The Nucleation Rate of Single O2 Nanobubbles at Pt Nanoelectrodes

Imaging and measuring of oxygen flux produced by disproportionation of hydrogen peroxide by immobilized catalase with scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM)

The immobilization of catalase, with the formation of protein deposits with maintained activity and a homogeneous distribution of active sites, is crucial for neutralizing reactive oxygen species in biological and industrial applications. Thus, mapping the spatial distribution of activity towards hydrogen peroxide decomposition is essential for validating immobilization procedures and analyzing heterogeneous activity. For imaging the activity of immobilized catalase, we propose the use of mercury deposited on platinum (Hg@Pt) and mercury-gold amalgam microelectrodes as tips for scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM). Hg@Pt or Hg-Au amalgam microelectrodes allow for the selective determination of local concentrations of dissolved oxygen in solutions containing hydrogen peroxide. These SECM tips can also locally deliver H2O2 via a 2-electron oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). Asymmetric loop feedback mode (FB) and substrate generation/tip collection mode (SG/TC) were applied to image samples of catalase immobilized on glutaraldehyde-modified glass slides and spots of adsorbed enzyme on polystyrene Petri dishes delivered by means of a micropipette. Hg@Pt microelectrodes obtained by electrodeposition possess inlaid disk geometry at open circuit and become slightly recessed convex planes upon cathodic polarization. SG/TC SECM imaging results indicate that the decomposition rate of H2O2 at micrometer-sized spots of adsorbed catalase is predominantly diffusion-limited. The proposed immobilization and activity imaging methods can be applied to samples with low surface concentrations of immobilized enzymes.

Unveiling micro- and nanoscale bubble dynamics for enhanced electrochemical water splitting

Bubbles generated during electrochemical and photoelectrochemical water splitting critically influence efficiency through complex factors, including chemical reactions, species transport, mass transfer at the three-phase interface, and bubble coverage. A detailed understanding of the nucleation, growth, coalescence, and detachment of micro- and nanoscale bubbles is vital for advancing water splitting technologies. Surface-attached bubbles significantly reduce the electrocatalytically active area of electrodes, leading to increased surface overpotential at a given current density. Consequently, their effective removal is pivotal for optimizing the electrolysis process. However, the intricate interplay among single bubble evolution, mass transport, bubble coverage, and overpotential remain inadequately understood. This review explores the fundamental mechanisms underpinning bubble evolution, with an emphasis on the Marangoni effect and its influence on bubble dynamics. Furthermore, recent advancements in understanding individual bubbles on micro and nano-electrodes are highlighted, offering valuable insights into scale-dependent bubble behavior. These findings enrich our knowledge of gas-liquid interfacial phenomena and underscore their industrial significance, presenting opportunities to enhance water splitting performance through optimized bubble dynamics.

Gas Evolution in Water Electrolysis

Gas bubbles generated by the hydrogen evolution reaction and oxygen evolution reaction during water electrolysis influence the energy conversion efficiency of hydrogen production. Here, we survey what is known about the interaction of gas bubbles and electrode surfaces and the influence of gas evolution on practicable devices used for water electrolysis. We outline the physical processes occurring during the life cycle of a bubble, summarize techniques used to characterize gas evolution phenomena in situ and in practical device environments, and discuss ways that electrodes can be tailored to facilitate gas removal at high current densities. Lastly, we review efforts to model the behavior of individual gas bubbles and multiphase flows produced at gas-evolving electrodes. We conclude our review with a short summary of outstanding questions that could be answered by future efforts to characterize gas evolution in electrochemical device environments or by improved simulations of multiphase flows.

Bridging Innovations of Phase Change Heat Transfer to Electrochemical Gas Evolution Reactions

Bubbles play a ubiquitous role in electrochemical gas evolution reactions. However, a mechanistic understanding of how bubbles affect the energy efficiency of electrochemical processes remains limited to date, impeding effective approaches to further boost the performance of gas evolution systems. From a perspective of the analogy between heat and mass transfer, bubbles in electrochemical gas evolution reactions exhibit highly similar dynamic behaviors to them in the liquid-vapor phase change. Recent developments of liquid-vapor phase change systems have substantially advanced the fundamental knowledge of bubbles, leading to unprecedented enhancement of heat transfer performance. In this Review, we aim to elucidate a promising opportunity of understanding bubble dynamics in electrochemical gas evolution reactions through a lens of phase change heat transfer. We first provide a background about key parallels between electrochemical gas evolution reactions and phase change heat transfer. Then, we discuss bubble dynamics in gas evolution systems across multiple length scales, with an emphasis on exciting research problems inspired by new insights gained from liquid-vapor phase change systems. Lastly, we review advances in engineered surfaces for manipulating bubbles to enhance heat and mass transfer, providing an outlook on the design of high-performance gas evolving electrodes.

