Catalytic N2-to-NH3 Conversion by Fe at Lower Driving Force: A Proposed Role for Metallocene-Mediated PCET

Catalytic Nitrogen Fixation Using Well-Defined Molecular Catalysts under Ambient or Mild Reaction Conditions

Ammonia (NH3) is industrially produced from dinitrogen (N2) and dihydrogen (H2) by the Haber-Bosch process, although H2 is prepared from fossil fuels, and the reaction requires harsh conditions. On the other hand, microorganisms have fixed nitrogen under ambient reaction conditions. Recently, well-defined molecular transition metal complexes have been found to work as catalyst to convert N2 into NH3 by reactions with chemical reductants and proton sources under ambient reaction conditions. Among them, involvement of both N2-splitting pathway and proton-coupled electron transfer is found to be very effective for high catalytic activity. Furthermore, direct electrocatalytic and photocatalytic conversions of N2 into NH3 have been recently achieved. In addition to catalytic formation of NH3, selective catalytic conversion of N2 into hydrazine (NH2NH2) and catalytic silylation of N2 into silylamines have been reported. Catalytic C-N bond formation has been more recently established to afford cyanate anion (NCO-) under ambient reaction conditions. Further development of direct conversion of N2 into nitrogen-containing compounds as well as green ammonia synthesis leading to the use of ammonia as an energy carrier is expected.

Iron(I) Complex Bearing an Open-Shell Diazenido Ligand

Low-valent transition-metal diazenido species are important intermediates in transition-metal-mediated dinitrogen reduction reactions. Isolable complexes of the type unanimously feature closed-shell diazenido ligands. Those bearing open-shell diazenido ligands have remained elusive. Herein, we report the synthesis, characterization, and reactivity of a d7 iron(I) complex featuring an open-shell silyldiazenido ligand, [(ICy)Fe(NNSiiPr3)(η2:η2-dvtms)] (1, ICy = 1,3-dicyclohexylimidazole-2-ylidene, dvtms = divinyltetramethyldisiloxane). Complex 1 is prepared in good yield by silylation of the iron(-I)-N2 complex [K(18-crown-6)][(ICy)Fe(N2)(η2:η2-dvtms)] with iPr3SiOTf and has been fully characterized by various spectroscopic methods. Theoretical studies, in combination with characterization data, established an S = 1/2 ground spin-state for 1 that can best be described as a quartet iron(I) center featuring an antiferromagnetically coupled triplet silyldiazenido ligand. The diazenido and alkene ligands in 1 are labile, as indicated by the facile disproportionation reaction of 1 at ambient temperature to transform into the iron(II) bis(diazenido) species [(ICy)(NNSiiPr3)2Fe(dvtms)Fe(NNSiiPr3)2(ICy)] (2) and the iron(0) species [(ICy)Fe(η2:η2-dvtms)] and also the alkene-exchange reaction of 1 with PhCH═CHBC8H14 to form [(ICy)Fe(NNSiiPr3)(η2-trans-PhCH═CHBC8H14)] (3). Complex 1 is light-sensitive. Upon photolysis, it undergoes a SiiPr3 radical-transfer reaction to yield [(ICy)Fe(σ:η2-MeCHSiMe2OSiMe2CH═CHSiiPr3)] (4) and N2. The reactions of 1 with the trityl radical and organic bromides yield iron(II) complexes, which indicates its reducing nature. Moreover, 1 is a weak hydrogen-atom abstractor, as indicated by its inertness toward HSi(SiMe3)3 and cyclohexa-1,4-diene and the low calculated N-H bond dissociation energy (48 kcal/mol) of its corresponding iron(II) iso-hydrazenido species.

Role of Lewis acid/base anchor atoms in catalyst regeneration: a comprehensive study on biomimetic EP3Fe nitrogenases

In the quest for sustainable ammonia synthesis routes, biomimetic complexes have been intensively studied. Here we focus on the Peter's group Fe-nitrogenase catalyst with EPPP scorpionate ligands, and explore the effect of anchor atom selection (B, Al, Ga, N and P) and the impact of chloro substitution on the phenyl rings on nitrogen fixation. The reaction profiles of complexes with Lewis basic anchor atoms exhibited energy-demanding reduction steps, with more exergonic protonation steps compared to the smoother reaction profiles observed for catalysts with Lewis acid anchor atoms, also implying that catalyst regeneration is especially challenging for catalysts with Lewis basic anchor atoms. The binding affinities of N2 and H2 to the complexes suggest that the autocatalytic hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), which ultimately leads to consumption of reactants and catalyst deactivation, is likely to become more prevalent for heavier anchor atoms and be more significant for Lewis basic anchor atom complexes. Out of the studied complexes, boron showed the smoothest reaction profile and the smallest affinity for H2, which supports its superiour role as an anchor atom in accordance with experimental data.

Molecular Dihydrogen Activation by (C5Me5)M/N (M=Rh, Ir) Transition Metal Frustrated Lewis Pairs: Reversible Proton Migration to, and Proton Abstraction from, the C5Me5 Ligand

The masked transition-metal frustrated Lewis pairs [Cp*M(κ3N,N',N''-L)][SbF6] (Cp*=η5-C5Me5; M=Ir, 1, Rh, 2; HL=pyridinyl-amidine ligand) reversibly activate H2 under mild conditions rendering the hydrido derivatives [Cp*MH(κ2N,N'-HL)][SbF6] observed as a mixture of the E and Z isomers at the amidine C=N bond (M=Ir, 3Z, 3E; M=Rh, 4Z, 4E). DFT calculations indicate that the formation of the E isomers follows a Grotthuss type mechanism in the presence of water. A mixture of Rh(I) isomers of formula [(Cp*H)Rh(κ2N,N'-HL)][SbF6] (5 a-d) is obtained by reductive elimination of Cp*H from 4. The formation of 5 a-d was elucidated by means of DFT calculations. Finally, when 2 reacts with D2, the Cp* and Cp*H ligands of the resulting rhodium complexes 4 and 5, respectively, are deuterated as a result of a reversible hydrogen abstraction from the Cp* ligand and D2 activation at rhodium.

