Engineering Spatially Organized Multienzyme Assemblies for Complex Chemical Transformation

Engineering Compositionally Uniform Yeast Whole-Cell Biocatalysts with Maximized Surface Enzyme Density for Cellulosic Biofuel Production

In recent decades, whole-cell biocatalysis has played an increasingly important role in the food, pharmaceutical, and energy sector. One promising application is the use of ethanologenic yeast displaying minicellulosomes on the cell surface to combine cellulose hydrolysis and fermentation into a single step for consolidated bioprocessing. However, cellulosic ethanol production using existing yeast whole-cell biocatalysts (yWCBs) has not reached industrial feasibility due to their inefficient cellulose hydrolysis. As prior studies have demonstrated enzyme density on the yWCB surface to be one of the most important parameters for enhancing cellulose hydrolysis, we sought to maximize this parameter at both the population and single-cell levels in yWCBs displaying tetrafunctional minicellulosomes. At the population level, enzyme density is limited by the presence of a nondisplay population constituting 25-50% of all cells. In this study, we identified the cause to be plasmid loss and successfully eliminated the nondisplay population to generate compositionally uniform yWCBs. At the single-cell level, we demonstrate that enzyme density is limited by molecular crowding, which hinders minicellulosome assembly. By adjusting the integrated gene copy number, we obtained yWCBs of tunable enzyme display levels. This tunability allowed us to avoid the crowding-limited regime and achieve a maximum enzyme density per cell. As a result, the best strain showed a cellulose-to-ethanol yield of 4.92 g/g, corresponding to 96% of the theoretical maximum and near-complete conversion (∼96%) of the starting cellulose (1% PASC). Our holistic engineering strategy that combines a population and single-cell level approach is broadly applicable to enhance the WCB performance in other biocatalytic cascade schemes.

Tuning Multistep Biocatalysis through Enzyme and Cofactor Colocalization in Charged Porous Protein Macromolecular Frameworks

Spatial organization of biocatalytic activities is crucial to organisms to efficiently process complex metabolism. Inspired by this mechanism, artificial scaffold structures are designed to harbor functionally coupled biocatalysts, resulting in acellular materials that can complete multistep reactions at high efficiency and low cost. Substrate channeling is an approach for efficiency enhancement of multistep reactions, but fast diffusion of small molecule intermediates poses a major challenge to achieve channeling in vitro. Here, we explore how multistep biocatalysis is affected, and can be modulated, by cofactor-enzyme colocalization within a synthetic bioinspired material. In this material, a heterogeneous protein macromolecular framework (PMF) acts as a porous host matrix for colocalization of two coupled enzymes and their small molecule cofactor, nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD). After formation of the PMF from a higher order assembly of P22 virus-like particles (VLPs), the enzymes were partitioned into the PMF by covalent attachment and presentation on the VLP exterior. Using a collective property of the PMF (i.e., high density of negative charges in the PMF), NAD molecules were partitioned into the framework via electrostatic interactions after being conjugated to a polycationic species. This effectively controlled the localization and diffusion of NAD, resulting in substrate channeling between the enzymes. Changing ionic strength modulates the PMF-NAD interactions, tuning two properties that impact the multistep efficiency oppositely in response to ionic strength: cofactor partitioning (colocalization with the enzymes) and cofactor mobility (translocation between the enzymes). Within the range tested, we observed a maximum of 5-fold increase or 75% decrease in multistep efficiency as compared to free enzymes in solution, which suggest both the colocalization and the mobility are critical for the multistep efficiency. This work demonstrates utility of collective behaviors, exhibited by hierarchical bioassemblies, in the construction of functional materials for enzyme cascades, which possess properties such as tunable multistep biocatalysis.

