Are compatible solutes compatible with biological treatment of saline wastewater? Batch and continuous studies using submerged anaerobic membrane bioreactors (SAMBRs)

Acute impact of salinity and C/N ratio on the formation and properties of soluble microbial products from activated sludge

The present study investigated the shock of NaCl and C/N ratio on properties of soluble microbial products (SMPs), focusing on their sized fractions. The results indicated that the NaCl stress increased the content of biopolymers, humic substances, building blocks, and LMW substances in SMPs, while the addition of 40 g NaCl L^-1 significantly changed their relative abundance in SMPs. The acute impact of both N-rich and N-deficient conditions accelerated the secretion of SMPs, but the characteristics of LMW substances differed. Meanwhile, the bio-utilization of SMPs has been enhanced with the increase of NaCl dosage but decreased with the increase of the C/N ratio. The mass balance of sized fractions in SMPs + EPS could be set up when NaCl dosage <10 g/L and C/N ratio >5, which indicates the hydrolysis of sized fractions in EPS mainly compensated for their increase/reduction in SMPs. Besides, the results of the toxic assessment indicated that the oxidative damage caused by the NaCl shock was an important factor affecting the property of SMPs, and the abnormal expression of DNA transcription cannot be neglected for bacteria metabolisms with the change of C/N ratio.

Mitigating the detrimental effects of salt stress on anammox process: A comparison between glycine betaine and mannitol

The use of seawater to alleviate water shortages causes an increase of salinity in municipal pipe networks, posing challenges for biological wastewater treatment. The impacts of two compatible solutes on the anammox process under salt stress (20 g L^-1) were compared here at the genetic and microbial levels. The findings revealed that both 0.3 mM glycine betaine (GB) and mannitol (MA) could alleviate the salt stress on anammox process, with GB exhibiting a better effect. Specifically, the addition of GB recovered the nitrogen removal efficiency (NRE) from 40 % to >80 % within 13 days. The addition of MA caused the reduction of the absolute abundance of hdh and hzsA, implying that 0.6 mM was not the optimal concentration. Moreover, salt stress induced an increase in the absolute abundance of nitrification functional genes and a decrease in the abundance of denitrification functional genes. Notably, compared with the initial level, the abundance of Candidatus Kuenenia increased by 7.1 % and 4.3 % after adding GB and MA, respectively. According to the network analysis, two compatible solutes promoted the bacterial interactions in anammox systems, which promoted the nitrogen circulation and further the nitrogen removal performance. This work provides a feasible strategy to relieve the salt stress on anammox process and then facilitates its application for treating saline wastewater.

Osmoprotectants boost adaptation and protect methanogenic microbiome during ammonia toxicity events in continuous processes

Different osmoprotectants were used to counteract ammonia toxicity in continuous anaerobic reactors. The anaerobic microbiome osmoadaptation process and its role to the methanogenic recovery are also assessed. Three osmoprotectants (i.e., glycine betaine, MgCl2 and KCl) were respectively introduced in continuous reactors at high ammonia levels, namely RGB, RMg, RK, while a control reactor (RCtrl) was also used. After ammonia was introduced, the RGB, RMg, RK and RCtrl suffered 39.0%, 36.6%, 39.9% and 36.2% methane production loss, respectively. Osmoprotectants addition recovered significantly methane production by up to 68.9%, 54.3% and 32.2% for RGB, RMg and RK, respectively contrary to RCtrl, where production increased only by 13.6%. The recovered methane production was maintained in RGB and RMg for at least four HRTs, even after the addition of osmoprotectants was stopped, due to the formed methanogenic microbiota by osmoadaptation process, with Methanoculleus sp. as the dominant species.

An overview of deploying membrane bioreactors in saline wastewater treatment from perspectives of microbial and treatment performance

The discharged saline wastewater has severely influenced the aquatic environment as the treatment performance of many wastewater treatment techniques is limited. In addition, the sources of saline wastewater are also plentiful from agricultural and various industrial fields such as food processing, tannery, pharmaceutical, etc. Although high salinity levels negatively impact the performance of both physicochemical and biological processes, membrane bioreactor (MBR) processes are considered as a potential technology to treat saline wastewater under different salinity levels depending on the adaption of the microbial community. Therefore, this study aims to systematically review the application of MBR widely used in the saline wastewater treatment from the perspectives of microbial structure and treatment efficiencies. At last, the concept of carbon dioxide capture and storage will be proposed for the MBR-treating saline wastewater technologies and considered toward the circular economy with the target of zero emission.

Influence of salinity on biofilm formation and COD removal efficiency in anaerobic moving bed biofilm reactors

Anaerobic digestion is widely used for wastewater treatment, but this approach often relies on microbial communities that are adversely affected by high-salinity conditions. This study investigated the applicability of an anaerobic moving bed biofilm reactor (AMBBR) to treating high-salinity wastewater. The removal performance and microbial community were examined under salinity conditions of 1000-3000 mg/L, and a soluble chemical oxygen demand (sCOD) removal efficiency of up to 8% ± 2.74% was achieved at high-salinity. Scanning electron microscopy showed that microorganisms successfully attached onto the polyvinyl alcohol gel carrier, and the extracellular polymeric substances on the biofilm increased at higher salt concentrations. The AMBBR also maintained traditionally accepted levels of total alkalinity and volatile fatty acids for stable wastewater processing under these operating conditions. High-throughput sequencing indicated that Desulfomicrobium and three methanogenic groups were the dominant contributors to sCOD removal. Overall, the results showed that the AMBBR can successfully treat fish factory wastewater under varying salinity conditions.