IZCp and PZCp: Redox Non-innocent Cyclopentadienyl Ligands as Electron Reservoirs for Sandwich Complexes

A long-sustained effort of systematic steric and electronic modification of cyclopentadienyl (Cp) ligands has enabled them to find wide-ranging, valuable applications. Herein, we present two novel Cp ligands: imidazolium- and pyrrolinium-substituted zwitterionic Cps (IZCp and PZCp), whose key utility is redox non-innocence─the ability to participate cooperatively with the metal center in redox reactions. Through the simple metalation of ZCps, the Cr(0) and Mo(0) half-sandwich complexes (IZCp)Cr(CO)3, (PZCp)Cr(CO)3, (IZCp)Mo(CO)3, and (PZCp)Mo(CO)3, respectively, as well as the Ru(II) sandwich complexes [(IZCp)RuCp]PF6 and [(PZCp)RuCp]PF6 were prepared. The sandwich complexes were fully characterized and showed by cyclic voltammetry reversible one-electron reduction at E1/2 potentials ranging from -1.7 to -2.7 V vs Fc/Fc+. These values are unusually low and have not been observed with other Cp ligands due to the instability of the reduced complexes. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations for the reduced sandwich derivatives with IZCp and PZCp showed their spin densities to be highly delocalized over their ZCp ligand moieties (70-90%). Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) analysis of the isolated K[(PZCp)Mo(CO)3] and (PZCp)RuCp also indicated a high degree of ligand-localized radical character. Thus, the IZCp and PZCp ligands act as electron reservoirs to sustain these sandwich complexes in highly reduced states. At the same time, the CO stretching frequencies of K[(PZCp)Mo(CO)3]: νCO 1871, 1748, and 1699 cm-1, rank the [PZCp]- ligand as the strongest electron-donating Cp ligand among the reported CpMo(CO)3 derivatives, whose νCO > 1746 cm-1. In addition, these redox non-innocent Cps were obtained in high yields and found to be practically air- and moisture-stable, unlike typical Cps.

Catalytic Reduction of Cyanide to Ammonia and Methane at a Mononuclear Fe Site

Nitrogenase enzymes catalyze nitrogen reduction (N2R) to ammonia and also the reduction of non-native substrates, including the 7H+/6e- reduction of cyanide to CH4 and NH3. CN- and N2 are isoelectronic, and it is hence fascinating to compare the mechanisms of synthetic Fe catalysts capable of both CN- and N2 reduction. Here, we describe the catalytic reduction of CN- to NH3 and CH4 by a highly selective (P3Si)Fe(CN) catalyst (P3Si represents a tris(phosphine)silyl ligand). Catalysis is driven in the presence of excess acid ([Ph2NH2]OTf) and reductant ((C6H6)2Cr), with turnover as high as 73 demonstrated. This catalyst system is also modestly competent for N2R and structurally related to other tris(phosphine)Fe-based N2R catalysts. The choice of catalyst and reductant is important to observe high yields. Mechanistic studies elucidate several intermediates of CN- reduction, including iron isocyanides (P3SiFeCNH+/0) and terminal iron aminocarbynes (P3SiFeCNH2+/0). Aminocarbynes are isoelectronic to iron hydrazidos (Fe═N-NH2+/0), which have been invoked as selectivity-determining intermediates of N2R (NH3 versus N2H4 products). For the present CN- reduction catalysis, reduction of aminocarbyne P3SiFeCNH2+ is proposed to be rate but not selectivity contributing. Instead, by comparison with the reactivity of a methylated aminocarbyne analogue (P3SiFeCNMe2), and associated computational studies, formation of a Fischer carbene (P3SiFeC(H)(NH2)+) intermediate that is on path for either CH4 and NH3 (6 e-) or CH3NH2 (4 e-) products is proposed. From this carbene intermediate, pathways to the observed CH4 and NH3 products (distinct from CH3NH2 formation) are considered to compare and contrast the (likely) mechanism/s of CN- and N2 reduction.

Low-Valent Transition Metalate Anions in Synthesis, Small Molecule Activation, and Catalysis

This review surveys the synthesis and reactivity of low-oxidation state metalate anions of the d-block elements, with an emphasis on contributions reported between 2006 and 2022. Although the field has a long and rich history, the chemistry of transition metalate anions has been greatly enhanced in the last 15 years by the application of advanced concepts in complex synthesis and ligand design. In recent years, the potential of highly reactive metalate complexes in the fields of small molecule activation and homogeneous catalysis has become increasingly evident. Consequently, exciting applications in small molecule activation have been developed, including in catalytic transformations. This article intends to guide the reader through the fascinating world of low-valent transition metalates. The first part of the review describes the synthesis and reactivity of d-block metalates stabilized by an assortment of ligand frameworks, including carbonyls, isocyanides, alkenes and polyarenes, phosphines and phosphorus heterocycles, amides, and redox-active nitrogen-based ligands. Thereby, the reader will be familiarized with the impact of different ligand types on the physical and chemical properties of metalates. In addition, ion-pairing interactions and metal-metal bonding may have a dramatic influence on metalate structures and reactivities. The complex ramifications of these effects are examined in a separate section. The second part of the review is devoted to the reactivity of the metalates toward small inorganic molecules such as H2, N2, CO, CO2, P4 and related species. It is shown that the use of highly electron-rich and reactive metalates in small molecule activation translates into impressive catalytic properties in the hydrogenation of organic molecules and the reduction of N2, CO, and CO2. The results discussed in this review illustrate that the potential of transition metalate anions is increasingly being tapped for challenging catalytic processes with relevance to organic synthesis and energy conversion. Therefore, it is hoped that this review will serve as a useful resource to inspire further developments in this dynamic research field.

