Balancing a genetic toggle switch by real-time feedback control and periodic forcing

Automated adjustment of metabolic niches enables the control of natural and engineered microbial co-cultures

Much attention has focused on understanding microbial interactions leading to stable co-cultures. In this work, substrate pulsing was performed to promote better control of the metabolic niches (MNs) corresponding to each species, leading to the continuous co-cultivation of diverse microbial organisms. We used a cell-machine interface, which allows adjustment of the temporal profile of two MNs according to a rhythm, ensuring the successive growth of two species, in our case, a yeast and a bacterium. The resulting approach, called 'automated adjustment of metabolic niches' (AAMN), was effective for stabilizing both cooperative and competitive co-cultures. AAMN can be considered an enabling technology for the deployment of co-cultures in bioprocesses, demonstrated here based on the continuous bioproduction of p-coumaric acid. The data accumulated suggest that AAMN could be used not only for a wider range of biological systems, but also to gain fundamental insights into microbial interaction mechanisms.

Biocomputing at the crossroad between emulating artificial intelligence and cellular supremacy

Biocomputation aims to create sophisticated biological systems capable of addressing important problems in (bio)medicine with a machine-like precision. At present, computational gene networks engineered by single- or multi-layered assembly of DNA-, RNA- and protein-level gene switches have allowed bacterial or mammalian cells to perform various regulation logics of interest, including Boolean calculation or neural network-like computing. This review highlights the molecular building blocks, design principles, and computational tasks demonstrated by current biocomputers, before briefly discussing possible fields where biological computers may ultimately outcompete their electronic counterparts and achieve cellular supremacy.

Population-level amplification of gene regulation by programmable gene transfer

Engineering cells to sense and respond to environmental cues often focuses on maximizing gene regulation at the single-cell level. Inspired by population-level control mechanisms like the immune response, we demonstrate dynamic control and amplification of gene regulation in bacterial populations using programmable plasmid-mediated gene transfer. By regulating plasmid loss rate, transfer rate and fitness effects via Cas9 endonuclease, F conjugation machinery and antibiotic selection, we modulate the fraction of plasmid-carrying cells, serving as an amplification factor for single-cell-level regulation. This approach expands the dynamic range of gene expression and allows orthogonal control across populations. Our platform offers a versatile strategy for dynamically regulating gene expression in engineered microbial communities.

Dynamic processes of fate decision in inducible bistable systems

The process of biological fate decision regulated by gene regulatory networks involves numerous complex dynamical interactions among many components. Mathematical modeling typically employed ordinary differential equations and steady-state analysis, which has yielded valuable quantitative insights. However, stable states predicted by theoretical models often fail to capture transient or metastable phenomena that occur during most observation periods in experimental or real biological systems. We attribute this discrepancy to the omission of dynamic processes of various complex interactions. Here, we demonstrate the influence of delays in gene regulatory steps and the timescales of the external induction on the dynamic processes of the fate decision in inducible bistable systems. We propose that steady-state parameters determine the landscape of fate decision. However, during the dynamic evolution along the landscape, the unequal delays of biochemical interactions as well as the timescale of external induction cause deviations in the differentiation trajectories, leading to the formation of new transient distributions that persist long term. Our findings emphasize the importance of considering dynamic processes in fate decision instead of relying solely on steady-state analysis. We provide insights into the interpretation of experimental phenomena and offer valuable guidance for future efforts in dynamical modeling and synthetic biology design.

Image-guided optogenetic spatiotemporal tissue patterning using μPatternScope

In the field of tissue engineering, achieving precise spatiotemporal control over engineered cells is critical for sculpting functional 2D cell cultures into intricate morphological shapes. In this study, we engineer light-responsive mammalian cells and target them with dynamic light patterns to realize 2D cell culture patterning control. To achieve this, we developed μPatternScope (μPS), a modular framework for software-controlled projection of high-resolution light patterns onto microscope samples. μPS comprises hardware and software suite governing pattern projection and microscope maneuvers. Together with a 2D culture of the engineered cells, we utilize μPS for controlled spatiotemporal induction of apoptosis to generate desired 2D shapes. Furthermore, we introduce interactive closed-loop patterning, enabling a dynamic feedback mechanism between the measured cell culture patterns and the light illumination profiles to achieve the desired target patterning trends. Our work offers innovative tools for advanced tissue engineering applications through seamless fusion of optogenetics, optical engineering, and cybernetics.

Rational Design of High-Efficiency Synthetic Small Regulatory RNAs and Their Application in Robust Genetic Circuit Performance Through Tight Control of Leaky Gene Expression

Synthetic sRNAs show promise as tools for targeted and programmable gene expression manipulation. However, the design of high-efficiency synthetic sRNAs is a challenging task that necessitates careful consideration of multiple factors. Therefore, this study aims to investigate rational design strategies that significantly and robustly enhance the efficiency of synthetic sRNAs. This is achieved by optimizing the following parameters: the sRNA scaffold, mRNA binding affinity, Hfq protein expression level, and mRNA secondary structure. By utilizing optimized synthetic sRNAs within a positive feedback circuit, we effectively addressed the issue of gene expression leakage─an enduring challenge in synthetic biology that undermines the reliability of genetic circuits in bacteria. Our designed synthetic sRNAs successfully prevented gene expression leakage, thus averting unintended circuit activation caused by initial expression noise, even in the absence of signal molecules. This result shows that high-efficiency synthetic sRNAs not only enable precise gene knockdown for metabolic engineering but also ensure the robust performance of synthetic circuits. The strategies developed here hold significant promise for broad applications across diverse biotechnological fields, establishing synthetic sRNAs as pivotal tools in advancing synthetic biology and gene regulation.

