Deconstructing the Tissue Engineered Vascular Graft: Evaluating Scaffold Pre-Wetting, Conditioned Media Incubation, and Determining the Optimal Mononuclear Cell Source

Modulating biomechanical and integrating biochemical cues to foster adaptive remodeling of tissue engineered matrices for cardiovascular implants

Cardiovascular disease remains one of the leading causes of mortality in the Western world. Congenital heart disease affects nearly 1 % of newborns, with approximately one-fourth requiring reconstructive surgery during their lifetime. Current cardiovascular replacement options have significant limitations. Their inability to grow poses particular challenges for pediatric patients. Tissue Engineered Matrix (TEM)-based in situ constructs, with their self-repair and growth potential, offer a promising solution to overcome the limitations of current clinically used replacement options. Various functionalization strategies, involving the integration of biomechanical or biochemical components to enhance biocompatibility, have been developed for Tissue Engineered Vascular Grafts (TEVG) and Tissue Engineered Heart Valves (TEHV) to foster their capacity for in vivo remodeling. In this review, we present the current state of clinical translation for TEVG and TEHV, and provide a comprehensive overview of biomechanical and biochemical functionalization strategies for TEVG and TEHV. We discuss the rationale for functionalization, the implementation of functionalization cues in TEM-based TEVG and TEHV, and the interrelatedness of biomechanical and biochemical cues in the in vivo response. Finally, we address the challenges associated with functionalization and discuss how interdisciplinary research, especially when combined with in silico models, could enhance the translation of these strategies into clinical applications. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Cardiovascular disease remains one of the leading causes of mortality, with current replacements being unable to grow and regenerate. In this review, we present the current state of clinical translation for tissue engineered vascular grafts (TEVG) and heart valves (TEHV). Particularly, we discuss the rationale and implementation for functionalization cues in tissue engineered matrix-based TEVGs and TEHVs, and for the first time we introduce the interrelatedness of biomechanical and biochemical cues in the in-vivo response. These insights pave the way for next-generation cardiovascular implants that promise better durability, biocompatibility, and growth potential. Finally, we address the challenges associated with functionalization and discuss how interdisciplinary research, especially when combined with in silico models, could enhance the translation of these strategies into clinical applications .

Hemodynamics and Wall Mechanics of Vascular Graft Failure

Blood vessels are subjected to complex biomechanical loads, primarily from pressure-driven blood flow. Abnormal loading associated with vascular grafts, arising from altered hemodynamics or wall mechanics, can cause acute and progressive vascular failure and end-organ dysfunction. Perturbations to mechanobiological stimuli experienced by vascular cells contribute to remodeling of the vascular wall via activation of mechanosensitive signaling pathways and subsequent changes in gene expression and associated turnover of cells and extracellular matrix. In this review, we outline experimental and computational tools used to quantify metrics of biomechanical loading in vascular grafts and highlight those that show potential in predicting graft failure for diverse disease contexts. We include metrics derived from both fluid and solid mechanics that drive feedback loops between mechanobiological processes and changes in the biomechanical state that govern the natural history of vascular grafts. As illustrative examples, we consider application-specific coronary artery bypass grafts, peripheral vascular grafts, and tissue-engineered vascular grafts for congenital heart surgery as each of these involves unique circulatory environments, loading magnitudes, and graft materials.

Unraveling the potential of 3D bioprinted immunomodulatory materials for regulating macrophage polarization: State-of-the-art in bone and associated tissue regeneration