Insight into halotolerance of a robust heterotrophic nitrifying and aerobic denitrifying bacterium Halomonas salifodinae

Studies toward biotreating hypersaline wastewater containing different salts and halotolerant mechanism of robust strains are important but still rare. Here an isolated bacterium Halomonas salifodinae can perform simultaneous nitrification and denitrification (SND) at 15% salinity, showing high nitrogen removal efficiencies of over 98% via response surface methodology optimization. Besides NaCl, this robust strain had high resistance to other salts (KCl, Na₂SO₄, and K₂SO₄) and can efficiently remove nitrogen in saline wastewater containing heavy metals such as Fe(II), Mn(II), Zn(II), Cr(VI), Ni(II), and Cu(II). After repeated-batch culturing at different salinities, the treated strains with different halotolerant capabilities were used as single strain model to study halotolerant mechanism via metabolic analysis. The halotolerant bacterium can convert D-proline and glutamic acid to glutamine as well as lactulose to trehalose. The accumulated intracellular compatible solutes can resist high osmotic pressure and bound water molecule in hypersaline wastewater to accomplish high-efficiency SND processes.

Anammox sludge preservation: Preservative agents, temperature and substrate

The difficulties of enrichment and preservation of anaerobic ammonium oxidation bacteria (AnAOB) greatly limit their application in practice. Herein, traditional and emerging preservative agents (e.g., EPS + N2H4, betaine, glycerol and trehalose) were evaluated for their preservation of AnAOB-dominant sludge at different temperatures (e.g., 4 °C and room temperature). In addition, the effects of substrates on preservation were also considered. The results showed that adding betaine or glycerol at 4 °C was the optimal strategy for preserving anammox granular sludge. The relative anammox activities (rAA) increased by 145.26% and 158.30% at the recovery phase, respectively. Moreover, the absolute abundances of functional gene hzsA increased by 339% and 46%, respectively. Although the granular properties and microbial community structures changed during the preservation, the general performance of anammox granules could effectively restored. Collectively, this study provides the optimal strategies for anammox sludge preservation at low temperatures.

Adaptation and evolution of freshwater Anammox communities treating saline/brackish wastewater

The most common way to apply Anammox for saline wastewater treatment is via salt adaptation of freshwater Anammox bacteria (FAB). To better apply this process in practice, it's essential to understand the salt adaptation process of FBA, as well as the underlying mechanisms. This study investigated the long-term salt adaptation process of a fixed-film FAB culture in three reactors (namely R1-R3), under salinities of 2, 8, and 12 NaCl g/L, correspondingly. All three reactors were under stable operation and achieved 80-90% total inorganic nitrogen removal efficiency throughout the 425-day operation period. R1 servers as a blank control, based on the clear microbial community shifts in R2 and R3, the operation period was divided into 2 phases. During Phase 1, all FAB in the three reactors belonged to Ca. Brocadia sp.. The Anammox activity (AA) and the ratio of nitrite/ammonium (NO₂^--N/NH₄⁺-N) consumption in R2 and R3 decreased with the increase of salinity and did not recover to the initial levels. During Phase 2, the relative abundance of Ca. Kuenenia sp. in R2 and R3 increased from nearly 0 to about 60 and 77%, respectively. With the growth of Ca. Kuenenia sp., the AA and stoichiometry of R2 and R3 gradually recovered. AA of R2 and R3 both reached 1.0 g NH₄⁺-N/L/day at the end of this phase, which was about 80% of that in R1. These results indicated that the salt adaptation of FAB culture was achieved by species shift from a low salt-tolerance one to a high salt-tolerance one.

Simultaneous nitrification and denitrification of hypersaline wastewater by a robust bacterium Halomonas salifodinae from a repeated-batch acclimation

Biotreatment of hypersaline wastewater requires robust strains with high resistance to activity inhibition and even bacterium death, which remains a worldwide challenge. Here Halomonas salifodinae, a simultaneous nitrification and denitrification (SND) bacterium, was isolated by performing repeated-batch acclimation, showing efficient nitrogen removal at 0-15% salinity and low activity inhibition prominently superior to that of other strains such as Pseudomonas sp. and Acinetobacter sp. Community analysis as well as comparison of microbial activity at different salinities revealed an increased relative abundance of halotolerant populations by stimulating their salt tolerance during the repeated-batch process. For single or mixed nitrogen sources at 15% salinity, the SND efficiencies of the isolated strain reached above 95%. The high activities were attributed to the key enzymes AMO and HAO for nitrification as well as NAP and NIR for denitrification. The findings provide a promising acclimation pathway to obtain robust bacteria for biotreatment of hypersaline wastewater.

The application of glycine betaine to alleviate the inhibitory effect of salinity on one-stage partial nitritation/anammox process

One-stage partial nitritation/anammox (PN/A) has been proposed as a sustainable method for removing nitrogen from various wastewater. However, the activities of ammonium-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and anammox bacteria are often inhibited by the exposure to salinity, thereby hindering their wide application in treating industrial wastewater with high salinity. This study reports that the addition of glycine betaine (GB), which is a compatible solute, could alleviate the inhibitory effects of salinity on both AOB and anammox, thereby improving nitrogen removal performance in a one-stage PN/A system. Short-term tests showed that with an addition of GB higher than 1 mM, the activity of AOB and anammox under salinity of 30 g/L could be increased by at least 45% and 51%, respectively. The half-inhibitory concentration of AOB and anammox rose with increasing GB concentration, with 1 mM GB being the optimal cost-effective dosage. Long-term experiments also demonstrated that 1 mM GB addition could enhance nitrogen removal performance and shorten recovery time by 42.9% under a salinity stress of 30 g/L. Collectively, GB addition was found to be a feasible and effective strategy to the counteract adverse effects of salinity on PN/A process. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Glycine betaine (GB) could improving performance of the PN/A process by alleviating the inhibitory effects of salinity on both AOB and anammox bacteria. A GB concentration of 1 mM was found to be optimum in terms of effectiveness and cost. GB addition was a feasible and effective strategy to remain stabilized in the community structure of PN/A sludge. GB could optimize the nitrogen removal performance and shorten the recovery time of PN/A process under saline stress.

