Kinetic mechanism of transcription initiation by bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase

The NS1 protein of influenza B virus binds 5'-triphosphorylated dsRNA to suppress RIG-I activation and the host antiviral response

Influenza A and B viruses overcome the host antiviral response to cause a contagious and often severe human respiratory disease. Here, integrative structural biology and biochemistry studies on non-structural protein 1 of influenza B virus (NS1B) reveal a previously unrecognized viral mechanism for innate immune evasion. Conserved basic groups of its C-terminal domain (NS1B-CTD) bind 5'triphosphorylated double-stranded RNA (5'-ppp-dsRNA), the primary pathogen-associated feature that activates the host retinoic acid-inducible gene I protein (RIG-I) to initiate interferon synthesis and the cellular antiviral response. Like RIG-I, NS1B-CTD preferentially binds blunt-end 5'ppp-dsRNA. NS1B-CTD also competes with RIG-I for binding 5'ppp-dsRNA, and thus suppresses activation of RIG-I's ATPase activity. Although the NS1B N-terminal domain also binds dsRNA, it utilizes a different binding mode and lacks 5'ppp-dsRNA end preferences. In cells infected with wild-type influenza B virus, RIG-I activation is inhibited. In contrast, RIG-I activation and the resulting phosphorylation of transcription factor IRF-3 are not inhibited in cells infected with a mutant virus encoding NS1B with a R208A substitution it its CTD that eliminates its 5'ppp-dsRNA binding activity. These results reveal a novel mechanism in which NS1B binds 5'ppp-dsRNA to inhibit the RIG-I antiviral response during influenza B virus infection, and open the door to new avenues for antiviral drug discovery.

High throughput quantification of short nucleic acid samples by capillary electrophoresis with automated data processing

Analysis of catalytic activity of nucleic acid enzymes is crucial for many applications, ranging from biotechnology to the search for antiviral drugs. Commonly used analytical methods for quantifying DNA and RNA reaction products based on slab-gel electrophoresis are limited in throughput, speed, and accuracy. Here we report the optimization of high throughput methods to separate and quantify short nucleic acid reaction products using DNA sequencing instruments based on capillary electrophoresis with fluorescence detection. These methods afford single base resolution without requiring extensive sample preparation. Additionally, we show that the utility of our system extends to quantifying RNA products. The efficiency and reliability of modern instruments offers a large increase in throughput but complications due to variations in migration times between capillaries required us to develop a computer program to normalize the data and quantify the products for automated kinetic analysis. The methods presented here greatly increase sample throughput and accuracy and should be applicable to many nucleic acid enzymes.

Probing steps in DNA transcription using single-molecule methods

Transcriptional regulation is one of the key steps in determining gene expression. Diverse single-molecule techniques have been applied to characterize the stepwise progression of transcription, yielding complementary results. These techniques include, but are not limited to, fluorescence-based microscopy with single or multiple colors, force measuring and manipulating microscopy using magnetic field or light, and atomic force microscopy. Here, we summarize and evaluate these current methodologies in studying and resolving individual steps in the transcription reaction, which encompasses RNA polymerase binding, initiation, elongation, mRNA production, and termination. We also describe the advantages and disadvantages of each method for studying transcription.

High-salt transcription of DNA cotethered with T7 RNA polymerase to beads generates increased yields of highly pure RNA

High yields of RNA are routinely prepared following the two-step approach of high-yield in vitro transcription using T7 RNA polymerase followed by extensive purification using gel separation or chromatographic methods. We recently demonstrated that in high-yield transcription reactions, as RNA accumulates in solution, T7 RNA polymerase rebinds and extends the encoded RNA (using the RNA as a template), resulting in a product pool contaminated with longer-than-desired, (partially) double-stranded impurities. Current purification methods often fail to fully eliminate these impurities, which, if present in therapeutics, can stimulate the innate immune response with potentially fatal consequences. In this work, we introduce a novel in vitro transcription method that generates high yields of encoded RNA without double-stranded impurities, reducing the need for further purification. Transcription is carried out at high-salt conditions to eliminate RNA product rebinding, while promoter DNA and T7 RNA polymerase are cotethered in close proximity on magnetic beads to drive promoter binding and transcription initiation, resulting in an increase in overall yield and purity of only the encoded RNA. A more complete elimination of double-stranded RNA during synthesis will not only reduce overall production costs, but also should ultimately enable therapies and technologies that are currently being hampered by those impurities.

Dynamic self-assembly of compartmentalized DNA nanotubes

Bottom-up synthetic biology aims to engineer artificial cells capable of responsive behaviors by using a minimal set of molecular components. An important challenge toward this goal is the development of programmable biomaterials that can provide active spatial organization in cell-sized compartments. Here, we demonstrate the dynamic self-assembly of nucleic acid (NA) nanotubes inside water-in-oil droplets. We develop methods to encapsulate and assemble different types of DNA nanotubes from programmable DNA monomers, and demonstrate temporal control of assembly via designed pathways of RNA production and degradation. We examine the dynamic response of encapsulated nanotube assembly and disassembly with the support of statistical analysis of droplet images. Our study provides a toolkit of methods and components to build increasingly complex and functional NA materials to mimic life-like functions in synthetic cells.

Single-pass transcription by T7 RNA polymerase

RNA molecules can be conveniently synthesized in vitro by the T7 RNA polymerase (T7 RNAP). In some experiments, such as cotranscriptional biochemical analyses, continuous synthesis of RNA is not desired. Here, we propose a method for a single-pass transcription that yields a single transcript per template DNA molecule using the T7 RNAP system. We hypothesized that stalling the polymerase downstream from the promoter region and subsequent cleavage of the promoter by a restriction enzyme (to prevent promoter binding by another polymerase) would allow synchronized production of a single transcript per template. The single-pass transcription was verified in two different scenarios: a short self-cleaving ribozyme and a long mRNA. The results show that a controlled single-pass transcription using T7 RNAP allows precise measurement of cotranscriptional ribozyme activity, and this approach will facilitate the study of other kinetic events.

Features of the Influence of a DNA Sequence on Its Adjacent Sequence

To explore the features of the influence of a DNA sequence (here called sequence A) on its adjacent sequence (here called sequence B), we linked some DNA repeated sequences to the 5'-end of the T7 promoter in the plasmid pET-42a (+) or the 5'- and/or 3'-end(s) of the EcoRI site in some DNA fragments using PCR and other molecular cloning methods. As a result, we found that the efficiency of the T7 promoter and EcoRI could be impacted by some flanking sequences, indicating that sequence B could be impacted by sequence A. The features of such influence include the following: (i) sequence A can directly impact sequence B without changing/modifying the base composition of sequence B or destroying the inherent connection between sequence B and its function-related sequences; (ii) such influence does not need the participation of trans-acting factors or products of sequence A (if any); (iii) such an influence might be undetectable when the activities of trans-acting factors of sequence B are normal but might become detectable when those are lower than the normal one; (iv) such an influence might be enhancive, inhibitory, or unobvious; (v) the influence of sequence A linked to the 5'-end of sequence B might be the same as or opposite to that of sequence A linked to the 3'-end; and (vi) the influences of sequence A linked to different ends of sequence B could enhance or partially offset each other when sequence A is linked to both 5'- and 3'-ends of sequence B. These findings might give us a further understanding of the interaction of two adjacent DNA sequences.