Macrophage-assisted immunomodulation is an alternative strategy in tissue engineering, wherein the interplay between pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory macrophage cells and body cells determines the fate of healing or inflammation. Although several reports have demonstrated that tissue regeneration depends on spatial and temporal regulation of the biophysical or biochemical microenvironment of the biomaterial, the underlying molecular mechanism behind immunomodulation is still under consideration for developing immunomodulatory scaffolds. Currently, most fabricated immunomodulatory platforms reported in the literature show regenerative capabilities of a particular tissue, for example, endogenous tissue (e.g., bone, muscle, heart, kidney, and lungs) or exogenous tissue (e.g., skin and eye). In this review, we briefly introduced the necessity of the 3D immunomodulatory scaffolds and nanomaterials, focusing on material properties and their interaction with macrophages for general readers. This review also provides a comprehensive summary of macrophage origin and taxonomy, their diverse functions, and various signal transduction pathways during biomaterial-macrophage interaction, which is particularly helpful for material scientists and clinicians for developing next-generation immunomodulatory scaffolds. From a clinical standpoint, we briefly discussed the role of 3D biomaterial scaffolds and/or nanomaterial composites for macrophage-assisted tissue engineering with a special focus on bone and associated tissues. Finally, a summary with expert opinion is presented to address the challenges and future necessity of 3D bioprinted immunomodulatory materials for tissue engineering.

Promoting Angiogenesis Using Immune Cells for Tissue-Engineered Vascular Grafts

Implantable tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) usually trigger the host reaction which is inextricably linked with the immune system, including blood-material interaction, protein absorption, inflammation, foreign body reaction, and so on. With remarkable progress, the immune response is no longer considered to be entirely harmful to TEVGs, but its therapeutic and impaired effects on angiogenesis and tissue regeneration are parallel. Although the implicated immune mechanisms remain elusive, it is certainly worthwhile to gain detailed knowledge about the function of the individual immune components during angiogenesis and vascular remodeling. This review provides a general overview of immune cells with an emphasis on macrophages in light of the current literature. To the extent possible, we summarize state-of-the-art approaches to immune cell regulation of the vasculature and suggest that future studies are needed to better define the timing of the activity of each cell subpopulation and to further reveal key regulatory switches.

Immunomodulation Strategies for the Successful Regeneration of a Tissue-Engineered Vascular Graft

Cardiovascular disease leads to the highest morbidity worldwide. There is an urgent need to solve the lack of a viable arterial graft for patients requiring coronary artery bypass surgery. The current gold standard is to use the patient's own blood vessel, such as a saphenous vein graft. However, some patients do not have appropriate vessels to use because of systemic disease or secondary surgery. On the other hand, there is no commercially available synthetic vascular graft available on the market for small diameter (<6 mm) blood vessels like coronary, carotid, and peripheral popliteal arteries. Tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) are studied in recent decades as a promising alternative to synthetic arterial prostheses. Yet only a few studies have proceeded to a clinical trial. Recent studies have uncovered that the host immune response can be directed toward increasing the success of a TEVG by shedding light on ways to modulate the macrophage response and improve the tissue regeneration outcome. In this review, the basic concepts of vascular tissue engineering and immunoengineering are considered. The state-of-art of TEVGs is summarized and the role of macrophages in TEVG regeneration is analyzed. Current immunomodulatory strategies based on biomaterials are also discussed.

Zoledronate alters natural progression of tissue-engineered vascular grafts

Macrophages are a critical driver of neovessel formation in tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs), but also contribute to graft stenosis, a leading clinical trial complication. Macrophage depletion via liposomal delivery of clodronate, a first-generation bisphosphonate, mitigates stenosis, but simultaneously leads to a complete lack of tissue development in TEVGs. This result and the associated difficulty of utilizing liposomal delivery means that clodronate may not be an ideal means of preventing graft stenosis. Newer generation bisphosphonates, such as zoledronate, may have differential effects on graft development with more facile drug delivery. We sought to examine the effect of zoledronate on TEVG neotissue formation and its potential application for mitigating TEVG stenosis. Thus, mice implanted with TEVGs received zoledronate or no treatment and were monitored by serial ultrasound for graft dilation and stenosis. After two weeks, TEVGs were explanted for histological examination. The overall graft area and remaining graft material (polyglycolic-acid) were higher in the zoledronate treatment group. These effects were associated with a corresponding decrease in macrophage infiltration. In addition, zoledronate affected the deposition of collagen in TEVGs, specifically, total and mature collagen. These differences may be, in part, explained by a depletion of leukocytes within the bone marrow that subsequently led to a decrease in the number of tissue-infiltrating macrophages. TEVGs from zoledronate-treated mice demonstrated a significantly greater degree of smooth muscle cell presence. There was no statistical difference in graft patency between treatment and control groups. While zoledronate led to a decrease in the number of macrophages in the TEVGs, the severity of stenosis appears to have increased significantly. Zoledronate treatment demonstrates that the process of smooth muscle cell-mediated neointimal hyperplasia may occur separately from a macrophage-mediated mechanism.

