Nonadiabatic Dynamics of Photoexcited cis-Stilbene Using Ab Initio Multiple Spawning

Tipping the ultrafast photochemical balance of cis-stilbene

Multi-state nonadiabatic molecular dynamics simulations combined with MRSF-TDDFT have revealed that the quantum yield of photoproducts in cis-stilbene is dependent on the initial temperature of the ground state, thereby resolving controversies regarding the competition between isomerization and ring-closure reactions. Specifically, 4,4-dihydrophenanthrene (DHP) is preferentially formed at low temperatures, while trans-stilbene is favored at high temperatures. The ethylenic torsional motions ( θ ) are particularly coupled with the initial thermal condition, tipping the balance of the competition.

Sensitivity Analysis in Photodynamics: How Does the Electronic Structure Control cis-Stilbene Photodynamics?

The techniques of computational photodynamics are increasingly employed to unravel reaction mechanisms and interpret experiments. However, misinterpretations in nonadiabatic dynamics caused by inaccurate underlying potentials are often difficult to foresee. This work focuses on revealing the systematic errors in the nonadiabatic simulations due to the underlying potentials and suggests a thrifty approach to evaluate the sensitivity of the simulations to the potential. This issue is exemplified in the photochemistry of cis-stilbene, where similar experimental outcomes have been differently interpreted based on the electronic structure methods supporting nonadiabatic dynamics. We examine the predictions of cis-stilbene photochemistry using trajectory surface hopping methods coupled with various electronic structure methods (OM3-MRCISD, SA2-CASSCF, XMS-SA2-CASPT2, and XMS-SA3-CASPT2) and assess their ability to interpret experimental observations. While the excited-state lifetimes and calculated photoelectron spectra show consistency with experiments, the reaction quantum yields vary significantly: either completely suppressing cyclization or isomerization. Intriguingly, analyzing stationary points on the potential energy surface does not hint at any major discrepancy, making the electronic structure methods seemingly reliable when treated separately. We show that performing an ensemble of simulations with different potentials provides an estimate of the electronic structure sensitivity. However, this ensemble approach is costly. Thus, we propose running nonadiabatic simulations with an external bias at a resource-efficient underlying potential (semiempirical or machine-learned) for the sensitivity analysis. We demonstrate this approach using a semiempirical OM3-MRCISD method with a harmonic bias toward cyclization.

An ab initio study on the photoisomerization in 2-styrylpyridine

We report results of a theoretical study on photoinduced processes in 2-styrylpyridine. The geometries and the relative energies of the possible conformers were investigated using the second-order Møller-Plesset (MP2) and algebraic diagrammatic construction to second-order (ADC(2)) methods and the cc-pVTZ basis set. The complete active space self consistent field (CASSCF) method is used for locating the minimum-energy conical intersection (MECI) geometries between the S0 and S1 states. In addition to the twisted-pyramidalized MECI points along the trans and cis isomerization pathways, S1/S0 cooperating-ring MECI and cyclized-ring MECI structures, lying on the cyclization pathways of cis-2-styrylpyridine, were also located. Except the twisted pyramidalized CI2 and cyclized Cyc-CI3, all the other MECI points are found to be accessible from either one or more Franck-Condon points. The possibilities for the cis-trans isomerization and cyclization processes are discussed along the image-dependent pair potential (IDPP) paths.

Photoisomerization pathways of trans-resveratrol

Resveratrol is well-known for promoting health benefits due to its antioxidant, anti-aging, anti-carcinogenic, and other beneficial activities. Understanding the photophysics of resveratrol is essential for determining its applicability to pharmaceutical innovations. In the present work, we used an explore-then-assess strategy to map the internal conversion pathways of trans-resveratrol. This strategy consists of exploring the multidimensional configurational space with nonadiabatic dynamics simulations based on a semiempirical multireference method, followed by a feasibility assessment of reduced-dimensionality pathways at a high ab initio theoretical level. The exploration step revealed that internal conversion to the ground state may occur near five distinct conical intersections. The assessment step showed that the main photoisomerization pathway involves a twisted-pyramidalized S1/S0 conical intersection, yielding either trans or cis isomers. However, a secondary path was identified, where cis-trans isomerization happens in the excited state and internal conversion occurs at a cyclic conical intersection, yielding a closed-ring resveratrol derivative. This derivative, which can be formed through this direct path or an indirect photoexcitation, may be connected to the production of oxygen-reactive species previously reported and have implications in photodynamic therapy.

