Catalytic site nucleotide and inorganic phosphate dependence of the conformation of the epsilon subunit in Escherichia coli adenosinetriphosphatase

Atomic insights of an up and down conformation of the Acinetobacter baumannii F1 -ATPase subunit ε and deciphering the residues critical for ATP hydrolysis inhibition and ATP synthesis

The Acinetobacter baumannii F1 FO -ATP synthase (α3 :β3 :γ:δ:ε:a:b2 :c10 ), which is essential for this strictly respiratory opportunistic human pathogen, is incapable of ATP-driven proton translocation due to its latent ATPase activity. Here, we generated and purified the first recombinant A. baumannii F1 -ATPase (AbF1 -ATPase) composed of subunits α3 :β3 :γ:ε, showing latent ATP hydrolysis. A 3.0 Å cryo-electron microscopy structure visualizes the architecture and regulatory element of this enzyme, in which the C-terminal domain of subunit ε (Abε) is present in an extended position. An ε-free AbF1 -ɑβγ complex generated showed a 21.5-fold ATP hydrolysis increase, demonstrating that Abε is the major regulator of AbF1 -ATPase's latent ATP hydrolysis. The recombinant system enabled mutational studies of single amino acid substitutions within Abε or its interacting subunits β and γ, respectively, as well as C-terminal truncated mutants of Abε, providing a detailed picture of Abε's main element for the self-inhibition mechanism of ATP hydrolysis. Using a heterologous expression system, the importance of Abε's C-terminus in ATP synthesis of inverted membrane vesicles, including AbF1 FO -ATP synthases, has been explored. In addition, we are presenting the first NMR solution structure of the compact form of Abε, revealing interaction of its N-terminal β-barrel and C-terminal ɑ-hairpin domain. A double mutant of Abε highlights critical residues for Abε's domain-domain formation which is important also for AbF1 -ATPase's stability. Abε does not bind MgATP, which is described to regulate the up and down movements in other bacterial counterparts. The data are compared to regulatory elements of F1 -ATPases in bacteria, chloroplasts, and mitochondria to prevent wasting of ATP.

F-ATP-ase of Escherichia coli membranes: The ubiquitous MgADP-inhibited state and the inhibited state induced by the ε-subunit's C-terminal domain are mutually exclusive

ATP synthases are important energy-coupling, rotary motor enzymes in all kingdoms of life. In all F-type ATP synthases, the central rotor of the catalytic F₁ complex is composed of the γ subunit and the N-terminal domain (NTD) of the ε subunit. In the enzymes of diverse bacteria, the C-terminal domain of ε (εCTD) can undergo a dramatic conformational change to trap the enzyme in a transiently inactive state. This inhibitory mechanism is absent in the mitochondrial enzyme, so the εCTD could provide a means to selectively target ATP synthases of pathogenic bacteria for antibiotic development. For Escherichia coli and other bacterial model systems, it has been difficult to dissect the relationship between ε inhibition and a MgADP-inhibited state that is ubiquitous for F_OF₁ from bacteria and eukaryotes. A prior study with the isolated catalytic complex from E. coli, EcF₁, showed that these two modes of inhibition are mutually exclusive, but it has long been known that interactions of F₁ with the membrane-embedded F_O complex modulate inhibition by the εCTD. Here, we study membranes containing EcF_OF₁ with wild-type ε, ε lacking the full εCTD, or ε with a small deletion at the C-terminus. By using compounds with distinct activating effects on F-ATP-ase activity, we confirm that εCTD inhibition and ubiquitous MgADP inhibition are mutually exclusive for membrane-bound E. coli F-ATP-ase. We determine that most of the enzyme complexes in wild-type membranes are in the ε-inhibited state (>50%) or in the MgADP-inhibited state (30%).

Modulation of coupling in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase by ADP and Pi: Role of the ε subunit C-terminal domain

The ε-subunit of ATP-synthase is an endogenous inhibitor of the hydrolysis activity of the complex and its α-helical C-terminal domain (εCTD) undergoes drastic changes among at least two different conformations. Even though this domain is not essential for ATP synthesis activity, there is evidence for its involvement in the coupling mechanism of the pump. Recently, it was proposed that coupling of the ATP synthase can vary as a function of ADP and P_i concentration. In the present work, we have explored the possible role of the εCTD in this ADP- and P_i-dependent coupling, by examining an εCTD-lacking mutant of Escherichia coli. We show that the loss of P_i-dependent coupling can be observed also in the εCTD-less mutant, but the effects of P_i on both proton pumping and ATP hydrolysis were much weaker in the mutant than in the wild-type. We also show that the εCTD strongly influences the binding of ADP to a very tight binding site (half-maximal effect≈1nM); binding at this site induces higher coupling in EF_OF₁ and increases responses to P_i. It is proposed that one physiological role of the εCTD is to regulate the kinetics and affinity of ADP/P_i binding, promoting ADP/P_i-dependent coupling.

ATP Synthesis by Oxidative Phosphorylation

The F1F0-ATP synthase (EC 3.6.1.34) is a remarkable enzyme that functions as a rotary motor. It is found in the inner membranes of Escherichia coli and is responsible for the synthesis of ATP in response to an electrochemical proton gradient. Under some conditions, the enzyme functions reversibly and uses the energy of ATP hydrolysis to generate the gradient. The ATP synthase is composed of eight different polypeptide subunits in a stoichiometry of α3β3γδεab2c10. Traditionally they were divided into two physically separable units: an F1 that catalyzes ATP hydrolysis (α3β3γδε) and a membrane-bound F0 sector that transports protons (ab2c10). In terms of rotary function, the subunits can be divided into rotor subunits (γεc10) and stator subunits (α3β3δab2). The stator subunits include six nucleotide binding sites, three catalytic and three noncatalytic, formed primarily by the β and α subunits, respectively. The stator also includes a peripheral stalk composed of δ and b subunits, and part of the proton channel in subunit a. Among the rotor subunits, the c subunits form a ring in the membrane, and interact with subunit a to form the proton channel. Subunits γ and ε bind to the c-ring subunits, and also communicate with the catalytic sites through interactions with α and β subunits. The eight subunits are expressed from a single operon, and posttranscriptional processing and translational regulation ensure that the polypeptides are made at the proper stoichiometry. Recent studies, including those of other species, have elucidated many structural and rotary properties of this enzyme.

F1-ATPase of Escherichia coli: the ε- inhibited state forms after ATP hydrolysis, is distinct from the ADP-inhibited state, and responds dynamically to catalytic site ligands

F1-ATPase is the catalytic complex of rotary nanomotor ATP synthases. Bacterial ATP synthases can be autoinhibited by the C-terminal domain of subunit ε, which partially inserts into the enzyme's central rotor cavity to block functional subunit rotation. Using a kinetic, optical assay of F1·ε binding and dissociation, we show that formation of the extended, inhibitory conformation of ε (εX) initiates after ATP hydrolysis at the catalytic dwell step. Prehydrolysis conditions prevent formation of the εX state, and post-hydrolysis conditions stabilize it. We also show that ε inhibition and ADP inhibition are distinct, competing processes that can follow the catalytic dwell. We show that the N-terminal domain of ε is responsible for initial binding to F1 and provides most of the binding energy. Without the C-terminal domain, partial inhibition by the ε N-terminal domain is due to enhanced ADP inhibition. The rapid effects of catalytic site ligands on conformational changes of F1-bound ε suggest dynamic conformational and rotational mobility in F1 that is paused near the catalytic dwell position.

