Interaction between the erythromycin and chloramphenicol binding sites on the Escherichica coli ribosome

Antimicrobial macrozones interact with biological macromolecules via two-site binding mode of action: Fluorimetric, NMR and docking studies

Macrozones are novel conjugates of azithromycin and thiosemicarbazones, which exhibit very good in vitro antibacterial activities against susceptible and some resistant bacterial strains thus showing a potential for further development. A combination of spectrometric (fluorimetry, STD and WaterLOGSY NMR) and molecular docking studies provided insights into atomic details of interactions between selected macrozones and biological receptors such as E. coli ribosome and bovine serum albumin. Fluorimetric measurements revealed binding constants in the micro-molar range while NMR experiments provided data on binding epitopes. It has been demonstrated that both STD and WaterLOGSY gave comparable and consistent results unveiling atoms in intimate contacts with biological receptors. Docking studies pointed towards main interactions between macrozones and E. coli ribosome which included specific π - π stacking and hydrogen bonding interactions with thiosemicarbazone part extending down the ribosome exit tunnel. The results of the docking experiments were in fine correlation with those obtained by NMR and fluorimetry. Our investigation pointed towards a two-site binding mechanism of interactions between macrozones and E. coli ribosome which is the most probable reason for their activity against azithromycin-resistant strains. Much better activity of macrozone-nickel coordinated compound against E. coli ribosome compared to other macrozones has been attributed to the higher polarity which enabled better bacterial membrane penetration and binding of the two thiosemicarbazone units thus additionally contributing to the overall binding energy. The knowledge gained in this study should play an important role in anti-infective macrolide design in the future.

Fluorescent macrolide probes - synthesis and use in evaluation of bacterial resistance

The emerging crisis of antibiotic resistance requires a multi-pronged approach in order to avert the onset of a post-antibiotic age. Studies of antibiotic uptake and localisation in live cells may inform the design of improved drugs and help develop a better understanding of bacterial resistance and persistence. To facilitate this research, we have synthesised fluorescent derivatives of the macrolide antibiotic erythromycin. These analogues exhibit a similar spectrum of antibiotic activity to the parent drug and are capable of labelling both Gram-positive and -negative bacteria for microscopy. The probes localise intracellularly, with uptake in Gram-negative bacteria dependent on the level of efflux pump activity. A plate-based assay established to quantify bacterial labelling and localisation demonstrated that the probes were taken up by both susceptible and resistant bacteria. Significant intra-strain and -species differences were observed in these preliminary studies. In order to examine uptake in real-time, the probe was used in single-cell microfluidic microscopy, revealing previously unseen heterogeneity of uptake in populations of susceptible bacteria. These studies illustrate the potential of fluorescent macrolide probes to characterise and explore drug uptake and efflux in bacteria.

Macrolide fluorescent probes illuminate the interactions between antibiotics and bacteria, providing new insight into mechanisms of resistance.

From Differential Stains to Next Generation Physiology: Chemical Probes to Visualize Bacterial Cell Structure and Physiology

Chemical probes have been instrumental in microbiology since its birth as a discipline in the 19th century when chemical dyes were used to visualize structural features of bacterial cells for the first time. In this review article we will illustrate the evolving design of chemical probes in modern chemical biology and their diverse applications in bacterial imaging and phenotypic analysis. We will introduce and discuss a variety of different probe types including fluorogenic substrates and activity-based probes that visualize metabolic and specific enzyme activities, metabolic labeling strategies to visualize structural features of bacterial cells, antibiotic-based probes as well as fluorescent conjugates to probe biomolecular uptake pathways.

Fluorescent Antibiotics: New Research Tools to Fight Antibiotic Resistance

Better understanding how multidrug-resistant (MDR) bacteria can evade current and novel antibiotics requires a better understanding of the chemical biology of antibiotic action. This necessitates using new tools and techniques to advance our knowledge of bacterial responses to antibiotics, ideally in live cells in real time, to selectively investigate bacterial growth, division, metabolism, and resistance in response to antibiotic challenge. In this review, we discuss the preparation and biological evaluation of fluorescent antibiotics, focussing on how these reporters and assay methods can help elucidate resistance mechanisms. We also examine the potential utility of such probes for real-time in vivo diagnosis of infections.

