Ehrlichia chaffeensis and E. canis hypothetical protein immunoanalysis reveals small secreted immunodominant proteins and conformation-dependent antibody epitopes

Ehrlichia canis Vaccine Development: Challenges and Advances

Canine monocytic ehrlichiosis (CME) is an infectious disease caused by Ehrlichia canis, a globally recognized obligate intracellular bacterium. In addition to dogs, other animals, including humans, may be affected. Despite its epidemiological importance and impact on public health, there is currently no commercial vaccine against E. canis. This study aimed to present relevant aspects of the challenges and advances encountered in the development of vaccines for CME and highlight perspectives for future investigations. High genetic variability, along with the various evasion mechanisms employed by E. canis, has hindered the identification of an antigen that targets Th1 cells and is immunogenic to most E. canis isolates, considering their genotypic and phenotypic characteristics. The vaccine must predominantly confer cellular and humoral immunity to achieve robust immune responses. Early production efforts have been challenging due to low immunogenicity, difficulties in establishing long-term protection, and limitations of the techniques used. However, with the refinement of bioinformatic tools, research in this area will be facilitated, thereby accelerating the development of effective vaccines for CME. According to these authors, this vaccine should consist of multiple epitopes.

Immuno- and expression analysis of Ehrlichia canis immunoreactive proteins

Ehrlichia canis is the primary etiologic agent of canine monocytic ehrlichiosis, a serious and sometimes fatal hemorrhagic disease of dogs. Diagnosis of E. canis infection is often retrospectively confirmed by serologic detection of antibodies by immunofluorescent microscopy. Our laboratory previously identified numerous major immunoreactive proteins with species-specific linear antibody epitopes that are useful for immunodiagnosis of CME. More recently, we have defined the entire antibody-reactive immunome of E. canis, substantially increasing the number of major immunoreactive proteins known to exist. In this study, we analyzed and compared seven recently identified antibody reactive E. canis proteins with established diagnostic antigens including tandem repeat proteins TRP19, TRP36 and TRP140 and observed comparable immunoreactivity. Many of these proteins were conserved in different E. canis strains. Multiple linear antibody epitopes were mapped in a highly conserved TRP (Ecaj_0126), including within the tandem repeat domain. Temporal antibody responses were examined, and multiple proteins reacted with antibodies in sera as early as 21 days post experimental infection. Host-specific expression of the proteins was examined which revealed that some proteins exhibited higher expression in mammalian cells, while others in tick cells. This study has identified new immunodiagnostic candidates that exhibit different host expression patterns, information which may be useful for developing ultrasensitive immunodiagnostics and effective vaccines for CME.

RipE expression correlates with high ATP levels in Ehrlichia, which confers resistance during the extracellular stage to facilitate a new cycle of infection

Ehrlichiosis is a potentially life-threatening disease caused by infection with the obligatory intracellular bacteria Ehrlichia species. Ehrlichia japonica infection of mice provides an animal model of ehrlichiosis as it recapitulates full-spectrum and lethal ehrlichiosis in humans. The E. japonica transposon mutant of EHF0962, which encodes a previously uncharacterized hypothetical protein, is attenuated in both infection and virulence in mice. EHF0962 was hence named here as resistance-inducing protein of Ehrlichia (RipE). Using this ΔripE mutant, we studied how RipE protein contributes to Ehrlichia pathogenesis. Ehrlichia species have an intracellular developmental cycle and a brief extracellular stage to initiate a new cycle of infection. Majority of RipE proteins were expressed on the surface of the smaller infectious dense-core stage of bacteria. Extracellular ΔripE E. japonica contained significantly less adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and lost infectivity more rapidly in culture compared with wild-type (WT) E. japonica. Genetic complementation in the ΔripE mutant or overexpression of ripE in WT E. japonica significantly increased bacterial ATP levels, and RipE-overexpressing E. japonica was more virulent in mice than WT E. japonica. RipE is conserved among Ehrlichia species. Immunization of mice with recombinant RipE induced an in vitro infection-neutralizing antibody, significantly prolonged survival time after a lethal dose of E. japonica challenge, and cross-protected mice from infection by Ehrlichia chaffeensis, the agent of human monocytic ehrlichiosis. Our findings shed light on the extracellular stage of Ehrlichia, highlighting the importance of RipE and ATP levels in Ehrlichia for extracellular resistance and the next cycle of infection. Thus, RipE is a critical Ehrlichia protein for infection as such can be a potential vaccine target for ehrlichiosis.