A Systematic Study on Long-acting Nanobubbles: Current Advancement and Prospects on Theranostic Properties

Delivery of diagnostic drugs via nanobubbles (NBs) has shown to be an emerging field of study. Due to their small size, NBs may more easily travel through constricted blood vessels and precisely target certain bodily parts. NB is considered the major treatment for cancer treatment and other diseases which are difficult to diagnose. The field of NBs is dynamic and continues to grow as researchers discover new properties and seek practical applications in various fields. The predominant usage of NBs in novel drug delivery is to enhance the bioavailability, and controlled drug release along with imaging properties NBs are important because they may change interfacial characteristics including surface force, lubrication, and absorption. The quick diffusion of gas into the water was caused by a hypothetical film that was stimulated and punctured by a strong acting force at the gas/water contact of the bubble. In this article, various prominent aspects of NBs have been discussed, along with the long-acting nature, and the theranostical aspect which elucidates the potential marketed drugs along with clinical trial products. The article also covers quality by design aspects, different production techniques that enable method-specific therapeutic applications, increasing the floating time of the bubble, and refining its properties to enhance the prepared NB's quality. NB containing both analysis and curing properties makes it special from other nano-carriers. This work includes all the possible methods of preparing NB, its application, all marketed drugs, and products in clinical trials.

Molecular Mechanisms of the Generation and Accumulation of Gas at the Interface

Gas-evolving reactions are widespread in chemical and energy fields. However, the generated gas will accumulate at the interface, which reduces the rate of gas generation. Understanding the microscopic processes of the generation and accumulation of gas at the interface is crucial for improving the efficiency of gas generation. Here, we develop an algorithm to reproduce the process of catalytic gas generation at the molecular scale based on the all-atom molecular dynamics simulations and obtain the quantitative evolution of the gas generation, which agrees well with the experimental results. In addition, we demonstrate that under an external electric field, the generated gas molecules do not accumulate at the electrode surface, which implies that the electric field can significantly increase the rate of the gas generation. The results suggest that the external electric field changes the structure of the water molecules near the electrode surface, making it difficult for gas molecules to accumulate on the electrode surface. Furthermore, it is found that gas desorption from the electrode surface is an entropy-driven process, and its accumulation at the electrode surface depends mainly on the competition between the entropy and the enthalpy of the water molecules under the influence of the electric field. These results provide deep insight into gas generation and inhibition of gas accumulation.

Nucleation of surface nanobubbles in electrochemistry: Analysis with nucleation theorem

The formation of single bubbles at nanoelectrodes during electrochemical reactions allows to accurately identify the critical nucleus for bubble formation. As demonstrated before, combining nanoelectrode experiments and an analysis approach based on classical nucleation theory (CNT) delivers useful insight into bubble nucleation. In this work we propose an alternative approach to analyze the critical nuclei by applying the nucleation theorem (NT), which is able to overcome the inherent shortcomings of CNT. The size of the critical nucleus can be calculated more accurately by fitting experimental data in a simple form of the NT. Simulating the local gas concentration using a finite element approach, and considering the effect of gas oversaturation on the interfacial tension and the real gas compressibility, we obtain a more realistic estimation of the critical nuclei morphology. With the NT-based analysis presented, we re-analyze the nucleation data reported before. The properties of the critical nuclei obtained here are roughly consistent with those obtained from the CNT-based approach. In addition, we confirm that the critical nucleus for bubble formation in high gas oversaturation is featured with a contact angle much larger than Young's contact angle.

Review on Bubble Dynamics in Proton Exchange Membrane Water Electrolysis: Towards Optimal Green Hydrogen Yield

Water electrolysis using a proton exchange membrane (PEM) holds substantial promise to produce green hydrogen with zero carbon discharge. Although various techniques are available to produce hydrogen gas, the water electrolysis process tends to be more cost-effective with greater advantages for energy storage devices. However, one of the challenges associated with PEM water electrolysis is the accumulation of gas bubbles, which can impair cell performance and result in lower hydrogen output. Achieving an in-depth knowledge of bubble dynamics during electrolysis is essential for optimal cell performance. This review paper discusses bubble behaviors, measuring techniques, and other aspects of bubble dynamics in PEM water electrolysis. It also examines bubble behavior under different operating conditions, as well as the system geometry. The current review paper will further improve the understanding of bubble dynamics in PEM water electrolysis, facilitating more competent, inexpensive, and feasible green hydrogen production.

Solutal Marangoni effect determines bubble dynamics during electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution

Understanding and manipulating gas bubble evolution during electrochemical water splitting is a crucial strategy for optimizing the electrode/electrolyte/gas bubble interface. Here gas bubble dynamics are investigated during the hydrogen evolution reaction on a well-defined platinum microelectrode by varying the electrolyte composition. We find that the microbubble coalescence efficiency follows the Hofmeister series of anions in the electrolyte. This dependency yields very different types of H2 gas bubble evolution in different electrolytes, ranging from periodic detachment of a single H2 gas bubble in sulfuric acid to aperiodic detachment of small H2 gas bubbles in perchloric acid. Our results indicate that the solutal Marangoni convection, induced by the anion concentration gradient developing during the reaction, plays a critical role at practical current density conditions. The resulting Marangoni force on the H2 gas bubble and the bubble departure diameter therefore depend on how surface tension varies with concentration for different electrolytes. This insight provides new avenues for controlling bubble dynamics during electrochemical gas bubble formation.

