Insights into the self-assembly of giant polyoxomolybdates from building blocks to supramolecular structures

Giant polyoxomolybdates are a special class of polyoxometalate clusters which can bridge the gap between small molecule clusters and large polymeric entities. Besides, giant polyoxomolybdates also show interesting applications in catalysis, biochemistry, photovoltaic and electronic devices, and other fields. Revealing the evolution route of the reducing species into the final cluster structure and also their further hierarchical self-assembly behaviour is undoubtedly fascinating, aiming to guide the design and synthesis. Herein, we reviewed the self-assembly mechanism study of giant polyoxomolybdate clusters, and the exploration of a new structure and new synthesis methodology is also summarized. Finally, we emphasize the importance of in-operando characterization in revealing the self-assembly mechanism of giant polyoxomolybdates, and especially for the further reconstruction of intermediates into the designable synthesis of new structures.

Gamma-Ray-Induced Formation of Uranyl Peroxide Cage Clusters

Aqueous solutions of lithium uranyl triperoxide, Li₄[UO₂(O₂)₃] (LiUT), were irradiated with gamma rays at room temperature and found to form the uranyl peroxide cage cluster, Li₂₄[(UO₂)(O₂)(OH)]₂₄ (Li-U₂₄). Raman spectroscopy and ¹⁸O labeling were used to identify the Raman-active vibrations of LiUT. With these assignments, the concentration of LiUT was tracked as a function of radiation dose. A discrepancy between monomer removal and cluster formation suggests that the reaction proceeds by the assembly of an intermediate. Non-negative matrix factorization was used to separate Raman spectra into components and resulted in the identification of a unique intermediate species. Much of the conversion appears to be driven by water radiolysis products, particularly the hydroxyl radical. This differs from the ¹⁸O-labeled copper-catalyzed formation of U₂₄, which progresses at a steady rate with no observation of intermediates. Li-U₂₄ in solution decomposes at high radiation doses resulting in a solid insoluble product similar to Na-compreignacite, Na₂(UO₂)₆O₄(OH)₆·7H₂O, which contains uranyl oxyhydroxy sheets.

Detecting the Subtle Photo-Responsive Conformational Bistability of Monomeric Azobenzene Functionalized Keggin Polyoxometalates by Using Ion-Mobility Mass Spectrometry

Accurately characterizing the conformational variation of novel molecular assemblies is important but often ignored due to limited characterization methods. Herein, we reported the use of ion-mobility mass spectrometry (IMS/MS) to investigate the conformational changes of four azobenzene covalently functionalized Keggin hybrids (azo-Keggins, compounds 1–4). The as-prepared azo-Keggins showed the general molecular formula of [C₁₆H₃₆N]₄[SiW₁₁O₄₀(Si(CH₂)₃NH–CO(CH₂)_nO–C₆H₄N=NC₆H₄–R)₂] (R = H, n = 0 (1); R = NO₂, n = 0 (2); R = H, n = 5 (3); R = H, n = 10 (4)). The resultant azo-Keggins maintained stable monomeric states in the gas phase with intact molecular structures. Furthermore, the subtle photo-responsive trans-cis conformational variations of azo-Keggins were clearly revealed by the molecular shape-related collision cross-section value difference ranging from 2.44 Ų to 6.91 Ų. The longer the alkyl chains linkers were, the larger the conformational variation was. Moreover, for compounds 1 and 2, higher stability in trans-conformation can be observed, while for compounds 3 and 4, bistability can be achieved for both of them.

Lanthanides Singing the Blues: Their Fascinating Role in the Assembly of Gigantic Molybdenum Blue Wheels

Molybdenum blues (MBs) are a distinct class of polyoxometalates, exhibiting versatile/impressive architectures and high structural flexibility. In acidified and reduced aqueous environments, isopolymolybdates generate precisely organizable building blocks, which enable unique nanoscopic molecular systems (MBs) to be constructed and further fine-tuned by hetero elements such as lanthanide (Ln) ions. This Review discusses wheel-shaped MB-based structure types with strong emphasis on the ∼30 Ln-containing MBs as of August 2021, which include both organically hybridized and nonhybridized structures synthesized to date. The spotlight is thereby put on the lanthanide ions and ligand types, which are crucial for the resulting Ln-patterns and alterations in the gigantic structures. Several critical steps and reaction conditions in their synthesis are highlighted, as well as appropriate methods to investigate them both in solid state and in solution. The final section addresses the homogeneous/heterogeneous catalytic, molecular recognition and separation properties of wheel-shaped Ln-MBs, emphasizing their inimitable behavior and encouraging their application in these areas.