Neural network-enabled, all-electronic control of non-Newtonian fluid flow

Real-time, all-electronic control of non-Newtonian fluid flow through a microscale channel is crucial for various applications in manufacturing and healthcare. However, existing methods lack the sensitivity required for accurate measurement and the real-time responsiveness necessary for effective adjustment. Here, we demonstrate an all-electronic system that enables closed-loop, real-time, high-sensitivity control of various waveforms of non-Newtonian fluid flow (0.76 μl min-1) through a micro-sized outlet. Our approach combines a contactless, cuff-like flow sensor with a neural-network control program. This system offers a simple, miniaturized, versatile, yet high-performance solution for non-Newtonian fluid flow control, easily integrated into existing setups.

Pattern Formation and Bistability in a Synthetic Intercellular Genetic Toggle

Differentiation within multicellular organisms is a complex process that helps to establish spatial patterning and tissue formation within the body. Often, the differentiation of cells is governed by morphogens and intercellular signaling molecules that guide the fate of each cell, frequently using toggle-like regulatory components. Synthetic biologists have long sought to recapitulate patterned differentiation with engineered cellular communities, and various methods for differentiating bacteria have been invented. Here, we couple a synthetic corepressive toggle switch with intercellular signaling pathways to create a "quorum-sensing toggle". We show that this circuit not only exhibits population-wide bistability in a well-mixed liquid environment but also generates patterns of differentiation in colonies grown on agar containing an externally supplied morphogen. If coupled to other metabolic processes, circuits such as the one described here would allow for the engineering of spatially patterned, differentiated bacteria for use in biomaterials and bioelectronics.

Multi-layered computational gene networks by engineered tristate logics

So far, biocomputation strictly follows traditional design principles of digital electronics, which could reach their limits when assembling gene circuits of higher complexity. Here, by creating genetic variants of tristate buffers instead of using conventional logic gates as basic signal processing units, we introduce a tristate-based logic synthesis (TriLoS) framework for resource-efficient design of multi-layered gene networks capable of performing complex Boolean calculus within single-cell populations. This sets the stage for simple, modular, and low-interference mapping of various arithmetic logics of interest and an effectively enlarged engineering space within single cells. We not only construct computational gene networks running full adder and full subtractor operations at a cellular level but also describe a treatment paradigm building on programmable cell-based therapeutics, allowing for adjustable and disease-specific drug secretion logics in vivo. This work could foster the evolution of modern biocomputers to progress toward unexplored applications in precision medicine.

Yeast cell responses and survival during periodic osmotic stress are controlled by glucose availability

Natural environments of living organisms are often dynamic and multifactorial, with multiple parameters fluctuating over time. To better understand how cells respond to dynamically interacting factors, we quantified the effects of dual fluctuations of osmotic stress and glucose deprivation on yeast cells using microfluidics and time-lapse microscopy. Strikingly, we observed that cell proliferation, survival, and signaling depend on the phasing of the two periodic stresses. Cells divided faster, survived longer, and showed decreased transcriptional response when fluctuations of hyperosmotic stress and glucose deprivation occurred in phase than when the two stresses occurred alternatively. Therefore, glucose availability regulates yeast responses to dynamic osmotic stress, showcasing the key role of metabolic fluctuations in cellular responses to dynamic stress. We also found that mutants with impaired osmotic stress response were better adapted to alternating stresses than wild-type cells, showing that genetic mechanisms of adaptation to a persistent stress factor can be detrimental under dynamically interacting conditions.

Deep model predictive control of gene expression in thousands of single cells

Gene expression is inherently dynamic, due to complex regulation and stochastic biochemical events. However, the effects of these dynamics on cell phenotypes can be difficult to determine. Researchers have historically been limited to passive observations of natural dynamics, which can preclude studies of elusive and noisy cellular events where large amounts of data are required to reveal statistically significant effects. Here, using recent advances in the fields of machine learning and control theory, we train a deep neural network to accurately predict the response of an optogenetic system in Escherichia coli cells. We then use the network in a deep model predictive control framework to impose arbitrary and cell-specific gene expression dynamics on thousands of single cells in real time, applying the framework to generate complex time-varying patterns. We also showcase the framework's ability to link expression patterns to dynamic functional outcomes by controlling expression of the tetA antibiotic resistance gene. This study highlights how deep learning-enabled feedback control can be used to tailor distributions of gene expression dynamics with high accuracy and throughput without expert knowledge of the biological system.

Machine Learning for Biological Design

We briefly present machine learning approaches for designing better biological experiments. These approaches build on machine learning predictors and provide additional tools to guide scientific discovery. There are two different kinds of objectives when designing better experiments: to improve the predictive model or to improve the experimental outcome. We survey five different approaches for adaptive experimental design that iteratively search the space of possible experiments while adapting to measured data. The approaches are Bayesian optimization, bandits, reinforcement learning, optimal experimental design, and active learning. These machine learning approaches have shown promise in various areas of biology, and we provide broad guidelines to the practitioner and links to further resources.

Mechanistic Model-Driven Biodesign in Mammalian Synthetic Biology

Mathematical modeling plays a vital role in mammalian synthetic biology by providing a framework to design and optimize design circuits and engineered bioprocesses, predict their behavior, and guide experimental design. Here, we review recent models used in the literature, considering mathematical frameworks at the molecular, cellular, and system levels. We report key challenges in the field and discuss opportunities for genome-scale models, machine learning, and cybergenetics to expand the capabilities of model-driven mammalian cell biodesign.

