Comparison of the kinetic specificity of subtilisin and thiolsubtilisin toward n-alkyl p-nitrophenyl esters

Correlation between catalysis and tertiary structure arrangement in an archaeal halophilic subtilase

Nep (Natrialba magadii extracellular protease) is a halolysin-like peptidase secreted by the haloalkaliphilic archaeon N. magadii that exhibits optimal activity and stability in salt-saturated solutions. In this work, the effect of salt on the function and structure of Nep was investigated. In absence of salt, Nep became unfolded and aggregated, leading to the loss of activity. The enzyme did not recover its structural and functional properties even after restoring the ideal conditions for catalysis. At salt concentrations higher than 1 M (NaCl), Nep behaved as monomers in solution and its enzymatic activity displayed a nonlinear concave-up dependence with salt concentration resulting in a 20-fold activation at 4 M NaCl. Although transition from a high to a low-saline environment (3-1 M NaCl) did not affect its secondary structure contents, it diminished the enzyme stability and provoked large structural rearrangements, changing from an elongated shape at 3 M NaCl to a compact conformational state at 1 M NaCl. The thermodynamic analysis of peptide hydrolysis by Nep suggests a significant enzyme reorganization depending on the environmental salinity, which supports in solution SAXS and DLS studies. Moreover, solvent kinetic isotopic effect (SKIE) data indicates the general acid-base mechanism as the rate-limiting step for Nep catalysis, like classical serine-peptidases. All these data correlate the Nep conformational states with the enzymatic behavior providing a further understanding on the stability and structural determinants for the functioning of halolysins under different salinities.

Cryptic proteolytic activity of dihydrolipoamide dehydrogenase

The mitochondrial enzyme, dihydrolipoamide dehydrogenase (DLD), is essential for energy metabolism across eukaryotes. Here, conditions known to destabilize the DLD homodimer enabled the mouse, pig, or human enzyme to function as a protease. A catalytic dyad (S456-E431) buried at the homodimer interface was identified. Serine protease inhibitors and an S456A or an E431A point mutation abolished the proteolytic activity, whereas other point mutations at the homodimer interface domain enhanced the proteolytic activity, causing partial or complete loss of DLD activity. In humans, mutations in the DLD homodimer interface have been linked to an atypical form of DLD deficiency. These findings reveal a previously unrecognized mechanism by which certain DLD mutations can simultaneously induce the loss of a primary metabolic activity and the gain of a moonlighting proteolytic activity. The latter could contribute to the metabolic derangement associated with DLD deficiency and represent a target for therapies of this condition.

Triggered release of proteins from emulsan–alginate beads

Emulsan/alginate beads were studied for protein adsorption and stability in the context of controlled release. The beads, 400 +/- 80 microm diameter with approximately 10% emulsan content, offer unusual opportunities for delivery of proteins due to the natural ability of emulsan to bind proteins, coupled with the selective biological activation features of this complex lipoheteropolysaccharide. The binding capacity of azo-bovine serum albumin by the emulsan/alginate beads was 0.637 +/- 0.004 vs. 0.170 +/- 0.007 microg/mg for beads formed from alginate alone. In additional protein adsorption experiments, the lipase and subtilisin maintained activity when adsorbed to the emulsan/alginate beads albeit with lower specific activity when compared to the enzyme free in solution. However, the half life of the adsorbed enzyme was significantly higher than the free forms. To explore functional utility of this system, two types of triggered release were studied in the context of these bead systems. First, azo-BSA as a model protein was physically bound to emulsan/alginate beads and then selectively released by triggering with subtilisin, a serine protease, which cleaves the azo dye, sulfanilic acid, from the bound protein. In absence of subtilisin no triggered release was observed. Second, azo-BSA as a prodrug model, was adsorbed to the emulsan/alginate beads and then release of the dye was demonstrated by lipase treatment which cleaves the fatty acid esters from the emulsan structure to release the bound protein. The results establish the versatility and utility of emulsan-based beads for protein binding and triggered release.