Exploring the Geometric Space of Metal-Organic Polyhedrons (MOPs) of Metal-Oxo Clusters

Metal organic polyhedra (MOPs) such as coordination cages and clusters are increasingly utilized across many fields, but their geometrically selective assembly during synthesis is nontrivial. When ligand coordination along these polyhedral edges is arranged in an unsymmetrical mode or the bridging ligand itself is nonsymmetric, a vast combinatorial space of potential isomers exists complicating formation and isolation. Here we describe two generalizable combinatorial methodologies to explore the geometrical space and enumerate the configurational isomers of MOPs with discrimination of the chiral and achiral structures. The methodology has been applied to the case of the octahedron {Bi₆Fe₁₃L₁₂} which has unsymmetrical coordination of a carboxylate ligand (L) along its edges. For these polyhedra, the enumeration methodology revealed 186 distinct isomers, including 74 chiral pairs and 38 achiral. To explore the programming of these, we then used a range of ligands to synthesize several configurational isomers. Our analysis demonstrates that ligand halo-substituents influence isomer symmetry and suggests that more symmetric halo-substituted ligands counterintuitively yield lower symmetry isomers. We performed mass spectrometry studies of these {Bi₆Fe₁₃L₁₂} clusters to evaluate their stability and aggregation behavior in solution and the gas phase showing that various isomers have different levels of aggregation in solution.

We describe combinatorial methodologies to explore the geometrical space and enumerate the configurational isomers of metal organic polyhedra with discrimination of the chiral and achiral structures. The methodology was applied to the octahedral {Bi₆Fe₁₃L₁₂} which has an unsymmetrical coordination of a carboxylate ligands (L) along its edges. For these polyhedra, the enumeration methodology revealed 186 distinct isomers, including 74 chiral pairs and 38 achiral. We used a range of ligands to synthesize several configurational isomers.

Reactivity, Formation, and Solubility of Polyoxometalates Probed by Calorimetry

Room temperature calorimetry methods were developed to describe the energy landscapes of six polyoxometalates (POMs), Li-U24, Li-U28, K-U28, Li/K-U60, Mo132, and Mo154, in terms of three components: enthalpy of dissolution (ΔHdiss), enthalpy of formation of aqueous POMs (ΔHf,(aq)), and enthalpy of formation of POM crystals (ΔHf,(c)). ΔHdiss is controlled by a combination of cation solvation enthalpy and the favorability of cation interactions with binding sites on the POM. In the case of the four uranyl peroxide POMs studied, clusters with hydroxide bridges have lower ΔHf,(aq) and are more stable than those containing only peroxide bridges. In general for POMs, the combination of calorimetric results and synthetic observations suggest that spherical topologies may be more stable than wheel-like clusters, and ΔHf,(aq) can be accurately estimated using only ΔHf,(c) values owing to the dominance of the clusters in determining the energetics of POM crystals.

An unprecedented polyhydroxycarboxylic acid ligand bridged multi-EuIII incorporated tellurotungstate and its luminescence properties

The first polyhydroxycarboxylic acid ligand bridged multi-EuIII-incorporated tellurotungstate K14H10[Eu4(H2O)4W6(H2glu)4O12(B-α-TeW9O33)4]·60H2O (H6glu = d-gluconic acid) (1) was synthesized via an organic ligand-driven self-assembly strategy. The polyhydroxycarboxylic acid ligand bridged tetrameric polyoxoanion [Eu4(H2O)4W6(H2glu)4O12(B-α-TeW9O33)4]24- in 1 can be viewed as an aggregation of four trivacant Keggin [B-α-TeW9O33]8- fragments and an innovative heterometallic [Eu4(H2O)4W6(H2glu)4O12]8+ cluster, in which four high-coordinate polyhydroxy flexible H2glu4- ligands chelate W and Eu centers through carboxyl and hydroxyl groups, giving rise to a heterometallic cluster. The hexagonal packing of the tetrameric polyoxoanions in 1 along the c axis provides excellent porous channels, which greatly increases the specific surface area of the whole framework and may be of benefit for fluorescence sensing in aqueous solution. 1 can function as a "turn-off" luminescence sensor to detect Cu2+ ions in aqueous solution. The limit of detection (LOD) of the 1-sensor is 8.82 × 10-6 mM, which is the lowest among the reported polyoxometalate-based fluorescence sensors. As for the Cu2+-quenching system, it can function as an "off-on" sensor to detect cysteine in an aqueous system, affording a LOD of 1.75 × 10-4 mM. This work opens up an avenue to broaden the applications of polyoxometalate-based materials in the optical intelligence detection field.