Tissue Engineered Vascular Graft Recipient Interleukin 10 Status Is Critical for Preventing Thrombosis

Tissue engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) are a promising technology, but are hindered by occlusion. Seeding with bone-marrow derived mononuclear cells (BM-MNCs) mitigates occlusion, yet the precise mechanism remains unclear. Seeded cells disappear quickly and potentially mediate an anti-inflammatory effect through paracrine signaling. Here, a series of reciprocal genetic TEVG implantations plus recombinant protein treatment is reported to investigate what role interleukin-10, an anti-inflammatory cytokine, plays from both host and seeded cells. TEVGs seeded with BM-MNCs from wild-type and IL-10 KO mice, plus unseeded grafts, are implanted into wild-type and IL-10 KO mice. Wild-type mice with unseeded grafts also receive recombinant IL-10. Serial ultrasound evaluates occlusion and TEVGs are harvested at 14 d for immunohistochemical analysis. TEVGs in IL-10 KO mice have significantly higher occlusion incidence compared to wild-type mice attributed to acute (<3 d) thrombosis. Cell seeding rescues TEVGs in IL-10 KO mice comparable to wild-type patency. IL-10 from the host and seeded cells do not significantly influence graft inflammation and macrophage phenotype, yet IL-10 treatment shows interesting biologic effects including decreasing cell proliferation and increasing M2 macrophage polarization. IL-10 from the host is critical for preventing TEVG thrombosis and seeded BM-MNCs exert a significant anti-thrombotic effect in IL-10 KO mice.

Progressive Reinvention or Destination Lost? Half a Century of Cardiovascular Tissue Engineering

The concept of tissue engineering evolved long before the phrase was forged, driven by the thromboembolic complications associated with the early total artificial heart programs of the 1960s. Yet more than half a century of dedicated research has not fulfilled the promise of successful broad clinical implementation. A historical account outlines reasons for this scientific impasse. For one, there was a disconnect between distinct eras each characterized by different clinical needs and different advocates. Initiated by the pioneers of cardiac surgery attempting to create neointimas on total artificial hearts, tissue engineering became fashionable when vascular surgeons pursued the endothelialisation of vascular grafts in the late 1970s. A decade later, it were cardiac surgeons again who strived to improve the longevity of tissue heart valves, and lastly, cardiologists entered the fray pursuing myocardial regeneration. Each of these disciplines and eras started with immense enthusiasm but were only remotely aware of the preceding efforts. Over the decades, the growing complexity of cellular and molecular biology as well as polymer sciences have led to surgeons gradually being replaced by scientists as the champions of tissue engineering. Together with a widening chasm between clinical purpose, human pathobiology and laboratory-based solutions, clinical implementation increasingly faded away as the singular endpoint of all strategies. Moreover, a loss of insight into the healing of cardiovascular prostheses in humans resulted in the acceptance of misleading animal models compromising the translation from laboratory to clinical reality. This was most evident in vascular graft healing, where the two main impediments to the in-situ generation of functional tissue in humans remained unheeded–the trans-anastomotic outgrowth stoppage of endothelium and the build-up of an impenetrable surface thrombus. To overcome this dead-lock, research focus needs to shift from a biologically possible tissue regeneration response to one that is feasible at the intended site and in the intended host environment of patients. Equipped with an impressive toolbox of modern biomaterials and deep insight into cues for facilitated healing, reconnecting to the “user needs” of patients would bring one of the most exciting concepts of cardiovascular medicine closer to clinical reality.

