Regulating the Packing of Non-Fullerene Acceptors via Multiple Noncovalent Interactions for Enhancing the Performance of Organic Solar Cells

Lest We Forget-The Importance of Heteroatom Interactions in Heterocyclic Conjugated Systems, from Synthetic Metals to Organic Semiconductors

The field of synthetic metals is, and remains, highly influential for the development of organic semiconductor materials. Yet, with the passing of time and the rapid development of conjugated materials in recent years, the link between synthetic metals and organic semiconductors is at risk of being forgotten. This review reflects on one of the key concepts developed in synthetic metals - heteroatom interactions. The application of this strategy in recent organic semiconductor materials, small molecules and polymers, is highlighted, with analysis of X-ray crystal structures and comparisons with model systems used to determine the influence of these non-covalent short contacts. The case is made that the wide range of effective heteroatom interactions and the high performance that has been achieved in devices from organic solar cells to transistors is testament to the seeds sown by the synthetic metals research community.

Low-Cost Nonfused-Ring Electron Acceptors Enabled by Noncovalent Conformational Locks

ConspectusSince the first bilayer-structured organic solar cells (OSCs) in 1986, fullerenes and their derivatives have dominated the landscape for two decades due to their unique properties. In recent years, the breakthrough in nonfullerene acceptors (NFAs) was mainly attributed to the development of fused-ring electron acceptors (FREAs), whose photovoltaic performance surpassed that of fullerene derivatives. Through the unremitting efforts of the whole community, the power conversion efficiencies (PCEs) have surpassed 19% in FREA-based OSCs. However, FREAs generally suffered from complex synthetic approaches and high product costs, which hindered large-scale production. Therefore, many researchers are seeking a new type of NFA to achieve cost-effective, highly efficient OSCs.In collaboration with Marks and Facchetti in 2012, Huang et al. (Huang, H. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2012, 134, 10966-10973, 10.1021/ja303401s) proposed the concept of "noncovalent conformational locks" (NoCLs). In the following years, our group has been focusing on the theoretical and experimental exploration of NoCLs, revealing their fundamental nature, formulating a simple descriptor for quantifying their strength, and employing this approach to achieve high-performance organic/polymeric semiconductors for optoelectronics, such as OSCs, thin-film transistors, room-temperature phosphorescence, and photodetectors. The NoCLs strategy has been proven to be a simple and effective approach for enhancing molecular rigidity and planarity, thus improving the charge transport mobilities of organic/polymeric semiconductors, attributed to reduced reorganization energy and suppressed nonradiative decay.In 2018, Chen et al. (Li, S. Adv. Mater. 2018, 30, 1705208, 10.1002/adma.201705208) reported the first example of nonfused-ring electron acceptors (NFREAs) with intramolecular noncovalent F···H interactions. The NoCLs strategy is essential in NFREAs, as it simplifies the conjugated structures while maintaining high coplanarity comparable to that of FREAs. Due to their simple structures and concise synthesis routes, NFREAs show great potential for achieving cost-effective and highly efficient OSCs. In this Account, we provide an overview of our efforts in developing NFREAs with the NoCLs strategy. We begin with a discussion on the distinct features of NFREAs compared with FREAs, and the structural simplification from FREAs to NFREAs to completely NFREAs. Next, we examine several selected typical examples of NFREAs with remarkable photovoltaic performance, aiming to provide an in-depth exploration of the molecular design principle and structure-property-performance relationships. Then, we discuss how to achieve a balance among efficiency, stability, and cost through a two-in-one strategy of polymerized NFREAs (PNFREAs). Finally, we offer our views on the current challenges and future prospects of NFREAs. We hope this Account will trigger intensive research interest in this field, thus propelling OSCs into a new stage.

Research Advances of Nonfused Ring Acceptors for Organic Solar Cells

The last few decades have witnessed the rapid development of organic solar cells (OSCs). High power conversion efficiencies (PCEs) of over 19% have been successfully achieved due to the emergence of fused-ring acceptors (FRAs). However, the high complexity and low yield for the material synthesis result in high production costs of FRAs, limiting the further commercial application of OSCs. In contrast, nonfused ring acceptors (NFRAs) with the merits of facile synthesis, high yield, and preferable stability can promote the development of low-cost OSCs. Currently, the PCEs of NFRAs-based OSCs have exceeded 17%, which is expected to reach efficiency comparable to that of the FRAs-based OSCs. This review describes the advantages of the recent advances in NFRAs, which emphasizes exploring how the chemical structures of NFRAs influence molecular conformation, aggregation, and packing modes. In addition, the further development of NFRA materials is prospected from molecular design, morphological control, and stability perspectives.