Resolution of minor size differences in a family of heteroleptic coordination cages by trapped ion mobility ESI-MS

We report a complex system of heteroleptic coordination cages based on the combination of four bis-monodentate ligands whose backbones only slightly differ in shape and length. cis-[Pd2L2L'2] assemblies cleanly form after addition of PdII cations to a 1 : 1 mixture of two shape-complementary ligands, each. When three or even all four ligands are used in combination, the unambiguous discrimination of all individual species in the product mixture becomes difficult by conventional NMR spectroscopic and mass spectrometric methods. Due to steric constraints, the system is restricted to the formation of ten different coordination cages in total, two of which are isomeric. We show that high-resolution trapped ion mobility mass spectrometry (TIMS) allows the clear differentiation of all ten species. Observed size trends could be readily reproduced by the calculation of theoretical values for collisional cross sections (CCS) from geometry-optimized models.

Soluble Hetero-Polyoxovanadates and Their Solution Chemistry Analyzed by Electrospray Ionization Mass Spectrometry

Polyoxometalates (POMs) are an intriguing class of compounds due to their tremendous structural variety and the wide spectrum of resulting properties, which make them interesting for applications in fields such as catalysis, material science or nanotechnology. Their ability to form large supramolecular architectures by self-assembly offers an entry to complex, functional systems. After an introduction into the structure and synthesis of POMs of the early transition metals, recently discovered water-soluble antimonato polyoxovanadates (Sb-POVs) and the investigation of their chemical reactivity are discussed. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) is presented as an analytical technique suitable to investigate the structure of complex POM assemblies in solution and to probe the underlying reactivity and formation mechanisms. This Minireview highlights the first studies on the soluble Sb-POVs and how the knowledge of their reactivity obtained by ESI-MS has fostered the syntheses of numerous novel Sb-POV compounds.

An unprecedented nanocage-like and heterometallic [MoO4]-polyoxomolybdate hybrid

The solvothermal oxidation of [Mo₃O₂(O₂CCH₃)₆(H₂O)₃]·ZnCl₄ has been established as a general route toward [Mo⁴⁺₃O₄]-incorporated polyoxomolybdates (Mo^IV-POMs). Two unprecedented family members: the first Mo⁴⁺-Mo⁵⁺-Mo⁶⁺ nanocage cluster, Na[MoMoMoO₄₃(OH)Py₁₂]·11H₂O (1) and the first heterometallic hybrid, [MoMoZn(PO₄)₄(OH)₂O₃₁py₃]·2(C₅H₆N)·3(C₅H₅N)·2H₂O (2) have been prepared and characterized by X-ray crystallography, elemental and DFT theoretical analyses, XPS, mass spectroscopy, cyclic voltammetry, and IR spectroscopy.

Diversity of metal-organic macrocycles assembled from carbazole based ligands with different lengths

A series of carbazole based ligands with different lengths were assembled with nickel ions to construct metal-organic macrocycles. High-resolution mass spectrometry and ion mobility-mass spectrometry have been used to analyse the resulting M_nL_n assembly coexisting in solution. Combining with the structural analysis of their solid confirmation, it was revealed that the diversity of the metal-organic macrocycles was increased with the flexibility of the ligands.