Development of Parallel On-the-Fly Algorithm for Global Exploration of Conical Intersection Seam Space

Conical intersection (CI) seams are configuration spaces of a molecular system where two or more (spin) adiabatic electronic states are degenerate in energy. They play essential roles in photochemistry because nonradiative decays often occur near the minima of the seam, i.e., the minimum energy CIs (MECIs). Thus, it is important to explore the CI seams and discover the MECIs. Although various approaches exist for CI seam exploration, most of them are local in nature, requiring reasonable initial guesses of geometries and nuclear gradients during the search. Global search algorithms, on the other hand, are powerful because they can fully sample the configurational space and locate important MECIs missed by local algorithms. However, global algorithms are often computationally expensive for large systems due to their poor scalability with respect to the number of degrees of freedom. To overcome this challenge, we develop the parallel on-the-fly Crystal algorithm to globally explore the CI seam space, taking advantage of its superior scaling behavior. Specifically, Crystal is coupled with on-the-fly evaluations of the excited and ground state energies using multireference electronic structure methods. Meanwhile, the algorithm is parallelized to further boost its computational efficiency. The effectiveness of this new algorithm is tested for three types of molecular photoswitches of significant importance in material and biomedical sciences: photostatin (PST), stilbene, and butadiene. A rudimentary implementation of the algorithm is applied to PST and stilbene, resulting in the discovery of all previously identified MECIs and several new ones. A refined version of the algorithm, combined with a systematic clustering technique, is applied to butadiene, resulting in the identification of an unprecedented number of energetically accessible MECIs. The results demonstrate that the parallel on-the-fly Crystal algorithm is a powerful tool for automated global CI seam exploration.

Excited State Dynamics in Unidirectional Photochemical Molecular Motors

Unidirectional photochemically driven molecular motors (PMMs) convert the energy of absorbed light into continuous rotational motion. As such they are key components in the design of molecular machines. The prototypical and most widely employed class of PMMs is the overcrowded alkenes, where rotational motion is driven by successive photoisomerization and thermal helix inversion steps. The efficiency of such PMMs depends upon the speed of rotation, determined by the rate of ground state thermal helix inversion, and the quantum yield of photoisomerization, which is dependent on the excited state energy landscape. The former has been optimized by synthetic modification across three generations of overcrowded alkene PMMs. These improvements have often been at the expense of photoisomerization yield, where there remains room for improvement. In this perspective we review the application of ultrafast spectroscopy to characterize the excited state dynamics in PMMs. These measurements lead to a general mechanism for all generations of PMMs, involving subpicosecond decay of a Franck-Condon excited state to populate a dark excited state which decays within picoseconds via conical intersections with the electronic ground state. The model is discussed in the context of excited state dynamics calculations. Studies of PMM photochemical dynamics as a function of solvent suggest exploitation of intramolecular charge transfer and solvent polarity as a route to controlling photoisomerization yield. A test of these ideas for a first generation motor reveals a high degree of solvent control over isomerization yield. These results suggest a pathway to fine control over the performance of future PMMs.

Ultrafast electronic relaxation pathways of the molecular photoswitch quadricyclane

The light-induced ultrafast switching between molecular isomers norbornadiene and quadricyclane can reversibly store and release a substantial amount of chemical energy. Prior work observed signatures of ultrafast molecular dynamics in both isomers upon ultraviolet excitation but could not follow the electronic relaxation all the way back to the ground state experimentally. Here we study the electronic relaxation of quadricyclane after exciting in the ultraviolet (201 nanometres) using time-resolved gas-phase extreme ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy combined with non-adiabatic molecular dynamics simulations. We identify two competing pathways by which electronically excited quadricyclane molecules relax to the electronic ground state. The fast pathway (<100 femtoseconds) is distinguished by effective coupling to valence electronic states, while the slow pathway involves initial motions across Rydberg states and takes several hundred femtoseconds. Both pathways facilitate interconversion between the two isomers, albeit on different timescales, and we predict that the branching ratio of norbornadiene/quadricyclane products immediately after returning to the electronic ground state is approximately 3:2.

