Cell fate roadmap of human primed-to-naive transition reveals preimplantation cell lineage signatures

Proteogenomic reprogramming to a functional human blastomere-like stem cell state via a PARP-DUX4 regulatory axis

Here, we show that conventional human pluripotent stem cells cultured with non-specific tankyrase-PARP1-inhibited conditions underwent proteogenomic reprogramming to functional blastomere-like tankyrase/PARP inhibitor-regulated naive stem cells (TIRN-SC). TIRN-SCs concurrently expressed hundreds of pioneer factors in hybrid 2C-8C-morula-ICM programs that were augmented by induced expression of DUX4. Injection of TIRN-SCs into 8C-staged murine embryos equipotently differentiated human cells to the extra-embryonic and embryonic compartments of chimeric blastocysts and fetuses. Ectopic expression of murine-E-Cadherin in TIRN-SCs further enhanced interspecific chimeric tissue targeting. TIRN-SC-derived trophoblast stem cells efficiently generated placental chimeras. Proteome-ubiquitinome analyses revealed increased TNKS and reduced PARP1 levels and an ADP-ribosylation-deficient, hyper-ubiquitinated proteome that impacted expression of both tankyrase and PARP1 substrates. ChIP-seq of NANOG-SOX2-OCT4 and PARP1 (NSOP) revealed genome-wide NSOP co-binding at DUX4-accessible enhancers of embryonic lineage factors; suggesting a DUX4-NSOP axis regulated TIRN-SC lineage plasticity. TIRN-SCs may serve as valuable models for studying the proteogenomic regulation of pre-lineage human embryogenesis. VIDEO ABSTRACT.

α-Ketoglutarate promotes trophectoderm induction and maturation from naive human embryonic stem cells

Development and lineage choice are driven by interconnected transcriptional, epigenetic and metabolic changes. Specific metabolites, such as α-ketoglutarate (αKG), function as signalling molecules affecting the activity of chromatin-modifying enzymes. However, how metabolism coordinates cell-state changes, especially in human pre-implantation development, remains unclear. Here we uncover that inducing naive human embryonic stem cells towards the trophectoderm lineage results in considerable metabolic rewiring, characterized by αKG accumulation. Elevated αKG levels potentiate the capacity of naive embryonic stem cells to specify towards the trophectoderm lineage. Moreover, increased αKG levels promote blastoid polarization and trophectoderm maturation. αKG supplementation does not affect global histone methylation levels; rather, it decreases acetyl-CoA availability, reduces histone acetyltransferase activity and weakens the pluripotency network. We propose that metabolism functions as a positive feedback loop aiding in trophectoderm fate induction and maturation, highlighting that global metabolic rewiring can promote specificity in cell fate decisions through intricate regulation of signalling and chromatin.

Moving toward totipotency: the molecular and cellular features of totipotent and naive pluripotent stem cells

BACKGROUND

Dissecting the key molecular mechanism of embryonic development provides novel insights into embryogenesis and potential intervention strategies for clinical practices. However, the ability to study the molecular mechanisms of early embryo development in humans, such as zygotic genome activation and lineage segregation, is meaningfully constrained by methodological limitations and ethical concerns. Totipotent stem cells have an extended developmental potential to differentiate into embryonic and extraembryonic tissues, providing a suitable model for studying early embryo development. Recently, a series of ground-breaking results on stem cells have identified totipotent-like cells or induced pluripotent stem cells into totipotent-like cells.

OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE

This review followed the PRISMA guidelines, surveys the current works of literature on totipotent, naive, and formative pluripotent stem cells, introduces the molecular and biological characteristics of those stem cells, and gives advice for future research.

SEARCH METHODS

The search method employed the terms 'totipotent' OR 'naive pluripotent stem cell' OR 'formative pluripotent stem cell' for unfiltered search on PubMed, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library. Papers included were those with information on totipotent stem cells, naive pluripotent stem cells, or formative pluripotent stem cells until June 2024 and were published in the English language. Articles that have no relevance to stem cells, or totipotent, naive pluripotent, or formative pluripotent cells were excluded.

