Optical signatures of molecular dissymmetry: combining theory with experiments to address stereochemical puzzles

Recognition in the Domain of Molecular Chirality: From Noncovalent Interactions to Separation of Enantiomers

It is not a coincidence that both chirality and noncovalent interactions are ubiquitous in nature and synthetic molecular systems. Noncovalent interactivity between chiral molecules underlies enantioselective recognition as a fundamental phenomenon regulating life and human activities. Thus, noncovalent interactions represent the narrative thread of a fascinating story which goes across several disciplines of medical, chemical, physical, biological, and other natural sciences. This review has been conceived with the awareness that a modern attitude toward molecular chirality and its consequences needs to be founded on multidisciplinary approaches to disclose the molecular basis of essential enantioselective phenomena in the domain of chemical, physical, and life sciences. With the primary aim of discussing this topic in an integrated way, a comprehensive pool of rational and systematic multidisciplinary information is provided, which concerns the fundamentals of chirality, a description of noncovalent interactions, and their implications in enantioselective processes occurring in different contexts. A specific focus is devoted to enantioselection in chromatography and electromigration techniques because of their unique feature as "multistep" processes. A second motivation for writing this review is to make a clear statement about the state of the art, the tools we have at our disposal, and what is still missing to fully understand the mechanisms underlying enantioselective recognition.

A Chirality-Based Quantum Leap

There is increasing interest in the study of chiral degrees of freedom occurring in matter and in electromagnetic fields. Opportunities in quantum sciences will likely exploit two main areas that are the focus of this Review: (1) recent observations of the chiral-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect in chiral molecules and engineered nanomaterials and (2) rapidly evolving nanophotonic strategies designed to amplify chiral light-matter interactions. On the one hand, the CISS effect underpins the observation that charge transport through nanoscopic chiral structures favors a particular electronic spin orientation, resulting in large room-temperature spin polarizations. Observations of the CISS effect suggest opportunities for spin control and for the design and fabrication of room-temperature quantum devices from the bottom up, with atomic-scale precision and molecular modularity. On the other hand, chiral-optical effects that depend on both spin- and orbital-angular momentum of photons could offer key advantages in all-optical and quantum information technologies. In particular, amplification of these chiral light-matter interactions using rationally designed plasmonic and dielectric nanomaterials provide approaches to manipulate light intensity, polarization, and phase in confined nanoscale geometries. Any technology that relies on optimal charge transport, or optical control and readout, including quantum devices for logic, sensing, and storage, may benefit from chiral quantum properties. These properties can be theoretically and experimentally investigated from a quantum information perspective, which has not yet been fully developed. There are uncharted implications for the quantum sciences once chiral couplings can be engineered to control the storage, transduction, and manipulation of quantum information. This forward-looking Review provides a survey of the experimental and theoretical fundamentals of chiral-influenced quantum effects and presents a vision for their possible future roles in enabling room-temperature quantum technologies.

Specific optical rotation is a versatile tool for the identification of critical micelle concentration and micellar growth of tartaric acid-based diastereomeric amphiphiles

Four novel tartaric acid-based diastereomeric chiral amphiphiles, two being enantiomers of the other two, have been synthesized and investigated using chiroptical spectroscopic methods, along with tensiometry and dynamic light scattering experiments. We found that an inflection point in specific optical rotation (SOR) values at ~0.32 mM corresponds to the critical micelle concentration (CMC). The increase in magnitude of SOR values beyond CMC corresponds to the growth of aggregates. For enantiomers, oppositely signed SOR values were observed, ruling out the possibility for the presence of aggregation size mediated artefacts. SOR values did not exhibit concentration dependence for a chiral tartaric acid based non-aggregating analogue further establishing the absence of artefacts or anomalous interaction of tartaric acid based head group with solvent. Electronic circular dichroism spectra showed no significant changes in band positions or intensities with concentration. Due to the requirement for higher concentrations (~200 mM) needed to obtain vibrational circular dichroism spectra, these measurements are not found to be useful for studying concentration dependent properties of chiral amphiphiles.