Dinitrogen Activation Mediated by the (P2PPh)Fe Complex: Electronic Structure, Dimerization Mechanism, and Magnetic Coupling

Herein, we report the estimation of the extent of dinitrogen activation by different charged and structural forms of (P2PPh)Fe biomimetic catalysts, which, in the presence of light, exhibit significant yield in the N2-to-NH3 conversion. Complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) calculations have been used to determine the electronic structure of different reduced forms of the mononuclear complexes: the neutral (P2PPh)Fe(N2)2 adduct and the anionic [(P2PPh)Fe(N2)]- and [(P2PPh)Fe(N2)]2- complexes. These calculations also revealed that the extent of reduction of a dinitrogen molecule reaches up to one electron (N21-) due to the back-bonding from the Fe center, in agreement with the changes observed in the vibration frequency of the N-N bond in these complexes. In addition, the energy profile of the dimerization of the mononuclear (P2PPh)Fe(N2)2 complex to the dinuclear mono-N2-bridged [(P2PPh)Fe]2(μ-N2) complex has been determined by means of density functional theory (DFT) calculations. A three-step mechanism has been proposed for the dimerization, favored by both kinetics and thermodynamics criteria. Finally, the magnetic coupling constant in the diiron (μ-N2) complex is estimated from CASSCF/NEVPT2 calculations. Such a dinuclear complex presents a strong antiferromagnetic coupling resulting from the interaction between two S = 1 d6 Fe2+ ions, bridged by a highly activated dinitrogen molecule (N22-) with two electrons on the π* orbitals.

Proton transfer kinetics of transition metal hydride complexes and implications for fuel-forming reactions

Proton transfer reactions involving transition metal hydride complexes are prevalent in a number of catalytic fuel-forming reactions, where the proton transfer kinetics to or from the metal center can have significant impacts on the efficiency, selectivity, and stability associated with the catalytic cycle. This review correlates the often slow proton transfer rate constants of transition metal hydride complexes to their electronic and structural descriptors and provides perspective on how to exploit these parameters to control proton transfer kinetics to and from the metal center. A toolbox of techniques for experimental determination of proton transfer rate constants is discussed, and case studies where proton transfer rate constant determination informs fuel-forming reactions are highlighted. Opportunities for extending proton transfer kinetic measurements to additional systems are presented, and the importance of synergizing the thermodynamics and kinetics of proton transfer involving transition metal hydride complexes is emphasized.

Electrocatalytic Reduction of Dinitrogen to Ammonia with Water as Proton and Electron Donor Catalyzed by a Combination of a Tri-ironoxotungstate and an Alkali Metal Cation

The electrification of ammonia synthesis is a key target for its decentralization and lowering impact on atmospheric CO2 concentrations. The lithium metal electrochemical reduction of nitrogen to ammonia using alcohols as proton/electron donors is an important advance, but requires rather negative potentials, and anhydrous conditions. Organometallic electrocatalysts using redox mediators have also been reported. Water as a proton and electron donor has not been demonstrated in these reactions. Here a N2 to NH3 electrocatalytic reduction using an inorganic molecular catalyst, a tri-iron substituted polyoxotungstate, {SiFe3W9}, is presented. The catalyst requires the presence of Li+ or Na+ cations as promoters through their binding to {SiFe3W9}. Experimental NMR, CV and UV-vis measurements, and MD simulations and DFT calculations show that the alkali metal cation enables the decrease of the redox potential of {SiFe3W9} allowing the activation of N2. Controlled potential electrolysis with highly purified 14N2 and 15N2 ruled out formation of NH3 from contaminants. Importantly, using Na+ cations and polyethylene glycol as solvent, the anodic oxidation of water can be used as a proton and electron donor for the formation of NH3. In an undivided cell electrolyzer under 1 bar N2, rates of NH3 formation of 1.15 nmol sec-1 cm-2, faradaic efficiencies of ∼25%, 5.1 equiv of NH3 per equivalent of {SiFe3W9} in 10 h, and a TOF of 64 s-1 were obtained. The future development of suitable high surface area cathodes and well solubilized N2 and the use of H2O as the reducing agent are important keys to the future deployment of an electrocatalytic ammonia synthesis.

Advancing electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation: insights from molecular systems

Nitrogen fixation has a rich history within the inorganic chemistry community. In recent years attention has (re)focused on developing electrocatalytic systems capable of mediating the nitrogen reduction reaction (N2RR). Well-defined molecular catalyst systems have much to offer in this context. This personal perspective summarizes recent progress from our laboratory at Caltech, pulling together lessons learned from a number of studies we have conducted, placing them within the broader context of thermodynamic efficiency and selectivity for the N2RR. In particular, proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) provides an attractive strategy to achieve enhanced efficiency for the multi-electron/proton reduction of N2 to produce NH3 (or NH4+), and electrocatalytic PCET (ePCET) via an ePCET mediator affords a promising means of mitigating HER such that the N2RR can be achieved in a catalytic fashion.