Imaging Single H2 Nanobubbles Using Off-Axis Dark-Field Microscopy

A robust and detailed physicochemical description of electrochemically generated surface nanobubbles and their effects on electrochemical systems remains at large. Herein, we report the development and utilization of an off-axis, dark-field microscopy imaging tool for probing the dynamic process of generating single H2 nanobubbles at the surface of a carbon nanoelectrode. A change in the direction of the incident light is made to significantly reduce the intensity of the background light, which enables us to image both the nanoelectrode and nanobubble on the electrode surface or the metal nanoparticles in the vicinity of the electrode. The correlated electrochemical and optical response provides novel insights regarding bubble nucleation and dissolution on a nanoelectrode previously unattainable solely from its current-voltage response.

Current oscillations from bipolar nanopores for statistical monitoring of hydrogen evolution on a confined electrochemical catalyst

Taking advantage of bipolar electrochemistry and a glass nanopipette, continuous single bubbles can be controlled which are generated and detached from a nanometer-sized area of confined electrochemical catalysts. The observed current oscillations offer opportunities to rapidly collect data for the statistical analysis of single-bubble generation on and departure from the catalysts.

Confined Electrochemical Behaviors of Single Platinum Nanoparticles Revealing Ultrahigh Density of Gas Molecules inside a Nanobubble

Understanding the basic physicochemical properties of gas molecules confined within nanobubbles is of fundamental importance for chemical and biological processes. Here, we successfully monitored the nanobubble-confined electrochemical behaviors of single platinum nanoparticles (PtNPs) at a carbon fiber ultramicroelectrode in HClO₄ and H₂O₂ solution. Due to the catalytic decomposition of H₂O₂, a single oxygen nanobubble was formed on individual PtNPs to block the active surface of particles for proton reduction and to suppress their stochastic motion, resulting in significantly distinguished current traces. Furthermore, the combination of theoretical calculations and high-resolution electrochemical measurements allowed the nanobubble size and the oxygen gas density inside a single nanobubble to be quantified. Moreover, the ultrahigh oxygen density inside (1046 kg/m³) was revealed, indicating that gas molecules in a nanosized space existed with a high state of aggregation. Our approach sheds light on the gas aggregation behaviors of nanoscale bubbles using single-entity electrochemical measurements.

Critical Nucleus Size and Activation Energy of Ag Nucleation by Electrochemical Observation of Isolated Nucleation Events

The induction times for electrodeposition of individual Ag nanoparticles on Pt nanodisk electrodes in acetonitrile were used to determine the critical nucleus size and activation energy barrier associated with the formation of Ag nuclei. Induction times for the nucleation and growth of a single Ag nanoparticle were determined following the application of a potential step to reduce Ag+ at overpotentials, η, ranging from -130 to -70 mV. Sufficiently small Pt electrodes (5.1 × 10-10-2.6 × 10-11 cm2) were used to ensure that the detection of a single Ag nucleation event occurred during the experimental observation time (150 ms-1000 s). Multiple measurements of Ag nucleation induction times were recorded to determine nucleation rates as a function of η using cumulative probability theory. Both classical nucleation theory (CNT) and the atomistic theory of electrochemical nucleation were employed to analyze experimental nucleation rates, without a requisite knowledge of the nucleus geometry or surface free energy. Using the CNT, the number of atoms comprising the critical size nucleus, Nc, was estimated to be 1-9 atoms for η ranging from -130 to -70 mV, in good agreement with 1-5 atoms obtained using atomistic theory. The experimental nucleation rates were also used to determine the activation energy barriers for nucleation from the CNT, which varied from 3.31 ± 0.05 to 13 ± 1 kT over the same range of η.

In Situ Characterization of Oxygen Evolution Electrocatalysis of Silver Salt Oxide on a Wireless Nanopore Electrode

Silver salt oxide shows superior oxidation ability for the applications of superconductivity, sterilization, and catalysis. However, due to the easy decomposition, the catalytic properties of silver salt oxide are difficult to characterize by conventional methods. Herein, we used a closed-type wireless nanopore electrode (CWNE) to in situ and real-time monitor the electrocatalytic performance of Ag₇NO₁₁ in the oxygen evolution reaction. The real-time current recording revealed that the deposited Ag₇NO₁₁ on the CWNE tip greatly enhanced the oxidative capacity of the electrode, resulting in water splitting. The statistical event analysis reveals the periodic O₂ bubble formation and dissolution at the Ag₇NO₁₁ interface, which ensures the characterization of the oxygen evolution electrocatalytic process at the nanoscale. The calculated k_cat and Markov chain modeling suggest the anisotropy of Ag₇NO₁₁ at a low voltage may lead to multiple catalytic rates. Therefore, our results demonstrate the powerful capability of CWNE in direct and in situ characterization of gas-liquid-solid catalytic reactions for unstable catalysts.

