In Vivo-In Vitro Correlations for the Assessment of Cadmium Bioavailability in Vegetables

Health risk assessment of dietary cadmium exposure based on cadmium bioavailability in food: Opportunities and challenges

Long-term exposure to Cd through contaminated food can lead to multiple adverse health effects on humans. Although previous studies have covered global food Cd concentrations and dietary Cd exposures across different populations, there are increasing concerns regarding the adequacy of current food Cd safety standards to protect populations from adverse health effects. Moreover, incorporation of Cd relative bioavailability (Cd-RBA) in foods improves the accuracy of health risk assessment. However, factors influencing food Cd-RBA have not been systematically discussed, thereby hindering its application in risk assessment. This review aims to provide an overview of Cd contents in foods, discuss concerns regarding international food Cd concentration standards, explore factors influencing food Cd bioavailability, and highlight the opportunities and challenges in refining differences between dietary Cd intakes and body burdens. Our findings suggest that current safety standards may be insufficient to protect human health, as they primarily focus on kidney damage as the protective endpoint and fail to account for global and regional variations in food consumption patterns and temporal changes in dietary habits over time. Factors such as crop cultivars and food compositions greatly influence food Cd-RBA. To improve the accuracy of Cd health risk assessment, future studies should incorporate food Cd-RBA, sociodemographic characteristics, nutritional status, and incidental Cd exposure. This review highlights new insights into food Cd safety standards and Cd bioavailability, identifies critical knowledge gaps, and offers recommendations for refining health risk assessments. This information is essential to inform future bioavailability investigations, health risk assessment, and safety standard development.

Bioaccessibility assessment of Mn, Cu, Fe, and Cd in Henan Province wheat using physiologically based extraction

As an important crop in China, wheat serves as a crucial source of micronutrients and a potential vector for toxic elements in human diets. This study systematically collected wheat grains from 54 counties in Henan Province and conducted in vitro physiological extraction experiments to assess the bioavailability of Mn, Cu, Fe, and Cd in wheat samples. Results turned out that the bioavailability of Cd significantly decreased from the gastric to the intestinal stage. The bioavailability of Mn exhibited similar trends to Cd in the two phases, whereas Cu and Fe showed a higher bioaccessibility in the intestinal phase compared to the gastric phase. Correlation analysis revealed that higher total metal concentrations always resulted in a higher bioaccessible fraction, and the bioaccessibility of Cd was positively correlated with Mn and its bioaccessibility. Eventually, health risk to Cd from wheat consumption evaluated by Monte Carlo simulation indicated that children exhibited a heightened vulnerability to health risks in comparison to adults and risks could be decreased significantly by introducing bioaccessibility. Consequently, it is evident that refining the relationship between bioaccessibility and biotoxicity of elements could provide the methodology to accurately and efficiently assess human health risks.

Exploration of the bio-availability and the risk thresholds of cadmium and arsenic in contaminated paddy soils

Cadmium (Cd) and arsenic (As) contamination risk in paddy soils has raised global concern. In order to scientifically and objectively evaluate the bioavailability of soil Cd, As and the risk of Cd or As threshold in contaminated farmland, this study was conducted to investigate different types of extractants for their potential extraction efficiency of Cd and As. Soils from two different parent materials in Hunan, Yueyang and Yiyang, typical double-cropping rice production areas in the south of China, were used as test soils. The extraction capabilities of 10 extractants (ultrapure water, 0.1 mol/L HCl, 1.0 mol/L NH4OAc, CaCl2-DTPA, 0.01 mol/L CaCl2, 0.1 mol/L CaCl2, 0.5 mol/L NaH2PO4, 0.05 mol/L NaHCO3, 0.1 mol/L NaNO3, 0.1 mol/L HNO3), were compared for their extraction capabilities of soil available Cd and As. Meanwhile, the content of Cd and As in plants issues and grains of rice was monitored during harvest, and the Cd, As content correlation between extracted forms and rice was analyzed. The results showed that the HCl, CaCl2, HNO3, and CaCl2-DTPA solutions exhibited high extraction efficiency for Cd (42.2-88.4 %); for As, NaH2PO4, HCl, and HNO3 have the extraction efficiency (0.85-23.4 %). The concentration of Cd extracted by 0.01 mol/L CaCl2 was significantly positively correlated with Cd levels in rice. The potential risk extraction threshold of CaCl2 in sandy loam soil was 0.178 mg/kg, while it was 0.312 mg/kg in clay soil. The concentration of As extracted by CaCl2-DTPA and 0.05 mol/L NaHCO3 in clay soil was significantly positively correlated with As levels in rice, the potential risk extraction thresholds were 0.115 mol/L and 0.106 mg/kg, respectively. These investigations indicated that the heavy metals extraction methods by 0.01 mol/L CaCl2, CaCl2-DTPA, and 0.05 mol/L NaHCO3 could reflect the Cd and As pollution degree in farmland and suggest their potential to serve as methods for assessing the risk of Cd and As pollution in sandy loam and clay paddy soil.

