FIGNL1 AAA+ ATPase remodels RAD51 and DMC1 filaments in pre-meiotic DNA replication and meiotic recombination

Structures and mechanisms of AAA+ protein complexes in DNA processing

AAA+ proteins are a large family of ATPases involved in a myriad of cellular activities. Recent advances in AAA+ proteins, especially cryoEM structures of these proteins in complex with their substrates, have provided key insights into how they function. Here we review recent progress in structural studies and mechanistic understanding of AAA+ proteins involved in DNA processing, including gene transcription, DNA replication, repair/recombination and transposition. Using a few selected examples, we show how AAA+ proteins act on both DNA and protein peptides, which are often enclosed in the pores of AAA+ hexamers. We propose that using AAA+ proteins to translocate a peptide to partially unfold a substrate is an effective strategy in disassembling an assembled complex. Further, several studies show that although they often act as asymmetric hexamers in their active form, AAA+ proteins adopt a range of oligomers for their functions.

FIGNL1 hexamer dissociates RAD51-filament: a new mechanism

Homologous recombination (HR) is critical for maintaining genome stability, relying on RAD51 recombinase to catalyze homology-dependent accurate DNA repair. While various cellular modulators control HR, Carver, Yu, et al. reveal a unique molecular mechanism used by FIDGETIN-LIKE-1 (FIGNL1) that dissociates RAD51 from DNA through RAD51 N terminus and FIGNL1 hexamer assembly.

Molecular basis of FIGNL1 in dissociating RAD51 from DNA and chromatin

Maintaining genome integrity is an essential and challenging process. RAD51 recombinase, the central component of several crucial processes in repairing DNA and protecting genome integrity, forms filaments on DNA, which are tightly regulated. One of these RAD51 regulators is FIGNL1 (fidgetin-like 1), which prevents RAD51 genotoxic chromatin association in normal cells and persistent RAD51 foci upon DNA damage. The cryogenic electron microscopy-imaged structure of FIGNL1 in complex with RAD51 reveals that FIGNL1 forms a nonplanar hexamer and encloses RAD51 N terminus in the FIGNL1 hexamer pore. Mutations in pore loop or catalytic residues of FIGNL1 render it defective in filament disassembly and are lethal in mouse embryonic stem cells. Our study reveals a distinct mechanism for removing RAD51 from bound substrates and provides the molecular basis for FIGNL1 in maintaining genome stability.

Distinct and interdependent functions of three RING proteins regulate recombination during mammalian meiosis

During meiosis, each pair of homologous chromosomes becomes connected by at least one crossover, as required for accurate segregation, and adjacent crossovers are widely separated thereby limiting total numbers. In coarsening models, this crossover patterning results from nascent recombination sites competing to accrue a limiting pro-crossover RING-domain protein (COR) that diffuses between synapsed chromosomes. Here, we delineate the localization dynamics of three mammalian CORs in the mouse and determine their interdependencies. RNF212, HEI10, and the newest member RNF212B show divergent spatiotemporal dynamics along synapsed chromosomes, including profound differences in spermatocytes and oocytes, that are not easily reconciled by elementary coarsening models. Contrasting mutant phenotypes and genetic requirements indicate that RNF212B, RNF212, and HEI10 play distinct but interdependent functions in regulating meiotic recombination and coordinating the events of meiotic prophase-I by integrating signals from DNA breaks, homolog synapsis, the cell-cycle, and incipient crossover sites.

Extensive homologous recombination safeguards oocyte genome integrity in mammals

Meiosis in mammalian oocytes is interrupted by a prolonged arrest at the germinal vesicle stage, during which oocytes have to repair DNA lesions to ensure genome integrity or otherwise undergo apoptosis. The FIRRM/FLIP-FIGNL1 complex dissociates RAD51 from the joint DNA molecules in both homologous recombination (HR) and DNA replication. However, as a type of non-meiotic, non-replicative cells, whether this RAD51-dismantling mechanism regulates genome integrity in oocytes remains elusive. Here, we show that FIRRM/FLIP is required for disassembly of RAD51-filaments and maintenance of genome integrity in oocytes. Deletion of FIRRM in oocytes leads to formation of massive nuclear RAD51 foci in oocytes of primordial follicles and activated follicles in mice. These RAD51 foci colocalize with the sites of DNA damage repair, as indicated by RPA2 and EdU, suggesting substantial DNA damage and extensive HR in oocytes. Especially in fully-grown FIRRM-deleted oocytes, RAD51 forms a net-like structure. As a consequence, FIRRM-deleted females are infertile due to aberrant homologous chromosome segregation at metaphase I and primordial follicle insufficiency at young adulthood. Hence, our study demonstrates the physiological importance of HR in maintaining genome integrity in oocytes.