New Insight into Plasmid-Driven T7 RNA Polymerase in Escherichia coli and Use as a Genetic Amplifier for a Biosensor

T7 RNA polymerase (T7RNAP) and T7 promoter are powerful genetic components, thus a plasmid-driven T7 (PDT7) genetic circuit could be broadly applied for synthetic biology. However, the limited knowledge of the toxicity and instability of such a system still restricts its application. Herein, we constructed 16 constitutive genetic circuts of PDT7 and investigated the orthogonal effects in toxicity and instability. The T7 toxicity was elucidated from the construction processes and cell growth characterization, showing the importance of optimal orthogonality for PDT7. Besides, a protein analysis was performed to validate how the T7 system affected cell metabolism and led to the instability. The application of constitutive PDT7 in functional protein expressions, including carbonic anhydrase, lysine decarboxylase, and 5-ALA synthetase was demonstrated. Furthermore, PDT7 working as a genetic amplifier had been designed for E. coli cell-based biosensors, which illustrated the opportunities in the future of PDT7 used in synthetic biology.

Identification of a Small Interface between the Methyltransferase and RNA Polymerase of NS5 that is Essential for Zika Virus Replication

The spread of Zika virus (ZIKV) has caused an international health emergency due to its ability to cause microcephaly in infants. Yet, our knowledge of how ZIKV replicates at the molecular level is limited. For example, how the non-structural protein 5 (NS5) performs replication, and in particular whether the N-terminal methytransferase (MTase) domain is essential for the function of the C-terminal RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) remains unclear. In contrast to previous reports, we find that MTase is absolutely essential for all activities of RdRp in vitro. For instance, the MTase domain confers stability onto the RdRp elongation complex (EC) and and is required for de novo RNA synthesis and nucleotide incorporation by RdRp. Finally, structure function analyses identify key conserved residues at the MTase-RdRp interface that specifically activate RdRp elongation and are essential for ZIKV replication in Huh-7.5 cells. These data demonstrate the requirement for the MTase-RdRp interface in ZIKV replication and identify a specific site within this region as a potential site for therapeutic development.

Helicase promotes replication re-initiation from an RNA transcript

To ensure accurate DNA replication, a replisome must effectively overcome numerous obstacles on its DNA substrate. After encountering an obstacle, a progressing replisome often aborts DNA synthesis but continues to unwind. However, little is known about how DNA synthesis is resumed downstream of an obstacle. Here, we examine the consequences of a non-replicating replisome collision with a co-directional RNA polymerase (RNAP). Using single-molecule and ensemble methods, we find that T7 helicase interacts strongly with a non-replicating T7 DNA polymerase (DNAP) at a replication fork. As the helicase advances, the associated DNAP also moves forward. The presence of the DNAP increases both helicase’s processivity and unwinding rate. We show that such a DNAP, together with its helicase, is indeed able to actively disrupt a stalled transcription elongation complex, and then initiates replication using the RNA transcript as a primer. These observations exhibit T7 helicase’s novel role in replication re-initiation.

During DNA replication, replicative helicases play an essential role for DNA unwinding to occur. Here the authors find that bacteriophage T7 helicase is also involved in replication re-initiation by interacting with a non-replicating DNAP and increasing unwinding rate.

Correlating Transcription Initiation and Conformational Changes by a Single-Subunit RNA Polymerase with Near Base-Pair Resolution

We provide a comprehensive analysis of transcription in real time by T7 RNA Polymerase (RNAP) using single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer by monitoring the entire life history of transcription initiation, including stepwise RNA synthesis with near base-pair resolution, abortive cycling, and transition into elongation. Kinetically branching pathways were observed for abortive initiation with an RNAP either recycling on the same promoter or exchanging with another RNAP from solution. We detected fast and slow populations of RNAP in their transition into elongation, consistent with the efficient and delayed promoter release, respectively, observed in ensemble studies. Real-time monitoring of abortive cycling using three-probe analysis showed that the initiation events are stochastically branched into productive and failed transcription. The abortive products are generated primarily from initiation events that fail to progress to elongation, and a majority of the productive events transit to elongation without making abortive products.

Synthesis of photocaged 6-O-(2-nitrobenzyl)guanosine and 4-O-(2-nitrobenzyl) uridine triphosphates for photocontrol of the RNA transcription reaction

6-O-(2-Nitrobenzyl)guanosine and 4-O-(2-nitrobenzyl)uridine triphosphates (^NBGTP, ^NBUTP) were synthesized, and their biochemical and photophysical properties were evaluated. We synthesized ^NBUTP using the canonical triphosphate synthesis method and ^NBGTP from 2',3'-O-TBDMS guanosine via a triphosphate synthesis method by utilizing mild acidic desilylation conditions. Deprotection of the nitrobenzyl group in ^NBGTP and ^NBUTP proceeded within 60s by UV irradiation at 365nm. Experiments using ^NBGTP or ^NBUTP in T7-RNA transcription reactions showed that ^NBGTP could be useful for the photocontrol of transcription by UV irradiation.

Transcriptional fidelities of human mitochondrial POLRMT, yeast mitochondrial Rpo41, and phage T7 single-subunit RNA polymerases

Single-subunit RNA polymerases (RNAPs) are present in phage T7 and in mitochondria of all eukaryotes. This RNAP class plays important roles in biotechnology and cellular energy production, but we know little about its fidelity and error rates. Herein, we report the error rates of three single-subunit RNAPs measured from the catalytic efficiencies of correct and all possible incorrect nucleotides. The average error rates of T7 RNAP (2 × 10^-6), yeast mitochondrial Rpo41 (6 × 10^-6), and human mitochondrial POLRMT (RNA polymerase mitochondrial) (2 × 10^-5) indicate high accuracy/fidelity of RNA synthesis resembling those of replicative DNA polymerases. All three RNAPs exhibit a distinctly high propensity for GTP misincorporation opposite dT, predicting frequent A→G errors in RNA with rates of ∼10^-4 The A→C, G→A, A→U, C→U, G→U, U→C, and U→G errors mostly due to pyrimidine-purine mismatches were relatively frequent (10^-5-10^-6), whereas C→G, U→A, G→C, and C→A errors from purine-purine and pyrimidine-pyrimidine mismatches were rare (10^-7-10^-10). POLRMT also shows a high C→A error rate on 8-oxo-dG templates (∼10^-4). Strikingly, POLRMT shows a high mutagenic bypass rate, which is exacerbated by TEFM (transcription elongation factor mitochondrial). The lifetime of POLRMT on terminally mismatched elongation substrate is increased in the presence of TEFM, which allows POLRMT to efficiently bypass the error and continue with transcription. This investigation of nucleotide selectivity on normal and oxidatively damaged DNA by three single-subunit RNAPs provides the basic information to understand the error rates in mitochondria and, in the case of T7 RNAP, to assess the quality of in vitro transcribed RNAs.

MicroRNA signatures from multidrug‑resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Tuberculosis (TB) infections, caused by multi-drug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MDR MTB), remain a significant public health concern worldwide. The regulatory mechanisms underlying the emergence of MDR MTB strains remain to be fully elucidated, and further investigation is required in order to develop better strategies for TB control. The present study investigated the expression profile of microRNA (miRNA) in MTB strains, and examined the differences between sensitive MTB and MDR MTB using next generation sequencing (NGS) with Illumina Deep Sequencing technology to better understand the mechanisms of resistance in MDR MTB, A total of 5, 785 and 195, and 6, 290 and 595 qualified Illumina reads were obtained from two MDR MTB strains, and 6, 673 and 665, and 7, 210 and 217 qualified Illumina reads were obtained from two sensitive MTB strains. The overall de novo assembly of miRNA sequence data generated 62 and 62, and 95 and 112 miRNAs between the 18 and 30 bp long from sensitive MTB strains and MDR MTB strains, respectively. Comparative miRNA analysis revealed that 142 miRNAs were differentially expressed in the MDR MTB strain, compared with the sensitive MTB strain, of which 48 were upregulated and 94 were downregulated. There were six similarly expressed miRNAs between the MDR and sensitive MTB strains, and 108 miRNAs were expressed only in the MDR MTB strain. The present study acquired miRNA data from sensitive MTB and MDR MTB strains using NGS techniques, and this identification miRNAs may serve as an invaluable resource for revealing the molecular basis of the regulation of expression associated with the mechanism of drug-resistance in MTB.