Cloning and expression of islandisin, a new thermostable subtilisin from Fervidobacterium islandicum, in Escherichia coli

A gene encoding a subtilisin-like protease, designated islandisin, from the extremely thermophilic bacterium Fervidobacterium islandicum (DSMZ 5733) was cloned and actively expressed in Escherichia coli. The gene was identified by PCR using degenerated primers based on conserved regions around two of the three catalytic residues (Asp, His, and Ser) of subtilisin-like serine protease-encoding genes. Using inverse PCR regions flanking the catalytic residues, the gene could be cloned. Sequencing revealed an open reading frame of 2,106 bp. The deduced amino acid sequence indicated that the enzyme is synthesized as a proenzyme with a putative signal sequence of 33 amino acids (aa) in length. The mature protein contains the three catalytic residues (Asp177, His215, and Ser391) and has a length of 668 aa. Amino acid sequence comparison and phylogenetic analysis indicated that this enzyme could be classified as a subtilisin-like serine protease in the subgroup of thermitase. The whole gene was amplified by PCR, ligated into pET-15b, and successfully expressed in E. coli BL21(DE3)pLysS. The recombinant islandisin was purified by heat denaturation, followed by hydroxyapatite chromatography. The enzyme is active at a broad range of temperatures (60 to 80 degrees C) and pHs (pH 6 to 8.5) and shows optimal proteolytic activity at 80 degrees C and pH 8.0. Islandisin is resistant to a number of detergents and solvents and shows high thermostability over a long period of time (up to 32 h) at 80 degrees C with a half-life of 4 h at 90 degrees C and 1.5 h at 100 degrees C.

Ionisations within a subtilisin-glyoxal inhibitor complex

Z-Ala-Pro-Phe-glyoxal (where Z is benzyloxycarbonyl) has been shown to be a competitive inhibitor of subtilisin with a K(i)=2.3+/-0.2 microM at pH 7.0 and 25 degrees C. Using Z-Ala-Pro-[2-(13)C]Phe-glyoxal we have detected a signal at 107.3 ppm by (13)C NMR, which we assign to the tetrahedral adduct formed between the hydroxy group of serine-195 and the (13)C-enriched keto-carbon of the inhibitor. The chemical shift of this signal is pH independent from pH 4.2 to 7.0 and we conclude that the oxyanion pK(a)<3. This is the first observation of oxyanion formation in a reversible subtilisin-inhibitor complex. The inhibitor is bound as a hemiketal which is in slow exchange with the free inhibitor. Inhibitor binding depends on a pK(a) of approximately 6.5 in the free enzyme and on a pK(a)<3.0 when the inhibitor is bound to subtilisin. Protonation of the oxyanion promotes the disassociation of the inhibitor. We show that oxyanion formation cannot be rate limiting during catalysis and that subtilisin stabilises the oxyanion by at least 45.1 kJ mol(-1). We conclude that if the energy required for oxyanion stabilisation is utilised as binding energy in drug design it should make a significant contribution to inhibitor potency.

Thiolsubtilisin acts as an acetyltransferase in organic solvents

The catalytic mechanism of arylamine N-acetyltransferase has been proposed to involve Cys-His-Asp as its catalytic triad. Thiolsubtilisin, a chemically modified enzyme that has a catalytic triad of Cys-His-Asp at the active site, mimics the catalysis of arylamine N-acetyltransferase, serotonin N-acetyltransferase, histone N-acetyltransferase and amino acid N-acetyltransferase. Thiolsubtilisin not only can catalyze amino acid transacetylation, but is also able to catalyze amine transacetylation. Ethyl acetate was used as the acylating reagent to form N-acetyl amino acids and amines in organic solvents with moderate yield. Hence, these findings broaden our understanding of the structural features required for N-acetyltransferases activity as well as provide a structural relationship between cysteine protease and other N-acyltransferases.

Protein engineering of subtilisin

The serine protease subtilisin is an important industrial enzyme as well as a model for understanding the enormous rate enhancements affected by enzymes. For these reasons along with the timely cloning of the gene, ease of expression and purification and availability of atomic resolution structures, subtilisin became a model system for protein engineering studies in the 1980s. Fifteen years later, mutations in well over 50% of the 275 amino acids of subtilisin have been reported in the scientific literature. Most subtilisin engineering has involved catalytic amino acids, substrate binding regions and stabilizing mutations. Stability has been the property of subtilisin which has been most amenable to enhancement, yet perhaps least understood. This review will give a brief overview of the subtilisin engineering field, critically review what has been learned about subtilisin stability from protein engineering experiments and conclude with some speculation about the prospects for future subtilisin engineering.

