Impact of Internal Fragments on Top-Down Analysis of Intact Proteins by 193 nm UVPD

A Fast Neural Network for Isotopic Charge State Assignment

Electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry is an essential technique for chemical analysis in a range of fields. In ESI, analytes can produce multiple charge states, which must be correctly assigned for identification. Existing approaches to charge state assignment can suffer from limited accuracy or poor speed. Here, we developed a fast neural network to perform isotopic envelope charge assignment. The performance of our algorithm, IsoDec, was demonstrated on top-down proteomics spectra collected on diverse instruments. On these highly complex individual spectra, we found that IsoDec correctly assigns more features compared to existing software tools while simultaneously providing improved speed and accuracy. Importantly, this performance enhancement stems directly from the neural network charge assignment approach and not simply from improved scoring and filtering of isotopic envelopes. Finally, when applied to large top-down proteomics data sets, we discovered that database searching of the IsoDec deconvolution output produces proteoform-spectrum matches with a better combination of coverage and accuracy. Overall, IsoDec provides a compelling demonstration of the potential of lightweight neural networks in mass spectrometry data analysis for diverse applications.

Revealing Unpredicted Aspartic Acid Isomerization Hotspots by Probing Diagnostic Fragmentation Propensities in Top-Down and Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry

Isomerization of aspartic acid residues is a relevant degradation pathway of protein biopharmaceuticals as it can impair their biological activity. However, the in silico prediction of isomerization hotspots and their consequences remains ambiguous and misleading. We have previously shown that all ion differential analysis (AiDA) of middle-down spectra can be used to reveal diagnostic terminal and internal fragments with more sensitivity than the conventional fragment ion mass matching methodology. In this study, we use AiDA to characterize the degradation of an antibody fragment at three aspartic acid isomerization sites including a novel DW motif directly with electron-transfer/higher-energy collisional dissociation top-down and middle-down mass spectrometry. We show that AiDA methodology is pivotal to probe diagnostic fragmentation propensities of terminal c and z fragments at the N-terminus and vicinity of isomerization sites in addition to the diagnostic c+57 terminal fragments. Furthermore, AiDA can probe remote structural changes in the loop of an antibody complementarity-determining region induced by isomerization and the succinimide intermediate, revealing interactions between residues in agreement with molecular simulations. This study shows that aspartic acid residues at noncanonical DW and DF motifs can be hotspots for isomerization despite being ranked as false positives in physics-based prediction models. We show that the enzyme-free, fast, and sensitive AiDA methodology can be used as an orthogonal technique to fractionation for online variant characterization.

Photolysis of the peptide bond at 193 and 222 nm

Ultraviolet (UV) light is a well-established tool for fragmenting peptides in vacuum. This study investigates the fragmentation of peptides using 193 and 222 nm light in aqueous solution. Changes in the absorption spectra of solutions of the model dipeptide glycylglycine are monitored using a combination of real-time in situ transmission measurements and UV-Vis spectroscopy to report peptide bond scission following UV irradiation. Irradiation by a broadband ultraviolet light source flattens the absorbance peak centered near 193 nm, indicating cleavage of peptide bonds. Irradiation with low-intensity, monochromatic 193 and 222 nm light enabled measurements of the single-photon quantum yield of peptide bond scission, found to be (1.50 ± 0.12)% at 193 nm and (0.16 ± 0.03)% at 222 nm. These findings indicate that peptides may be fragmented in solution prior to emission into a mass spectrometer for new types of single-molecule analyses. The susceptibility of peptide bonds to ultraviolet radiation also suggests limited lifetimes for peptides on the early Earth's surface, which are relevant to theories of the origins-of-life, and suggests a role for protein damage in explanations of the germicidal effect of 222 nm light exposure.

Development of Top-Down Mass Spectrometry Strategies in the Chromatographic Time Scale (LC-TD-MS) for the Extended Characterization of an Anti-EGFR Single-Domain Antibody-Drug Conjugate in Both Reduced and Nonreduced Forms