Characterization of the relationship between ADP- and epsilon-induced inhibition in cyanobacterial F1-ATPase

The ATPase activity of chloroplast and bacterial F(1)-ATPase is strongly inhibited by both the endogenous inhibitor ε and tightly bound ADP. Although the physiological significance of these inhibitory mechanisms is not very well known for the membrane-bound F(0)F(1), these are very likely to be important in avoiding the futile ATP hydrolysis reaction and ensuring efficient ATP synthesis in vivo. In a previous study using the α(3)β(3)γ complex of F(1) obtained from the thermophilic cyanobacteria, Thermosynechococcus elongatus BP-1, we succeeded in determining the discrete stop position, ∼80° forward from the pause position for ATP binding, caused by ε-induced inhibition (ε-inhibition) during γ rotation (Konno, H., Murakami-Fuse, T., Fujii, F., Koyama, F., Ueoka-Nakanishi, H., Pack, C. G., Kinjo, M., and Hisabori, T. (2006) EMBO J. 25, 4596-4604). Because γ in ADP-inhibited F(1) also pauses at the same position, ADP-induced inhibition (ADP-inhibition) was assumed to be linked to ε-inhibition. However, ADP-inhibition and ε-inhibition should be independent phenomena from each other because the ATPase core complex, α(3)β(3)γ, also lapses into the ADP-inhibition state. By way of thorough biophysical and biochemical analyses, we determined that the ε subunit inhibition mechanism does not directly correlate with ADP-inhibition. We suggest here that the cyanobacterial ATP synthase ε subunit carries out an important regulatory role in acting as an independent "braking system" for the physiologically unfavorable ATP hydrolysis reaction.

The regulatory C-terminal domain of subunit ε of F₀F₁ ATP synthase is dispensable for growth and survival of Escherichia coli

The C-terminal domain of subunit ε of the bacterial F₀F₁ ATP synthase is reported to be an intrinsic inhibitor of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis activity in vitro, preventing wasteful hydrolysis of ATP under low-energy conditions. Mutants defective in this regulatory domain exhibited no significant difference in growth rate, molar growth yield, membrane potential, or intracellular ATP concentration under a wide range of growth conditions and stressors compared to wild-type cells, suggesting this inhibitory domain is dispensable for growth and survival of Escherichia coli.

What is the role of epsilon in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase?

The ATP synthase from Escherichia coli is a prototype of the ATP synthases that are found in many bacteria, in the mitochondria of eukaryotes, and in the chloroplasts of plants. It contains eight different types of subunits that have traditionally been divided into F(1), a water-soluble catalytic sector, and F(o), a membrane-bound ion transporting sector. In the current rotary model for ATP synthesis, the subunits can be divided into rotor and stator subunits. Several lines of evidence indicate that epsilon is one of the three rotor subunits, which rotate through 360 degrees. The three-dimensional structure of epsilon is known and its interactions with other subunits have been explored by several approaches. In light of recent work by our group and that of others, the role of epsilon in the ATP synthase from E. coli is discussed.

Intrinsic uncoupling in the ATP synthase of Escherichia coli

The ATP hydrolysis activity and proton pumping of the ATP synthase of Escherichia coli in isolated native membranes have been measured and compared as a function of ADP and Pi concentration. The ATP hydrolysis activity was inhibited by Pi with an half-maximal effect at 140 microM, which increased progressively up in the millimolar range when the ADP concentration was progressively decreased by increasing amounts of an ADP trap. In addition, the relative extent of this inhibition decreased with decreasing ADP. The half-maximal inhibition by ADP was found in the submicromolar range, and the extent of inhibition was enhanced by the presence of Pi. The parallel measurement of ATP hydrolysis activity and proton pumping indicated that, while the rate of ATP hydrolysis was decreased as a function of either ligand, the rate of proton pumping increased. The latter showed a biphasic response to the concentration of Pi, in which an inhibition followed the initial stimulation. Similarly as previously found for the ATP synthase from Rhodobacter caspulatus [P. Turina, D. Giovannini, F. Gubellini, B.A. Melandri, Physiological ligands ADP and Pi modulate the degree of intrinsic coupling in the ATP synthase of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus, Biochemistry 43 (2004) 11126-11134], these data indicate that the E. coli ATP synthase can operate at different degrees of energetic coupling between hydrolysis and proton transport, which are modulated by ADP and Pi.

Regulatory mechanisms of proton-translocating F(O)F (1)-ATP synthase

H(+)-F(O)F(1)-ATP synthase catalyzes synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate using the energy of transmembrane electrochemical potential difference of proton (deltamu(H)(+). The enzyme can also generate this potential difference by working as an ATP-driven proton pump. Several regulatory mechanisms are known to suppress the ATPase activity of F(O)F(1): 1. Non-competitive inhibition by MgADP, a feature shared by F(O)F(1) from bacteria, chloroplasts and mitochondria 2. Inhibition by subunit epsilon in chloroplast and bacterial enzyme 3. Inhibition upon oxidation of two cysteines in subunit gamma in chloroplast F(O)F(1) 4. Inhibition by an additional regulatory protein (IF(1)) in mitochondrial enzyme In this review we summarize the information available on these regulatory mechanisms and discuss possible interplay between them.

Chemical modification of mono-cysteine mutants allows a more global look at conformations of the epsilon subunit of the ATP synthase from Escherichia coli

The epsilon subunit of the ATP synthase from E. coli undergoes conformational changes while rotating through 360 degrees during catalysis. The conformation of epsilon was probed in the membrane-bound ATP synthase by reaction of mono-cysteine mutants with 3-N-maleimidyl-propionyl biocytin (MPB) under resting conditions, during ATP hydrolysis, and after inhibition by ADP-AlF(3). The relative extents of labeling were quantified after electrophoresis and blotting of the partially purified epsilon subunit. Residues from the N-terminal beta-sandwich domain showed a position-specific pattern of labeling, consistent with prior structural studies. Some residues near the epsilon-gamma interface showed changes up to two-fold if labeling occurred during ATP hydrolysis or after inhibition by ADP-AlF(3). In contrast, residues found in the C-terminal alpha-helices were all labeled to a moderate or high level with a pattern that was consistent with a partially opened helical hairpin. The results indicate that the two C-terminal alpha-helices do not adopt a fixed conformation under resting conditions, but rather exhibit intrinsic flexibility.

Regulatory interplay between proton motive force, ADP, phosphate, and subunit epsilon in bacterial ATP synthase

ATP synthase couples transmembrane proton transport, driven by the proton motive force (pmf), to the synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate (P(i)). In certain bacteria, the reaction is reversed and the enzyme generates pmf, working as a proton-pumping ATPase. The ATPase activity of bacterial enzymes is prone to inhibition by both ADP and the C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon. We studied the effects of ADP, P(i), pmf, and the C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon on the ATPase activity of thermophilic Bacillus PS3 and Escherichia coli ATP synthases. We found that pmf relieved ADP inhibition during steady-state ATP hydrolysis, but only in the presence of P(i). The C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon in the Bacillus PS3 enzyme enhanced ADP inhibition by counteracting the effects of pmf. It appears that these features allow the enzyme to promptly respond to changes in the ATP:ADP ratio and in pmf levels in order to avoid potentially wasteful ATP hydrolysis in vivo.

Modulation of proton pumping efficiency in bacterial ATP synthases

The ATP synthase in chromatophores of Rhodobacter caspulatus can effectively generate a transmembrane pH difference coupled to the hydrolysis of ATP. The rate of hydrolysis was rather insensitive to the depletion of ADP in the assay medium by an ATP regenerating system (phospho-enol-pyruvate (PEP) and pyruvate kinase (PK)). The steady state values of DeltapH were however drastically reduced as a consequence of ADP depletion. The clamped concentrations of ADP obtained using different PK activities in the assay medium could be calculated and an apparent Kd approximately 0.5 microM was estimated. The extent of proton uptake was also strongly dependent on the addition of phosphate to the assay medium. The Kd for this effect was about 70 microM. Analogous experiments were performed in membrane fragment from Escherichia coli. In this case, however, the hydrolysis rate was strongly inhibited by Pi, added up to 3 mM. Inhibition by Pi was nearly completely suppressed following depletion of ADP. The Kd's for the ADP and Pi were in the micromolar range and submillimolar range, respectively, and were mutually dependent from the concentration of the other ligand. Contrary to hydrolysis, the pumping of protons was rather insensitive to changes in the concentrations of the two ligands. At intermediate concentrations, proton pumping was actually stimulated, while the hydrolysis was inhibited. It is concluded that, in these two bacterial organisms, ADP and phosphate induce a functional state of the ATP synthase competent for a tightly coupled proton pumping, while the depletion of either one of these two ligands favors an inefficient (slipping) functional state. The switch between these states can probably be related to a structural change in the C-terminal alpha-helical hairpin of the epsilon-subunit, from an extended conformation, in which ATP hydrolysis is tightly coupled to proton pumping, to a retracted one, in which ATP hydrolysis and proton pumping are loosely coupled.

