The critical role of mouse CD4+ cells in the rejection of highly disparate xenogeneic pig thymus grafts

Transplanting organs from pigs to humans

The success of organ transplantation is limited by the complications of immunosuppression, by chronic rejection, and by the insufficient organ supply, and thousands of patients die every year while waiting for a transplant. With recent progress in xenotransplantation permitting porcine organ graft survival of months or even years in nonhuman primates, there is renewed interest in its potential to alleviate the organ shortage. Many of these advances are the result of our heightened capacity to modify pigs genetically, particularly with the development of CRISPR-Cas9-based gene editing methodologies. Although this approach allows the engineering of pig organs that are less prone to rejection, the clinical application of xenotransplantation will require the ability to avoid the ravages of a multifaceted attack on the immune system while preserving the capacity to protect both the recipient and the graft from infectious microorganisms. In this review, we will discuss the potential and limitations of these modifications and how the engineering of the graft can be leveraged to alter the host immune response so that all types of immune attack are avoided.

CD4 T cells mediate cardiac xenograft rejection via host MHC Class II

BACKGROUND

Previous studies have shown that acute CD4 T-cell-mediated cardiac allograft rejection requires donor major histocompatibility complex (MHC) Class II expression and can be independent of "indirect" antigen presentation. However, other studies suggested that indirect antigen presentation to CD4 T cells may play a primary role in cellular xenograft immunity. Thus, the relative roles of direct/indirect CD4 T cell reactivity against cardiac xenografts are unclear. In this study we set out to determine the role for indirect CD4 T cell reactivity in cardiac xenograft rejection.

METHODS

Rat hearts were transplanted heterotopically into wild-type and immunodeficient mice. Recipients were untreated, treated with depleting antibodies, or reconstituted with wild-type cells.

RESULTS

Antibody depletion confirmed that rat heart xenograft rejection in C57Bl/6 mice was CD4 T-cell-dependent. Also, heart xenografts survived long term in B6 MHC Class II (C2D)-deficient mice. Graft acceptance in C2D mice was not secondary to CD4 T cell deficiency alone, because transferred B6 CD4 T cells failed to trigger rejection in C2D hosts. Furthermore, purified CD4 T cells were sufficient for acute rejection of rat heart xenografts in immune-deficient B6rag1(-/-) recipients. Importantly, CD4 T cells did not reject rat hearts in C2Drag1(-/-) hosts, in contrast to results using cardiac allografts. "Direct" xenoreactive CD4 T cells were not sufficient to mediate rejection despite vigorous reactivity to rat stimulator cells in vitro.

CONCLUSIONS

Taken together, our results show that CD4 T cells are both necessary and sufficient for acute cardiac xenograft rejection and that host MHC Class II is critical in this process.

T-cell-mediated immunological barriers to xenotransplantation

Xenotransplantion remains the most viable option for significant expansion of the donor organ pool in clinical transplantation. With the advent of nuclear transfer technologies, the production of transgenic swine has become a possibility. These animals have allowed transplant investigators to overcome humoral mechanisms of hyperacute xenograft rejection in experimental pig-to-non-human primate models. However, other immunologic barriers preclude long-term acceptance of xenografts. This review article focuses on a major feature of xenogeneic rejection: xenogeneic T cell responses. Evidence obtained from both small and large animal models, particularly those using either islet cells or kidneys, have demonstrated that T cell responses play a major role in xenogeneic rejection, and that immunosuppression alone is likely incapable of completely suppressing these responses. Additionally, both the direct and indirect pathway of antigen presentation appear to be involved in these anti donor processes. Enhanced understanding of (i) CD47 and its role in transduced xeno-bone marrow (ii) CD39 and its role in coagulation dysregulation and (iii) thymic transplantation have provided us with encouraging results. Presently, experiments evaluating the possibility of xenogeneic tolerance are underway.

The allogeneic effect revisited: exogenous help for endogenous, tumor-specific T cells

The "allogeneic effect" refers to the induction of host B cell antibody synthesis or host T cell cytotoxicity, including tumoricidal activity, by an infusion of allogeneic lymphocytes. We show that treatment of mice with cyclophosphamide (Cy) followed by CD8(+) T cell-depleted allogeneic donor lymphocyte infusion (Cy + CD8(-) DLI) induces regression of established tumors with minimal toxicity in models of both hematologic and solid cancers, even though the donor cells are eventually rejected by the host immune system. The optimal antitumor effect of Cy + CD8(-) DLI required the presence of donor CD4(+) T cells, host CD8(+) T cells, and alloantigen expression by normal host but not tumor tissue. The results support a model in which a donor CD4(+) T cell-mediated graft-versus-host (GVH) reaction effectively awakens antitumor immunity among Cy-resistant host CD8(+) T cells. These events provide the cellular mechanism of the "allogeneic effect" in antitumor immunity. Cy + CD8(-) DLI may be an effective and minimally toxic strategy for awakening the host immune response to advanced cancers.

