Investigating metalloenzyme reactions using electrochemical sweeps and steps: fine control and measurements with reactants ranging from ions to gases

The oxygen reactivity of an artificial hydrogenase designed in a reengineered copper storage protein

The O₂ reactivity of an artificial biomolecular hydrogenase, the nickel binding protein (NBP) is investigated.

Hydrogenases

Hydrogenases catalyze the simple yet important interconversion between H₂ and protons and electrons. Found throughout prokaryotes, lower eukaryotes, and archaea, hydrogenases are used for a variety of redox and signaling purposes and are found in many different forms. This diverse group of metalloenzymes is divided into [NiFe], [FeFe], and [Fe] variants, based on the transition metal contents of their active sites. A wide array of biochemical and spectroscopic methods has been used to elucidate hydrogenases, and this along with a general description of the main enzyme types and catalytic mechanisms is discussed in this chapter.

Implementation of photobiological H2 production: the O 2 sensitivity of hydrogenases

The search for the ultimate carbon-free fuel has intensified in recent years, with a major focus on photoproduction of H2. Biological sources of H2 include oxygenic photosynthetic green algae and cyanobacteria, both of which contain hydrogenase enzymes. Although algal and cyanobacterial hydrogenases perform the same enzymatic reaction through metallo-clusters, their hydrogenases have evolved separately, are expressed differently (transcription of algal hydrogenases is anaerobically induced, while bacterial hydrogenases are constitutively expressed), and display different sensitivity to O2 inactivation. Among various physiological factors, the sensitivity of hydrogenases to O2 has been one of the major factors preventing implementation of biological systems for commercial production of renewable H2. This review addresses recent strategies aimed at engineering increased O2 tolerance into hydrogenases (as of now mainly unsuccessful), as well as towards the development of methods to bypass the O2 sensitivity of hydrogenases (successful but still yielding low solar conversion efficiencies). The author concludes with a description of current approaches from various laboratories to incorporate multiple genetic traits into either algae or cyanobacteria to jointly address limiting factors other than the hydrogenase O2 sensitivity and achieve more sustained H2 photoproduction activity.

Investigations of the efficient electrocatalytic interconversions of carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide by nickel-containing carbon monoxide dehydrogenases

Carbon monoxide dehydrogenases (CODH) play an important role in utilizing carbon monoxide (CO) or carbon dioxide (CO2) in the metabolism of some microorganisms. Two distinctly different types of CODH are distinguished by the elements constituting the active site. A Mo-Cu containing CODH is found in some aerobic organisms, whereas a Ni-Fe containing CODH (henceforth simply Ni-CODH) is found in some anaerobes. Two members of the simplest class (IV) of Ni-CODH behave as efficient, reversible electrocatalysts of CO2/CO interconversion when adsorbed on a graphite electrode. Their intense electroactivity sets an important benchmark for the standard of performance at which synthetic molecular and material electrocatalysts comprised of suitably attired abundant first-row transition elements must be able to operate. Investigations of CODHs by protein film electrochemistry (PFE) reveal how the enzymes respond to the variable electrode potential that can drive CO2/CO interconversion in each direction, and identify the potential thresholds at which different small molecules, both substrates and inhibitors, enter or leave the catalytic cycle. Experiments carried out on a much larger (Class III) enzyme CODH/ACS, in which CODH is complexed tightly with acetyl-CoA synthase, show that some of these characteristics are retained, albeit with much slower rates of interfacial electron transfer, attributable to the difficulty in making good electronic contact at the electrode. The PFE results complement and clarify investigations made using spectroscopic investigations.

A unified electrocatalytic description of the action of inhibitors of nickel carbon monoxide dehydrogenase

Several small molecules and ions, notably carbon monoxide, cyanide, cyanate, and hydrogen sulfide, are potent inhibitors of Ni-containing carbon monoxide dehydrogenases (Ni-CODH) that catalyze very rapid, efficient redox interconversions of CO(2) and CO. Protein film electrochemistry, which probes the dependence of steady-state catalytic rate over a wide potential range, reveals how these inhibitors target particular oxidation levels of Ni-CODH relating to intermediates (C(ox), C(red1), and C(red2)) that have been established for the active site. The following properties are thus established: (1) CO suppresses CO(2) reduction (CO is a product inhibitor), but its binding affinity decreases as the potential becomes more negative. (2) Cyanide totally inhibits CO oxidation, but its effect on CO(2) reduction is limited to a narrow potential region (between -0.5 and -0.6 V), below which CO(2) reduction activity is restored. (3) Cyanate is a strong inhibitor of CO(2) reduction but inhibits CO oxidation only within a narrow potential range just above the CO(2)/CO thermodynamic potential--EPR spectra confirm that cyanate binds selectively to C(red2). (4) Hydrogen sulfide (H(2)S/HS(-)) inhibits CO oxidation but not CO(2) reduction--the complex on/off characteristics are consistent with it binding at the same oxidation level as C(ox) and forming a modified version of this inactive state rather than reacting directly with C(red1). The results provide a new perspective on the properties of different catalytic intermediates of Ni-CODH--uniting and clarifying many previous investigations.

