CO2 Reduction on an Iron-Porphyrin Center: A Computational Study

Beyond scaling relations in electrocatalysis: unifying concepts from molecular systems and metallic surfaces

Transitioning the chemical industry away from fossil fuels is a critical goal that requires the adoption of alternative, non-fossil carbon feedstocks. The electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction, driven via renewable-derived electricity, represents an unparalleled technology that uses CO2 as a C1-building block to generate industrially relevant products. Although many electrocatalytic systems have demonstrated promising activities in producing a wide range of products, challenges remain in controlling the product selectivity and reducing the operating overpotential for large-scale applications. This Perspective outlines recent efforts in designing tailored microenvironments in electrocatalytic systems to boost their selectivity and energy efficiency. We review examples from homogeneous and heterogeneous systems, emphasizing mechanistic studies that elucidate how the modulation of the space surrounding catalytic active sites can control the outcome of electrocatalysis. Lastly, we carry out a thermodynamic-kinetic analysis to identify existing scaling relationships that govern the electrocatalytic performance of molecular catalysts, and we highlight examples of catalysts that circumvent these relations through the functionalization of their secondary coordination sphere.

CO2 reduction to CO on an iron-porphyrin complex with crown-ether appended cation-binding site

With increasing carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere, the utilization and conversion of CO2 into valuable materials is an important goal. In recent years, evidence has emerged of low-valent iron-porphyrin complexes able to bind CO2 and reduce it to carbon monoxide and water. To find out how the porphyrin scaffold and second coordination sphere influence the CO2 reduction on iron-porphyrin complexes, we study the structure, electronic and redox properties of a novel crown-ether appended porphyrin complex with cation (K+) binding site. Cyclic voltammetry studies show that the K+ binding site does not change the Fe0/I and FeI/II redox potentials of the complexes. Subsequently, density functional theory calculations were performed on the catalytic cycle of CO2 reduction on the K+-bound crown-ether appended iron-porphyrin complex. The work shows that proton-donors such as acetic acid bind the K+ strongly and can assist with efficient and fast proton transfer that leads to the conversion of CO2 to CO and water. In agreement with experiment, the calculations show little perturbations of the redox potentials upon binding K+ to the crown-ether scaffold.

Theoretical Study on the Mechanism of the Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction to Formate by an Iron Schiff Base Complex

The iron(III) chloride compound 6,6'-di(3,5-ditert-butyl-2-hydroxybenzene)-2,2'-bipyridine (Fe(tbudhbpy)Cl) can effectively catalyze the electrochemical CO2 reduction in N,N-dimethylformamide. Density functional calculations were conducted to investigate the mechanism and unravel the governing factors of product selectivity. The results suggest that the initial catalyst, Fe(tbudhbpy)Cl (formally FeIII-Cl), undergoes two reduction steps, accompanied by the dissociation of Cl-, leading to the formation of the active ferrous radical intermediate 2 (formally FeI). Without phenol, 2 attacks CO2 to generate the FeIII-carboxylate intermediate FeIII-CO2, followed by a one-electron reduction to generate FeII-CO2, which reacts with another CO2 to produce CO. This aligns with the experimental result that CO is the main product when the phenol is absent. In contrast, when phenol is presented, the triple reduced species 3 is protonated at its ligand N site to yield 3pt(N) (formally Fe0-NH), which subsequently performs a nucleophilic attack on CO2 to afford formate. This process occurs via an orthogonal electron/proton transfer mechanism, where two electrons and one proton are transferred from the ligand to the CO2 moiety. The redox noninnocent nature of the ligand is thus crucial for formate formation, as it facilitates electron and proton shuttling, enabling 3pt(N) to attack CO2 through this unusual mechanism effectively.