Human mitochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase substrate specificity: comparison of esterase with dehydrogenase reaction

Substrate specificity of human mitochondrial low Km aldehyde dehydrogenase (EC 1.2.1.3) E2 isozyme has been investigated employing p-nitrophenyl esters of acyl groups of two to six carbon atoms and comparing with that of aldehydes of one to eight carbon atoms. The esterase reaction was studied under three conditions: in the absence of coenzyme, in the presence of NAD (1 mM), and in the presence of NADH (160 microM). The maximal velocity of the esterase reaction with p-nitrophenyl acetate and propionate as substrates in the presence of NAD was 3.9-4.7 times faster than that of the dehydrogenase reaction. Under all other conditions the velocities of dehydrogenase and esterase reactions were similar; the lowest kcat was for p-nitrophenyl butyrate in the presence of NAD. Stimulation of esterase activity by coenzymes was confined to esters of short acyl chain length; with longer acyl chain lengths or increased bulkiness (p-nitrophenyl guanidinobenzoate) no effect or even inhibition was observed. Comparison of kinetic constants for esters demonstrates that p-nitrophenyl butyrate is the worst substrate of all esters tested, suggesting that the active site topography is uniquely unfavorable for p-nitrophenyl butyrate. This fact is, however, not reflected in kinetic constants for butyraldehyde, which is a good substrate. The substrate specificity profile as determined by comparison of kcat/Km ratios was found to be quite different for aldehydes and esters. For aldehydes kcat/Km ratios increased with the increase of chain length; with esters under all three conditions, a V-shaped curve was produced with a minimum at p-nitrophenyl butyrate.

A chromogenic substrate for phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C: 4-nitrophenyl myo-inositol-1-phosphate

A chromogenic water-soluble substrate for phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C was synthesized starting from myo-inositol employing isopropylidene and 4-methoxytetrahydropyranyl protecting groups. In this analogue of phosphatidylinositol, 4-nitrophenol replaces the diacylglycerol moiety, resulting in synthetic, racemic 4-nitrophenyl myo-inositol-1-phosphate. Using this synthetic substrate a rapid, convenient and sensitive spectrophotometric assay for the phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C from Bacillus cereus was developed. Initial rates of the cleavage of the nitrophenol substrate were linear with time and the amount of enzyme used. At pH 7.0, specific activities for the B. cereus enzyme were 77 and 150 mumol substrate cleaved min-1 (mg protein)-1 at substrate concentrations of 1 and 2 mM, respectively. Under these conditions, less than 50 ng quantities of enzyme were easily detected. The chromogenic substrate was stable during long term storage (6 months) as a solid at -20 degrees C.

Crystal structure of rat trypsin-S195C at -150 degrees C. Analysis of low activity of recombinant and semisynthetic thiol proteases

The X-ray crystal structure of trypsin-S195C, a rat anionic trypsin mutant in which the active site serine has been replaced by cysteine, was determined at -150 degrees C and room temperature to 1.6 A resolution, R = 15.4% and 1.8 A resolution, R = 15.0%, respectively. Cryo-crystallography was employed to improve the quality of the diffraction data and the resulting structure by eliminating radiation damage and decreasing atomic thermal motion. The average temperature factor decreased by 10 A2 relative to that of the room temperature structure. No radiation-induced decay of the data was detected. The side-chains of the catalytic cysteine and histidine of trypsin-S195C are found with 25% occupancy in secondary orientations rotated 104 degrees and 90 degrees out of the active site, respectively. These alterations, as well as more subtle changes in the active site may be caused by the oxidation of the catalytic sulfur to sulfenic acid. The position of the carbonyl carbon of the tetrahedral intermediate analog, p-amidinophenylpyruvic acid, modeled into trypsin-S195C, is 1.1 A from the catalytic sulfur. The large size and altered approach of the catalytic sulfur to substrates could account for the observed low catalytic activity relative to wild-type trypsin. In addition to the benzamidine in the specificity pocket, two additional binding sites for benzamidine are characterized. One of these mediates an intermolecular contact that appears to maintain the crystal lattice.

Chemical modification of the RTEM-1 thiol beta-lactamase by thiol-selective reagents: evidence for activation of the primary nucleophile of the beta-lactamase active site by adjacent functional groups