Buffer Effects in Zirconium-Based UiO Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs) That Influence Enzyme Immobilization and Catalytic Activity in Enzyme/MOF Biocatalysts

Novel biocatalysts that feature enzymes immobilized onto solid supports have recently become a major research focus in an effort to create more sustainable and greener chemistries in catalysis. Many of these novel biocatalyst systems feature enzymes immobilized onto metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), which have been shown to increase enzyme activity, stability, and recyclability in industrial processes. While the strategies used for immobilizing enzymes onto MOFs can vary, the conditions always require a buffer to maintain the functionality of the enzymes during immobilization. This report brings attention to critical buffer effects important to consider when developing enzyme/MOF biocatalysts, specifically for buffering systems containing phosphate ions. A comparative analysis of different enzyme/MOF biocatalysts featuring horseradish peroxidase and/or glucose oxidase immobilized onto the MOFs UiO-66, UiO-66-NH₂, and UiO-67 using a noncoordinate buffering system (MOPSO buffer) and a phosphate buffering system (PBS) show that phosphate ions can have an inhibitory effect. Previous studies utilizing phosphate buffers for enzyme immobilization onto MOFs have shown Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectra that have been assigned stretching frequencies associated with enzymes after immobilization. Analyses and characterizations using zeta potential measurements, scanning electron microscopy, Brunauer-Emmett-Teller surface area, powder X-ray diffraction, Energy Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy, and FT-IR show concerning differences in enzyme loading and activity based on the buffering system used during immobilization.

Ultrasensitive electrochemical biosensor for detection of circulating tumor cells based on a highly efficient enzymatic cascade reaction

There has been great interest in the enzymatic cascade amplification strategy for the electrochemical detection of circulating tumor cells (CTCs). In this work, we designed a highly efficient enzymatic cascade reaction based on a multiwalled carbon nanotubes-chitosan (MWCNTs-CS) composite for detection of CTCs. A high electrochemical effective surface area was obtained for a MWCNTs-CS-modified glassy carbon electrode (GCE) for loading glucose oxidase (GOD), as well as a high loading rate and high electrical activity of the enzyme. As a 'power source', the MWCNTs-CS composites provided a strong driving power for horseradish peroxidase (HRP) on the surface of polystyrene (PS) microspheres, which acted as probes for capturing CTCs and allowed the reaction to proceed with further facilitation of electron transfer. Aptamer, CTCs, and PS microspheres with HRP and anti-epithelial cell adhesion molecule (anti-EpCAM) antibody were assembled on the MWCNTs-CS/GCE to allow for the modulation of enzyme distance at the micrometer level, and thus ultra-long-range signal transmission was made possible. An ultrasensitive response to CTCs was obtained via this proposed sensing strategy, with a linear range from 10 cell mL^-1 to 6 × 10⁶ cell mL^-1 and a detection limit of 3 cell mL^-1. Moreover, this electrochemical sensor possessed the capability to detect CTCs in serum samples with satisfactory accuracy, which indicated great potential for early diagnosis and clinical analysis of cancer.

Direct Yeast Surface Codisplay of Sequential Enzymes with Complementary Anchor Motifs: Enabling Enhanced Glycosylation of Natural Products

Yeast surface display is an appealing technique for constructing multienzyme cascades. This technique is commonly achieved using a scaffold for the ordered arrangement of various enzymes. However, this method is typically complicated because scaffold use may engender extra metabolic burden on the cell host. Here, we established a direct yeast surface codisplay strategy by employing two complementary anchor motifs, Agα1 and Pir1. These motifs allow for the codisplay of sequential uridine diphosphate-glycosyltransferase (UGT) and sucrose synthase (SUS) on the surface of Pichia pastoris (syn. Komagataella phaffii) for the glycosylation of natural products. We manipulated the displayed stoichiometry, amount, and assembly order of UGT and SUS by coupling them with anchor motifs. Furthermore, their effect on enzyme activity was thoroughly investigated. The surface-codisplayed strain UGT-Pir-SUS-Agα exhibited greater thermostability than the single-displayed strains and their free counterparts. Moreover, the strain UGT-Pir-SUS-Agα was successfully applied to glycyrrhetinic acid (GA) glycosylation to produce GA-3-O-Glc, with sucrose being the sugar donor in this process. This generated 7.5- to 20- and 5.3-fold higher GA-3-O-Glc concentration compared with the free counterparts (enzyme mass loading of 20-fold in excess) and mixed single-displayed strains of UGT-Agα and SUS-Pir, respectively. This increase was due to the improved biochemical properties and substrate channeling effect of strain UGT-Pir-SUS-Agα. This controllable direct surface codisplay strategy, based on complementary anchor motifs, is readily extendable to other enzyme cascades.

