Birds multiplex spectral and temporal visual information via retinal On- and Off-channels

Comparative transcriptomic insights into the evolution of vertebrate photoreceptor types

To explore the molecular similarities and potential evolutionary origins of vertebrate photoreceptor types, we analyzed single-cell and -nucleus transcriptomic atlases from six vertebrate species: zebrafish, chicken, lizard, opossum, ground squirrel, and human. Comparative analyses identified conserved transcriptional signatures for the five ancestral photoreceptor types: red, blue, green, and UV cones, as well as rods. We further identified and validated molecular markers of the principal and accessory members of the tetrapod double cone. Comparative transcriptomics suggests that the principal member originated from ancestral red cones, although the origin of the accessory member is less clear. The gene expression variation among cone types mirrors their spectral order (red → green → blue → UV). We find that rods are highly dissimilar to all cone types, suggesting that rods may have diverged prior to the spectral diversification of cones.

A standardized nomenclature for the rods and cones of the vertebrate retina

Vertebrate photoreceptors have been studied for well over a century, but a fixed nomenclature for referring to orthologous cell types across diverse species has been lacking. Instead, photoreceptors have been variably-and often confusingly-named according to morphology, presence/absence of 'rhodopsin', spectral sensitivity, chromophore usage, and/or the gene family of the opsin(s) they express. Here, we propose a unified nomenclature for vertebrate rods and cones that aligns with the naming systems of other retinal cell classes and that is based on the photoreceptor type's putative evolutionary history. This classification is informed by the functional, anatomical, developmental, and molecular identities of the neuron as a whole, including the expression of deeply conserved transcription factors required for development. The proposed names will be applicable across all vertebrates and indicative of the widest possible range of properties, including their postsynaptic wiring, and hence will allude to their common and species-specific roles in vision. Furthermore, the naming system is open-ended to accommodate the future discovery of as-yet unknown photoreceptor types.

Morphology and connectivity of retinal horizontal cells in two avian species

In the outer vertebrate retina, the visual signal is separated into intensity and wavelength information. In birds, seven types of photoreceptors (one rod, four single cones, and two members of the double cone) mediate signals to >20 types of second-order neurons, the bipolar cells and horizontal cells. Horizontal cells contribute to color and contrast processing by providing feedback signals to photoreceptors and feedforward signals to bipolar cells. In fish, reptiles, and amphibians they either encode intensity or show color-opponent responses. Yet, for the bird retina, the number of horizontal cell types is not fully resolved and even more importantly, the synapses between photoreceptors and horizontal cells have never been quantified for any bird species. With a combination of light microscopy and serial EM reconstructions, we found four different types of horizontal cells in two distantly related species, the domestic chicken and the European robin. In agreement with some earlier studies, we confirmed two highly abundant cell types (H1, H2) and two rare cell types (H3, H4), of which H1 is an axon-bearing cell, whereas H2-H4 are axonless. H1 cells made chemical synapses with one type of bipolar cell and an interplexiform amacrine cell at their soma. Dendritic contacts of H1-H4 cells to photoreceptors were type-specific and similar to the turtle retina, which confirms the high degree of evolutionary conservation in the vertebrate outer retina. Our data further suggests that H1 and potentially H2 cells may encode intensity, whereas H3 and H4 may represent color opponent horizontal cells which may contribute to the birds' superb color and/or high acuity vision.

Transplantation of genome-edited retinal organoids restores some fundamental physiological functions coordinated with severely degenerated host retinas

We have previously shown that the transplantation of stem cell-derived retinal organoid (RO) sheets into animal models of end-stage retinal degeneration can lead to host-graft synaptic connectivity and restoration of vision, which was further improved using genome-edited Islet1-/- ROs (gROs) with a reduced number of ON-bipolar cells. However, the details of visual function restoration using this regenerative therapeutic approach have not yet been characterized. Here, we evaluated the electrophysiological properties of end-stage rd1 retinas after transplantation (TP-rd1) and compared them with those of wild-type (WT) retinas using multi-electrode arrays. Notably, retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) in TP-rd1 retinas acquired light sensitivity comparable to that of WT retinas. Furthermore, RGCs in TP-rd1 retinas showed light adaptation to a photopic background and responded to flickering stimuli. These results demonstrate that transplantation of gRO sheets may restore some fundamental physiological functions, possibly coordinating with the remaining functions in retinas with end-stage degeneration.