Extracellular Vesicles Enhance the Remodeling of Cell-Free Silk Vascular Scaffolds in Rat Aortae

Vascular tissue engineering is aimed at developing regenerative vascular grafts to restore tissue function by bypassing or replacing defective arterial segments with tubular biodegradable scaffolds. Scaffolds are often combined with stem or progenitor cells to prevent acute thrombosis and initiate scaffold remodeling. However, there are limitations to cell-based technologies regarding safety and clinical translation. Extracellular vesicles (EVs) are nanosized particles released by most cell types, including stem and progenitor cells, that serve to transmit protein and RNA cargo to target cells throughout the body. EVs have been shown to replicate the therapeutic effect of their parent cells; therefore, EVs derived from stem or progenitor cells may serve as a more translatable, cell-free, therapeutic base for vascular scaffolds. Our study aims to determine if EV incorporation provides a positive effect on graft patency and remodeling in vivo. We first assessed the effect of human adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cell (hADMSC) EVs on vascular cells using in vitro bioassays. We then developed an EV-functionalized vascular graft by vacuum-seeding EVs into porous silk-based tubular scaffolds. These constructs were implanted as aortic interposition grafts in Lewis rats, and their remodeling capacity was compared to that observed for hADMSC-seeded and blank (non-seeded) controls. The EV group demonstrated improved patency (100%) compared to the hADMSC (56%) and blank controls (82%) following eight weeks in vivo. The EV group also produced significantly more elastin (126.46%) and collagen (44.59%) compared to the blank group, while the hADMSC group failed to produce significantly more elastin (57.64%) or collagen (11.21%) compared to the blank group. Qualitative staining of the explanted neo-tissue revealed improved endothelium formation, increased smooth muscle cell infiltration, and reduced macrophage numbers in the EV group compared to the controls, which aids in explaining this group's favorable pre-clinical outcomes.

Design and characterization of a porous pouch to prevent peritoneal adhesions during in vivo vascular graft maturation

Vein grafts for coronary artery bypass are not available in more than 30% of patients due to prior use or systemic vascular diseases. Tissue engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) have shown promise, but intimal hyperplasia and graft thrombosis are still concerns when grafted in small-diameter arteries. In this study, we utilized the peritoneal cavity as an "in vivo" bioreactor to recruit autologous cells to electrospun conduits enclosed within porous pouches to improve the response after grafting. Specifically, we designed a new poly (ethylene glycol)-based pouch to avoid adhesion to the peritoneal wall and still allow the necessary peritoneal fluid to reach the enclosed conduit. The pouch mechanics in compression and bending were determined through experiments and finite element simulations to optimize the pouch design. This included poly (ethylene glycol) concentration, pore density, and pouch size. We demonstrated that the optimized pouch was able to withstand the estimated forces applied in the rat peritoneal cavity and it allowed maturation of the enclosed electrospun conduit. This pouch significantly reduced peritoneal adhesion formation compared to polytetrafluoroethylene pouches that have been used previously, which overcomes this potential limitation to clinical translation. After aortic grafting of pre-conditioned conduits, patent grafts with limited intimal hyperplasia were observed. Overall, this study demonstrated a new pouch design that allows the in vivo bioreactor strategy to be used for vascular tissue engineering without the potential side effect of peritoneal adhesion formation.

Early natural history of neotissue formation in tissue-engineered vascular grafts in a murine model

Aim: To characterize early events in neotissue formation during the first 2 weeks after vascular scaffold implantation. Materials & methods: Biodegradable polymeric scaffolds were implanted as abdominal inferior vena cava interposition grafts in wild-type mice. Results: All scaffolds explanted at day 1 contained a platelet-rich mural thrombus. Within the first few days, the majority of cell infiltration appeared to be from myeloid cells at the peritoneal surface with modest infiltration along the lumen. Host reaction to the graft was distinct between the scaffold and mural thrombus; the scaffold stimulated an escalating foreign body reaction, whereas the thrombus was quickly remodeled into collagen-rich neotissue. Conclusion: Mural thrombi remodel into neotissue that persistently occludes the lumen of vascular grafts.