Modulating the frequency and bias of stochastic switching to control phenotypic variation

Mechanisms that control cell-to-cell variation in gene expression ('phenotypic variation') can determine a population's growth rate, robustness, adaptability and capacity for complex behaviours. Here we describe a general strategy (termed FABMOS) for tuning the phenotypic variation and mean expression of cell populations by modulating the frequency and bias of stochastic transitions between 'OFF' and 'ON' expression states of a genetic switch. We validated the strategy experimentally using a synthetic fim switch in Escherichia coli. Modulating the frequency of switching can generate a bimodal (low frequency) or a unimodal (high frequency) population distribution with the same mean expression. Modulating the bias as well as the frequency of switching can generate a spectrum of bimodal and unimodal distributions with the same mean expression. This remarkable control over phenotypic variation, which cannot be easily achieved with standard gene regulatory mechanisms, has many potential applications for synthetic biology, engineered microbial ecosystems and experimental evolution.

Dual role of MsRbpA: transcription activation and rescue of transcription from the inhibitory effect of rifampicin

MsRbpA is an RNA polymerase (RNAP) binding protein from Mycobacterium smegmatis. According to previous studies, MsRbpA rescues rifampicin-induced transcription inhibition upon binding to the RNAP. Others have shown that RbpA from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MtbRbpA) is a transcription activator. In this study, we report that both MsRbpA and MtbRbpA activate transcription as well as rescue rifampicin-induced transcription inhibition. Transcription activation is achieved through the increased formation of closed RNAP-promoter complex as well as enhanced rate of conversion of this complex to a stable transcriptionally competent RNAP-promoter complex. When a 16 aa peptide fragment (Asp 58 to Lys 73) was deleted from MsRbpA, the resulting protein showed 1000-fold reduced binding with core RNAP. The deletion results in abolition of transcription activation and rescue of transcription from the inhibitory effect of rifampicin. Through alanine scanning of this essential region of MsRbpA, Gly 67, Val 69, Pro 70 and Pro 72 residues are identified to be important for MsRbpA function. Furthermore, we report here that the protein is indispensable for M. smegmatis, and it appears to help the organism grow in the presence of the antibiotic rifampicin.

Synthetic circuit for exact adaptation and fold-change detection

Biological organisms use their sensory systems to detect changes in their environment. The ability of sensory systems to adapt to static inputs allows wide dynamic range as well as sensitivity to input changes including fold-change detection, a response that depends only on fold changes in input, and not on absolute changes. This input scale invariance underlies an important strategy for search that depends solely on the spatial profile of the input. Synthetic efforts to reproduce the architecture and response of cellular circuits provide an important step to foster understanding at the molecular level. We report the bottom-up assembly of biochemical systems that show exact adaptation and fold-change detection. Using a malachite green aptamer as the output, a synthetic transcriptional circuit with the connectivity of an incoherent feed-forward loop motif exhibits pulse generation and exact adaptation. A simple mathematical model was used to assess the amplitude and duration of pulse response as well as the parameter regimes required for fold-change detection. Upon parameter tuning, this synthetic circuit exhibits fold-change detection for four successive rounds of two-fold input changes. The experimental realization of fold-change detection circuit highlights the programmability of transcriptional switches and the ability to obtain predictive dynamical systems in a cell-free environment for technological applications.

Distinct and contrasting transcription initiation patterns at Mycobacterium tuberculosis promoters

Although sequencing of Mycobacterium tuberculosis genome lead to better understanding of transcription units and gene functions, interactions occurring during transcription initiation between RNA polymerase and promoters is yet to be elucidated. Different stages of transcription initiation include promoter specific binding of RNAP, isomerization, abortive initiation and promoter clearance. We have now analyzed these events with four promoters of M. tuberculosis viz. P_gyrB1, P_gyrR, P_rrnPCL1 and P_metU. The promoters differed from each other in their rates of open complex formation, decay, promoter clearance and abortive transcription. The equilibrium binding and kinetic studies of various steps revealed distinct rate limiting events for each of the promoter, which also differed markedly in their characteristics from the respective promoters of Mycobacterium smegmatis. Surprisingly, the transcription at gyr promoter was enhanced in the presence of initiating nucleotides and decreased in the presence of alarmone, pppGpp, a pattern typically seen with rRNA promoters studied so far. The gyr promoter of M. smegmatis, on the other hand, was not subjected to pppGpp mediated regulation. The marked differences in the transcription initiation pathway seen with rrn and gyr promoters of M. smegmatis and M. tuberculosis suggest that such species specific differences in the regulation of expression of the crucial housekeeping genes could be one of the key determinants contributing to the differences in growth rate and lifestyle of the two organisms. Moreover, the distinct rate limiting steps during transcription initiation of each one of the promoters studied point at variations in their intracellular regulation.

Ensemble Bayesian analysis of bistability in a synthetic transcriptional switch

An overarching goal of synthetic and systems biology is to engineer and understand complex biochemical systems by rationally designing and analyzing their basic component interactions. Practically, the extent to which such reductionist approaches can be applied is unclear especially as the complexity of the system increases. Toward gradually increasing the complexity of systematically engineered systems, programmable synthetic circuits operating in cell-free in vitro environments offer a valuable testing ground for principles for the design, characterization, and analysis of complex biochemical systems. Here we illustrate this approach using in vitro transcriptional circuits ("genelets") while developing an activatable transcriptional switch motif and configuring it as a bistable autoregulatory circuit, using just four synthetic DNA strands and three essential enzymes, bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase, Escherichia coli ribonuclease H, and ribonuclease R. Fulfilling the promise of predictable system design, the thermodynamic and kinetic constraints prescribed at the sequence level were enough to experimentally demonstrate intended bistable dynamics for the synthetic autoregulatory switch. A simple mathematical model was constructed based on the mechanistic understanding of elementary reactions, and a Monte Carlo Bayesian inference approach was employed to find parameter sets compatible with a training set of experimental results; this ensemble of parameter sets was then used to predict a test set of additional experiments with reasonable agreement and to provide a rigorous basis for confidence in the mechanistic model. Our work demonstrates that programmable in vitro biochemical circuits can serve as a testing ground for evaluating methods for the design and analysis of more complex biochemical systems such as living cells.

Structural studies of arginine induced enhancement in the activity of T7 RNA polymerase

Addition of arginine enhances the activity of the enzyme T7 RNA polymerase. Different methods have been employed to understand the enhancement in the light of arginine induced alteration of the tertiary structure. The increase in activity of the enzyme reaches a maximum value around a concentration of 125 mM arginine. Fluorescence, circular dichroism and dynamic light scattering studies indicate an alteration in the tertiary structure of the enzyme. Enthalpy change as a function of input concentration of arginine to a fixed concentration of the enzyme (5 μM) shows a dip at 100 mM concentration of arginine. Differential scanning calorimetric studies of the denaturation of the enzyme in absence and presence of arginine indicates arginine induced destabilization of the C-terminal domain of the enzyme. Structural alterations induced by arginine have been compared with those induced by the denaturant guanidine hydrochloride.

