RNA-mediated symmetry breaking enables singular olfactory receptor choice

Genomic snowflakes: how the uniqueness of DNA folding allows us to smell the chemical universe

Olfactory receptor (OR) gene choice, the stable expression of one out of >2000 OR alleles by olfactory sensory neurons, constitutes a gene regulatory process that is driven by three-dimensional nuclear architecture. Moreover, the differentiation-dependent process that culminates in monogenic and monoallelic OR transcription represents a powerful demonstration of the rich mechanistic insight that single-cell genomics and multiomics can provide toward the understanding of a biological process. At this review, we describe the latest advances in the understanding of OR gene regulation and highlight important standing questions regarding the emerging specificity of ultra-long-range genomic interaction and the contribution of transcription and noncoding RNAs.

Solid phase transitions as a solution to the genome folding paradox

Ultra-long-range genomic contacts, which are key components of neuronal genome architecture1-3, constitute a biochemical enigma. This is because regulatory DNA elements make selective and stable contacts with DNA sequences located hundreds of kilobases away, instead of interacting with proximal sequences occupied by the exact same transcription factors1,4. This is exemplified in olfactory sensory neurons (OSNs), in which only a fraction of LHX2-, EBF1- and LDB1-bound sites interact with each other, converging into highly selective multi-chromosomal enhancer hubs5. To obtain biochemical insight into this process, here we assembled olfactory receptor (OR) enhancer hubs in vitro with recombinant proteins and enhancer DNA. Cell-free reconstitution of enhancer hubs revealed that OR enhancers form nucleoprotein condensates with unusual, solid-like characteristics. Assembly of these solid condensates is orchestrated by specific DNA motifs enriched in OR enhancers, which are likely to confer distinct homotypic properties on their resident LHX2-EBF1-LDB1 complexes. Single-molecule tracking and pulse-chase experiments in vivo confirmed that LHX2 and EBF1 assemble OR-transcription-competent condensates with solid properties in OSN nuclei, under physiological concentrations of protein. Thus, homophilic nucleoprotein interactions that are influenced by DNA sequence generate new types of biomolecular condensate, which might provide a generalizable explanation for the stability and specificity of long-range genomic contacts across cell types.

New dimensions in the molecular genetics of insect chemoreception

Chemoreception is the foundation of olfaction and taste, which in insects underlie the detection of humans to whom they spread disease and crops that they ravage. Recent advances have provided clear and in some cases surprising new insights into the molecular genetics of chemoreception. We describe mechanisms that govern the choice of a single Odorant receptor gene by an olfactory receptor neuron in Drosophila. We highlight genetic and epigenetic mechanisms by which chemoreceptor expression can be modulated. Exitrons, RNA editing, and pseudo-pseudogenes in chemosensory systems are described. We summarize key insights from the recent structural determinations of odorant and taste receptors. Finally, new molecular components of chemosensory systems, including long noncoding RNAs, are described.

3D genome folding in epigenetic regulation and cellular memory

The 3D folding of the genome is tightly linked to its epigenetic state which maintains gene expression programmes. Although the relationship between gene expression and genome organisation is highly context dependent, 3D genome organisation is emerging as a novel epigenetic layer to reinforce and stabilise transcriptional states. Whether regulatory information carried in genome folding could be transmitted through mitosis is an area of active investigation. In this review, we discuss the relationship between epigenetic state and nuclear organisation, as well as the interplay between transcriptional regulation and epigenetic genome folding. We also consider the architectural remodelling of nuclei as cells enter and exit mitosis, and evaluate the potential of the 3D genome to contribute to cellular memory.

Principles of long-range gene regulation

Transcription from gene promoters occurs in specific spatiotemporal patterns in multicellular organisms, controlled by genomic regulatory elements. The communication between a regulatory element and a promoter requires a certain degree of physical proximity between them; hence, most gene regulation occurs locally in the genome. However, recent discoveries have revealed long-range gene regulation strategies that enhance interactions between regulatory elements and promoters by overcoming the distances between them in the linear genome. These new findings challenge the traditional view of how gene expression patterns are controlled. This review examines long-range gene regulation strategies recently reported in Drosophila and mammals, offering insights into their mechanisms and evolution.

Exploring the interplay between enhancer-promoter interactions and transcription

Enhancers in metazoan genomes are known to activate their target genes across both short and long genomic distances. Recent advances in chromosome conformation capture assays and single-cell imaging have shed light on the underlying chromatin contacts and dynamics. Yet the relationship between 3D physical enhancer-promoter (E-P) interactions and transcriptional activation remains unresolved. In this brief review, we discuss recent studies exploring this relationship across scales: from developmental stages to the minutes surrounding transcriptional activation and from the tissue level to single-allele subcellular dynamics. We discuss how seemingly contradictory observations might be reconciled and contribute to a refined causal relationship between E-P interactions and transcription, with mutual influences.