Single-Entity Electrochemistry of Nano- and Microbubbles in Electrolytic Gas Evolution

Gas bubbles are found in diverse electrochemical processes, ranging from electrolytic water splitting to chlor-alkali electrolysis, as well as photoelectrochemical processes. Understanding the intricate influence of bubble evolution on the electrode processes and mass transport is key to the rational design of efficient devices for electrolytic energy conversion and thus requires precise measurement and analysis of individual gas bubbles. In this Perspective, we review the latest advances in single-entity measurement of gas bubbles on electrodes, covering the approaches of voltammetric and galvanostatic studies based on nanoelectrodes, probing bubble evolution using scanning probe electrochemistry with spatial information, and monitoring the transient nature of nanobubble formation and dynamics with opto-electrochemical imaging. We emphasize the intrinsic and quantitative physicochemical interpretation of single gas bubbles from electrochemical data, highlighting the fundamental understanding of the heterogeneous nucleation, dynamic state of the three-phase boundary, and the correlation between electrolytic bubble dynamics and nanocatalyst activities. In addition, a brief discussion of future perspectives is presented.

Electroprecipitation of Nanometer-Thick Films of Ln(OH)3 [Ln = La, Ce, and Lu] at Pt Microelectrodes and Their Effect on Electron-Transfer Reactions

We report investigations of the deposition of nanometer-thick Ln(OH)₃ films (Ln = La, Ce, and Lu) and their effect on outer-sphere and inner-sphere electron-transfer reactions. Insoluble Ln(OH)₃ films are deposited from aqueous solutions of LaCl₃ onto the surface of 12.5 μm radius Pt microdisk electrodes during water or oxygen reduction. Both reactions produce interfacial OH^-, which complexes with Ln³⁺, resulting in the precipitation of Ln(OH)₃. Surface analyses by scanning electron microscopy (SEM), SEM-energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy, and atomic force microscopy indicate the formation of a 1-2 nm thick uniform film. Outer-sphere electron-transfer reactions (Ru(NH₃)₆³⁺ reduction, FcMeOH oxidation, and Fe(CN)₆^4-/3- oxidation/reduction) were investigated at Ln(OH)₃-modified electrodes of different film thicknesses. The results demonstrate that the steady-state transport-limited current for these reactions decreases with an increase in the film thickness. Moreover, the degree of blockage depends upon the redox species, suggesting that the Ln(OH)₃ films are free from pinholes greater than the size of the redox molecules. This suggests that the films are either ionically conducting or that electron tunneling occurs across these thin layers. A similar blocking effect was observed for the inner-sphere reductions of H₂O and O₂. We further demonstrate that the thickness of La(OH)₃ films can be controlled by anodic dissolution. Additionally, we show that La³⁺ lowers the supersaturation of dissolved H₂ required to nucleate a stable nanobubble.

Oxygen Generation Using Catalytic Nano/Micromotors

Gaseous oxygen plays a vital role in driving the metabolism of living organisms and has multiple agricultural, medical, and technological applications. Different methods have been discovered to produce oxygen, including plants, oxygen concentrators and catalytic reactions. However, many such approaches are relatively expensive, involve challenges, complexities in post-production processes or generate undesired reaction products. Catalytic oxygen generation using hydrogen peroxide is one of the simplest and cleanest methods to produce oxygen in the required quantities. Chemically powered micro/nanomotors, capable of self-propulsion in liquid media, offer convenient and economic platforms for on-the-fly generation of gaseous oxygen on demand. Micromotors have opened up opportunities for controlled oxygen generation and transport under complex conditions, critical medical diagnostics and therapy. Mobile oxygen micro-carriers help better understand the energy transduction efficiencies of micro/nanoscopic active matter by careful selection of catalytic materials, fuel compositions and concentrations, catalyst surface curvatures and catalytic particle size, which opens avenues for controllable oxygen release on the level of a single catalytic microreactor. This review discusses various micro/nanomotor systems capable of functioning as mobile oxygen generators while highlighting their features, efficiencies and application potentials in different fields.

Efficient Mesh Interface Engineering: Insights from Bubble Dynamics in Electrocatalysis

Electrochemical catalysis offers great potential in energy and mass conversion in academy and industry. However, bubble dynamics and its influence on gas-evolving electrode systems remain ambiguous. Detailed information on the local transport process between different phases and the underlying mechanism are required for the full understanding of two-phase flow evolution and distribution. Here, we construct a three-electrode water splitting reaction system to study the bubble dynamics and system efficiency of titanium electrodes with different morphologies. The dynamics of a gas bubble at an electrode with a plate and 100-mesh, 150-mesh, and 300-mesh structures is systematically investigated with respect to applied voltage conditions. Parameters and underlying mechanisms that influence the two-phase flow evolution and electrochemical reaction performance are carefully discussed. Finally, the underlying dynamic force balance on the gas bubble is analyzed to illustrate the mechanism and experimental observations. Our study provides insights in gas-evolving electrocatalysis and offers opportunities for the design and fabrication of high-performance electrocatalytic reactors.