Structural and biochemical characterization of linear dinucleotide analogues bound to the c-di-GMP-I aptamer

The cyclic dinucleotide c-di-GMP regulates lifestyle transitions in many bacteria, such as the change from a free motile state to a biofilm-forming community. Riboswitches that bind this second messenger are important downstream targets in this bacterial signaling pathway. The breakdown of c-di-GMP in the cell is accomplished enzymatically and results in the linear dinucleotide pGpG. The c-di-GMP-binding riboswitches must be able to discriminate between their cognate cyclic ligand and linear dinucleotides in order to be selective biological switches. It has been reported that the c-di-GMP-I riboswitch binds c-di-GMP 5 orders of magnitude better than the linear pGpG, but the cause of this large energetic difference in binding is unknown. Here we report binding data and crystal structures of several linear c-di-GMP analogues in complex with the c-di-GMP-I riboswitch. These data reveal the parameters for phosphate recognition and the structural basis of linear dinucleotide binding to the riboswitch. Additionally, the pH dependence of binding shows that exclusion of pGpG is not due to the additional negative charge on the ligand. These data reveal principles that, along with published work, will contribute to the design of c-di-GMP analogues with properties desirable for use as chemical tools and potential therapeutics.

Biphasic association of T7 RNA polymerase and a nucleotide analogue, cibacron blue as a model to understand the role of initiating nucleotide in the mechanism of enzyme action

T7 RNA polymerase (T7 RNAP) is an enzyme that utilizes ribonucleotides to synthesize the nascent RNA chain in a template-dependent manner. Here we have studied the interaction of T7 RNAP with cibacron blue, an anthraquinone monochlorotriazine dye, its effect on the function of the enzyme and the probable mode of binding of the dye. We have used difference absorption spectroscopy and isothermal titration calorimetry to show that the dye binds T7 RNAP in a biphasic manner. The first phase of the binding is characterized by inactivation of the enzyme. The second binding site overlaps with the common substrate-binding site of the enzyme. We have carried out docking experiment to map the binding site of the dye in the promoter bound protein. Competitive displacement of the dye from the high affinity site by labeled GTP and isothermal titration calorimetry of high affinity GTP bound enzyme with the dye suggests a strong correlation between the high affinity dye binding and the high affinity GTP binding in T7 RNAP reported earlier from our laboratory.

Timing molecular motion and production with a synthetic transcriptional clock

The realization of artificial biochemical reaction networks with unique functionality is one of the main challenges for the development of synthetic biology. Due to the reduced number of components, biochemical circuits constructed in vitro promise to be more amenable to systematic design and quantitative assessment than circuits embedded within living organisms. To make good on that promise, effective methods for composing subsystems into larger systems are needed. Here we used an artificial biochemical oscillator based on in vitro transcription and RNA degradation reactions to drive a variety of "load" processes such as the operation of a DNA-based nanomechanical device ("DNA tweezers") or the production of a functional RNA molecule (an aptamer for malachite green). We implemented several mechanisms for coupling the load processes to the oscillator circuit and compared them based on how much the load affected the frequency and amplitude of the core oscillator, and how much of the load was effectively driven. Based on heuristic insights and computational modeling, an "insulator circuit" was developed, which strongly reduced the detrimental influence of the load on the oscillator circuit. Understanding how to design effective insulation between biochemical subsystems will be critical for the synthesis of larger and more complex systems.

Synthetic in vitro transcriptional oscillators

A fundamental goal of synthetic biology is to understand design principles through engineering biochemical systems.

Three in vitro synthetic transcriptional oscillators were constructed and analyzed: a two-node-negative feedback oscillator, an amplified negative-feedback oscillator, and a three-node ring oscillator.

The in vitro oscillators are governed by similar design principles as previous theoretical studies and synthetic oscillators in vivo.

Because of unintended reactions that arise even without the complexity of living cells, several challenges remain for predictive and robust oscillator performance.

Fundamental goals for synthetic biology are to understand the principles of biological circuitry from an engineering perspective and to establish engineering methods for creating biochemical circuitry to control molecular processes—both in vitro and in vivo (Benner and Sismour, 2005; Adrianantoandro et al, 2006). Here, we make use of a previously proposed class of in vitro biochemical systems, transcriptional circuits, that can be modularly wired into arbitrarily complex networks by changing the regulatory and coding sequence domains of DNA templates (Kim et al, 2006; Subsoontorn et al 2011). Using design motifs for inhibitory and excitatory regulations, three different oscillator designs were constructed and characterized: a two-switch negative-feedback oscillator, loosely analogous to the p53–Mdm2-feedback loop (Bar-Or et al, 2000); the same oscillator augmented with a positive-feedback loop, loosely analogous to a synthetic relaxation oscillator (Atkinson et al, 2003); and a three-switch ring oscillator analogous to the repressilator (Elowitz and Leibler, 2000).

DNA and RNA hybridization reactions (Figure 1B) can be assembled to create either an inhibitable switch (Figure 1A, right and bottom) with a threshold set by the total concentration of its DNA activator strand (Figure 1C, bottom), or an activatable switch (Figure 1A, left and top) with a threshold set by its DNA inhibitor strand concentration (Figure 1C, top). This threshold mechanism is analogous to biological threshold mechanisms such as ‘inhibitor ultrasensitivity' (Ferrell, 1996) and ‘molecular titration' (Buchler and Louis, 2008). Using these design motifs, we constructed a two-switch negative-feedback oscillator (Figure 1A, inset): RNA activator rA1 activates the production of RNA inhibitor rI2 by modulating switch Sw21, while RNA inhibitor rI2, in turn, inhibits the production of RNA activator rA1 by modulating switch Sw12. A total of seven DNA strands are used, in addition to the two enzymes, bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase and Escherichia coli ribonuclease H. The fact that such a negative-feedback loop can lead to temporal oscillations can be seen from a mathematical model of transcriptional networks. Experimental results showed qualitative agreement with predicted oscillator behavior from simple model simulations.

The fully optimized system revealed five complete oscillation cycles with a nearly 50% amplitude swing (Figure 3A) until, after ∼20 h, the production rate could no longer be sustained in the batch reaction. Gel measurements verified oscillations in RNA concentrations and switch states (Figure 3B and C). However to our surprise, rather than oscillations with constant amplitude and constant mean, the RNA inhibitor concentration builds up after each cycle. An extended mathematical model that incorporated an interference reaction from ‘waste' product (Figure 3B and C) could qualitatively capture this behavior.

Using a new autoregulatory switch Sw11, we added a positive-feedback loop to the two-node oscillator to make an amplified negative feedback oscillator (Design II, Figure 1D). Further, we replaced the excitatory connection of Sw21 by a chain of two inhibitory connections, Sw23 and Sw31, to construct a three-switch ring oscillator (Design III, Figure 1D). All three oscillator designs could be tuned to reach the oscillatory regime in parameter space.

Reassuringly, our in vitro oscillators exhibit several design principles previously observed in vivo. (1) Introducing delay in a simple negative-feedback loop can help achieve stable oscillation (Novák and Tyson, 2008; Stricker et al, 2008). (2) The addition of a positive-feedback self-loop to a negative-feedback oscillator provides access to rich dynamics and improved tunability (Tsai et al, 2008). (3) Oscillations in biochemical ring oscillators (such as the repressilator) are sensitive to parameter asymmetry among individual components (Tuttle et al, 2005). (4) The saturation of degradation machinery and the management of waste products could play an important role.