The Evolution of Tissue Engineered Vascular Graft Technologies: From Preclinical Trials to Advancing Patient Care

Currently available synthetic grafts have contributed to improved outcomes in cardiovascular surgery. However, the implementation of these graft materials at small diameters have demonstrated poor patency, inhibiting their use for coronary artery bypass surgery in adults. Additionally, when applied to a pediatric patient population, they are handicapped by their lack of growth ability. Tissue engineered alternatives could possibly address these limitations by producing biocompatible implants with the ability to repair, remodel, grow, and regenerate. A tissue engineered vascular graft (TEVG) generally consists of a scaffold, seeded cells, and the appropriate environmental cues (i.e., growth factors, physical stimulation) to induce tissue formation. This review critically appraises current state-of-the-art techniques for vascular graft production. We additionally examine current graft shortcomings and future prospects, as they relate to cardiovascular surgery, from two major clinical trials.

Amnion-Based Scaffold with Enhanced Strength and Biocompatibility for In Vivo Vascular Repair

IMPACT STATEMENT

This study aimed at developing an amnion-based scaffold suitable for vascular tissue engineering applications and in vivo usage. We successfully produced a multilayered scaffold with improved biomechanical properties and biocompatibility for in vivo vascular implantation. Our approach not only offers an allogeneic "off-the-shelf" solution for clinical use but also it provides the possibility of personalized medicine using a patient's own amnion and stem cells for the production of tissue engineered grafts for reconstructive heart surgery.

Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Shear Stress and Wall Thickness in Tissue-Engineered Vascular Grafts

OBJECTIVES

Tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) have demonstrated potential for treating congenital heart disease (CHD); however, quantitative imaging for tracking functional and structural remodeling of TEVGs has not been applied. Therefore, we evaluated the potential of magnetic resonance (MR) imaging for assessing TEVG wall shear stress (WSS) and wall thickness in a large animal model.

METHODS

Cell-seeded (n = 3) or unseeded (n = 3) TEVGs were implanted as inferior vena cava interposition grafts in juvenile lambs. Six months following implantation, two-dimensional phase-contrast MR imaging was performed at 3 slice locations (proximal, middle, and distal) to assess normalized WSS (i.e., WSS-to-cross sectional area). T2-weighted MR imaging was performed to assess TEVG wall thickness. Histology was qualitatively assessed, whereas immunohistochemistry was semiquantitatively assessed for smooth muscle cells (αSMA), macrophage lineage cells (CD11b), and matrix metalloproteinase activity (MMP-2 and MMP-9). Picrosirius Red staining was performed to quantify collagen content.

RESULTS

TEVG wall thickness was significantly higher for proximal, middle, and distal slices in unseeded versus cell-seeded grafts. Significantly higher WSS values existed for proximal versus distal slice locations for cell-seeded TEVGs, whereas no differences in WSS existed between slices for unseeded TEVGs. Additionally, no differences in WSS existed between cell-seeded and unseeded groups. Both groups demonstrated elastin formation, without vascular calcification. Unseeded TEVGs possessed greater content of smooth muscle cells when compared with cell-seeded TEVGs. No differences in macrophage, MMP activity, or collagen content existed between groups.

CONCLUSION

MR imaging allows for in vivo assessment of functional and anatomical characteristics of TEVGs and may provide a nonionizing approach that is clinically translatable to children undergoing treatment for CHD.