Recent Advances in the Rejection of Endocrine-Disrupting Compounds from Water Using Membrane and Membrane Bioreactor Technologies: A Review

Water is a critical resource necessary for life to be sustained, and its availability should be secured, appropriated, and easily obtainable. The continual detection of endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) (ng/L or µg/L) in water and wastewater has attracted critical concerns among the regulatory authorities and general public, due to its associated public health, ecological risks, and a threat to global water quality. Presently, there is a lack of stringent discharge standards regulating the emerging multiclass contaminants to obviate its possible undesirable impacts. The conventional treatment processes have reportedly ineffectual in eliminating the persistent EDCs pollutants, necessitating the researchers to develop alternative treatment methods. Occurrences of the EDCs and the attributed effects on humans and the environment are adequately reviewed. It indicated that comprehensive information on the recent advances in the rejection of EDCs via a novel membrane and membrane bioreactor (MBR) treatment techniques are still lacking. This paper critically studies and reports on recent advances in the membrane and MBR treatment methods for removing EDCs, fouling challenges, and its mitigation strategies. The removal mechanisms and the operating factors influencing the EDCs remediation were also examined. Membranes and MBR approaches have proven successful and viable to eliminate various EDCs contaminants.

Enhancement of pollutants removal from saline wastewater through simultaneous anammox and denitrification (SAD) process with glycine betaine addition

Enhanced pollutants removal from saline wastewater was investigated in simultaneous anammox and denitrification (SAD) process with glycine betaine (GB) addition. Long-term operation indicated the optimal GB dose was around 0.4 mM, which enhanced both anammox and denitrifying activity by 30% and 45%, respectively. The total nitrogen and organic removal rates were 0.38 ± 0.2 kgN/m³/d and 0.34 ± 0.3 kgCOD/m³/d, respectively, which increased by 34.5% and 20.5%. Independent of GB dose, denitrifying activity was promoted, but anammox activity was drastically deteriorated after excessive GB addition. The optimal GB dose predicated by both Gaussian and Modified-Boltzmann models were 0.42-0.45 mM. Besides, the bacterial activity recovery after excessive GB addition could be analyzed by the Modified-Boltzmann model. With 1.5 mM GB, granular floatation occurred since numerous gas bubbles were inside the granules. In general, exogenous GB addition can mitigate salinity inhibition and promote pollutants removal from saline wastewater.

Insights into Ammonia Adaptation and Methanogenic Precursor Oxidation by Genome-Centric Analysis

Ammonia released from the degradation of protein and/or urea usually leads to suboptimal anaerobic digestion (AD) when N-rich organic waste is used. However, the insights behind the differential ammonia tolerance of anaerobic microbiomes remain an enigma. In this study, the cultivation in synthetic medium with different carbon sources (acetate, methanol, formate, and H2/CO2) shaped a common initial inoculum into four unique ammonia-tolerant syntrophic populations. Specifically, various levels of ammonia tolerance were observed: consortia fed with methanol and H2/CO2 could grow at ammonia levels up to 7.25 g NH+-N/L, whereas the other two groups (formate and acetate) only thrived at 5.25 and 4.25 g NH+-N/L, respectively. Metabolic reconstruction highlighted that this divergent microbiome might be achieved by complementary metabolisms to maximize biomethane recovery from carbon sources, thus indicating the importance of the syntrophic community in the AD of N-rich substrates. Besides, sodium/proton antiporter operon, osmoprotectant/K+ regulator, and osmoprotectant synthesis operon may function as the main drivers of adaptation to the ammonia stress. Moreover, energy from the substrate-level phosphorylation and multiple energy-converting hydrogenases (e.g., Ech and Eha) could aid methanogens to balance the energy request for anabolic activities and contribute to thriving when exposed to high ammonia levels.

Metabolic acclimation of anammox consortia to decreased temperature

Widespread application of anammox process has been primarily limited to the high sensitivity of anammox consortia to fluctuations of temperature. However, the metabolic acclimation of anammox consortia to decreased temperature remains unclear, which is the core of developing potential strategies for improving their low-temperature resistance. Here, we operated anammox reactors at 25 °C and 35 °C to explore the acclimation mechanism of anammox consortia in terms of metabolic responses and cross-feedings. Accordingly, we found that the adaptation of anammox consortia to ambient temperature (25 °C) was significantly linked to energy conservation strategy, resulting in decreased extracellular polymeric substance secretion, accumulation of ATP and amino acids. The expression patterns of cold shock proteins and core enzymes caused the apparent metabolic advantage of Candidatus Brocadia fulgida for acclimation to ambient temperature compared to other anammox species. Importantly, strengthened cross-feedings of amino acids, nitrite and glycine betaine benefited adaptation of anammox consortia to ambient temperature. Our work not only uncovers the temperature-adaptive mechanisms of anammox consortia, but also emphasizes the important role of metabolic cross-feeding in the temperature adaptation of microbial community.

Cation exchange membrane behaviour of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in salt adapted granular sludge

This paper aims to elucidate the role of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in regulating anion and cation concentrations and toxicity towards microorganisms in anaerobic granular sludges adapted to low (0.22 M of Na⁺) and high salinity (0.87 M of Na⁺). The ion exchange properties of EPS were studied with a novel approach, where EPS were entangled with an inert binder (PVDF-HFP) to form a membrane and characterized in an electrodialysis cell. With a mixture of NaCl and KCl salts the EPS membrane was shown to act as a cation exchange membrane (CEM) with a current efficiency of ∼80%, meaning that EPS do not behave as ideal CEM. Surprisingly, the membrane had selectivity for transport of K⁺ compared to Na⁺ with a separation factor ( [Formula: see text] ) of 1.3. These properties were compared to a layer prepared from a model compound of EPS (alginate) and a commercial CEM. The alginate layer had a similar current efficiency (∼80%.), but even higher [Formula: see text] of 1.9, while the commercial CEM did not show selectivity towards K⁺ or Na⁺, but exhibited the highest current efficiency of 92%. The selectivity of EPS and alginate towards K⁺ transport has interesting potential applications for ion separation from water streams and should be further investigated. The anion repelling and cation binding properties of EPS in hydrated and dehydrated granules were further confirmed with microscopy (SEM-EDX, epifluorescence) and ion chromatography (ICP-OES, IC) techniques. Results of specific methanogenic activity (SMA) tests conducted with 0.22 and 0.87 M Na⁺ adapted granular sludges and with various monovalent salts suggested that ions which are preferentially transported by EPS are also more toxic towards methanogenic cells.