New Fluorescent Macrolide Derivatives for Studying Interactions of Antibiotics and Their Analogs with the Ribosomal Exit Tunnel

Novel fluorescent derivatives of macrolide antibiotics related to tylosin bearing rhodamine, fluorescein, Alexa Fluor 488, BODIPY FL, and nitrobenzoxadiazole (NBD) residues were synthesized. The formation of complexes of these compounds with 70S E. coli ribosomes was studied by measuring the fluorescence polarization depending on the ribosome amount at constant concentration of the fluorescent substance. With the synthesized fluorescent tylosin derivatives, the dissociation constants for ribosome complexes with several known antibiotics and macrolide analogs previously obtained were determined. It was found that the fluorescent tylosin derivatives containing BODIPY FL and NBD groups could be used to screen the binding of novel antibiotics to bacterial ribosomes in the macrolide-binding site.

Mechanism-independent method for predicting response to multidrug combinations in bacteria

Drugs are commonly used in combinations larger than two for treating bacterial infection. However, it is generally impossible to infer directly from the effects of individual drugs the net effect of a multidrug combination. Here we develop a mechanism-independent method for predicting the microbial growth response to combinations of more than two drugs. Performing experiments in both Gram-negative (Escherichia coli) and Gram-positive (Staphylococcus aureus) bacteria, we demonstrate that for a wide range of drugs, the bacterial responses to drug pairs are sufficient to infer the effects of larger drug combinations. To experimentally establish the broad applicability of the method, we use drug combinations comprising protein synthesis inhibitors (macrolides, aminoglycosides, tetracyclines, lincosamides, and chloramphenicol), DNA synthesis inhibitors (fluoroquinolones and quinolones), folic acid synthesis inhibitors (sulfonamides and diaminopyrimidines), cell wall synthesis inhibitors, polypeptide antibiotics, preservatives, and analgesics. Moreover, we show that the microbial responses to these drug combinations can be predicted using a simple formula that should be widely applicable in pharmacology. These findings offer a powerful, readily accessible method for the rational design of candidate therapies using combinations of more than two drugs. In addition, the accurate predictions of this framework raise the question of whether the multidrug response in bacteria obeys statistical, rather than chemical, laws for combinations larger than two.

Design, synthesis, and biological evaluation of BODIPY®–erythromycin probes for bacterial ribosomes

BODIPY-erythromycin probes of bacterial ribosomes were designed and synthesized by attaching a BODIPY fluorophore to the 4''- and 9-positions of the erythromycin structure. The probes exhibited excellent binding affinity to bacterial ribosomes and competed with erythromycin and other drugs whose binding sites are in the same vicinity of the 50S subunit. The synthetic fluorescent probe 5 was successfully adapted in our ultra high-throughput screening (uHTS) to identify novel ribosome inhibitors.

Fluorescence polarization method to characterize macrolide-ribosome interactions

A fluorescence polarization assay is described that measures the binding of fluorescently labeled erythromycin to 70S ribosomes from Escherichia coli and the displacement of the erythromycin from these ribosomes. The assay has been validated with several macrolide derivatives and other known antibiotics. We demonstrate that this assay is suitable for determining the dissociation constants of novel compounds that have binding sites overlapping those of macrolides. This homogeneous binding assay provides a valuable tool for defining structure-activity relationships among compounds during the discovery and development of new ribosome-targeting drugs.

Effect of polyamines on the inhibition of peptidyltransferase by antibiotics: revisiting the mechanism of chloramphenicol action

Chloramphenicol is thought to interfere competitively with the binding of the aminoacyl-tRNA 3'-terminus to ribosomal A-site. However, noncompetitive or mixed-noncompetitive inhibition, often observed to be dependent on chloramphenicol concentration and ionic conditions, leaves some doubt about the precise mode of action. Here, we examine further the inhibition effect of chloramphenicol, using a model system derived from Escherichia coli in which a peptide bond is formed between puromycin and AcPhe-tRNA bound at the P-site of poly(U)-programmed ribosomes, under ionic conditions (6 mM Mg2+, 100 mM NH4+, 100 microM spermine) more closely resembling the physiological status. Kinetics reveal that chloramphenicol (I) reacts rapidly with AcPhe-tRNA.poly(U).70S ribosomal complex (C) to form the encounter complex CI which is then isomerized slowly to a more tight complex, C*I. A similar inhibition pattern is observed, if complex C modified by a photoreactive analogue of spermine, reacts in buffer free of spermine. Spermine, either reversibly interacting with or covalently attached to ribosomes, enhances the peptidyltransferase activity and increases the chloramphenicol potency, without affecting the isomerization step. As indicated by photoaffinity labeling, the peptidyltransferase center at which chloramphenicol binds, is one of the preferred cross-linking sites for polyamines. This fact may explain the effect of spermine on chloramphenicol binding to ribosomes.