Nascent transcript O-MAP reveals the molecular architecture of a single-locus subnuclear compartment built by RBM20 and the TTN RNA

Eukaryotic nuclei adopt a highly compartmentalized architecture that influences nearly all genomic processes. Understanding how this architecture impacts gene expression has been hindered by a lack of tools for elucidating the molecular interactions at individual genomic loci. Here, we adapt oligonucleotide-mediated proximity-interactome mapping (O-MAP) to biochemically characterize discrete, micron-scale nuclear neighborhoods. By targeting O-MAP to introns within the TTN pre-mRNA, we systematically map the chromatin loci, RNAs, and proteins within a muscle-specific RNA factory organized around the TTN locus. This reveals an unanticipated compartmental architecture that organizes cis - and trans -interacting chromosomal domains, including a hub of transcriptionally silenced chromatin. The factory also recruits dozens of unique RNA-binding and chromatin-scaffolding factors, including QKI and SAFB, along with their target transcripts. Loss of the cardiac-specific splicing factor RBM20-a master regulator of TTN splicing that is mutated in dilated cardiomyopathy-remodels nearly every facet of this architecture. This establishes O-MAP as a pioneering method for probing single-locus, microcompartment-level interactions that are opaque to conventional tools. Our findings suggest new mechanisms by which coding genes can "moonlight" in nuclear-architectural roles.

Noncanonical microprotein regulation of immunity

The immune system is highly regulated but, when dysregulated, suboptimal protective or overly robust immune responses can lead to immune-mediated disorders. The genetic and molecular mechanisms of immune regulation are incompletely understood, impeding the development of more precise diagnostics and therapeutics for immune-mediated disorders. Recently, thousands of previously unrecognized noncanonical microprotein genes encoded by small open reading frames have been identified. Many of these microproteins perform critical functions, often in a cell- and context-specific manner. Several microproteins are now known to regulate immunity; however, the vast majority are uncharacterized. Therefore, illuminating what is often referred to as the "dark proteome," may present opportunities to tune immune responses more precisely. Here, we review noncanonical microprotein biology, highlight recently discovered examples regulating immunity, and discuss the potential and challenges of modulating dysregulated immune responses by targeting microproteins.

The influence of olfactory experience on the birthrates of olfactory sensory neurons with specific odorant receptor identities

Olfactory sensory neurons (OSNs) are one of a few neuron types that are generated continuously throughout life in mammals. The persistence of olfactory sensory neurogenesis beyond early development has long been thought to function simply to replace neurons that are lost or damaged through exposure to environmental insults. The possibility that olfactory sensory neurogenesis may also serve an adaptive function has received relatively little consideration, largely due to the assumption that the generation of new OSNs is stochastic with respect to OSN subtype, as defined by the single odorant receptor gene that each neural precursor stochastically chooses for expression out of hundreds of possibilities. Accordingly, the relative birthrates of different OSN subtypes are predicted to be constant and impervious to olfactory experience. This assumption has been called into question, however, by evidence that the birthrates of specific OSN subtypes can be selectively altered by manipulating olfactory experience through olfactory deprivation, enrichment, and conditioning paradigms. Moreover, studies of recovery of the OSN population following injury provide further evidence that olfactory sensory neurogenesis may not be strictly stochastic with respect to subtype. Here we review this evidence and consider mechanistic and functional implications of the prospect that specific olfactory experiences can regulate olfactory sensory neurogenesis rates in a subtype-selective manner.

Establishment and maintenance of random monoallelic expression

This Review elucidates the regulatory principles of random monoallelic expression by focusing on two well-studied examples: the X-chromosome inactivation regulator Xist and the olfactory receptor gene family. Although the choice of a single X chromosome or olfactory receptor occurs in different developmental contexts, common gene regulatory principles guide monoallelic expression in both systems. In both cases, an event breaks the symmetry between genetically and epigenetically identical copies of the gene, leading to the expression of one single random allele, stabilized through negative feedback control. Although many regulatory steps that govern the establishment and maintenance of monoallelic expression have been identified, key pieces of the puzzle are still missing. We provide an overview of the current knowledge and models for the monoallelic expression of Xist and olfactory receptors. We discuss their similarities and differences, and highlight open questions and approaches that could guide the study of other monoallelically expressed genes.

Transcriptional priming and chromatin regulation during stochastic cell fate specification

Stochastic cell fate specification, in which a cell chooses between two or more fates with a set probability, diversifies cell subtypes in development. Although this is a vital process across species, a common mechanism for these cell fate decisions remains elusive. This review examines two well-characterized stochastic cell fate decisions to identify commonalities between their developmental programmes. In the fly eye, two subtypes of R7 photoreceptors are specified by the stochastic ON/OFF expression of a transcription factor, spineless. In the mouse olfactory system, olfactory sensory neurons (OSNs) randomly select to express one copy of an olfactory receptor (OR) gene out of a pool of 2800 alleles. Despite the differences in these sensory systems, both stochastic fate choices rely on the dynamic interplay between transcriptional priming, chromatin regulation and terminal gene expression. The coupling of transcription and chromatin modifications primes gene loci in undifferentiated neurons, enabling later expression during terminal differentiation. Here, we compare these mechanisms, examine broader implications for gene regulation during development and posit key challenges moving forward. This article is part of a discussion meeting issue 'Causes and consequences of stochastic processes in development and disease'.