Evolution and functional divergence of the Fidgetin family

The Fidgetin (FIGN) family, which comprises FIGN, Fidgetin-like 1 (FIGNL1), and Fidgetin-like 2 (FIGNL2), is a vital group of microtubule-severing proteins. These proteins feature a conserved AAA+ domain essential for ATPase activity and a hexameric assembly. This review provides an in-depth analysis of the evolution and functional divergence of the FIGN family members, highlighting their role in the dynamic organization of the cytoskeleton. We further explore their broader biological functions across various species, systems, and subcellular localization. Although the FIGN family is conserved, each member exhibits unique structural characteristics and functions that reflect their evolutionary adaptations. FIGNL1 is found across animal species, while FIGNL2 is specific to vertebrates, thereby indicating its more recent evolutionary origin. Moreover, synteny analysis has revealed that FIGN is located in a more conserved genomic region compared to FIGNL2, which has undergone substantial evolutionary changes. The expression patterns of the FIGN members also vary across organisms and tissues. For example, FIGNL2 shows a notably reduced expression in the mammalian nervous system compared to that in lower vertebrates. The FIGN family members have distinct roles in microtubule severing, cell division, and DNA repair. Specifically, FIGN is involved in cell division and neuronal regeneration, FIGNL1 in axonal growth and DNA repair, and FIGNL2 in cell migration and vascular development. Their involvement in these processes underscores their role as potential biomarkers for certain cancers as well as therapeutic targets for diseases affecting the nervous system and cardiovascular development. All these evolutionary insights and functional distinctions of the FIGN family offer a comprehensive framework for understanding cytoskeletal regulation and its implications in health and disease.

FIGL1 attenuates meiotic interhomolog repair and is counteracted by the RAD51 paralog XRCC2 and the chromosome axis protein ASY1 during meiosis

Two recombinases, RAD51 and DMC1, catalyze meiotic break repair to ensure crossovers (COs) between homologous chromosomes (interhomolog) rather than between sisters (intersister). FIDGETIN-LIKE-1 (FIGL1) downregulates both recombinases. However, the understanding of how FIGL1 functions in meiotic repair remains limited. Here, we discover new genetic interactions of Arabidopsis thaliana FIGL1 that are important in vivo determinants of meiotic repair outcome. In figl1 mutants, compromising RAD51-dependent repair, either through the loss of RAD51 paralogs (RAD51B or XRCC2) or RAD54 or by inhibiting RAD51 catalytic activity, results in either unrepaired breaks or meiotic CO defects. Further, XRCC2 physically interacts with FIGL1 and partially counteracts FIGL1 activity for RAD51 focus formation. Our data indicate that RAD51-mediated repair mechanisms compensate FIGL1 dysfunction. FIGL1 is not necessary for intersister repair in dmc1 but is essential for the completion of meiotic repair in mutants such as asy1 that have impaired DMC1 functions and interhomolog bias. We show that FIGL1 attenuates interhomolog repair, and ASY1 counteracts FIGL1 to promote interhomolog recombination. Altogether, this study underlines that multiple factors can counteract FIGL1 activity to promote accurate meiotic repair.

Elevated temperature affects the expression of signaling molecules in quail testes meiosis I prophase, but spermatogenesis remains normal