The role of subunit epsilon in the catalysis and regulation of FOF1-ATP synthase

The regulation of ATP synthase activity is complex and involves several distinct mechanisms. In bacteria and chloroplasts, subunit epsilon plays an important role in this regulation, (i) affecting the efficiency of coupling, (ii) influencing the catalytic pathway, and (iii) selectively inhibiting ATP hydrolysis activity. Several experimental studies indicate that the regulation is achieved through large conformational transitions of the alpha-helical C-terminal domain of subunit epsilon that occur in response to membrane energization, change in ATP/ADP ratio or addition of inhibitors. This review summarizes the experimental data obtained on different organisms that clarify some basic features as well as some molecular details of this regulatory mechanism. Multiple functions of subunit epsilon, its role in the difference between the catalytic pathways of ATP synthesis and hydrolysis and its influence on the inhibition of ATP hydrolysis by ADP are also discussed.

A functionally inactive, cold-stabilized form of the Escherichia coli F1Fo ATP synthase

An unusual effect of temperature on the ATPase activity of E. coli F1Fo ATP synthase has been investigated. The rate of ATP hydrolysis by the isolated enzyme, previously kept on ice, showed a lag phase when measured at 15 degrees C, but not at 37 degrees C. A pre-incubation of the enzyme at room temperature for 5 min completely eliminated the lag phase, and resulted in a higher steady-state rate. Similar results were obtained using the isolated enzyme after incorporation into liposomes. The initial rates of ATP-dependent proton translocation, as measured by 9-amino-6-chloro-2-methoxyacridine (ACMA) fluorescence quenching, at 15 degrees C also varied according to the pre-incubation temperature. The relationship between this temperature-dependent pattern of enzyme activity, termed thermohysteresis, and pre-incubation with other agents was examined. Pre-incubation of membrane vesicles with azide and Mg2+, without exogenous ADP, resulted in almost complete inhibition of the initial rate of ATPase when assayed at 10 degrees C, but had little effect at 37 degrees C. Rates of ATP synthesis following this pre-incubation were not affected at any temperature. Azide inhibition of ATP hydrolysis by the isolated enzyme was reduced when an ATP-regenerating system was used. A gradual reactivation of azide-blocked enzyme was slowed down by the presence of phosphate in the reaction medium. The well-known Mg2+ inhibition of ATP hydrolysis was shown to be greatly enhanced at 15 degrees C relative to at 37 degrees C. The results suggest that thermohysteresis is a consequence of an inactive form of the enzyme that is stabilized by the binding of inhibitory Mg-ADP.

Regulation of the F0F1-ATP synthase: the conformation of subunit epsilon might be determined by directionality of subunit gamma rotation

F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase couples ATP synthesis/hydrolysis with transmembrane proton transport. The catalytic mechanism involves rotation of the gamma epsilon c(approximately 10)-subunits complex relative to the rest of the enzyme. In the absence of protonmotive force the enzyme is inactivated by the tight binding of MgADP. Subunit epsilon also modulates the activity: its conformation can change from a contracted to extended form with C-terminus stretched towards F(1). The latter form inhibits ATP hydrolysis (but not synthesis). We propose that the directionality of the coiled-coil subunit gamma rotation determines whether subunit epsilon is in contracted or extended form. Block of rotation by MgADP presumably induces the extended conformation of subunit epsilon. This conformation might serve as a safety lock, stabilizing the ADP-inhibited state upon de-energization and preventing spontaneous re-activation and wasteful ATP hydrolysis. The hypothesis merges the known regulatory effects of ADP, protonmotive force and conformational changes of subunit epsilon into a consistent picture.

Pi binding by the F1-ATPase of beef heart mitochondria and of theEscherichia coliplasma membrane

Pi binding by the F(1)-ATPase of beef heart mitochondria and of the Escherichia coli plasma membrane (E. coli F(1)) was examined by two methods: the centrifuge column procedure [Penefsky, H.S. (1977) J. Biol. Chem. 252, 2891-2899] and the Paulus pressure dialysis cell [Paulus, H. (1969) Anal. Biochem. 32, 91-100]. The latter is an equilibrium dialysis-type procedure. Pi binding by beef heart F(1) could be determined by either procedure. However, direct binding of Pi to E. coli F(1) could be determined adequately only in the Paulus cell which indicated more than two binding sites per mol of enzyme with a K(d) in the range of 0.1 mM. It is concluded that previous failure to observe Pi binding to E. coli F(1) with the centrifuge column procedure is due to a rapid rate of dissociation of Pi from the E. coli enzyme which results in loss of Pi during transit of the enzyme-Pi complex through the column.

Genetic fusions of globular proteins to the epsilon subunit of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase: Implications for in vivo rotational catalysis and epsilon subunit function

The rotational mechanism of ATP synthase was investigated by fusing three proteins from Escherichia coli, the 12-kDa soluble cytochrome b(562), the 20-kDa flavodoxin, and the 28-kDa flavodoxin reductase, to the C terminus of the epsilon subunit of the enzyme. According to the concept of rotational catalysis, because epsilon is part of the rotor a large domain added at this site should sterically clash with the second stalk, blocking rotation and fully inhibiting the enzyme. E. coli cells expressing the cytochrome b(562) fusion in place of wild-type epsilon grew using acetate as the energy source, indicating their capacity for oxidative phosphorylation. Cells expressing the larger flavodoxin or flavodoxin reductase fusions failed to grow on acetate. Immunoblot analysis showed that the fusion proteins were stable in the cells and that they had no effect on enzyme assembly. These results provide initial evidence supporting rotational catalysis in vivo. In membrane vesicles, the cytochrome b(562) fusion caused an increase in the apparent ATPase activity but a minor decrease in proton pumping. Vesicles bearing ATP synthase containing the larger fusion proteins showed reduced but significant levels of ATPase activity that was sensitive to inhibition by dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) but no proton pumping. Thus, all fusions to epsilon generated an uncoupled component of ATPase activity. These results imply that a function of the C terminus of epsilon in F(1)F(0) is to increase the efficiency of the enzyme by specifically preventing the uncoupled hydrolysis of ATP. Given the sensitivity to DCCD, this uncoupled ATP hydrolysis may arise from rotational steps of gammaepsilon in the inappropriate direction after ATP is bound at the catalytic site. It is proposed that the C-terminal domain of epsilon functions to ensure that rotation occurs only in the direction of ATP synthesis when ADP is bound and only in the direction of hydrolysis when ATP is bound.

The activity of the ATP synthase from Escherichia coli is regulated by the transmembrane proton motive force

The ATP synthase from Escherichia coli was reconstituted into liposomes from phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidic acid. The proteoliposomes were energized by an acid-base transition and a K(+)/valinomycin diffusion potential, and one second after energization, the electrochemical proton gradient was dissipated by uncouplers, and the ATP hydrolysis measurement was started. In the presence of ADP and P(i), the initial rate of ATP hydrolysis was up to 9-fold higher with pre-energized proteoliposomes than with proteoliposomes that had not seen an electrochemical proton gradient. After dissipating the electrochemical proton gradient, the high rate of ATP hydrolysis decayed to the rate without pre-energization within about 15 s. During this decay the enzyme carried out approximately 100 turnovers. In the absence of ADP and P(i), the rate of ATP hydrolysis was already high and could not be significantly increased by pre-energization. It is concluded that ATP hydrolysis is inhibited when ADP and P(i) are bound to the enzyme and that a high Delta mu(H(+)) is required to release ADP and P(i) and to convert the enzyme into a high activity state. This high activity state is metastable and decays slowly when Delta mu(H(+)) is abolished. Thus, the proton motive force does not only supply energy for ATP synthesis but also regulates the fraction of active enzymes.