Simultaneous endo and exo Complex Formation of Pyridine[4]arene Dimers with Neutral and Anionic Guests

The formation of complexes between hexafluorophosphate (PF₆^- ) and tetraisobutyloctahydroxypyridine[4]arene has been thoroughly studied in the gas phase (ESI-QTOF-MS, IM-MS, DFT calculations), in the solid state (X-ray crystallography), and in chloroform solution (¹ H, ¹⁹ F, and DOSY NMR spectroscopy). In all states of matter, simultaneous endo complexation of solvent molecules and exo complexation of a PF₆^- anion within a pyridine[4]arene dimer was observed. While similar ternary complexes are often observed in the solid state, this is a unique example of such behavior in the gas phase.

Overcoming the Crystallization Bottleneck: A Family of Gigantic Inorganic {Pdx }(L) (x=84, 72) Palladium Macrocycles Discovered using Solution Techniques

The {Pd₈₄}^Ac wheel, initially discovered serendipitously, is the only reported giant palladium macrocycle—a unique structure that spontaneously assembles from small building blocks. Analogues of this structure are elusive. A new modular route to {Pd₈₄}^Ac is described, allowing incorporation of other ligands, and a new screening approach to cluster discovery. Structural assignments were made of new species from solution experiments, overcoming the need for crystallographic analysis. As a result, two new palladium macrocycles were discovered: a structural analogue of the existing {Pd₈₄}^Ac wheel with glycolate ligands, {Pd₈₄}^Gly, and the next in a magic number series for this cluster family—a new {Pd₇₂}^Prop wheel decorated with propionate ligands. These findings confirm predictions of a magic number rule for the family of {Pd_x} macrocycles. Furthermore, structures with variable fractions of functional ligands were obtained. Together these discoveries establish palladium clusters as a new class of tunable nanostructures. In facilitating the discovery of species that would not have been discovered by orthodox crystallization approaches, this work also demonstrates the value of solution‐based screening and characterization in cluster chemistry, as a means to decouple cluster formation, discovery, and isolation.

Investigating the Transformations of Polyoxoanions Using Mass Spectrometry and Molecular Dynamics

The reactions of [γ-SiW10O36](8-) represent one of the most important synthetic gateways into a vast array of polyoxotungstate chemistry. Herein, we set about exploring the transformation of the lacunary polyoxoanion [β2-SiW11O39](8-) into [γ-SiW10O36](8-) using high-resolution electrospray mass spectrometry, density functional theory, and molecular dynamics. We show that the reaction proceeds through an unexpected {SiW9} precursor capable of undertaking a direct β → γ isomerization via a rotational transformation. The remarkably low-energy transition state of this transformation could be identified through theoretical calculations. Moreover, we explore the significant role of the countercations for the first time in such studies. This combination of experimental and the theoretical studies can now be used to understand the complex chemical transformations of oxoanions, leading to the design of reactivity by structural control.

Sizing and Discovery of Nanosized Polyoxometalate Clusters by Mass Spectrometry

Ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) is a powerful technique for structural characterization, e.g., sizing and conformation, particularly when combined with quantitative modeling and comparison to theoretical values. Traveling wave IM-MS (TW-IM-MS) has recently become commercially available to nonspecialist groups and has been exploited in the structural study of large biomolecules, however reliable calibrants for large anions have not been available. Polyoxometalate (POM) species-nanoscale inorganic anions-share many of the facets of large biomolecules, however, the full potential of IM-MS in their study has yet to be realized due to a lack of suitable calibration data or validated theoretical models. Herein we address these limitations by reporting DT-IM (drift tube) data for a set of POM clusters {M12} Keggin 1, {M18} Dawson 2, and two {M7} Anderson derivatives 3 and 4 which demonstrate their use as a TW-IM-MS calibrant set to facilitate characterization of very large (ca. 1-4 nm) anionic species. The data was also used to assess the validity of standard techniques to model the collision cross sections of large inorganic anions using the nanoscale family of compounds based upon the {Se2W29} unit including the trimer, {Se8W86O299} A, tetramer, {Se8W116O408} B, and hexamer {Se12W174O612} C, including their relative sizing in solution. Furthermore, using this data set, we demonstrated how IM-MS can be used to conveniently characterize and identify the synthesis of two new, i.e., previously unreported POM species, {P8W116}, unknown D, and {Te8W116}, unknown E, which are not amenable to analysis by other means with the approximate formulation of [H34W118X8M2O416](44-), where X = P and M = Co for D and X = Te and M = Mn for E. This work establishes a new type of inorganic calibrant for IM-MS allowing sizing, structural analysis, and discovery of molecular nanostructures directly from solution.