High geological background concentrations of As and Cd in karstic soils may not contribute to greater risks to human health via rice consumption

High geological background concentrations of toxic metal(loid)s arsenic (As) and cadmium (Cd) from natural enrichment in soils of karst regions have attracted much attention. In this study, paired soil-rice samples were collected from karst and non-karst regions in Guangxi, China to assess the potential risks of metal(loid) transfer from soil to rice grains, and rice grains to humans. Our results indicate that the karstic soils had greater As (25.7 vs. 12.4 mg·kg-1) and Cd (2.12 vs. 1.04 mg·kg-1) contents than those in non-karstic soils. However, metal(loid) transfer from soil to rice grains (ratio of rice grains to soil content) of As and Cd was 40 % and 49 % lower in karst regions, which may relate to their 42 % and 61 % lower HNO3-extractable As and CaCl2-extractable Cd, resulting in similar As/Cd contents in karstic and non-karstic rice grains. In vitro assay using a modified physiologically-based extraction test shows that karstic rice grains had a lower As/Cd bioaccessibility than non-karstic grains, which can be attributed to their ∼50 % greater P content, which negatively correlated with As/Cd bioaccessibility. Additionally, karstic rice grains had 39 % greater phytate and exhibited 45 % and 9.4 % lower As and Cd bioaccessibility in the gastric phase with phytate supplement at 0.6 %. Our work indicates that despite the greater As/Cd contents in karstic soils, the risks of As/Cd transfer from soil to rice grains as well as their exposure risks to humans via rice consumption may not be greater than non-karst regions.

Bioaccessibility and bioavailability assessment of cadmium in rice: In vitro simulators with/without gut microbiota and validation through in vivo mouse and human data

Assessing the bioaccessibility and bioavailability of cadmium (Cd) is crucial for effective evaluation of the exposure risk associated with intake of Cd-contaminated rice. However, limited studies have investigated the influence of gut microbiota on these two significant factors. In this study, we utilized in vitro gastrointestinal simulators, specifically the RIVM-M (with human gut microbial communities) and the RIVM model (without gut microbial communities), to determine the bioaccessibility of Cd in rice. Additionally, we employed the Caco-2 cell model to assess bioavailability. Our findings provide compelling evidence that gut microbiota significantly reduces Cd bioaccessibility and bioavailability (p<0.05). Notably, strong in vivo-in vitro correlations (IVIVC) were observed between the in vitro bioaccessibilities and bioavailabilities, as compared to the results obtained from an in vivo mouse bioassay (R2 = 0.63-0.65 and 0.45-0.70, respectively). Minerals such as copper (Cu) and iron (Fe) in the food matrix were found to be negatively correlated with Cd bioaccessibility in rice. Furthermore, the results obtained from the toxicokinetic (TK) model revealed that the predicted urinary Cd levels in the Chinese population, based on dietary Cd intake adjusted by in vitro bioaccessibility from the RIVM-M model, were consistent with the actual measured levels (p > 0.05). These results indicated that the RIVM-M model represents a potent approach for measuring Cd bioaccessibility and underscore the crucial role of gut microbiota in the digestion and absorption process of Cd. The implementation of these in vitro methods holds promise for reducing uncertainties in dietary exposure assessment.