Stochastic chemical kinetics of cell fate decision systems: From single cells to populations and back

Stochastic chemical kinetics is a widely used formalism for studying stochasticity of chemical reactions inside single cells. Experimental studies of reaction networks are generally performed with cells that are part of a growing population, yet the population context is rarely taken into account when models are developed. Models that neglect the population context lose their validity whenever the studied system influences traits of cells that can be selected in the population, a property that naturally arises in the complex interplay between single-cell and population dynamics of cell fate decision systems. Here, we represent such systems as absorbing continuous-time Markov chains. We show that conditioning on non-absorption allows one to derive a modified master equation that tracks the time evolution of the expected population composition within a growing population. This allows us to derive consistent population dynamics models from a specification of the single-cell process. We use this approach to classify cell fate decision systems into two types that lead to different characteristic phases in emerging population dynamics. Subsequently, we deploy the gained insights to experimentally study a recurrent problem in biology: how to link plasmid copy number fluctuations and plasmid loss events inside single cells to growth of cell populations in dynamically changing environments.

Fitness cost associated with cell phenotypic switching drives population diversification dynamics and controllability

Isogenic cell populations can cope with stress conditions by switching to alternative phenotypes. Even if it can lead to increased fitness in a natural context, this feature is typically unwanted for a range of applications (e.g., bioproduction, synthetic biology, and biomedicine) where it tends to make cellular response unpredictable. However, little is known about the diversification profiles that can be adopted by a cell population. Here, we characterize the diversification dynamics for various systems (bacteria and yeast) and for different phenotypes (utilization of alternative carbon sources, general stress response and more complex development patterns). Our results suggest that the diversification dynamics and the fitness cost associated with cell switching are coupled. To quantify the contribution of the switching cost on population dynamics, we design a stochastic model that let us reproduce the dynamics observed experimentally and identify three diversification regimes, i.e., constrained (at low switching cost), dispersed (at medium and high switching cost), and bursty (for very high switching cost). Furthermore, we use a cell-machine interface called Segregostat to demonstrate that different levels of control can be applied to these diversification regimes, enabling applications involving more precise cellular responses.

Advances in automated and reactive flow cytometry for synthetic biotechnology

Automated flow cytometry (FC) has been initially considered for bioprocess monitoring and optimization. More recently, new physical and software interfaces have been made available, facilitating the access to this technology for labs and industries. It also comes with new capabilities, such as being able to act on the cultivation conditions based on population data. This approach, known as reactive FC, extended the range of applications of automated FC to bioprocess control and the stabilization of cocultures, but also to the broad field of synthetic and systems biology for the characterization of gene circuits. However, several issues must be addressed before automated and reactive FC can be considered standard and modular technologies.

Modulating Biological Rhythms: A Noncomputational Strategy Harnessing Nonlinearity and Decoupling Frequency and Amplitude

Understanding and achieving concurrent modulation of amplitude and frequency, particularly adjusting one quantity and simultaneously sustaining the other at an invariant level, are of paramount importance for complex biophysical systems, including the signal pathway where different frequency indicates different upstream signal yielding a certain downstream physiological function while different amplitude further determines different efficacy of a downstream output. However, such modulators with clearly described and universally valid mechanisms are still lacking. Here, we rigorously propose an easy-to-use control strategy containing only one or two steps, leveraging the nonlinearity in the modulated systems to decouple frequency and amplitude in a noncomputational manner. The strategy's efficacy is demonstrated using representative biochemical systems and, thus, it could be potentially applicable to modulating rhythms in experiments of biochemistry and synthetic biology.

Revealing the Host-Dependent Nature of an Engineered Genetic Inverter in Concordance with Physiology

Broad-host-range synthetic biology is an emerging frontier that aims to expand our current engineerable domain of microbial hosts for biodesign applications. As more novel species are brought to "model status," synthetic biologists are discovering that identically engineered genetic circuits can exhibit different performances depending on the organism it operates within, an observation referred to as the "chassis effect." It remains a major challenge to uncover which genome-encoded and biological determinants will underpin chassis effects that govern the performance of engineered genetic devices. In this study, we compared model and novel bacterial hosts to ask whether phylogenomic relatedness or similarity in host physiology is a better predictor of genetic circuit performance. This was accomplished using a comparative framework based on multivariate statistical approaches to systematically demonstrate the chassis effect and characterize the performance dynamics of a genetic inverter circuit operating within 6 Gammaproteobacteria. Our results solidify the notion that genetic devices are strongly impacted by the host context. Furthermore, we formally determined that hosts exhibiting more similar metrics of growth and molecular physiology also exhibit more similar performance of the genetic inverter, indicating that specific bacterial physiology underpins measurable chassis effects. The result of this study contributes to the field of broad-host-range synthetic biology by lending increased predictive power to the implementation of genetic devices in less-established microbial hosts.

Regulation strategies for two-output biomolecular networks

Feedback control theory facilitates the development of self-regulating systems with desired performance which are predictable and insensitive to disturbances. Feedback regulatory topologies are found in many natural systems and have been of key importance in the design of reliable synthetic bio-devices operating in complex biological environments. Here, we study control schemes for biomolecular processes with two outputs of interest, expanding previously described concepts based on single-output systems. Regulation of such processes may unlock new design possibilities but can be challenging due to coupling interactions; also potential disturbances applied on one of the outputs may affect both. We therefore propose architectures for robustly manipulating the ratio/product and linear combinations of the outputs as well as each of the outputs independently. To demonstrate their characteristics, we apply these architectures to a simple process of two mutually activated biomolecular species. We also highlight the potential for experimental implementation by exploring synthetic realizations both in vivo and in vitro. This work presents an important step forward in building bio-devices capable of sophisticated functions.

Maximizing protein production by keeping cells at optimal secretory stress levels using real-time control approaches

Optimizing the production of recombinant proteins is a problem of major industrial and pharmaceutical importance. Secretion of the protein by the host cell considerably simplifies downstream purification processes. However, for many proteins, this is also the limiting production step. Current solutions involve extensive engineering of the chassis cell to facilitate protein trafficking and limit protein degradation triggered by excessive secretion-associated stress. Here, we propose instead a regulation-based strategy in which induction is dynamically adjusted to an optimal strength based on the current stress level of the cells. Using a small collection of hard-to-secrete proteins, a bioreactor-based platform with automated cytometry measurements, and a systematic assay to quantify secreted protein levels, we demonstrate that the secretion sweet spot is indicated by the appearance of a subpopulation of cells that accumulate high amounts of proteins, decrease growth, and face significant stress, that is, experience a secretion burnout. In these cells, adaptations capabilities are overwhelmed by a too strong production. Using these notions, we show for a single-chain antibody variable fragment that secretion levels can be improved by 70% by dynamically keeping the cell population at optimal stress levels using real-time closed-loop control.