Bimodal concentration-dependent reactivity pattern of a glycosyl donor: Is the solution structure involved?

Changes in concentration (0.001-0.1 M) of an arabinofuranosyl donor (1) have been shown to modulate the temperature T at which activation of 1 occurs (from -23 °C to +7 °C), the reaction time (from 1.5 h to 3 days) and the yield of the disaccharide formed (from 14% to 82%). At concentrations exceeding 0.01 M, these parameters, as well as the specific optical rotation of the solution of 1, virtually do not depend on concentration suggesting formation of reacting species (supramers) of glycosyl donor with similar structures, hence reactivities, but considerably different from those formed in more dilute solutions. The found critical concentration (0.01 M) separates two concentration ranges of reaction solutions corresponding to two types of solution structure that are featured by the presence of fundamentally different supramers of glycosyl donor, which have distinct chemical properties. These results allow a fresh look at the problems of reactivity of chemical compounds and selectivity of the reactions in which they participate.

Chiroptical properties of streptorubin B: the synergy between theory and experiment

Analysis of the calculated and measured optical rotation (OR) together with other calculated chiroptical properties such as electronic circular dichroism (ECD) and vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) of the prodigiosin alkaloid streptorubin B shows that these are dominated by the pseudoenantiomeric atropisomers anti-(S)-streptorubin B (1A) and syn-(S)-streptorubin (1B). Atropisomerism is a dynamic phenomenon with a potentially nonequilibrium population of isomers, and accordingly the measured chiroptical responses may vary with time, concentration, temperature, and the anion of the salts used. Streptorubin also has the potential to form stacked homodimers for which the optical rotations measured at 589 nm can vary greatly due to the presence of ECD-active electronic transitions in this region.

Specific rotation of monosaccharides: a global property bringing local information

Carbohydrates generally occur in several conformations that may differ among themselves by energy values that are smaller than the accuracy of the most sophisticated theoretical methods used to determine them. In addition, the preferential orientations of the hydroxyl groups of these molecules cannot be identified by any experimental technique. Therefore, a method that is able to validate the absolute conformations (i.e., consisting of the orientations of the hydroxyl groups) of carbohydrates would be helpful to improve our knowledge about monosaccharides. SR has been used for this purpose, and here, we present a test to measure the specific rotation (SR) ability of a molecule that possesses not only many conformations, but also four adjacent chiral centers. The results show that the final SR value is a weighted average of a global property (obtained for each conformation), and the latter by its turn is influenced by each chiral center in a multi chiral system. By comparing the SR values calculated for the most abundant anomers of xylopyranose with those of the corresponding monochiral analogs obtained by saturation of three different chiral centers each time, the influence of each center on the global property is confirmed.

Probing chirality fluctuations in molecules by nonlinear optical spectroscopy

Symmetry breaking caused by geometric fluctuations can enable processes that are otherwise forbidden. An example is a perylene bisimide dyad whose dipole moments are perpendicular to each other. Förster-type energy transfer is thus forbidden at the equilibrium geometry since the dipolar coupling vanishes. Yet, fluctuations of the geometric arrangement have been shown to induce finite energy transfer that depends on the dipole variance, rather than the mean. We demonstrate an analogous effect associated with chirality symmetry breaking. In its equilibrium geometry, this dimer is non-chiral. The linear chiral response which depends on the average geometry thus vanishes. However, we show that certain 2D chiral optical signals are finite due to geometric fluctuations. Furthermore, the correlation time of these fluctuations can be experimentally revealed by the waiting time dependence of the 2D signal.