Microscale Colocalization of Cascade Enzymes Yields Activity Enhancement

Colocalization of cascade enzymes is broadly discussed as a phenomenon that can boost the cascade reaction throughput, although a direct experimental verification is often challenging. This is mainly due to difficulties in establishing proper size regimes and in the analytical quantification of colocalization effect with adequate experimental systems and simulations. In this study, by taking advantage of reversible DNA-directed colocalization of enzymes on microspheres, we established a cascade system that can be used to directly evaluate the colocalization effect with exactly the same experimental settings except for the state of enzyme dispersion. In the regime of highly dilute microspheres of particular sizes, the colocalized cascade shows enhanced activity compared with the freely diffusing cascade, as evidenced by a shortened lag phase in the time-course production. Reaction-diffusion modeling reveals that the enhancement can be ascribed to the initial accumulation of intermediate substrate around the colocalized enzymes and is found to be carrier-size-dependent. This work demonstrates the dependence of the colocalization effect of enzyme cascades on an interplay of nano- and microscales, lending theoretical support to the rational design of highly efficient multienzyme catalysts.

Protein Mediated Enzyme Immobilization

Enzyme immobilization is an essential technology for commercializing biocatalysis. It imparts stability, recoverability, and other valuable features that improve the effectiveness of biocatalysts. While many avenues to join an enzyme to solid phases exist, protein-mediated immobilization is rapidly developing and has many advantages. Protein-mediated immobilization allows for the binding interaction to be genetically coded, can be used to create artificial multienzyme cascades, and enables modular designs that expand the variety of enzymes immobilized. By designing around binding interactions between protein domains, they can be integrated into functional materials for protein immobilization. These materials are framed within the context of biocatalytic performance, immobilization efficiency, and stability of the materials. In this review, supports composed entirely of protein are discussed first, with systems such as cellulosomes and protein cages being discussed alongside newer technologies like spore-based biocatalysts and forizymes. Protein-composite materials such as polymersomes and protein-inorganic supraparticles are then discussed to demonstrate how protein-mediated strategies are applied to many classes of solid materials. Critical analysis and future directions of protein-based immobilization are then discussed, with a particular focus on both computational and design strategies to advance this area of research and make it more broadly applicable to many classes of enzymes.

Engineering the 2-Oxoglutarate Dehydrogenase Complex to Understand Catalysis and Alter Substrate Recognition

The E. coli 2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase complex (OGDHc) is a multienzyme complex in the tricarboxylic acid cycle, consisting of multiple copies of three components, 2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase (E1o), dihydrolipoamide succinyltransferase (E2o) and dihydrolipoamide dehydrogenase (E3), which catalyze the formation of succinyl-CoA and NADH (+H+) from 2-oxoglutarate. This review summarizes applications of the site saturation mutagenesis (SSM) to engineer E. coli OGDHc with mechanistic and chemoenzymatic synthetic goals. First, E1o was engineered by creating SSM libraries at positions His260 and His298.Variants were identified that: (a) lead to acceptance of substrate analogues lacking the 5-carboxyl group and (b) performed carboligation reactions producing acetoin-like compounds with good enantioselectivity. Engineering the E2o catalytic (core) domain enabled (a) assignment of roles for pivotal residues involved in catalysis, (b) re-construction of the substrate-binding pocket to accept substrates other than succinyllysyldihydrolipoamide and (c) elucidation of the mechanism of trans-thioesterification to involve stabilization of a tetrahedral oxyanionic intermediate with hydrogen bonds by His375 and Asp374, rather than general acid–base catalysis which has been misunderstood for decades. The E. coli OGDHc is the first example of a 2-oxo acid dehydrogenase complex which was evolved to a 2-oxo aliphatic acid dehydrogenase complex by engineering two consecutive E1o and E2o components.