Highly Selective Fe-Catalyzed Nitrogen Fixation to Hydrazine Enabled by Sm(II) Reagents with Tailored Redox Potential and pKa

Controlling product selectivity in multiproton, multielectron reductions of unsaturated small molecules is of fundamental interest in catalysis. For the N₂ reduction reaction (N₂RR) in particular, parameters that dictate selectivity for either the 6H⁺/6e^- product ammonia (NH₃) or the 4H⁺/4e^- product hydrazine (N₂H₄) are poorly understood. To probe this issue, we have developed conditions to invert the selectivity of a tris(phosphino)borane iron catalyst (Fe), with which NH₃ is typically the major product of N₂R, to instead favor N₂H₄ as the sole observed fixed-N product (>99:1). This dramatic shift is achieved by replacing moderate reductants and strong acids with a very strongly reducing but weakly acidic Sm^II-(2-pyrrolidone) core supported by a hexadentate dianionic macrocyclic ligand (Sm^II-PH) as the net hydrogen-atom donor. The activity and efficiency of the catalyst with this reagent remain high (up to 69 equiv of N₂H₄ per Fe and 67% fixed-N yield per H⁺). However, by generating N₂H₄ as the kinetic product, the overpotential of this Sm-driven reaction is 700 mV lower than that of the mildest reported set of NH₃-selective conditions with Fe. Mechanistic data support assignment of iron hydrazido(2-) species FeNNH₂ as selectivity-determining: we infer that protonation of FeNNH₂ at N_β, favored by strong acids, releases NH₃, whereas one-electron reduction to FeNNH₂^-, favored by strong reductants such as Sm^II-PH, produces N₂H₄ via reactivity initiated at N_α. Spectroscopic data also implicate a role for Sm^III-binding to anionic FeN₂^- (via an Fe-N₂- -Sm^III species) with respect to catalytic efficacy.

Cyclopentadienyl ring activation in organometallic chemistry and catalysis

The cyclopentadienyl (Cp) ligand is a cornerstone of modern organometallic chemistry. Since the discovery of ferrocene, the Cp ligand and its various derivatives have become foundational motifs in catalysis, medicine and materials science. Although largely considered an ancillary ligand for altering the stereoelectronic properties of transition metal centres, there is mounting evidence that the core Cp ring structure also serves as a reservoir for reactive protons (H⁺), hydrides (H^-) or radical hydrogen (H^•) atoms. This Review chronicles the field of Cp ring activation, highlighting the pivotal role that Cp ligands can have in electrocatalytic H₂ production, N₂ reduction, hydride transfer reactions and proton-coupled electron transfer.

Polarized Au(I)/Rh(I) bimetallic pairs cooperatively trigger ligand non-innocence and bond activation

The combination of molecular metallic fragments of contrasting Lewis character offers many possibilities for cooperative bond activation and for the disclosure of unusual reactivity. Here we provide a systematic investigation on the partnership of Lewis basic Rh(I) compounds of type [(η5-L)Rh(PR3)2] (η5-L = (C5Me5)- or (C9H7)-) with highly congested Lewis acidic Au(I) species. For the cyclopentadienyl Rh(I) compounds, we demonstrate the non-innocent role of the typically robust (C5Me5)- ligand through migration of a hydride to the Rh site and provide evidence for the direct implication of the gold fragment in this unusual bimetallic ligand activation event. This process competes with the formation of dinuclear Lewis adducts defined by a dative Rh → Au bond, with selectivity being under kinetic control and tunable by modifying the stereoelectronic and chelating properties of the phosphine ligands bound to the two metals. We provide a thorough computational study on the unusual Cp* non-innocent behavior and the divergent bimetallic pathways observed. The cooperative FLP-type reactivity of all bimetallic pairs has been investigated and computationally examined for the case of N-H bond activation in ammonia.

Light Alters the NH3 vs N2 H4 Product Profile in Iron-catalyzed Nitrogen Reduction via Dual Reactivity from an Iron Hydrazido (Fe=NNH2 ) Intermediate

Whereas synthetically catalyzed nitrogen reduction (N2 R) to produce ammonia is widely studied, catalysis to instead produce hydrazine (N2 H4 ) has received less attention despite its considerable mechanistic interest. Herein, we disclose that irradiation of a tris(phosphine)borane (P3 B ) Fe catalyst, P3 B Fe+ , significantly alters its product profile to increase N2 H4 versus NH3 ; P3 B Fe+ is otherwise known to be highly selective for NH3 . We posit a key terminal hydrazido intermediate, P3 B Fe=NNH2 , as selectivity-determining. Whereas its singlet ground state undergoes protonation to liberate NH3 , a low-lying triplet excited state leads to reactivity at Nα and formation of N2 H4 . Associated electrochemical and spectroscopic studies establish that N2 H4 lies along a unique product pathway; NH3 is not produced from N2 H4 . Our findings are distinct from the canonical mechanism for hydrazine formation, which proceeds via a diazene (HN=NH) intermediate and showcase light as a tool to tailor selectivity.

