Normal growth hormone secretion in growth hormone insufficient children retested after completion of linear growth

Identifying patient-related predictors of permanent growth hormone deficiency

Objective

Isolated childhood growth hormone deficiency (GHD) can persist into adulthood, and re-testing at the transition period is needed to determine whether continued growth hormone therapy is indicated. Here, our objective was to identify predictors of permanent GHD.

Design

Retrospective single-centre study of patients with childhood-onset GHD who were re-tested after adult height attainment.

Methods

Auxological, clinical, laboratory, and MRI data throughout follow-up were collected.

Results

We included 101 patients. At GH treatment initiation, age was 8.1 ± 0.4 years, height -2.25 ± 0.8, and BMI -0.27 ± 0.1 SDS. The 29 (28.7%) patients with persistent GHD had lower height SDS (-2.57 ± 0.1 vs. -2.11 ± 0.1, p<0.001) and mean GH peaks (8.4 ± 1.0 vs.13.2 ± 0.5 mIU/L, p<0.001) at GHD diagnosis; at adult height, they had lower IGF1 (232 ± 19.9 vs. 331 ± 9.1 ng/mL, p<0.001) and higher BMI SDS (-0.15 ± 0.27 vs. -0.73 ± 0.13, p<0.005). By multivariate analysis, the best predictive model included height and BMI SDS, both GH peaks, and MRI findings at diagnosis. Patients with height at diagnosis <-3 SDS had a 7.7 (95% IC 1.4-43.1, p=0.02) fold higher risk of persistent GHD after adjustment on BMI SDS. An abnormal pituitary region by MRI was the strongest single predictor (7.2 times, 95% CI 2.7-19.8) and after multivariate analysis adjustment for GH peaks and height SDS at diagnosis, the risk increased to 10.6 (1.8 - 61.3) times.

Conclusions

Height <-3 SDS at GHD diagnosis and pituitary MRI abnormalities should lead to a high index of suspicion for persistent GHD.

The landscape of retesting in childhood-onset idiopathic growth hormone deficiency and its reversibility: a systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

Children diagnosed with idiopathic isolated growth hormone deficiency (IGHD) are frequently observed to no longer be GH-deficient at a later stage of growth as a result of 'GHD reversal'. Reevaluation of GH status by stimulation test is currently incorporated into management guidelines at attainment of final height (FH). Over the past three decades, numerous studies have evaluated reversal rates using different methodologies including crucial parameters like GHD aetiology, GH cut-off and retesting time point, with heterogeneous results. We aimed to systematically analyse the reversibility of childhood-onset IGHD dependent on retesting GH cut-offs and retesting time points.

METHODS

PubMed, Cochrane Library, TRIP database and NHS Evidence were searched for publications investigating the reversibility of IGHD from database initiation to 30 June 2020 following PRISMA recommendations. Study cohorts were pooled according to retesting GH cut-off and time point. Reversal rates were calculated using random-effects models.

RESULTS

Of the 29 studies initially identified, 25 provided sufficient detail for IGHD analysis, resulting in 2030 IGHD patient data. Reversal rates decreased significantly as the retesting GH cut-off increased (P = 0.0013). Pooled (95% CI) reversal rates were 80% (59-92%, n = 227), 73% (62-81%, n = 516) and 55% (41-68%, n = 1287) for cohorts using retesting GH cut-offs of 3-4 ng/mL, 5-6 ng/mL and 7.7-10 ng/mL, respectively. Individuals retested at FH (n = 674) showed a pooled reversal rate of 74% (64-82%) compared to 48% (25-71%) when retested before FH (n = 653).

CONCLUSION

Provided evidence supports reevaluation of current IGHD management guidelines. The high reversal rates should instigate consideration of early retesting.

Influence of biochemical diagnosis of growth hormone deficiency on replacement therapy response and retesting results at adult height

Isolated growth hormone deficiency (IGHD) is the most frequent endocrinological disorder in children with short stature, however the diagnosis is still controversial due to the scarcity of reliable diagnostic criteria and pre-treatment predictive factors of long term-response. To evaluate recombinant growth hormone (rGH) long-term response and retesting results in three different groups of children divided in accordance with the biochemical criteria of initial diagnosis. Height gain (∆HT) at adult height (AH) and retesting results were evaluated in 57 rGH treated children (M = 34, 59.6%) divided into 3 groups according to initial diagnosis: Group A (n = 25) with max GH peak at stimulation test < 8 µg/L, Group B (n = 19) between 8 and 10 µg/L and Group C (n = 13) with mean overnight GH < 3 µg/L (neurosecretory dysfunction, NSD). Retesting was carried out in all patients after at least one month off therapy upon reaching the AH. 40/57 (70.2%) patients were pre-pubertal at diagnosis and showed ∆HT of 1.37 ± 1.00 SDS, with no significant differences between groups (P = 0.08). Nonetheless, 46% patients in Group B showed ∆HT < 1SDS (vs 13% and 12% in Group A and C, respectively) and 25% children failed to reach mid-parental height (vs 6% and 0% in Group A and C, respectively). At AH attainment, IGHD was reconfirmed in 28% (7/25) and 10% (2/19) in Group A and B, respectively. A reduction of diagnostic cut-off at GH stimulation tests could better discriminate between "good" and "poor responders" and predict the persistence of IGHD through transition. Group C response and the predictive value of baseline IGF-I SDS bring back to light NSD: should we consider an underlying hypothalamic derangement when the clinical presentation is strongly consistent with IGHD but pharmacological stimulation test is normal?