Spermatogenesis in eukaryotes is a process that occurs within a very narrow temperature threshold, typically not exceeding 36 °C. SPO11 was isolated from the temperature-sensitive mutant receptor of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and is thought to be the only protein that functions during meiosis. This suggested that SPO11 may be the key protein that influenced the temperature of spermatogenesis not exceeding 36 °C. Elevated temperatures typically damage the spermatogenic cells. Birds have a core body temperature of 41-42 °C, and their testis are located inside their bodies, providing an alternative perspective to investigate the potential impact of temperature threshold on spermatogenesis. The objective of this study was to ascertain whether elevated ambient temperatures affect spermatogenesis in birds and whether SPO11 is the key gene affecting the temperature threshold for spermatogenesis. STRA8, SCP3, SPO11, γ-H2AX, and RAD51 were all crucial components in the process of meiotic initiation, synapsis, DNA double-strand break (DSB) induction, homologous chromosome crossover recombination, and repair of DSB. In this study, 39-day-old Japanese quail were subjected to heat stress (HS) at 38 °C for 8 h per day for 3 (3d HS) and 13 (13d HS) consecutive days and analyzed the expression of meiotic signaling molecules (STRA8, SCP3, SPO11, γ-H2AX, and RAD51) using molecular biology techniques, including Immunohistochemistry (IHC), Western Blot (WB), and Real-time Quantitative Polymerase Chain Reaction (qRT-PCR). We found that spermatogenesis was normal in both groups exposed to HS. Meiotic signaling molecules were expressed normally in the 3d HS group. All detected signaling molecules were normally expressed in the 13d HS group, except for SPO11, which showed a significant increase in expression, indicating that SPO11 was temperature-sensitive. We examined the localized expression of each meiotic signaling molecule in quail testis, explored the temperature sensitivity of SPO11, and determined that quail testis can undergo normal spermatogenesis at ambient temperatures exceeding 36 °C. This study concluded that SPO11 is not the key protein influencing spermatogenesis in birds. These findings enhance our understanding of avian spermatogenesis.

Unravelling meiosis in wheat

This article is a Commentary on Osman et al. (2024), 244: 528–541.

FIGL1 prevents aberrant chromosome associations and fragmentation and limits crossovers in polyploid wheat meiosis

Meiotic crossovers (COs) generate genetic diversity and are crucial for viable gamete production. Plant COs are typically limited to 1-3 per chromosome pair, constraining the development of improved varieties, which in wheat is exacerbated by an extreme distal localisation bias. Advances in wheat genomics and related technologies provide new opportunities to investigate, and possibly modify, recombination in this important crop species. Here, we investigate the disruption of FIGL1 in tetraploid and hexaploid wheat as a potential strategy for modifying CO frequency/position. We analysed figl1 mutants and virus-induced gene silencing lines cytogenetically. Genetic mapping was performed in the hexaploid. FIGL1 prevents abnormal meiotic chromosome associations/fragmentation in both ploidies. It suppresses class II COs in the tetraploid such that CO/chiasma frequency increased 2.1-fold in a figl1 msh5 quadruple mutant compared with a msh5 double mutant. It does not appear to affect class I COs based on HEI10 foci counts in a hexaploid figl1 triple mutant. Genetic mapping in the triple mutant suggested no significant overall increase in total recombination across examined intervals but revealed large increases in specific individual intervals. Notably, the tetraploid figl1 double mutant was sterile but the hexaploid triple mutant was moderately fertile, indicating potential utility for wheat breeding.

Mechanisms and regulation of replication fork reversal

DNA replication is remarkably accurate with estimates of only a handful of mutations per human genome per cell division cycle. Replication stress caused by DNA lesions, transcription-replication conflicts, and other obstacles to the replication machinery must be efficiently overcome in ways that minimize errors and maximize completion of DNA synthesis. Replication fork reversal is one mechanism that helps cells tolerate replication stress. This process involves reannealing of parental template DNA strands and generation of a nascent-nascent DNA duplex. While fork reversal may be beneficial by facilitating DNA repair or template switching, it must be confined to the appropriate contexts to preserve genome stability. Many enzymes have been implicated in this process including ATP-dependent DNA translocases like SMARCAL1, ZRANB3, HLTF, and the helicase FBH1. In addition, the RAD51 recombinase is required. Many additional factors and regulatory activities also act to ensure reversal is beneficial instead of yielding undesirable outcomes. Finally, reversed forks must also be stabilized and often need to be restarted to complete DNA synthesis. Disruption or deregulation of fork reversal causes a variety of human diseases. In this review we will describe the latest models for reversal and key mechanisms of regulation.

FIGNL1-FIRRM is essential for meiotic recombination and prevents DNA damage-independent RAD51 and DMC1 loading