Oxygen-Selective Diffusion-Bubbling Membranes with Core-Shell Structure: Bubble Dynamics and Unsteady Effects

Oxygen is the second-largest-volume industrial gas that is mainly produced using cryogenic air separation. However, the state-of-the-art cryogenic technology thermodynamic efficiency has approached a theoretical limit as near as is practicable. Therefore, there is stimulus to develop an alternative technology for efficient oxygen separation from air. Mixed ionic electronic-conducting (MIEC) ceramic membrane-based oxygen separation technology could become this alternative, but commercialization aspects, including cost, have revealed inadequacies in ceramic membrane materials. Currently, diffusion-bubbling molten oxide membrane-based oxygen separation technology is being developed. It is a potentially disruptive technology that would propose an improvement in oxygen purity and a reduction in capital costs. Bubbles play an important role in ensuring the oxygen mass transfer in diffusion-bubbling membranes. However, there is not sufficient understanding of the bubble dynamics. This understanding is important to be able to control transport properties of these membranes and assess their potential for technological application. The aim of this feature article is to highlight the progress made in developing this understanding and specify the directions for future research.

Effect of Surfactant on Electrochemically Generated Surface Nanobubbles

Surfactants, mimics of contamination, play an important role in nanobubble nucleation, stability, and growth at the electrode surface. Herein, we utilize single-molecule fluorescence microscopy as a sensitive imaging tool to monitor nanobubble dynamics in the presence of a surfactant. Our results show that the presence of anionic and nonionic surfactants increase the rate of nanobubble nucleation at all potentials in a voltage scan. The fluorescence and electrochemical responses indicate the successful lowering of the critical gas concentration needed for nanobubble nucleation across all voltages. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the accumulation of surfactants at the gas-liquid interface changes the interaction of fluorophores with the nanobubble surface. Specifically, differences in fluorophore intensity and residence lifetime at the nanobubble surface suggest that the labeling of nanobubbles is affected by the nature of the nanobubble (size, shape, etc.) and the structure of the gas-liquid interface (surfactant charge, hydrophobicity, etc.).

Dynamic Equilibrium Model for Surface Nanobubbles in Electrochemistry

Gas bubbles are ubiquitous in electrochemical processes, particularly in water electrolysis. Due to the development of gas-evolving electrocatalysis and energy conversion technology, a deep understanding of gas bubble behaviors at the electrode surface is highly desirable. In this work, by combining theoretical analysis and molecular simulations, we study the behaviors of a single nanobubble electrogenerated at a nanoelectrode. With the dynamic equilibrium model, the stability criteria for stationary surface nanobubbles are established. We show theoretically that a slight change in either the gas solubility or solute concentration results in various nanobubble dynamic states at a nanoelectrode: contact line pinning in aqueous and ethylene glycol solutions, oscillation of pinning states in dimethyl sulfoxide, and mobile nanobubbles in methanol. The above complex nanobubble behavior at the electrode/electrolyte interface is explained by the competition between gas influx into the nanobubble and outflux from the nanobubble.

Visualization and Quantification of Electrochemical H2 Bubble Nucleation at Pt, Au, and MoS2 Substrates

Electrolytic gas evolution is a significant phenomenon in many electrochemical technologies from water splitting, chloralkali process to fuel cells. Although it is known that gas evolution may substantially affect the ohmic resistance and mass transfer, studies focusing on the electrochemistry of individual bubbles are critical but also challenging. Here, we report an approach using scanning electrochemical cell microscopy (SECCM) with a single channel pipet to quantitatively study individual gas bubble nucleation on different electrode substrates, including conventional polycrystalline Pt and Au films, as well as the most interesting two-dimensional semiconductor MoS₂. Due to the confinement effect of the pipet, well-defined peak-shaped voltammetric features associated with single bubble nucleation and growth are consistently observed. From stochastic bubble nucleation measurement and finite element simulation, the surface H₂ concentration corresponding to bubble nucleation is estimated to be ∼218, 137, and 157 mM, with critical nuclei contact angles of ∼156°, ∼161°, and ∼160° at polycrystalline Pt, Au, and MoS₂ substrates, respectively. We further demonstrated the surface faceting at polycrystalline Pt is not specifically correlated with the bubble nucleation behavior.