Diagnosis and Treatment of Growth Hormone Deficiency: A Position Statement from Korean Endocrine Society and Korean Society of Pediatric Endocrinology

Growth hormone (GH) deficiency is caused by congenital or acquired causes and occurs in childhood or adulthood. GH replacement therapy brings benefits to body composition, exercise capacity, skeletal health, cardiovascular outcomes, and quality of life. Before initiating GH replacement, GH deficiency should be confirmed through proper stimulation tests, and in cases with proven genetic causes or structural lesions, repeated GH stimulation testing is not necessary. The dosing regimen of GH replacement therapy should be individualized, with the goal of minimizing side effects and maximizing clinical improvements. The Korean Endocrine Society and the Korean Society of Pediatric Endocrinology have developed a position statement on the diagnosis and treatment of GH deficiency. This position statement is based on a systematic review of evidence and expert opinions.

Growth Hormone (GH) Therapy During the Transition Period: Should We Think About Early Retesting in Patients with Idiopathic and Isolated GH Deficiency?

To investigate growth hormone (GH) secretion at the transition age, retesting of all subjects who have undergone GH replacement therapy is recommended when linear growth and pubertal development are complete to distinguish between transitional and persistent GH deficiency (GHD). Early retesting of children with idiopathic and isolated GHD (i.e., before the achievement of final height and/or the adult pubertal stage) can avoid possible over-treatment. Here, we report data from our population with idiopathic and isolated GHD to encourage changes in the management and timing of retesting. We recruited 31 patients (19 males) with idiopathic GHD who received recombinant GH (rGH) for at least 2 years. All of the patients were retested at the transition age at least 3 months after rGH discontinuation. Permanent GHD was defined as a GH peak of <19 ng/mL after administration of growth hormone–releasing hormone (GHRH) + arginine as a provocative test. Permanent GHD was confirmed in only five of 31 patients (16.13%). None of these patients presented low serum insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-1 levels (<−2 standard deviation score (SDS)). Only one male patient with an IGF-1 serum level lower than −2 SDS showed a normal GH stimulation response, with a GH peak of 44.99 ng/mL. Few patients with idiopathic and isolated GHD demonstrated persistence of the deficit when retested at the transition age, suggesting that the timing of retesting should be anticipated to avoid overtreatment.

Clinical and laboratory parameters predicting a requirement for the reevaluation of growth hormone status during growth hormone treatment: Retesting early in the course of GH treatment

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to define the predictive criteria, in the form of specific clinical, hormonal and radiological parameters, for children with growth hormone deficiency (GHD) who may benefit from the reevaluation of GH status early in the course of growth hormone (GH) treatment.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Two hundred sixty-five children with growth hormone deficiency were retested by GH stimulation at the end of the first year of GH treatment. The initial clinical and laboratory characteristics of those with a normal (GH≥10ng/ml) response and those with a subnormal (GH<10ng/ml) response were compared to predict a normal GH status during reassessment.

RESULTS

Sixty-nine patients (40.6%) out of the 170 patients with isolated growth hormone deficiency (IGHD) had a peak GH of ≥10ng/ml during the retest. None of the patients with multiple pituitary hormone deficiency (MPHD) had a peak GH of ≥10ng/ml. Puberty and sex steroid priming in peripubertal cases increased the probability of a normal GH response. Only one patient with IGHD who had an ectopic posterior pituitary without stalk interruption on MRI analysis showed a normal GH response during the retest. Patients with a peak GH between 5 and 10ng/ml, an age at diagnosis of ≥9years or a height gain below 0.61 SDS during the first year of treatment had an increased probability of having a normal GH response at the retest.

CONCLUSION

Early reassessment of GH status during GH treatment is unnecessary in patients who have MPHD with at least 3 hormone deficiencies. Retesting at the end of the first year of therapy is recommended for patients with IGHD who have a height gain of <0.61 SDS in the first year of treatment, especially those with a normal or 'hypoplastic' pituitary on imaging. Priming can increase the likelihood of a normal response in patients in the pubertal age group who do not show overt signs of pubertal development.