Coupling of electricity generation and denitrification in three-phase single-chamber MFCs in high-salt conditions

High-salt conditions reduce the efficiency of electricity generation and nitrogen removal in microbial fuel cells (MFCs). In this work, we propose a three-phase single-chamber MFC (TP-MFC) by setting up a phase with immobilized cells in a conventional bipolar single-chamber MFC (common MFC). Cells from Halomonas were used as the immobilized phase, because these cells secrete the compatible solute ectoine and exhibit simultaneous nitrification and denitrification (SND). This enhanced the efficiency of SND and subsequent electricity generation under high-salt conditions. The average voltage of TP-MFC generated during the stable period in the presence of 30 g/L NaCl was 439.3 mV, which was 55.2% higher than that generated in common MFC. In addition, the N-removal rate of TP-MFC at 72 h was 63.4%, which was 38.4% higher than that of common MFC. The 16S rRNA diversity analysis showed an improved abundance of Pseudomonas, Acinetobacter, Alcaligenes, and Halomonas in TP-MFC, indicating that the ectoine secreted by immobilized Halomonas conferred substantial salt-tolerance on the electrogenic bacteria growing in a high-salt environment. This paper establishes an efficient and convenient method for improving the salt tolerance of microbial flora in MFCs, which is of great significance for the application of MFCs in high-strength wastewater treatment.

Long-term nitrogen removal performance and kinetics of anaerobic ammonia oxidation bacteria treating nitrogen-rich saline wastewater with trehalose addition

A sequencing batch reactor was used to study long-term nitrogen removal performance of anaerobic ammonia oxidation bacteria (AnAOB) with trehalose addition treating nitrogen-rich saline wastewater. The operating temperature was controlled at 35 ± 0.5°C with influent pH of 7.5 ± 0.1. Trehalose played a significant role in enhancing long-term nitrogen removal performance. When trehalose was 0.1, 0.2, and 0.3 mM, ammonia removal efficiency (ARE) increased by 4.9%, 16.2%, and 32.4%, and nitrite removal efficiency (NRE) improved by 7.5%, 27.9%, and 42.2%, respectively. Optimal ARE and NRE were 92.4% and 97.4% achieved at 0.35 mM trehalose. Moreover, NO 2 - - N was removed completely within 2 hr at high trehalose content due to the synergistic effect resulting from AnAOB and heterotrophic denitrifying bacteria. Δ NO 2 - - N / Δ NH 4 + - N increased with trehalose addition, while Δ NO 3 - - N / Δ NH 4 + - N decreased. Compared to Δ NO 3 - - N / Δ NH 4 + - N , Δ NO 2 - - N / Δ NH 4 + - N fluctuated greatly. The remodified Logistic model and modified Gompertz model were suitable for describing nitrogen removal in an operating cycle with trehalose addition. Fitted ARE_max values were consistent with experimental values. Appropriate trehalose addition could shorten the response time of AnAOB coping with hazardous environment stress. Lag time was within 1 hr and the minimal fitted λ value got close to 0 achieved at 0.15 mM trehalose. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Trehalose enhanced nitrogen removal of AnAOB in saline wastewater treatment. Optimal ARE and NRE were 92.4% and 97.4% achieved at 0.35 mM trehalose. Remodified Logistic and Gompertz models can analyze nitrogen removal with trehalose. Appropriate trehalose can shorten response time of AnAOB coping with salt stress.

The potential of osmolytes and their precursors to alleviate osmotic stress of anaerobic granular sludge

Increasing amounts of saline (waste)water with high concentrations of organic pollutants are generated globally. In the anaerobic (waste)water treatment domain, high salt concentrations are repeatedly reported to inhibit methanogenic activity and strategies to overcome this toxicity are needed. Current research focuses on the use of potential osmolyte precursor compounds for osmotic stress alleviation in granular anaerobic sludges upon exposure to hypersalinity shocks. Glutamic acid, aspartic acid, lysine, potassium, gelatine, and tryptone were tested for their potential to alleviate osmotic stress in laboratory grown and full - scale granular sludge. The laboratory grown granular sludge was adapted to 5 (R5) and 20 (R20) g Na⁺/L. Full-scale granular sludge was obtained from internal circulation reactors treating tannery (waste)water with influent conductivity of 29.2 (Do) and 14.1 (Li) mS/cm. In batch experiments which focused on specific methanogenic activity (SMA), R5 granular sludge was exposed to a hypersalinity shock of 20 g Na⁺/L. The granular sludge of Do and Li was exposed to a hypersalinity shock of 10 g Na⁺/L with sodium acetate as the sole carbon source. The effects on R20 granular sludge were studied at the salinity level to which the sludge was already adapted, namely 20 g Na⁺/L. Dosing of glutamic acid, aspartic acid, gelatine, and tryptone resulted in increased SMA compared to only acetate fed batches. In batches with added glutamic acid, the SMA increased by 115% (Li), 35% (Do) and 9% (R20). With added aspartic acid, SMA increased by 72% (Li), 26% (Do), 12% (R5) and 7% (R20). The addition of tryptone resulted in SMA increases of 36% (R5), 17% (R20), 179% (Li), and 48% (Do), whereas added gelatine increased the SMA by 30% (R5), 14% (R20), 23% (Li), and 13% (Do). The addition of lysine, meanwhile, gave negative effects on SMA of all tested granular sludges. Potassium at sea water Na/K ratio (27.8 w/w) had a slight positive effect on SMA of Do (7.3%) and Li (10.1%), whereas at double the sea water ratio (13.9% w/w) had no pronounced positive effect. R20 granular sludge was also exposed to hyposalinity shock from 20 down to 5 g Na⁺/L. Glutamate and N-acetyl-β-lysine were excreted by microbial consortium in anaerobic granular sludge adapted to 20 g Na⁺/L upon this exposure to hyposalinity. A potential consequence when applying these results is that saline streams containing specific and hydrolysable proteins can be anaerobically treated without additional dosing of osmolytes.