Structures of five antibiotics bound at the peptidyl transferase center of the large ribosomal subunit

Structures of anisomycin, chloramphenicol, sparsomycin, blasticidin S, and virginiamycin M bound to the large ribosomal subunit of Haloarcula marismortui have been determined at 3.0A resolution. Most of these antibiotics bind to sites that overlap those of either peptidyl-tRNA or aminoacyl-tRNA, consistent with their functioning as competitive inhibitors of peptide bond formation. Two hydrophobic crevices, one at the peptidyl transferase center and the other at the entrance to the peptide exit tunnel play roles in binding these antibiotics. Midway between these crevices, nucleotide A2103 of H.marismortui (2062 Escherichia coli) varies in its conformation and thereby contacts antibiotics bound at either crevice. The aromatic ring of anisomycin binds to the active-site hydrophobic crevice, as does the aromatic ring of puromycin, while the aromatic ring of chloramphenicol binds to the exit tunnel hydrophobic crevice. Sparsomycin contacts primarily a P-site bound substrate, but also extends into the active-site hydrophobic crevice. Virginiamycin M occupies portions of both the A and P-site, and induces a conformational change in the ribosome. Blasticidin S base-pairs with the P-loop and thereby mimics C74 and C75 of a P-site bound tRNA.

Kinetic study of irreversible inhibition of an enzyme consumed in the reaction it catalyses. Application to the inhibition of the puromycin reaction by spiramycin and hydroxylamine

A systematic procedure for the kinetic study of irreversible inhibition when the enzyme is consumed in the reaction which it catalyses, has been developed and analysed. Whereas in most reactions the enzymes are regenerated after each catalytic event and serve as reusable transacting effectors, in the consumed enzymes each catalytic center participates only once and there is no enzyme turnover. A systematic kinetic analysis of irreversible inhibition of these enzyme reactions is presented. Based on the algebraic criteria proposed in this work, it should be possible to evaluate either the mechanism of inhibition (complexing or non-complexing), or the type of inhibition (competitive, non-competitive, uncompetitive, mixed non-competitive). In addition, all kinetic constants involved in each case could be calculated. An experimental application of this analysis is also presented, concerning peptide bond formation in vitro. Using the puromycin reaction, which is a model reaction for the study of peptide bond formation in vitro and which follows the same kinetic law as the enzymes under study, we have found that: (i) the antibiotic spiramycin inhibits the puromycin reaction as a competitive irreversible inhibitor in a one step mechanism with an association rate constant equal to 1.3 x 10(4) M-1 s-1 and, (ii) hydroxylamine inhibits the same reaction as an irreversible non-competitive inhibitor also in a one step mechanism with a rate constant equal to 1.6 x 10(-3) M-1 s-1.

Aminoacyl and peptidyl analogs of chloramphenicol as slow-binding inhibitors of ribosomal peptidyltransferase: a new approach for evaluating their potency

In a model system derived from Escherichia coli, acetylphenylalanyl-puromycin is produced in a pseudo-first-order reaction between the preformed acetylphenylalanyl/tRNA/poly(U)/ribosome complex (complex C) and excess puromycin. Two aminoacyl analogs [3, Gly-chloramphenicol (CAM): 4, L-Phe-CAM] and two peptidyl analogs (2, L-Phe-Gly-CAM: 5, Gly-Phe-CAM) of CAM (1) were tested as inhibitors in this reaction. Detailed kinetic analysis suggests that these analogs (I) react competitively with complex C and form the complex C*l, which is inactive toward puromycin. C*l is formed via a two-step mechanism in which C*l is the product of a slow conformational change of the initial encounter complex Cl according to the equation C + l reversible Cl reversible C*l. Furthermore, we provide evidence that analog 5 may react further with C*l forming the species C*l2. The values of the apparent association rate constant (K(assoc)) are 1.42 x microM-1 min-1 for 2, 0.55 x microM-1 min-1 for 3, and 0.18 x microM-1 min-1 for 4 and 0.038 x microM-1 min-1 for 5 [corrected]. In the case of analog 5, K(assoc) is a linear function of the inhibitor concentration; when [I] approaches zero, the K(assoc) value is equal to 3.8 x 10(2) M-1 sec-1. Such values allow the classification of CAM analogs as slow-binding inhibitors. According to K(assoc) values, we could surmise that analog 2 is 2.5-fold more potent than 3 and 8-fold more potent than 4. The relative potency of analog 5 is the lowest among the analogs and is dependent on its concentration. The results are compared with previous data and discussed on the basis of a possible retro-inverso relationship between CAM analogs and puromycin.