Multienzyme nanoassemblies: from rational design to biomedical applications

Multienzyme nanoassemblies (MENAs) that combine the functions of several enzymes into one entity have attracted widespread research interest due to their improved enzymatic performance and great potential for multiple applications. Considerable progress has been made to design and fabricate MENAs in recent years. This review begins with an introduction of the up-to-date strategies in designing MENAs, mainly including substrate channeling, compartmentalization and control of enzyme stoichiometry. The desirable properties that endow MENAs with important applications are also discussed in detail. Then, the recent advances in utilizing MENAs in the biomedical field are reviewed, with a particular focus on biosensing, tumor therapy, antioxidant and drug delivery. Finally, the challenges and perspectives for development of versatile MENAs are summarized.

Metabolic channeling: predictions, deductions, and evidence

With the elucidation of myriad anabolic and catabolic enzyme-catalyzed cellular pathways crisscrossing each other, an obvious question arose: how could these networks operate with maximal catalytic efficiency and minimal interference? A logical answer was the postulate of metabolic channeling, which in its simplest embodiment assumes that the product generated by one enzyme passes directly to a second without diffusion into the surrounding medium. This tight coupling of activities might increase a pathway's metabolic flux and/or serve to sequester unstable/toxic/reactive intermediates as well as prevent their access to other networks. Here, we present evidence for this concept, commencing with enzymes that feature a physical molecular tunnel, to multi-enzyme complexes that retain pathway substrates through electrostatics or enclosures, and finally to metabolons that feature collections of enzymes assembled into clusters with variable stoichiometric composition. Lastly, we discuss the advantages of reversibly assembled metabolons in the context of the purinosome, the purine biosynthesis metabolon.

Biofilm-Mediated Immobilization of a Multienzyme Complex for Accelerating Inositol Production from Starch

Bacterial biofilm, as a natural and renewable material, is a promising architecture for enzyme immobilization. In this study, we have demonstrated the feasibility of an Escherichia coli biofilm to immobilize a self-assembly multienzyme complex by the covalent interaction between a peptide SpyTag and its protein partner SpyCatcher. The SpyTag-labeled biofilm is displayed on the surface of E. coli by overexpressing the recombinant CsgA-SpyTag, in which CsgA is capable of forming biofilms. This SpyTag bearing biofilm is used to bind with SpyCatcher bearing synthetic mini-scaffoldin, which also contains a carbohydrate-binding module 3 (CBM3), and four different cohesins from different microorganisms. CBM3 was used to bind with cellulose, while the four different cohesins were used to recruit four dockerin-containing cascade enzymes, which were subsequently applied to convert starch to myo-inositol. Compared to the free enzyme mixture, the biofilm-immobilized enzyme complex exhibited a 4.28 times increase in initial reaction rate in producing myo-inositol from 10 g/L maltodextrin (a derivative of starch). Additionally, this biofilm-immobilized enzyme complex showed much higher recycle ability than the enzyme complex which was immobilized on a regenerated amorphous cellulose (RAC) system. In conclusion, the biofilm-mediated immobilization of the enzymatic biosystem provides a promising strategy to increase the reaction rate and enhance the stability of an in vitro enzymatic biosystem, exhibiting high potential to improve the efficiency of an in vitro biosystem.

Organizing Multi-Enzyme Systems into Programmable Materials for Biocatalysis

Significant advances in enzyme discovery, protein and reaction engineering have transformed biocatalysis into a viable technology for the industrial scale manufacturing of chemicals. Multi-enzyme catalysis has emerged as a new frontier for the synthesis of complex chemicals. However, the in vitro operation of multiple enzymes simultaneously in one vessel poses challenges that require new strategies for increasing the operational performance of enzymatic cascade reactions. Chief among those strategies is enzyme co-immobilization. This review will explore how advances in synthetic biology and protein engineering have led to bioinspired co-localization strategies for the scaffolding and compartmentalization of enzymes. Emphasis will be placed on genetically encoded co-localization mechanisms as platforms for future autonomously self-organizing biocatalytic systems. Such genetically programmable systems could be produced by cell factories or emerging cell-free systems. Challenges and opportunities towards self-assembling, multifunctional biocatalytic materials will be discussed.