Future Perspectives on the Role of Stem Cells and Extracellular Vesicles in Vascular Tissue Regeneration

Vascular tissue engineering is an area of regenerative medicine that attempts to create functional replacement tissue for defective segments of the vascular network. One approach to vascular tissue engineering utilizes seeding of biodegradable tubular scaffolds with stem (and/or progenitor) cells wherein the seeded cells initiate scaffold remodeling and prevent thrombosis through paracrine signaling to endogenous cells. Stem cells have received an abundance of attention in recent literature regarding the mechanism of their paracrine therapeutic effect. However, very little of this mechanistic research has been performed under the aegis of vascular tissue engineering. Therefore, the scope of this review includes the current state of TEVGs generated using the incorporation of stem cells in biodegradable scaffolds and potential cell-free directions for TEVGs based on stem cell secreted products. The current generation of stem cell-seeded vascular scaffolds are based on the premise that cells should be obtained from an autologous source. However, the reduced regenerative capacity of stem cells from certain patient groups limits the therapeutic potential of an autologous approach. This limitation prompts the need to investigate allogeneic stem cells or stem cell secreted products as therapeutic bases for TEVGs. The role of stem cell derived products, particularly extracellular vesicles (EVs), in vascular tissue engineering is exciting due to their potential use as a cell-free therapeutic base. EVs offer many benefits as a therapeutic base for functionalizing vascular scaffolds such as cell specific targeting, physiological delivery of cargo to target cells, reduced immunogenicity, and stability under physiological conditions. However, a number of points must be addressed prior to the effective translation of TEVG technologies that incorporate stem cell derived EVs such as standardizing stem cell culture conditions, EV isolation, scaffold functionalization with EVs, and establishing the therapeutic benefit of this combination treatment.

Performance of marrow stromal cell-seeded small-caliber multilayered vascular graft in a senescent sheep model

Failure of small-caliber grafts, used as bypass or reconstructive grafts in cardiovascular treatments, is often caused by thrombosis and stenosis. We have developed a multilayered, compliant graft with an electrospun heparin-encapsulated core and collagen-chitosan shell. Herein, the performances of acellular and cell-seeded grafts were evaluated in adult sheep for preclinical assessment. Allogeneic ovine marrow stroma cells (MSCs) were uniformly attached to the lumen of cell-seeded grafts. Interposition grafts were used for carotid arteries. Four grafts were tested for each type. Upon implantation, all grafts successfully restored perfusion and rhythmically deformed under pulsatile arterial flow. Weekly ultrasonography and Doppler revealed that all grafts remained patent for perfusion during the course of one-month study. No formation of blood clots or other complications were found. The diameter of graft lumen did not vary significantly over the time or with the graft type, while narrowing at anastomosis and significant thickening of graft wall were found in both types of grafts. More significant neotissue formation was found at anastomotic sections of acellular controls compared to cell-seeded grafts. Results from histological and immunofluorescent analyses revealed moderate intimal hyperplasia (IH) at anastomosis. When compared to cell-seeded grafts, acellular controls presented thicker IH composed of α-smooth muscle actin positive cells and ground substances, which correlated with reduced and more disturbing flow. IH was thickest at anastomosis and tapered off to a minimum in the mid-section. Few PECAM-positive cells appeared on cell-seeded grafts but not acellular controls. Additionally, lesser graft thickening was found in cell-seed grafts, which might be associated with the function of stromal cells in altering the fibrotic process during tissue repair. Results suggest that MSCs held the potential to reduce hyperplasia and improve healing in an aged, large animal model for vascular grafting.

Toward a patient-specific tissue engineered vascular graft

Integrating three-dimensional printing with the creation of tissue-engineered vascular grafts could provide a readily available, patient-specific, autologous tissue source that could significantly improve outcomes in newborns with congenital heart disease. Here, we present the recent case of a candidate for our tissue-engineered vascular graft clinical trial deemed ineligible due to complex anatomical requirements and consider the application of three-dimensional printing technologies for a patient-specific graft. We 3D-printed a closed-disposable seeding device and validated that it performed equivalently to the traditional open seeding technique using ovine bone marrow–derived mononuclear cells. Next, our candidate’s preoperative imaging was reviewed to propose a patient-specific graft. A seeding apparatus was then designed to accommodate the custom graft and 3D-printed on a commodity fused deposition modeler. This exploratory feasibility study represents an important proof of concept advancing progress toward a rationally designed patient-specific tissue-engineered vascular graft for clinical application.