Sulfite and membrane energization induce two different active states of the Paracoccus denitrificans F0F1-ATPase

Activation of the latent ATPase activity of inside-out vesicles from plasma membranes of Paracoccus denitrificans was studied. Several factors were found to induce activation: heat, membrane energization by succinate oxidation, methanol, oxyanions (sulfite, phosphate, arsenate, bicarbonate) and limited proteolysis with trypsin. Among the oxyanions, sulfite induced the higher increase in ATPase activity. Sulfite functioned as a nonessential activator that slightly modified the affinity for ATP and increased notoriously the Vmax. There was a competitive effect between sulfite, bicarbonate and phosphate for ATPase activation; their similar chemical geometry suggests that these oxyanions have a common binding site on the enzyme. Dithiothreitol did not affect the ATPase activity. ATPase activation by sulfite was decreased by uncoupler, enhanced by trypsin and inhibited by ADP, oligomycin and venturicidin. In contrast, activation induced by succinate was less sensitive to ADP, oligomycin, venturicidin and trypsin. It is proposed that the active states induced by sulfite and succinate reflect two conformations of the enzyme, in which the inhibitory subunit epsilon is differently exposed to trypsin.

The gammaepsilon-c subunit interface in the ATP synthase of Escherichia coli. cross-linking of the epsilon subunit to the c subunit ring does not impair enzyme function, that of gamma to c subunits leads to uncoupling

Mutants with a cysteine residue in the gamma subunit at position 207 and the epsilon subunit at position 31 were expressed in combination with a c-dimer construct, which contains a single cysteine at position 42 of the second c subunit. These mutants are called gammaY207C/cc'Q42C and epsilonE31C/cc'Q42C, respectively. Cross-linking of epsilon to the c subunit ring was obtained almost to completion without significant effect on any enzyme function, i.e. ATP hydrolysis, ATP synthesis, and ATP hydrolysis-driven proton translocation were all close to that of wild type. The gamma subunit could also be linked to the c subunit ring in more than 90% yield, but this affected coupling. Thus, ATP hydrolysis was increased 2. 5-fold, ATP synthesis was dramatically decreased, and ATP hydrolysis-driven proton translocation was abolished, as measured by the 9-amino-6-chloro-2-methoxyacridinequenching method. These results for epsilonE31C/cc'Q42C indicate that the c subunit ring rotates with the central stalk element. That the gamma-epsilon cross-linked enzyme retains ATPase activity also argues for a gammaepsilon-c subunit rotor. However, the uncoupling induced by cross-linking of gamma to the c subunit ring points to important conformational changes taking place in the gammaepsilon-c subunit interface during this. Blocking these structural changes by cross-linking leads to a proton leak within the F(0).

The epsilon subunit of the F(1)F(0) complex of Escherichia coli. cross-linking studies show the same structure in situ as when isolated

Four double mutants in the epsilon subunit were generated, each containing two cysteines, which, based on the NMR structure of this subunit, should form internal disulfide bonds. Two of these were designed to generate interdomain cross-links that lock the C-terminal alpha-helical domain against the beta-sandwich (epsilonM49C/A126C and epsilonF61C/V130C). The second set should give cross-linking between the two C-terminal alpha-helices (epsilonA94C/L128C and epsilonA101C/L121C). All four mutants cross-linked with 90-100% efficiency upon CuCl(2) treatment in isolated Escherichia coli ATP synthase. This shows that the structure obtained for isolated epsilon is essentially the same as in the assembled complex. Functional studies revealed increased ATP hydrolysis after cross-linking between the two domains of the subunit but not after cross-linking between the C-terminal alpha-helices. None of the cross-links had any effect on proton pumping-coupled ATP hydrolysis, on DCCD sensitivity of this activity, or on ATP synthesis rates. Therefore, big conformational changes within epsilon can be ruled out as a part of the enzyme function. Protease digestion studies, however, showed that subtle changes do occur, since the epsilon subunit could be locked in an ADP or 5'-adenylyl-beta,gamma-imidodiphosphate conformation by the cross-linking with resulting differences in cleavage rates.

Novel features in the structure of bovine ATP synthase

The F1F0-ATP synthase from bovine heart mitochondria catalyses the synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate by using the energy of an electrochemical proton gradient derived from electron transport. The enzyme consists of three major domains: the globular F1catalytic domain of known atomic structure lies outside the lipid bilayer and is attached by a central stalk to the intrinsic membrane domain, F0, which transports protons through the membrane. Proton transport through F0evokes structural changes that are probably transmitted by rotation of the stalk to the catalytic sites in F1. In an alpha3beta3gamma1subcomplex, the rotation of the central gamma subunit driven by ATP hydrolysis has been visualised by optical microscopy. In order to prevent the alpha3beta3structure from following the rotation of the central gamma subunit, it has been proposed that the enzyme might have a stator connecting static parts in F0to alpha3beta3,thereby keeping it fixed relative to the rotating parts. Here we present electron microscopy images that reveal three new features in bovine F1F0-ATPase, one of which could be a stator. The second feature is a collar structure above the membrane domain and the third feature is some additional density on top of the F1domain.

Mutation of the mitochrondrially encoded ATPase 6 gene modeled in the ATP synthase of Escherichia coli

Defects of respiratory chain protein complexes and the ATP synthase are becoming increasingly implicated in human disease. Recently, mutations in the ATPase 6 gene have been shown to cause several different neurological disorders. The product of this gene is homologous to the a subunit of the ATP synthase of Escherichia coli. Here, mutations equivalent to those described in humans have been introduced into the a subunit of E. coli by site-directed mutagenesis, and the effects of these mutations on the ATPase activity, ATP synthesis and ability of the enzyme to pump protons studied in detail. The effects of the mutations varied considerably. The mutation L262P (9185 T-C equivalent) caused a 70% loss of ATP synthesis activity, reduced DCCD sensitivity, and lowered proton pumping activity. The L207P (8993 T-C equivalent) reduced ATP synthesis by 50%, affected DCCD sensitivity, while proton pumping was only marginally affected when measured by the standard AMCA quenching assay. The other mutations studied affected the functioning of the ATP synthase much less. The results confirm that modeling of these point mutations in the E. coli enzyme is a useful approach to determining how alterations in the ATPase 6 gene affect enzyme function and, therefore, how a pathogenic effect can be exerted.

Solution structure of the epsilon subunit of the F1-ATPase from Escherichia coli and interactions of this subunit with beta subunits in the complex

The solution structure of the epsilon subunit of the Escherichia coli F1-ATPase has been determined by NMR spectroscopy. This subunit has a two-domain structure with an N-terminal 10-stranded beta sandwich and a C-terminal antiparallel two alpha-helix hairpin, as described previously (Wilkens, S., Dahlquist, F. W., McIntosh, L. P., Donaldson, L. W., and Capaldi, R. A. (1995) Nat. Struct. Biol. 2, 961-967). New data show that the two domains interact in solution in an interface formed by beta strand 7 and the very C-terminal alpha-helix. This interface involves only hydrophobic interactions. The dynamics of the epsilon subunit in solution were examined. The two domains are relatively tightly associated with little or no flexibility relative to one another. The epsilon subunit can exist in two states in the ECF1F0 complex depending on whether ATP or ADP occupies catalytic sites. Proteolysis of the epsilon subunit in solution and when bound to the core F1 complex indicates that the conformation of the polypeptide in solution closely resembles the conformation of epsilon when bound to the F1 in the ADP state. Chemical and photo-cross-linking show that the epsilon subunit spans and interacts with two beta subunits in the ADP state. These interactions are disrupted on binding of ATP + Mg2+, as is the interaction between the N- and C-terminal domains of the epsilon subunit.