OUTCOMES

There were 152 records included in this review. These publications were divided into four groups according to the species of the cells included in the studies: 67 human stem cell studies, 70 mouse stem cell studies, 9 porcine stem cell studies, and 6 cynomolgus stem cell studies. Naive pluripotent stem cell models have been established in other species such as porcine and cynomolgus. Human and mouse totipotent stem cells, e.g. human 8-cell-like cells, human totipotent blastomere-like cells, and mouse 2-cell-like cells, have been successfully established and exhibit high developmental potency for both embryonic and extraembryonic contributions. However, the observed discrepancies between these cells and real embryos in terms of epigenetics and transcription suggest that further research is warranted. Our results systematically reviewed the established methods, molecular characteristics, and developmental potency of different naive, formative pluripotent, and totipotent stem cells. Furthermore, we provide a parallel comparison between animal and human models, and offer recommendations for future applications to advance early embryo research and assisted reproduction technologies.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS

Totipotent cell models provide a valuable resource to understand the underlying mechanisms of embryo development and forge new paths toward future treatment of infertility and regenerative medicine. However, current in vitro cell models exhibit epigenetic and transcriptional differences from in vivo embryos, and many cell models are unstable across passages, thus imperfectly recapitulating embryonic development. In this regard, standardizing and expanding current research on totipotent stem cell models are essential to enhance our capability to resemble and decipher embryogenesis.

Chromosome number alterations cause apoptosis and cellular hypertrophy in induced pluripotent stem cell models of embryonic epiblast cells

Chromosomal aneuploidies are a major cause of developmental failure and pregnancy loss. To investigate the possible consequences of aneuploidy on early embryonic development in vitro, we focused on primed pluripotent stem cells that are relatable to the epiblast of post-implantation embryos in vivo. We used human induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) as an epiblast model and altered chromosome numbers by treating with reversine, a small-molecule inhibitor of monopolar spindle 1 kinase (MSP1) that inactivates the spindle assembly checkpoint, which has been strongly implicated in chromosome mis-segregation and aneuploidy generation. Upon reversine treatment, we obtained cells with varied chromosomal content that retained pluripotency and potential to differentiate into cells of three germ lineages. However, these cells displayed lagging chromosomes, increased micronuclei content, high p53 expression and excessive apoptotic activity. Cell proliferation was not affected. Prolonged in vitro culture of these cells resulted in a selective pool of cells with supernumerary chromosomes, which exhibited cellular hypertrophy, enlarged nuclei, and overproduction of total RNAs and proteins. We conclude that increased DNA damage responses, apoptosis, and improper cellular mass and functions are possible mechanisms that contribute to abnormal epiblast development.

Transcriptome and epigenome dynamics of the clonal heterogeneity of human induced pluripotent stem cells for cardiac differentiation

Human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) generate multiple clones with inherent heterogeneity, leading to variations in their differentiation capacity. Previous studies have primarily addressed line-to-line variations in differentiation capacity, leaving a gap in the comprehensive understanding of clonal heterogeneity. Here, we aimed to profile the heterogeneity of hiPSC clones and identify predictive biomarkers for cardiomyocyte (CM) differentiation capacity by integrating transcriptomic, epigenomic, endogenous retroelement, and protein kinase phosphorylation profiles. We generated multiple clones from a single donor and validated that these clones exhibited comparable levels of pluripotency markers. The clones were classified into two groups based on their differentiation efficiency to CMs-productive clone (PC) and non-productive clone (NPC). We performed RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) and assay for transposase-accessible chromatin with sequencing (ATAC-seq). NPC was enriched in vasculogenesis and cell adhesion, accompanied by elevated levels of phosphorylated ERK1/2. Conversely, PC exhibited enrichment in embryonic organ development and transcription factor activation, accompanied by increased chromatin accessibility near transcription start site (TSS) regions. Integrative analysis of RNA-seq and ATAC-seq revealed 14 candidate genes correlated with cardiac differentiation potential. Notably, TEK and SDR42E1 were upregulated in NPC. Our integrative profiles enhance the understanding of clonal heterogeneity and highlight two novel biomarkers associated with CM differentiation. This insight may facilitate the identification of suboptimal hiPSC clones, thereby mitigating adverse outcomes in clinical applications.