L-2L ladder digital-to-analogue converter for dynamics generation of chemical concentrations

Cellular response to dynamic chemical stimulation encodes rich information about the underlying reaction pathways and their kinetics. Microfluidic chemical stimulators play a key role in generating dynamic concentration waveforms by mixing several aqueous solutions. In this article, we propose a multi-layer microfluidic chemical stimulator capable of modulating chemical concentrations by a simple binary logic based on the electronic-hydraulic analogy of electronic R-2R ladder circuits. The proposed device, which we call L-2L ladder digital-to-analogue converter (DAC), allows us to systematically modulate 2 n levels of concentrations from single sources of solution and solvent by a single operation of 2n membrane valves, which contrasts with existing devices that require complex channel geometry with multiple input sources and valve operations. We fabricated the L-2L ladder DAC with n = 3 bit resolution and verified the concept by comparing the generated waveforms with computational simulations. The response time of the proposed DAC was within the order of seconds because of its simple operation logic of membrane valves. Furthermore, detailed analysis of the waveforms revealed that the transient concentration can be systematically predicted by a simple addition of the transient waveforms of 2n = 6 base patterns, enabling facile optimization of the channel geometry to fine-tune the output waveforms.

Benchmarking tools for a priori identifiability analysis

MOTIVATION

The theoretical possibility of determining the state and parameters of a dynamic model by measuring its outputs is given by its structural identifiability and its observability. These properties should be analysed before attempting to calibrate a model, but their a priori analysis can be challenging, requiring symbolic calculations that often have a high computational cost. In recent years, a number of software tools have been developed for this task, mostly in the systems biology community. These tools have vastly different features and capabilities, and a critical assessment of their performance is still lacking.

RESULTS

Here, we present a comprehensive study of the computational resources available for analysing structural identifiability. We consider 13 software tools developed in 7 programming languages and evaluate their performance using a set of 25 case studies created from 21 models. Our results reveal their strengths and weaknesses, provide guidelines for choosing the most appropriate tool for a given problem and highlight opportunities for future developments.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

https://github.com/Xabo-RB/Benchmarking_files.

Avoiding the All-or-None Response in Gene Expression During E. coli Continuous Cultivation Based on the On-Line Monitoring of Cell Phenotypic Switching Dynamics

Different expression vectors are available for the effective production of recombinant proteins by bacterial populations. However, the productivity of such systems is limited by the inherent noise of the gene circuits used for the synthesis of recombinant products. An extreme case of cell-to-cell heterogeneity that has been previously reported for the ara- and lac-based expression systems in E. coli is the all-or-none response. According to this mode of response, two subpopulations of cells are generated, i.e., a "low-" subpopulation exhibiting a shallow expression level and a "high-" subpopulation exhibiting a high-expression level. The "low-" subpopulation can be considered as a cluster of non-producing cells contributing to the loss of productivity. Here we describe the setup, design, and operation of a continuous culture where inducer addition is operated based on microbial population dynamics. The determination of population dynamics is done based on an automated flow cytometry (FC) procedure previously denoted as segregostat. We illustrate how this setup can be used to control the activation of an ara-based expression system and avoid phenotypic diversification leading to an all-or-none response. Upon the determination of the natural frequency of the gene circuit used as an expression system, our current protocol can be set up without the requirement of a feedback controller.

Microfluidics for long-term single-cell time-lapse microscopy: Advances and applications

Cells are inherently dynamic, whether they are responding to environmental conditions or simply at equilibrium, with biomolecules constantly being made and destroyed. Due to their small volumes, the chemical reactions inside cells are stochastic, such that genetically identical cells display heterogeneous behaviors and gene expression profiles. Studying these dynamic processes is challenging, but the development of microfluidic methods enabling the tracking of individual prokaryotic cells with microscopy over long time periods under controlled growth conditions has led to many discoveries. This review focuses on the recent developments of one such microfluidic device nicknamed the mother machine. We overview the original device design, experimental setup, and challenges associated with this platform. We then describe recent methods for analyzing experiments using automated image segmentation and tracking. We further discuss modifications to the experimental setup that allow for time-varying environmental control, replicating batch culture conditions, cell screening based on their dynamic behaviors, and to accommodate a variety of microbial species. Finally, this review highlights the discoveries enabled by this technology in diverse fields, such as cell-size control, genetic mutations, cellular aging, and synthetic biology.

Cybergenetic control of microbial community composition

The use of bacterial communities in bioproduction instead of monocultures has potential advantages including increased productivity through division of labour, ability to utilise cheaper substrates, and robustness against perturbations. A key challenge in the application of engineered bacterial communities is the ability to reliably control the composition of the community in terms of its constituent species. This is crucial to prevent faster growing species from outcompeting others with a lower relative fitness, and to ensure that all species are present at an optimal ratio during different steps in a biotechnological process. In contrast to purely biological approaches such as synthetic quorum sensing circuits or paired auxotrophies, cybergenetic control techniques - those in which computers interface with living cells-are emerging as an alternative approach with many advantages. The community composition is measured through methods such as fluorescence intensity or flow cytometry, with measured data fed real-time into a computer. A control action is computed using a variety of possible control algorithms and then applied to the system, with actuation taking the form of chemical (e.g., inducers, nutrients) or physical (e.g., optogenetic, mechanical) inputs. Subsequent changes in composition are then measured and the cycle repeated, maintaining or driving the system to a desired state. This review discusses recent and future developments in methods for implementing cybergenetic control systems, contrasts their capabilities with those of traditional biological methods of population control, and discusses future directions and outstanding challenges for the field.