Trapping of conformations of the Escherichia coli F1 ATPase by disulfide bond formation. A state of the enzyme with all three catalytic sites of equal and low affinity for nucleotides

A mutant of Escherichia coli F1F0-ATPase, alphaS411C/betaY331W/betaE381C/gammaC87S, has been generated. CuCl2 treatment of this mutant led to cross-linking between alpha and beta subunits in yields of up to 90%. This cross-linking across non-catalytic site interfaces inhibited ATP hydrolysis activity. In the absence of cross-linking, MgATP bound in catalytic sites of the mutant with three different affinities of 0.1 microM, 6 microM and 60 microM, respectively, values that are comparable to wild-type. For MgADP, there was one tight site (0.34 microM) and two sites of lower affinity (each 27 microM), again comparable to wild-type enzyme. After cross-linking all three catalytic sites bound MgATP or MgADP with the same relatively low affinity (approximately 60 microM). Thus cross-linking fixed all three catalytic sites in the same conformation. Trypsin cleavage experiments showed that cross-linking fixed the epsilon subunit in the ATP+EDTA conformation.

Thermophilic F1-ATPase is activated without dissociation of an endogenous inhibitor, epsilon subunit

Subunit complexes (alpha3beta3gamma, alpha3beta3gammadelta, alpha3beta3gammaepsilon, and alpha3beta3gammadeltaepsilon) of thermophilic F1-ATPase were prepared, and their catalytic properties were compared to know the role of delta and epsilon subunits in catalysis. The presence of delta subunit in the complexes had slight inhibitory effect on the ATPase activity. The effect of epsilon subunit was more profound. The (-epsilon) complexes, alpha3beta3gamma and alpha3beta3gammadelta, initiated ATP hydrolysis without a lag. In contrast, the (+epsilon) complexes, alpha3beta3gammaepsilon and alpha3beta3gammadeltaepsilon, started hydrolysis of ATP (<700 microM) with a lag phase that was gradually activated during catalytic turnover. As ATP concentration increased, the lag phase of the (+epsilon) complexes became shorter, and it was not observed above 1 mM ATP. Analysis of binding and hydrolysis of the ATP analog, 2',3'-O-(2,4,6-trinitrophenyl)-ATP, suggested that the (+epsilon) complexes bound substrate only slowly. Differing from Escherichia coli F1-ATPase, the activation of the (+epsilon) complexes from the lag phase was not due to dissociation of epsilon subunit since the re-isolated activated complex retained epsilon subunit. This indicates that there are two alternative forms of the (+epsilon) complex, inhibited form and activated form, and the inhibited one is converted to the activated one during catalytic turnover.

Structure and arrangement of the delta subunit in the E. coli ATP synthase (ECF1F0)

F1F0 type ATPases are made up of two parts, an F1, which contains three catalytic sites on beta subunits, and an F0 which contains the proton channel. These two domains have been visualized in electron microscopy as linked by a narrow stalk of around 45 A in length. Biochemical studies have provided clear evidence that the gamma and epsilon subunits are components of this stalk. There is an emerging consensus that the gamma and epsilon subunits rotate relative to the alpha 3 beta 3 domain as part of the cooperativity and energy coupling within the complex. Two other subunits are required to link the F1 to F0 in the E. coli enzyme, and these are the delta and b subunits. The structure of a major part of the delta subunit (residues 1-134) has now been obtained by NMR spectroscopy. The main feature is a six alpha-helix bundle, which provides the N-terminal domain of the delta subunit. This domain interacts with the F1 core via the N-terminal part of the alpha subunit. The C-terminal domain of delta is less well defined. This part is required for binding to the F0 part by direct interaction with the b subunits. It is argued that delta and the two copies of the b subunit are components of a second stalk linking the F1 and F0 parts, which acts as a stator to allow the energy-linked rotational movements of delta and epsilon subunits.

Crystal structure of the epsilon subunit of the proton-translocating ATP synthase from Escherichia coli

BACKGROUND

Proton-translocating ATP synthases convert the energy generated from photosynthesis or respiration into ATP. These enzymes, termed F0F1-ATPases, are structurally highly conserved. In Escherichia coli, F0F1-ATPase consists of a membrane portion, F0, made up of three different polypeptides (a, b and c) and an F1 portion comprising five different polypeptides in the stoichiometry alpha 3 beta 3 gamma delta epsilon. The minor subunits gamma, delta and epsilon are required for the coupling of proton translocation with ATP synthesis; the epsilon subunit is in close contact with the alpha, beta, gamma and c subunits. The structure of the epsilon subunit provides clues to its essential role in this complex enzyme.

RESULTS

The structure of the E. coli F0F1-ATPase epsilon subunit has been solved at 2.3 A resolution by multiple isomorphous replacement. The structure, comprising residues 2-136 of the polypeptide chain and 14 water molecules, refined to an R value of 0.214 (Rfree = 0.288). The molecule has a novel fold with two domains. The N-terminal domain is a beta sandwich with two five-stranded sheets. The C-terminal domain is formed from two alpha helices arranged in an antiparallel coiled-coil. A series of alanine residues from each helix form the central contacting residues in the helical domain and can be described as an 'alanine zipper'. There is an extensive hydrophobic contact region between the two domains providing a stable interface. The individual domains of the crystal structure closely resemble the structures determined in solution by NMR spectroscopy.

CONCLUSIONS

Sequence alignments of a number of epsilon subunits from diverse sources suggest that the C-terminal domain, which is absent in some species, is not essential for function. In the crystal the N-terminal domains of two epsilon subunits make a close hydrophobic interaction across a crystallographic twofold axis. This region has previously been proposed as the contact surface between the epsilon and gamma subunits in the complete F1-ATPase complex. In the crystal structure we observe what is apparently a stable interface between the two domains of the epsilon subunit, consistent with the fact that the crystal and solution structures are quite similar despite close crystal packing. This suggests that a gross conformational change in the epsilon subunit, to transmit the effect of proton translocation to the catalytic domain, is unlikely, but cannot be ruled out.

Rotation of a gamma-epsilon subunit domain in the Escherichia coli F1F0-ATP synthase complex. The gamma-epsilon subunits are essentially randomly distributed relative to the alpha3beta3delta domain in the intact complex

A triple mutant of Escherichia coli F1F0-ATP synthase, alphaQ2C/alphaS411C/epsilonS108C, has been generated for studying movements of the gamma and epsilon subunits during functioning of the enzyme. It includes mutations that allow disulfide bond formation between the Cys at alpha411 and both Cys-87 of gamma and Cys-108 of epsilon, two covalent cross-links that block enzyme function (Aggeler, R., and Capaldi, R. A. (1996) J. Biol. Chem. 271, 13888-13891). A cross-link is also generated between the Cys at alpha2 and Cys-140 of the delta subunit, which has no effect on functioning (Ogilvie, I., Aggeler, R., and Capaldi, R. A. (1997) J. Biol. Chem. 272, 16652-16656). CuCl2 treatment of the mutant alphaQ2C/alphaS411C/epsilonS108C generated five major cross-linked products. These are alpha-gamma-delta, alpha-gamma, alpha-delta-epsilon, alpha-delta, and alpha-epsilon. The ratio of alpha-gamma-delta to the alpha-gamma product was close to 1:2, i.e. in one-third of the ECF1F0 molecules the gamma subunit was attached to the alpha subunit at which the delta subunit is bound. Also, 20% of the epsilon subunit was present as a alpha-delta-epsilon product. With regard to the delta subunit, 30% was in the alpha-gamma-delta, 20% in the alpha-delta-epsilon, and 50% in the alpha-delta products when the cross-linking was done after incubation in ATP + MgCl2. The amounts of these three products were 40, 22, and 38%, respectively, in experiments where Cu2+ was added after preincubation in ATP + Mg2+ + azide. The delta subunit is fixed to, and therefore identifies, one specific alpha subunit (alphadelta). A distribution of the gamma and epsilon subunits, which is essentially random with respect to the alpha subunits, can only be explained by rotation of gamma-epsilon relative to the alpha3beta3 domain in ECF1F0.