Increased salinity improves the thermotolerance of mesophilic anammox consortia

While the application of anammox-based process for mesophilic sidestream treatment is at present the state of the art and mainstream treatment at ambient temperature is also in development, the feasibility of thermophilic anammox process is still unclear. This study investigated the effects of salinity on the thermotolerance of mesophilic anammox sludge. In batch activity tests, 45 °C seems to be the critical temperature for the tolerance of mesophilic anammox consortia without acclimatization or amendments. The optimal anammox activity at 40, 42.5, and 45 °C can be achieved with the amendment of salt at 5-8, 8-10, and ~12 g NaCl L^-1, respectively. However, this improvement effect was limited at 50 °C or when the shock duration was longer than 24 h even at 45 °C. In continuous-flow bioreactors, mesophilic anammox consortia could gradually adapt to 40-50 °C under a transition of 2.5 °C, and the performance was enhanced by an increase in salinity, which may be associated with the increase in extracellular polymeric substances. A nitrogen removal rate of 0.53 kgN m^-3 d^-1 was finally obtained at 50 °C. Overall, these interesting results facilitate further opportunities for thermophilic anammox process.

Is anammox a promising treatment process for nitrogen removal from nitrogen-rich saline wastewater?

Rapidly growing discharge of nitrogen-rich saline wastewater has significantly affect environment. However, due to the inhibition resulting from high salinity on microbes, it is still a challenge to treat nitrogen-rich saline wastewater efficiently. Anammox process, as a cost-effective and environment-friendly nitrogen removal approach, has shown a potential in treating nitrogen-rich saline wastewater. This review is conducted from a critical perspective and provides a comprehensive overview on the performance of anammox process treating nitrogen-rich saline wastewater. Two strategies including freshwater-derived anammox bacteria acclimatization and marine anammox bacteria enrichment are evaluated. Second, effects resulting from salinity on the performance of anammox reactor, the microbial communities and sludge characteristics are discussed. Third, salinity-tolerant mechanism of anammox bacteria is analyzed. This review also reveals some critical knowledge gaps and future research needs, which benefits application of anammox process to treat nitrogen-rich saline wastewater.

Advanced membrane bioreactors systems: New materials and hybrid process design

Membrane bioreactor (MBR) is deemed as one of the most powerful technologies for efficient municipal and industrial wastewater treatment around the world. However, low microbial activity of activated sludge and serious membrane fouling still remain big challenges in worldwide application of MBR technology. Nowadays, more and more progresses on the research and development of advanced MBR with new materials and hybrid process are just on the way. In this paper, an overview on the perspective of high efficient strains applied into MBR for biological activity enhancement and fouling reduction is provided first. Secondly, as emerging fouling control strategy, design and fabrication of novel anti-fouling composited membranes are comprehensively highlighted. Meanwhile, hybrid MBR systems integrated with some novel dynamic membrane modules and/or with other technologies like advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) are introduced and compared. Finally, the challenges and opportunities of advanced MBRs combined with bioenergy production in wastewater treatment are discussed.

Effects of temperature on anammox performance and community structure

A lab-scale anammox up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) reactor was run to investigate the influence of temperature on anammox performance and community structure. The anammox system had a higher substrate tolerance at 13 °C than at 18 °C. The adverse effects caused by the use of a lower temperature (8 °C) could be restored. The nitrogen removal rate (NRR) decreased with decreasing in situ specific anammox activity (SAA). Interestingly, the ex situ SAA acclimated at 23 °C, when exposed to ex situ temperatures of 33 and 28 °C, was higher than for those acclimated at 33 and 28 °C. No shift was observed in the optimum temperature for ex situ SAA in the whole lowering process of anammox UASB. More extracellular polymeric substances were produced in response to cooler conditions (18 °C and 13 °C). Ca. Kuenenia became much more abundant (55.18% of the microbial community) and had a competitive advantage over other anammox bacteria (AnAOB) at 13 °C.

Fast anaerobic sludge granulation at elevated salinity

It is commonly accepted that high salt concentrations negatively affect microbial activity in biological wastewater treatment reactors such as upflow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) reactors. Microbial aggregation in such reactors is equally important. It is well documented that anaerobic granules, when exposed to high salinity become weak and disintegrate, causing wash-out, operational problems and decreasing process performance. In this research, the possibility of microbial granule formation from dispersed biomass was investigated at salinity levels of 5 and 20 g Na⁺/L. High removal efficiencies of soluble influent organics were achieved at both salinity levels and this was accompanied by fast and robust formation of microbial granules. The process was found to be stable for the entire operational period of 217 days. As far as we know this is the first time it has been demonstrated that stable granule formation is possible at a salinity level as high as 20 g Na⁺/L. Methanosaeta was identified as the dominant methanogen at both salinity levels. Streptococcus spp. and bacteria belonging to the family Lachnospiraceae were identified as the dominant microbial population at 5 and 20 and g Na⁺/L, respectively.

Microbial fuel cells in saline and hypersaline environments: Advancements, challenges and future perspectives

This review is aimed to report the possibility to utilize microbial fuel cells for the treatment of saline and hypersaline solutions. An introduction to the issues related with the biological treatment of saline and hypersaline wastewater is reported, discussing the limitation that characterizes classical aerobic and anaerobic digestions. The microbial fuel cell (MFC) technology, and the possibility to be applied in the presence of high salinity, is discussed before reviewing the most recent advancements in the development of MFCs operating in saline and hypersaline conditions, with their different and interesting applications. Specifically, the research performed in the last 5years will be the main focus of this review. Finally, the future perspectives for this technology, together with the most urgent research needs, are presented.