CO2 adsorption in natural deep eutectic solvents: insights from quantum mechanics and molecular dynamics

CO2 capture is an important process for mitigating CO2 emissions in the atmosphere. Recently, ionic liquids have been identified as possible systems for CO2 capture processes. Major drawbacks of such systems are mostly in the high cost of synthesis of such liquids and poor biodegradability. Natural deep eutectic solvents, a class of eutectic solvents using materials of natural origin, have been developed, which compared to ionic liquids are low-cost and more environmentally benign. However, very little is known on the details at a molecular level that govern the CO2 adsorption in these systems and what the limits are of the adsorption features. Elucidating such aspects would represent a step forward in the design and implementation of such promising systems in mitigating CO2 emissions. Herein, we report a computational study on the mechanisms and characteristics of CO2 adsorption in natural deep eutectic solvents containing arginine/glycerol mixtures. We establish details of the hydrogen bonding effects that drive the carbon dioxide capture in systems composed of L-arginine and glycerol using molecular dynamics and quantum mechanics simulations. Our findings indicate that, although both arginine and glycerol contain multiple atoms capable of acting as hydrogen bond donors and hydrogen bond acceptors, L-arginine primarily functions as the hydrogen bond acceptor while glycerol serves as the hydrogen bond donor in most interactions. Furthermore, both compounds contribute hydrogen bond donors that participate in CO2 binding. This study provides valuable insights into the behaviour of CO2 adsorption in natural deep eutectic solvents and enhances our understanding from the perspective of hydrogen bonding interactions.

Biomimetic [MFe3S4]3+ Cubanes (M = V/Mo) as Catalysts for a Fischer-Tropsch-like Hydrocarbon Synthesis─A Computational Study

Nitrogenase is the enzyme primarily responsible for reducing atmospheric nitrogen to ammonia. There are three general forms of nitrogenase based on the metal ion present in the cofactor binding site, namely, molybdenum-dependent nitrogenases with the iron-molybdenum cofactor (FeMoco), the vanadium-dependent nitrogenases with FeVco, and the iron-only nitrogenases. It has been shown that the vanadium-dependent nitrogenases tend to have a lesser efficacy in reducing dinitrogen but a higher efficacy in binding and reducing carbon monoxide. In biomimetic chemistry, [MFe3S4] (M = Mo/V) cubanes have been synthesized, studied, and shown to be promising mimics of some of the geometric and electronic properties of the nitrogenase cofactors. In this work, a density functional theory (DFT) study is presented on Fischer-Tropsch catalysis by these cubane complexes by studying CO binding and reduction to hydrocarbons. Our work implies that molybdenum has stronger binding interactions with the iron-sulfur framework of the cubane, which results in easier reduction of substrates like N2H4. However, this inhibits the binding and activation of CO, and hence, the molybdenum-containing complexes are less suitable for Fischer-Tropsch catalysis than vanadium-containing complexes.

Implications of non-native metal substitution in carbonic anhydrase - engineered enzymes and models

The enzyme carbonic anhydrase has been intensely studied over decades as a means to understand the role of zinc in hydrating CO2. The naturally occurring enzyme has also been immobilized on distinct heterogeneous platforms, which results in a different hybrid class of catalysts that are useful for the adsorption and hydration of CO2. However, the reusability and robustness of such natural and immobilized systems are substantially affected when tested under industrial conditions, such as high temperature and high flow rate. This led to the generation of model systems in the form of metal-coordination complexes, metal-organic frameworks, metallo-peptide self-assembled supramolecules and nanomaterials that mimic the primary, and, to some extent, secondary coordination sphere of the active site of the natural carbonic anhydrase enzymes. Furthermore, the effects of zinc-substitution by other relevant transition metals in both the naturally occurring enzymes and model systems has been reported. It has been observed that some other transition metal ions in the active site of carbonic anhydrase and its models can also accomplish similar activity, established by various reaction probes and ideas. Herein, we present a comprehensive highlight about substituting zinc in the active site of the modified enzymes and its biomimetic model systems with non-native metal ions and review how they affect the structural orientation and reactivity towards CO2 hydration. In addition, the utility of artificially engineered carbonic anhydrases towards a number of non-natural reactions is also discussed.