Cross-linking of the delta subunit to one of the three alpha subunits has no effect on functioning, as expected if delta is a part of the stator that links the F1 and F0 parts of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase

A mutant of the Escherichia coli F1F0-ATPase has been generated (alphaQ2C) in which the glutamine at position 2 of the alpha subunit has been replaced with a cysteine residue. Cu2+ treatment of ECF1 from this mutant cross-linked an alpha subunit to the delta subunit in high yield. Two different sites of disulfide bond formation were involved, i.e. between Cys90 (or the closely spaced Cys47) of alpha with Cys140 of delta, and between Cys2 of alpha and Cys140 of delta. Small amounts of other cross-linked products, including alpha-alpha, delta internal, and alpha-alpha-delta were obtained. In ECF1F0, there was no cross-linking between the intrinsic Cys of alpha and Cys140. Instead, the product generated between Cys2 of alpha and Cys140 of delta was obtained at near 90% yield. Small amounts of alpha-alpha and delta internal were present, and under high Cu2+ concentrations, alpha-alpha-delta was also formed. The ATPase activity of ECF1 and ECF1F0 was not significantly affected by the presence of these cross-links. When Cys140 of delta was first modified with N-ethylmaleimide in ECF1F0, an alpha-delta cross-link was still produced, although in lower yield, between Cys64 of delta and Cys2 of alpha. ATP hydrolysis-linked proton pumping of inner membranes from the mutant alpha2QC was only marginally affected by cross-linking of the alpha to the delta subunit. These results indicate that Cys140 and Cys64 of the delta subunit and Cys2 of the alpha subunit are in close proximity. This places the delta subunit near the top of the alpha-beta hexagon and not in the stalk region. As fixing the delta to the alpha by cross-linking does not greatly impair either the ATPase function of the enzyme, or coupled proton translocation, we argue that the delta subunit forms a portion of the stator linking F1 to F0.

Interactions between the F1 and F0 parts in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase. Associations involving the loop region of C subunits

The N-ethylmaleimide reactivity of c subunits in Escherichia coli F1F0 ATP synthase (ECF1F0) isolated from five mutants, each with a cysteine at a different position in the polar loop region (positions 39, 40, 42, 43, and 44), has been investigated. The maleimide was found to react with Cys placed at positions 42, 43, and 44 but not at 39 or 40. All copies of the c subunit reacted similarly when the Cys was at position 43 or 44. In contrast, the Cys in the mutant cQ42C reacted as two classes, with 60% reacting relatively rapidly and 40% reacting at a rate 40-fold slower. After removing F1, all copies of the c subunit in this mutant reacted equally fast. Therefore, the slow class in the cQ42C mutant represents c subunits shielded by, and probably involved directly in, the interaction of the F0 with gamma and epsilon subunits of the F1 part. Based on the estimated stoichiometry of c subunits in the ECF1F0 complex, 4 or 5 c subunits are involved in this F1 interaction. N-Ethylmaleimide modification of all of the c subunits reduced ATPase activity by only 30% in ECF1F0 from mutant cQ42C. Modification of the more rapidly reacting class had little effect on ATP hydrolysis-driven proton translocation, and did not alter the DCCD inhibition of ATPase activity. However, as those c subunits involved in the F1 interaction became modified, DCCD inhibition was progressively lost, as was coupling between ATP hydrolysis and proton translocation.

The absence of the mitochondrial ATP synthase delta subunit promotes a slow growth phenotype of rho- yeast cells by a lack of assembly of the catalytic sector F1

In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, inactivation of the gene encoding the delta subunit of the ATP synthase led to a lack of assembly of the catalytic sector. In addition a slow-growth phenotype was observed on fermentable medium. This alteration appears in strains lacking intact mitochondrial DNA and showing a defect in the assembly of the catalytic sector, such as the yeast strain inactivated in the gene encoding the epsilon subunit. In rho mitochondria having an intact F1, the ion movement resulting from the exchange of ADP formed in the organelle and ATP entering the mitochondrial compartment led to a mitochondrial transmembranous potential delta psi that was sensitive to carboxyactractyloside. This ion movement was dramatically decreased in rho mitochondria lacking the delta subunit and thus the F1 sector, whereas a cell devoid of delta subunit and complemented with a plasmid harboring the ATPdelta gene displayed an assembled F1, a normal generation time and a fully restored mitochondrial potential. This result could be linked to the involvement of the membrane potential delta psi which is indispensible for mitochondrial biogenesis.

Epsilon-binding regions of the gamma subunit of Escherichia coli ATP synthase

The interaction between the gamma and epsilon subunits of the F1-ATPase sector of Escherichia coli ATP synthase has been investigated using monoclonal antibodies directed against the gamma subunit and ligand blotting using 125I-epsilon. Monoclonal antibody (MAb) gamma-1 was able to bind to epsilon-depleted F1-ATPase but not to epsilon-replete F1, implying that epsilon blocked access to the epitope. A ligand blot assay for the binding of 125I-epsilon to gamma was developed. Both MAb gamma-1 and a second antibody, MAb gamma II, inhibited binding of 125I-epsilon to gamma in this assay while two other anti-gamma monoclonal antibodies did not. The epitope recognized by MAb gamma-1 was mapped between residues R49 and R70, quite distant in sequence from that of MAb gamma II, which is located C-terminal to residue K199 of the 286-residue polypeptide. The competition of these antibodies with epsilon for binding to gamma implies that their epitopes, quite separate in sequence, are both located in parts of the subunit involved in binding epsilon.

The trapping of different conformations of the Escherichia coli F1 ATPase by disulfide bond formation. Effect on nucleotide binding affinities of the catalytic sites

Two mutants of the Escherichia coli F1 ATPase, betaY331W:E381C/epsilonS108C and alphaS411C/betaY331W/epsilonS108C, have been used to relate nucleotide binding in catalytic sites with different interactions of the stalk-forming subunits gamma and epsilon at the alpha3beta3 subunit domain. Essentially full yield cross-linking between beta + gamma and beta + epsilon, or between alpha + gamma and alpha + epsilon, was obtained in these mutants by Cu2+-induced disulfide bond formation, thereby trapping the enzyme in states with the small subunits interacting either with beta or alpha subunits. The presence of the Trp for beta Tyr-331 in both mutants allowed direct measurement of nucleotide occupancy of catalytic sites. Before cross-linking, Mg2+ATP could be bound in all three catalytic sites in both mutants with a Kd of around 0.1 microM for the highest affinity site and Kd values of approximately 2 microM and 30-40 microM for the second and third sites, respectively. In the absence of Mg2+, ATP also bound in all three catalytic sites but with a single low affinity (above 100 microM) in both mutants. Cu2+-induced cross-linking of ECF1 from the mutant betaY331W:E381C/epsilonS108C had very little effect on nucleotide binding. The binding affinities of the three catalytic sites for Mg2+ATP were not significantly altered from those obtained before cross-linking, and the enzyme still switched between cooperative binding and equal binding affinities of the three catalytic sites (when Mg2+ was absent). When the gamma and epsilon subunits were cross-linked to alpha subunits, ATP binding in the highest affinity catalytic site was dramatically altered. This site became closed so that nucleotide (ATP or ADP) that had been bound into it prior to cross-linking was trapped and could not exchange out. Also, ATP or ADP could not enter this site, although empty, once the enzyme had been cross-linked. Finally, cross-linking of the gamma and epsilon to the alpha subunits prevented the switching between cooperative binding and the state where the three catalytic sites are equivalent. We argue that the conformation of the enzyme in which the small subunits are at alpha subunits occurs during functioning of the enzyme in the course of the rotation of gamma and epsilon subunits within the alpha3beta3 hexamer and that this may be the activated state for ATP synthesis.