Blockade of the PD-1/PD-1L pathway reverses the protective effect of anti-CD40L therapy in a rat to mouse concordant islet xenotransplantation model

BACKGROUND

We have previously demonstrated that costimulatory blockade with anti-CD40L monoclonal antibody (mAb) prolongs the survival of non-vascularized concordant rat to mouse islet xenografts. Here, we examine whether signaling through the PD-1/PD-1L pathway is required for the anti-CD40L therapy to prolong concordant islet graft survival using a novel anti-murine PD-1 mAb (clone 4F10).

METHODS

C57BL/6 mice received a cellular concordant islet xenograft under the left kidney capsule and four experimental groups were prepared. Group I: untreated control; group II: recipient mice were treated with three doses of 0.5 mg of anti-CD40L mAb (clone MR1) on days 0, 2 and 4; group III: mice were treated with 0.5 mg of anti-PD-1 (CD279) mAb (clone 4F10) every other day for 8 days; and finally group IV: mice received the combined treatment that consisted of anti-CD40L plus anti-PD-1 mAb.

RESULTS

Concordant islet xenografts transplanted in control untreated mice showed a median survival time (MST) of 17 +/- 7.43 days, whereas anti-CD40L treatment led to a significant prolongation of graft survival (MST: 154 +/- 65.56, P < 0.0001). The administration of anti-PD-1 alone significantly accelerated graft rejection compared to non-treated controls (MST: 10 +/- 2.24 vs. MST: 17 +/- 7.43, P < 0.0004). Remarkably, the combined administration of anti-CD40L and anti-PD-1 reversed the protective effect obtained with anti-CD40L alone (anti-CD40L, MST: 154 +/- 65.56 vs. anti-CD40L plus anti-PD-1, MST: 10 +/- 7.72, P < 0.0002).

CONCLUSION

Overall, our data indicate that the PD-1/PD-1L pathway is required for the achievement of prolonged graft survival in anti-CD40L-treated mice in a setting of rat to mouse concordant islet xenotransplantation.

Presence of functional mouse regulatory CD4+CD25+T cells in xenogeneic neonatal porcine thymus-grafted athymic mice

Xenotransplantation with porcine thymus is emerging as a possible means to reconstitute host cellular immunity and to induce immune tolerance in rodents and large animals. However, the presence of regulatory T cells (Treg cells) in this model needs to be determined. We herein demonstrated that efficient repopulation of mouse CD4+CD25+Treg cells was achieved in Balb/c nude mice by grafting neonatal porcine thymic tissue (NP THY). Mouse CD4+CD25+T cells expressed normal levels of Foxp3 in NP THY-grafted nude mice. Furthermore, these CD4+CD25+Treg cells showed significant inhibitory effects on the cell proliferation or interleukin-2 products of syngeneic T cells to alloantigens, Con A or a peptide antigen, although the potent immunosuppressive function might be lower than CD4+CD25+Treg cells in Balb/c mice. CD4+CD25+T cells in NP THY-grafted nude mice showed significantly stronger inhibition on the response to donor porcine antigens of CD4+CD25(-)T cells than CD4+CD25+Treg cells in Balb/c mice. Both CD4+CD25+Treg cells in NP THY-grafted nude and Balb/c mice prevented the development of autoimmune disease mediated by syngeneic CD4+CD25(-)T cells in a similar efficient way in the secondary recipients. These findings provide evidence for the potential involvement of CD4+CD25+Treg cells in keeping self-tolerance and transplant tolerance in this xeno-thymus transplantation model.

Corneal rat-to-mouse xenotransplantation and the effects of anti-CD4 or anti-CD8 treatment on cytokine and nitric oxide production

Corneal xenotransplantation may be an alternative approach to overcome shortage of allografts for clinical transplantation. Orthotopic corneal rat-to-mouse xenotransplantation and syngeneic transplantation was performed and the effects of anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 treatments on corneal xenograft survival and production of cytokines, interleukin (IL)-2, IL-4, IL-10, gamma-interferon (IFN-gamma) and nitric oxide (NO) were evaluated. RT-PCR was used to determine the expression of genes for cytokines and inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) in the grafts. The presence of iNOS protein in grafts was detected by immunofluorescent staining. We found that corneal xenotransplantation was associated with a strong upregulation of genes for both Th1 and Th2 cytokines and with NO production in the graft. Treatment of xenograft recipients with mAb anti-CD4, but not anti-CD8, resulted in a profound inhibition of IL-2, IL-4 and IL-10 production, and in a significant prolongation of corneal xenograft survival. The results show that upregulation of Th2 cytokines after corneal xenotransplantation does not correlate with xenograft rejection. Rather, corneal graft rejection is associated with the expression of genes for IFN-gamma and iNOS and with NO production.