Catalysis of "outer-phase" oxygen atom exchange reactions by encapsulated "inner-phase" water in {V15Sb6}-type polyoxovanadates

A water molecule encapsulated inside water-soluble {V₁₅Sb₆} antimonato polyoxovanadate cages accelerates oxygen-exchange reactions in the cluster periphery.

Antimonato polyoxovanadate (POV) cluster compounds {M(en)₃}₃[V₁₅Sb₆O₄₂(H₂O)_x]·nH₂O (M = Fe^II, Co^II, Ni^II and x = 0 or 1) obtained under solvothermal conditions exhibit unusual high water solubility making these compounds promising synthons for generation of new POV structure types. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry provides evidence (i) for a water molecule encapsulated inside the cavity of a fraction of the spherical cluster shells, (ii) for a post-functionalization in water, namely a slow exchange of VO against Sb₂O, (iii) for the inner-phase reactivity of the encapsulated water that is capable of opening an oxo-bridge, and (iv) for a significant acceleration of the ¹⁶O/¹⁸O exchange reactions of oxygen atoms in the cluster periphery with surrounding H₂¹⁸O, when encapsulated water is present. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first example in polyoxovanadate chemistry for the transduction of inner-phase reactivity of an encapsulated guest molecule into changes in the outer-phase reactivity of the cluster. Magnetic susceptibility measurements reflect the individual contributions of the frustrated {V₁₅} spin polytope and the {M(en)₃}²⁺ complexes, with very weak coupling between these groups.

Exploiting the equilibrium dynamics in the self-assembly of inorganic macrocycles based upon polyoxothiometalate building blocks

Manipulation of the equilibrium dynamics allowed access to new thermodynamic minima and formation of two new inorganic macrocycles, {Mo₁₆} = {(Mo₂O₂S₂)₈(OH)₁₆(C₄O₄)₂}⁴⁻ and {Mo₁₂} = {(Mo₂O₂S₂)₆(OH)₁₂(CH₃COO)₂}²⁻.

Effect of adduct formation with molecular nitrogen on the measured collisional cross sections of transition metal-1,10-phenanthroline complexes in traveling wave ion-mobility spectrometry: N2 is not always an "inert" buffer gas

The number of separations and analyses of molecular species using traveling wave ion-mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (TWIMS-MS) is increasing, including those extending the technique to analytes containing metal atoms. A critical aspect of such applications of TWIMS-MS is the validity of the collisional cross sections (CCSs) measured and whether they can be accurately calibrated against other ion-mobility spectrometry (IMS) techniques. Many metal containing species have potential reactivity toward molecular nitrogen, which is present in high concentration in the typical Synapt-G2 TWIMS cell. Here, we analyze the effect of nitrogen on the drift time of a series of cationic 1,10-phenanthroline complexes of the late transition metals, [(phen)M](+), (M = Ni, Pd, Pt, Cu, Ag, Au, Zn, Cd, and Hg) in order to understand potential deviations from expected drift time behaviors. These metal complexes were chosen for their metal open-coordination site and lack of rotameric species. The target species were generated via electrospray ionization (ESI), analyzed using TWIMS in N2 drift gas, and the observed drift time trends compared. Theoretically derived CCSs for all species (via both the projection approximation and trajectory method) were also compared. The results show that, indeed, for metal containing species in this size regime, reaction with molecular nitrogen has a dramatic effect on measured drift times and must not be ignored when comparing and interpreting TWIMS arrival time distributions. Density-functional theory (DFT) calculations are employed to analyze the periodic differences due to the metal's interaction with nitrogen (and background water) in detail.