The F0F1-type ATP synthases of bacteria: structure and function of the F0 complex

Membrane-bound ATP synthases (F0F1-ATPases) of bacteria serve two important physiological functions. The enzyme catalyzes the synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate utilizing the energy of an electrochemical ion gradient. On the other hand, under conditions of low driving force, ATP synthases function as ATPases, thereby generating a transmembrane ion gradient at the expense of ATP hydrolysis. The enzyme complex consists of two structurally and functionally distinct parts: the membrane-integrated ion-translocating F0 complex and the peripheral F1 complex, which carries the catalytic sites for ATP synthesis and hydrolysis. The ATP synthase of Escherichia coli, which has been the most intensively studied one, is composed of eight different subunits, five of which belong to F1, subunits alpha, beta, gamma, delta, and epsilon (3:3:1:1:1), and three to F0, subunits a, b, and c (1:2:10 +/- 1). The similar overall structure and the high amino acid sequence homology indicate that the mechanism of ion translocation and catalysis and their mode of coupling is the same in all organisms.

Structural changes in the gamma and epsilon subunits of the Escherichia coli F1F0-type ATPase during energy coupling

Structural changes in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase (ECF1F0) occur as part of catalysis, cooperativity and energy coupling within the complex. The gamma and epsilon subunits, two major components of the stalk that links the F1 and F0 parts, are intimately involved in conformational coupling that links catalytic site events in the F1 part with proton pumping through the membrane embedded F0 section. Movements of the gamma subunit have been observed by electron microscopy, and by cross-linking and fluorescence studies in which reagents are bound to Cys residues introduced at selected sites by mutagenesis. Conformational changes and shifts of the epsilon subunit related to changes in nucleotide occupancy sites have been followed by similar approaches.

Conformational transmission in ATP synthase during catalysis: search for large structural changes

Escherichia coli ATP synthase has eight subunits and functions through transmission of conformational changes between subunits. Defective mutation at beta Gly-149 was suppressed by the second mutations at the outer surface of the beta subunit, indicating that the defect by the first mutation was suppressed by the second mutation through long range conformation transmission. Extensive mutant/pseudorevertant studies revealed that beta/alpha and beta/gamma subunits interactions are important for the energy coupling between catalysis and H+ translocation. In addition, long range interaction between amino and carboxyl terminal regions of the gamma subunit has a critical role(s) for energy coupling. These results suggest that the dynamic conformation change and its transmission are essential for ATP synthase.

Nucleotide-dependent movement of the epsilon subunit between alpha and beta subunits in the Escherichia coli F1F0-type ATPase

Mutants of ECF1-ATPase were generated, containing cysteine residues in one or more of the following positions: alphaSer-411, betaGlu-381, and epsilonSer-108, after which disulfide bridges could be created by CuCl2 induced oxidation in high yield between alpha and epsilon, beta and epsilon, alpha and gamma, beta and gamma (endogenous Cys-87), and alpha and beta. All of these cross-links lead to inhibition of ATP hydrolysis activity. In the two double mutants, containing a cysteine in epsilonSer-108 along with either the DELSEED region of beta (Glu-381) or the homologous region in alpha (Ser-411), there was a clear nucleotide dependence of the cross-link formation with the epsilon subunit. In betaE381C/epsilonS108C the beta-epsilon cross-link was obtained preferentially when Mg2+ and ADP + Pi (addition of MgCl2 + ATP) was present, while the alpha-epsilon cross-link product was strongly favored in the alphaS411C/epsilonS108C mutant in the Mg2+ ATP state (addition of MgCl2 + 5'-adenylyl-beta,gamma-imidodiphosphate). In the triple mutant alphaS411C/betaE381C/epsilonS108C, the epsilon subunit bound to the beta subunit in Mg2+-ADP and to the alpha subunit in Mg2+-ATP, indicating a significant movement of this subunit. The gamma subunit cross-linked to the beta subunit in higher yield in Mg2+-ATP than in Mg2+-ADP, and when possible, i.e. in the triple mutant, always preferred the interaction with the beta over the alpha subunit.

Characterization of the binding of Fe(III) to F1ATPase from bovine heart mitochondria

The binding Fe(III) to F1ATPase purified from beef heart mitochondria has been characterized by chemical analyses and EPR spectroscopy. F1ATPase binds 2 mol of Fe(III)/mol of protein selectively in the presence of saturating concentrations of ATP. In the absence of nucleotides or in the presence of either saturating ADP or limiting ATP concentrations, the enzyme binds 1 equivalent of Fe(III). F1ATPase pretreated with 5'-p- fluorosulfonylbenzoyladenosine, that selectively modifies the non-catalytic sites, binds only 1 mol of Fe(III)/mol of protein in the presence of either saturating ATP or ADP, Fe(III)-loaded F1ATPase containing either 1 or 2 equivalents of Fe(III) show identical EPR signals at g=4.3. The signals are not perturbed by the binding of nucleotides to the enzyme while they are altered by phosphate addition. These results indicate that F1ATPase contains two distinct Fe(III)-binding sites, which differ from nucleotide-binding sites, and that one of these sites is opened up for Fe(III) uptake by conformational changes induced by binding of ATP to the loose non-catalytic site.

Structural features of the epsilon subunit of the Escherichia coli ATP synthase determined by NMR spectroscopy

The tertiary fold of the epsilon subunit of the Escherichia coli F1F0 ATPsynthase (ECF1F0) has been determined by two- and three-dimensional heteronuclear (13C, 15N) NMR spectroscopy. The epsilon subunit exhibits a distinct two domain structure, with the N-terminal 84 residues of the protein forming a 10-stranded beta-structure, and with the C-terminal 48 amino acids arranged as two alpha-helices running antiparallel to one another (two helix hairpin). The beta-domain folds as a beta-sandwich with a hydrophobic interior between the two layers of the sandwich. The C-terminal two-helix hairpin folds back to the N-terminal domain and interacts with one side of the beta-domain. The arrangement of the epsilon subunit in the intact F1F0 ATP synthase involves interaction of the two helix hairpin with the F1 part, and binding of the open side of the beta-sandwich to the c subunits of the membrane-embedded F0 part.

Alanine-scanning mutagenesis of the epsilon subunit of the F1-F0 ATP synthase from Escherichia coli reveals two classes of mutants

Alanine-scanning mutagenesis was applied to the epsilon subunit of the F1-F0 ATP synthase from E. coli. Nineteen amino acid residues were changed to alanine, either singly or in pairs, between residues 10 and 93. All mutants, when expressed in the epsilon deletion strain XH1, were able to grow on succinate minimal medium. Membranes were prepared from all mutants and assayed for ATP-driven proton translocation, ATP hydrolysis +/- lauryldiethylamine oxide, and sensitivity of ATPase activity to N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD). Most of the mutants fell into 2 distinct classes. The first group had inhibited ATPase activity, with near normal levels of membrane-bound F1, but decreased sensitivity to DCCD. The second group had stimulated ATPase activity, with a reduced level of membrane-bound F1, but normal sensitivity to DCCD. Membranes from all mutants were further characterized by immunoblotting using 2 monoclonal antibodies. A model for the secondary structure of epsilon and its role in the function of the ATP synthase has been developed. Some residues are important for the binding of epsilon to F1 and therefore for inhibition. Other residues, from Glu-59 through Glu-70, are important for the release of inhibition by epsilon that is part of the normal enzyme cycle.

