Thermodynamics and kinetics of adaptive binding in the malachite green RNA aptamer

Impact of Chemical Dynamics of Commercial PURE Systems on Malachite Green Aptamer Fluorescence

The malachite green aptamer (MGapt) is known for its utility in RNA measurement in vivo and in lysate-based cell-free protein systems. However, MGapt fluorescence dynamics do not accurately reflect RNA concentration. Our study finds that MGapt fluorescence is unstable in commercial PURE systems. We discovered that the chemical composition of the cell-free reaction strongly influences MGapt fluorescence, which leads to inaccurate RNA calculations. Specific to the commercial system, we posit that MGapt fluorescence is significantly affected by the system's chemical properties, governed notably by the presence of dithiothreitol (DTT). We propose a model that, on average, accurately predicts MGapt measurement within a 10% margin, leveraging DTT concentration as a critical factor. This model sheds light on the complex dynamics of MGapt in cell-free systems and underscores the importance of considering environmental factors in RNA measurements using aptamers.

Assays to Estimate the Binding Affinity of Aptamers

Aptamers have become coming-of-age molecular recognition elements in both diagnostic and therapeutic applications. Generated by SELEX, the 'quality control' of aptamers, which involves the validation of their binding affinity against their respective targets is pivotal to ascertain their potency prior to use in any downstream assays or applications. Several aptamers have been isolated thus far, however, the usage of inappropriate validation assays renders some of these aptamers dubitable in terms of their binding capabilities. Driven by this need, we provide an up-to-date critical review of the various strategies used to determine the aptamer-target binding affinity with the aim of providing researchers a better comprehension of the different analytical approaches in respect to the molecular properties of aptamers and their intended targets. The techniques reported have been classified as label-based techniques such as fluorescence intensity, fluorescence anisotropy, filter-binding assays, gel shift assays, ELISA; and label-free techniques such as UV-Vis spectroscopy, circular dichroism, isothermal titration calorimetry, native electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry, quartz crystal microbalance, surface plasmon resonance, NECEEM, backscattering interferometry, capillary electrophoresis, HPLC, and nanoparticle aggregation assays. Hybrid strategies combining the characteristics of both categories such as microscale thermophoresis have been also additionally emphasized. The fundamental principles, complexity, benefits, and challenges under each technique are elaborated in detail.

Computational Studies of a DNA-Based Aptasensor: toward Theory-Driven Transduction Improvement

Aptamers are a class of bioreceptors intensively used in current analytical tools dedicated to molecular diagnostics due to their ability to perform large structural reorganization upon target binding. However, there is a lack of methodologies allowing us to rationalize their structure in order to improve the transduction efficiency in aptamer sensors. We choose here, as a model system, a three-strand DNA structure as the probe, composed of two DNA strands anchored on a gold surface and partially hybridized with an aptamer sequence sensitive to ampicillin (AMP). The DNA structure has been designed to show strong structural change upon AMP binding to its aptamer. Using a set of computational techniques including molecular dynamics simulations, we deeply investigated the structure change upon analyte binding, taking into account the grafting on the surface. Original analyses of ion distributions along the trajectories unveil a distinct pattern between both states which can be related to changes in capacitance of the interface between these states. To our knowledge, this work demonstrates the ability of computational investigations for the first time to drive, in silico, the design of aptasensors.

Ligand specificity and affinity in the sulforhodamine B binding RNA aptamer

Binding affinity and selectivity are critical properties of aptamers that must be optimized for any application. The sulforhodamine B binding RNA aptamer (SRB-2) is a somewhat promiscuous aptamer that can bind ligands that vary markedly in shape, size and charge. Here we categorize potential ligands based on their binding mode and structural characteristics required for high affinity and selectivity. Several known and potential ligands of SRB-2 were screened for binding affinity using LSPR, ITC and NMR spectroscopy. The study shows that rhodamine B has the ideal structural and electrostatic properties for selective and high-affinity binding of the SRB-2 aptamer.