During meiosis, nucleoprotein filaments of the strand exchange proteins RAD51 and DMC1 are crucial for repairing SPO11-generated DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) by homologous recombination (HR). A balanced activity of positive and negative RAD51/DMC1 regulators ensures proper recombination. Fidgetin-like 1 (FIGNL1) was previously shown to negatively regulate RAD51 in human cells. However, FIGNL1's role during meiotic recombination in mammals remains unknown. Here, we decipher the meiotic functions of FIGNL1 and FIGNL1 Interacting Regulator of Recombination and Mitosis (FIRRM) using male germline-specific conditional knock-out (cKO) mouse models. Both FIGNL1 and FIRRM are required for completing meiotic prophase in mouse spermatocytes. Despite efficient recruitment of DMC1 on ssDNA at meiotic DSB hotspots, the formation of late recombination intermediates is defective in Firrm cKO and Fignl1 cKO spermatocytes. Moreover, the FIGNL1-FIRRM complex limits RAD51 and DMC1 accumulation on intact chromatin, independently from the formation of SPO11-catalyzed DSBs. Purified human FIGNL1ΔN alters the RAD51/DMC1 nucleoprotein filament structure and inhibits strand invasion in vitro. Thus, this complex might regulate RAD51 and DMC1 association at sites of meiotic DSBs to promote proficient strand invasion and processing of recombination intermediates.

Molecular basis of FIGNL1 in dissociating RAD51 from DNA and chromatin

Maintaining genome integrity is an essential and challenging process. RAD51 recombinase, the central player of several crucial processes in repairing and protecting genome integrity, forms filaments on DNA. RAD51 filaments are tightly regulated. One of these regulators is FIGNL1, that prevents persistent RAD51 foci post-damage and genotoxic chromatin association in cells. The cryogenic electron microscopy structure of FIGNL1 in complex with RAD51 reveals that the FIGNL1 forms a non-planar hexamer and RAD51 N-terminus is enclosed in the FIGNL1 hexamer pore. Mutations in pore loop or catalytic residues of FIGNL1 render it defective in filament disassembly and are lethal in mouse embryonic stem cells. Our study reveals a unique mechanism for removing RAD51 from DNA and provides the molecular basis for FIGNL1 in maintaining genome stability.

Human AAA+ ATPase FIGNL1 suppresses RAD51-mediated ultra-fine bridge formation

RAD51 filament is crucial for the homology-dependent repair of DNA double-strand breaks and stalled DNA replication fork protection. Positive and negative regulators control RAD51 filament assembly and disassembly. RAD51 is vital for genome integrity but excessive accumulation of RAD51 on chromatin causes genome instability and growth defects. However, the detailed mechanism underlying RAD51 disassembly by negative regulators and the physiological consequence of abnormal RAD51 persistence remain largely unknown. Here, we report the role of the human AAA+ ATPase FIGNL1 in suppressing a novel type of RAD51-mediated genome instability. FIGNL1 knockout human cells were defective in RAD51 dissociation after replication fork restart and accumulated ultra-fine chromosome bridges (UFBs), whose formation depends on RAD51 rather than replication fork stalling. FIGNL1 suppresses homologous recombination intermediate-like UFBs generated between sister chromatids at genomic loci with repeated sequences such as telomeres and centromeres. These data suggest that RAD51 persistence per se induces the formation of unresolved linkage between sister chromatids resulting in catastrophic genome instability. FIGNL1 facilitates post-replicative disassembly of RAD51 filament to suppress abnormal recombination intermediates and UFBs. These findings implicate FIGNL1 as a key factor required for active RAD51 removal after processing of stalled replication forks, which is essential to maintain genome stability.

FIRRM and FIGNL1: partners in the regulation of homologous recombination

DNA repair through homologous recombination (HR) is of vital importance for maintaining genome stability and preventing tumorigenesis. RAD51 is the core component of HR, catalyzing the strand invasion and homology search. Here, we highlight recent findings on FIRRM and FIGNL1 as regulators of the dynamics of RAD51.

Positive and negative regulators of RAD51/DMC1 in homologous recombination and DNA replication

RAD51 recombinase plays a central role in homologous recombination (HR) by forming a nucleoprotein filament on single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) to catalyze homology search and strand exchange between the ssDNA and a homologous double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). The catalytic activity of RAD51 assembled on ssDNA is critical for the DNA-homology-mediated repair of DNA double-strand breaks in somatic and meiotic cells and restarting stalled replication forks during DNA replication. The RAD51-ssDNA complex also plays a structural role in protecting the regressed/reversed replication fork. Two types of regulators control RAD51 filament formation, stability, and dynamics, namely positive regulators, including mediators, and negative regulators, so-called remodelers. The appropriate balance of action by the two regulators assures genome stability. This review describes the roles of positive and negative RAD51 regulators in HR and DNA replication and its meiosis-specific homolog DMC1 in meiotic recombination. We also provide future study directions for a comprehensive understanding of RAD51/DMC1-mediated regulation in maintaining and inheriting genome integrity.