Early retesting by GHRH + arginine test shows normal GH response in most children with idiopathic GH deficiency

PURPOSE

Most children with idiopathic isolated GH deficiency (IGHD) normalize GH response to stimulation tests when retested at the completion of growth. The objective of this study was to test the effectiveness of early retesting in challenging the diagnosis of idiopathic IGHD and critically review the diagnostic workup leading to this diagnosis in children with short stature.

METHODS

We cross-sectionally retested 38 children with idiopathic IGHD and still on GH treatment. The initial diagnosis of idiopathic IGHD was based on subnormal GH responses to two stimulation tests and normal brain imaging or minor/nonspecific findings at magnetic resonance. The GH response normalization at retesting was considered as the main outcome measure. Clinical features of children who were falsely classified as idiopathic IGHD based on first GH testing were retrospectively analyzed.

RESULTS

GH secretion was normal in 36/38 children (95%). Two children showed slightly reduced peak GH responses and normal IGF-I levels. Fourteen children underwent GH retesting before puberty, 24 children during puberty.

CONCLUSION

The diagnostic process should be improved to minimize the rate of false positive at GH testing and, in case of unsatisfactory response to GH treatment, the diagnosis of isolated idiopathic GHD should be challenged with early retesting.

Reappraisal of serum insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-1) measurement in the detection of isolated and combined growth hormone deficiency (GHD) during the transition period

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the accuracy of serum IGF-1 in the detection of isolated (IGHD) or combined growth hormone deficiency (CGHD) at the transition phase.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Forty nine patients with GHD during childhood [16 with IGHD (10 men) and 33 with CGHD (24 men); age 23.2 ± 3.5 yrs.] were submitted to an insulin tolerance test (ITT) with a GH peak < 5 µg/L used for the diagnosis of GHD at the transition phase. Pituitary function and IGF-1 measurements were evaluated in the basal sample of the ITT. Transition patients were reclassified as GH-sufficient (SGH; n = 12), IGHD (n = 7), or CGHD (n = 30).

RESULTS

Five (31%) patients with IGHD and 32 (97%) with CGHD at childhood persisted with GHD at retesting. One patient with IGHD was reclassified as CGHD, whereas 3 patients with CGHD were reclassified as IGHD. Mean GH peak was 0.2 ± 0.3 µg/L in the CGHD, 1.3 ± 1.5 µg/L in the IGHD, and 18.1 ± 13.1 µg/L in the SGH group. Serum IGF-1 level was significantly higher in the SGH (272 ± 107 ng/mL) compared to IGHD (100.2 ± 110) and CGHD (48.7 ± 32.8) (p < 0.01). All patients reclassified as CGHD, 86% reclassified as IGHD, and 8.3% reclassified as SGH had low IGF-1 level, resulting in 97.3% sensitivity and 91.6% specificity in the detection of GHD at the transition period; the cutoff value of 110 ng/mL showed 94.5% sensitivity and 100% specificity. Mean IGF-1 values did not differ in IGHD or CGHD associated with one, two, three, or four additional pituitary deficiencies.

CONCLUSION

IGF-1 measurement is accurate to replace ITT as initial diagnostic test for IGHD and CGHD detection at the transition phase.

Diagnosis and treatment of growth hormone deficiency in adults

The availability of synthetic recombinant human growth hormone (GH) in potentially unlimited quantities since the 1980s has improved understanding of the many nonstatural effects of GH on metabolism, body composition, physical and psychological function, as well as the consequences of GH deficiency in adult life. Adult GH deficiency is now recognized as a distinct if nonspecific syndrome with considerable adverse health consequences. GH replacement therapy in lower doses than those used in children can reverse many of these abnormalities and restore functional capacities toward or even to normal; if dosed appropriately, GH therapy has few adverse effects. Although some doubts remain about possible long-term risks of childhood GH therapy, most registries of adult GH replacement therapy, albeit limited in study size and duration, have not shown an increased incidence of cancers or of cardiovascular morbidity or mortality.

United States multicenter study of factors predicting the persistence of GH deficiency during the transition period between childhood and adulthood

Background

Many patients with childhood-onset growth hormone (GH) deficiency do not fulfill diagnostic criteria for GH deficiency (GHD) after attainment of adult height and may not require long-term GH treatment. Patients with history of idiopathic GHD (IGHD) pose the greatest management dilemma, as data regarding factors predictive of persistent GHD in this group are lacking.

Objectives

The objective of this study was to assess potential predictors of persistent GHD in a US patient cohort during transition from childhood to adulthood, particularly in patients with history of IGHD.

Methods

We studied 73 US patients with history of childhood-onset GHD screened at 21 US pediatric endocrine centers for a randomized clinical trial of GH replacement after attainment of adult height. The cohort comprised 42 boys/men and 31 girls/women aged14–22 years, who had received ≥1 year of GH treatment and had completed linear growth. The main outcome measures were sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values (PPV, NPV) of clinical and hormonal factors for persistent GHD (defined a priori in this study as peak GH < 5 μg/L).