Engineering DNA-Templated Nonribosomal Peptide Synthesis

Diffusive escape of intermediates limits the rate enhancement that nanocontainers or macromolecular scaffolds can provide for artificial biocatalytic cascades. Nonribosomal peptide synthetases (NRPSs) naturally form gigantic assembly lines and prevent escape by covalently tethering intermediates. Here, we have built DNA-templated NRPS (DT-NRPS) by adding zinc-finger tags to split NRPS modules. The zinc fingers direct the NRPS modules to 9-bp binding sites on a DNA strand, where they form a catalytically active enzyme cascade. Geometric constraints of the DT-NRPSs were investigated using the template DNA as a molecular ruler. Up to four DT-NRPS modules were assembled on DNA to synthesize peptides. DT-NRPSs outperform previously reported DNA-templated enzyme cascades in terms of DNA acceleration, which demonstrates that covalent intermediate channeling is possible along the DNA template. Attachment of assembly line enzymes to a DNA scaffold is a promising catalytic strategy for the sequence-controlled biosynthesis of nonribosomal peptides and other polymers.

Yeast Intracellular Staining (yICS): Enabling High-Throughput, Quantitative Detection of Intracellular Proteins via Flow Cytometry for Pathway Engineering

The complexities of pathway engineering necessitate screening libraries to discover phenotypes of interest. However, this approach is challenging when desirable phenotypes cannot be directly linked to growth advantages or fluorescence. In these cases, the ability to rapidly quantify intracellular proteins in the pathway of interest is critical to expedite the clonal selection process. While Saccharomyces cerevisiae remains a common host for pathway engineering, current approaches for intracellular protein detection in yeast either have low throughput, can interfere with protein function, or lack the ability to detect multiple proteins simultaneously. To fill this need, we developed yeast intracellular staining (yICS) that enables fluorescent antibodies to access intracellular compartments of yeast cells while maintaining their cellular integrity for analysis by flow cytometry. Using the housekeeping proteins β actin and glyceraldehyde 3-phophate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) as targets for yICS, we demonstrated for the first time successful antibody-based flow cytometric detection of yeast intracellular proteins with no modification. Further, yICS characterization of a recombinant d-xylose assimilation pathway showed 3-plexed, quantitative detection of the xylose reductase (XR), xylitol dehydrogenase (XDH), and xylulokinase (XK) enzymes each fused with a small (6-10 amino acids) tag, revealing distinct enzyme expression profiles between plasmid-based and genome-integrated expression approaches. As a result of its high-throughput and quantitative capability, yICS enabled rapid screening of a library created from CRISPR-mediated XDH integration into the yeast δ site, identifying rare (1%) clones that led to an 8.4-fold increase in XDH activity. These results demonstrate the utility of yICS for greatly accelerating pathway engineering efforts, as well as any application where the high-throughput and quantitative detection of intracellular proteins is desired.

Overview on Multienzymatic Cascades for the Production of Non-canonical α-Amino Acids

The 22 genetically encoded amino acids (AAs) present in proteins (the 20 standard AAs together with selenocysteine and pyrrolysine), are commonly referred as proteinogenic AAs in the literature due to their appearance in ribosome-synthetized polypeptides. Beyond the borders of this key set of compounds, the rest of AAs are generally named imprecisely as non-proteinogenic AAs, even when they can also appear in polypeptide chains as a result of post-transductional machinery. Besides their importance as metabolites in life, many of D-α- and L-α-"non-canonical" amino acids (NcAAs) are of interest in the biotechnological and biomedical fields. They have found numerous applications in the discovery of new medicines and antibiotics, drug synthesis, cosmetic, and nutritional compounds, or in the improvement of protein and peptide pharmaceuticals. In addition to the numerous studies dealing with the asymmetric synthesis of NcAAs, many different enzymatic pathways have been reported in the literature allowing for the biosynthesis of NcAAs. Due to the huge heterogeneity of this group of molecules, this review is devoted to provide an overview on different established multienzymatic cascades for the production of non-canonical D-α- and L-α-AAs, supplying neophyte and experienced professionals in this field with different illustrative examples in the literature. Whereas the discovery of new or newly designed enzymes is of great interest, dusting off previous enzymatic methodologies by a "back and to the future" strategy might accelerate the implementation of new or improved multienzymatic cascades.