Time-Resolved Mechanistic Depiction of Photoinduced CO2 Reduction Catalysis on a Urea-Modified Iron Porphyrin

The development of functional artificial photosynthetic devices relies on the understanding of mechanistic aspects involved in specialized photocatalysts. Modified iron porphyrins have long been explored as efficient catalysts for the light-induced reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2) towards solar fuels. In spite of the advancements in homogeneous catalysis, the development of the next generation of catalysts requires a complete understanding of the fundamental photoinduced processes taking place prior to and after activation of the substrate by the catalyst. In this work, we employ a state-of-the-art nanosecond optical transient absorption spectroscopic setup with a double excitation capability to induce charge accumulation and trigger the reduction of CO2 to carbon monoxide (CO). Our biomimetic system is composed of a urea-modified iron(III) tetraphenylporphyrin (UrFeIII) catalyst, the prototypical [Ru(bpy)3]2+ (bpy=2,2'-bipyridine) used as a photosensitizer, and sodium ascorbate as an electron donor. Under inert atmosphere, we show that two electrons can be successively accumulated on the catalyst as the fates of the photogenerated UrFeII and UrFeI reduced species are tracked. In the presence of CO2, the catalytic cycle is kick-started providing further evidence on CO2 activation by the UrFe catalyst in its formal FeI oxidation state.

Fingerprint of Dipole Moment Orientation of Water Molecules in Cu2+ Aqueous Solution Probed by X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy

The electronic structure and geometrical organization of aqueous Cu2+ have been investigated by using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) at the Cu L-edge combined with state-of-the-art ab initio molecular dynamics and a quantum molecular approach designed to simulate the Cu 2p X-ray photoelectron spectrum. The calculations offer a comprehensive insight into the origin of the main peak and satellite features. It is illustrated how the energy drop of the Cu 3d levels (≈7 eV) following the creation of the Cu 2p core hole switches the nature of the highest singly occupied molecular orbitals (MOs) from the dominant metal to the dominant MO nature of water. It is particularly revealed how the repositioning of the Cu 3d levels induces the formation of new bonding (B) and antibonding (AB) orbitals, from which shakeup mechanisms toward the relaxed H-SOMO operate. As highlighted in this study, the appearance of the shoulder near the main peak corresponds to the characteristic signature of shakeup intraligand (1a1 → H-SOMO(1b1)) excitations in water, providing insights into the average dipole moment distribution (≈36°) of the first-shell water molecules surrounding the metal ion and its direct impact on the broadening of the satellite. It is also revealed that the main satellite at 8 eV from the main peak corresponds to (metal/1b2 → H-SOMO(1b1) of water) excitations due to a bonding/antibonding (B/AB) interaction of Cu 3d levels with the deepest valence O2p/H1s 1b2 orbitals of water. This finding underscores the sensitivity of XPS to the electronic structure and orientation of the nearest water molecules around the central ion.

CO2 Reduction by an Iron(I) Porphyrinate System: Effect of Hydrogen Bonding on the Second Coordination Sphere

Transforming CO2 into valuable materials is an important reaction in catalysis, especially because CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere have been growing steadily due to extensive fossil fuel usage. From an environmental perspective, reduction of CO2 to valuable materials should be catalyzed by an environmentally benign catalyst and avoid the use of heavy transition-metal ions. In this work, we present a computational study into a novel iron(I) porphyrin catalyst for CO2 reduction, namely, with a tetraphenylporphyrin ligand and analogues. In particular, we investigated iron(I) tetraphenylporphyrin with one of the meso-phenyl groups substituted with o-urea, p-urea, or o-2-amide groups. These substituents can provide hydrogen-bonding interactions in the second coordination sphere with bound ligands and assist with proton relay. Furthermore, our studies investigated bicarbonate and phenol as stabilizers and proton donors in the reaction mechanism. Potential energy landscapes for double protonation of iron(I) porphyrinate with bound CO2 are reported. The work shows that the bicarbonate bridges the urea/amide groups to the CO2 and iron center and provides a tight bonding pattern with strong hydrogen-bonding interactions that facilitates easy proton delivery and reduction of CO2. Specifically, bicarbonate provides a low-energy proton shuttle mechanism to form CO and water efficiently. Furthermore, the o-urea group locks bicarbonate and CO2 in a tight orientation and helps with ideal proton transfer, while there is more mobility and lesser stability with an o-amide group in that position instead. Our calculations show that the o-urea group leads to reduction in proton-transfer barriers, in line with experimental observation. We then applied electric-field-effect calculations to estimate the environmental effects on the two proton-transfer steps in the reaction. These calculations describe the perturbations that enhance the driving forces for the proton-transfer steps and have been used to make predictions about how the catalysts can be further engineered for more enhanced CO2 reduction processes.