Interaction behavior, mechanisms and hazardous changes of microplastics on single and binary component pesticide in the environment and food: Diethofencarb and pyrimethanil

In order to investigate the adsorption behavior and mechanism of microplastics (MPs) on multiple coexisting pesticides in practical systems, as well as their hazardous changes upon binding, diethofencarb and pyrimethanil were selected to be studied with four MPs. The adsorption rate of both pesticides would be faster in the binary-component case, conforming to pseudo-second-order kinetics, with adsorption sites and chemical adsorption dominating. And the more hydrophobic the pesticide, the faster the adsorption rate and the higher the adsorption capacity. Diethofencarb belonged to monolayer adsorption, whereas pyrimethanil belonged to monomolecular combined with multilayer adsorption, depending on the size of pesticides. And the adsorption process was both competitive and synergistic when pesticides coexist. In addition, the adsorption process was a spontaneous heat absorption process. Electrostatic forces have little effect on adsorption, while the adsorption capacity can be altered by the adsorption sites and hydrophobicity of MPs. The salting-out effect also facilitated the adsorption process. As for changes in hazard, the bioluminescence of A. fischeri wasn't significantly inhibited, lacking of acute environmental toxicity. However, in vitro digestion experiments demonstrated a significant increase in bioavailability of diethofencarb and pyrimethanil in combination with MPs. These findings suggest the stronger adsorption behaviors and higher loading capacities between pesticides and MPs could lead more serious hazards to the human body, which deserves further attention.

Influence of Foliar Zinc Application on Cadmium and Zinc Bioaccessibility in Brassica chinensis L.: In Vitro Digestion and Chemical Sequential Extraction

Foliar zinc (Zn) application can affect the accumulation and bioaccessibility of cadmium (Cd) and Zn in crops. However, the mechanisms by which foliar Zn application influences Cd and Zn bioaccessibility remain elusive. This study examined the effects of spraying ZnSO4 and ZnNa2EDTA on bioaccessibility and chemical forms of Cd and Zn in pakchoi (Brassica chinensis L.) shoots and evaluated human health risks via pakchoi consumption. Spraying ZnSO4 reduced the concentrations of ethanol-extractable (Fethanol) and deionized water-extractable (Fd-H2O) Cd, as well as the corresponding bioaccessible Cd concentrations (20.3-66.4%) and attendant health risks of Cd, whereas spraying high-dose ZnNa2EDTA significantly increased the concentrations of both Cd forms and bioaccessible Cd. Spraying ZnSO4 and high-dose ZnNa2EDTA significantly increased the concentrations of Zn in Fethanol and Fd-H2O and the corresponding bioaccessible Zn concentrations (0.8-8.3-fold). Fethanol and Fd-H2O were the primary sources of bioaccessible Cd and Zn, contributing more than 59% of the bioaccessible Cd and Zn. These results indicate that foliar Zn application can affect Cd and Zn bioaccessibility in pakchoi mainly by modulating Cd and Zn in Fethanol and Fd-H2O. These findings provide scientific support for the development of more efficient measures to produce safe and high-quality leafy vegetables from Cd-polluted soils.

Inhalation bioaccessibility of imidacloprid in particulate matter: Implications for risk assessment during spraying

Adverse health outcomes due to the inhalation of pesticide residues in atmospheric particulate matter (PM) are gaining global attention. Quantitative health risk assessments of pesticide inhalation exposure highlight the need to understand the bioaccessibility of pesticide residues. Herein, the inhalation bioaccessibility of imidacloprid in PM was determined using three commonly used in vitro lung modeling methods (Artificial Lysosomal Fluid, Gamble Solution, and Simulated Lung Fluid). To validate its feasibility and effectiveness, we evaluated the bioavailability of imidacloprid using a mouse nasal instillation assay. The in vitro inhalation bioaccessibility of imidacloprid was extracted using Gamble Solution with a solid-liquid ratio of 1/1000, an oscillation rate of 150 r/min, and an extraction time of 24 h, showed a strong linear correlation with its in vivo liver-based bioavailability (R2 =0.8928). Moreover, the margin of exposure was incorporated into the inhalation exposure risk assessment, considering both formulations and nozzles. The inhalation unit exposure of imidacloprid for residents was 0.95-4.09 ng/m3. The margin of exposure for imidacloprid was determined to be acceptable when considering inhalation bioaccessibility. Taken together, these results indicate that the inhalation bioaccessibility of pesticides should be incorporated into assessments of human health risks posed by PM particles.