However, several significant difficulties remain for predictive and robust oscillator performances: limited lifetime of closed batch reactions, interference from waste products, and asymmetry of switch components make quantitative modeling and predictio difficult. As a complementary approach to top-down view of systems biology, cell-free in vitro systems offer a valuable training ground to create and explore increasingly interesting and powerful information-based chemical systems (Simpson, 2006). In vitro oscillators could be used to orchestrate other chemical processes such as DNA nanomachines (Dittmer and Simmel, 2004) and to provide embedded controllers within prototype artificial cells (Noireaux and Libchaber, 2004; Griffiths and Tawfik, 2006).

The construction of synthetic biochemical circuits from simple components illuminates how complex behaviors can arise in chemistry and builds a foundation for future biological technologies. A simplified analog of genetic regulatory networks, in vitro transcriptional circuits, provides a modular platform for the systematic construction of arbitrary circuits and requires only two essential enzymes, bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase and Escherichia coli ribonuclease H, to produce and degrade RNA signals. In this study, we design and experimentally demonstrate three transcriptional oscillators in vitro. First, a negative feedback oscillator comprising two switches, regulated by excitatory and inhibitory RNA signals, showed up to five complete cycles. To demonstrate modularity and to explore the design space further, a positive-feedback loop was added that modulates and extends the oscillatory regime. Finally, a three-switch ring oscillator was constructed and analyzed. Mathematical modeling guided the design process, identified experimental conditions likely to yield oscillations, and explained the system's robust response to interference by short degradation products. Synthetic transcriptional oscillators could prove valuable for systematic exploration of biochemical circuit design principles and for controlling nanoscale devices and orchestrating processes within artificial cells.

Fluorescence-based assay to measure the real-time kinetics of nucleotide incorporation during transcription elongation

Understanding the mechanism and fidelity of transcription by the RNA polymerase (RNAP) requires measurement of the dissociation constant (K(d)) of correct and incorrect NTPs and their incorporation rate constants (k(pol)). Currently, such parameters are obtained from radiometric-based assays that are both tedious and discontinuous. Here, we report a fluorescence-based assay for measuring the real-time kinetics of single-nucleotide incorporation during transcription elongation. The fluorescent adenine analogue 2-aminopurine was incorporated at various single positions in the template or the nontemplate strand of the promoter-free elongation substrate. On addition of the correct NTP to the T7 RNAP-DNA, 2-aminopurine fluorescence increased rapidly and exponentially with a rate constant similar to the RNA extension rate obtained from the radiometric assay. The fluorescence stopped-flow assay, therefore, provides a high-throughput way to measure the kinetic parameters of RNA synthesis. Using this assay, we report the k(pol) and K(d) of all four correct NTP additions by T7 RNAP, which showed a range of values of 145-190 s(-1) and 28-124 μM, respectively. The fluorescent elongation substrates were used to determine the misincorporation kinetics as well, which showed that T7 RNAP discriminates against incorrect NTP both at the nucleotide binding and incorporation steps. The fluorescence-based assay should be generally applicable to all DNA-dependent RNAPs, as they use similar elongation substrates. It can be used to elucidate the mechanism, fidelity, and sequence dependency of transcription and is a rapid means to screen for inhibitors of RNAPs for therapeutic purposes.

Quantifying transcription of clinically relevant immobilized DNA within a continuous flow microfluidic reactor

Flow-through reactors are commonly used to control and optimize reagent delivery and product removal. Although recent research suggests that transcription reactions using picogram quantities of cDNA produce RNA efficiently in a flow-through microreactor, there has not been a detailed study on the mass transport and reagent dependence of microfluidic transcription reactions. We present a novel microreactor that contains H5 influenza cDNA immobilized directly onto the reactor walls to study the kinetics and reagent dependence of in vitro transcription reactions on a microfluidic platform. Enzyme and the rNTP substrate continuously flow over the cDNA and create RNA, which flows to a downstream collection well. Using nanogram quantities of cDNA, we found that enzyme limiting conditions caused by the concentration of cDNA in a small-volume microreactor channel may be partially overcome as the enzyme binds and concentrates near the channel wall. Kinetics confirm this phenomenon and show that the timescale for enzyme binding can be approximated by t(f) = cDNA/Q[E]. Surprisingly, on-chip transcription reactions have a strong dependence on the rNTP concentration from 5 to 9 mM despite a low consumption rate of rNTP molecules that is largely independent of the flow rate. Faster flow rates decrease the time it takes to fill DNA promoter sites with enzyme while additionally refreshing rNTP and MgCl(2) to allow for a greater consumption of rNTP. These two effects cause reactions with higher concentrations of cDNA in the reactor channel to have a greater dependence on the flow rate. At high flow rates (>0.37 nL/s), the reaction rate begins to drop, likely because of the release and escape of enzyme molecules from the cDNA layer. This critical flow rate can be predicted by a new modified Peclet number, Pe(m) = L(c)V/D, where L(c) is the full length of the tightly packed cDNA molecules, V is the velocity at the DNA/fluid interface, and D is the diffusivity of the enzyme molecule. Together, these insights can inspire reactor designs for a variety of applications.

Incorporation of the fluorescent ribonucleotide analogue tCTP by T7 RNA polymerase

Fluorescent RNA is an important analytical tool in medical diagnostics, RNA cytochemistry, and RNA aptamer development. We have synthesized the fluorescent ribonucleotide analogue 1,3-diaza-2-oxophenothiazine-ribose-5'-triphosphate (tCTP) and tested it as substrate for T7 RNA polymerase in transcription reactions, a convenient route for generating RNA in vitro. When transcribing a guanine, T7 RNA polymerase incorporates tCTP with 2-fold higher catalytic efficiency than CTP and efficiently polymerizes additional NTPs onto the tC. Remarkably, T7 RNA polymerase does not incorporate tCTP with the same ambivalence opposite guanine and adenine with which DNA polymerases incorporate the analogous dtCTP. While several DNA polymerases discriminated against a d(tC-A) base pair only by factors <10, T7 RNA polymerase discriminates against tC-A base pair formation by factors of 40 and 300 when operating in the elongation and initiation mode, respectively. These catalytic properties make T7 RNA polymerase an ideal tool for synthesizing large fluorescent RNA, as we demonstrated by generating a approximately 800 nucleotide RNA in which every cytosine was replaced with tC.

Comparison of promoter-specific events during transcription initiation in mycobacteria

DNA-protein interactions that occur during transcription initiation play an important role in regulating gene expression. To initiate transcription, RNA polymerase (RNAP) binds to promoters in a sequence-specific fashion. This is followed by a series of steps governed by the equilibrium binding and kinetic rate constants, which in turn determine the overall efficiency of the transcription process. We present here the first detailed kinetic analysis of promoter-RNAP interactions during transcription initiation in the sigma(A)-dependent promoters P(rrnAPCL1), P(rrnB) and P(gyr) of Mycobacterium smegmatis. The promoters show comparable equilibrium binding affinity but differ significantly in open complex formation, kinetics of isomerization and promoter clearance. Furthermore, the two rrn promoters exhibit varied kinetic properties during transcription initiation and appear to be subjected to different modes of regulation. In addition to distinct kinetic patterns, each one of the housekeeping promoters studied has its own rate-limiting step in the initiation pathway, indicating the differences in their regulation.