Current Status of Synthetic Mammalian Embryo Models

Advances in three-dimensional culture technologies have facilitated the development of synthetic embryo models, such as blastoids, through the co-culturing of diverse stem cell types. These in vitro models enable precise investigation of developmental processes, including gastrulation, neurulation, and lineage specification, thereby advancing our understanding of early embryogenesis. By providing controllable, ethically viable platforms, they help circumvent the limitations of in vivo mammalian embryo studies and contribute to developing regenerative medicine strategies. Nonetheless, ethical challenges, particularly regarding human applications, persist. Comparative studies across various species-such as mice, humans, non-human primates, and ungulates, like pigs and cattle-offer crucial insights into both species-specific and conserved developmental mechanisms. In this review, we outline the species-specific differences in embryonic development and discuss recent advancements in stem cell and synthetic embryo models. Specifically, we focus on the latest stem cell research involving ungulates, such as pigs and cattle, and provide a comprehensive overview of the improvements in synthetic embryo technology. These insights contribute to our understanding of species-specific developmental biology, help improve model efficiency, and guide the development of new models.

Highly cooperative chimeric super-SOX induces naive pluripotency across species

Our understanding of pluripotency remains limited: iPSC generation has only been established for a few model species, pluripotent stem cell lines exhibit inconsistent developmental potential, and germline transmission has only been demonstrated for mice and rats. By swapping structural elements between Sox2 and Sox17, we built a chimeric super-SOX factor, Sox2-17, that enhanced iPSC generation in five tested species: mouse, human, cynomolgus monkey, cow, and pig. A swap of alanine to valine at the interface between Sox2 and Oct4 delivered a gain of function by stabilizing Sox2/Oct4 dimerization on DNA, enabling generation of high-quality OSKM iPSCs capable of supporting the development of healthy all-iPSC mice. Sox2/Oct4 dimerization emerged as the core driver of naive pluripotency with its levels diminished upon priming. Transient overexpression of the SK cocktail (Sox+Klf4) restored the dimerization and boosted the developmental potential of pluripotent stem cells across species, providing a universal method for naive reset in mammals.

Amino acid intake strategies define pluripotent cell states

Mammalian preimplantation development is associated with marked metabolic robustness, and embryos can develop under a wide variety of nutrient conditions, including even the complete absence of soluble amino acids. Here we show that mouse embryonic stem cells (ESCs) capture the unique metabolic state of preimplantation embryos and proliferate in the absence of several essential amino acids. Amino acid independence is enabled by constitutive uptake of exogenous protein through macropinocytosis, alongside a robust lysosomal digestive system. Following transition to more committed states, ESCs reduce digestion of extracellular protein and instead become reliant on exogenous amino acids. Accordingly, amino acid withdrawal selects for ESCs that mimic the preimplantation epiblast. More broadly, we find that all lineages of preimplantation blastocysts exhibit constitutive macropinocytic protein uptake and digestion. Taken together, these results highlight exogenous protein uptake and digestion as an intrinsic feature of preimplantation development and provide insight into the catabolic strategies that enable embryos to sustain viability before implantation.

Discordance between chromatin accessibility and transcriptional activity during the human primed-to-naïve pluripotency transition process

Naïve pluripotent state can be obtained by several strategies from various types of cells, in which the cell fate roadmap as well as key biological events involved in the journey have been described in detail. Here, we carefully explored the chromatin accessibility dynamics during the primed-to-naïve transition by adopting a dual fluorescent reporter system and the assay for transposase-accessible chromatin (ATAC)-seq. Our results revealed critical chromatin remodeling events and highlight the discordance between chromatin accessibility and transcriptional activity. We further demonstrate that the differential epigenetic modifications and transcription factor (TF) activities may play a critical role in regulating gene expression, and account for the observed variations in gene expression despite similar chromatin landscapes.