Biofilm formation and granule properties in anaerobic digestion at high salinity

For the anaerobic biological treatment of saline wastewater, Anaerobic Digestion (AD) is currently a possibility, even though elevated salt concentrations can be a major obstacle. Anaerobic consortia and especially methanogenic archaea are very sensitive to fluctuations in salinity. When working with Upflow Sludge Blanket Reactor (UASB) technology, in which the microorganisms are aggregated and retained in the system as a granular biofilm, high sodium concentration negatively affects aggregation and consequently process performances. In this research, we analysed the structure of the biofilm and granules formed during the anaerobic treatment of high salinity (at 10 and 20 g/L of sodium) synthetic wastewater at lab scale. The acclimated inoculum was able to accomplish high rates of organics removal at all the salinity levels tested. 16S rRNA gene clonal analysis and Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization (FISH) analyses identified the acetoclastic Methanosaeta harundinacea as the key player involved acetate degradation and microbial attachment/granulation. When additional calcium (1 g/L) was added to overcome the negative effect of sodium on microbial aggregation, during the biofilm formation process microbial attachment and acetate degradation decreased. The same result was observed on granules formation: while calcium had a positive effect on granules strength when added to UASB reactors, Methanosaeta filaments were not present and the degradation of the partially acidified substrate was negatively influenced. This research demonstrated the possibility to get granulation at high salinity, bringing to the forefront the importance of a selection towards Methanosaeta cells growing in filamentous form to obtain strong and healthy granules.

Nitrogen removal performance and operation strategy of anammox process under temperature shock

Sequencing batch reactors were used to study anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) process under temperature shock. Both long-term (15-35 °C) and short-term (10-50 °C) temperature effects on nitrogen removal performance were performed. In reactor operation test, the results indicated that ammonium removal rate decreased from 0.35 kg/(m³ day) gradually to 0.059 kg/(m³ day) when temperature dropped from 35 to 15 °C. Although bacteria morphology was not modified, sludge settling velocity decreased with decreasing temperature. In batch test, apparent activation energy (E_a) increased with decreasing temperature, which suggested the activity decrease of anaerobic ammonium oxidizing bacteria (AAOB). Low temperature inhibited AAOB and weakened nitrogen removal performance. The cardinal temperature model with inflection was first used to describe temperature effect on anammox process. Simulated results revealed that anammox reaction could occur at 10.52-50.15 °C with maximum specific anammox activity of 0.50 kg/(kg day) at 36.72 °C. The cold acclimatization of AAOB could be achieved and glycine betaine could slightly improve nitrogen removal performance at low temperature.

Short-Term Exposure of Paddy Soil Microbial Communities to Salt Stress Triggers Different Transcriptional Responses of Key Taxonomic Groups

Soil salinization due to seawater intrusion along coastal areas is an increasing threat to rice cultivation worldwide. While the detrimental impact on rice growth and yield has been thoroughly studied, little is known about how severe salinity affects structure and function of paddy soil microbial communities. Here, we examined their short-term responses to half- and full-strength seawater salinity in controlled laboratory experiments. Slurry microcosms were incubated under anoxic conditions, with rice straw added as carbon source. Stress exposure time was for 2 days after a pre-incubation period of 7 days. Relative to the control, moderate (300 mM NaCl) and high (600 mM NaCl) salt stress suppressed both net consumption of acetate and methane production by 50% and 70%, respectively. Correspondingly, community-wide mRNA expression decreased by 50–65%, with significant changes in relative transcript abundance of family-level groups. mRNA turnover was clearly more responsive to salt stress than rRNA dynamics. Among bacteria, Clostridiaceae were most abundant and the only group whose transcriptional activity was strongly stimulated at 600 mM NaCl. In particular, clostridial mRNA involved in transcription/translation, fermentation, uptake and biosynthesis of compatible solutes, and flagellar motility was significantly enriched in response salt stress. None of the other bacterial groups were able to compete at 600 mM NaCl. Their responses to 300 mM NaCl were more diverse. Lachnospiraceae increased, Ruminococcaceae maintained, and Peptococcaceae, Veillonellaceae, and Syntrophomonadaceae decreased in relative mRNA abundance. Among methanogens, Methanosarcinaceae were most dominant. Relative to other family-level groups, salt stress induced a significant enrichment of transcripts related to the CO dehydrogenase/acetyl-coenzyme A synthase complex, methanogenesis, heat shock, ammonium uptake, and thermosomes, but the absolute abundance of methanosarcinal mRNA decreased. Most strikingly, the transcriptional activity of the Methanocellaceae was completely suppressed already at 300 mM NaCl. Apparently, the key taxonomic groups involved in the methanogenic breakdown of plant polymers significantly differ in their ability to cope with severe salt stress. Presumably, this different ability is directly linked to differences in their genetic potential and metabolic flexibility to reassign available energy resources for cellular adaptation to salt stress.

Effects of pressurized aeration on organic degradation efficiency and bacterial community structure of activated sludge treating saline wastewater

This study was aimed to investigate the effect of moderate pressure on organic matter removal efficiency and microbial population of activated sludge treating saline wastewater. The activated sludge was cultivated with a gradual increase of salt concentrations under gage pressure of 0.3MPa for 71days. Microbial diversities of activated sludge sampled in different stages of domestication were investigated by Illumina sequencing technology. Results showed that pressurized aeration could improve the treatment efficiency and the dehydrogenase activity (DHA) of activated sludge, especially at high salinity (35, 50gNaClL^-1). Bacterial richness and community diversity of activated sludge in the pressurized reactor were significantly higher than those in the control reactor. Microbial population structures were quite different between the two reactors. More species originating from fresh wastewater biological treatment process would survive and remain in pressurized activated sludge.