Minimal RNA aptamer sequences that can inhibit or alleviate noncompetitive inhibition of the muscle-type nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

Combinatorially synthesized nucleotide polymers have been used during the last decade to find ligands that bind to specific sites on biological molecules, including membrane-bound proteins such as the nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAChRs). The neurotransmitter receptors belong to a group of four structurally related proteins that regulate signal transmission between ~10(11) neurons of the mammalian nervous system. The nAChRs are inhibited by compounds such as the anticonvulsant MK-801 [(+)-dizocilpine] and abused drugs such as cocaine. Based on predictions arising from the mechanism of receptor inhibition by MK-801 and cocaine, we developed two classes of RNA aptamers: class I members, which inhibit the nAChR, and class II members, which alleviate inhibition of the receptor by MK-801 and cocaine. The systematic evolution of ligands by the exponential enrichment (SELEX) method was used to obtain these compounds. Here, we report that we have truncated RNA aptamers in each class to determine the minimal nucleic acid sequence that retains the characteristic function for which the aptamer was originally selected. We demonstrate that a truncated class I aptamer containing a sequence of seven nucleotides inhibits the nAChR and that a truncated class II aptamer containing a sequence of only four nucleotides can alleviate MK-801 inhibition.

Real-time observation of the transition from transcription initiation to elongation of the RNA polymerase

The transition from initiation to elongation of the RNA polymerase (RNAP) is an important stage of transcription that often limits the production of the full-length RNA. Little is known about the RNAP transition kinetics and the steps that dictate the transition rate, because of the challenge in monitoring subpopulations of the transient and heterogeneous transcribing complexes in rapid and real time. Here, we have dissected the complete transcription initiation pathway of T7 RNAP by using kinetic modeling of RNA synthesis and by determining the initiation (IC) to elongation (EC) transition kinetics at each RNA polymerization step using single-molecule and stopped-flow FRET methods. We show that the conversion of IC to EC in T7 RNAP consensus promoter occurs only after 8- to 12-nt synthesis, and the 12-nt synthesis represents a critical juncture in the transcriptional initiation pathway when EC formation is most efficient. We show that the slow steps of transcription initiation, including DNA scrunching/RNAP-promoter rotational changes during 5- to 8-nt synthesis, not the major conformational changes, dictate the overall rate of EC formation in T7 RNAP and represent key steps that regulate the synthesis of full-length RNA.

Steric effects and mass-transfer limitations surrounding amplification reactions on immobilized long and clinically relevant DNA templates

DNA and RNA are commonly captured on solid substrates during purification and isolation, where they can be transferred to downstream amplification and transcription reactions. When compared to the solution phase, however, immobilized DNA- and RNA-directed reactions are less efficient because of a variety of complex factors. Steric inhibition because of the bead surface and neighboring biological polymers, a change in solution chemistry because of the high local concentration of template molecules, and mass transfer to the bead surface could all affect the overall reaction kinetics. Furthermore, these effects may be particularly evident when working with long clinically relevant molecules, such as mRNA, viral RNA, and cDNA. In this paper, we focus on the in vitro transcription reaction (IVT) of both a long and short strand of H5 influenza A RNA (1777 and 465 nt) on both free and immobilized DNA templates to study these phenomena. We found that transcription was less efficient on immobilized beads than in solution, but that it can be dramatically increased with optimal solution chemistry. Using high ribonucleotide concentrations (>6 mM total rNTP), the RNA yield from long immobilized cDNA templates was boosted to 60% of solution control. Surprisingly, we found that steric effects because of surrounding immobilized molecules were only significant when the DNA molecules were short enough to achieve a high density (9x10(-4) microm2/molecule) on the silica substrate, such that the gap between molecules is on the order of the polymerase diameter. Eventually, these findings can be exploited in an automated microreactor, where isolation, purification, amplification, and detection of nucleic acids can be unified into one portable device.

Transcription initiation in a single-subunit RNA polymerase proceeds through DNA scrunching and rotation of the N-terminal subdomains

Elucidating the mechanism of transcription initiation by RNA polymerases (RNAP) is essential for understanding gene transcription and regulation. Although several models, such as DNA scrunching, RNAP translation, and RNAP rotation, have been proposed, the mechanism of initiation by T7 RNAP has remained unclear. Using ensemble and single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) studies, we provide evidence for concerted DNA scrunching and rotation during initiation by T7 RNAP. A constant spatial distance between the upstream and downstream edges of initiation complexes making 4-7 nt RNA supports the DNA scrunching model, but not the RNAP translation or the pure rotation model. DNA scrunching is accompanied by moderate hinging motion (18 degrees +/- 4 degrees ) of the promoter toward the downstream DNA. The observed stepwise conformational changes provide a basis to understand abortive RNA synthesis during early stages of initiation and promoter escape during the later stages that allows transition to processive elongation.

The transition to an elongation complex by T7 RNA polymerase is a multistep process

During the transition from an initiation complex to an elongation complex (EC), T7 RNA polymerase undergoes major conformational changes that involve reorientation of a "core" subdomain as a rigid body and extensive refolding of other elements in the 266 residue N-terminal domain. The pathway and timing of these events is poorly understood. To examine this, we introduced proline residues into regions of the N-terminal domain that become alpha-helical during the reorganization and changed the charge of a key residue that interacts with the RNA:DNA hybrid 5 bp upstream of the active site in the EC but not in the initiation complex. These alterations resulted in a diminished ability to make products >5-7 nt and/or a slow transition through this point. The results indicate that the transition to an EC is a multistep process and that the movement of the core subdomain and reorganization of certain elements in the N-terminal domain commence prior to promoter release (at 8-9 nt).

Effects of discontinuities in the DNA template on abortive initiation and promoter escape by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

Using singly gapped or nicked templates containing the T7A1 promoter, we have measured several kinetic parameters related to the process of transcription initiation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase, confirming and extending previous results using a population of randomly gapped templates. A reduced probability of transcript abortion at RNA lengths of 6 and 7 nucleotides and a lower ratio of abortive to productive initiation events was observed for some discontinuous templates, consistent with models attributing abortive initiation to the accumulation of strain in the initiating complex. The effect of DNA discontinuity on abortion of shorter RNA transcripts (2-3 nucleotides) was less pronounced; abortion at these short chain lengths may primarily be attributed to the low stability of the RNA-DNA hybrid. Certain discontinuities had significant effects on the intrinsic catalytic capacity of the open complex and also on the partitioning between productive and unproductive complexes, suggesting that subtle changes in the conformation of the open complex can profoundly affect its function. The rate and efficiency of promoter escape were not correlated with the stability of the open promoter complex despite previous suggestions to the contrary. We conclude that the stability of the open promoter complex is only one of several factors that contribute to the overall rate of promoter escape.

Kinetic analysis of the entire RNA amplification process by Qbeta replicase

The kinetics of the RNA replication reaction by Qbeta replicase were investigated. Qbeta replicase is an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase responsible for replicating the RNA genome of coliphage Qbeta and plays a key role in the life cycle of the Qbeta phage. Although the RNA replication reaction using this enzyme has long been studied, a kinetic model that can describe the entire RNA amplification process has yet to be determined. In this study, we propose a kinetic model that is able to account for the entire RNA amplification process. The key to our proposed kinetic model is the consideration of nonproductive binding (i.e. binding of an enzyme to the RNA where the enzyme cannot initiate the reaction). By considering nonproductive binding and the notable enzyme inactivation we observed, the previous observations that remained unresolved could also be explained. Moreover, based on the kinetic model and the experimental results, we determined rate and equilibrium constants using template RNAs of various lengths. The proposed model and the obtained constants provide important information both for understanding the basis of Qbeta phage amplification and the applications using Qbeta replicase.