Mathematical approaches in estimating aptamer-target binding affinity

The performance of aptamers as versatile tools in numerous analytical applications is critically dependent on their high target binding specificity and selectivity. However, only the technical or methodological aspects of measuring aptamer-target binding affinities are focused, ignoring the equally important mathematical components that play pivotal roles in affinity measurements. In this study, we aim to provide a comprehensive review regarding the utilization of different mathematical models and equations, along with a detailed description of the computational steps involved in mathematically deriving the binding affinity of aptamers against their specific target molecules. Mathematical models ranging from one-site binding to multiple aptameric binding site-based models are explained in detail. Models applied in several different approaches of affinity measurements such as thermodynamics and kinetic analysis, including cooperativity and competitive-assay based mathematical models have been elaborately discussed. Mathematical models incorporating factors that could potentially affect affinity measurements are also further scrutinized.

A new aptamer/black phosphorous interdigital electrode for malachite green detection

Malachite Green (MG), a cationic triphenylmethane dye, has adverse effects on the immune and reproductive system. Thus, it is essential to develop a rapid, sensitive and high-selective method for determination of MG. Black phosphorus (BP) has high charge-carrier mobility (∼1000 cm² V^-1 s^-1) and high adsorption capacity for cationic dyes (i.e. MG) through both electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions. Thus, it potentially plays as a high-sensitive sensing platform for detecting MG. However, BP degrades within 12 h under humid condition, which limits its applications. To overcome this issue, cysteine (CYS) is used for protecting BP from oxidation and ceasing its degradation. To the best of our knowledge, it is the first time that CYS is used to functionalize BP, and a silicon interdigital electrode is fabricated with the functionalized BP and aptamer. The BP-based interdigital electrode shows a lowest detection limit of 0.3 ng L^-1 toward MG. This work provides a new route to prepare a large scale and selective biosensor for MG monitoring on site in future.

"Second-generation" fluorogenic RNA-based sensors

A fluorogenic aptamer can specifically interact with a fluorophore to activate its fluorescence. These nucleic acid-based fluorogenic modules have been dramatically developed over the past decade, and have been used as versatile reporters in the sensor development and for intracellular imaging. In this review, we summarize the design principles, applications, and challenges of the first-generation fluorogenic RNA-based sensors. Moreover, we discuss some strategies to develop next-generation biosensors with improved sensitivity, selectivity, quantification property, and eukaryotic robustness. Using genetically encoded catalytic hairpin assembly strategy as an example, we further introduce a standard protocol to design, characterize, and apply these fluorogenic RNA-based sensors for in vitro detection and cellular imaging of target biomolecules. By incorporating natural RNA machineries, nucleic acid nanotechnology, and systematic evolution approaches, next-generation fluorogenic RNA-based devices can be potentially engineered to be widely applied in cell biology and biomedicine.

RNA Structure and Cellular Applications of Fluorescent Light-Up Aptamers

The cellular functions of RNA are not limited to their role as blueprints for protein synthesis. In particular, noncoding RNA, such as, snRNAs, lncRNAs, miRNAs, play important roles. With increasing numbers of RNAs being identified, it is well known that the transcriptome outnumbers the proteome by far. This emphasizes the great importance of functional RNA characterization and the need to further develop tools for these investigations, many of which are still in their infancy. Fluorescent light-up aptamers (FLAPs) are RNA sequences that can bind nontoxic, cell-permeable small-molecule fluorogens and enhance their fluorescence over many orders of magnitude upon binding. FLAPs can be encoded on the DNA level using standard molecular biology tools and are subsequently transcribed into RNA by the cellular machinery, so that they can be used as fluorescent RNA tags (FLAP-tags). In this Minireview, we give a brief overview of the fluorogens that have been developed and their binding RNA aptamers, with a special focus on published crystal structures. A summary of current and future cellular FLAP applications with an emphasis on the study of RNA-RNA and RNA-protein interactions using split-FLAP and Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) systems is given.

Labeling RNAs in Live Cells Using Malachite Green Aptamer Scaffolds as Fluorescent Probes

RNAs mediate many different processes that are central to cellular function. The ability to quantify or image RNAs in live cells is very useful in elucidating such functions of RNA. RNA aptamer-fluorogen systems have been increasingly used in labeling RNAs in live cells. Here, we use the malachite green aptamer (MGA), an RNA aptamer that can specifically bind to malachite green (MG) dye and induces it to emit far-red fluorescence signals. Previous studies on MGA showed a potential for the use of MGA for genetically tagging other RNA molecules in live cells. However, these studies also exhibited low fluorescence signals and high background noise. Here we constructed and tested RNA scaffolds containing multiple tandem repeats of MGA as a strategy to increase the brightness of the MGA aptamer-fluorogen system as well as to make the system fluoresce when tagging various RNA molecules, in live cells. We demonstrate that our MGA scaffolds can induce fluorescence signals by up to ∼20-fold compared to the basal level as a genetic tag for other RNA molecules. We also show that our scaffolds function reliably as genetically encoded fluorescent tags for mRNAs of fluorescent proteins and other RNA aptamers.