Antibody- and complement-independent phagocytotic and cytolytic activities of human macrophages toward porcine cells

BACKGROUND

It has been speculated that host macrophages contribute to rapid clearance of transplanted xenogeneic cells. To address such a possibility, phagocytotic and cytolytic activities of human macrophages toward xenogeneic porcine cells were evaluated in vitro in the absence of antibodies and complement factors.

METHODS

Human peripheral monocyte-derived macrophages (P-macrophages) and reticulo-endothelial macrophages (RE-macrophages) were obtained from volunteers' peripheral blood and from the perfusion effluents of liver allografts for transplantation, respectively. 5-(and 6-) carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester (CFSE)-labeled human autologous red blood cells (auto-RBCs), ABO-incompatible RBCs (incom-RBCs) and xenogeneic porcine RBCs (xeno-RBCs) were incubated with the human macrophages; subsequently, the macrophages that had phagocytosed the RBCs could be identified as CFSE positive cells by FCM analyses and confocal microscopy. Cytolytic activity was quantified by calculating levels of lactate dehydrogenase in each culture supernatant.

RESULTS

Human RE-macrophages spontaneously phagocytosed and had a remarkable cytolytic activity toward xeno-RBCs, but not toward auto-RBCs or incom-RBCs. Elimination of alpha-galactosyl xenoantigen (alpha-Gal) epitopes on xeno-RBCs did not prevent phagocytotic or cytolytic activity of RE-macrophages.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings indicate phagocytotic and cytolitic activities of human macrophages toward porcine cells are initiated by a factor other than alpha-Gal in a mechanism independent of antibody/complement opsonization.

Activated macrophages require T cells for xenograft rejection under the kidney capsule

Transplantation of tissues from other species has been advocated as a way to overcome the extreme shortage of human donors. Rejection, however, remains a major hurdle for clinical xenotransplantation. Although activation of macrophages by T cells is critical for the cellular rejection of xenografts, what other important interactions between these two types of cells remain less defined. When we activated macrophages of immuno-deficient mice (SCID or Rag-/-) using interferon-gamma and lipopolysacharide, xenogeneic cells were rejected by activated macrophages in the peritoneal cavity (which has an abundance of resident macrophages), but were not rejected under the kidney capsule (which requires the recruitment of effectors). This difference between the two sites implies that activated macrophages are inefficient for self-recruitment to peripheral graft sites and that T cells may still be required for the process. To test this hypothesis further, immunodeficient mice that had received xenogeneic cells were infused with peritoneal exudate cells (containing activated macrophages and activated T cells) from preimmunized immunocompetent mice. Xenogeneic cells at both the kidney capsule and peritoneal sites were rejected soon after cell transfer. However, when the exudate cells were transferred into SCID recipients that first had been injected with T cell depleting antibodies, xenograft rejection was only prominent at the peritoneal site but not kidney capsule site. These results argue that activated macrophages (as the result of T cell activation) still require T cells for xenograft rejection at peripheral sites.

Xenogeneic thymokidney and thymic tissue transplantation in a pig-to-baboon model: I. Evidence for pig-specific T-cell unresponsiveness

BACKGROUND

The potential of xenotransplantation for clinical application will require overcoming barriers of humoral and cellular rejection, through strategies using immune suppression or tolerance induction. This laboratory has previously reported the induction of tolerance in the discordant xenogeneic model of pig-to-rodent thymic transplantation. We also have described a miniature swine model of fully mismatched allogeneic composite vascularized thymokidney transplantation that induced transplantation tolerance. We tested a combination of these approaches in a clinically relevant pig-to-primate model of xenotransplantation.

METHODS

Composite thymokidney grafts were prepared 40 to 80 days before transplantation by the autologous implantation of thymic tissue under the renal capsule of human decay-accelerating factor transgenic swine. Baboons received xenotransplants of both human decay-accelerating factor composite thymokidneys and omental implants of thymic tissue. Recipients were treated with an immunosuppressive-conditioning regimen including thymectomy or thymic irradiation, extracorporeal immunoadsorption of anti-alphaGal antibodies and T-cell depletion. Recipients were followed for indicators of xenograft rejection, T-cell depletion and reconstitution, anti-alphaGal antibody levels, and mixed lymphocyte responses. Immunologic responses were studied in those animals that survived for more than 3 weeks.