4a,4b-Dihydrophenanthrene → cis-stilbene photoconversion: TD-DFT/DFT study

CONTEXT

DHP → CS photoconversion was analyzed in terms of electron density redistribution for the first time. The following explanation for the non-recovery of the C4a-C4b bond upon CS relaxation is proposed: during this process, the Coulomb repulsion energy between these pairs of atoms increases by almost one and a half times, and their bonding by an electron at LUMO is insufficient to recover the C4a-C4b bond. According to calculations, upon CS relaxation, the linker connecting the benzene rings undergoes significant structural changes. In this case, the distance between the C4a and C4b atoms increases from 3.00 Å to 3.28 Å. Calculations showed that the C4a-C4b vibration of the DHP bond has a very low intensity. Therefore, thermal motion does not contribute to the rupture of this bond.

METHODS

All calculations were performed using the Gaussian16 software package at the B3LYP/6-311 +  + G(d,p)/IEFPCM theory level. B3LYP was the only hybrid functional supported by Gaussian16, which ensured the cleavage of the C4a-C4b bond of DHP while optimizing its S1 excited state. A quantitative description of the redistribution of electron density in the studied conformers was carried out using the analysis of the NPA of atomic charges. Cyclohexane was used as an implicitly specified non-polar solvent. Visualization of molecular orbitals, and electron densities, as well as plotting of calculated IR spectra, were performed using the Gaussview6 software package.

Ultrafast Raman observation of the perpendicular intermediate phantom state of stilbene photoisomerization

Trans-cis photoisomerization is generally described by a model in which the reaction proceeds via a common intermediate having a perpendicular conformation around the rotating bond, irrespective of from which isomer the reaction starts. Nevertheless, such an intermediate has yet to be identified unambiguously, and it is often called the 'phantom' state. Here we present the structural identification of the common, perpendicular intermediate of stilbene photoisomerization using ultrafast Raman spectroscopy. Our results reveal ultrafast birth and decay of an identical, short-lived transient that exhibits a vibrational signature characteristic of the perpendicular state upon photoexcitation of the trans and cis forms. In combination with ab initio molecular dynamics simulations, it is shown that the photoexcited trans and cis forms are funnelled off to the ground state through the same, perpendicular intermediate.

Impact of the core on the inter-branch exciton exchange in dendrimers

Organic dendrimers with π conjugated systems are capable of capturing solar energy as a renewable source for human use. Nonetheless, further study regarding the relationship between the structure and the energy transfer mechanism in these types of molecules is still necessary. In this work, nonadiabatic excited state molecular dynamics (NEXMD) were carried out to study the intra- and inter-branch exciton migration in two tetra-branched dendrimers, C(dSSB)₄ and Ad(BuSSB)₄, which differ in their respective carbon and adamantane core. Both systems undergo a ladder decay mechanism between excited states, with back-and-forth transitions between S₁ and S₂. Despite presenting very similar absorption-emission spectra, differences in the photoinduced energy relaxation are observed. The size of the core impacts the inter-branch energy exchange and transient exciton localization/delocalization, which ultimately condition the relative energy relaxation rates, being faster in Ad(BuSSB)₄ with respect to C(dSSB)₄. Nevertheless, the photoinduced processes lead to a progressive final exciton-self-trapping in one of the branches of both dendrimers, which is a desirable feature in organic photovoltaic applications. Our results can inspire the design of more efficient dendrimers with the desired magnitude of inter-branch exciton exchange and localization/delocalization according to changes in their core.