Vaccine development: obligate intracellular bacteria new tools, old pathogens: the current state of vaccines against obligate intracellular bacteria

Obligate intracellular bacteria have remained those for which effective vaccines are unavailable, mostly because protection does not solely rely on an antibody response. Effective antibody-based vaccines, however, have been developed against extracellular bacteria pathogens or toxins. Additionally, obligate intracellular bacteria have evolved many mechanisms to subvert the immune response, making vaccine development complex. Much of what we know about protective immunity for these pathogens has been determined using infection-resolved cases and animal models that mimic disease. These studies have laid the groundwork for antigen discovery, which, combined with recent advances in vaccinology, should allow for the development of safe and efficacious vaccines. Successful vaccines against obligate intracellular bacteria should elicit potent T cell memory responses, in addition to humoral responses. Furthermore, they ought to be designed to specifically induce strong cytotoxic CD8+ T cell responses for protective immunity. This review will describe what we know about the potentially protective immune responses to this group of bacteria. Additionally, we will argue that the novel delivery platforms used during the Sars-CoV-2 pandemic should be excellent candidates to produce protective immunity once antigens are discovered. We will then look more specifically into the vaccine development for Rickettsiaceae, Coxiella burnetti, and Anaplasmataceae from infancy until today. We have not included Chlamydia trachomatis in this review because of the many vaccine related reviews that have been written in recent years.

Antibody reactive immunomes of Ehrlichia chaffeensis and E. canis are diverse and defined by conformational antigenic determinants

For decades, the defined antibody reactive proteins of Ehrlichia chaffeensis and E. canis were limited to a small group with linear antibody epitopes. Recently, our laboratory has utilized an immunomics-based approach to rapidly screen and identify undefined Ehrlichia chaffeensis and E. canis antigenic proteins and antibody epitopes. In this study, we analyzed the remaining portion (~50%) of the E. chaffeensis and E. canis proteomes (n = 444 and n = 405 proteins, respectively), that were not examined in previous studies, to define the complete immunomes of these important pathogens. Almost half of the E. chaffeensis proteins screened (196/444) reacted with antibodies in convalescent HME patient sera, while only 43 E. canis proteins reacted with CME dog sera. New major immunoreactive proteins were identified in E. chaffeensis (n = 7) and E. canis (n = 1), increasing the total number of E. chaffeensis (n = 14) and E. canis proteins (n = 18) that exhibited antibody reactivity comparable to well-defined major antigenic proteins (TRP120 and TRP19). All of the E. chaffeensis but only some E. canis major immunoreactive proteins contained major conformation-dependent antibody epitopes. The E. chaffeensis immunoreactive proteins were generally small (< 250 amino acids; ~27kDa) and the E. canis proteins were slightly larger (> 320 amino acids; ~35 kDa). The majority of these new Ehrlichia major immunoreactive proteins were predicted to be type I secreted effectors, some of which contained transmembrane domains. Characterization of the immunomes of E. chaffeensis and E. canis and understanding the host specific Ehrlichia immune responses will facilitate identification of protective antigens and define the biophysical epitope characteristics vital to effective vaccine development for the ehrlichioses.