Multianalytical Study of the Binding between a Small Chiral Molecule and a DNA Aptamer: Evidence for Asymmetric Steric Effect upon 3'- versus 5'-End Sequence Modification

Nucleic acid aptamers are involved in a broad field of applications ranging from therapeutics to analytics. Deciphering the binding mechanisms between aptamers and small ligands is therefore crucial to improve and optimize existing applications and to develop new ones. Particularly interesting is the enantiospecific binding mechanism involving small molecules with nonprestructured aptamers. One archetypal example is the chiral binding between l-tyrosinamide and its 49-mer aptamer for which neither structural nor mechanistic information is available. In the present work, we have taken advantage of a multiple analytical characterization strategy (i.e., using electroanalytical techniques such as kinetic rotating droplet electrochemistry, fluorescence polarization, isothermal titration calorimetry, and quartz crystal microbalance) for interpreting the nature of binding process. Screening of the binding thermodynamics and kinetics with a wide range of aptamer sequences revealed the lack of symmetry between the two ends of the 23-mer minimal binding sequence, showing an unprecedented influence of the 5' aptamer modification on the bimolecular binding rate constant k_on and no significant effect on the dissociation rate constant k_off. The results we have obtained lead us to conclude that the enantiospecific binding reaction occurs through an induced-fit mechanism, wherein the ligand promotes a primary nucleation binding step near the 5'-end of the aptamer followed by a directional folding of the aptamer around its target from 5'-end to 3'-end. Functionalization of the 5'-end position by a chemical label, a polydA tail, a protein, or a surface influences the kinetic/thermodynamic constants up to 2 orders of magnitude in the extreme case of a surface immobilized aptamer, while significantly weaker effect is observed for a 3'-end modification. The reason is that steric hindrance must be overcome to nucleate the binding complex in the presence of a modification near the nucleation site.

Kinetic and Thermodynamic Analyses of Interaction between a High-Affinity RNA Aptamer and Its Target Protein

AML1 (RUNX1) protein is an essential transcription factor involved in the development of hematopoietic cells. Several genetic aberrations that disrupt the function of AML1 have been frequently observed in human leukemia. AML1 contains a DNA-binding domain known as the Runt domain (RD), which recognizes the RD-binding double-stranded DNA element of target genes. In this study, we identified high-affinity RNA aptamers that bind to RD by systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment. The binding assay using surface plasmon resonance indicated that a shortened aptamer retained the ability to bind to RD when 1 M potassium acetate was used. A thermodynamic study using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) showed that the aptamer-RD interaction is driven by a large enthalpy change, and its unfavorable entropy change is compensated by a favorable enthalpy change. Furthermore, the binding heat capacity change was identified from the ITC data at various temperatures. The aptamer binding showed a large negative heat capacity change, which suggests that a large apolar surface is buried upon such binding. Thus, we proposed that the aptamer binds to RD with long-range electrostatic force in the early stage of the association and then changes its conformation and recognizes a large surface area of RD. These findings about the biophysics of aptamer binding should be useful for understanding the mechanism of RNA-protein interaction and optimizing and modifying RNA aptamers.

Organic additives stabilize RNA aptamer binding of malachite green

Aptamer-ligand binding has been utilized for biological applications due to its specific binding and synthetic nature. However, the applications will be limited if the binding or the ligand is unstable. Malachite green aptamer (MGA) and its labile ligand malachite green (MG) were found to have increasing apparent dissociation constants (Kd) as determined through the first order rate loss of emission intensity of the MGA-MG fluorescent complex. The fluorescent intensity loss was hypothesized to be from the hydrolysis of MG into malachite green carbinol base (MGOH). Random screening organic additives were found to reduce or retain the fluorescence emission and the calculated apparent Kd of MGA-MG binding. The protective effect became more apparent as the percentage of organic additives increased up to 10% v/v. The mechanism behind the organic additive protective effects was primarily from a ~5X increase in first order rate kinetics of MGOH→MG (kMGOH→MG), which significantly changed the equilibrium constant (Keq), favoring the generation of MG, versus MGOH without organic additives. A simple way has been developed to stabilize the apparent Kd of MGA-MG binding over 24h, which may be beneficial in stabilizing other triphenylmethane or carbocation ligand-aptamer interactions that are susceptible to SN1 hydrolysis.