Coplanar Conformational Structure of π-Conjugated Polymers for Optoelectronic Applications

Hierarchical structure of conjugated polymers is critical to dominating their optoelectronic properties and applications. Compared to nonplanar conformational segments, coplanar conformational segments of conjugated polymers (CPs) demonstrate favorable properties for applications as a semiconductor. Herein, recent developments in the coplanar conformational structure of CPs for optoelectronic devices are summarized. First, this review comprehensively summarizes the unique properties of planar conformational structures. Second, the characteristics of the coplanar conformation in terms of optoelectrical properties and other polymer physics characteristics are emphasized. Five primary characterization methods for investigating the complanate backbone structures are illustrated, providing a systematical toolbox for studying this specific conformation. Third, internal and external conditions for inducing the coplanar conformational structure are presented, offering guidelines for designing this conformation. Fourth, the optoelectronic applications of this segment, such as light-emitting diodes, solar cells, and field-effect transistors, are briefly summarized. Finally, a conclusion and outlook for the coplanar conformational segment regarding molecular design and applications are provided.

Molecular-Shape-Controlled Nonfused Ring Electron Acceptors for High-Performance Organic Solar Cells with Tunable Phase Morphology

Two nonfused ring electron acceptors (NFREAs), BTh-OC8-2F and DTh-OC8-2F, with different molecular shapes are designed and synthesized. Both acceptors can form planar molecular shapes by the assistance of S···O intramolecular interactions. Differently, BTh-OC8-2F, with a linear molecular backbone and two trans-arranged side chains at the core unit, exhibits much stronger crystallinity than DTh-OC8-2, with a C-shape molecular shape and two cis-arranged steric side chains at the core unit. Thus, the DTh-OC8-2F based blend film displays a better nanoscale phase separation, more suppressed charge recombination, more efficient exciton dissociation, and lower nonradiative energy loss. Organic solar cells based on DTh-OC8-2F can deliver a power conversion efficiency of 14.13%, which is much higher than BTh-OC8-2F based ones (11.95%) and is also one of the highest values reported for organic solar cells based on NFREAs.

Unfused Acceptors Matching π-Bridge Blocks with Proper Frameworks Enable Over 12% As-Cast Organic Solar Cells

Emerging unfused-ring acceptors (UFAs) have been explored in pursuit of low-cost high-efficient organic solar cells (OSCs). Assembling unfused building blocks into proper frameworks are challenging for the molecular design of UFAs. The authors report herein four UFAs adopting either dithiophene cyclopentadiene (DTC) or dithieno[3,2-b:2',3'-d]pyrrole (DTP) as π-bridge units with different molecular frameworks for high-efficient as-cast OSCs. All these acceptors exhibit strong near-infrared absorption and narrow optical band gap (E_g ^opt  < 1.50 eV). DTC-bridged symmetric and DTP-bridged asymmetric UFAs exhibit higher planar conformation as well as suitable miscibility and homogeneous phase separation when blending with polymer donor PBDB-T to promote efficient charge transport in the blends. Their blends with PBDB-T contribute optimal PCE of 12.17% and 11.92% in as-cast OSCs, among the highest values for UFAs based as-cast devices in the literature. Experimental and theoretical simulations systematically reveal the impact of manipulating the molecular framework of UFAs on their conformation, optoelectronic, and photovoltaic performance. The results indicate the matching π-bridge units with molecular frameworks as an attractive approach to design UFAs for high-performance as-cast OSCs.

Influence of Large Steric Hinderance Substituent Position on Conformation and Charge Transfer Process for Non-Fused Ring Acceptors

To obtain stable and planar molecular geometry in non-fused electron acceptors, A4T-25 and A4T-26 are designed and synthesized by introducing the bulk 2,4,6-triisopropylphenyl side groups onto different positions of the central two thiophene units. A4T-25 and A4T-26 both show a narrow-bandgap of 1.39 and 1.46 eV, with highest occupied molecular orbital/lowest unoccupied molecular orbital levels of -5.56/-3.81 and -5.65/-3.83 eV, respectively, and the electrostatic potential distributions imply that they have strong electron-accepting capability. The single crystal structure analysis and the transfer integral calculation demonstrate that the much more compact π-π stacking in A4T-26 can promote efficient charge transportation compared to that in A4T-25. Therefore, the electron mobility of A4T-26 is obviously higher and more balanced than that of A4T-25. When blending the two acceptors with the same polymer donor PBDB-TF, the photovoltaic cell based on PBDB-TF:A4T-25 has an inadequate power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 7.83%, while the PBDB-TF:A4T-26-based one yields an enhanced PCE of 12.1%. Overall, this study offers an insight into the relationship between the fine-tuning of the molecular structure of non-fused ring acceptors and the corresponding charge transfer process in organic solar cells.