Role of protonated and neutral forms of macrolides in binding to ribosomes from gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria

Erythromycin binds to a single site on the bacterial 50S ribosomal subunit and perturbs protein synthesis. However, erythromycin contains desosamine and thus exists in both protonated (greater than 96%) and neutral (less than 4%) forms at physiological pH because of the pKa of the dimethylamino group. We therefore examined the relative roles of both forms in binding to ribosomes isolated from two species each of gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria. We developed a system to directly measure the forward (association) rate constant of formation of the macrolide-ribosome complex, and we have measured both the forward and reverse (dissociation) rate constants as a function of pH. Forward rate constants and binding affinity did not correlate with pH when the interaction of erythromycin with ribosomes from both gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria was examined, demonstrating that the protonated form of this macrolide binds to ribosomes. Conversely, the neutral form of macrolide cannot be the sole binding species and appears to bind with the same kinetics as the protonated form. Forward rate constants were 3- to 4-fold greater at physiological pH, and binding affinity calculated from rate constants was 5- to 10-fold greater than previously estimated. Similar results were obtained with azithromycin, a novel 15-membered macrolide that contains an additional tertiary amine in the macrolide ring. Ribosome- and macrolide-specific kinetic parameters were demonstrated at neutral pH and may be related to the potency of the two macrolides against gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria.

Binding of novel macrolide structures to macrolides-lincosamides-streptogramin B-resistant ribosomes inhibits protein synthesis and bacterial growth

Dimethylation of adenine 2058 in 23S rRNA renders bacteria resistant to macrolides, lincosamides, and streptogramin B (MLS resistance), because the antibiotic binding site on the altered 50S ribosomal subunit is no longer accessible. We now report that certain 6-O-methyl-11,12-cyclic carbamate derivatives of erythromycin are able to bind to dimethylated MLS-resistant 50S ribosomal subunits, thus inhibiting protein synthesis and cell growth. One of these novel structures, an 11-deoxy-11-(carboxyamino)-6-O-methylerythromycin A 11,12-(cyclic ester) derivative, structure 1a, was studied in detail. It inhibited in vitro protein synthesis in extracts prepared from both susceptible and MLS-resistant Bacillus subtilis with 50% inhibitory concentrations of 0.4 and 20 microM, respectively. The derivative bound specifically to a single site on the 50S subunit of MLS-resistant ribosomes prepared from B. subtilis and Staphylococcus aureus, and no binding to 30S subunits was observed. The association rate constant of derivative 1a with sensitive and resistant ribosomes was 100- and 500-fold slower, respectively, than that of the parent compound, erythromycin, with sensitive ribosomes. The dissociation rate constant of 1a from sensitive and resistant ribosomes was 50- to 100-fold slower than the rate of erythromycin dissociation from sensitive ribosomes. Furthermore, 1a binding to sensitive 50S subunits led to induction of ermC and ermD, while binding to resistant 50S subunits did not, showing that perturbation of sensitive and resistant 50S subunit function by 1a differs. These data demonstrated that 1a is unique in its interaction with MLS-resistant ribosomes and that this interaction causes a novel allosteric perturbation of ribosome function.

Ribosome structure: binding site of macrolides studied by photoaffinity labeling

The macrolide antibiotics carbomycin A, niddamycin, and tylosin have been radioactively labeled by reducing their aldehyde group at the C-18 position. Dihydro derivatives with specific activities around 2.5 Ci/mmol can be obtained that, although partially affected in their activity, still bind to the ribosomes with high affinity. The presence in the chemical structure of these antibiotics of alpha-beta-unsaturated ketone groups makes them photochemically reactive, and by irradiation above 300 nm, covalent incorporation of the radioactive dihydro derivatives into ribosomes has been achieved. The covalent binding seems to take place at the specific binding sites for macrolides as deduced from binding saturation studies and competition experiments with unmodified drugs. Analysis of the ribosomal components labeled by the drugs indicated that most radioactivity is associated with the proteins L27, L2, and L28 when 50S subunits are labeled, and with L27, L2, L32/33, S9, and S12 in the case of 70S ribosomes. These results agree well with a model of macrolides' mode of action that assumes an interaction of the drug at the peptidyl transferase P site that would block the exit channel for the growing peptide chain.