Construction of an in vitro bistable circuit from synthetic transcriptional switches

Information processing using biochemical circuits is essential for survival and reproduction of natural organisms. As stripped-down analogs of genetic regulatory networks in cells, we engineered artificial transcriptional networks consisting of synthetic DNA switches, regulated by RNA signals acting as transcription repressors, and two enzymes, bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase and Escherichia coli ribonuclease H. The synthetic switch design is modular with programmable connectivity and allows dynamic control of RNA signals through enzyme-mediated production and degradation. The switches support sharp and adjustable thresholds using a competitive hybridization mechanism, allowing arbitrary analog or digital circuits to be created in principle. As an example, we constructed an in vitro bistable memory by wiring together two synthetic switches and performed a systematic quantitative characterization. Good agreement between experimental data and a simple mathematical model was obtained for switch input/output functions, phase plane trajectories, and the bifurcation diagram for bistability. Construction of larger synthetic circuits provides a unique opportunity for evaluating model inference, prediction, and design of complex biochemical systems and could be used to control nanoscale devices and artificial cells.

Transient state kinetics of transcription elongation by T7 RNA polymerase

The single subunit DNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RNAP) from bacteriophage T7 catalyzes both promoter-dependent transcription initiation and promoter-independent elongation. Using a promoter-free substrate, we have dissected the kinetic pathway of single nucleotide incorporation during elongation. We show that T7 RNAP undergoes a slow conformational change (0.01-0.03 s(-1)) to form an elongation competent complex with the promoter-free substrate (dissociation constant (Kd) of 96 nM). The complex binds to a correct NTP (Kd of 80 microM) and incorporates the nucleoside monophosphate (NMP) into RNA primer very efficiently (220 s(-1) at 25 degrees C). An overall free energy change (-5.5 kcal/mol) and internal free energy change (-3.7 kcal/mol) of single NMP incorporation was calculated from the measured equilibrium constants. In the presence of inorganic pyrophosphate (PPi), the elongation complex catalyzes the reverse pyrophosphorolysis reaction at a maximum rate of 0.8 s(-1) with PPi Kd of 1.2 mM. Several experiments were designed to investigate the rate-limiting step in the pathway of single nucleotide addition. Acid-quench and pulse-chase kinetics indicated that an isomerization step before chemistry is rate-limiting. The very similar rate constants of sequential incorporation of two nucleotides indicated that the steps after chemistry are fast. Based on available data, we propose that the preinsertion to insertion isomerization of NTP observed in the crystallographic studies of T7 RNAP is a likely candidate for the rate-limiting step. The studies here provide a kinetic framework to investigate structure-function and fidelity of RNA synthesis and to further explore the role of the conformational change in nucleotide selection during RNA synthesis.

Mechanism of instability in abortive cycling by T7 RNA polymerase

Abortive transcription, the premature release of short transcripts 2-8 bases in length, is a unique feature of transcription, accompanying the transition from initiation to elongation in all RNA polymerases. The current study focuses on major factors that relate to the stability of initially transcribing abortive complexes in T7 RNA polymerase. Building on previous studies, results reveal that collapse of the DNA from the downstream end of the bubble is a major contributor to the characteristic instability of abortive complexes. Furthermore, transcription from a novel DNA construct containing a nick between positions -14 and -13 of the nontemplate strand suggests that the more flexible promoter reduces somewhat the strain inherent in initially transcribing complexes, with a resulting decrease in abortive product release. Finally, as assessed by exonuclease III footprinting and transcription profiles, a DNA construct defective in bubble collapse specifically from the downstream end exhibits less abortive cycling and little perturbation of the final transition to elongation, including the process of promoter release.

Sequential release of promoter contacts during transcription initiation to elongation transition

Bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase undergoes major conformational changes as transcription proceeds from initiation to elongation. Using limited trypsin digestion and stopped-flow fluorescence kinetic methods, we have monitored promoter release, initial bubble collapse, and refolding of the 152-205 region (subdomain H), the latter being important for RNA channel formation. The kinetic studies show that the conformational changes are temporally coupled, commencing at the synthesis of 9 nt and completing by the synthesis of 12 nt of RNA. The temporal coupling of initial bubble collapse and RNA channel formation is proposed to facilitate proper binding of the RNA dissociated from the late initiation complexes into the RNA channel. Using promoter mutations, we have determined that promoter contacts are broken sequentially during transition from initiation to elongation. The specificity loop interactions are broken after synthesis of 8 nt or 9 nt of RNA, whereas the upstream promoter contacts persists up to synthesis of 12 nt of RNA. Both promoter contacts need to be broken for transition into elongation. The A-15C mutation resulted in efficient transition to elongation by synthesis of 9 nt of RNA, whereas the C-9A mutation resulted in early transition to elongation by synthesis of 7-8 nt of RNA. The effect of early promoter clearance in the mutant promoters was observed as reduced production of long abortive products.

Different de novo initiation strategies are used by influenza virus RNA polymerase on its cRNA and viral RNA promoters during viral RNA replication

Various mechanisms are used by single-stranded RNA viruses to initiate and control their replication via the synthesis of replicative intermediates. In general, the same virus-encoded polymerase is responsible for both genome and antigenome strand synthesis from two different, although related promoters. Here we aimed to elucidate the mechanism of initiation of replication by influenza virus RNA polymerase and establish whether initiation of cRNA and viral RNA (vRNA) differed. To do this, two in vitro replication assays, which generated transcripts that had 5' triphosphate end groups characteristic of authentic replication products, were developed. Surprisingly, mutagenesis screening suggested that the polymerase initiated pppApG synthesis internally on the model cRNA promoter, whereas it initiated pppApG synthesis terminally on the model vRNA promoter. The internally synthesized pppApG could subsequently be used as a primer to realign, by base pairing, to the terminal residues of both the model cRNA and vRNA promoters. In vivo evidence, based on the correction of a mutated or deleted residue 1 of a cRNA chloramphenicol acetyltransferase reporter construct, supported this internal initiation and realignment model. Thus, influenza virus RNA polymerase uses different initiation strategies on its cRNA and vRNA promoters. To our knowledge, this is novel and has not previously been described for any viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase. Such a mechanism may have evolved to maintain genome integrity and to control the level of replicative intermediates in infected cells.

Direct observation of abortive initiation and promoter escape within single immobilized transcription complexes

Using total-internal-reflection fluorescence microscopy equipped with alternating-laser excitation, we were able to detect abortive initiation and promoter escape within single immobilized transcription complexes. Our approach uses fluorescence resonance energy transfer to monitor distances between a fluorescent probe incorporated in RNA polymerase (RNAP) and a fluorescent probe incorporated in DNA. We observe small, but reproducible and abortive-product-length-dependent, decreases in distance between the RNAP leading edge and DNA downstream of RNAP upon abortive initiation, and we observe large decreases in distance upon promoter escape. Inspection of population distributions and single-molecule time traces for abortive initiation indicates that, at a consensus promoter, at saturating ribonucleoside triphosphate concentrations, abortive-product release is rate-limiting (i.e., abortive-product synthesis and RNAP-active-center forward translocation are fast, whereas abortive-product dissociation and RNAP-active-center reverse translocation are slow). The results obtained using this new methodology confirm and extend those obtained from diffusing single molecules, and pave the way for real-time, single-molecule observations of the transitions between various states of the transcription complex throughout transcription.