Simultaneously Enhanced Efficiency and Operational Stability of Nonfullerene Organic Solar Cells via Solid-Additive-Mediated Aggregation Control

The additive strategy is widely used in optimizing the morphology of organic solar cells (OSCs). The majority of additives are liquid with high boiling points, which will be trapped within device and consequently deteriorate performance during operation. In this work, solid but volatile additives 2-(4-fluorobenzylidene)-1H-indene-1,3(2H)-dione (INB-F) and 2-(4-chlorobenzylidene)-1H-indene-1,3(2H)-dione (INB-Cl) are designed to replace the common 1,8-diiodooctane (DIO) in nonfullerene OSCs. These additives present during solution casting but evaporate after moderate heating. Molecular dynamics simulations show that they can reduce the adsorption energy to improve π-π stacking among nonfullerene acceptor (NFA) molecules, an effect that enhances light absorption and electron mobility. Both INB-F and INB-Cl enhance efficiency, with INB-F achieving a maximum efficiency of 16.7% from 15.1% of the reference PBDB-T-2F (PM6):BTP-BO-4F (Y6-BO) cell, and outperforming DIO. Remarkably, they can simultaneously enhance the operational stability, with the INB-F-treated OSC maintaining over 60% of the initial efficiency after 1000 h operation, demonstrating a T₈₀ lifetime of 523 h, which is a significant improvement over T₈₀ values of 66.2 h for the reference and 6.6 h for DIO-treated OSC. The simultaneously enhanced efficiency and operational lifetime are also effective in PM6:BTP-BO-4Cl (Y7-BO) OSCs, demonstrating a universal strategy to improve the performance of OSCs.

High-Performance Simple Nonfused Ring Electron Acceptors with Diphenylamino Flanking Groups

Four simple nonfused ring electron acceptors (H-2F, CH₃-2F, OCH₃-2F, and SCH₃-2F) were designed and synthesized. The use of diphenylamine derivatives as the flanking group for the construction of nonfused ring electron acceptors can improve solubility, avoid the formation of oversized aggregates, and enhance the intramolecular charge-transfer effect to extend absorption spectra. The substituent group at the diphenylamine unit has a great impact on the absorption and energy level of acceptors, electron mobility and morphology of blend films. Unlike the other three acceptors, CH₃-2F can form ordered molecular stacking and a face-on orientation in the donor/acceptor blend film. A single-crystal analysis demonstrates that CH₃-2F can form a two-dimensional electron transport network. Among these four acceptors, CH₃-2F-based organic solar cells provide the highest PCE of 12.28%. Our work has demonstrated that triarylamine is a helpful construction unit for low-cost and high efficiency nonfused ring electron acceptors.

Highly Efficient Non-Fused-Ring Electron Acceptors Enabled by the Conformational Lock and Structural Isomerization Effects

Two novel nonfused-ring electron acceptors (N-FREAs) namely DTP-out-F and DTP-in-F, containing 2,5-difluorophenylene central core flanked with DTP blocks and end-capped with IC-2F terminals were designed and synthesized. The C-H···F noncovalent interactions between F atom of 2,5-difluorophenylene and H-3 and H-6 from DTP moiety (for DTP-in-F and DTP-out-F, respectively) locked the molecular conformation within a planar geometry. Benefiting from asymmetric nature of DTP block, the two different connection positions (2- or 7-position) of DTP to 2,5-difluorophenylene afforded the structural isomers of DTP-in-F and DTP-out-F, which affected the overall properties of these N-FREAs, especially the molecular packing behaviors. The more preferred J-aggregation and face-on packing of DTP-in-F shifted the absorption to slightly longer wavelength and provided a polymer-like extended crystal transport channels for improving the charge transport. Therefore, the power conversion efficiency (PCE) was significantly improved from 3.97% of DTP-out-F-based devices to 10.66% of DTP-in-F-based devices. These results reveal the great potential of isomerization strategy to develop high-performance N-FREAs.