Second Coordination Sphere Effect Shifts CO2 to CO Reduction by Iron Porphyrin from Fe0 to FeI

Iron porphyrins are among the most studied molecular catalysts for carbon dioxide (CO2 ) reduction and their reactivity is constantly being enhanced through the implementation of chemical functionalities in the second coordination sphere inspired by the active sites of enzymes. In this study, we were intrigued to observe that a multipoint hydrogen bonding scheme provided by embarked urea groups could also shift the redox activation step of CO2 from the well-admitted Fe(0) to the Fe(I) state. Using EPR, resonance Raman, IR and UV-Visible spectroscopies, we underpinned a two-electron activation step of CO2 starting from the Fe(I) oxidation state to form, after protonation, an Fe(III)-COOH species. The addition of another electron and a proton to the latter species converged to the cleavage of a C-O bond with the loss of water molecule resulting in an Fe(II)-CO species. DFT analyses of these postulated intermediates are in good agreement with our collected spectroscopic data, allowing us to propose an alternative pathway in the catalytic CO2 reduction with iron porphyrin catalyst. Such a remarkable shift opens new lines of research in the design of molecular catalysts to reach low overpotentials in performing multi-electronic CO2 reduction catalysis.

Uncoordinated amino groups of MIL-101 anchoring cobalt porphyrins for highly selective CO2 electroreduction

Electrocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO2RR) presents a sustainable route to address energy crisis and environmental issues, where the rational design of catalysts remains crucial. Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with high CO2 capture capacities have immense potential as CO2RR electrocatalysts but suffer from poor activity. Herein we report a redox-active cobalt protoporphyrin grafted MIL-101(Cr)-NH2 for CO2 electroreduction. Material characterizations reveal that porphyrin molecules are covalently attached to uncoordinated amino groups of the parent MOF without compromising its well-defined porous structure. Furthermore, in situ spectroscopic techniques suggest inherited CO2 concentrate ability and more abundant adsorbed carbonate species on the modified MOF. As a result, a maximum CO Faradaic efficiency (FECO) up to 97.1% and a turnover frequency of 0.63 s-1 are achieved, together with FECO above 90% within a wide potential window of 300 mV. This work sheds new light on the coupling of MOFs with molecular catalysts to enhance catalytic performances.

Photocatalytic Reduction of CO2 to HCOOH and CO by a Phosphine-Bipyridine-Phosphine Ir(III) Catalyst: Photophysics, Nonadiabatic Effects, Mechanism, and Selectivity

Photocatalytic CO2 reduction is one of the best solutions to solve the global energy crisis and to realize carbon neutralization. The tetradentate phosphine-bipyridine (bpy)-phosphine (PNNP)-type Ir(III) photocatalyst, Mes-IrPCY2, was reported with a high HCOOH selectivity but the photocatalytic mechanism remains elusive. Herein, we employ electronic structure methods in combination with radiative, nonradiative, and electron transfer rate calculations, to explore the entire photocatalytic cycle to either HCOOH or CO, based on which a new mechanistic scenario is proposed. The catalytic reduction reaction starts from the generation of the precursor metal-to-ligand charge transfer (3 MLCT) state. Subsequently, the divergence happens from the 3 MLCT state, the single electron transfer (SET) and deprotonation process lead to the formation of one-electron-reduced species and Ir(I) species, which initiate the reduction reaction to HCOOH and CO, respectively. Interestingly, the efficient occurrence of proton or electron transfer reduces barriers of critical steps. In addition, nonadiabatic transitions play a nonnegligible role in the cycle. We suggest a lower free-energy barrier in the reaction-limiting step and the very efficient SET in 3 MLCT are cooperatively responsible for a high HCOOH selectivity. The gained mechanistic insights could help chemists to understand, regulate, and design photocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction of similar function-integrated molecular photocatalyst.