Stochasticity in Single-Entity Electrochemistry

Most electrochemical processes are stochastic and discrete in nature. Yet experimental observables, e.g., i vs E, are typically smooth and deterministic, due to many events/processes, e.g., electron transfers, being averaged together. However, when the number of entities measured approaches a few or even one, stochasticity frequently emerges. Yet all is not lost! Probabilistic and statistical interpretation can generate insights matching or superseding those from macroscale/ensemble measurements, revealing phenomena that were hitherto averaged over. Herein, we review recent literature examples of stochastic processes in single-entity electrochemistry, highlighting strategies for interpreting stochasticity, contrasting them with macroscale measurements, and describing the insights generated.

Harnessing bubble behaviors for developing new analytical strategies

Gas bubbles are easily accessible and offer many unique characteristic properties of a gas/liquid two-phase system for developing new analytical methods. In this minireview, we discuss the newly developed analytical strategies that harness the behaviors of bubbles. Recent advancements include the utilization of the gas/liquid interfacial activity of bubbles for detection and preconcentration of surface-active compounds; the employment of the gas phase properties of bubbles for acoustic imaging and detection, microfluidic analysis, electrochemical sensing, and emission spectroscopy; and the application of the mass transport behaviors at the gas/liquid interface in gas sensing, biosensing, and nanofluidics. These studies have demonstrated the versatility of gas bubbles as a platform for developing new analytical strategies.

Electrochemically Generated Nanobubbles: Invariance of the Current with Respect to Electrode Size and Potential

Gas-producing electrochemical reactions are key to energy conversion and generation technologies. Bubble formation dramatically decreases gas-production rates on nanoelectrodes, by confining the reaction to the electrode boundary. This results in the collapse of the current to a stationary value independent of the potential. Startlingly, these residual currents also appear to be insensitive to the nanoelectrode diameter in the 5 to 500 nm range. These results are counterintuitive, as it may be expected that the current be proportional to the circumference of the electrode, i.e., the length of the three-phase line where the reaction occurs. Here, we use molecular simulations and a kinetic model to elucidate the origin of current insensitivity with respect to the potential and establish its relationship to the size of nanoelectrodes. We provide critical insights for the design and operation of nanoscale electrochemical devices and demonstrate that nanoelectrode arrays maximize conversion rates compared to macroscopic electrodes with same total area.

Nanoelectrochemistry in the study of single-cell signaling

Label-free biosensing has been the dream of scientists and biotechnologists as reported by Vollmer and Arnold (Nat Methods 5:591-596, 2008). The ability of examining living cells is crucial to cell biology as noted by Fang (Int J Electrochem 2011:460850, 2011). Chemical measurement with electrodes is label-free and has demonstrated capability of studying living cells. In recent years, nanoelectrodes of different functionality have been developed. These nanometer-sized electrodes, coupled with scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM), have further enabled nanometer spatial resolution study in aqueous environments. Developments in the field of nanoelectrochemistry have allowed measurement of signaling species at single cells, contributing to better understanding of cell biology. Leading studies using nanoelectrochemistry of a variety of cellular signaling molecules, including redox-active neurotransmitter (e.g., dopamine), non-redox-active neurotransmitter (e.g., acetylcholine), reactive oxygen species (ROS), and reactive nitrogen species (RNS), are reviewed here.

Nitrogen Bubbles at Pt Nanoelectrodes in a Nonaqueous Medium: Oscillating Behavior and Geometry of Critical Nuclei

Gas bubble evolution is present in many electrochemical and photoelectrochemical processes. We previously reported the formation of individual H₂, N₂, and O₂ nanobubbles generated from electrocatalytic reduction of H⁺ and oxidation of N₂H₄ and H₂O₂, respectively, at Pt nanodisk electrodes in an aqueous solution. All the nanobubbles formed display a dynamic stationary state of a three-phase boundary with an invariant residual current. Here, we test the hypothesis that gas nanobubbles can also be electrogenerated in a nonaqueous medium. Interestingly, we found oscillating bubble behavior corresponding to nucleation, growth, and dissolution in dimethyl sulfoxide and methanol. One possible explanation of the oscillation mechanism is provided by the instable dynamic equilibrium between the gas influx due to supersaturation and outflux due to Laplace pressure. Furthermore, the critical gas concentrations for N₂ nanobubble nucleation are estimated to be 148, 386, 200, and 16 times supersaturation and the contact angles of the critical nuclei to be 164°, 151°, 160°, and 174° in water, dimethyl sulfoxide, ethylene glycol, and methanol, respectively. This is the first report on electrochemical nucleation of gas bubbles in nonaqueous solvents. Our electrochemical gas bubble study based on a nanoelectrode platform has proven to be a prototypical example of single-entity electrochemistry.