RESULTS

Thymokidney xenografts survived for up to 30 days, with evidence of viable thymic epithelium and Hassall's corpuscles under the renal capsule and in the omental implants, and with evidence of few host lymphocytes. Three animals demonstrated donor-specific unresponsiveness, while maintaining normal alloresponses, in mixed-lymphocyte-response assays performed after immunosuppression had been stopped. Rejected grafts demonstrated humoral damage without evidence of cellular infiltrates. After graftectomy, one animal maintained donor-specific cellular unresponsiveness and stable anti-alphaGal antibody levels for more than 2 months.

CONCLUSIONS

We concluded that composite thymokidney and thymic-tissue xenotransplantation from swine to baboons can induce donor-specific cellular unresponsiveness and stable anti-alphaGal antibody levels, suggesting avoidance of sensitization after xenotransplantation. The presence of viable donor-swine thymic epithelium could have a role in the development of donor-specific T-cell tolerance. Further strategies to address humoral rejection could prolong graft survival and result in long-term tolerance to xenografts.

Xenogeneic skin graft rejection in M-CSF/macrophage deficient osteopetrotic mice

BACKGROUND

The cellular infiltrate in xenografts suggests that macrophages may be involved in xenograft rejection. However, the precise role of macrophages in xenograft rejection has not yet been fully addressed.

METHODS

Xenogeneic rat skin grafts were transplanted to macrophage colony stimulating factor (M-CSF)/macrophage-deficient osteopetrotic ([OP]-/-) and wild-type control mice. Skin graft survival and antidonor rat humoral responses were quantified.

RESULTS

Xenogeneic rat skin grafts survived 13 days in wild-type control mice, survival of rat skin grafts was significantly prolonged to 24 days in [OP]-/- mice (P<0.01). Similar results were observed in sensitized [OP]-/- and control mouse recipients, showing markedly prolonged rat skin graft survival in [OP]-/- mice. Levels of T-cell-dependent antirat antibodies [immunoglobulin G (IgG)2a and IgG3] in sera of [OP]-/- mice were significantly lower than that of control mice 2 weeks post-rat skin grafting. The proliferative responses to xenogeneic rats not to allogeneic mouse stimulation of T cells from [OP]-/- mice were significantly lower than that of wild-type mice. However, neutrilization of M-CSF by anti-M-CSF monoclonal antibody (mAb) or the addition of M-CSF to the in vitro culture systems of wild-type or [OP]-/- mouse T-responder cells, respectively, did not significantly change proliferative responses and cytolytic function against xenogeneic rat targets of wild-type or [OP]-/- mouse T-responder cells.

CONCLUSIONS

The in vitro data indicate that M-CSF does not directly regulate cellular immune responses to xenoantigens. The present studies indicate that macrophages may play an important role in immune rejection of xenografts. The precise role of macrophages in xenograft rejection should be further investigated.

Highly disparate xenogeneic skin graft tolerance induction by fetal pig thymus in thymectomized mice: Conditioning requirements and the role of coimplantation of fetal pig liver

BACKGROUND

Highly disparate xenogeneic pig skin graft tolerance and efficient repopulation of mouse CD4+ T cells are achieved in thymectomized (ATX) B6 mice that receive T cell and natural killer (NK) cell depletion by injection of a mixture of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) (GK1.5, 2.43, 30-H12, and PK136) on days -6, -1, +7, and +14 and 3 Gy total body irradiation (TBI) followed by implantation of fetal pig thymus/liver (FP THY/LIV) grafts on day 0. The requirements for each treatment in this model to achieve pig skin graft tolerance have not previously been defined. Therefore, we performed a series of experiments to address the role of each treatment in achieving maximal skin graft tolerance.

METHODS

Peripheral mouse CD4+ T-cell repopulation and pig skin graft survival were followed in this pig-to-mouse model in which recipient B6 mice were treated with modified regimens that omitted thymectomy, 3 Gy TBI, anti-Thy1.2, and anti-NK1.1 mAbs, injection of a mixture of mAbs on day +14, or coimplantation of FP LIV, respectively.

RESULTS

Prolongation but not permanent survival of donor MHC-matched pig skin grafts was observed in euthymic B6 mice that received T and NK cell depletion, 3 Gy TBI, and 7 Gy thymic irradiation and FP THY/LIV in the mediastinum, suggesting that full xenogeneic tolerance was not achieved in euthymic mice. However, after grafting FP THY alone to ATX B6 mice treated either with the "standard" regimen, or with a conditioning regimen that omitted all components of the conditioning regimen except treatment with anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 mAbs, efficient peripheral repopulation of mouse CD4+ T cells and long-term donor MHC-matched pig skin graft acceptance were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Highly disparate xenogeneic pig skin graft tolerance can be achieved by grafting FP THY alone in anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 mAb-treated ATX B6 mice, but not in euthymic B6 mice. Additional treatment of ATX recipient mice with anti-Thy1.2 and NK1.1 mAbs and 3 Gy TBI is not essential for donor pig skin graft tolerance induction.