CyberSco.Py an open-source software for event-based, conditional microscopy

Timelapse fluorescence microscopy imaging is routinely used in quantitative cell biology. However, microscopes could become much more powerful investigation systems if they were endowed with simple unsupervised decision-making algorithms to transform them into fully responsive and automated measurement devices. Here, we report CyberSco.Py, Python software for advanced automated timelapse experiments. We provide proof-of-principle of a user-friendly framework that increases the tunability and flexibility when setting up and running fluorescence timelapse microscopy experiments. Importantly, CyberSco.Py combines real-time image analysis with automation capability, which allows users to create conditional, event-based experiments in which the imaging acquisition parameters and the status of various devices can be changed automatically based on the image analysis. We exemplify the relevance of CyberSco.Py to cell biology using several use case experiments with budding yeast. We anticipate that CyberSco.Py could be used to address the growing need for smart microscopy systems to implement more informative quantitative cell biology experiments.

Ratiometric control of cell phenotypes in monostrain microbial consortia

We address the problem of regulating and keeping at a desired balance the relative numbers between cells exhibiting a different phenotype within a monostrain microbial consortium. We propose a strategy based on the use of external control inputs, assuming each cell in the community is endowed with a reversible, bistable memory mechanism. Specifically, we provide a general analytical framework to guide the design of external feedback control strategies aimed at balancing the ratio between cells whose memory is stabilized at either one of two equilibria associated with different cell phenotypes. We demonstrate the stability and robustness properties of the control laws proposed and validate them in silico, implementing the memory element via a genetic toggle-switch. The proposed control framework may be used to allow long-term coexistence of different populations, with both industrial and biotechnological applications. As a representative example, we consider the realistic agent-based implementation of our control strategy to enable cooperative bioproduction of a dimer in a monostrain microbial consortium.

Platforms for Optogenetic Stimulation and Feedback Control

Harnessing the potential of optogenetics in biology requires methodologies from different disciplines ranging from biology, to mechatronics engineering, to control engineering. Light stimulation of a synthetic optogenetic construct in a given biological species can only be achieved via a suitable light stimulation platform. Emerging optogenetic applications entail a consistent, reproducible, and regulated delivery of light adapted to the application requirement. In this review, we explore the evolution of light-induction hardware-software platforms from simple illumination set-ups to sophisticated microscopy, microtiter plate and bioreactor designs, and discuss their respective advantages and disadvantages. Here, we examine design approaches followed in performing optogenetic experiments spanning different cell types and culture volumes, with induction capabilities ranging from single cell stimulation to entire cell culture illumination. The development of automated measurement and stimulation schemes on these platforms has enabled researchers to implement various in silico feedback control strategies to achieve computer-controlled living systems—a theme we briefly discuss in the last part of this review.

Control-Based Continuation: A New Approach to Prototype Synthetic Gene Networks

Control-Based Continuation (CBC) is a general and systematic method to carry out the bifurcation analysis of physical experiments. CBC does not rely on a mathematical model and thus overcomes the uncertainty introduced when identifying bifurcation curves indirectly through modeling and parameter estimation. We demonstrate, in silico, CBC applicability to biochemical processes by tracking the equilibrium curve of a toggle switch, which includes additive process noise and exhibits bistability. We compare the results obtained when CBC uses a model-free and model-based control strategy and show that both can track stable and unstable solutions, revealing bistability. We then demonstrate CBC in conditions more representative of an in vivo experiment using an agent-based simulator describing cell growth and division, cell-to-cell variability, spatial distribution, and diffusion of chemicals. We further show how the identified curves can be used for parameter estimation and discuss how CBC can significantly accelerate the prototyping of synthetic gene regulatory networks.

Continuous phenotypic modulation explains male horn allometry in three dung beetle species

Many dung beetle species show male horn polyphenism, the ability of males to develop into distinct phenotypes without intermediate forms as a response to the larval growth environment. While males with long (majors) and rudimentary (minor) horn have been widely reported in literature, little is known about the existence of individuals with intermediate horn length. Here we investigate the occurrence of intermediates in natural populations of three dung beetle species (Onthophagus furcatus, Copris lunaris and C. hispanus). We analysed the body size-horn length relationship using linear, exponential, and sigmoidal models with different error structures. We inferred the number of individuals in the minor, intermediate, and major groups by combining changepoint analysis and simulation from fitted allometric models. The sigmoidal equation was a better descriptor of the body size-horn length relationship than linear or exponential equations in all the three studied species. Our results indicated that the number of intermediates equals or exceeds the number of minor and major males. This work provides evidence that, at least in the studied species, males with intermediate horn length exist in natural populations. For similar cases we therefore suggest that continuous phenotypic modulation rather than discrete polyphenism can explain variation in male horn allometry.

Exploiting Information and Control Theory for Directing Gene Expression in Cell Populations

Microbial populations can adapt to adverse environmental conditions either by appropriately sensing and responding to the changes in their surroundings or by stochastically switching to an alternative phenotypic state. Recent data point out that these two strategies can be exhibited by the same cellular system, depending on the amplitude/frequency of the environmental perturbations and on the architecture of the genetic circuits involved in the adaptation process. Accordingly, several mitigation strategies have been designed for the effective control of microbial populations in different contexts, ranging from biomedicine to bioprocess engineering. Technically, such control strategies have been made possible by the advances made at the level of computational and synthetic biology combined with control theory. However, these control strategies have been applied mostly to synthetic gene circuits, impairing the applicability of the approach to natural circuits. In this review, we argue that it is possible to expand these control strategies to any cellular system and gene circuits based on a metric derived from this information theory, i.e., mutual information (MI). Indeed, based on this metric, it should be possible to characterize the natural frequency of any gene circuits and use it for controlling gene circuits within a population of cells.