Co-immobilization of an Enzyme System on a Metal-Organic Framework to Produce a More Effective Biocatalyst

In many respects, enzymes offer advantages over traditional chemical processes due to their decreased energy requirements for function and inherent greener processing. However, significant barriers exist for the utilization of enzymes in industrial processes due to their limited stabilities and inability to operate over larger temperature and pH ranges. Immobilization of enzymes onto solid supports has gained attention as an alternative to traditional chemical processes due to enhanced enzymatic performance and stability. This study demonstrates the co-immobilization of glucose oxidase (GOx) and horseradish peroxidase (HRP) as an enzyme system on Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs), UiO-66 and UiO-66-NH2, that produces a more effective biocatalyst as shown by the oxidation of pyrogallol. The two MOFs utilized as solid supports for immobilization were chosen to investigate how modifications of the MOF linker affect stability at the enzyme/MOF interface and subsequent activity of the enzyme system. The enzymes work in concert with activation of HRP through the addition of glucose as a substrate for GOx. Enzyme immobilization and leaching studies showed HRP/GOx@UiO-66-NH2 immobilized 6% more than HRP/GOx@UiO-66, and leached only 36% of the immobilized enzymes over three days in the solution. The enzyme/MOF composites also showed increased enzyme activity in comparison with the free enzyme system: the composite HRP/GOx@UiO-66-NH2 displayed 189 U/mg activity and HRP/GOx@UiO-66 showed 143 U/mg while the free enzyme showed 100 U/mg enzyme activity. This increase in stability and activity is due to the amine group of the MOF linker in HRP/GOx@UiO-66-NH2 enhancing electrostatic interactions at the enzyme/MOF interface, thereby producing the most stable biocatalyst material in solution. The HRP/GOx@UiO-66-NH2 also showed long-term stability in the solid state for over a month at room temperature.

All Wrapped up: Stabilization of Enzymes within Single Enzyme Nanoparticles

Enzymes are extremely useful in many industrial and pharmaceutical areas due to their ability to catalyze reactions with high selectivity. In order to extend their lifetime, significant efforts have been made to increase their stability using protein- or medium engineering as well as by chemical modification. Many researchers have explored the immobilization of enzymes onto carriers, or entrapment within a matrix, framework or nanoparticle with the hope of constricting the movement of the enzyme and shielding it from aggressive environments, thus delaying the denaturation. These strategies often balance three competing interests: (i) maintaining high enzymatic activity, (ii) ensuring good long-term stability against temperature, dehydration, organic solvents, and or aggressive pH, and (iii) enabling a tuning or reversible switching of enzyme activity. In most cases, multiple enzymes will be contained within a single nanoparticle or matrix, but in recent years researchers have begun to wrap up individual enzymes within single enzyme nanoparticles (SENs). In these nanoparticles the enzyme is stabilized by a thin shell, typically a polymer, prepared either by in situ polymerization from the enzyme surface or by assembling a preformed polymer around it. Because of the increased control over the environment directly around the enzyme, and the possibility of more directly controlling substrate diffusion, many SENs show remarkable stability while retaining high initial activities even for quite fragile enzymes. Moreover, the activity of the enzyme can often be more easily fine-tuned by adjusting the layer properties. We postulate that this emerging field will offer exciting and elegant opportunities to both extend the catalytic lifetime of enzymes in aggressive solvents, temperatures and pH, and enable their activity to be switched on and off on demand by modulation of the outer material layer.

Elucidating structure-performance relationships in whole-cell cooperative enzyme catalysis

Cooperative enzyme catalysis in nature has long inspired the application of engineered multi-enzyme assemblies for industrial biocatalysis. Despite considerable interest, efforts to harness the activity of cell-surface displayed multi-enzyme assemblies have been based on trial and error rather than rational design due to a lack of quantitative tools. In this study, we developed a quantitative approach to whole-cell biocatalyst characterization enabling a comprehensive study of how yeast-surface displayed multi-enzyme assemblies form. Here we show that the multi-enzyme assembly efficiency is limited by molecular crowding on the yeast cell surface, and that maximizing enzyme density is the most important parameter for enhancing cellulose hydrolytic performance. Interestingly, we also observed that proximity effects are only synergistic when the average inter-enzyme distance is > ~130 nm. The findings and the quantitative approach developed in this work should help to advance the field of biocatalyst engineering from trial and error to rational design.