Mechanism of CO2 Reduction to Methanol with H2 on an Iron(II)-scorpionate Catalyst

CO2 utilization is an important process in the chemical industry with great environmental power. In this work we show how CO2 and H2 can be reacted to form methanol on an iron(II) center and highlight the bottlenecks for the reaction and what structural features of the catalyst are essential for efficient turnover. The calculations predict the reactions to proceed through three successive reaction cycles that start with heterolytic cleavage of H2 followed by sequential hydride and proton transfer processes. The H2 splitting process is an endergonic process and hence high pressures will be needed to overcome this step and trigger the hydrogenation reaction. Moreover, H2 cleavage into a hydride and proton requires a metal to bind hydride and a nearby source to bind the proton, such as an amide or pyrazolyl group, which the scorpionate ligand used here facilitates. As such the computations highlight the non-innocence of the ligand scaffold through proton shuttle from H2 to substrate as an important step in the reaction mechanism.

Further Understanding the Roles of Solvent, Brønsted Acids, and Hydrogen Bonding in Iron Porphyrin-Mediated Carbon Dioxide Reduction

Improving our understanding of how molecules and materials mediate the electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2) to upgraded products is of great interest as a means to address climate change. A leading class of molecules that can facilitate the electrochemical conversion of CO2 to carbon monoxide (CO) is iron porphyrins. These molecules can have high rate constants for CO2-to-CO conversion; they are robust, and they rely on abundant and inexpensive synthetic building blocks. Important foundational work has been conducted using chloroiron 5,10,15,20-tetraphenylporphyrin (FeTPPCl) in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) solvent. A related and recent report points out that the corresponding perchlorate complex, FeTPPClO4, can have superior function due to its solubility in other organic solvents. However, the importance of hydrogen bonding and solvent effects was not discussed. Herein, we present a detailed kinetic study of the triflate (CF3SO3-) complex of FeTPP in DMF and in MeCN using a range of phenol Brønsted acid additives. We also detected the formation of Fe(III)TPP-phenolate complexes using cyclic voltammetry experiments. Importantly, our new analysis of apparent rate constants with different added phenols allows for a modification to the established mechanistic model for CO2-to-CO conversion. Critically, our improved model accounts for hydrogen bonding and solvent effects by using simple hydrogen bond acidity and basicity descriptors. We use this augmented model to rationalize function in other reported porphyrin systems and to make predictions about operational conditions that can enhance the CO2 reduction chemistry.

Mechanistic Insights into Photochemical CO2 Reduction to CH4 by a Molecular Iron-Porphyrin Catalyst

Iron tetraphenylporphyrin complex modified with four trimethylammonium groups (Fe-p-TMA) is found to be capable of catalyzing the eight-electron eight-proton reduction of CO₂ to CH₄ photochemically in acetonitrile. In the present work, density functional theory (DFT) calculations have been performed to investigate the reaction mechanism and to rationalize the product selectivity. Our results revealed that the initial catalyst Fe-p-TMA ([Cl-Fe(III)-LR₄]⁴⁺, where L = tetraphenylporphyrin ligand with a total charge of -2, and R₄ = four trimethylammonium groups with a total charge of +4) undergoes three reduction steps, accompanied by the dissociation of the chloride ion to form [Fe(II)-L^••2-R₄]²⁺. [Fe(II)-L^••2-R₄]²⁺, bearing a Fe(II) center ferromagnetically coupled with a tetraphenylporphyrin diradical, performs a nucleophilic attack on CO₂ to produce the ¹η-CO₂ adduct [CO₂^•--Fe(II)-L^•-R₄]²⁺. Two intermolecular proton transfer steps then take place at the CO₂ moiety of [CO₂^•--Fe(II)-L^•-R₄]²⁺, resulting in the cleavage of the C-O bond and the formation of the critical intermediate [Fe(II)-CO]⁴⁺ after releasing a water molecule. Subsequently, [Fe(II)-CO]⁴⁺ accepts three electrons and one proton to generate [CHO-Fe(II)-L^•-R₄]²⁺, which finally undergoes a successive four-electron-five-proton reduction to produce methane without forming formaldehyde, methanol, or formate. Notably, the redox non-innocent tetraphenylporphyrin ligand was found to play an important role in CO₂ reduction since it could accept and transfer electron(s) during catalysis, thus keeping the ferrous ion at a relatively high oxidation state. Hydrogen evolution reaction via the formation of Fe-hydride ([Fe(II)-H]³⁺) turns out to endure a higher total barrier than the CO₂ reduction reaction, therefore providing a reasonable explanation for the origin of the product selectivity.