Even though mAbs have attracted the biggest interest in the development of therapeutic proteins, next-generation therapeutics such as single-domain antibodies (sdAb) are propelling increasing attention as new alternatives with appealing applications in different clinical areas. These constructs are small therapeutic proteins formed by a variable domain of the heavy chain of an antibody with multiple therapeutic and production benefits compared with their mAb counterparts. These proteins can be subjected to different bioconjugation processes to form single-domain antibody-drug conjugates (sdADCs) and hence increase their therapeutic potency, and akin to other therapeutic proteins, nanobodies and related products require dedicated analytical strategies to fully characterize their primary structure prior to their release to the market. In this study, we report for the first time the extensive sequence characterization of a conjugated anti-EGFR 14 kDa sdADC by using state-of-the-art top-down mass spectrometry strategies in combination with liquid chromatography (LC-TD-MS). Mass analysis revealed a highly homogeneous sample with one conjugated molecule. Subsequently, the reduced sdADC was submitted to different fragmentation techniques, namely, higher-energy collisional dissociation, electron-transfer dissociation, and electron-transfer higher-energy collision dissociation, allowing to unambiguously assess the conjugation site with 24 diagnostic fragment ions and 85% of global sequence coverage. The sequence coverage of the nonreduced protein was significantly lower (around 16%); however, the analysis of the fragmentation spectra corroborated the presence of the intramolecular disulfide bridge along with the localization of the conjugation site. Altogether, our results pinpoint the difficulties and challenges associated with the fragmentation of sdAb-derived formats in the LC time scale due to their remarkable stability as a consequence of the intramolecular disulfide bridge. However, the use of complementary activation techniques along with the identification of specific ion fragments allows an improved sequence coverage, the characterization of the intramolecular disulfide bond, and the unambiguous localization of the conjugation site.

Leveraging Ion-Ion and Ion-Photon Activation to Improve the Sequencing of Proteins Carrying Multiple Disulfide Bonds: The Human Serum Albumin Case Study

Gas-phase sequencing of large intact proteins (>30 kDa) via tandem mass spectrometry is an inherently challenging process that is further complicated by the extensive overlap of multiply charged product ion peaks, often characterized by a low signal-to-noise ratio. Disulfide bonds exacerbate this issue because of the need to cleave both the S-S and backbone bonds to liberate sequence informative fragments. Although electron-based ion activation techniques such as electron transfer dissociation (ETD) have been proven to rupture disulfide bonds in whole protein ions, they still struggle to produce extensive sequencing when multiple, concatenated S-S bonds are present on the same large polypeptide chain. Here, we evaluate the increase in sequence coverage obtained by combining activated-ion ETD (AI-ETD) and proton transfer charge reduction (PTCR) in the analysis of 66 kDa human serum albumin, which holds 17 disulfide bridges. We also describe the combination of AI-ETD with supplemental postactivation of the ETD reaction products via higher-energy collisional dissociation─a hybrid fragmentation method termed AI-EThcD. AI-EThcD leads to a further improvement compared to AI-ETD in both the global number of cleaved backbone bonds and the number of ruptured backbone bonds from disulfide-protected regions. Our results also demonstrate that the full potential of AI-ETD and AI-EThcD is unveiled only when combined with PTCR: reduction in overlap of ion signals leads to a sequence coverage as high as 39% in a single experiment, highlighting the relevance of spectral simplification in top-down mass spectrometry of large proteins.

Are Internal Fragments Observable in Electron Based Top-Down Mass Spectrometry?

Protein tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) often generates sequence-informative fragments from backbone bond cleavages near the termini. This lack of fragmentation in the protein interior is particularly apparent in native top-down mass spectrometry (MS). Improved sequence coverage, critical for reliable annotation of posttranslational modifications and sequence variants, may be obtained from internal fragments generated by multiple backbone cleavage events. However, internal fragment assignments can be error prone due to isomeric/isobaric fragments from different parts of a protein sequence. Also, internal fragment generation propensity depends on the chosen MS/MS activation strategy. Here, we examine internal fragment formation in electron capture dissociation (ECD) and electron transfer dissociation (ETD) following native and denaturing MS, as well as LC/MS of several proteins. Experiments were undertaken on multiple instruments, including quadrupole time-of-flight, Orbitrap, and high-field Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) across four laboratories. ECD was performed at both ultrahigh vacuum and at similar pressure to ETD conditions. Two complementary software packages were used for data analysis. When feasible, ETD-higher energy collision dissociation MS3 was performed to validate/refute potential internal fragment assignments, including differentiating MS3 fragmentation behavior of radical versus even-electron primary fragments. We show that, under typical operating conditions, internal fragments cannot be confidently assigned in ECD or ETD. On the other hand, such fragments, along with some b-type terminal fragments (not typically observed in ECD/ETD spectra) appear at atypical ECD operating conditions, suggesting they originate from a separate ion-electron activation process. Furthermore, atypical fragment ion types, e.g., x ions, are observed at such conditions as well as upon EThcD, presumably due to vibrational activation of radical z-type ions.

