economies that ignore the water-food-health security nexus.