Ammonia Solvation vs Aqueous Solvation of Samarium Diiodide. A Theoretical and Experimental Approach to Understanding Bond Activation Upon Coordination to Sm(II)

Molecular Design of Al(II) Intermediates for Small Molecule Activation

Promoting societally important small molecule activation processes with earth-abundant metals is foundational for a sustainable chemistry future. In this context, mapping new reaction pathways that would enable abundant main-group elements to mimic the behaviors of d- and f-block elements is facilitated by exploring unusual oxidation states. The most abundant metal on earth, aluminum, has been well studied in the Lewis acidic +III and Lewis basic +I oxidation states but rarely in the potentially biphilic +II oxidation state until recently, when a renaissance of Al-(II) chemistry emerged from a range of research groups. In this Perspective, we review the chemistry of mononuclear Al radicals, including both Al-centered radicals (i.e., Al-(II) compounds) and redox non-innocent systems (i.e., formally Al-(II) species that are physically Al-(III) with ligand-centered radicals), with an emphasis on small molecule reactivity. We also provide a meta-analysis of the Al-(II) literature to summarize how different design strategies (e.g., redox non-innocence, strained coordination geometries) have been shown to impart biphilic character to Al radicals and tune their behavior, thus allowing Al radicals to mimic the chemistry of certain d- and f-block metal ions such as Ti-(III) and Sm-(II). We expect these molecular design concepts to inform future Al-(II) studies as the chemistry of this unusual oxidation state of Al continues to grow.

Two-fold proton coupled electron transfer of a Ta(V) aniline complex mediated by a redox active NNN pincer ligand

We report the proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactivity of an octahedral Ta(V) aniline complex supported by an acridane-derived redox active NNN pincer ligand. The reversible binding of aniline to a Ta(V) dichloride induces significant coordination-induced bond weakening (CIBW) of the aniline N-H bonds. This enables a rare two-fold hydrogen atom abstraction, resulting in a terminal imido complex and a two-electron oxidation of the NNN pincer ligand, all while maintaining the metal's oxidation state. The bond dissociation free energies (BDFEs) of the aniline and a transient radical amido complex are estimated through stoichiometric reactions with different hydrogen atom abstractors and donors, further supported by density functional theory calculations.

Exploring the Dynamic Coordination Sphere of Lanthanide Aqua Ions: Insights from r2SCAN-3c Composite-DFT Born-Oppenheimer Molecular Dynamics Studies

Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics (BOMD) simulations were performed to investigate the structure and dynamics of the first hydration shells of five trivalent lanthanide ions (Ln3+) at room temperature. These ions are relevant in various environments, including the bulk aqueous solution. Despite numerous studies, accurately classifying the molecular geometry of the first hydration sphere remains a challenge. To addres this, a cluster microsolvation approach was employed to study the interaction of Ln3+ ions (La, Nd, Gd, Er, and Lu) with up to 27 explicit water molecules. Electronic structure calculations were performed with the composite r2SCAN-3c method. The results demonstrate that this method offers an optimal balance between precision and computational efficiency. Specifically, it accurately predicts average Ln-O distances (MAE = 0.02 Å) of the first hydration sphere and preferred coordination numbers (CN) for the different lanthanide cations as compared to reported data in bulk. Highly dynamic first hydration shells for the examined Ln3+ ions were found, with noticeable and rapid rearrangements in their coordination geometries, some of which can be recognized as the tricapped trigonal prism (TTP) and the capped square antiprism (CSAP) for CN = 9, and as the square antiprism (SAP), the bicapped trigonal prism (BTP), and the trigonal dodecahedron (DDH) for CN = 8. However, ca. 70% of the nonacoordinated configurations did not meet the criteria of TTP or CSAP structures. For CN = 8, the percentage of configurations that could not be assigned to SAP, BTP, or DDH was lower, around 30%. The theoretical EXAFS spectra obtained from the BOMD simulations are in good agreement with the experimental data and confirm that model microsolvated environments accurately represent the near-solvation structure of these trivalent rare-earth ions. Moreover, this demonstrates that the faster dynamics of the first hydration shell can be studied separately from the dynamics of water exchange in the bulk aqueous solution.