Polarimetry as a tool for the study of solutions of chiral solutes

Optical rotation of aqueous solutions of D-levoglucosan was studied experimentally in the 0.03-4.0 mol L(-1) concentration range and a nonlinear concentration dependence of specific optical rotation (SR) was revealed. Discontinuities observed in the concentration plot of SR (at 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 mol L(-1)) are well correlated with those found by static and dynamic light scattering and identify concentration ranges in which different solution domains (supramers) may exist. The average SR experimental value for a D-levoglucosan aqueous solution ([α]D(28) -58.5±8.7 deg dm(-1) cm(-3) g(-1)) was found to be in good agreement with values obtained by theoretical calculation (TD-DFT/GIAO) of SR for 15 different conformers revealed by conformational sampling at the PCM/B3LYP/6-311++G(2d,2p)//B3LYP/6-31+G(d,p) level, which were shown to be strongly affected by the solvation microenvironment (0, 1, 2, and 3 explicit solvent molecules considered) due to local geometrical changes induced in the solute molecule. This exceptionally high sensitivity of SR makes polarimetry a unique method capable of sensing changes in the structure of supramers detected in this study.

The absolute configuration of (+)- and (-)-erythro-mefloquine

The controversy over the absolute configuration of (+)-erythro-mefloquine, the less psychosis-causing enantiomer of the anti-malarial drug Lariam, has been resolved by Mosher ester crystallization. The configuration determined previously by physical methods is correct, whereas the configuration determined by three enantioselective syntheses is wrong.

VCD studies on chiral characters of metal complex oligomers

The present article reviews the results on the application of vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) spectroscopy to the study of stereochemical properties of chiral metal complexes in solution. The chiral characters reflecting on the vibrational properties of metal complexes are revealed by measurements of a series of β-diketonato complexes with the help of theoretical calculation. Attention is paid to the effects of electronic properties of a central metal ion on vibrational energy levels or low-lying electronic states. The investigation is further extended to the oligomers of β-diketonato complex units. The induction of chiral structures is confirmed by the VCD spectra when chiral inert moieties are connected with labile metal ions. These results have demonstrated how VCD spectroscopy is efficient in revealing the static and dynamic properties of mononuclear and multinuclear chiral metal complexes, which are difficult to clarify by means of other spectroscopes.

Memory of chirality in rebound cyclizations of α-amide radicals

Reduction of (S)-N-(2-bromoallyl)-N-(tert-butyl)-2-methyl-3-phenylpropanamide with tributyltin hydride provides (3S,4S)-3-benzyl-1-(tert-butyl)-3,4-dimethylpyrrolidin-2-one with about 80% retention of chirality at the stereocenter adjacent to the amide carbonyl group. This memory of chirality is suggested to occur by transfer of chirality from a stereocenter to an axis, then from the axis back to a new stereocenter.

Chiroptical, linear, and second-order nonlinear optical properties of binaphthol derivatives

We have investigated the chiroptical, linear, and second-order nonlinear optical (NLO) properties of seven binaphthol derivatives and elucidated structure-property relationships from the micromechanism for the first time. The excitation energies, oscillator strengths, and rotational strengths of the 150 lowest energy electron excitations for the most stable conformers have been calculated at TDB3LYP/cc-pVDZ level of theory. The experimental UV-vis absorption energies were reproduced well by our calculations. The simulated circular dichroism (CD) spectra and calculated optical rotation (OR) values are in reasonable agreement with experimental ones. These results demonstrate that TDDFT calculations can not only describe the electron transition property but also can be used to assign the absolute configurations (ACs) of binaphthol derivatives with high confidence. Whereas OR values are more sensitive to the molecular structures than CD spectra. The electron transition property and chiroptical origin have been assigned and analyzed. These derivatives possess remarkably large molecular first hyperpolarizabilities, especially compound 7 which has a value of 241.65 × 10(-30) esu. This value is about 60 times as large as that of highly π-delocalized phenyliminomethyl ferrocene complex. Moreover, compound 6 exhibits pronounced different second-order NLO response values from neutral state to the two cationic states (6(2+) and 6(4+)), which indicates that this compound could act as a potential NLO switch material. The cooperativity of intramolecular charge transfer of the studied compounds was also discussed.

Molecular structure determination using chiroptical spectroscopy: where we may go wrong?