Effect of P and A site substrates on the binding of a macrolide to ribosomes. Analysis of the puromycin-induced stimulation

The puromycin-induced stimulation of [3H]dihydrorosaramicin binding is due to a twofold increase in affinity of the macrolide antibiotic, with no change in the number of binding sites. Conversely, the binding of [3H]puromycin (A site) is stimulated by rosaramicin. The synergistic effect observed between the two antibiotics can be explained by a conformational change with positive effect, which occurs at the level of their binding sites. Various effectors of [3H]dihydrorosaramicin binding have been tested. Adenosine and dimethyladenosine stimulate the binding; phenylalanine, uridine and gougerotin (A site) have no effect whereas AMP, ADP, ATP, GTP, puromycin 5'-phosphate and lincomycin (P site) are inhibitors. These results point to the importance of the purine moiety in the stimulatory effect and of the phosphate function in reversing this effect. It is concluded that rosaramicin binds to the ribosomal P site and that the synergism observed between rosaramicin and puromycin may be related to interactions between the A and P sites.

Mode of action of bottromycin A2: effect of bottromycin A2 on polysomes

When bottromycin A2 was added to an in vitro protein synthesis system carried out by naturally occurring polysomes, it inhibited protein synthesis effectively. Examination of the 3 steps of peptide chain elongation revealed that the binding of aminoacyl-tRNA to the polyribosomes was inhibited by bottromycin A2. In contrast, we concluded that the peptide bond formation and the translocation steps in this system were not inhibited by bottromycin A2 on the basis of the following observations: (1) The break-down of polysomes, which is dependent on EFG, puromycin and RR (ribosome releasing) factor, was insensitive to bottromycin A2; (2) The puromycin dependent release of polypeptide from polysomes, with or without EFG, was not inhibited by bottromycin A2. Thus bottromycin specifically interferes with proper functioning of the A sites of polysomes. This is consistent with the results obtained using the model system with synthetic polynucleotides.

Competition between erythromycin and virginiamycin for in vitro binding to the large ribosomal subunit

When the S component of virginiamycin binds in vitro to the 50 S ribosomal subunit, a change of fluorescence intensity proportional to the amount of complex formed occurs. Erythromycin competes with virginiamycin S for attachment to ribosomes, and removes previously bound virginiamycin S from its target, as revealed by spectrofluorimetric analysis. The 50 S subunits which are incubated with the M component of virginiamycin (50 S*) have an increased affinity for virginiamycin S (the association constants of virginiamycin S with ribosomes are 2.5 x 10(6) M-1 in the absence of virginiamycin M, and 15 x 10(6) M-1 in its presence). Erythromycin does not compete with virginiamycin S for attachment to 50 S* subunits nor is it able to remove virginiamycin S previously bound to the 50 S* subunit. Thus, virginiamycin M produces a change in ribosomes, which results in a tighter complex virginiamycin S-50 S* subunit. Such change does not require the presence of virginiamycin M, however, as shown by the observation that ribosomes to which labeled virginiamycin M is transiently linked bind virginiamycin S in a form that cannot be removed by erythromycin.

Effects of erythromycin on membrane-bound chloroplast ribosomes from wild-type Chlamydomonas reinhardi and erythromycin-resistant mutants

1. Treatment of wild-type cells of Chlamydomonas reinhardi with high concentrations of erythromycin results in increased recovery of membrane-bound chloroplast ribosomes, presumably by preventing polysomal runoff during harvesting of cells. No such membrane-retention effect is detected if erythromycin is added after harvesting of cultures, before cell breakage. 2. Growth of wild-type cells is inhibited by 10 microgram/ml erythromycin, but a concentration twice as high is required to increase recovery of membrane-bound wild-type ribosomes. On the other hand, the concentrations of erythromycin which inhibit growth of mutant ery-M1b produce a membrane-retention effect. Mutant ery-U1a is resistant to high concentrations of erythromycin and no membrane-retention effect is detectable at concentrations which produce one in wild type and ery-M1b. 3. These results can be reconciled by a two-point model of the mechanism of erythromycin action on chloroplast ribosomes in Chlamydomonas.