Enabling reactive microscopy with MicroMator

Microscopy image analysis has recently made enormous progress both in terms of accuracy and speed thanks to machine learning methods and improved computational resources. This greatly facilitates the online adaptation of microscopy experimental plans using real-time information of the observed systems and their environments. Applications in which reactiveness is needed are multifarious. Here we report MicroMator, an open and flexible software for defining and driving reactive microscopy experiments. It provides a Python software environment and an extensible set of modules that greatly facilitate the definition of events with triggers and effects interacting with the experiment. We provide a pedagogic example performing dynamic adaptation of fluorescence illumination on bacteria, and demonstrate MicroMator’s potential via two challenging case studies in yeast to single-cell control and single-cell recombination, both requiring real-time tracking and light targeting at the single-cell level.

In microscopy, applications in which reactiveness is needed are multifarious. Here the authors report MicroMator, a Python software package for reactive experiments, which they use for applications requiring real-time tracking and light-targeting at the single-cell level.

Designing Biological Circuits: From Principles to Applications

Genetic circuit design is a well-studied problem in synthetic biology. Ever since the first genetic circuits─the repressilator and the toggle switch─were designed and implemented, many advances have been made in this area of research. The current review systematically organizes a number of key works in this domain by employing the versatile framework of generalized morphological analysis. Literature in the area has been mapped on the basis of (a) the design methodologies used, ranging from brute-force searches to control-theoretic approaches, (b) the modeling techniques employed, (c) various circuit functionalities implemented, (d) key design characteristics, and (e) the strategies used for the robust design of genetic circuits. We conclude our review with an outlook on multiple exciting areas for future research, based on the systematic assessment of key research gaps that have been readily unravelled by our analysis framework.

Using single-cell models to predict the functionality of synthetic circuits at the population scale

SignificanceAt the single-cell level, biochemical processes are inherently stochastic. For many natural systems, the resulting cell-to-cell variability is exploited by microbial populations. In synthetic biology, however, the interplay of cell-to-cell variability and population processes such as selection or growth often leads to circuits not functioning as predicted by simple models. Here we show how multiscale stochastic kinetic models that simultaneously track single-cell and population processes can be obtained based on an augmentation of the chemical master equation. These models enable us to quantitatively predict complex population dynamics of a yeast optogenetic differentiation system from a specification of the circuit's components and to demonstrate how cell-to-cell variability can be exploited to purposefully create unintuitive circuit functionality.

Parameter inference for stochastic biochemical models from perturbation experiments parallelised at the single cell level

Understanding and characterising biochemical processes inside single cells requires experimental platforms that allow one to perturb and observe the dynamics of such processes as well as computational methods to build and parameterise models from the collected data. Recent progress with experimental platforms and optogenetics has made it possible to expose each cell in an experiment to an individualised input and automatically record cellular responses over days with fine time resolution. However, methods to infer parameters of stochastic kinetic models from single-cell longitudinal data have generally been developed under the assumption that experimental data is sparse and that responses of cells to at most a few different input perturbations can be observed. Here, we investigate and compare different approaches for calculating parameter likelihoods of single-cell longitudinal data based on approximations of the chemical master equation (CME) with a particular focus on coupling the linear noise approximation (LNA) or moment closure methods to a Kalman filter. We show that, as long as cells are measured sufficiently frequently, coupling the LNA to a Kalman filter allows one to accurately approximate likelihoods and to infer model parameters from data even in cases where the LNA provides poor approximations of the CME. Furthermore, the computational cost of filtering-based iterative likelihood evaluation scales advantageously in the number of measurement times and different input perturbations and is thus ideally suited for data obtained from modern experimental platforms. To demonstrate the practical usefulness of these results, we perform an experiment in which single cells, equipped with an optogenetic gene expression system, are exposed to various different light-input sequences and measured at several hundred time points and use parameter inference based on iterative likelihood evaluation to parameterise a stochastic model of the system.

Optogenetics Illuminates Applications in Microbial Engineering

Optogenetics has been used in a variety of microbial engineering applications, such as chemical and protein production, studies of cell physiology, and engineered microbe-host interactions. These diverse applications benefit from the precise spatiotemporal control that light affords, as well as its tunability, reversibility, and orthogonality. This combination of unique capabilities has enabled a surge of studies in recent years investigating complex biological systems with completely new approaches. We briefly describe the optogenetic tools that have been developed for microbial engineering, emphasizing the scientific advancements that they have enabled. In particular, we focus on the unique benefits and applications of implementing optogenetic control, from bacterial therapeutics to cybergenetics. Finally, we discuss future research directions, with special attention given to the development of orthogonal multichromatic controls. With an abundance of advantages offered by optogenetics, the future is bright in microbial engineering. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Volume 13 is October 2022. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.

Linking Molecular Mechanisms and Evolutionary Consequences of Resource Polyphenism

Resource polyphenism-the occurrence of environmentally induced, discrete, and intraspecific morphs showing differential niche use-is taxonomically widespread and fundamental to the evolution of ecological function where it has arisen. Despite longstanding appreciation for the ecological and evolutionary significance of resource polyphenism, only recently have its proximate mechanisms begun to be uncovered. Polyphenism switches, especially those influencing and influenced by trophic interactions, offer a route to integrating proximate and ultimate causation in studies of plasticity, and its potential influence on evolution more generally. Here, we use the major events in generalized polyphenic development as a scaffold for linking the molecular mechanisms of polyphenic switching with potential evolutionary outcomes of polyphenism and for discussing challenges and opportunities at each step in this process. Not only does the study of resource polyphenism uncover interesting details of discrete plasticity, it also illuminates and informs general principles at the intersection of development, ecology, and evolution.