Diastereoselective Dearomatizing Cyclizations of 5-Arylpentan-2-ones by Samarium Diiodide - A Computational Analysis

This study analyzes the samarium diiodide-promoted cyclizations of 5-arylpentan-2-ones to dearomatized bicyclic products utilizing density functional theory. The reaction involves a single electron transfer to the carbonyl group, which occurs synchronously with the rate determining cyclization event, and a second subsequent proton-coupled electron transfer. These redox reactions are accurately computed employing small core pseudo potentials explicitly involving all f-electrons of samarium. Comparison of the energies of the possible final products rules out thermodynamic control of the observed regio- and diastereoselectivities. Kinetic control via appropriate transition states is correctly predicted, but to obtain reasonable energy levels the influence of the co-solvent hexamethylphosphortriamide has to be estimated by using a correction term. The steric effect of the bulky samarium ligands is decisive for the observed stereoselectivity. Carbonyl groups in para-position of the aryl group change the regioselectivity of the cyclization and lead to spiro compounds. The computations suggest again kinetic control of this deviating outcome. However, the standard mechanism has to be modified and the involvement of a complex activated by two SmI2 moieties is proposed in which two electrons are transferred simultaneously to form the new C-C bond. Computation of model intermediates show the feasibility of this alternative+ mechanism.

Coordination-induced O-H/N-H bond weakening by a redox non-innocent, aluminum-containing radical

Several renewable energy schemes aim to use the chemical bonds in abundant molecules like water and ammonia as energy reservoirs. Because the O-H and N-H bonds are quite strong (>100 kcal/mol), it is necessary to identify substances that dramatically weaken these bonds to facilitate proton-coupled electron transfer processes required for energy conversion. Usually this is accomplished through coordination-induced bond weakening by redox-active metals. However, coordination-induced bond weakening is difficult with earth's most abundant metal, aluminum, because of its redox inertness under mild conditions. Here, we report a system that uses aluminum with a redox non-innocent ligand to achieve significant levels of coordination-induced bond weakening of O-H and N-H bonds. The multisite proton-coupled electron transfer manifold described here points to redox non-innocent ligands as a design element to open coordination-induced bond weakening chemistry to more elements in the periodic table.

Entropic Effects on the Aqueous Microsolvation of Protonated Glycine and Protonated β-Alanine. Hybrid Density Functional Theory Born-Oppenheimer Molecular Dynamics Studies

Recent low-temperature infrared-based experimental studies provided information about the effects of aqueous microsolvation on the intramolecular hydrogen bond of protonated glycine and β-alanine [J. Phys. Chem. A 2019, 123, 3355]. Here we address the temperature-dependent entropic effects on the aqueous microsolvation patterns of these protonated amino acids using the AAH⁺(H₂O)_n (n = 1-8) cluster model at 50 K and room temperature with Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics using a calibrated hybrid density functional. The C_COOH-O_w, N-O_w, and center-of-mass-O_w radial distribution functions provide accurate structural data and temperature-dependent water coordination numbers vs. solvation degree. The solvation patterns for protonated glycine at 50 K show structural features in agreement with previous static optimizations. However, entropic effects at room temperature play a crucial role in the evolution of the intramolecular HB strength vs. solvation degree for both protonated amino acids. With increasing hydration entropic effects favor the making of solvent hydrogen bond networks over full solvation of protonated glycine. At room temperature four water molecules are needed to build the first solvation shell for protonated glycine while five are required for protonated β-alanine. A new statistical Cumulative Percentage of Structures (CPS) scheme is proposed; when the CPS data are analyzed in light of the empirical formula of Rozenberg et al. [Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2000, 2, 2699] and the hydrogen bond relative strength (HBRS) criteria of Jeffrey [An Introduction to Hydrogen Bonding; Oxford University: 1997] we can provide a detailed molecular mechanism for the weakening of the intramolecular hydrogen bond based on the average dynamical structures, which clearly reveals the temperature dependence of this process. The new CPS-HBRS scheme proposed here can be utilized using any type of molecular dynamics trajectory (classical, BOMD, CPMD, etc.).

Coordination Structure of Samarium Diiodide in a Tetrahydrofuran-Water Mixture

Chemoselective reductive conversion of organic and inorganic compounds has been developed by the combination of samarium(II) diiodide (SmI₂) and water. Despite the extensive previous studies to elucidate the role of water in the reactivity of SmI₂, the direct structural data of the reactive Sm²⁺-water complexes, SmI₂(H₂O)_n, in an organic solvent-water mixture have not been reported experimentally so far. Herein, we performed the structure analysis of the Sm²⁺-water complex in tetrahydrofuran (THF) in the presence of water by in situ X-ray absorption spectroscopy using high-energy X-rays (Sm K-edge, 46.8 keV). The analysis revealed the dissociation of the Sm²⁺-I bonds in the presence of ≥ eight equivalents of water in the THF-water mixture. The origin of the peak shift in the UV/visible absorption spectra after the addition of water into SmI₂/THF solution was proposed based on electron transitions simulated with time-dependent density-functional-theory calculations using optimized structures in THF or water. The obtained structural information provides the fundamental insights for elucidating the reactivity and chemoselectivity in the Sm²⁺-water complex system.