Nucleation and Growth of a Nanobubble on Rough Surfaces

We study the nucleation and growth of a nanobubble on rough surfaces using molecular dynamics simulations. A nanobubble nucleates and grows by virtue of a heterogeneous surface reaction which results in the production of gas molecules near the surface. We study the role of surface roughness in the nucleation and growth behavior of a nanobubble. We perform simulations at various reaction rates and surface morphology and quantified the growth dynamics of a nanobubble. Our simulations show that after the onset of nucleation, the nanobubble grows rapidly with radius following t^1/3 behavior followed by a diffusive growth regime which is marked by t^1/2 growth behavior. This growth behavior remains independent of surface roughness and reaction rates over the range considered in this study. We also quantified the oversaturation of gas required for nucleation of a nanobubble and demonstrated its dependence on the surface morphology.

Monitoring nanobubble nucleation at early-stage within a sub-9 nm solid-state nanopore

Nanobubble nucleation study is important for understanding the dynamic behavior of nanobubble growth, which is instructive for the nanobubble applications. Benefiting from nanopore fabrication, herein, we fabricated a sub-9 nm SiN_X nanopore with the comparable size to nanobubbles at early-stage. The confined nanopore interface serves as a generator for producing nanobubbles by the chemical reaction between NaBH₄ and H₂ O and as an ultra-sensitive sensor for monitoring the H₂ nanobubble nucleation process. By carrying out the NaBH₄ concentration-dependent experiments, we found the life-time of nanobubbles decreased 250 times and the frequency of nanobubble generation increased 38 times with the NaBH₄ concentration increasing from 6 to 100 mM. The long-time equilibrium between gas molecules inward flux and outward flux could prolong the life-time of nanobubbles to hundreds of milliseconds at low NaBH₄ concentration. The raw current trace depicted that the transient accumulation and dissolution of cavity occurred during all the life-time of nanobubbles. Therefore, the sub-9 nm SiN_X nanopore shows a strong ability for real-time monitoring the nanobubble nucleation at early-stage with high temporal and spatial resolution. This work provides a guide to study the dynamic and stochastic characteristics of nanobubbles.

Nanoscale electrochemical kinetics & dynamics: the challenges and opportunities of single-entity measurements

The development of nanoscale electrochemistry since the mid-1980s has been predominately coupled with steady-state voltammetric (i-E) methods. This research has been driven by the desire to understand the mechanisms of very fast electrochemical reactions, by electroanalytical measurements in small volumes and unusual media, including in vivo measurements, and by research on correlating electrocatalytic activity, e.g., O2 reduction reaction, with nanoparticle size and structure. Exploration of the behavior of nanoelectrochemical structures (nanoelectrodes, nanoparticles, nanogap cells, etc.) of a characteristic dimension λ using steady-state i-E methods generally relies on the well-known relationship, λ2 ∼ Dt, which relates diffusional lengths to time, t, through the coefficient, D. Decreasing λ, by performing measurements at a nanometric length scales, results in a decrease in the effective timescale of the measurement, and provides a direct means to probe the kinetics of steps associated with very rapid electrochemical reactions. For instance, steady-state voltammetry using a nanogap twin-electrode cell of characteristic width, λ ∼ 10 nm, allows investigations of events occurring at timescales on the order of ∼100 ns. Among many other advantages, decreasing λ also increases spatial resolution in electrochemical imaging, e.g., in scanning electrochemical microscopy, and allows probing of the electric double layer. This Introductory Lecture traces the evolution and driving forces behind the "λ2 ∼ Dt" steady-state approach to nanoscale electrochemistry, beginning in the late 1950s with the introduction of the rotating ring-disk electrode and twin-electrode thin-layer cells, and evolving to current-day investigations using nanoelectrodes, scanning nanocells for imaging, nanopores, and nanoparticles. The recent focus on so-called "single-entity" electrochemistry, in which individual and very short redox events are probed, is a significant departure from the steady-state approach, but provides new opportunities to probe reaction dynamics. The stochastic nature of very fast single-entity events challenges current electrochemical methods and modern electronics, as illustrated using recent experiments from the authors' laboratory.

Methodology for Investigating Electrochemical Gas Evolution Reactions: Floating Electrode as a Means for Effective Gas Bubble Removal

The future significance of energy conversion has stimulated intense investigation of various electrocatalytic materials. Hence electrocatalysts have become the subject of electrochemical characterization on a daily basis. In certain cases of interest, when measuring electrochemical reactions beyond the onset potentials, however, appropriateness of existing electroanalytical methods may be questioned and alternative approaches need to be developed. The present study highlights some shortcomings in the electrochemical investigation of gas evolving reactions. The oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is selected as a case example with a specific focus on the electrochemical stability of a nanoparticulate iridium catalyst. When conventional electrochemical methods, such as thin film rotating disc electrodes are employed to study the materials’ stability, the intrinsic degradation is masked by oxygen bubbles, which are inherently being formed during the reaction, especially when high current densities are used. In this Letter, we present a solution to this issue, the so-called floating electrode arrangement. Its elegant usage enables fast and reliable electrochemical characterization of oxygen evolution electrocatalysts.