Comparative transcriptomic insights into the evolutionary origin of the tetrapod double cone

The tetrapod double cone is a pair of tightly associated cones called the "principal" and the "accessory" member. It is found in amphibians, reptiles, and birds, as well as monotreme and marsupial mammals but is absent in fish and eutherian mammals. To explore the potential evolutionary origins of the double cone, we analyzed single-cell and -nucleus transcriptomic atlases of photoreceptors from six vertebrate species: zebrafish, chicken, lizard, opossum, ground squirrel, and human. Computational analyses separated the principal and accessory members in chicken and lizard, identifying molecular signatures distinguishing either member from single cones and rods in the same species. Comparative transcriptomic analyses suggest that both the principal and accessory originated from ancestral red cones. Furthermore, the gene expression variation among cone subtypes mirrors their spectral order (red → green → blue → UV), suggesting a constraint in their order of emergence during evolution. Finally, we find that rods are equally dissimilar to all cone types, suggesting that they emerged before the spectral diversification of cones.

Functional Differentiation along the Rostro-Caudal Axis of the Avian Hippocampal Formation

INTRODUCTION

Different functional domains can be identified along the longitudinal axis of the mammalian hippocampus. We have recently hypothesized that a similar functional gradient may exist along the longitudinal axis of the avian hippocampal formation (HF) as well. If the 2 gradients are homologous, we would expect the caudal HF to be more responsive to acute stress than the rostral HF.

METHODS

We restrained 8 adult Dekalb White hens in a bag for 30 min under red-light conditions and compared FOS-immunoreactive (FOS-ir) cell densities in different hippocampal subdivisions to control hens.

RESULTS

Although we could find no evidence of an activated stress response in the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis of the restrained birds, we did find a significant increase in FOS-ir cell densities in the rostral HF of the restrained birds compared to controls.

CONCLUSION

We speculate that the HF response is not due to an acute stress response, but instead, it is related to the change in spatial context that was part of taking the birds and restraining them in a different room. We see no activation in the caudal HF. This would be consistent with our hypothesis that the longitudinal axis of the avian HF is homologous to the long axis of the mammalian hippocampus.

Asymmetric distribution of color-opponent response types across mouse visual cortex supports superior color vision in the sky

Color is an important visual feature that informs behavior, and the retinal basis for color vision has been studied across various vertebrate species. While many studies have investigated how color information is processed in visual brain areas of primate species, we have limited understanding of how it is organized beyond the retina in other species, including most dichromatic mammals. In this study, we systematically characterized how color is represented in the primary visual cortex (V1) of mice. Using large-scale neuronal recordings and a luminance and color noise stimulus, we found that more than a third of neurons in mouse V1 are color-opponent in their receptive field center, while the receptive field surround predominantly captures luminance contrast. Furthermore, we found that color-opponency is especially pronounced in posterior V1 that encodes the sky, matching the statistics of natural scenes experienced by mice. Using unsupervised clustering, we demonstrate that the asymmetry in color representations across cortex can be explained by an uneven distribution of green-On/UV-Off color-opponent response types that are represented in the upper visual field. Finally, a simple model with natural scene-inspired parametric stimuli shows that green-On/UV-Off color-opponent response types may enhance the detection of 'predatory'-like dark UV-objects in noisy daylight scenes. The results from this study highlight the relevance of color processing in the mouse visual system and contribute to our understanding of how color information is organized in the visual hierarchy across species.

Species-specific circuitry of double cone photoreceptors in two avian retinas

In most avian retinas, double cones (consisting of a principal and accessory member) outnumber other photoreceptor types and have been associated with various functions, such as encoding luminance, sensing polarized light, and magnetoreception. However, their down-stream circuitry is poorly understood, particularly across bird species. Analysing species differences is important to understand changes in circuitry driven by ecological adaptations. We compare the ultrastructure of double cones and their postsynaptic bipolar cells between a night-migratory European robin and non-migratory chicken. We discover four previously unidentified bipolar cell types in the European robin retina, including midget-like bipolar cells mainly connected to one principal member. A downstream ganglion cell reveals a complete midget-like circuit similar to a circuit in the peripheral primate retina. Additionally, we identify a selective circuit transmitting information from a specific subset of accessory members. Our data highlight species-specific differences in double cone to bipolar cell connectivity, potentially reflecting ecological adaptations.