Foliar spraying of lanthanum activates endocytosis in lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) root cells, increasing Cd and Pb accumulation and their bioaccessibility

Cadmium (Cd) and lead (Pb) accumulate easily in leafy vegetables and can harm human health. Lanthanum (La) have been used to improve agricultural yield and quality, but the effect of La application on Cd/Pb enrichment in leafy vegetables remains incomplete currently. A previous study reported that the endocytosis in lettuce leaf cells can be activated by La, leading to an increase in Pb accumulation in lettuce leaves. However, it has not been investigated whether foliar application of La enhances root cellular endocytosis and promotes its uptake of Cd and Pb. In this study, the influence of La on the uptake of Cd and Pb, Cd bioaccessibility, and the safety risks of cultivating lettuce under Cd and Pb stress were explored. It was found that La increased Cd (16-30 % in shoot, 16-34 % in root) and Pb (25-29 % in shoot, 17-23 % in root) accumulation in lettuce. The increased accumulation of Cd and Pb could be attributed to La-enhanced endocytosis. Meanwhile, La enhanced the toxicity of both Cd and Pb, inhibited lettuce growth, and aggravated the damage to the photosynthetic and antioxidant systems. Finally, gastrointestinal simulation experiments showed that La increased the Cd bioaccessibility in both gastric and intestinal phase by 7-108 % and 9-87 %, respectively. These results offer valuable insights into the safety of REEs for agricultural applications.

Assessment of source-oriented health risk associated with the oral ingestion of heavy metals in dust within an iron/steel smelting-affected area of the North China Plain

Heavy metals (HMs) from iron/steel smelting activities pose notable risks to human health, especially to those living around industrial facilities of North China Plain, the base of China's steel production. In this study, 78 outdoor windowsill dust samples were collected around a large-scale iron/steel smelter with more than 65 years of production history in the western North China Plain. Nine HMs were analysed to comprehensively assess the health risks by integrating Monte Carlo simulation, oral bioaccessibility, and source apportionment. Results showed serious pollution with Cd, Pb, and Zn based on their geo-accumulation index values and concentrations. Four potential sources including industrial sources (49.85%), traffic sources (21.78%), natural sources (20.58%), and coal combustion (7.79%) were quantitatively identified by multivariate statistical analysis. The oral bioaccessibilities of HMs determined by the physiologically based extraction test ranged from 0.02% to 65.16%. Zn, Mn, Cd, and Pb had higher bioaccessibilities than other HMs. After incorporating oral bioavailability adjustments, noncarcinogenic and carcinogenic risks were significantly reduced, especially for adults. The mean hazard index (HI) for children and adults was below the safety threshold (1.0), whereas the mean of the total carcinogenic risk (TCR) based on HM bioaccessibilities in the gastric phase remained above the acceptable level (1.0E-06) (children: 5.20E-06; adults: 1.16E-06). Traffic sources warranted increased concern as it substantially increased TCR. Cd was identified as the priority pollution in iron/steel smelting areas. Assessing source-oriented health risks associated with oral ingestion exposure can guide the management and control of HM contamination within iron/steel smelting-affected areas.