The effect of salinity on waste activated sludge alkaline fermentation and kinetic analysis

The effect of salinity on sludge alkaline fermentation at low temperature (20°C) was investigated, and a kinetic analysis was performed. Different doses of sodium chloride (NaCl, 0-25g/L) were added into the fermentation system. The batch-mode results showed that the soluble chemical oxygen demand (SCOD) increased with salinity. The hydrolysate (soluble protein, polysaccharide) and the acidification products (short chain fatty acids (SCFAs), NH4(+)-N, and PO4(3-)-P) increased with salinity initially, but slightly declined respectively at higher level salinity (20g/L or 20-25g/L). However, the hydrolytic acidification performance increased in the presence of salt compared to that without salt. Furthermore, the results of Haldane inhibition kinetics analysis showed that the salt enhanced the hydrolysis rate of particulate organic matter from sludge particulate and the specific utilization of hydrolysate, and decreased the specific utilization of SCFAs. Pearson correlation coefficient analysis indicated that the importance of polysaccharide on the accumulation of SCFAs was reduced with salt addition, but the importance of protein and NH4(+)-N on SCFA accumulation was increased.

Bioaugmentation and its application in wastewater treatment: A review

Bioaugmentation (the process of adding selected strains/mixed cultures to wastewater reactors to improve the catabolism of specific compounds, e.g. refractory organics, or overall COD) is a promising technique to solve practical problems in wastewater treatment plants, and enhance removal efficiency. The potential of this option can now be enhanced in order to take advantage of important advances in the fields of microbial ecology, molecular biology, immobilization techniques and advanced bioreactor design. Reports on bioaugmentation in WWT show the difficulties in evaluating the potential parameters involved, leading frequently to inconclusive outcomes. Many studies have been carried out on the basis of trial-and-error approaches, and it has been reported that reactors bioaugmented with pure cultures often fail to perform as well as the pure cultures under laboratory conditions. As an interesting technical challenge, the feasibility of bioaugmentation should ultimately be assessed by data from field implementation, and this review highlights several promising areas to explore in the future.

Correlation between microbial community structure and biofouling as determined by analysis of microbial community dynamics

Three lab-scale membrane bioreactors (MBRs) were continuously operated to treat saline wastewater under 0%, 0.75% and 1.5% NaCl stress. 0.75% and 1.5% NaCl reduced the COD and NH4(+)-N removal at the beginning, while the removal efficiencies could be recovered along with the operation of MBRs. Also, the polysaccharide in extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and soluble microbial products (SMP) played an important role in the membrane fouling. Illumina sequencing of 16S rRNA gene showed that the increasing level of salinity reduced the diversity of the microbial community, and a higher salinity stimulated the growth of Bacteroidetes. At genus level, Flavobacterium, Aequorivita, Gelidibacter, Microbacterium, and Algoriphagus increased with the increase of salinity, which are shown to be highly salt tolerant. The strength of salinity or the duration of salinity could stimulate the microorganisms with similar functions, and the changes of polysaccharide in EPS and SMP were closely related to the membrane fouling rate as well as correlated with some saline-resistance genera.

Trehalose promotes Rhodococcus sp. strain YYL colonization in activated sludge under tetrahydrofuran (THF) stress

Few studies have focused on the role of compatible solutes in changing the microbial community structure in bioaugmentation systems. In this study, we investigated the influence of trehalose as a biostimulant on the microbial community in tetrahydrofuran (THF)-treated wastewater bioaugmentation systems with Rhodococcus sp. YYL. Functional gene profile changes were used to study the variation in the microbial community. Soluble di-iron monooxygenases (SDIMO), particularly group-5 SDIMOs (i.e., tetrahydrofuran and propane monooxygenases), play a significant role in the initiation of the ring cleavage of tetrahydrofuran. Group-5 SDIMOs genes are enriched upon trehalose addition, and exogenous tetrahydrofuran monooxygenase (thmA) genes can successfully colonize bioaugmentation systems. Cytochrome P450 monooxygenases (P450s) have a significant role in catalyzing the region- and stereospecific oxidation of non-activated hydrocarbons, and THF was reported to inhibit P450s in the environment. The CYP153 family was chosen as a representative P450 to study the inhibitory effects of THF. The results demonstrated that CYP153 family genes exhibited significant changes upon THF treatment and that trehalose helped maintain a rich diversity and high abundance of CYP153 family genes. Biostimulation with trehalose could alleviate the negative effects of THF stress on microbial diversity in bioaugmentation systems. Our results indicated that trehalose as a compatible solute plays a significant role for environmental strains under extreme conditions.

Enhancement of anammox activity by addition of compatible solutes at high salinity conditions

The enhancement effect of compatible solutes on anammox activity under salinity stress was investigated. Glycine betaine (GB) was the most effective in alleviating salt toxicity, although all the compatible solutes (GB, trehalose and ectoine) were found to be valid. Acclimation potential of anammox biomass under salinity of 30 g/L increased significantly with GB addition. The recovery time in the reactor with GB addition (RB) (49 days) accompanied by a more stable stoichiometric ratio was 2.65 times shorter than in the control reactor (RC) (130 days). After 49 days, the extracellular polymeric substances and the tetrazolium chloride-dehydrogenase activity were 217.9 mg/g VSS and 38.7 μg TF/g VSS/h in RB, 1.86 times lower and 3.17 times higher than the levels in RC, respectively. RB possessed evident superiority in the aspects of microbial population proportion. And thus, compatible solutes addition was regarded as one of the feasible solution to counteract saline inhibition on anammox.

Improving methane production and phosphorus release in anaerobic digestion of particulate saline sludge from a brackish aquaculture recirculation system

In this study, batch tests were conducted to examine the effects of trehalose and glycine betaine as well as potassium on the specific methanogenic activity (SMA), acid and alkaline phosphatase activity of anaerobic biomass and phosphorus release in anaerobic digestion of saline sludge from a brackish recirculation aquaculture system. The results of ANOVA and Tukey's HSD (honestly significant difference) tests showed that glycine betaine and trehalose enhanced SMA of anaerobic biomass and reactive phosphorus release from the particulate waste. Moreover, SMA tests revealed that methanogenic sludge, which was long-term acclimatized to a salinity level of 17 g/L was severely affected by the increase in salinity to values exceeding 35 g/L. Addition of compatible solutes, such as glycine betaine and trehalose, could be used to enhance the specific methane production rate and phosphorus release in anaerobic digestion from particulate organic waste produced in marine or brackish aquaculture recirculation systems.