Simple Non-Fused Electron Acceptors Leading to Efficient Organic Photovoltaics

Despite the remarkable progress achieved in recent years, organic photovoltaics (OPVs) still need work to approach the delicate balance between efficiency, stability, and cost. Herein, two fully non-fused electron acceptors, PTB4F and PTB4Cl, are developed via a two-step synthesis from single aromatic units. The introduction of a two-dimensional chain and halogenated terminals for these non-fused acceptors plays a synergistic role in optimizing their solid stacking and orientation, thus promoting an elongated exciton lifetime and fast charge-transfer rate in bulk heterojunction blends. As a result, PTB4Cl, upon blending with PBDB-TF polymer, has enabled single-junction OPVs with power conversion efficiencies of 12.76 %, representing the highest values among the reported fully unfused electron acceptors so far.

Systematic Merging of Nonfullerene Acceptor π-Extension and Tetrafluorination Strategies Affords Polymer Solar Cells with >16% Efficiency

The end-capping group (EG) is the essential electron-withdrawing component of nonfullerene acceptors (NFAs) in bulk heterojunction (BHJ) organic solar cells (OSCs). To systematically probe the impact of two frequent EG functionalization strategies, π-extension and halogenation, in A-DAD-A type NFAs, we synthesized and characterized four such NFAs: BT-BIC, LIC, L4F, and BO-L4F. To assess the relative importance of these strategies, we contrast these NFAs with the baseline acceptors, Y5 and Y6. Up to 16.6% power conversion efficiency (PCE) in binary inverted OSCs with BT-BO-L4F combining π-extension and halogenation was achieved. When these two factors are combined, the effect on optical absorption is cumulative. Single-crystal π-π stacking distances are similar for the EG strategies of π-extension. Increasing the alkyl substituent length from BT-L4F to BT-BO-L4F significantly alters the packing motif and eliminates the EG core interactions of BT-L4F. Electronic structure computations reveal some of the largest NFA π-π electronic couplings observed to date, 103.8 meV in BT-L4F and 47.5 meV in BT-BO-L4F. Computed electronic reorganization energies, 132 and 133 meV for BT-L4F and BT-BO-L4F, respectively, are also lower than Y6 (150 meV). BHJ blends show preferential π-face-on orientation, and both fluorination and π-extension increase NFA crystallinity. Femto/nanosecond transient absorption spectroscopy (fs/nsTA) and integrated photocurrent device analysis (IPDA) indicate that π-extension modifies the phase separation to enhance film ordering and carrier mobility, while fluorination suppresses unimolecular recombination. This systematic study highlights the synergistic effects of NFA π-extension and fluorination in affording efficient OSCs and provides insights into designing next-generation materials.

A–D–C–D–A type non-fullerene acceptors based on the benzotriazole (BTA) unfused core for organic solar cells

Increase of fluorine atoms to modulate the molecular orientation and thus enhanced the photovoltaic performances.

Designing high performance conjugated materials for photovoltaic cells with the aid of intramolecular noncovalent interactions

This review summarizes the recent progress in high performance photovoltaic materials with the aid of intramolecular noncovalent interactions.

High-Performance Ternary Polymer Solar Cells Enabled by a New Narrow Bandgap Nonfullerene Small Molecule Acceptor with a Higher LUMO Level

Obtaining a large open-circuit voltage (V_OC ) and high short-circuit current density (J_SC ) simultaneously is important in improving power conversion efficiency (PCE) of organic photovoltaics. The ternary strategy with using a higher lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) level nonfullerene acceptor (NFA) guest can achieve increased V_OC , yet J_SC is decreased or maintained, so it's still a challenge to offer increased V_OC and J_SC values concurrently via the newly presented V_OC -increased ternary strategy. To overcome this issue, a new narrow bandgap NFA TT-S-4F is reported by introducing 3,6-dimethoxylthieno[3,2-b]thiophene (TT) as π-spacers to connect electron-rich core with terminal groups, so as to upshift the LUMO level and extend π-system. When adding 10% TT-S-4F into binary system based on PTB7-Th:IEICO-4F, the higher-LUMO-level of TT-S-4F, the increased charge mobilities, the reduced trap-assisted combination loss, and a finer nanofiber structure and increased phase separation size are obtained, which simultaneously promotes J_SC , V_OC , and fill factor (FF), thus obtaining an optimal PCE (12.5% vs 11.5%). This work illustrates that an extending conjugated backbone with large π-spacers and inclusion of alkylthiophenyl side-chains is a concept to synthesize NFA guests for use on the V_OC -increased ternary strategy that enables to realize simultaneously increased J_SC , V_OC , and FF.