Intermediates in the catalytic cycle of [NiFe] hydrogenase: functional spectroscopy of the active site

The [NiFe] hydrogenase from the anaerobic sulphate reducing bacterium Desulfovibrio vulgaris Miyazaki F is an excellent model for constructing a mechanism for the function of the so-called 'oxygen-sensitive' hydrogenases. The present review focuses on spectroscopic investigations of the active site intermediates playing a role in the activation/deactivation and catalytic cycle of this enzyme as well as in the inhibition by carbon monoxide or molecular oxygen and the light-sensitivity of the hydrogenase. The methods employed include magnetic resonance and vibrational (FTIR) techniques combined with electrochemistry that deliver information about details of the geometrical and electronic structure of the intermediates and their redox behaviour. Based on these data a mechanistic scheme is developed.

Dynamic electrochemical investigations of hydrogen oxidation and production by enzymes and implications for future technology

This tutorial review describes studies of hydrogen production and oxidation by biological catalysts--metalloenzymes known as hydrogenases--attached to electrodes. It explains how the electrocatalytic properties of hydrogenases are studied using specialised electrochemical techniques and how the data are interpreted to allow assessments of catalytic rates and performance under different conditions, including the presence of O2, CO and H2S. It concludes by drawing some comparisons between the enzyme active sites and platinum catalysts and describing some novel proof-of-concept applications that demonstrate the high activities and selectivities of these 'alternative' catalysts for promoting H2 as a fuel.

Hydrogen production under aerobic conditions by membrane-bound hydrogenases from Ralstonia species

Studies have been carried out to establish the ability of O2-tolerant membrane-bound [NiFe] hydrogenases (MBH) from Ralstonia sp. to catalyze H2 production in addition to H2 oxidation. These hydrogenases are not noted for H2-evolution activity, and this is partly due to strong product inhibition. However, when adsorbed on a rotating disk graphite electrode the enzymes produce H2 efficiently, provided the H2 product is continuously removed by rapidly rotating the electrode and flowing N2 through the gastight electrochemical cell. Electrocatalytic H2 production proceeds with minimal overpotentiala significant observation because lowering the overpotential (the electrochemically responsive activation barrier) is seen as crucial in developing small-molecule catalysts for H2 production. A mutant having a high KM for H2 oxidation did not prove to be a better H2 producer relative to the wild type, thus suggesting that weak binding of H2 does not itself confer a tendency to be a H2 producer. Inhibition by H2 is much stronger than inhibition by CO and, most significantly, even O2. Consequently, H2 can be produced sustainably in the presence of O2 as long as the H2 is removed continuously, thereby proving the feasibility for biological H2 production in air.

Iron-only hydrogenase mimics. Thermodynamic aspects of the use of electrochemistry to evaluate catalytic efficiency for hydrogen generation

Voltammetry is widely used for the evaluation of iron-only hydrogenase mimics and other potential catalysts for hydrogen generation using various dipolar aprotic solvents. Effective catalysts show enhanced current in the presence of a proton donor at the potential where the catalyst is reduced. To facilitate the comparison of catalytic efficiencies, this paper provides a simple means of calculating the standard potential for reduction of the acid, HA, according to the half reaction 2HA + 2e- <==> H2 + 2A-. This standard potential depends on the pKa of HA in the solvent being used. It is thermodynamically impossible for reduction of HA to occur at less negative potentials than the standard potential, and the most effective catalysts will operate at potentials as close as possible to the standard potential. In addition, direct reduction of HA at the electrode will compete with the catalyzed reduction, thus complicating evaluation of the rate of the catalyzed reaction. Glassy carbon electrodes, commonly used in such evaluations, show a quite large overpotential for direct reduction of HA so that the necessary corrections are small. However, catalysis at very negative potentials will be contaminated by significant direct reduction of HA at glassy carbon. It is demonstrated that direct reduction can be almost completely suppressed by using a mercury or amalgamated gold electrode, even at very negative potentials.

Electricity from low-level H2 in still air--an ultimate test for an oxygen tolerant hydrogenase

We demonstrate an extreme test of O(2) tolerance for a biological hydrogen-cycling catalyst: the generation of electricity from just 3% H(2) released into still, ambient air using an open fuel cell comprising an anode modified with the unusual hydrogenase from Ralstonia metallidurans CH34, that oxidizes trace H(2) in atmospheric O(2), connected via a film of electrolyte to a cathode modified with the fungal O(2) reductase, laccase.