Ionization energies of metallocenes: a coupled cluster study of cobaltocene

Open-shell transition metal chemistry presents challenges to contemporary electronic structure methods, based on either density functional or wavefunction theory. While CCSD(T) is the well-trusted gold standard for maingroup thermochemistry, the accuracy and robustness of the method is less clear for open-shell transition metal chemistry, requiring benchmarking of CCSD(T)-based protocols against either higher-level theory or experiment. Ionization energies (IEs) of metallocenes provide an interesting test case with metallocenes being common redox reagents as well as playing roles as redox mediators and cocatalysts in redox catalysis. Using highly accurate ZEKE-MATI experimental measurements of gas phase adiabatic (5.3275 ± 0.0006 eV) and vertical (5.4424 ± 0.0006 eV) ionization energies of cobaltocene, we systematically assessed the accuracy of the local coupled-cluster method DLPNO-CCSD(T) with respect to geometry, reference determinant, basis set size and extrapolation schemes, PNO cut-off and extrapolation, local triples approximation, relativistic effects and core-valence correlation. We show that PNO errors are controllable via the recently introduced PNO extrapolation schemes and that the expensive iterative triples (T₁) contribution can be made more manageable by calculating it as a smaller-basis/smaller PNO-cutoff correction. The reference determinant turns out to be a critical aspect in these calculations with the HF determinant resulting in large DLPNO-CCSD(T) errors, likely due to the qualitatively flawed molecular orbital spectrum. The BP86 functional on the other hand was found to provide reference orbitals giving small DLPNO-CCSD(T) errors, likely due to more realistic orbitals as suggested by the more consistent MO spectrum compared to HF. A protocol including complete basis set extrapolations with correlation-consistent basis sets, complete PNO space extrapolations, iterative triples- and core-valence correlation corrections was found to give errors of -0.07 eV and -0.03 eV for adiabatic- and vertical-IE of cobaltocene, respectively, giving close to chemical accuracy for both properties. A computationally efficient DLPNO-CCSD(T) protocol was devised and tested against adiabatic ionization energies of 6 different metallocenes (V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni). For the other metallocenes, the iterative triples (T₁) and PNO extrapolation contributions turn out to be even more important. The results give errors close to the experimental uncertainty, similar to recent auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo results. The quality of the reference determinant orbitals is identified as the main source of uncertainty in CCSD(T) calculations of metallocenes.

Redox Mediators in Homogeneous Co-electrocatalysis

Homogeneous electrocatalysis has been well studied over the past several decades for the conversion of small molecules to useful products for green energy applications or as chemical feedstocks. However, in order for these catalyst systems to be used in industrial applications, their activity and stability must be improved. In naturally occurring enzymes, redox equivalents (electrons, often in a concerted manner with protons) are delivered to enzyme active sites by small molecules known as redox mediators (RMs). Inspired by this, co-electrocatalytic systems with homogeneous catalysts and RMs have been developed for the conversion of alcohols, nitrogen, unsaturated organic substrates, oxygen, and carbon dioxide. In these systems, the RMs have been shown to both increase the activity of the catalyst and shift selectivity to more desired products by altering catalytic cycles and/or avoiding high-energy intermediates. However, the area is currently underdeveloped and requires additional fundamental advancements in order to become a more general strategy. Here, we summarize the recent examples of homogeneous co-electrocatalysis and discuss possible future directions for the field.

Near ambient N2 fixation on solid electrodes versus enzymes and homogeneous catalysts

The Mo/Fe nitrogenase enzyme is unique in its ability to efficiently reduce dinitrogen to ammonia at atmospheric pressures and room temperature. Should an artificial electrolytic device achieve the same feat, it would revolutionize fertilizer production and even provide an energy-dense, truly carbon-free fuel. This Review provides a coherent comparison of recent progress made in dinitrogen fixation on solid electrodes, homogeneous catalysts and nitrogenases. Specific emphasis is placed on systems for which there is unequivocal evidence that dinitrogen reduction has taken place. By establishing the cross-cutting themes and synergies between these systems, we identify viable avenues for future research.

Vanadium-Catalyzed Dinitrogen Reduction to Ammonia via a [V]═NNH2 Intermediate

The catalytic transformation of N₂ to NH₃ by transition metal complexes is of great interest and importance but has remained a challenge to date. Despite the essential role of vanadium in biological N₂ fixation, well-defined vanadium complexes that can catalyze the conversion of N₂ to NH₃ are scarce. In particular, a V(N_xH_y) intermediate derived from proton/electron transfer reactions of coordinated N₂ remains unknown. Here, we report a dinitrogen-bridged divanadium complex bearing POCOP (2,6-(^tBu₂PO)₂-C₆H₃) pincer and aryloxy ligands, which can serve as a catalyst for the reduction of N₂ to NH₃ and N₂H₄. Low-temperature protonation and reduction of the dinitrogen complex afforded the first structurally characterized neutral metal hydrazido(2-) species ([V]═NNH₂), which mediated ¹⁵N₂ conversion to ¹⁵NH₃, indicating that it is a plausible intermediate of the catalysis. DFT calculations showed that the vanadium hydrazido complex [V]═NNH₂ possessed a N-H bond dissociation free energy (BDFE_N-H) of as high as 59.1 kcal/mol. The protonation of a vanadium amide complex ([V]-NH₂) with [Ph₂NH₂][OTf] resulted in the release of NH₃ and the formation of a vanadium triflate complex, which upon reduction under N₂ afforded the vanadium dinitrogen complex. These transformations model the final steps of a vanadium-catalyzed N₂ reduction cycle. Both experimental and theoretical studies suggest that the catalytic reaction may proceed via a distal pathway to liberate NH₃. These findings provide unprecedented insights into the mechanism of N₂ reduction related to FeV nitrogenase.

Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Reduction on a Molybdenum Complex Bearing a PNP Pincer Ligand

Electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction (N2R) mediated by well-defined molecular catalysts is poorly developed by comparison with other reductive electrocatalytic transformations. Herein, we explore the viability of electrocatalytic N2R mediated by a molecular Mo-PNP complex. A careful choice of acid, electrode material, and electrolyte mitigates electrode-mediated HER under direct electrolysis and affords up to 11.7 equiv of NH3 (Faradaic efficiency < 43%) at -1.89 V versus Fc+/Fc. The addition of a proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) mediator has no effect. The data presented are rationalized by an initial electron transfer (ET) that sets the applied bias needed and further reveal an important impact of [Mo] concentration, thereby pointing to potential bimolecular steps (e.g., N2 splitting) as previously proposed during chemically driven N2R catalysis. Finally, facile reductive protonation of [Mo(N)Br(HPNP)] with pyridinium acids is demonstrated.