Ehrlichia Notch signaling induction promotes XIAP stability and inhibits apoptosis

Ehrlichia chaffeensis has evolved multiple strategies to evade innate defenses of the mononuclear phagocyte. Recently, we reported the E. chaffeensis tandem repeat protein (TRP)120 effector functions as a Notch ligand mimetic and a ubiquitin ligase that degrades the nuclear tumor suppressor, F-box and WD repeat domain-containing 7, a negative regulator of Notch. The Notch intracellular domain (NICD) is known to inhibit apoptosis primarily by interacting with X-linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein (XIAP) to prevent degradation. In this study, we determined that E. chaffeensis activation of Notch signaling increases XIAP levels, thereby inhibiting apoptosis through both the intrinsic and executioner pathways. Increased NICD and XIAP levels were detected during E. chaffeensis infection and after TRP120 Notch ligand mimetic peptide treatment. Conversely, XIAP levels were reduced in the presence of Notch inhibitor DAPT. Cytoplasmic and nuclear colocalization of NICD and XIAP was observed during infection and a direct interaction was confirmed by co-immunoprecipitation. Procaspase levels increased temporally during infection, consistent with increased XIAP levels; however, knockdown (KD) of XIAP during infection significantly increased apoptosis and Caspase-3, -7, and -9 levels. Furthermore, treatment with SM-164, a second mitochondrial activator of caspases (Smac/DIABLO) antagonist, resulted in decreased procaspase levels and increased caspase activation, induced apoptosis, and significantly decreased infection. In addition, RNAi KD of XIAP also decreased infection and significantly increased apoptosis. Moreover, ectopic expression of TRP120 HECT Ub ligase catalytically defective mutant in HeLa cells decreased NICD and XIAP levels and increased caspase activation compared to HeLa cells with functional HECT Ub ligase catalytic activity (TRP120-WT). This investigation reveals a mechanism whereby E. chaffeensis modulates Notch signaling to stabilize XIAP and inhibit apoptosis.

Type 1 secretion system and effectors in Rickettsiales

Obligate intracellular bacteria in the order Rickettsiales are transmitted by arthropod vectors and cause life-threatening infections in humans and animals. While both type 1 and type 4 secretion systems (T1SS and T4SS) have been identified in this group, the most extensive studies of Rickettsiales T1SS and associated effectors have been performed in Ehrlichia. These studies have uncovered important roles for the T1SS effectors in pathobiology and immunity. To evade innate immune responses and promote intracellular survival, Ehrlichia and other related obligate pathogens secrete multiple T1SS effectors which interact with a diverse network of host targets associated with essential cellular processes. T1SS effectors have multiple functional activities during infection including acting as nucleomodulins and ligand mimetics that activate evolutionarily conserved cellular signaling pathways. In Ehrlichia, an array of newly defined major immunoreactive proteins have been identified that are predicted as T1SS substrates and have conformation-dependent antibody epitopes. These findings highlight the underappreciated and largely uncharacterized roles of T1SS effector proteins in pathobiology and immunity. This review summarizes current knowledge regarding roles of T1SS effectors in Rickettsiales members during infection and explores newly identified immunoreactive proteins as potential T1SS substrates and targets of a protective host immune response.

Ehrlichia canis: Molecular characterization and genetic diversity based on the p28 and trp36 genes

Ehrlichia canis is a common tick-borne intracellular pathogen causing canine monocytic ehrlichiosis (CME) in dogs worldwide. The aims of this study were to investigate the genetic diversity and antigenicity of E. canis based on the p28 and trp36 genes in dogs in Thailand. The E. canis p28 and trp36 genes were amplified by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and cloned for sequencing and bioinformatic analyses. 36% (44/120) of dog blood samples were positive for E. canis DNA consisting of p28 (31%, 14/44) and trp36 (69%, 30/44) genes with 792 and 882 bp of PCR products size, respectively. The E. canis TRP36 from all Thailand sequences exhibited encoded nine amino acids (TEDSVSAPA) with 11 copies of tandem repeats along the sequences. The phylogenetic trees of E. canis, using the p28 and trp36 genes, exhibited that the Thailand isolates fell into two clades and one clade with similarity ranging from 55.95 to 100% and 100%, respectively. The results of diversity analysis revealed 10 and 20 haplotypes of the p28 and trp 36 genes, respectively. The entropy analysis of the p28 and trp36 nucleic acid sequences showed 442 and 1321 high entropy peaks respectively, whereas those of the P28 and TRP36 amino acid sequences showed 477 and 388 high entropy peaks, respectively. For B-cell epitopes analysis, the conserved amino acid of P28 and TRP36 sequences has been also demonstrated. Therefore, the results could be utilized to improve the understanding of phylogenetic relationship, genetic diversity and antigenicity of E. canis Thailand isolates.