Noncovalently Fused-Ring Electron Acceptors with C2v Symmetry for Regulating the Morphology of Organic Solar Cells

Four noncovalently fused-ring electron acceptors p-DOC6-2F, o-DOC6-2F, o-DOC8-2F, and o-DOC2C6-2F have been designed and synthesized. p-DOC6-2F and o-DOC6-2F have the same molecular backbone but different molecular shapes and symmetries. p-DOC6-2F has an S-shaped molecular backbone and C_2h symmetry, whereas o-DOC6-2F possesses a U-shaped molecular backbone and C_2v symmetry. The molecular shape and symmetry can influence the dipole moment, solubility, optical absorption, energy level, molecular packing, and film morphology. Compared with the corresponding p-DOC6-2F, o-DOC6-2F exhibits better solubility, a wider band gap, and a larger dipole moment. When blended with the donor polymer PBDB-T, the C_2v symmetric o-DOC6-2F can form an appropriate active layer morphology, whereas the C_2h symmetric p-DOC6-2F forms oversized domains. Organic solar cells (OSCs) based on p-DOC6-2F, o-DOC6-2F, o-DOC8-2F, and o-DOC2C6-2F obtained power conversion efficiencies of 9.23, 11.87, 11.23, and 10.80%, respectively. The result reveals that the molecular symmetry can facilely regulate the performance of OSCs.

PDI-Based Hexapod-Shaped Nonfullerene Acceptors for the High-Performance As-Cast Organic Solar Cells

Three hexapod-shaped PDI-hexamers (PSM1, PSM2, and PSM3) with a diphenylmethylene-bridged triphenylamine (TPA) core and six peripheral PDI subunits have been designed and synthesized. The influence of different peripheral PDI subunits on the morphology and crystallinity of acceptors is investigated. Distinctly different from the previously reported PDI trimers with a TPA core, which exhibit amorphous morphologies, these hexapod-shaped acceptors display improved crystallinities and photophysical properties. Our studies have shown that PSM3 with six peripheral thiophene-fused PDI subunits gives the best result. The as-cast blend films of PBDB-T and PSM3, which possess appropriate phase separation and higher crystallinity, show high and balanced charge mobilities. As expected, OSCs with PBDB-T:PSM3 as the active layer achieve the highest power conversion efficiency of 6.71% among these three acceptors, which is the highest one in TPA-based acceptors and one of the best for the as-cast OSCs based on PDI derivatives.

Electron-Deficient and Quinoid Central Unit Engineering for Unfused Ring-Based A1 -D-A2 -D-A1 -Type Acceptor Enables High Performance Nonfullerene Polymer Solar Cells with High Voc and PCE Simultaneously

Here, a pair of A₁ -D-A₂ -D-A₁ unfused ring core-based nonfullerene small molecule acceptors (NF-SMAs), BO2FIDT-4Cl and BT2FIDT-4Cl is synthesized, which possess the same terminals (A₁ ) and indacenodithiophene unit (D), coupling with different fluorinated electron-deficient central unit (difluorobenzoxadiazole or difluorobenzothiadiazole) (A₂ ). BT2FIDT-4Cl exhibits a slightly smaller optical bandgap of 1.56 eV, upshifted highest occupied molecular orbital energy levels, much higher electron mobility, and slightly enhanced molecular packing order in neat thin films than that of BO2FIDT-4Cl. The polymer solar cells (PSCs) based on BT2FIDT-4Cl:PM7 yield the best power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 12.5% with a V_oc of 0.97 V, which is higher than that of BO2FIDT-4Cl-based devices (PCE of 10.4%). The results demonstrate that the subtle modification of A₂ unit would result in lower trap-assisted recombination, more favorable morphology features, and more balanced electron and hole mobility in the PM7:BT2FIDT-4Cl blend films. It is worth mentioning that the PCE of 12.5% is the highest value in nonfused ring NF-SMA-based binary PSCs with high V_oc over 0.90 V. These results suggest that appropriate modulation of the quinoid electron-deficient central unit is an effective approach to construct highly efficient unfused ring NF-SMAs to boost PCE and V_oc simultaneously.