Lowered oral bioaccessibility of cadmium and selenium and associated health risk by co-digestion of rice and vegetables

Since foods are not ingested individually, co-digestion, in accordance with human daily diet conditions, should be stressed when assessing elements bioaccessibility and associated health risks. The oral bioaccessibility of cadmium (Cd) and selenium (Se) in 11 types of crops (rice, maize, pakchoi, eggplant, red pepper, towel gourd, kidney bean, soybean, cowpea, sweet potato, and taro) were determined, and the effects of co-digestion of 7 types of rice and vegetables on the bioaccessibility of Cd and Se were evaluated and validated with in vitro PBET method. The underlying mechanism was revealed by observing the surface morphological characteristics of digested substrates, and the exposure risk of Cd and Se were assessed. The results showed that the average bioaccessibility of Cd and Se in 11 types of crops varied from 58.7 % to 39.1 % and 48.4 % to 62.6 % from the gastric phase (GP) to the intestinal phase (IP). Interestingly, co-digestion of rice and vegetables reduced the bioaccessibility of Cd and Se to varying degrees compared to theoretical values. Great reduction in the bioaccessibility of Cd and Se in the GP (16.9-36.4 % and 9.9-23.2 %) than that in the IP (0.2-6.62 % and 0.23-12.3 %) were detected, which was attributed to the rice-vegetable aggregates formed during co-digestion. Rice-vegetable aggregates inhibited the release of Cd and Se, which was more pronounced in the GP than in the IP. Consequently, co-digestion of rice and vegetables reduced the oral exposure to Cd by 35.8 % and to Se by 19.6 %. The areas with higher non-carcinogenic risk of Cd and Se in the study region were reduced by 17 % and 10 %, respectively. Therefore, the role of co-digestion in assessing Cd and Se bioaccessibility and associated health risk cannot be neglected. This study has significant implications for investigating elements bioaccessibility and optimizing associated health risk assessment from a novel perspective.

Bioaccessibility and reliable human health risk assessment of heavy metals in typical abandoned industrial sites of southeastern China

Heavy metal pollution caused by a large number of abandoned industrial sites cannot be underestimated, but its human health risks have not been accurately assessed. This study investigated the pollution of heavy metals in soils of the typical abandoned industrial sites in southeastern China. Based on the bioaccessibility of different heavy metals (Pb, Ni, Cu, Zn, Cd, Cr) in the industrial soils, the human health risks were accurately evaluated, and the controlling factors were quantitatively assessed. The results showed that the heavy metals in each typical abandoned industrial sites had a high degree of spatial heterogeneity. Among them, Cd was the most susceptible to relevant discrete input from external factors such as human activities, followed by Zn, Pb, Cr, Ni and Cu. The bioaccessible concentration of heavy metals by the physiological-based extraction test (PBET) had a good correlation (R² = 0.58 ∼ 0.86) with its bioavailable concentration by diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (DTPA) extraction. The regression model based on soil parameters had great potential to predict the bioaccessibility of heavy metals in abandoned industrial sites (R² = 0.49 ∼ 0.95). The total concentration of heavy metals, Fe, soil texture and pH were the controlling factors of the metal bioaccessibility. Compared with the total concentration, the hazard index (HI) and carcinogenic risk (CR) values calculated based on gastrointestinal bioaccessibility were decreased by 39.0∼77.9% and 68.2∼79.9% in adults, and 45.3∼88.0% and 73.9∼83.5% in children, respectively. This work provides a feasible theoretical basis for reliable assessment of the human health risks of heavy metals in the abandoned industrial sites in the future.

Cadmium mobility and health risk assessment in the soil-rice-human system using in vitro biaccessibility and in vivo bioavailability assay: Two year field experiment