Tetracycline determines the conformation of its aptamer at physiological magnesium concentrations

Synthetic riboswitches are versatile tools for the study and manipulation of biological systems. Yet, the underlying mechanisms governing its structural properties and regulation under physiological conditions are poorly studied. We performed spectroscopic and calorimetric experiments to explore the folding kinetics and thermodynamics of the tetracycline-binding aptamer, which can be employed as synthetic riboswitch, in the range of physiological magnesium concentrations. The dissociation constant of the ligand-aptamer complex was found to strongly depend on the magnesium concentration. At physiological magnesium concentrations, tetracycline induces a significant conformational shift from a compact, but heterogeneous intermediate state toward the completely formed set of tertiary interactions defining the regulation-competent structure. Thus, the switching functionality of the tetracycline-binding aptamer appears to include both a conformational rearrangement toward the regulation-competent structure and its thermodynamic stabilization.

In Vivo RNA Visualization in Plants Using MS2 Tagging

Intracellular trafficking and asymmetric localization of RNA molecules within cells are a prevalent process across phyla involved in developmental control and signaling and thus in the determination of cell fate. In addition to intracellular localization, plants support the trafficking of RNA molecules also between cells through plasmodesmata (PD), which has important roles in the cell-to-cell and systemic communication during plant growth and development. Viruses have developed strategies to exploit the underlying plant RNA transport mechanisms for the cell-to-cell and systemic dissemination of infection. In vivo RNA visualization methods have revolutionized the study of RNA dynamics in living cells. However, their application in plants is still in its infancy. To gain insights into the RNA transport mechanisms in plants, we study the localization and transport of Tobacco mosaic virus RNA using MS2 tagging. This technique involves the tagging of the RNA of interest with repeats of an RNA stem-loop (SL) that is derived from the origin of assembly of the bacteriophage MS2 and recruits the MS2 coat protein (MCP). Thus, expression of MCP fused to a fluorescent marker allows the specific visualization of the SL-carrying RNA. Here we describe a detailed protocol for Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transient expression and in vivo visualization of MS2-tagged mRNAs in Nicotiana benthamiana leaves.

Blu-ray based optomagnetic aptasensor for detection of small molecules

This paper describes an aptamer-based optomagnetic biosensor for detection of a small molecule based on target binding-induced inhibition of magnetic nanoparticle (MNP) clustering. For the detection of a target small molecule, two mutually exclusive binding reactions (aptamer-target binding and aptamer-DNA linker hybridization) are designed. An aptamer specific to the target and a DNA linker complementary to a part of the aptamer sequence are immobilized onto separate MNPs. Hybridization of the DNA linker and the aptamer induces formation of MNP clusters. The target-to-aptamer binding on MNPs prior to the addition of linker-functionalized MNPs significantly hinders the hybridization reaction, thus reducing the degree of MNP clustering. The clustering state, which is thus related to the target concentration, is then quantitatively determined by an optomagnetic readout technique that provides the hydrodynamic size distribution of MNPs and their clusters. A commercial Blu-ray optical pickup unit is used for optical signal acquisition, which enables the establishment of a low-cost and miniaturized biosensing platform. Experimental results show that the degree of MNP clustering correlates well with the concentration of a target small molecule, adenosine triphosphate (ATP) in this work, in the range between 10µM and 10mM. This successful proof-of-concept indicates that our optomagnetic aptasensor can be further developed as a low-cost biosensing platform for detection of small molecule biomarkers in an out-of-lab setting.

Ultrafast capillary electrophoresis isolation of DNA aptamer for the PCR amplification-based small analyte sensing

Here, we report a new homogeneous DNA amplification-based aptamer assay for small analyte sensing. The aptamer of adenosine chosen as the model analyte was split into two fragments able to assemble in the presence of target. Primers were introduced at extremities of one fragment in order to generate the amplifiable DNA component. The amount of amplifiable fragment was quantifiable by Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction (RT-PCR) amplification and directly reliable on adenosine concentration. This approach combines the very high separation efficiency and the homogeneous format (without immobilization) of capillary electrophoresis (CE) and the sensitivity of real time PCR amplification. An ultrafast isolation of target-bound split aptamer (60 s) was developed by designing a CE input/ouput scheme. Such method was successfully applied to the determination of adenosine with a LOD of 1 μM.