The RTEM-1 thiol beta-lactamase (Sigal, I.S., Harwood, B.G., Arentzen, R., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 79:7157-7160, 1982) is inactivated by thiol-selective reagents such as iodoacetamide, methyl methanethiosulfonate, and 4,4'-dipyridyldisulfide, which modify the active site thiol group. The pH-rate profiles of these inactivation reactions show that there are two nucleophilic forms of the enzyme, EH2 and EH, both of which, by analogy with the situation with cysteine proteinases, probably contain the active site nucleophile in the thiolate form. The pKa of the active site thiol is therefore shown by the data to be below 4.0. This low pKa is thought to reflect the presence of adjacent functionality which stabilizes the thiolate anion. The low nucleophilicity of the thiolate in both EH2 and EH, with respect to that of cysteine proteinases and model compounds, suggests that the thiolate of the thiol beta-lactamase is stabilized by two hydrogen-bond donors. One of these, of pKa greater than 9.0, is suggested to be the conserved and essential Lys-73 ammonium group, while the identity of the other group, of pKa around 6.7, is less clear, but may be the conserved Glu-166 carboxylic acid. beta-Lactamase activity is associated with the EH2 form, and thus the beta-lactamase active site is proposed to contain one basic or nucleophilic group (the thiolate in the thiol beta-lactamase) and two acidic (hydrogen-bond donor) groups (one of which is likely to be the above-mentioned lysine ammonium group).

Inactivation of the thiol RTEM-1 beta-lactamase by 6-beta-bromopenicillanic acid. Identity of the primary active-site nucleophile

The thiol RTEM-1 beta-lactamase [Sigal, Harwood & Arentzen (1982) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 79, 7157-7160] is inactivated by 6-beta-bromopenicillanic acid with formation of a characteristic chromophore, absorbing maximally at 350 nm, which is covalently bound to the enzyme. Model studies suggest that the chromophore is that of a 6-carboxylate thiol ester of 2,3-dihydro-2,2-dimethyl-1,4-thiazine-3,6-dicarboxylate, which can arise by rearrangement of the thiol-penicilloate obtained by thiolysis of the beta-lactam of 6-beta-bromopenicillanate. Loss of activity of the enzyme is also concerted with disappearance of its single (cysteine) thiol group. These results indicate that the thiol group of this enzyme is indeed a nucleophilic catalyst in beta-lactam turnover. The thiol beta-lactamase is also inactivated by clavulanic acid with formation of a chromophore, presumably a 3-aminoacrylate thiol ester, at 308 nm. Both 6-beta-bromopenicillanate and clavulanate are hydrolysed more slowly by the thiol enzyme than by the native serine beta-lactamase, but, probably as a consequence of this, both compounds inactivate the former enzyme more efficiently. Cefoxitin, a poor substrate of the native enzyme, does not appear to interact covalently with the thiol beta-lactamase.

Electrostatic effects on modification of charged groups in the active site cleft of subtilisin by protein engineering

The dielectric constant in the active site cleft of subtilisin from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens has been probed by mutating charged residues on the rim and measuring the effect on the pKa value of the active site histidine (His64) by kinetics. Mutation of a negatively charged surface residue, which is 12 to 13 A from His64, to an uncharged one Asp----Ser99) lowers the pKa of the histidine by up to 0.4 unit at low ionic strength (0.005 to 0.01 M). This corresponds to an apparent dielectric constant of about 40 to 50 between Asp99 and His64. The mutation is in an external loop that is known to tolerate a serine at position 99 from homologies with subtilisins from other bacilli. The environment between His64 and Asp99 is predominantly protein. Another charged residue that is at a similar distance from His64 (14 to 15 A) and is also in an external loop that is known to tolerate a serine residue is Glu156, at the opposite side of the active site. There is only water in a direct line between His64 and Glu156. Mutation of Glu----Ser156 also lowers the pKa of His64 by up to 0.4 unit at low ionic strength. This change again corresponds to an apparent dielectric constant of about 40 to 50. The pKa values were determined from the pH dependence of kcat/KM for the hydrolysis of peptide substrates, with a precision of typically +/- 0.02 unit. The following suggests that the changes in pKa are real and not artefacts of experimental conditions: Hill plots of the data for pKa determination have gradients (h) of -1.00(+/- 0.02), showing that there are negligible systematic deviations from theoretical ionization curves involving a monobasic acid: the pH dependence for the hydrolysis of two different substrates (succinyl-L-alanyl-L-alanyl-L-prolyl-L-phenylalanyl p-nitroanilide and benzoyl-L-valyl-L-glycyl-L-arginyl p-nitroanilide) gives identical results so that the pKa is independent of substrate; the pH dependence is unaffected by changing the concentration of enzyme, so that aggregation is not affecting the results; the shift in pKa is masked by high ionic strength, as expected qualitatively for ionic shielding of electrostatic interactions.