Chiroptical spectroscopy is being widely used for determining the three-dimensional molecular structures (i.e., absolute configurations and conformations) of chiral molecules. The general procedure used with any of the chiroptical spectroscopic methods is to analyze the experimental data using corresponding quantum chemical predictions. Such analysis involves multiple steps, including consideration of conformations, solvent effects, electronic transitions, stereoisomers, and experimental artifacts, each of which possesses certain limitations. These limitations, when not recognized or properly taken into account, may lead to incorrect conclusions. This review emphasizes on selected examples that illustrate the potential limitations in utilizing the chiroptical spectroscopic methods. The examples used include hibiscus acid dimethylester, hibiscus acid disodium salt, 3,3'-diphenyl-[2,2'-binaphthalene]-1,1'-diol, tartaric acid esters, and 6,6'-dibromo-[1,1'-binaphthalene]-2,2'-diol.

Novel coherent two-dimensional optical spectroscopy probes of chirality exchange and fluctuations in molecules

We demonstrate how stochastic transitions between molecular configurations with opposite senses of chirality may be probed by 2D optical signals with specific pulse polarization configurations. The third-order optical response of molecular dimers (such as biphenyls) with dynamical axial chirality is calculated to order of k(2) in the wavevector of light. Spectroscopic signatures of equilibrium chirality fluctuations are predicted for three dynamical models (Ornstein-Uhlenbeck, two-state jump, and diffusion in double well) of the dihedral angle that controls the chirality.

Transfer of chirality for memory and separation

Transfer of chirality is an intriguing issue worth studying to understand better the origin of life and for possible technological applications. In the last few years we have been working in this area studying the chain of events that begins with induction, reaches a permanent transfer (chiral memory) and extends in some cases to a (quasi-)reversible situation in which induced and permanently memorized chirality coexists. This can happen thanks to a designed blend of thermodynamics and kinetics.

Determination of the absolute configurations of bicyclo[3.1.0]hexane derivatives via electronic circular dichroism, optical rotation dispersion and vibrational circular dichroism spectroscopy and density functional theory calculations

The electronic circular dichroism (ECD), optical rotation dispersion (ORD), and vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) spectra of a pair of enantiomers, i.e. 3 and 4, of a bicyclo[3.1.0]hexane derivative have been measured in acetonitrile and acetonitrile-d(3), respectively. Extensive conformational searches at the B3LYP/6-311++G** level have been carried out for 3, which has four OH and one N(3) functional groups. For the bicyclo[3.1.0]hexane ring of 3, the boat-like conformers have been found to be much more stable than the chair-like conformers, while the number and the strength of the intramolecular hydrogen bonds have been identified as the dominant factors in the relative stability among the boat-like and among the chair-like conformers. DFT simulations of the ECD, ORD and VCD spectra have been performed for all low energy conformers at the B3LYP/6-311++G** and B3LYP/aug-cc-pVDZ level. Implicit continuum polarization model has been used to account for solvent effects in all these chiroptical measurements. Comparison of the DFT simulations with the experimental data shows that all three chiroptical properties yield the same absolute configuration assignment for . This work demonstrates that using multiple chiroptical spectroscopic methods in combination with DFT calculations allows one to determine absolute configurations with high confidence for chiral carbohydrates and their analogues, which possess a large number of rotatable bonds.

Time-dependent density functional response theory for electronic chiroptical properties of chiral molecules

Methodology to calculate electronic chiroptical properties from time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) is outlined. Applications of TDDFT to computations of electronic circular dichroism, optical rotation, and optical rotatory dispersion are reviewed. Emphasis is put on publications from 2005 to 2010, but much of the older literature is also cited and discussed. The determination of the absolute configuration of chiral molecules by combined measurements and computations is an important application of TDDFT chiroptical methods and discussed in some detail. Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra are obtained from normal-mode derivatives of the optical rotation tensor and other linear response tensors. A few selected (ROA) benchmarks are reviewed.