Major conformational changes during T7RNAP transcription initiation coincide with, and are required for, promoter release

During transcription initiation conformational changes in the transcriptional machinery are required to accommodate the growing RNA, to allow the polymerase to release the promoter, and to endow the elongation complex with high processivity. In T7 RNA polymerase these changes involve refolding and reorientation of elements of the N-terminal domain, as well as changes in how the DNA is bound within the complex. However, when and where these conformational changes occur is unknown, and the role of these changes in allowing the polymerase to disengage the promoter is poorly understood. To address this we have used chemical nucleases tethered to the polymerase to monitor conformational changes, and engineered disulfide bonds to block conformational changes at defined steps in transcription. We find that many of the major structural transitions occur cooperatively, at a point coincident with promoter release. Moreover, promoter release requires that two elements of the polymerase which form a continuous promoter recognition surface in the initial transcription complex move apart: if this movement is blocked the polymerase cannot disengage the promoter.

Normal modes for predicting protein motions: a comprehensive database assessment and associated Web tool

We carry out an extensive statistical study of the applicability of normal modes to the prediction of mobile regions in proteins. In particular, we assess the degree to which the observed motions found in a comprehensive data set of 377 nonredundant motions can be modeled by a single normal-mode vibration. We describe each motion in our data set by vectors connecting corresponding atoms in two crystallographically known conformations. We then measure the geometric overlap of these motion vectors with the displacement vectors of the lowest-frequency mode, for one of the conformations. Our study suggests that the lowest mode contains useful information about the parts of a protein that move most (i.e., have the largest amplitudes) and about the direction of this movement. Based on our findings, we developed a Web tool for motion prediction (available from http://molmovdb.org/nma) and apply it here to four representative motions--from bacteriorhodopsin, calmodulin, insulin, and T7 RNA polymerase.

A mutation in T7 RNA polymerase that facilitates promoter clearance

Like multisubunit RNA polymerases (RNAPs), T7 RNAP frequently releases its transcript over the initial 8-12 transcribed nucleotides, when it still contacts the promoter. This abortive cycling, which is most prominent with initial sequences that deviate from those of T7 late genes, eventually compromises productive transcription. Starting from an in vivo situation where transcription of a target gene by T7 RNAP is virtually abolished because of extensive abortive cycling, we have selected a mutation in RNAP that restores target gene expression. In vitro, this mutation (P266L) weakens promoter binding but markedly reduces abortive cycling over a variety of initial sequences by stabilizing the transcription complex at nucleotides 5-8. Other substitutions of P266 have similar effects. X-ray data show that during the transition from initial to elongation complex, the N-terminal region undergoes a major structural switch of which P266 constitutes one of the hinges. How the mutation might facilitate this switch is tentatively discussed. On the practical side, the mutation can significantly improve in vitro transcription, particularly from templates carrying unfavorable initial sequences.

Multiple roles for the T7 promoter nontemplate strand during transcription initiation and polymerase release

Transcription initiation begins with recruitment of an RNA polymerase to a promoter. Polymerase-promoter interactions are retained until the nascent RNA is extended to 8-12 nucleotides. It has been proposed that accumulation of "strain" in the transcription complex and RNA displacement of promoter-polymerase interactions contribute to releasing the polymerase from the promoter, and it has been further speculated that too strong a promoter interaction can inhibit the release step, whereas a weak interaction may facilitate release. We examined the effects of partial deletion of the nontemplate strand on release of T7 RNA polymerase from the T7 promoter. T7 polymerase will initiate from such partially single-stranded promoters but binds them with higher affinity than duplex promoters. We found that release on partially single-stranded promoters is strongly inhibited. The inhibition of release is not due to an indirect effect on transcription complex structure or loss of specific polymerase-nontemplate strand interactions, because release on partially single-stranded templates is recovered if the interaction with the promoter is weakened by a promoter base substitution. This same substitution also appears to allow the polymerase to escape more readily from a duplex promoter. Our results further suggest that template-nontemplate strand reannealing drives dissociation of abortive transcripts during initial transcription and that loss of interactions with either the nontemplate strand or duplex DNA downstream of the RNA lead to increased transcription complex slippage during initiation.

RNA displacement and resolution of the transcription bubble during transcription by T7 RNA polymerase

Unlike DNA polymerases, RNA polymerases (RNAPs) must displace the nascent product from the template and restore the DNA to duplex form after passage of the transcription complex. To accomplish this, RNAPs establish a locally denatured "bubble" that encloses a short RNA:DNA hybrid. As the polymerase advances along the template, the RNA is displaced at the trailing edge of the bubble and the two DNA strands are reannealed. Structural analyses have revealed a number of elements that are likely to be involved in this process in T7 RNAP. In this work, we used genetic and biochemical methods to explore the roles of these elements during the transition from an initiation complex to an elongation complex. The results indicate that the transition is a multistep process and reveal a critical role for the nontemplate strand of the DNA.

Initial bubble collapse plays a key role in the transition to elongation in T7 RNA polymerase

RNA polymerases bind to specific sequences in DNA, melt open duplex DNA around the start site, and start transcription within the initially melted bubble. The initially transcribing complex is relatively unstable, releasing short abortive products. After synthesis of a minimal length of RNA (approximately 10-12 bases in the T7 system), RNA polymerases complete the transition to a processive (highly stable) elongation phase and lose the initial promoter contacts. The current study strongly supports a model for T7 RNA polymerase in which initial bubble collapse from position -4 to position +3 is responsible for initiating RNA displacement in the transition process. More specifically, collapse of the bubble from position -4 to position -1 indirectly and energetically facilitates the direct strand invasion offered by collapse at positions +1 to +3. Parallel work shows that promoter release, another key event occurring during this stage of transcription, begins after translocation to position +8 and is largely complete upon translocation to about position +12. The timing of promoter release agrees with the timing of initial bubble collapse determined by our previous fluorescence studies, suggesting that these two events are closely related.

T7 Lysozyme Represses T7 RNA Polymerase Transcription by Destabilizing the Open Complex during Initiation

Bacteriophage T7 lysozyme binds to T7 RNA polymerase and inhibits transcription initiation and the transition from initiation to elongation. We have investigated each step of transcription initiation to determine where T7 lysozyme has the most effect. Stopped flow and equilibrium DNA binding studies indicate that T7 lysozyme does not inhibit the formation of the preinitiation open complex (open complex in the absence of initiating nucleotide). T7 lysozyme, however, does prevent the formation of a fully open initiation complex (open complex in the presence of the initiating nucleotide). This is consistent with the results that in the presence of T7 lysozyme the rate of G ladder RNA synthesis is about 5-fold slower and the GTP Kd is about 2-fold higher, but T7 lysozyme does not inhibit the initial rate of RNA synthesis with a premelted bulge-6 promoter (bubble from -4 to +2). Neither the RNA synthesis rate nor the extent of promoter opening is restored by increasing the initiating nucleotide concentration, indicating that T7 lysozyme represses transcription by interfering with the formation of a stable and a fully open initiation bubble or by altering the structure of the DNA in the initiation complex. As a consequence of the unstable initiation bubble and/or the inhibition of the conformational changes in the N-terminal domain of T7 RNAP, T7 lysozyme causes an increased production of abortive products from 2- to 5-mer that delays the transition from the initiation to the elongation phase.