Mass spectrometry-intensive top-down proteomics: an update on technology advancements and biomedical applications

Proteoforms are all forms of protein molecules from the same gene because of variations at the DNA, RNA, and protein levels, e.g., alternative splicing and post-translational modifications (PTMs). Delineation of proteins in a proteoform-specific manner is crucial for understanding their biological functions. Mass spectrometry (MS)-intensive top-down proteomics (TDP) is promising for comprehensively characterizing intact proteoforms in complex biological systems. It has achieved substantial progress in technological development, including sample preparation, proteoform separations, MS instrumentation, and bioinformatics tools. In a single TDP study, thousands of proteoforms can be identified and quantified from a cell lysate. It has also been applied to various biomedical research to better our understanding of protein function in regulating cellular processes and to discover novel proteoform biomarkers of diseases for early diagnosis and therapeutic development. This review covers the most recent technological development and biomedical applications of MS-intensive TDP.

Tracking Inhibition of Human Small C-Terminal Domain Phosphatase 1 Using 193 nm Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry

Working in tandem with kinases via a dynamic interplay of phosphorylation and dephosphorylation of proteins, phosphatases regulate many cellular processes and thus represent compelling therapeutic targets. Here we leverage ultraviolet photodissociation to shed light on the binding characteristics of two covalent phosphatase inhibitors, T65 and rabeprazole, and their respective interactions with the human small C-terminal domain phosphatase 1 (SCP1) and its single-point mutant C181A, in which a nonreactive alanine replaces one key reactive cysteine. Top-down MS/MS analysis is used to localize the binding of T65 and rabeprazole on the two proteins and estimate the relative reactivities of each cysteine residue.

Panda-UV Unlocks Deeper Protein Characterization with Internal Fragments in Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry

Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) mass spectrometry unlocks insights into the protein structure and sequence through fragmentation patterns. While N- and C-terminal fragments are traditionally relied upon, this work highlights the critical role of internal fragments in achieving near-complete sequencing of protein. Previous limitations of internal fragment utilization, owing to their abundance and potential for random matching, are addressed here with the development of Panda-UV, a novel software tool combining spectral calibration, and Pearson correlation coefficient scoring for confident fragment assignment. Panda-UV showcases its power through comprehensive benchmarks on three model proteins. The inclusion of internal fragments boosts identified fragment numbers by 26% and enhances average protein sequence coverage to a remarkable 93% for intact proteins, unlocking the hidden region of the largest protein carbonic anhydrase II in model proteins. Notably, an average of 65% of internal fragments can be identified in multiple replicates, demonstrating the high confidence of the fragments Panda-UV provided. Finally, the sequence coverages of mAb subunits can be increased up to 86% and the complementary determining regions (CDRs) are nearly completely sequenced in a single experiment. The source codes of Panda-UV are available at https://github.com/PHOENIXcenter/Panda-UV.

Internal Fragments Enhance Middle-Down Mass Spectrometry Structural Characterization of Monoclonal Antibodies and Antibody-Drug Conjugates

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) are important large biotherapeutics (∼150 kDa) and high structural complexity that require extensive sequence and structure characterization. Middle-down mass spectrometry (MD-MS) is an emerging technique that sequences and maps subunits larger than those released by trypsinolysis. It avoids potentially introducing artifactual modifications that may occur in bottom-up MS while achieving higher sequence coverage compared to top-down MS. However, returning complete sequence information by MD-MS is still challenging. Here, we show that assigning internal fragments in direct infusion MD-MS of a mAb and an ADC substantially improves their structural characterization. For MD-MS of the reduced NIST mAb, including internal fragments recovers nearly 100% of the sequence by accessing the middle sequence region that is inaccessible by terminal fragments. The identification of important glycosylations can also be improved after the inclusion of internal fragments. For the reduced lysine-linked IgG1-DM1 ADC, we show that considering internal fragments increases the DM1 conjugation sites coverage to 80%, comparable to the reported 83% coverage achieved by peptide mapping on the same ADC (Luo et al. Anal. Chem. 2016, 88, 695-702). This study expands our work on the application of internal fragment assignments in top-down MS of mAbs and ADCs and can be extended to other heterogeneous therapeutic molecules such as multispecifics and fusion proteins for more widespread applications.