Kinetics of subtilisin and thiolsubtilisin

Subtilisin is a bacterial serine protease with a broad specificity in the S1 subsite. It has been very extensively studied using a variety of kinetic and physical techniques. A chemical derivative, thiolsubtilisin, has been subjected to similar studies in order to analyze the effects of the OH to SH conversion on enzyme activity. The native structure of thiolsubtilisin is indicated by a variety of physical techniques. Oligopeptides bind nearly equally well to both enzymes, and a peptide chloromethylketone is much more reactive to thiolsubtilisin than to subtilisin. Both enzymes have a similar level of activity towards activated nonspecific amides and esters. However, thiolsubtilisin is inactive towards highly specific peptide amides and esters. Thiolsubtilisin also does not show good binding to boronic and arsonic acids. The observation that these transition state analog inhibitors bind poorly to thiolsubtilisin while other compounds bind nearly equally well to both enzymes suggests that thiolsubtilisin may not be able to stabilize the transition state during acylation by specific substrates.

A factor X-activating cysteine protease from malignant tissue

A proteolytic procoagulant has been identified in extracts of human and animal tumors and in cultured malignant cells. It directly activated Factor X but its similarity to other Factor S-activating serine proteases was not clear. This study describes work done to determine whether this enzyme, cancer procoagulant, is a serine or cysteine protease. Purified cancer procoagulant from rabbit V2 carcinoma was bound to a p-chloromercurialbenzoate-agarose affinity column and was eluted with dithiothreitol. The initiation of recalcified, citrated plasma coagulation activity by cancer procoagulant was inhibited by 5 mM diisopropylfluorophosphate, 1 mM phenylmethylsulfonylfluoride, 0.1 mM HgCl2, and 1 mM iodoacetamide. Activity was restored in the diisopropylfluorophosphate-, phenylmethylsulfonylfluoride-, and HgCl2-inhibited samples by 5 mM dithiothreitol; iodoacetamide inhibition was irreversible. Russell's viper venom, a control Factor X-activating serine protease, was not inhibited by either 0.1 mM HgCl2 or 1 mM iodoacetamide. The direct activation of Factor X by cancer procoagulant in a two-stage assay was inhibited by diisopropylfluorophosphate and iodoacetamide. Diisopropylfluorophosphate inhibits serine proteases, and an undefined impurity in most commercial preparations inhibits cysteine proteases. Hydrolysis of diisopropylfluorophosphate with CuSO4 and imidazole virtually eliminated inhibition of thrombin, but cancer procoagulant inhibition remained complete, suggesting that cancer procoagulant was inhibited by the undefined impurity. These results suggest that cancer procoagulant is a cysteine endopeptidase, which distinguishes it from other coagulation factors including tissue factor. This and other data suggest that neoplastic cells produce this unique cysteine protease which may initiate blood coagulation.

On the inactivity of thiol-subtilisin

Based on computed proton affinities for several model systems, the energetics of proton transfer and the acidity of the catalytic triads Cys-His-Asn (papain). Cys-His-Asp (thiol-subtilisin) and Ser-His-Asp (subtilisin) are discussed. It is shown that in papain the ion-pair Cys--HisH+ exists owing to the intramolecular electric field, and that a similar situation is found in thiol-subtilisin. but not in subtilisin. Assuming similar reaction mechanisms for papain and thiol-subtilisin - i.e. proton transfer from HisH+ to the NH group of the scissile peptide bond - the inactivity of thil-subtilisin towards proteins is explained by the much greater basicity of His in the complex His-Asp- than in His-Asn. In order for this explanation to be consistent, it is tentatively concluded that the catalytic mechanism of the serine proteases is different from that of the cystein proteases, and involves direct transfer of the serine proton to the leaving group in the acylation step.

Evidence that the lack of high catalytic activity of thiolsubtilisin towards specific substrates may be due to an inappropriately located proton-distribution system. Demonstration of highly nucleophilic character of the thiol group of thiolsubtilisin in the catalytically relevant ionization state of the active centre by use of a two-protonic-state reactivity probe

The active centre of the semi-synthetic enzyme thiolsubtilisin was investigated by studying the kinetics of the reaction of the thiol group of cysteine-221 with the thiol-specific two-protonic-state reactivity probe 2,2'-dipyridyl disulphide. The three-states criterion [Brocklehurst (1974) Tetrahedron 30, 2397-2407] was used to provide definitive evidence of the existence of a thiol--imidazole interactive system in acidic media in which the sulphur atom possesses highly nucleophilic character. The lack of catalytic competence of thiolsubtilisin despite its possession of the requisite nucleophilic capability is discussed. The exceedingly high rate of reaction of thiolsubtilisin with 2,2'-dipyridyl disulphide at pH 4--5 is shown to constitute a rapid and convenient active-site titration in which intact thiol--imidazole interaction is detected even in the presence of other thiols.