Ammonia from dinitrogen at ambient conditions by organometallic catalysts

Fixation of atmospheric dinitrogen in plants by [Mo-Fe] cofactor of nitrogenase enzyme takes place efficiently under atmospheric pressure and normal temperature. In search for an alternative methodology for the highly energy intensive Haber-Bosch process, design and synthesis of highly efficient inorganic and organometallic complexes by mimicking the structure and function of [Mo-Fe] cofactor system is highly desirable for ammonia synthesis from dinitrogen. An ideal catalyst for ammonia synthesis should effectively catalyse the reduction of dinitrogen in the presence of a proton source under mild to moderate conditions, and thereby, significantly reducing the cost of ammonia production and increasing the energy efficacy of the process. In the light of current research, it is evident that there is a plenty of scope for the development and enhanced performance of the inorganic and organometallic catalysts for ammonia synthesis under ambient temperature and pressure. The review furnishes a comprehensive outlook of numerous organometallic catalysts used in the synthesis of ammonia from dinitrogen in the past few decades.

Characterization of a Proposed Terminal Iron(III) Nitride Intermediate of Nitrogen Fixation Stabilized by a Trisphosphine-Borane Ligand

Terminal iron nitrides (Fe≡N) have been proposed as intermediates of Fe-mediated nitrogen fixation, and well-defined synthetic iron nitrides have been characterized in high oxidation states, including FeIV , FeV , and FeVI . This study reports the generation and low temperature characterization of a terminally bound iron(III) nitride, P3 B Fe(N) (P3 B =tris(o-diisopropylphosphinophenyl)borane), which is a proposed intermediate of iron-mediated nitrogen fixation by the P3 B Fe-catalyst system. CW- and pulse EPR spectroscopy (HYSCORE and ENDOR), supported by DFT calculations, help to define a 2 A ground state electronic structure of this C3 -symmetric nitride species, placing the unpaired spin in a sigma orbital along the B-Fe-N vector; this electronic structure is distinct for an iron nitride. The unusual d5 -configuration is stabilized by significant delocalization (≈50 %) of the unpaired electron onto the axial boron and nitrogen ligands, with a majority of the spin residing on boron.

Tandem electrocatalytic N2 fixation via proton-coupled electron transfer

New electrochemical ammonia (NH3) synthesis technologies are of interest as a complementary route to the Haber-Bosch process for distributed fertilizer generation, and towards exploiting ammonia as a zero-carbon fuel produced via renewably sourced electricity1. Apropos of these goals is a surge of fundamental research targeting heterogeneous materials as electrocatalysts for the nitrogen reduction reaction (N2RR)2. These systems generally suffer from poor stability and NH3 selectivity; the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) outcompetes N2RR3. Molecular catalyst systems can be exquisitely tuned and offer an alternative strategy4, but progress has been thwarted by the same selectivity issue; HER dominates. Here we describe a tandem catalysis strategy that offers a solution to this puzzle. A molecular complex that can mediate an N2 reduction cycle is partnered with a co-catalyst that interfaces the electrode and an acid to mediate proton-coupled electron transfer steps, facilitating N-H bond formation at a favourable applied potential (-1.2 V versus Fc+/0) and overall thermodynamic efficiency. Certain intermediates of the N2RR cycle would be otherwise unreactive via uncoupled electron transfer or proton transfer steps. Structurally diverse complexes of several metals (W, Mo, Os, Fe) also mediate N2RR electrocatalysis at the same potential in the presence of the mediator, pointing to the generality of this tandem approach.

Catalytic Reduction of Dinitrogen into Ammonia and Hydrazine by Using Chromium Complexes Bearing PCP-Type Pincer Ligands

A series of chromium-halide, -nitride, and -dinitrogen complexes bearing carbene- and phosphine-based PCP-type pincer ligands has been newly prepared, and some of them are found to work as effective catalysts to reduce dinitrogen under atmospheric pressure, whereby up to 11.60 equiv. of ammonia and 2.52 equiv. of hydrazine (16.6 equiv. of fixed N atom) are produced based on the chromium atom. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first successful example of chromium-catalyzed conversion of dinitrogen to ammonia and hydrazine under mild reaction conditions.

Facile conversion of ammonia to a nitride in a rhenium system that cleaves dinitrogen

Rhenium complexes with aliphatic PNP pincer ligands have been shown to be capable of reductive N₂ splitting to nitride complexes. However, the conversion of the resulting nitride to ammonia has not been observed. Here, the thermodynamics and mechanism of the hypothetical N–H bond forming steps are evaluated through the reverse reaction, conversion of ammonia to the nitride complex. Depending on the conditions, treatment of a rhenium(iii) precursor with ammonia gives either a bis(amine) complex [(PNP)Re(NH₂)₂Cl]⁺, or results in dehydrohalogenation to the rhenium(iii) amido complex, (PNP)Re(NH₂)Cl. The N–H hydrogen atoms in this amido complex can be abstracted by PCET reagents which implies that they are quite weak. Calorimetric measurements show that the average bond dissociation enthalpy of the two amido N–H bonds is 57 kcal mol⁻¹, while DFT computations indicate a substantially weaker N–H bond of the putative rhenium(iv)-imide intermediate (BDE = 38 kcal mol⁻¹). Our analysis demonstrates that addition of the first H atom to the nitride complex is a thermochemical bottleneck for NH₃ generation.

Rhenium–PNP complexes split N₂ to nitrides, but the nitrides do not give ammonia. Here, the thermodynamics of the hypothetical N–H bond forming steps are evaluated through the reverse reaction, showing that the first H addition is the bottleneck.