Quantitative Structure–Electrochemistry Relationship (QSER) Studies on Metal–Amino–Porphyrins for the Rational Design of CO2 Reduction Catalysts

The quantitative structure–electrochemistry relationship (QSER) method was applied to a series of transition-metal-coordinated porphyrins to relate their structural properties to their electrochemical CO2 reduction activity. Since the reactions mainly occur within the core of the metalloporphyrin catalysts, the cluster model was used to calculate their structural and electronic properties using density functional theory with the M06L exchange–correlation functional. Three dependent variables were employed in this work: the Gibbs free energies of H*, C*OOH, and O*CHO. QSER, with the genetic algorithm combined with multiple linear regression (GA–MLR), was used to manipulate the mathematical models of all three Gibbs free energies. The obtained statistical values resulted in a good predictive ability (R2 value) greater than 0.945. Based on our QSER models, both the electronic properties (charges of the metal and porphyrin) and the structural properties (bond lengths between the metal center and the nitrogen atoms of the porphyrin) play a significant role in the three Gibbs free energies. This finding was further applied to estimate the CO2 reduction activities of the metal–monoamino–porphyrins, which will prove beneficial in further experimental developments.

Tandem electrocatalytic CO2 reduction with Fe-porphyrins and Cu nanocubes enhances ethylene production

Copper-based tandem schemes have emerged as promising strategies to promote the formation of multi-carbon products in the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction. In such approaches, the CO-generating component of the tandem catalyst increases the local concentration of CO and thereby enhances the intrinsic carbon-carbon (C-C) coupling on copper. However, the optimal characteristics of the CO-generating catalyst for maximizing the C2 production are currently unknown. In this work, we developed tunable tandem catalysts comprising iron porphyrin (Fe-Por), as the CO-generating component, and Cu nanocubes (Cucub) to understand how the turnover frequency for CO (TOFCO) of the molecular catalysts impacts the C-C coupling on the Cu surface. First, we tuned the TOFCO of the Fe-Por by varying the number of orbitals involved in the π-system. Then, we coupled these molecular catalysts with the Cucub and assessed the current densities and faradaic efficiencies. We discovered that all of the designed Fe-Por boost ethylene production. The most efficient Cucub/Fe-Por tandem catalyst was the one including the Fe-Por with the highest TOFCO and exhibited a nearly 22-fold increase in the ethylene selectivity and 100 mV positive shift of the onset potential with respect to the pristine Cucub. These results reveal that coupling the TOFCO tunability of molecular catalysts with copper nanocatalysts opens up new possibilities towards the development of Cu-based catalysts with enhanced selectivity for multi-carbon product generation at low overpotential.

Interpretation of Shakeup Mechanisms in Copper L-Shell Photoelectron Spectra

We report on an original full ab initio quantum molecular approach designed to simulate Cu 2p X-ray photoelectron spectra. The description includes electronic relaxation/correlation and spin-orbit coupling effects and is implemented within nonorthogonal sets of molecular orbitals for the initial and final states. The underlying mechanism structuring the Cu 2p photoelectron spectra is clarified thanks to a correlation diagram applied to the CuO₄C₆H₆ paradigm. This diagram illustrates how the energy drop of the Cu 3d levels following the creation of the Cu 2p core hole switches the nature of the highest singly occupied molecular orbital (H-SOMO) from dominant metal to dominant ligand character. It also reveals how the repositioning of the Cu 3d levels induces the formation of new bonding and antibonding orbitals from which shakeup mechanisms toward the relaxed H-SOMO operate. The specific nature, ligand → ligand and metal → ligand, of these excitations building the satellite lines is exposed. Our approach finally applied to the real Cu(acac)₂ system clearly demonstrates how a definite interpretation of the XPS spectra can be obtained when a correct evaluation of binding energies, intensities, and relative widths of the spectral lines is achieved.

Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory Calculations of Iron(II) Porphyrin: Effects of Hybrid Pair-Density Functionals and Expanded RAS and DMRG Active Spaces on Spin-State Orderings

Iron(II) porphyrins play critical roles in enzymes and synthetic catalysts. Computationally determining the spin-state ordering for even the unsubstituted iron(II) porphyrin (FeP) is challenging due to its large size. Multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory (MC-PDFT), a method capable of accurately capturing correlation with lower cost than comparably accurate methods, was previously used to predict a triplet ground state for FeP across a wide range of active spaces up to (34e, 35o). The purpose of this present MC-PDFT study is to determine the effects of including nonlocal exchange in the energy calculation and of using a larger active space size [DMRG(40e, 42o) and RAS(40, 2, 2; 16, 6, 20)] on the calculated FeP spin-state ordering. The recently developed hybrid MC-PDFT method, which uses a weighted average of the MC-PDFT energy and the energy expectation value of the reference wave function, is applied with a weight of the reference wave function energy of λ. We find that increasing λ stabilizes the quintet relative to the triplets. The hybrid tPBE0 functional (tPBE with λ set to 0.25) consistently predicts a triplet ground state with the quintet lying above by 0.10-0.16 eV, depending on the reference wave function. These values are particularly interesting in light of tPBE0's very strong performance for a diverse set of other systems.

Electronic structure analysis of electrochemical CO2 reduction by iron-porphyrins reveals basic requirements to design catalysts bearing non-innocent ligands

Electrocatalytic CO2 reduction is a possible solution to the increasing CO2 concentration in the earth atmosphere, because it enables storage of energy while using the harmful CO2 feedstock as starting...

Mechanistic Insights into Co and Fe Quaterpyridine-Based CO2 Reduction Catalysts: Metal-Ligand Orbital Interaction as the Key Driving Force for Distinct Pathways

Both [Co^II(qpy)(H₂O)₂]²⁺ and [Fe^II(qpy)(H₂O)₂]²⁺ (with qpy = 2,2':6',2″:6'',2‴-quaterpyridine) are efficient homogeneous electrocatalysts and photoelectrocatalysts for the reduction of CO₂ to CO. The Co catalyst is more efficient in the electrochemical reduction, while the Fe catalyst is an excellent photoelectrocatalyst ( ACS Catal. 2018, 8, 3411-3417). This work uses density functional theory to shed light on the contrasting catalytic pathways. While both catalysts experience primarily ligand-based reductions, the second reduction in the Co catalyst is delocalized onto the metal via a metal-ligand bonding interaction, causing a spin transition and a distorted ligand framework. This orbital interaction explains the experimentally observed mild reduction potential and slow kinetics of the second reduction. The decreased hardness and doubly occupied d_z²-orbital facilitate a σ-bond with the CO₂-π* in an η¹-κC binding mode. CO₂ binding is only possible after two reductions resulting in an EEC mechanism (E = electron transfer, C = chemical reaction), and the second protonation is rate-limiting. In contrast, the Fe catalyst maintains a Lewis acidic metal center throughout the reduction process because the metal orbitals do not strongly mix with the qpy-π* orbitals. This allows binding of the activated CO₂ in an η²-binding mode. This interaction stabilizes the activated CO₂ via a π-type interaction of a Fe-t_2g orbital and the CO₂-π* and a dative bond of the oxygen lone pair. This facilitates CO₂ binding to a singly reduced catalyst resulting in an ECE mechanism. The barrier for CO₂ addition and the second protonation are higher than those for the Co catalyst and rate-limiting.

Recent Developments in Metalloporphyrin Electrocatalysts for Reduction of Small Molecules: Strategies for Managing Electron and Proton Transfer Reactions

Porphyrins are archetypal ligands in inorganic chemistry. The last 10 years have seen important new advances in the use of metalloporphyrins as catalysts in the activation and reduction of small molecules, in particular O₂ and CO₂ . Recent developments of new molecular designs, scaling relationships, and theoretical modeling of mechanisms have rapidly advanced the utility of porphyrins as electrocatalysts. This Minireview focuses on the summary and evaluation of recent developments of metalloporphyrin O₂ and CO₂ reduction electrocatalysts, with an emphasis on contrasting homogeneous and heterogeneous electrocatalysis. Comparisons for proposed reaction mechanisms are provided for both CO₂ and O₂ reduction, and ideas are proposed about how lessons from the last decade of research can lead to the development of practical, applied porphyrin-derived catalysts.