Exploiting Noise, Non-Linearity, and Feedback for Differential Control of Multiple Synthetic Cells with a Single Optogenetic Input

Synthetic biology seeks to develop modular biocircuits that combine to produce complex, controllable behaviors. These designs are often subject to noisy fluctuations and uncertainties, and most modern synthetic biology design processes have focused to create robust components to mitigate the noise of gene expression and reduce the heterogeneity of single-cell responses. However, a deeper understanding of noise can achieve control goals that would otherwise be impossible. We explore how an "Optogenetic Maxwell Demon" could selectively amplify noise to control multiple cells using single-input-multiple-output (SIMO) feedback. Using data-constrained stochastic model simulations and theory, we show how an appropriately selected stochastic SIMO controller can drive multiple different cells to different user-specified configurations irrespective of initial conditions. We explore how controllability depends on cells' regulatory structures, the amount of information available to the controller, and the accuracy of the model used. Our results suggest that gene regulation noise, when combined with optogenetic feedback and non-linear biochemical auto-regulation, can achieve synergy to enable precise control of complex stochastic processes.

Virtual Parts Repository 2: Model-Driven Design of Genetic Regulatory Circuits

Engineering genetic regulatory circuits is key to the creation of biological applications that are responsive to environmental changes. Computational models can assist in understanding especially large and complex circuits for which manual analysis is infeasible, permitting a model-driven design process. However, there are still few tools that offer the ability to simulate the system under design. One of the reasons for this is the lack of accessible model repositories or libraries that cater to the modular composition of models of synthetic systems. Here, we present the second version of the Virtual Parts Repository, a framework to facilitate the model-driven design of genetic regulatory circuits, which provides reusable, modular, and composable models. The new framework is service-oriented, easier to use in computational workflows, and provides several new features and access methods. New features include supporting hierarchical designs via a graph-based repository or compatible remote repositories, enriching existing designs, and using designs provided in Synthetic Biology Open Language documents to derive system-scale and hierarchical Systems Biology Markup Language models. We also present a reaction-based modeling abstraction inspired by rule-based modeling techniques to facilitate scalable and modular modeling of complex and large designs. This modeling abstraction enhances the modeling capability of the framework, for example, to incorporate design patterns such as roadblocking, distributed deployment of genetic circuits using plasmids, and cellular resource dependency. The framework and the modeling abstraction presented in this paper allow computational design tools to take advantage of computational simulations and ultimately help facilitate more predictable applications.

Context-Dependent Stability and Robustness of Genetic Toggle Switches with Leaky Promoters

Multistable switches are ubiquitous building blocks in both systems and synthetic biology. Given their central role, it is thus imperative to understand how their fundamental properties depend not only on the tunable biophysical properties of the switches themselves, but also on their genetic context. To this end, we reveal in this article how these factors shape the essential characteristics of toggle switches implemented using leaky promoters such as their stability and robustness to noise, both at single-cell and population levels. In particular, our results expose the roles that competition for scarce transcriptional and translational resources, promoter leakiness, and cell-to-cell heterogeneity collectively play. For instance, the interplay between protein expression from leaky promoters and the associated cost of relying on shared cellular resources can give rise to tristable dynamics even in the absence of positive feedback. Similarly, we demonstrate that while promoter leakiness always acts against multistability, resource competition can be leveraged to counteract this undesirable phenomenon. Underpinned by a mechanistic model, our results thus enable the context-aware rational design of multistable genetic switches that are directly translatable to experimental considerations, and can be further leveraged during the synthesis of large-scale genetic systems using computer-aided biodesign automation platforms.

A frequency-amplitude coordinator and its optimal energy consumption for biological oscillators

Biorhythm including neuron firing and protein-mRNA interaction are fundamental activities with diffusive effect. Their well-balanced spatiotemporal dynamics are beneficial for healthy sustainability. Therefore, calibrating both anomalous frequency and amplitude of biorhythm prevents physiological dysfunctions or diseases. However, many works were devoted to modulate frequency exclusively whereas amplitude is usually ignored, although both quantities are equally significant for coordinating biological functions and outputs. Especially, a feasible method coordinating the two quantities concurrently and precisely is still lacking. Here, for the first time, we propose a universal approach to design a frequency-amplitude coordinator rigorously via dynamical systems tools. We consider both spatial and temporal information. With a single well-designed coordinator, they can be calibrated to desired levels simultaneously and precisely. The practical usefulness and efficacy of our method are demonstrated in representative neuronal and gene regulatory models. We further reveal its fundamental mechanism and optimal energy consumption providing inspiration for biorhythm regulation in future.

A light tunable differentiation system for the creation and control of consortia in yeast

Artificial microbial consortia seek to leverage division-of-labour to optimize function and possess immense potential for bioproduction. Co-culturing approaches, the preferred mode of generating a consortium, remain limited in their ability to give rise to stable consortia having finely tuned compositions. Here, we present an artificial differentiation system in budding yeast capable of generating stable microbial consortia with custom functionalities from a single strain at user-defined composition in space and in time based on optogenetically-driven genetic rewiring. Owing to fast, reproducible, and light-tunable dynamics, our system enables dynamic control of consortia composition in continuous cultures for extended periods. We further demonstrate that our system can be extended in a straightforward manner to give rise to consortia with multiple subpopulations. Our artificial differentiation strategy establishes a novel paradigm for the creation of complex microbial consortia that are simple to implement, precisely controllable, and versatile to use.