Voltammetry and in situ scanning tunneling microscopy of cytochrome C nitrite reductase on Au(111) electrodes

Escherichia coli cytochrome c nitrite reductase (NrfA) catalyzes the six-electron reduction of nitrite to perform an important role in the biogeochemical cycling of nitrogen. Here we describe NrfA adsorption on single-crystal Au(111) electrodes as an electrocatalytically active film in which the enzyme undergoes direct electron exchange with the electrode. The adsorbed NrfA has been imaged to molecular resolution by in situ scanning tunneling microscopy (in situ STM) under full electrochemical potential control and under conditions where the enzyme is electrocatalytically active. Details of the density and orientational distribution of NrfA molecules are disclosed. The submonolayer coverage resolved by in situ STM is readily reconciled with the failure to detect nonturnover signals in cyclic voltammetry of the NrfA films. The molecular structures show a range of lateral dimensions. These are suggestive of a distribution of orientations that could account for the otherwise anomalously low turnover number calculated for the total population of adsorbed NrfA molecules when compared with that determined for solutions of NrfA. Thus, comparison of the voltammetric signals and in situ STM images offers a direct approach to correlate electrocatalytic and molecular properties of the protein layer, a long-standing issue in protein film voltammetry.

Rapid and reversible reactions of [NiFe]-hydrogenases with sulfide

Rapid and reversible binding of sulfide to [NiFe]-hydrogenases (particularly the enzyme from Desulfovibrio vulgaris) under weakly acidic conditions (pH 6) has been studied by protein film voltammetry, which tracks the formation of different species as a function of potential. Sulfide (most likely entering as H2S) rapidly attacks the active site during H2 oxidation. The inactive adduct is formed (and is stable) only at potentials substantially more positive than the comparable species formed with oxygen species and is easily reactivated upon reduction. The sulfide adduct also reacts further with O2 to produce a new species that undergoes reductive activation very slowly. The results clarify complex and controversial chemistry reported in the literature and provide insight into how these enzymes would cope with sulfide production in sulfate-reducing bacteria.

Pyrococcus furiosus 4Fe-ferredoxin, chemisorbed on gold, exhibits gated reduction and ionic strength dependent dimerization

Pyrococcus furiosus ferredoxin is a small metalloprotein that shuttles electrons between redox enzymes. In its native 4Fe-4S form the protein is highly thermostable. In addition to three cluster-ligating cysteines, two surface cysteine residues (C21 and C48) are present. We used the reactivity of these surface thiols to directly immobilize ferredoxin on a bare gold electrode, with an orientation in which the cluster is exposed to solution. Voltammetry, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and atomic force microscopy (AFM) studies established the immobilization of the 4Fe form. Native and recombinant wild-type ferredoxins were compared with the C48S, C21S, and C21S/C48S mutants. The variants with one and two surface cysteines can be directly chemisorbed on bare gold. Cyclic voltammetry demonstrated that the reduction potentials are similar to those in solution. The interfacial electron transfer kinetics revealed that the reduction is gated by the interconversion between two oxidized species. AFM images showed that dimers are chemisorbed at low ionic strength, while monomers are present at high ionic strength. XPS spectra revealed the presence of S, Fe, C, N, and O at the surface, which are assigned to the corresponding atoms in the peptide and the cofactor. Analysis of the sulfur spectrum corroborates that both C21 and C48 form gold-thiolate bonds. Moreover, two inorganic sulfide and two iron species were identified, suggesting an inhomogeneous charge distribution in the 4Fe-4S cluster. In conclusion, P. furiosus ferredoxin can be directly and vectorially chemisorbed on gold with retention of its properties. This may provide a biocompatible electrode surface with docking sites for redox enzymes.

A Nickel Superoxide Dismutase Maquette That Reproduces the Spectroscopic and Functional Properties of the Metalloenzyme

Described herein is a nickel superoxide dismutase (NiSOD) maquette ([Ni(SOD(M1))]) based on the first 12 residues from the N-terminal sequence of Streptomyces coelicolor NiSOD. The apopeptide (SOD(M1)) was prepared by standard solid-phase Fmoc peptide synthesis. SOD(M1) will readily coordinate Ni(II) in a 1:1 ratio in slightly basic aqueous sodium phosphate buffer (0.1 M; pH = 7.2) forming a lightly colored beige/pink solution. Unlike NiSOD, which is isolated as a 1:1 mixture of oxidized (Ni(III)) and reduced (Ni(II)) forms, [Ni(SOD(M1))] can only be isolated in the Ni(II) oxidation state. The UV/vis, X-ray absorption, and CD spectra of [Ni(II)(SOD(M1))] correspond well with those reported for the reduced form of NiSOD. Despite the fact that [Ni(III)(SOD(M1))] is not isolable, [Ni(SOD(M1))] has an appropriate redox potential to act as an SOD (E(1/2) = 0.70(2) V vs Ag/AgCl) and in fact will catalytically disproportionate >40 000 equiv of KO(2).