Ultrafast Ring Closure Reaction of Gaseous cis-Stilbene from S1(ππ*)

cis-Stilbene (cis-St) is a well-known benchmark system for cis-trans photoisomerization. cis-St also produces 4a,4b-dihydrophenanthrene (DHP) in solution with a quantum yield of less than 0.19. The ring closure reaction, however, has never been identified for gaseous cis-St, and a recent computational simulation predicted the quantum yield of DHP to be only 0.04. In the present study, we identified an ultrafast ring closure reaction of gaseous cis-St for the first time using extreme ultraviolet time-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy. Surface hopping trajectory calculations at the SA3-XMS-CASPT2(2,2) level of theory reproduce the features of the observed time-resolved photoelectron spectra and predict the cis-St:DHP:trans-St branching ratio to be 0.55:0.41:0.04, in contrast with previous estimates. The results indicate that photoexcited cis-St favors ring closure over cis-trans isomerization under the isolated condition.

Multi-state Energy Landscape for Photoreaction of Stilbene and Dimethyl-stilbene

We have recently developed the reaction space projector (ReSPer) method, which constructs a reduced-dimensionality reaction space uniquely determined from reference reaction paths for a polyatomic molecular system and projects classical trajectories into the same reaction space. In this paper, we extend ReSPer to the analysis of photoreaction dynamics and relaxation processes of stilbene and present the concept of a "multi-state energy landscape," incorporating the ground- and excited-state reaction subspaces. The multi-state energy landscape successfully explains the previously established photoreaction processes of cis-stilbene, such as the cis-trans photoisomerization and photocyclization. In addition, we discuss the difference in the excited-state reaction dynamics between stilbene and 1,1'-dimethyl stilbene based on a common reaction subspace determined from the framework part of reference structures with different number of atoms. This approach allows us to target any molecule with a common framework, greatly expanding the applicability of the ReSPer analysis. The multi-state energy landscape provides fruitful insight into photochemical reactions, exploring the excited- and ground-state potential energy surfaces, as well as comprehensive reaction processes with nonradiative transitions between adiabatic states, within the stage of a reduced-dimensionality reaction space.

E/Z photoisomerization pathway in pristine and fluorinated di(3-furyl)ethenes

We report an XMCQDPT2 study of the E/Z photoisomerization in a series of fluorinated di(3-furyl)ethenes (3DFEs). Upon excitation, pristine and low-fluorinated 3DFE show conventional behavior of many diarylethenes: unhindered twisting motion toward the pyramidalized zwitterionic state where relaxation to the ground state occurs. However, deep fluorination of 3DFEs can hamper E-to-Z isomerization by giving rise to an alternative excited-state relaxation pathway: an out-of-plane motion of a ring fluorine atom. Importantly, the case of fluorinated 3DFEs reveals serious deficiencies of the popular TDDFT approach. With some commonly used exchange-correlation functionals, the alternative relaxation pathway is not reproduced and, moreover, an irrelevant ring rotation coordinate is predicted instead. Nevertheless, TDDFT remains qualitatively adequate for the E-to-Z twisting coordinate taken alone.

Fast Screening of Minimum Energy Crossing Points with Semiempirical Tight-Binding Methods

The investigation of photochemical processes is a highly active field in computational chemistry. One research direction is the automated exploration and identification of minimum energy conical intersection (MECI) geometries. However, due to the immense technical effort required to calculate nonadiabatic potential energy landscapes, the routine application of such computational protocols is severely limited. In this study, we will discuss the prospect of combining adiabatic potential energy surfaces from semiempirical quantum mechanical calculations with specialized confinement potential and metadynamics simulations to identify S₀/T₁ minimum energy crossing point (MECP) geometries. It is shown that MECPs calculated at the GFN2-xTB level can provide suitable approximations to high-level S₀/S₁ab initio conical intersection geometries at a fraction of the computational cost. Reference MECIs of benzene are studied to illustrate the basic concept. An example application of the presented protocol is demonstrated for a set of photoswitch molecules.

Different timescales during ultrafast stilbene isomerization in the gas and liquid phases revealed using time-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy

Directly contrasting ultrafast excited-state dynamics in the gas and liquid phases is crucial to understanding the influence of complex environments. Previous studies have often relied on different spectroscopic observables, rendering direct comparisons challenging. Here, we apply extreme-ultraviolet time-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy to both gaseous and liquid cis-stilbene, revealing the coupled electronic and nuclear dynamics that underlie its isomerization. Our measurements track the excited-state wave packets from excitation along the complete reaction path to the final products. We observe coherent excited-state vibrational dynamics in both phases of matter that persist to the final products, enabling the characterization of the branching space of the S₁-S₀ conical intersection. We observe a systematic lengthening of the relaxation timescales in the liquid phase and a red shift of the measured excited-state frequencies that is most pronounced for the complex reaction coordinate. These results characterize in detail the influence of the liquid environment on both electronic and structural dynamics during a complete photochemical transformation.