Quantitative control of noise in mammalian gene expression by dynamic histone regulation

Fluctuation ('noise') in gene expression is critical for mammalian cellular processes. Numerous mechanisms contribute to its origins, yet the mechanisms behind large fluctuations that are induced by single transcriptional activators remain elusive. Here, we probed putative mechanisms by studying the dynamic regulation of transcriptional activator binding, histone regulator inhibitors, chromatin accessibility, and levels of mRNAs and proteins in single cells. Using a light-induced expression system, we showed that the transcriptional activator could form an interplay with dual functional co-activator/histone acetyltransferases CBP/p300. This interplay resulted in substantial heterogeneity in H3K27ac, chromatin accessibility, and transcription. Simultaneous attenuation of CBP/p300 and HDAC4/5 reduced heterogeneity in the expression of endogenous genes, suggesting that this mechanism is universal. We further found that the noise was reduced by pulse-wide modulation of transcriptional activator binding possibly as a result of alternating the epigenetic states. Our findings suggest a mechanism for the modulation of noise in synthetic and endogenous gene expression systems.

Reengineering protein-phosphorylation switches

Phosphorylation circuits operate as logic gates that rapidly toggle a system between two stable states

Reducing phenotypic instabilities of a microbial population during continuous cultivation based on cell switching dynamics

Predicting the fate of individual cells among a microbial population (i.e., growth and gene expression) remains a challenge, especially when this population is exposed to very dynamic environmental conditions, such as those encountered during continuous cultivation. Indeed, the dynamic nature of a continuous cultivation process implies the potential diversification of the microbial population resulting in genotypic and phenotypic heterogeneity. The present work focused on the induction of the arabinose operon in Escherichia coli as a model system to study this diversification process in continuous cultivations. As a preliminary step, the green fluorescent protein (GFP) level triggered by an arabinose-inducible ParaBAD promoter was tracked by flow cytometry in chemostat cultivations with glucose-arabinose co-feeding. For a wide range of glucose-arabinose co-feeding concentrations in the chemostats, the simultaneous occurrence of GFP positive and negative subpopulation was observed. In the second set of experiments, continuous cultivation was performed by adding glucose continuously and arabinose based on the capability of individual cells to switch from low GFP to high GFP expression states, performed with a technology setup called segregostat. In the segregostat cultivation mode, on-line flow cytometry analysis was used for adjusting the arabinose/glucose transitions based on the phenotypic switching profiles of the microbial population. This strategy allowed finding an appropriate arabinose pulsing frequency, leading to prolonged maintenance of the induction level with a limited increase in the phenotypic diversity for more than 60 generations. The results suggest that the steady forcing of individual cells into a given phenotypic trajectory may not be the best strategy for controlling cell populations. Instead, allowing individual cells to switch periodically around a predefined threshold seems to be a more robust strategy leading to oscillations, but within a predictable cell population behavior range.

Control engineering and synthetic biology: working in synergy for the analysis and control of microbial systems

The implementation of novel functionalities in living cells is a key aspect of synthetic biology. In the last decade, the field of synthetic biology has made progress working in synergy with control engineering, whose solid framework has provided concepts and tools to analyse biological systems and guide their design. In this review, we briefly highlight recent work focused on the application of control theoretical concepts and tools for the analysis and design of synthetic biology systems in microbial cells.

Cheetah: A Computational Toolkit for Cybergenetic Control

Advances in microscopy, microfluidics, and optogenetics enable single-cell monitoring and environmental regulation and offer the means to control cellular phenotypes. The development of such systems is challenging and often results in bespoke setups that hinder reproducibility. To address this, we introduce Cheetah, a flexible computational toolkit that simplifies the integration of real-time microscopy analysis with algorithms for cellular control. Central to the platform is an image segmentation system based on the versatile U-Net convolutional neural network. This is supplemented with functionality to robustly count, characterize, and control cells over time. We demonstrate Cheetah's core capabilities by analyzing long-term bacterial and mammalian cell growth and by dynamically controlling protein expression in mammalian cells. In all cases, Cheetah's segmentation accuracy exceeds that of a commonly used thresholding-based method, allowing for more accurate control signals to be generated. Availability of this easy-to-use platform will make control engineering techniques more accessible and offer new ways to probe and manipulate living cells.

Operating principles of circular toggle polygons

Decoding the dynamics of cellular decision-making and cell differentiation is a central question in cell and developmental biology. A common network motif involved in many cell-fate decisions is a mutually inhibitory feedback loop between two self-activating 'master regulators' A and B, also called as toggle switch. Typically, it can allow for three stable states-(high A, low B), (low A, high B) and (medium A, medium B). A toggle triad-three mutually repressing regulators A, B and C, i.e. three toggle switches arranged circularly (between A and B, between B and C, and between A and C)-can allow for six stable states: three 'single positive' and three 'double positive' ones. However, the operating principles of larger toggle polygons, i.e. toggle switches arranged circularly to form a polygon, remain unclear. Here, we simulate using both discrete and continuous methods the dynamics of different sized toggle polygons. We observed a pattern in their steady state frequency depending on whether the polygon was an even or odd numbered one. The even-numbered toggle polygons result in two dominant states with consecutive components of the network expressing alternating high and low levels. The odd-numbered toggle polygons, on the other hand, enable more number of states, usually twice the number of components with the states that follow 'circular permutation' patterns in their composition. Incorporating self-activations preserved these trends while increasing the frequency of multistability in the corresponding network. Our results offer insights into design principles of circular arrangement of regulatory units involved in cell-fate decision making, and can offer design strategies for synthesizing genetic circuits.

Stepwise target controllability identifies dysregulations of macrophage networks in multiple sclerosis

Identifying the nodes able to drive the state of a network is crucial to understand, and eventually control, biological systems. Despite recent advances, such identification remains difficult because of the huge number of equivalent controllable configurations, even in relatively simple networks. Based on the evidence that in many applications it is essential to test the ability of individual nodes to control a specific target subset, we develop a fast and principled method to identify controllable driver-target configurations in sparse and directed networks. We demonstrate our approach on simulated networks and experimental gene networks to characterize macrophage dysregulation in human subjects with multiple sclerosis.