In Vitro Embryogenesis and Gastrulation Using Stem Cells in Mice and Humans

During early mammalian embryonic development, fertilized one-cell embryos develop into pre-implantation blastocysts and subsequently establish three germ layers through gastrulation during post-implantation development. In recent years, stem cells have emerged as a powerful tool to study embryogenesis and gastrulation without the need for eggs, allowing for the generation of embryo-like structures known as synthetic embryos or embryoids. These in vitro models closely resemble early embryos in terms of morphology and gene expression and provide a faithful recapitulation of early pre- and post-implantation embryonic development. Synthetic embryos can be generated through a combinatorial culture of three blastocyst-derived stem cell types, such as embryonic stem cells, trophoblast stem cells, and extraembryonic endoderm cells, or totipotent-like stem cells alone. This review provides an overview of the progress and various approaches in studying in vitro embryogenesis and gastrulation in mice and humans using stem cells. Furthermore, recent findings and breakthroughs in synthetic embryos and gastruloids are outlined. Despite ethical considerations, synthetic embryo models hold promise for understanding mammalian (including humans) embryonic development and have potential implications for regenerative medicine and developmental research.

Human trophoblast stem cell-state acquisition from pluripotent stem cells and somatic cells

For an extended period of time, research on human embryo implantation and early placentation was hindered by ethical limitation and lack of appropriate in vitro models. Recently, an explosion of new research has significantly expanded our knowledge of early human trophoblast development and facilitated the derivation and culture of self-renewing human trophoblast stem cells (hTSCs). Multiple approaches have been undertaken in efforts to derive and understand hTSCs, including from blastocysts, early trophoblast tissue, and, more recently, from human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) and somatic cells. In this concise review, we summarize recent advances in derivation of hTSCs, with a focus on derivation from naive and primed hPSCs, as well as via reprogramming of somatic cells into induced hTSCs. Each of these methods harbors distinct advantages and setbacks, which are discussed. Finally, we briefly explore the possibility of the existence of trophectoderm-like hTSCs corresponding to earlier, preimplantation trophoblast cells.

Induction and application of human naive pluripotency

Over the past few decades, many attempts have been made to capture different states of pluripotency in vitro. Naive and primed pluripotent stem cells, corresponding to the pluripotency states of pre- and post-implantation epiblasts, respectively, have been well characterized in mice and can be interconverted in vitro. Here, we summarize the recently reported strategies to generate human naive pluripotent stem cells in vitro. We discuss their applications in studies of regulatory mechanisms involved in early developmental processes, including identification of molecular features, X chromosome inactivation modeling, transposable elements regulation, metabolic characteristics, and cell fate regulation, as well as potential for extraembryonic differentiation and blastoid construction for embryogenesis modeling. We further discuss the naive pluripotency-related research, including 8C-like cell establishment and disease modeling. We also highlight limitations of current naive pluripotency studies, such as imperfect culture conditions and inadequate responsiveness to differentiation signals.

Regulation of Embryonic Stem Cell Self-Renewal

Embryonic stem cells (ESCs) are a type of cells capable of self-renewal and multi-directional differentiation. The self-renewal of ESCs is regulated by factors including signaling pathway proteins, transcription factors, epigenetic regulators, cytokines, and small molecular compounds. Similarly, non-coding RNAs, small RNAs, and microRNAs (miRNAs) also play an important role in the process. Functionally, the core transcription factors interact with helper transcription factors to activate the expression of genes that contribute to maintaining pluripotency, while suppressing the expression of differentiation-related genes. Additionally, cytokines such as leukemia suppressor factor (LIF) stimulate downstream signaling pathways and promote self-renewal of ESCs. Particularly, LIF binds to its receptor (LIFR/gp130) to trigger the downstream Jak-Stat3 signaling pathway. BMP4 activates the downstream pathway and acts in combination with Jak-Stat3 to promote pluripotency of ESCs in the absence of serum. In addition, activation of the Wnt-FDZ signaling pathway has been observed to facilitate the self-renewal of ESCs. Small molecule modulator proteins of the pathway mentioned above are widely used in in vitro culture of stem cells. Multiple epigenetic regulators are involved in the maintenance of ESCs self-renewal, making the epigenetic status of ESCs a crucial factor in this process. Similarly, non-coding RNAs and cellular energetics have been described to promote the maintenance of the ESC's self-renewal. These factors regulate the self-renewal and differentiation of ESCs by forming signaling networks. This review focused on the role of major transcription factors, signaling pathways, small molecular compounds, epigenetic regulators, non-coding RNAs, and cellular energetics in ESC's self-renewal.