Mapping the Nucleation of H2 Bubbles on Polycrystalline Pt via Scanning Electrochemical Cell Microscopy

Electrochemically generated bubbles are gaining increasing attention for their detrimental effects on the efficiency of electrocatalysis involving gaseous products, including hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). As a model system, bubble nucleation is also of fundamental interest. Herein, we report a single-entity approach to map the nucleation of H₂ bubbles on polycrystalline Pt via scanning electrochemical cell microscopy (SECCM). Individual H₂ bubbles (∼500 nm radius) are generated via HER in the attoliter electrochemical cell of an SECCM instrument. Nucleation and growth of a H₂ bubble results in a characteristic voltammetric peak current, which is related to the concentration and activation energy required for nucleation. By mapping the local voltammograms at various locations on the polycrystalline Pt, we found a heterogeneous distribution of energetics of nucleation for H₂ bubbles on the Pt surface. However, such heterogeneity is not correlated with crystal grains or grain boundaries.

Voltammetric Determination of the Stochastic Formation Rate and Geometry of Individual H2, N2, and O2 Bubble Nuclei

Herein, we report a general voltammetric method to characterize the electrochemical nucleation rate and nuclei of single nanobubbles. Bubble nucleation is indicated by a sharp peak in the current in the voltammetry of gas-evolving reactions. In contrast to expectations based on the stochastic nature of nucleation events, the peak current signifying a stable nucleus is extremely reproducible over hundreds of cycles (∼3% deviation). By applying classical nucleation theory, this seemingly deterministic behavior can be not only understood but also used to quantify the nucleation rate and size of bubble nuclei. A statistical model is developed whereby properties of single critical nuclei (contact angle, the radius of curvature, activation energy, and Arrhenius pre-exponential factor) can be readily measured from the narrow distribution of peak currents (mean, standard deviation) from hundreds of voltammetric cycles at a nanoelectrode. Single nanobubbles formed from gas-evolving reactions (H₂ from H⁺ reduction, N₂ from N₂H₄ oxidation, O₂ from H₂O₂ oxidation) are analyzed to find that their critical nuclei have contact angles of ∼150, ∼160, and ∼154° for H₂, N₂, and O₂, respectively, corresponding to ∼50, ∼40, and ∼90 gas molecules in each nucleus. The energy barriers for heterogeneous nucleation of H₂, N₂, and O₂ bubbles are, respectively, 2, 0.4, and 0.7% of those required for homogeneous nucleation under the same supersaturation.

Measuring the activation energy barrier for the nucleation of single nanosized vapor bubbles

Heterogeneous bubble nucleation is one of the most fundamental interfacial processes that has received broad interest from diverse fields of physics and chemistry. While most studies focused on large microbubbles, here we employed a surface plasmon resonance microscopy to measure the nucleation rate constant and activation energy barrier of single nanosized embryo vapor bubbles upon heating a flat gold film with a focused laser beam. Image analysis allowed for simultaneously determining the local temperature and local nucleation rate constant from the same batch of optical images. By analyzing the dependence of nucleation rate constant on temperature, we were able to calculate the local activation energy barrier within a submicrometer spot. Scanning the substrate further led to a nucleation rate map with a spatial resolution of 100 nm, which revealed no correlation with the local roughness. These results indicate that facet structure and surface chemistry, rather than geometrical roughness, regulated the activation energy barrier for heterogeneous nucleation of embryo nanobubbles.

Intrinsic Activity of Oxygen Evolution Catalysts Probed at Single CoFe2O4 Nanoparticles

Identifying the intrinsic electrocatalytic activity of nanomaterials is challenging, as their characterization usually requires additives and binders whose contributions are difficult to dissect. Herein, we use nano impact electrochemistry as an additive-free method to overcome this problem. Due to the efficient mass transport at individual catalyst nanoparticles, high current densities can be realized. High-resolution bright-field transmission electron microscopy and selected area diffraction studies of the catalyst particles before and after the experiments provide valuable insights in the transformation of the nanomaterials during harsh oxygen evolution reaction (OER) conditions. We demonstrate this for 4 nm sized CoFe₂O₄ spinel nanoparticles. It is revealed that these particles retain their size and crystal structure even after OER at current densities as high as several kA·m^-2. The steady-state current scales with the particle size distribution and is limited by the diffusion of produced oxygen away from the particle. This versatilely applicable method provides new insights into intrinsic nanocatalyst activities, which is key to the efficient development of improved and precious metal-free catalysts for renewable energy technologies.

Gas Bubbles in Electrochemical Gas Evolution Reactions

Electrochemical gas evolution reactions are of vital importance in numerous electrochemical processes including water splitting, chloralkaline process, and fuel cells. During gas evolution reactions, gas bubbles are vigorously and constantly forming and influencing these processes. In the past few decades, extensive studies have been performed to understand the evolution of gas bubbles, elucidate the mechanisms of how gas bubbles impact gas evolution reactions, and exploit new bubble-based strategies to improve the efficiency of gas evolution reactions. In this feature article, we summarize the classical theories as well as recent advancements in this field and provide an outlook on future research topics.