Carbon Dioxide Reduction Mediated by Iron Catalysts: Mechanism and Intermediates That Guide Selectivity

The reduction of carbon dioxide represents an ambitious target, with potential impact on several of the United Nations' sustainable development goals including climate action, renewable energy, sustainable cities, and communities. This process shares a common issue with other redox reactions involved in energy-related schemes (i.e., proton reduction to hydrogen and water oxidation to oxygen), that is, the need for a catalyst in order to proceed at sustainable rates. Moreover, the reduction of CO₂ faces an additional selectivity complication, since several products can be formed, including carbon monoxide, formic acid/formate, methanol, and methane. In this Mini-Review, we will discuss iron-based molecular catalysts that catalyze the reduction of CO₂, focusing in particular on the selectivity of the processes, which is rationalized and guided on the basis of the reaction mechanism. Inspired by the active sites of carbon monoxide dehydrogenases, several synthetic systems have been proposed for the reduction of CO₂; these are discussed in terms of key intermediates such as iron hydrides or Fe-CO₂ adducts, where the ligand coordination motif, together with the presence of co-additives such as Brønsted acids, nucleophiles, or CO₂ trapping moieties, can guide the selectivity of the reaction. A mechanistic comparison is traced with heterogeneous iron single-atom catalysts. Perspectives on the use of molecular catalysts in devices for sustainable reduction of CO₂ are finally given.

Research Progress in Conversion of CO2 to Valuable Fuels

Rapid growth in the world's economy depends on a significant increase in energy consumption. As is known, most of the present energy supply comes from coal, oil, and natural gas. The overreliance on fossil energy brings serious environmental problems in addition to the scarcity of energy. One of the most concerning environmental problems is the large contribution to global warming because of the massive discharge of CO₂ in the burning of fossil fuels. Therefore, many efforts have been made to resolve such issues. Among them, the preparation of valuable fuels or chemicals from greenhouse gas (CO₂) has attracted great attention because it has made a promising step toward simultaneously resolving the environment and energy problems. This article reviews the current progress in CO₂ conversion via different strategies, including thermal catalysis, electrocatalysis, photocatalysis, and photoelectrocatalysis. Inspired by natural photosynthesis, light-capturing agents including macrocycles with conjugated structures similar to chlorophyll have attracted increasing attention. Using such macrocycles as photosensitizers, photocatalysis, photoelectrocatalysis, or coupling with enzymatic reactions were conducted to fulfill the conversion of CO₂ with high efficiency and specificity. Recent progress in enzyme coupled to photocatalysis and enzyme coupled to photoelectrocatalysis were specially reviewed in this review. Additionally, the characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages of different conversion methods were also presented. We wish to provide certain constructive ideas for new investigators and deep insights into the research of CO₂ conversion.

Structure and photophysical and electrochemical properties of a copper porphyrin complex with a three-dimensional framework

Porphyrins and metalloporphyrins can generally show attractive structural motifs and interesting properties. A new copper porphyrin, namely poly[[μ-chlorido-[μ₅-5,10,15,20-tetrakis(pyridin-4-yl)-21H,23H-porphine]tricopper(I)] [aquadichloridocopper(II)]], {[Cu₃(C₄₀H₂₄N₈)Cl][CuCl₂(H₂O)]}_n (1), was synthesized by the self-assembly of copper chloride with 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(pyridin-4-yl)-21H,23H-porphine under solvothermal conditions. The structure of this copper porphyrin was characterized by single-crystal X-ray crystallography and elemental analysis. The porphyrin macrocycle shows a distorted saddle geometry, with the four pyrrole rings slightly distorted in an alternating mode either upwards or downwards. The copper ions show three-coordinated triangular and four-coordinated square-planar geometries. Every copper-porphyrin unit connects to 12 others via four μ₄-bridging Cu₂Cl moieties to complete the three-dimensional framework of compound 1, with isolated CuCl₂(H₂O) units located in the voids. This copper porphyrin displays a red photoluminescence. Electrochemical measurements showed that compound 1 has two redox waves (E_1/2 = -160 and 91 mV).

Transition metal-based catalysts for the electrochemical CO2 reduction: from atoms and molecules to nanostructured materials

An overview of the main strategies for the rational design of transition metal-based catalysts for the electrochemical conversion of CO₂, ranging from molecular systems to single-atom and nanostructured catalysts.