Epigenetic programming of stochastic olfactory receptor choice

The mammalian sense of smell relies upon a vast array of receptor proteins to detect odorant compounds present in the environment. The proper deployment of these receptor proteins in olfactory sensory neurons is orchestrated by a suite of epigenetic processes that remodel the olfactory genes in differentiating neuronal progenitors. The goal of this review is to elucidate the central role of gene regulatory processes acting in neuronal progenitors of olfactory sensory neurons that lead to a singular expression of an odorant receptor in mature olfactory sensory neurons. We begin by describing the principal features of odorant receptor gene expression in mature olfactory sensory neurons. Next, we delineate our current understanding of how these features emerge from multiple gene regulatory mechanisms acting in neuronal progenitors. Finally, we close by discussing the key gaps in our understanding of how these regulatory mechanisms work and how they interact with each other over the course of differentiation.

Molecular mechanisms of differentiation and class choice of olfactory sensory neurons

The sense of smell is intricately linked to essential animal behaviors necessary for individual survival and species preservation. During vertebrate evolution, odorant receptors (ORs), responsible for detecting odor molecules, have evolved to adapt to changing environments, transitioning from aquatic to terrestrial habitats and accommodating increasing complex chemical environments. These evolutionary pressures have given rise to the largest gene family in vertebrate genomes. Vertebrate ORs are phylogenetically divided into two major classes; class I and class II. Class I OR genes, initially identified in fish and frog, have persisted across vertebrate species. On the other hand, class II OR genes are unique to terrestrial animals, accounting for ~90% of mammalian OR genes. In mice, each olfactory sensory neuron (OSN) expresses a single functional allele of a single OR gene from either the class I or class II OR repertoire. This one neuron-one receptor rule is established through two sequential steps: specification of OR class and subsequent exclusive OR expression from the corresponding OR class. Consequently, OSNs acquire diverse neuronal identities during the process of OSN differentiation, enabling animals to detect a wide array of odor molecules. This review provides an overview of the OSN differentiation process through which OSN diversity is achieved, primarily using the mouse as a model animal.

Exitron splicing of odor receptor genes in Drosophila

Proper expression of odor receptor genes is critical for the function of olfactory systems. In this study, we identified exitrons (exonic introns) in four of the 39 Odorant receptor (Or) genes expressed in the Drosophila antenna. Exitrons are sequences that can be spliced out from within a protein-coding exon, thereby altering the encoded protein. We focused on Or88a, which encodes a pheromone receptor, and found that exitron splicing of Or88a is conserved across five Drosophila species over 20 My of evolution. The exitron was spliced out in 15% of Or88a transcripts. Removal of this exitron creates a non-coding RNA rather than an RNA that encodes a stable protein. Our results suggest the hypothesis that in the case of Or88a, exitron splicing could act in neuronal modulation by decreasing the level of functional Or transcripts. Activation of Or88a-expressing olfactory receptor neurons via either optogenetics or pheromone stimulation increased the level of exitron-spliced transcripts, with optogenetic activation leading to a 14-fold increase. A fifth Or can also undergo an alternative splicing event that eliminates most of the canonical open reading frame. Besides these cases of alternative splicing, we found alternative polyadenylation of four Ors, and exposure of Or67c to its ligand ethyl lactate in the antenna downregulated all of its 3' isoforms. Our study reveals mechanisms by which neuronal activity could be modulated via regulation of the levels of Or isoforms.

A noncoding role of coding mRNA in monogenic olfactory receptor choice

In a recent study, Pourmorady and colleagues uncovered a noncoding role for olfactory receptor (OR)-coding mRNA in mediating nuclear architecture and singular OR choice. The OR mRNAs reinforce the prevailing enhancer hub and inhibit other competitors, facilitating transition from polygenic to singular OR expression.

Chromatin structure and var2csa - a tango in regulation of var gene expression in the human malaria parasite, Plasmodium falciparum?

Over the last few decades, novel methods have been developed to study how chromosome positioning within the nucleus may play a role in gene regulation. Adaptation of these methods in the human malaria parasite, Plasmodium falciparum, has recently led to the discovery that the three-dimensional structure of chromatin within the nucleus may be critical in controlling expression of virulence genes (var genes). Recent work has implicated an unusual, highly conserved var gene called var2csa in contributing to coordinated transcriptional switching, however how this gene functions in this capacity is unknown. To further understand how var2csa influences var gene switching, targeted DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) within the sub-telomeric region of chromosome 12 were used to delete the gene and the surrounding chromosomal region. To characterize the changes in chromatin architecture stemming from this deletion and how these changes could affect var gene expression, we used a combination of RNA-seq, Chip-seq and Hi-C to pinpoint epigenetic and chromatin structural modifications in regions of differential gene expression. We observed a net gain of interactions in sub-telomeric regions and internal var gene regions following var2csa knockout, indicating an increase of tightly controlled heterochromatin structures. Our results suggest that disruption of var2csa results not only in changes in var gene transcriptional regulation but also a significant tightening of heterochromatin clusters thereby disrupting coordinated activation of var genes throughout the genome. Altogether our result confirms a strong link between the var2csa locus, chromatin structure and var gene expression.