Humans are mainly exposed to cadmium (Cd) due to the rice consumption, however there exist considerable differences across rice cultivars in terms of Cd absorption and accumulation in the grains, and subsequent release after digestion (bioaccessibility), as well as uptake by Caco-2 cells of humans (bioavailability). This study comprised of field and lab simulation trials where in the field, firstly 39 mid-rice cultivars were screened for their phytoremediation potential coupled with safe production in relation to uptake and translocation of Cd. Lower Cd concentrations (˂0.2 mg kg^-1) in polished rice of 74 % cultivars were ascribed to the increased root to straw translocation indicating that straw may acquire higher accumulation of Cd. Furthermore, the ionomic profile demonstrated that the spatial distribution of metals in different rice organs corresponds to the plant growth morphology. In the second year, in vitro-in vivo assay model was employed to assess the bioaccessibility and bioavailability of Cd in polished rice and to further estimate the daily Cd intake by humans through rice grains. The results of bioaccessibility and bioavailability assays and daily estimated Cd intake presented the corresponding values of 39.02-59.76 %, 8.69-24.26 %, and 0.0185-0.9713 μg kg^-1 body weight day^-1, respectively. There exists a strong connection between total Cd and bioaccessible Cd to humans (R² = 0.94, P < 0.01). Polynomial fitting (R² = 0.91, P < 0.01) showed a better statistically significant correlation between total Cd contents and bioavailable levels, suggesting that in vitro-in vivo assays should be considered in future studies. The results of field experiments and in vitro-in vivo assays recommended the Tianyouhuazhan (MR-29), Heliangyou1hao (MR-17), and Yongyou15 (MR-1) as suitable mid-rice cultivars for the phytoremediation of slightly Cd contaminated soils coupled with rice agro-production due to their high nutritional value and low total and bioavailable Cd for human.

Screening of low-Cd accumulating early rice cultivars coupled with phytoremediation and agro-production: Bioavailability and bioaccessibility tests

Previous studies have focused on total cadmium (Cd) accumulation in rice or its transformation in soil, but only a few have examined the entire soil-rice-human system. This study investigated the Cd bioaccessibility and bioavailability for humans from grains of early rice cultivars grown in a Cd-polluted field and further combined with multi-traits to discover and evaluate the optimum safe production and phytoremediation potential cultivars. The results revealed that Cd concentration in polished rice was <0.20 mg kg^-1 in 79 % of early rice cultivars, implying that Cd levels in rice might be reduced by cultivar selection. Furthermore, the higher values of root to straw translocation factor indicates the maximal accumulation of Cd in straw and with highest soil to straw accumulation factor (>1.0) in 66.67 % of cultivars. However, bioaccessibility and bioavailability varied greatly among cultivars with corresponding values ranging from 5.68 to 7.67 % and 1.87 to 5.71 ng g^-1, respectively. Despite the fact that polynomial fitting revealed a statistically significant relationship between Cd content in polished rice and bioavailable Cd in humans (R² = 0.718, P = 0.025), poor goodness of fit for bioaccessibility, bioavailability, and toxicity varied even within low-Cd accumulating cultivars. As a result of multi trait analysis and bioavailability, Zhuliangyou4024 (ER-9), Lingliangyou211 (ER-3), and Yonxian15 (ER-28) were found to be the three best early rice cultivars with higher essential nutrients, less total and bioavailable Cd, and relative high phytoremediation potential and are suitable for healthy rice production and soil remediation.

Effects of foliar applications of Brassinolide and Selenium on the accumulation of Arsenic and Cadmium in rice grains and an assessment of their health risk

Arsenic and cadmium pose a potential health risk to human beings via rice grain consumption. In the current study, a pot experiment was conducted to evaluate the effect of Br (5 mM and 20 mM) and Se (1 mM) at rice tillering and filling stages on Cd and As accumulation in rice grain and their health risk indices. The results showed that Br or Se applications at different stages of rice improved the photosynthesis, reduce MDA content in flag leaves by 17.41%-38.65%, increased rice biomass and grain yield by 10.50%-29.94% and 10.50%-36.56%, and enhanced grain N and P uptake by 3.25%-34.90%, and 22.98%-72.05%, respectively. Applications of Br and Se effectively decreased Cd and As concentration in rice grain by 31.74%-86.97% and 16.42%-81.13% respectively. Compared to the individual treatment, combined 20 mM Br and 1 mM Se at the filling stage showed the lowest accumulation of As (0.149 mg·kg^-1) and Cd (0.105 mg·kg^-1) in grain, and its health risk index was below the acceptable limits (HRI < 1). This implies that application of Br and Se at the filling stage is a promising strategy for the safe production of rice in As and Cd co-contaminated regions.