Electrochemical definitions of O2 sensitivity and oxidative inactivation in hydrogenases

A new strategy is described for comparing, quantitatively, the ability of hydrogenases to tolerate exposure to O2 and anoxic oxidizing conditions. Using protein film voltammetry, the inherent sensitivities to these challenges (thermodynamic potentials and rates of reactions) have been measured for enzymes from a range of mesophilic microorganisms. In the absence of O2, all the hydrogenases undergo reversible inactivation at various potentials above that of the H+/H2 redox couple, and H2 oxidation activities are thus limited to characteristic "potential windows". Reactions with O2 vary greatly; the [FeFe]-hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ATCC 7757, an anaerobe, is irreversibly damaged by O2, surviving only if exposed to O2 in the anaerobically oxidized state (which therefore affords protection). In contrast, the membrane-bound [NiFe]-hydrogenase from the aerobe, Ralstonia eutropha, reacts reversibly with O2 even during turnover and continues to catalyze H2 oxidation in the presence of O2.

Electrocatalytic hydrogen oxidation by an enzyme at high carbon monoxide or oxygen levels

Use of hydrogen in fuel cells requires catalysts that are tolerant to oxygen and are able to function in the presence of poisons such as carbon monoxide. Hydrogen-cycling catalysts are widespread in the bacterial world in the form of hydrogenases, enzymes with unusual active sites composed of iron, or nickel and iron, that are buried within the protein. We have established that the membrane-bound hydrogenase from the beta-proteobacterium Ralstonia eutropha H16, when adsorbed at a graphite electrode, exhibits rapid electrocatalytic oxidation of hydrogen that is completely unaffected by carbon monoxide [at 0.9 bar (1 bar = 100 kPa), a 9-fold excess] and is inhibited only partially by oxygen. The practical significance of this discovery is illustrated with a simple fuel cell device, thus demonstrating the feasibility of future hydrogen-cycle technologies based on biological or biologically inspired electrocatalysts having high selectivity for hydrogen.

A single-crystal ENDOR and density functional theory study of the oxidized states of the [NiFe] hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio vulgaris Miyazaki F

The catalytic center of the [NiFe] hydrogenase of Desulfovibrio vulgaris Miyazaki F in the oxidized states was investigated by electron paramagnetic resonance and electron-nuclear double resonance spectroscopy applied to single crystals of the enzyme. The experimental results were compared with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. For the Ni-B state, three hyperfine tensors could be determined. Two tensors have large isotropic hyperfine coupling constants and are assigned to the beta-CH2 protons of the Cys-549 that provides one of the bridging sulfur ligands between Ni and Fe in the active center. From a comparison of the orientation of the third hyperfine tensor with the tensor obtained from DFT calculations an OH- bridging ligand has been identified in the Ni-B state. For the Ni-A state broader signals were observed. The signals of the third proton, as observed for the "ready" state Ni-B, were not observed at the same spectral position for Ni-A, confirming a structural difference involving the bridging ligand in the "unready" state of the enzyme.

Hydrogen cycling by enzymes: electrocatalysis and implications for future energy technology

Hydrogenases provide an inspiration for future energy technologies. The active sites of these microbial enzymes contain Fe or Ni and Fe coordinated by CO and CN ligands: yet they have activities for hydrogen cycling that compare with Pt catalysts. Is there a future for enzymes in technological H2 cycling? There are obviously going to be disadvantages, perhaps overwhelming, as enzymes are notoriously fragile; yet what are the positive aspects and can we learn any chemistry that might be applied to produce the electrolytic and fuel cell catalysts of the future? We have developed a suite of novel electrochemical experiments to probe the chemistry of hydrogenases. The reactions are controlled and monitored at the surface of a small electrode, and characteristic catalytic properties are discernible from tiny amounts of sample material, so this approach can be used to search the microbial world for the best catalysts. Although electrochemistry does not provide structural information directly, it does give a "road map" by which to navigate the pathways and conditions that lead to particular states of the enzymes. This has prompted many interdisciplinary collaborations with other scientists who have provided microbiological, spectroscopic and structural contexts for this work. This article describes how these electrochemical experiments are set up, the data are analysed, and the results interpreted. We have determined mechanisms of catalysis, electron transfer, activation and inactivation, and defined important properties such as O2 tolerance and CO resistance in physical terms. Using an O2-tolerant hydrogenase, we have demonstrated a "proof of concept" miniature fuel cell that will run on a mixed H2/O2 feed in aqueous solution.