Potentials and limitations of biomethane and phosphorus recovery from sludges of brackish/marine aquaculture recirculation systems: a review

Brackish/marine recirculation aquaculture systems (RAS) produce a relatively small but concentrated waste stream. The produced waste is perceived as a constraint for sustainable development of brackish/marine RAS. Appropriate disposal of sludge or waste from brackish/marine RAS is of great importance for widespread acceptance and implementation. Anaerobic stabilization of RAS sludge is considered as a potential cost-effective methodology to achieve effective sludge reduction and biogas production. Therefore, this review presents an overview of studies conducted on anaerobic digestion of sludge from brackish/marine RAS. Several researchers have shown that specific methane yield (SMY) of anaerobic digestion of sludges from brackish/marine RAS is relatively low, mainly in the range of 0.001-0.184 m(3) CH4 (STP)/kg COD of sludge added. The possible reasons for low SMY are reviewed in this work and can be mainly attributed to applied experimental set-ups, particularly improper inoculum, and high salinity, mainly resulting from high sodium cation levels. This review also evaluates the potentials and limitations for phosphorus recovery from the waste streams. Additionally, corresponding approaches to enhance specific methanogenic activities are proposed, particularly about the need for further thickening sludges from brackish/marine RAS in order to increase SMY from the wastes and downsize the anaerobic digestion units.

Dry anaerobic digestion of food waste under mesophilic conditions: performance and methanogenic community analysis

The performance of dry anaerobic digestion (AD) of food waste was investigated under mesophilic conditions and the methanogenic community was investigated using 454 pyrosequencing. Stable dry AD was achieved by hydraulic retention time (HRT) control without the addition of alkali agents. The average CH4 production rate, CH4 content, and volatile solid reduction rate were 2.51±0.17m(3)/m(3)/d, 66±2.1%, and 65.8±1.22%, respectively, at an HRT of 40d. The methanogenic community of the seed sludge experienced a significant reduction in genus diversity from 18 to 4 and a dominant methanogenic shift from hydrogenotrophic to acetoclastic groups after the acclimation under dry condition. Almost all sequences of the dry anaerobic digester were closely related with those of Methanosarcina thermophila with similarity of 96.4-99.1%. The experimental results would serve as useful information to understand the dry AD system.

Overcoming sodium toxicity by utilizing grass leaves as co-substrate during the start-up of batch thermophilic anaerobic digestion

Sodium toxicity is a common problem causing inhibition of anaerobic digestion, and digesters treating highly concentrated wastes, such as food and municipal solid waste, and concentrated animal manure, are likely to suffer from partial or complete inhibition of methane-producing consortia, including methanogens. When grass clippings were added at the onset of anaerobic digestion of acetate containing a sodium concentration of 7.8 gNa(+)/L, a total methane production about 8L/L was obtained, whereas no methane was produced in the absence of grass leaves. In an attempt to narrow down which components of grass leaves caused decrease of sodium toxicity, different hypotheses were tested. Results revealed that betaine could be a significant compound in grass leaves causing reduction to sodium inhibition.

Methanosarcina: the rediscovered methanogen for heavy duty biomethanation

Anaerobic digestion is an important technology in the framework of renewable energy production. The anaerobic digestion system is susceptible to perturbations due to the sensitivity of the methanogens towards environmental factors. Currently, technology is evolving from conventional waste treatment, i.e. the removal of pollutants, to very intensive biogas production from concentrated wastes, in the framework of bio-energy production. In the latter configuration Methanosarcina species appear to be of crucial importance. Methanosarcina sp. are, compared to other methanogens, quite robust towards different impairments. They are reported to be tolerant to total ammonium concentrations up to 7000 mg L(-1), salt concentrations up to 18,000 mg Na(+)L(-1), a pH shock of 0.8-1.0 units and acetate concentrations up to 15,000 mg CODL(-1). The possibilities of Methanosarcina sp. as key organisms in specific types of anaerobic digestion systems are demonstrated in this review.

Impacts of transient salinity shock loads on Anammox process performance

The effect of salinity shock (5-60 g l(-1) NaCl) on anaerobic ammonium oxidation (Anammox) process performance was investigated. The response to the shock loads can be divided into three stages: a sensitive period, an interim stable period and a recovery period which lasted 6-26 d. When exposed to NaCl shocks for 12h, the sludge retention time (SRT) of the reactor decreased with increasing NaCl shock loads, ranging between 2.9 and 22.5d, meanwhile the biomass decreased by 0.8-37.4%. When shock loads were higher than 10 g l(-1) NaCl, the reactor was at risk of losing too much biomass. The granular surface was rough due to rapid growth of filamentous bacteria and extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), also the EPS amount changed during all NaCl shock loads. In the latter of shocks, the microorganisms in the reactor showed a little adaption to the NaCl shock.

Wastewater treatment in a submerged anaerobic membrane bioreactor

Although most membrane bioreactors are used under aerobic conditions, over the last few years there has been increased interest in their application for anaerobic processes. This paper presents the results obtained when a bench-scale submerged anaerobic membrane bioreactor was used for the treatment of wastewaters generated in the agro-food industry. The reactor was fed with synthetic wastewater consisting of cheese whey and sucrose, and volumetric organic loading rates (OLRs) ranging from 1.5 to 13 kgCOD/(m(3)*d) were applied. Under the operating conditions studied, the maximum applicable OLR was between 6 and 10 gCOD/(g*L), which fell within the ranges of the high-rate anaerobic wastewater treatment systems, while high concentrations of volatile fatty acids were produced at higher OLR rates. With an OLR of 1.5-10 gCOD/(g*L), the reactor showed 94% COD removal, whereas this value dropped to 33% with the highest applied OLR of 13 gCOD/(g*L). The study therefore confirms that membrane bioreactors can be used for anaerobic wastewater treatment.