Malachite green interacts with the membrane skeletal protein, spectrin

Energy minimized complex of MG with the self association domain of spectrin.

Broccoli: rapid selection of an RNA mimic of green fluorescent protein by fluorescence-based selection and directed evolution

Genetically encoded fluorescent ribonucleic acids (RNAs) have diverse applications, including imaging RNA trafficking and as a component of RNA-based sensors that exhibit fluorescence upon binding small molecules in live cells. These RNAs include the Spinach and Spinach2 aptamers, which bind and activate the fluorescence of fluorophores similar to that found in green fluorescent protein. Although additional highly fluorescent RNA–fluorophore complexes would extend the utility of this technology, the identification of novel RNA–fluorophore complexes is difficult. Current approaches select aptamers on the basis of their ability to bind fluorophores, even though fluorophore binding alone is not sufficient to activate fluorescence. Additionally, aptamers require extensive mutagenesis to efficiently fold and exhibit fluorescence in living cells. Here we describe a platform for rapid generation of highly fluorescent RNA–fluorophore complexes that are optimized for function in cells. This procedure involves selection of aptamers on the basis of their binding to fluorophores, coupled with fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) of millions of aptamers expressed in Escherichia coli. Promising aptamers are then further optimized using a FACS-based directed evolution approach. Using this approach, we identified several novel aptamers, including a 49-nt aptamer, Broccoli. Broccoli binds and activates the fluorescence of (Z)-4-(3,5-difluoro-4-hydroxybenzylidene)-1,2-dimethyl-1H-imidazol-5(4H)-one. Broccoli shows robust folding and green fluorescence in cells, and increased fluorescence relative to Spinach2. This reflects, in part, improved folding in the presence of low cytosolic magnesium concentrations. Thus, this novel fluorescence-based selection approach simplifies the generation of aptamers that are optimized for expression and performance in living cells.

Kinetic and equilibrium binding characterization of aptamers to small molecules using a label-free, sensitive, and scalable platform

Nucleic acid aptamers function as versatile sensing and targeting agents for analytical, diagnostic, therapeutic, and gene-regulatory applications, but their limited characterization and functional validation have hindered their broader implementation. We report the development of a surface plasmon resonance-based platform for rapid characterization of kinetic and equilibrium binding properties of aptamers to small molecules. Our system is label-free and scalable and enables analysis of different aptamer–target pairs and binding conditions with the same platform. This method demonstrates improved sensitivity, flexibility, and stability compared to other aptamer characterization methods. We validated our assay against previously reported aptamer affinity and kinetic measurements and further characterized a diverse panel of 12 small molecule-binding RNA and DNA aptamers. We report the first kinetic characterization for six of these aptamers and affinity characterization of two others. This work is the first example of direct comparison of in vitro selected and natural aptamers using consistent characterization conditions, thus providing insight into the influence of environmental conditions on aptamer binding kinetics and affinities, indicating different possible regulatory strategies used by natural aptamers, and identifying potential in vitro selection strategies to improve resulting binding affinities.

Plug-and-play fluorophores extend the spectral properties of Spinach

Spinach and Spinach2 are RNA aptamers that can be used for the genetic encoding of fluorescent RNA. Spinach2 binds and activates the fluorescence of (Z)-4-(3,5-difluoro-4-hydroxybenzylidene)-1,2-dimethyl-1H-imidazol-5(4H)-one (DFHBI), allowing the dynamic localizations of Spinach2-tagged RNAs to be imaged in live cells. The spectral properties of Spinach2 are limited by DFHBI, which produces fluorescence that is bluish-green and is not optimized for filters commonly used in fluorescence microscopes. Here we characterize the structural features that are required for fluorophore binding to Spinach2 and describe novel fluorophores that bind and are switched to a fluorescent state by Spinach2. These diverse Spinach2–fluorophore complexes exhibit fluorescence that is more compatible with existing microscopy filter sets and allows Spinach2-tagged constructs to be imaged with either GFP or YFP filter cubes. Thus, these “plug-and-play” fluorophores allow the spectral properties of Spinach2 to be altered on the basis of the specific spectral needs of the experiment.