Sm(II)-Mediated Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer: Quantifying Very Weak N-H and O-H Homolytic Bond Strengths and Factors Controlling Them

Coordination of alcohols to the single-electron reductant samarium diiodide (SmI2) results in substantial O-H bond weakening, affording potent proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reagents. However, poorly defined speciation of SmI2 in tetrahydrofuran (THF)/alcohol mixtures limits reliable thermodynamic analyses of such systems. Rigorous determination of bond dissociation free energy (BDFE) values in such Sm systems, important to evaluating their reactivity profiles, motivates studies of model Sm systems where contributing factors can be teased apart. Here, a bulky and strongly chelating macrocyclic ligand ((tBu2ArOH)2Me2cyclam) maintains solubility, eliminates dimerization pathways, and facilitates clean electrochemical behavior in a well-defined functional model for the PCET reactivity of SmII with coordinating proton sources. Direct measurement of thermodynamic parameters enables reliable experimental estimation of the BDFEs in 2-pyrrolidone and MeOH complexes of ((tBu2ArO)2Me2cyclam)SmII, thereby revealing exceptionally weak N-H and O-H BDFEs of 27.2 and <24.1 kcal mol-1, respectively. Expanded thermochemical cycles reveal that this bond weakening stems from the very strongly reducing SmII center and the formation of strong SmIII-alkoxide (and -pyrrolidonate) interactions in the PCET products. We provide a detailed analysis comparing these BDFE values with those that have been put forward for SmI2 in THF in the presence of related proton donors. We suggest that BDFE values for the latter systems may in fact be appreciably higher than the system described herein. Finally, protonation and electrochemical reduction steps necessary for the regeneration of the PCET donors from SmIII-alkoxides are demonstrated, pointing to future strategies aimed at achieving (electro)catalytic turnover using SmII-based PCET reagents.

Cooperative Intrinsic Basicity and Hydrogen Bonding Render SmI2 More Azaphilic than Oxophilic

It has been recently shown that SmI₂ is more azaphilic than oxophilic. Density functional theory calculations reveal that coordination of 1-3 molecules of ethylenediamine is more exothermic by up to 10 kcal/mol than coordination of the corresponding number of ethylene glycol molecules. Taking into account also hydrogen bonds between ligands and tetrahydrofuran doubles this preference. The intrinsic affinity parallels the order of basicity. The cooperativity with the hydrogen bonding makes SmI₂ more azaphilic than oxophilic.

Coordination-Induced Bond Weakening

Coordination-induced bond weakening is a phenomenon wherein ligand X-H bond homolysis occurs in concert with the energetically favorable oxidation of a coordinating metal complex. The coupling of these two processes enables thermodynamically favorable proton-coupled electron transfer reductions to form weak bonds upon formal hydrogen atom transfer to substrates. Moreover, systems utilizing coordination-induced bond weakening have been shown to facilitate the dehydrogenation of feedstock molecules including water, ammonia, and primary alcohols under mild conditions. The formation of exceptionally weak substrate X-H bonds via small molecule homolysis is a powerful strategy in synthesis and has been shown to enable nitrogen fixation under mild conditions. Coordination-induced bond weakening has also been identified as an integral process in biophotosynthesis and has promising applications in renewable chemical fuel storage systems. This review presents a discussion of the advances made in the study of coordination-induced bond weakening to date. Because of the broad range of metal and ligand species implicated in coordination-induced bond weakening, each literature report is discussed individually and ordered by the identity of the low-valent metal. We then offer mechanistic insights into the basis of coordination-induced bond weakening and conclude with a discussion of opportunities for further research into the development and applications of coordination-induced bond weakening systems.

Solid-state and solution-phase characterization of SmII-aza[2.2.2]cryptate and its methylated analogue

Two new Sm^II-azacryptates are reported that differ in steric hindrance and Lewis basicity of donor atoms. The sterically hindered complex has a smaller coordination number and a more negative electrochemical potential than the complex with less steric hindrance.