The vertebrate retina: a window into the evolution of computation in the brain

Animal brains are probably the most complex computational machines on our planet, and like everything in biology, they are the product of evolution. Advances in developmental and palaeobiology have been expanding our general understanding of how nervous systems can change at a molecular and structural level. However, how these changes translate into altered function - that is, into 'computation' - remains comparatively sparsely explored. What, concretely, does it mean for neuronal computation when neurons change their morphology and connectivity, when new neurons appear or old ones disappear, or when transmitter systems are slowly modified over many generations? And how does evolution use these many possible knobs and dials to constantly tune computation to give rise to the amazing diversity in animal behaviours we see today? Addressing these major gaps of understanding benefits from choosing a suitable model system. Here, I present the vertebrate retina as one perhaps unusually promising candidate. The retina is ancient and displays highly conserved core organisational principles across the entire vertebrate lineage, alongside a myriad of adjustments across extant species that were shaped by the history of their visual ecology. Moreover, the computational logic of the retina is readily interrogated experimentally, and our existing understanding of retinal circuits in a handful of species can serve as an anchor when exploring the visual circuit adaptations across the entire vertebrate tree of life, from fish deep in the aphotic zone of the oceans to eagles soaring high up in the sky.

Hue selectivity from recurrent circuitry in Drosophila

In the perception of color, wavelengths of light reflected off objects are transformed into the derived quantities of brightness, saturation and hue. Neurons responding selectively to hue have been reported in primate cortex, but it is unknown how their narrow tuning in color space is produced by upstream circuit mechanisms. We report the discovery of neurons in the Drosophila optic lobe with hue-selective properties, which enables circuit-level analysis of color processing. From our analysis of an electron microscopy volume of a whole Drosophila brain, we construct a connectomics-constrained circuit model that accounts for this hue selectivity. Our model predicts that recurrent connections in the circuit are critical for generating hue selectivity. Experiments using genetic manipulations to perturb recurrence in adult flies confirm this prediction. Our findings reveal a circuit basis for hue selectivity in color vision.

Ancestral photoreceptor diversity as the basis of visual behaviour

Animal colour vision is based on comparing signals from different photoreceptors. It is generally assumed that processing different spectral types of photoreceptor mainly serves colour vision. Here I propose instead that photoreceptors are parallel feature channels that differentially support visual-motor programmes like motion vision behaviours, prey capture and predator evasion. Colour vision may have emerged as a secondary benefit of these circuits, which originally helped aquatic vertebrates to visually navigate and segment their underwater world. Specifically, I suggest that ancestral vertebrate vision was built around three main systems, including a high-resolution general purpose greyscale system based on ancestral red cones and rods to mediate visual body stabilization and navigation, a high-sensitivity specialized foreground system based on ancestral ultraviolet cones to mediate threat detection and prey capture, and a net-suppressive system based on ancestral green and blue cones for regulating red/rod and ultraviolet circuits. This ancestral strategy probably still underpins vision today, and different vertebrate lineages have since adapted their original photoreceptor circuits to suit their diverse visual ecologies.

Long-term, high-resolution in vivo calcium imaging in pigeons

In vivo 2-photon calcium imaging has led to fundamental advances in our understanding of sensory circuits in mammalian species. In contrast, few studies have exploited this methodology in birds, with investigators primarily relying on histological and electrophysiological techniques. Here, we report the development of in vivo 2-photon calcium imaging in awake pigeons. We show that the genetically encoded calcium indicator GCaMP6s, delivered by the adeno-associated virus rAAV2/7, allows high-quality, stable, and long-term imaging of neuronal populations at single-cell and single-dendrite resolution in the pigeon forebrain. We demonstrate the utility of our setup by investigating the processing of colors in the visual Wulst, the avian homolog of the visual cortex. We report that neurons in the Wulst are color selective and display diverse response profiles to light of different wavelengths. This technology provides a powerful tool to decipher the operating principles that underlie sensory encoding in birds.

From water to land: Evolution of photoreceptor circuits for vision in air

When vertebrates first conquered the land, they encountered a visual world that was radically distinct from that of their aquatic ancestors. Fish exploit the strong wavelength-dependent interactions of light with water by differentially feeding the signals from up to 5 spectral photoreceptor types into distinct behavioural programmes. However, above the water the same spectral rules do not apply, and this called for an update to visual circuit strategies. Early tetrapods soon evolved the double cone, a still poorly understood pair of new photoreceptors that brought the "ancestral terrestrial" complement from 5 to 7. Subsequent nonmammalian lineages differentially adapted this highly parallelised retinal input strategy for their diverse visual ecologies. By contrast, mammals shed most ancestral photoreceptors and converged on an input strategy that is exceptionally general. In eutherian mammals including in humans, parallelisation emerges gradually as the visual signal traverses the layers of the retina and into the brain.