Coupled Electron Pair-Type Approximations for Tensor Product State Wave Functions

Size extensivity, defined as the correct scaling of energy with system size, is a desirable property for any many-body method. Traditional configuration interaction (CI) methods are not size extensive, hence the error increases as the system gets larger. Coupled electron pair approximation (CEPA) methods can be constructed as simple extensions of a truncated CI that ensures size extensivity. One of the major issues with the CEPA and its variants is that singularities arise in the amplitude equations when the system starts to be strongly correlated. In this work, we extend the traditional Slater determinant based coupled electron pair approaches like CEPA-0, averaged coupled-pair functional, and average quadratic coupled-cluster to a new formulation based on tensor product states (TPS). We show that a TPS basis can often be chosen such that it removes the singularities that commonly destroy the accuracy of CEPA based methods. A suitable TPS representation can be formed by partitioning the system into separate disjoint clusters and forming the final wave function as the tensor product of the many body states of these clusters. We demonstrate the application of these methods on simple bond breaking systems such as CH₄ and F₂ where determinant based CEPA methods fail. We further apply the TPS-CEPA approach to stillbene isomerization and few planar π-conjugated systems. Overall, the results show that the TPS-CEPA method can remove the singularities and provide improved numerical results compared to common electronic structure methods.

Chiral photochemistry of achiral molecules

Chirality is a molecular property governed by the topography of the potential energy surface (PES). Thermally achiral molecules interconvert rapidly when the interconversion barrier between the two enantiomers is comparable to or lower than the thermal energy, in contrast to thermally stable chiral configurations. In principle, a change in the PES topography on the excited electronic state may diminish interconversion, leading to electronically prochiral molecules that can be converted from achiral to chiral by electronic excitation. Here we report that this is the case for two prototypical examples – cis-stilbene and cis-stiff stilbene. Both systems exhibit unidirectional photoisomerization for each enantiomer as a result of their electronic prochirality. We simulate an experiment to demonstrate this effect in cis-stilbene based on its interaction with circularly polarized light. Our results highlight the drastic change in chiral behavior upon electronic excitation, opening up the possibility for asymmetric photochemistry from an effectively nonchiral starting point.

The authors report non-adiabatic first principles molecular dynamics to show how an achiral molecule can be converted to a chiral one upon photoexcitation. These results demonstrate the possibility of asymmetric photochemistry starting from achiral reactants.

Scalable Ehrenfest Molecular Dynamics Exploiting the Locality of Density-Functional Tight-Binding Hamiltonian

To explore the science behind excited-state dynamics in high-complexity chemical systems, a scalable nonadiabatic molecular dynamics (MD) technique is indispensable. In this study, by treating the electronic degrees of freedom at the density-functional tight-binding level, we developed and implemented a reduced scaling and multinode-parallelizable Ehrenfest MD method. To achieve this goal, we introduced a concept called patchwork approximation (PA), where the effective Hamiltonian for real-time propagation of the electronic density matrix is partitioned into a set of local parts. Numerical results for giant icosahedral fullerenes, which comprise up to 6000 atoms, suggest that the scaling of the present PA-based method is less than quadratic, which yields a significant advantage over the conventional cubic scaling method in terms of computational time. The acceleration by the parallelization on multiple nodes was also assessed. Furthermore, the electronic and structural dynamics resulting from the perturbation by the external electric field were accurately reproduced with the PA, even when the electronic excitation was spatially delocalized.