Conformational changes of the mitochondrial F1-ATPase epsilon-subunit induced by nucleotide binding as observed by phosphorescence spectroscopy

Changes in conformation of the epsilon-subunit of the bovine heart mitochondrial F1-ATPase complex as a result of nucleotide binding have been demonstrated from the phosphorescence emission of tryptophan. The triplet state lifetime shows that whereas nucleoside triphosphate binding to the enzyme in the presence of Mg2+ increases the flexibility of the protein structure surrounding the chromophore, nucleoside diphosphate acts in an opposite manner, enhancing the rigidity of this region of the macromolecule. Such changes in dynamic structure of the epsilon-subunit are evident at high ligand concentration added to both the nucleotide-depleted F1 (Nd-F1) and the F1 preparation containing the three tightly bound nucleotides (F1(2,1)). Since the effects observed are similar in both the F1 forms, the binding to the low affinity sites must be responsible for the conformational changes induced in the epsilon-subunit. This is partially supported by the observation that the Trp lifetime is not significantly affected by adding an equimolar concentration of adenine nucleotide to Nd-F1. The effects on protein structure of nucleotide binding to either catalytic or noncatalytic sites have been distinguished by studying the phosphorescence emission of the F1 complex prepared with the three noncatalytic sites filled and the three catalytic sites vacant (F1(3,0)). Phosphorescence lifetime measurements on this F1 form demonstrate that the binding of Mg-NTP to catalytic sites induces a slight enhancement of the rigidity of the epsilon-subunit. This implies that the binding to the vacant noncatalytic site of F1(2,1) must exert the opposite and larger effect of enhancing the flexibility of the protein structure observed in both Nd-F1 and F1(2,1). The observation that enhanced flexibility of the protein occurs upon addition of adenine nucleotides to F1(2,1) in the absence of Mg2+ provides direct support for this suggestion. The connection between changes in structure and the possible functional role of the epsilon-subunit is discussed.

Asymmetry of Escherichia coli F1-ATPase as a function of the interaction of alpha-beta subunit pairs with the gamma and epsilon subunits

The asymmetry of Escherichia coli F1-ATPase (ECF1) has been explored in chemical modification experiments involving two mutant enzyme preparations. One mutant contains a cysteine (Cys) at position 149 of the beta subunit, along with conversion of a Val to Ala at residue 198 to suppress the deleterious effect of the Cys for Gly at 149 mutation (mutant beta G149C:V198A). The second mutant has these mutations and also Cys residues at positions 381 of beta and 108 of the epsilon subunit (mutant beta G149C:V198A:E381C/epsilon S108C). On CuCl2 treatment of this second mutant, there is cross-linking of one copy of the beta subunit to gamma via the Cys at 381, a second to the epsilon subunit (between beta Cys381 and epsilon Cys108), while the third beta subunit in the ECF1 complex is mostly free (some cross-linking to delta); thereby distinguishing the three beta subunits as beta gamma, beta epsilon, and beta free, respectively. Both mutants have ATPase activities similar to wild-type enzyme. Under all nucleotide conditions, including with essentially nucleotide-free enzyme, the three different beta subunits were found to react differently with N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) which reacts with Cys149, dicyclohexyl carbodiimide (DCCD) which reacts with Glu192, and 7-chloro-4-nitrobenzofurazan (NbfCl) which reacts with Tyr297. Thus, beta gamma reacted with DCCD but not NEM or NbfCl; beta free was reactive with all three reagents; beta epsilon reacted with NEM, but was poorly reactive to DCCD or NbfCl. There was a strong nucleotide dependence of the reaction of Cys149 in beta epsilon (but not in beta free) with NEM, indicative of the important role that the epsilon subunit plays in functioning of the enzyme.

The gamma subunit in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase complex (ECF1F0) extends through the stalk and contacts the c subunits of the F0 part

A mutant, in which a cysteine has been site-directed into the polar loop region of the c subunit at residue 44, has been studied. Cross-linking of the c subunit to both the gamma and epsilon subunits was observed with cupric 1,10-phenanthrolinate treatment. The linkage between the c and gamma subunits was localized to that part of the gamma subunit between residues 202-286, based on peptide analysis. Reference to the high resolution structure of F1 [Abrahams et al. (1994) Nature 370, 621-628] appears to limit this contact site to the region including residues 202-230. This segment contains 4 tyrosines and 1 tryptophan as possible reactive residues for cross-linking with the c subunit cysteine.

Arrangement of the epsilon subunit in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase from the reactivity of cysteine residues introduced at different positions in this subunit

ECF1F0 has been purified from three mutants in which a Cys has been incorporated by site-directed mutagenesis in the epsilon subunit: these mutants are epsilon S10C, epsilon H38C and epsilon S108C, respectively. ECF1F0 from the mutant epsilon S10C had a 2-fold higher activity than wild-type enzyme, due to altered association of the epsilon subunit with the rest of the complex, and yet showed normal proton pumping function. The other two mutants had ATPase activities similar to wild-type enzyme. The introduced Cys was exposed for reaction with maleimides in epsilon S10C and epsilon S108C. In epsilon H38C, the introduced Cys reacted readily with N-ethylmaleimide in isolated ECF1, but was unavailable for reaction with this or other maleimides in ECF1F0. When this Cys at position 38 in the epsilon subunit was reacted with various maleimides in isolated ECF1 and then the ECF1 bound back to F0, the interaction between the two parts was perturbed. While ECF1F0 reconstituted with unmodified ECF1 functioned normally, enzyme with maleimide-reacted Cys-38 showed much reduced proton pumping, had only around 50% of the DCCD inhibition of unmodified or wild-type enzyme, and had a much higher LDAO activation (as much as 8.3-fold, c.f. 4-fold for wild type). Nucleotide-dependent conformational changes have been observed previously, in studies of ECF1 from the mutants epsilon S10C and epsilon S108C. Identical nucleotide-dependent structural changes were observed in cross-linking experiments with tetrafluorophenylazide maleimides when the intact ECF1F0 from these mutants was examined. Taken together, the Cys reactivity data and cross-linking results provide the orientation of the epsilon subunit in the enzyme complex.

Disulfide bond formation between the COOH-terminal domain of the beta subunits and the gamma and epsilon subunits of the Escherichia coli F1-ATPase. Structural implications and functional consequences

A set of mutants of the Escherichia coli F1F0-type ATPase has been generated by site-directed mutagenesis as follows: beta E381C, beta S383C, beta E381C/epsilon S108C, and beta S383C/epsilon S108C. Treatment of ECF1 isolated from any of these mutants with CuCl2 induces disulfide bond formation. For the single mutants, beta E381C and beta S383C, a disulfide bond is formed in essentially 100% yield between a beta subunit and the gamma subunit, probably at Cys87 based on the recent structure determination of F1 (Abrahams, J. P., Leslie, A. G. W., Lutter, R., and Walker, J. E. (1994) Nature 370, 621-628). In the double mutants, two disulfide bonds are formed, again in essentially full yield, one between beta and gamma, the other between a beta and the epsilon subunit via Cys108. The same two cross-links are produced with CuCl2 treatment of ECF1F0 isolated from either of the double mutants. These results show that the parts of gamma around residue 87 (a short alpha-helix) and the epsilon subunit interact with different beta subunits. The yield of covalent linkage of beta to gamma is nucleotide dependent and highest in ATP and much lower with ADP in catalytic sites. The yield of covalent linkage of beta to epsilon is also nucleotide dependent but in this case is highest in ADP and much lower in ATP. Disulfide bond formation between either beta and gamma, or beta and epsilon inhibits the ATPase activity of the enzyme in proportion to the yield of the cross-linked product. Chemical modification of the Cys at either position 381 or 383 of the beta subunit inhibits ATPase activity in a manner that appears to be dependent on the size of the modifying reagent. These results are as expected if movements of the catalytic site-containing beta subunits relative to the gamma and epsilon subunits are an essential part of the cooperativity of the enzyme.