Ehrlichia Notch signaling induction promotes XIAP stability and inhibits apoptosis

Ehrlichia chaffeensis has evolved multiple strategies to evade innate defenses of the mononuclear phagocyte. Recently, we reported the E. chaffeensis TRP120 effector functions as a Notch ligand mimetic and a ubiquitin ligase that degrades the nuclear tumor suppressor, F-box and WD repeat domain-containing 7 (FBW7), a negative regulator of Notch. The Notch receptor intracellular domain (NICD) is known to inhibit apoptosis primarily by interacting with X-linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein (XIAP) to prevent degradation. In this study, we determined E. chaffeensis activation of Notch signaling increases XIAP levels, thereby inhibiting intrinsic apoptosis. Increased NICD and XIAP levels were detected during E. chaffeensis infection and after TRP120 Notch ligand mimetic peptide treatment. Conversely, XIAP levels were reduced in the presence of Notch inhibitor DAPT. Cytoplasmic colocalization of NICD and XIAP was observed during infection and a direct interaction was confirmed by co-immunoprecipitation. Procaspase levels increased temporally during infection, consistent with increased XIAP levels; however, knockdown of XIAP during infection significantly increased apoptosis and Caspase-3, -7 and -9 levels. Further, treatment with SM-164, a second mitochondrial activator of caspases (Smac/DIABLO) antagonist, resulted in decreased procaspase levels and increased caspase activation, induced apoptosis, and significantly decreased infection. In addition, iRNA knockdown of XIAP also decreased infection and significantly increased apoptosis. Moreover, ectopic expression of TRP120 HECT Ub ligase catalytically defective mutant in HeLa cells decreased NICD and XIAP levels and increased caspase activation compared to WT. This investigation reveals a mechanism whereby E. chaffeensis repurposes Notch signaling to stabilize XIAP and inhibit apoptosis.

Author Summary

Ehrlichia chaffeensis is a tick-borne, obligately intracellular bacterium that exhibits tropism for mononuclear phagocytes. E. chaffeensis survives by mobilizing various molecular strategies to promote cell survival, including modulation of apoptosis. This investigation reveals an E. chaffeensis initiated, Notch signaling regulated, antiapoptotic mechanism involving inhibitor of apoptosis proteins (IAPs). Herein, we demonstrate that E. chaffeensis induced Notch activation results in Notch intracellular domain stabilization of X-linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein (XIAP) to inhibit intrinsic apoptosis. This study highlights a novel mechanistic strategy whereby intracellular pathogens repurpose evolutionarily conserved eukaryotic signaling pathways to engage an antiapoptotic program for intracellular survival.

Genome-Wide Subtraction Analysis and Reverse Vaccinology to Detect Novel Drug Targets and Potential Vaccine Candidates Against Ehrlichia chaffeensis

Human monocytotropic ehrlichiosis is an emerging tick-borne infection caused by the obligate intracellular pathogen, Ehrlichia chaffeensis. The non-specific symptoms can range from a self-limiting fever to a fatal septic-like syndrome and may be misdiagnosed. The limited treatment choices including doxycycline are effective only in the initiation phase of the infection. It seems that novel therapeutic targets and new vaccine strategies could be effective to control this pathogen. This study is comprised of two major phases. First, the common proteins retrieved through subtractive analysis and potential drug targets were evaluated by subcellular localization, homology prediction, metabolic pathways, druggability, essentiality, protein-protein interaction networks, and protein data bank availability. In the second phase, surface-exposed proteins were assessed based on antigenicity, allergenicity, physiochemical properties, B cell and T cell epitopes, conserved domains, and protein-protein interaction networks. A multi-epitope vaccine was designed and characterized using molecular dockings and immune simulation analysis. Six proteins including WP_011452818.1, WP_011452723.1, WP_006010413.1, WP_006010278.1, WP_011452938.1, and WP_006010644.1 were detected. They belong to unique metabolic pathways of E. chaffeensis that are considered as new essential drug targets. Based on the reverse vaccinology, WP_011452702.1, WP_044193405.1, WP_044170604.1, and WP_006010191.1 proteins were potential vaccine candidates. Finally, four B cell epitopes, including SINNQDRNC, FESVSSYNI, SGKKEISVQSN, and QSSAKRKST, were used to generate the multi-epitope vaccine based on LCL platform. The vaccine showed strong interactions with toll-like receptors and acceptable immune-reactivity by immune simulation analysis. The findings of this study may represent a turning point in developing an effective drug and vaccine against E. chaffeensis. However, further experimental analyses have remained.