Unmasking the cis-Stilbene Phantom State via Vacuum Ultraviolet Time-Resolved Photoelectron Spectroscopy and Ab Initio Multiple Spawning

We present the first vacuum ultraviolet time-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy (VUV-TRPES) study of photoisomerization dynamics in the paradigmatic molecule cis-stilbene. A key reaction intermediate in its dynamics, known as the phantom state, has often been invoked but never directly detected in the gas phase. We report direct spectral signatures of the phantom state in isolated cis-stilbene, observed and characterized through a combination of VUV-TRPES and ab initio multiple spawning (AIMS) nonadiabatic dynamics simulations of the channel-resolved observable. The high VUV probe photon energy tracks the complete excited-state dynamics via multiple photoionization channels, from initial excitation to its return to the "hot" ground state. The TRPES was compared with AIMS simulations of the dynamics from initial excitation, to the phantom-state intermediate (an S₁ minimum), through to the ultimate electronic decay to the ground state. This combination revealed the unique spectral signatures and time-dependent dynamics of the phantom-state intermediate, permitting us to report here its direct observation.

Quantum transition probabilities due to overlapping electromagnetic pulses: Persistent differences between Dirac's form and nonadiabatic perturbation theory

The probability of transition to an excited state of a quantum system in a time-dependent electromagnetic field determines the energy uptake from the field. The standard expression for the transition probability has been given by Dirac. Landau and Lifshitz suggested, instead, that the adiabatic effects of a perturbation should be excluded from the transition probability, leaving an expression in terms of the nonadiabatic response. In our previous work, we have found that these two approaches yield different results while a perturbing field is acting on the system. Here, we prove, for the first time, that differences between the two approaches may persist after the perturbing fields have been completely turned off. We have designed a pair of overlapping pulses in order to establish the possibility of lasting differences, in a case with dephasing. Our work goes beyond the analysis presented by Landau and Lifshitz, since they considered only linear response and required that a constant perturbation must remain as t → ∞. First, a "plateau" pulse populates an excited rotational state and produces coherences between the ground and excited states. Then, an infrared pulse acts while the electric field of the first pulse is constant, but after dephasing has occurred. The nonadiabatic perturbation theory permits dephasing, but dephasing of the perturbed part of the wave function cannot occur within Dirac's method. When the frequencies in both pulses are on resonance, the lasting differences in the calculated transition probabilities may exceed 35%. The predicted differences are larger for off-resonant perturbations.

Unprecedentedly Ultrafast Dynamics of Excited States of C═C Photoswitching Molecules in Nanocrystals and Microcrystals

The C═C photoswitching molecules [1,2-di(4-pyridyl)ethylene (DPE), 4-styrylpyridine (SP), and trans-1,2-stilbene (TS)] show favorable photoisomerization characteristics. Although the solid states of photoswitching molecules are usually used in optical devices, their excited state's evolution has been little explored. Here, the excited state's relaxation of DPE, SP, and TS in nanocrystal/microcrystal suspensions as well as in solution phase was studied to uncover the early events of their excited states. The dynamics of nanocrystal/microcrystal suspensions was tremendously accelerated in comparison to the kinetics obtained in the solution for these molecules under excitation. DPE exhibits the slowest decay rate, while SP shows the fastest decay rate in nanocrystal suspensions or solution, suggesting SP may be the best candidate for the photoswitching device. The intermolecular interactions and space restriction of the crystal lead to the acceleration of the excited state's evolution for DPE, SP, and TS. This provides new insight into the design of optical materials.

PySpawn: Software for Nonadiabatic Quantum Molecular Dynamics

The ab initio multiple spawning (AIMS) method enables nonadiabatic quantum molecular dynamics simulations in an arbitrary number of dimensions, with potential energy surfaces provided by electronic structure calculations performed on-the-fly. However, the intricacy of the AIMS algorithm complicates software development, deployment on modern shared computer resources, and postsimulation data analysis. PySpawn is a nonadiabatic molecular dynamics software package that addresses these issues. The program is designed to be easily interfaced with electronic structure software, and an interface to the TeraChem software package is described here. PySpawn introduces a task-based reorganization of the AIMS algorithm, allowing fine-grained restart capability and setting the stage for efficient parallelization in a future release. PySpawn includes a user-friendly and interactive Python analysis module that will enable novice users to painlessly adopt AIMS. As a demonstration of PySpawn's simulation capability and analysis module, we report complete active space self-consistent field-based AIMS simulations of the 1,2-dithienyl-1,2-dicyanoethene molecule, a promising molecular photoswitch.