Synthesis and Reactivity of Manganese Complexes Bearing Anionic PNP- and PCP-Type Pincer Ligands toward Nitrogen Fixation

A series of manganese complexes bearing an anionic pyrrole-based PNP-type pincer ligand and an anionic benzene-based PCP-type pincer ligand is synthesized and characterized. The reactivity of these complexes toward ammonia formation and silylamine formation from dinitrogen under mild conditions is evaluated to produce only stoichiometric amounts of ammonia and silylamine, probably because the manganese pincer complexes are unstable under reducing conditions.

Synthesis and Reactivity of Cobalt-Dinitrogen Complexes Bearing Anionic PCP-Type Pincer Ligands toward Catalytic Silylamine Formation from Dinitrogen

A series of cobalt(I)-dinitrogen complexes bearing anionic 4-substituted benzene-based PCP-type pincer ligands are synthesized and characterized. These complexes work as highly efficient catalysts for the formation of silylamine from dinitrogen under ambient reaction conditions to produce up to 371 equiv of silylamine based on the cobalt atom of the catalyst.

Ligand Protonation at Carbon, not Nitrogen, during H2 Production with Amine-Rich Iron Electrocatalysts

We present monometallic H₂ production electrocatalysts containing electron-rich triamine-cyclopentadienyl (Cp) ligands coordinated to iron. After selective CO extrusion from the iron tricarbonyl precursors, electrocatalysis is observed via cyclic voltammetry in the presence of an exogenous acid. Contrary to the fact that amines in the secondary coordination sphere are often protonated during electrocatalysis, comprehensive quantum-chemical calculations indicate that the amines likely do not function as proton relays; instead, endo-Cp ring protonation is most favorable after 1e^- reduction. This unusual mechanistic pathway emphasizes the need to consider a broad domain of H⁺/e^- addition products by synergistically combining experimental and theoretical resources.

Reduction of highly bulky triphenolamine molybdenum nitrido and chloride complexes

Transition metal nitrides are key intermediates in the catalytic reduction of dinitrogen to ammonia. To date, transition metal nitride complexes with the triphenolamine (TPA) ligand have not been reported and the system with the ligand has been much less studied for ammonia formation compared with other systems. Herein, we report a series of molybdenum complexes supported by a sterically demanding TPA ligand, including a nitrido complex NMo(TPA). We achieved the stoichiometric conversion of the nitride moiety into ammonia under ambient conditions by adding proton and electron sources to NMo(TPA). However, the catalytic turnover for N₂ reduction to ammonia was not observed in the triphenolamine ligand system unlike the Schrock system-triamidoamine ligand. Density functional theory calculation revealed that the molybdenum center favors binding NH₃ over N₂ by 16.9 kcal mol^-1 and the structural lability of the trigonal bipyramidal (TBP) molybdenum complex seems to prevent catalytic turnover. Our systematic study showed that the electronegativity and bond length of ancillary ligands determine the preference between N₂ and NH₃, suggesting a systematic design strategy for improvement.

Uncovering Redox Non-innocent Hydrogen-Bonding in Cu(I)-Diazene Complexes

The life-sustaining reduction of N₂ to NH₃ is thermoneutral yet kinetically challenged by high-energy intermediates such as N₂H₂. Exploring intramolecular H-bonding as a potential strategy to stabilize diazene intermediates, we employ a series of [^xHetTpCu]₂(μ-N₂H₂) complexes that exhibit H-bonding between pendant aromatic N-heterocycles (^xHet) such as pyridine and a bridging trans-N₂H₂ ligand at copper(I) centers. X-ray crystallography and IR spectroscopy clearly reveal H-bonding in [^pyMeTpCu]₂(μ-N₂H₂) while low-temperature ¹H NMR studies coupled with DFT analysis reveals a dynamic equilibrium between two closely related, symmetric H-bonded structural motifs. Importantly, the ^xHet pendant negligibly influences the electronic structure of ^xHetTpCu^I centers in ^xHetTpCu(CNAr^2,6-Me₂) complexes that lack H-bonding as judged by nearly indistinguishable ν(CN) frequencies (2113-2117 cm^-1). Nonetheless, H-bonding in the corresponding [^xHetTpCu]₂(μ-N₂H₂) complexes results in marked changes in ν(NN) (1398-1419 cm^-1) revealed through resonance Raman studies. Due to the closely matched N-H BDEs of N₂H₂ and the pyH⁰ cation radical, the aromatic N-heterocyclic pendants may encourage partial H-atom transfer (HAT) from N₂H₂ to ^xHet through redox-non-innocent H-bonding in [^xHetTpCu]₂(μ-N₂H₂). DFT studies reveal modest thermodynamic barriers for concerted transfer of both H-atoms of coordinated N₂H₂ to the ^xHet pendants to generate tautomeric [^xHetHTpCu]₂(μ-N₂) complexes, identifying metal-assisted concerted dual HAT as a thermodynamically favorable pathway for N₂/N₂H₂ interconversion.

Visible light enables catalytic formation of weak chemical bonds with molecular hydrogen

The synthesis of weak chemical bonds at or near thermodynamic potential is a fundamental challenge in chemistry, with applications ranging from catalysis to biology to energy science. Proton-coupled electron transfer using molecular hydrogen is an attractive strategy for synthesizing weak element-hydrogen bonds, but the intrinsic thermodynamics presents a challenge for reactivity. Here we describe the direct photocatalytic synthesis of extremely weak element-hydrogen bonds of metal amido and metal imido complexes, as well as organic compounds with bond dissociation free energies as low as 31 kcal mol^-1. Key to this approach is the bifunctional behaviour of the chromophoric iridium hydride photocatalyst. Activation of molecular hydrogen occurs in the ground state and the resulting iridium hydride harvests visible light to enable spontaneous formation of weak chemical bonds near thermodynamic potential with no by-products. Photophysical and mechanistic studies corroborate radical-based reaction pathways and highlight the uniqueness of this photodriven approach in promoting new catalytic chemistry.