Computational Mining and Characterization of Hypothetical Proteins of Mycobacterium bovis Toward the Identification of Probable Vaccine Candidates

A hypothetical protein (HP) is one that is known to exist only on the basis of a corresponding gene but without any function assigned to it. Many HPs have emerged as attractive vaccine candidates against prokaryotic and eukaryotic pathogens as well as against cancers. Mycobacterium bovis is a serious veterinary pathogen of tremendous zoonotic importance. This protocol describes a computational workflow for the identification of the HPs of M. bovis with vaccine potential and their subsequent structural and functional characterization.

Immunoreactive Protein Repertoires of Ehrlichia chaffeensis and E. canis Reveal the Dominance of Hypothetical Proteins and Conformation-dependent Antibody Epitopes

The immunomes of Ehrlichia chaffeensis (E. ch.) and E. canis (E. ca.) have recently be revised to include immunodominant hypothetical proteins with conformational antibody epitopes. In this study, we examined 216 E. ch. and 190 E. ca. highly antigenic proteins according to ANTIGENpro and also performed a genome-wide hypothetical protein analysis (E. ch. n=104; E. ca. n=124) for immunoreactivity. Using cell-free protein expression and immunoanalysis, 118 E. ch. and 39 E. ca. proteins reacted with sera from naturally E. ch.-infected patients or E. ca.-infected dogs. Moreover, 22 E. ch. and 18 E. ca. proteins consistently and strongly reacted with a panel of patient or canine sera. A subset of E. ch. (n=18) and E. ca. (n=9) proteins were identified as immunodominant. Consistent with our previous study, most proteins were classified as hypothetical and the antibody epitopes exhibited complete or partial conformation-dependence. The majority (28/40; 70%) of E. ch. and E. ca. proteins contained transmembrane domains and 19 (48%) were predicted to be secreted effectors. The antigenic repertoires of E. ch. and E. ca. were mostly diverse and suggest that the immunomes of these closely related ehrlichiae are dominated by species-specific conformational antibody epitopes. This study reveals a significant group of previously undefined E. ch. and E. ca. antigens and reaffirms the importance of conformation-dependent epitopes as targets of anti-Ehrlichia immune responses. These findings substantially expand our understanding of host-Ehrlichia immune responses, advance efforts to define the molecular features of protective proteins and improve prospects for effective vaccines for the ehrlichioses.

Ehrlichia TRP effectors: moonlighting, mimicry and infection

Intracellular bacteria have evolved various strategies to evade host defense mechanisms. Remarkably, the obligately intracellular bacterium, Ehrlichia chaffeensis, hijacks host cell processes of the mononuclear phagocyte to evade host defenses through mechanisms executed in part by tandem repeat protein (TRP) effectors secreted by the type 1 secretion system. In the past decade, TRP120 has emerged as a model moonlighting effector, acting as a ligand mimetic, nucleomodulin and ubiquitin ligase. These defined functions illuminate the diverse roles TRP120 plays in exploiting and manipulating host cell processes, including cytoskeletal organization, vesicle trafficking, cell signaling, transcriptional regulation, post-translational modifications, autophagy and apoptosis. This review will focus on TRP effectors and their expanding roles in infection and provide perspective on Ehrlichia chaffeensis as an invaluable model organism for understanding infection strategies of obligately intracellular bacteria.