Characterization of Metallosupramolecular Polymers by Top-Down Multidimensional Mass Spectrometry Methods

Top-down multidimensional mass spectrometry, interfacing electrospray ionization (ESI) with ion mobility mass spectrometry (IM-MS), and energy resolved (gradient) tandem mass spectrometry (gMS(2) ) are employed to characterize the stoichiometries, architectures, and intrinsic stabilities of coordinatively bound supramolecular polymers containing terpyridine functionalized ligands. As a soft ionization method, ESI prevents or minimizes unwanted assembly destruction. The IM dimension affords separation of the supramolecular ions by charge and collision cross-section (a function of size and shape). The mobility separated ions are subsequently identified by their mass-to-charge-ratios and isotope patterns in the orthogonal MS dimension. Finally, the gMS(2) dimension reveals bond breaking proclivities and disintegration pathways of the assemblies. The described methodology does not require high sample purity due to the dispersive nature of the IM and MS steps. Its utility is demonstrated with the comprehensive analysis of bisterpyridine-based metallomacrocycle mixtures and a tristerpyridine based complex with 3-D nanosphere-like architecture.

Gas-Phase Fragmentation Pathways of Mixed Addenda Keggin Anions: PMo12-nW nO 40 3- (n = 0-12)

We report a collision-induced dissociation (CID) investigation of the mixed addenda polyoxometalate (POM) anions, PMo(12-n)W(n)O(40)(3-) (n = 0-12). The anions were generated in solution using a straightforward single-step synthesis approach and introduced into the gas phase by electrospray ionization (ESI). Distinct differences in fragmentation patterns were observed for the range of mixed addenda POMs examined in this study. CID of molybdenum-rich anions, PMo(12-n)W(n)O(40)(3-) (n = 0-2), generates an abundant doubly charged fragment containing seven metal atoms (M) and 22 oxygen atoms (M(7)O(22)(2-)) and its complementary singly charged PM(5)O(18)(-) ion. In comparison, the doubly charged Lindqvist anion, (M(6)O(19)(2-)) and its complementary singly charged PM(6)O(21)(-) ion are the dominant fragments of Keggin POMs containing more than two tungsten atoms, PMo(12-n)W(n)O(40)(3-) (n = 3-12). The observed transition in the dissociation pathways with an increase in the number of W atoms in the POM may be attributed to the higher barrier of tungsten-rich anions towards isomerization. We present evidence that the observed distribution of Mo and W atoms in the major M(6)O(19)(2-) and M(7)O(22)(2-) fragment ions is different from that predicted by a random distribution, indicating substantial segregation of the addenda metal atoms in the POMs. Charge reduction of the triply charged precursor anion resulting in formation of doubly charged anions is also observed. This is a dominant pathway for mixed POMs having a majority (8-11) of W atoms and a minor channel for other precursors indicating a close competition between fragmentation and charge loss pathways in CID of POM anions.

Photosensitive polyoxometalate-induced formation of thermotropic liquid crystal nanomaterial and its photovoltaic effect

The photosensitive POM [PW₁₁O₃₉RhCH₂CO₂H]⁵⁻ was first introduced into the liquid crystal nanomaterial and simulated by theoretical calculations. It exhibits the photovoltaic effect with the character of a p-type material.

Selenate as a novel ligand for keplerate chemistry. New {W72Mo60} keplerates with selenates inside the cavity

The synthesis and characterization of three novel keplerate-type compounds containing the {W₇₂Mo₆₀} mixed-metal core are reported.

Supramolecular reactivity in the gas phase: investigating the intrinsic properties of non-covalent complexes

The high vacuum inside a mass spectrometer offers unique conditions to broaden our view on the reactivity of supramolecules. Because dynamic exchange processes between complexes are efficiently suppressed, the intrinsic and intramolecular reactivity of the complexes of interest is observed. Besides this, the significantly higher strength of non-covalent interactions in the absence of competing solvent allows processes to occur that are unable to compete in solution. The present review highlights a series of examples illustrating different aspects of supramolecular gas-phase reactivity ranging from the dissociation and formation of covalent bonds in non-covalent complexes through the reactivity in the restricted inner phase of container molecules and step-by-step mechanistic studies of organocatalytic reaction cycles to cage contraction reactions, processes induced by electron capture, and finally dynamic molecular motion within non-covalent complexes as unravelled by hydrogen-deuterium exchange processes performed in the gas phase.

Two carboxyethyltin functionalized polyoxometalates for assembly on carbon nanotubes as efficient counter electrode materials in dye-sensitized solar cells

Two new POM-carboxyethyltin derivatives increased the electrocatalytic activity of single-walled carbon nanotubes toward triiodide reduction as counter electrodes in DSSCs.