Fixation of Dinitrogen at an Asymmetric Binuclear Titanium Complex

A new type of dititanium dinitrogen complex supported by a triphenolamine (TPA) ligand is reported. Analysis by single-crystal X-ray diffraction and Raman and NMR spectroscopy reveals different coordination geometries for the two titanium centers. Hence, coordination of TPA and a nitrogen ligand results in trigonal-bipyramidal geometry, while an octahedral titanium center is obtained upon additional coordination of an ethoxide generated upon C-O bond cleavage in a diethyl ether solvent molecule. The titanium complex successfully generates ammonia in the presence of an excess amount of PCy₃HI and KC₈ in 154% yield (per titanium atom). A titanium complex with a bulkier TPA does not form a dinitrogen complex, and mononuclear titanium dinitrogen complexes were not accessible, presumably because of the high tendency of early transition metals to form binuclear dinitrogen complexes.

Trends in computational molecular catalyst design

Computational methods have emerged as a powerful tool to augment traditional experimental molecular catalyst design by providing useful predictions of catalyst performance and decreasing the time needed for catalyst screening. In this perspective, we discuss three approaches for computational molecular catalyst design: (i) the reaction mechanism-based approach that calculates all relevant elementary steps, finds the rate and selectivity determining steps, and ultimately makes predictions on catalyst performance based on kinetic analysis, (ii) the descriptor-based approach where physical/chemical considerations are used to find molecular properties as predictors of catalyst performance, and (iii) the data-driven approach where statistical analysis as well as machine learning (ML) methods are used to obtain relationships between available data/features and catalyst performance. Following an introduction to these approaches, we cover their strengths and weaknesses and highlight some recent key applications. Furthermore, we present an outlook on how the currently applied approaches may evolve in the near future by addressing how recent developments in building automated computational workflows and implementing advanced ML models hold promise for reducing human workload, eliminating human bias, and speeding up computational catalyst design at the same time. Finally, we provide our viewpoint on how some of the challenges associated with the up-and-coming approaches driven by automation and ML may be resolved.

Theoretical Assessment of Dinitrogen Fixation on Carbon Atom

Dinitrogen activation in non-metallic systems has received considerable attention in recent years. Herein, we report the theoretical feasibility of N₂ fixation using aminocarbenes (L) or their anionic derivatives. The molecular descriptors of L and anionic L^- , which affect the interaction of L and anionic L^- with N₂ , were identified through multiple linear regression analysis. Additionally, the electron flow during C-N bond formation was confirmed by performing intrinsic reaction coordination calculations with intrinsic bond orbital analysis for the reaction of anionic L^- with N₂ .

Ammonia Formation Catalyzed by a Dinitrogen-Bridged Dirhenium Complex Bearing PNP-Pincer Ligands under Mild Reaction Conditions*

A series of rhenium complexes bearing a pyridine-based PNP-type pincer ligand are synthesized from rhenium phosphine complexes as precursors. A dinitrogen-bridged dirhenium complex bearing the PNP-type pincer ligands catalytically converts dinitrogen into ammonia during the reaction with KC₈ as a reductant and [HPCy₃ ]BAr^F ₄ (Cy=cyclohexyl, Ar^F =3,5-(CF₃ )₂ C₆ H₃ ) as a proton source at -78 °C to afford 8.4 equiv of ammonia based on the rhenium atom of the catalyst. The rhenium-dinitrogen complex also catalyzes silylation of dinitrogen in the reaction with KC₈ as a reductant and Me₃ SiCl as a silylating reagent under ambient reaction conditions to afford 11.7 equiv of tris(trimethylsilyl)amine based on the rhenium atom of the catalyst. These results demonstrate the first successful example of catalytic nitrogen fixation under mild reaction conditions using rhenium-dinitrogen complexes as catalysts.

Conversion of Dinitrogen into Nitrile: Cross-Metathesis of N2 -Derived Molybdenum Nitride with Alkynes

The direct synthesis of nitrile from N₂ under mild conditions is of great importance and has attracted much interest. Herein, we report a direct conversion of N₂ into nitrile via a nitrile-alkyne cross-metathesis (NACM) process involving a N₂ -derived Mo nitride. Treatment of the Mo nitride with alkyne in the presence of KOTf afforded an alkyne-coordinated nitride, which was then transformed into Mo^V carbyne and the corresponding nitrile upon 1 e^- oxidation. Both aryl- and alkyl-substituted alkynes underwent this process smoothly. Experiments and DFT calculations have proved that the oxidation state of the Mo center plays a crucial role. This method does not rely on the nucleophilicity of the N₂ -derived metal nitride, offering a novel strategy for N₂ fixation chemistry.

Comprehensive insights into synthetic nitrogen fixation assisted by molecular catalysts under ambient or mild conditions

N2 is fixed as NH3 industrially by the Haber-Bosch process under harsh conditions, whereas biological nitrogen fixation is achieved under ambient conditions, which has prompted development of alternative methods to fix N2 catalyzed by transition metal molecular complexes. Since the early 21st century, catalytic conversion of N2 into NH3 under ambient conditions has been achieved by using molecular catalysts, and now H2O has been utilized as a proton source with turnover frequencies reaching the values found for biological nitrogen fixation. In this review, recent advances in the development of molecular catalysts for synthetic N2 fixation under ambient or mild conditions are summarized, and potential directions for future research are also discussed.