Enhancing Top-Down Analysis of Proteins by Combining Ultraviolet Photodissociation (UVPD), Proton-Transfer Charge Reduction (PTCR), and Gas-Phase Fractionation to Alleviate the Impact of Nondissociated Precursor Ions

Recent advances in top-down mass spectrometry strategies continue to improve the analysis of intact proteins. 193 nm ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) is one method well-suited for top-down analysis. UVPD is often performed using relatively low photon flux in order to limit multiple-generation dissociation of fragment ions and maximize sequence coverage. Consequently, a large portion of the precursor ion survives the UVPD process, dominates the spectrum, and may impede identification of fragment ions. Here, we explore the isolation of subpopulations of fragment ions lower and higher than the precursor ion after UVPD as a means to eliminate the impact of the surviving precursor ion on the detection of low abundance fragment ions. This gas-phase fractionation method improved sequence coverage harvested from fragment ions found in the m/z regions lower and higher than the precursor by an average factor of 1.3 and 2.3, respectively. Combining this gas-phase fractionation method with proton transfer charge reduction (PTCR) further increased the sequence coverage obtained from these m/z regions by another factor of 1.3 and 1.4, respectively. Implementing a post-UVPD fractionation + PTCR strategy with six fractionation events resulted in a sequence coverage of 75% for enolase, the highest reported for 193 nm UVPD.

Improved characterization of trastuzumab deruxtecan with PTCR and internal fragments implemented in middle-down MS workflows

Antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) are highly complex proteins mainly due to the structural microvariability of the mAb, along with the additional heterogeneity afforded by the bioconjugation process. Top-down (TD) and middle-down (MD) strategies allow the straightforward fragmentation of proteins to elucidate the conjugated amino acid residues. Nevertheless, these spectra are very crowded with multiple overlapping and unassigned ion fragments. Here we report on the use of dedicated software (ClipsMS) and application of proton transfer charge reduction (PTCR), to respectively expand the fragment ion search space to internal fragments and improve the separation of overlapping fragment ions for a more comprehensive characterization of a recently approved ADC, trastuzumab deruxtecan (T-DXd). Subunit fragmentation allowed between 70 and 90% of sequence coverage to be obtained. Upon addition of internal fragment assignment, the three subunits were fully sequenced, although internal fragments did not contribute significantly to the localization of the payloads. Finally, the use of PTCR after subunit fragmentation provided a moderate sequence coverage increase between 2 and 13%. The reaction efficiently decluttered the fragmentation spectra allowing increasing the number of fragment ions characteristic of the conjugation site by 1.5- to 2.5-fold. Altogether, these results show the interest in the implementation of internal fragment ion searches and more particularly the use of PTCR reactions to increase the number of signature ions to elucidate the conjugation sites and enhance the overall sequence coverage of ADCs, making this approach particularly appealing for its implementation in R&D laboratories.

Recent advances in structural mass spectrometry methods in the context of biosimilarity assessment: from sequence heterogeneities to higher order structures

Biotherapeutics and their biosimilar versions have been flourishing in the biopharmaceutical market for several years. Structural and functional characterization is needed to achieve analytical biosimilarity through the assessment of critical quality attributes as required by regulatory authorities. The role of analytical strategies, particularly mass spectrometry-based methods, is pivotal to gathering valuable information for the in-depth characterization of biotherapeutics and biosimilarity assessment. Structural mass spectrometry methods (native MS, HDX-MS, top-down MS, etc.) provide information ranging from primary sequence assessment to higher order structure evaluation. This review focuses on recent developments and applications in structural mass spectrometry for biotherapeutic and biosimilar characterization.

Enhanced Characterization of Histones Using 193 nm Ultraviolet Photodissociation and Proton Transfer Charge Reduction

Top-down characterization of histones, proteins that are critical participants in an array of DNA-dependent processes, offers the potential to examine the relationship between histone structure and mechanisms of genetic regulation. Mapping patterns of post-translational modifications (PTMs) of histones requires extensive backbone cleavages to bracket the sites of mass shifts corresponding to specific PTMs. Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) causes substantial fragmentation of proteins, which is well-suited for PTM localization, but the resulting spectra are congested with fragment ions that may have overlapping isotopic distributions that confound deconvolution. Gas-phase proton transfer charge reduction (PTCR) decreases the charge states of highly charged ions, thus alleviating this congestion and facilitating the identification of additional sequence-determining and PTM-localizing fragment ions. By integrating UVPD with PTCR for histone proteoform analyses, sequence coverages up to 91% were achieved for calf thymus histone H4 containing acetylation marks at the N-terminus and Lys12 as well as a dimethylation at Arg3. UVPD-PTCR exhibited large gains in characterization for other histones, such as histone H2A, increasing the sequence coverage from 59 to 77% for monoacetylated H2A.