Results

For the cohort as a whole, the best predictors of persistent GHD (100% PPV) were history of organic hypothalamic-pituitary disorder or ≥2 additional pituitary hormone deficiencies (PHD). Best predictors of persistent GHD in patients with childhood history of IGHD were standard deviation scores (SDS) for serum insulin-like growth factor binding protein-3 (IGFBP-3) below -2.0, and for insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) below -5.3 (measured ≥6 weeks after completion of GH treatment; PPV 100% for both), and age <4 years at original diagnosis (PPV 89%). IGF-I above -1.6 SDS had 100% NPV.

Conclusions

US patients with an organic cause of childhood-onset GHD or ≥2 additional PHDs may not require GH stimulation testing to reconfirm GHD after completion of childhood treatment. In contrast, patients with idiopathic childhood-onset GHD almost invariably require retesting, as GHD persists in only a minority (those who were very young at initial diagnosis and those who have subnormal IGFBP-3 or extremely low IGF-I after completion of childhood treatment). Subnormal posttreatment IGF-I (<-2.0 SDS) lacked predictive power for persistent GHD, whereas IGF-I > -1.6 SDS was 100% predictive of GH sufficiency.

Effect of body mass index on the growth hormone response to clonidine stimulation testing in children with short stature

OBJECTIVES

An inverse relationship has been shown between body mass index (BMI) and the peak growth hormone (GH) response to stimulation in adults and in children with short stature. This relation is observed even within a normal range of BMI. The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of BMI on the GH response to clonidine in a large number of children with short stature.

DESIGN

We conducted a retrospective study on the GH response to clonidine in a single centre.

METHODS

We studied 202 children with short stature (135 M and 67 F) who underwent clonidine testing from 2007 to 2009.

RESULTS

One hundred and twenty-eight patients had a GH peak >10 μg/l. In univariate regression analysis, the peak GH after clonidine was negatively correlated with BMI-standard deviation score (BMI-SDS) and positively correlated with height velocity-SDS and IGF-I-SDS. Only the relationship between peak GH and BMI-SDS remained significant in children with a BMI-SDS from -2 to +2. In the multivariate stepwise regression analysis, BMI-SDS and IGF-I-SDS were the only significant variables in the entire cohort, explaining 19·5% of the variance in peak GH. When only subjects with BMI-SDS between -2·0 and +2·0 were included in the analysis (n = 173), BMI-SDS alone explained 21·4% of the variability in peak GH. The number of patients who failed the clonidine test increased with increasing BMI-SDS.

CONCLUSIONS

BMI affects the GH response to clonidine in children with short stature and should be considered when interpreting the results to the stimulation test.

The glucagon test in the diagnosis of growth hormone deficiency in children with short stature younger than 6 years

CONTEXT

Few studies have addressed the diagnostic role of the glucagon test in children with suspected GH deficiency (GHD).

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to investigate the diagnostic value of the glucagon test as an alternative test to insulin tolerance test (ITT) and arginine in GHD children younger than 6 yr.

DESIGN AND SETTING

This study was conducted in two pediatric endocrinology centers.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Forty-eight children (median age 4.2 yr, median height -3.0 sd score) with GHD confirmed by a peak GH to ITT and arginine less than 10 microg/liter (median 4.7 and 3.4 microg/liter, respectively) underwent a glucagon stimulation test. Magnetic resonance imaging showed normal hypothalamic-pituitary anatomy in 24 children, isolated anterior pituitary hypoplasia in seven, and structural hypothalamic-pituitary abnormalities in 17.

RESULTS

Median GH peak response to glucagon (13.5 microg/liter) was significantly higher than that observed after ITT and arginine (P < 0.0001). GH peak after glucagon was less than 10 microg/liter in 20 subjects (group 1) and greater than 10 microg/liter in 28 subjects (group 2) without significant clinical or biochemical differences between the two groups. Median GH peak after glucagon was similar between patients with multiple pituitary hormone deficiency and those with isolated GHD and between subjects with and without structural hypothalamic-pituitary abnormalities. The magnitude of the GH peak after glucagon was negatively correlated to age at diagnosis (rho = -0.636, P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that glucagon has an effective GH-releasing activity and can be used to evaluate somatotroph function in young children with short stature. Normative data for this test in young children need to be established before its use in clinical practice.

Pharmacological and physiological growth hormone stimulation tests to predict successful GH therapy in children

Although the current use of growth hormone (GH) stimulation tests (GHSTs) is still subject to debate, the tests are widely used to diagnose GH deficiency. This literature review evaluates primarily the sensitivity, specificity and reliability of GHSTs and secondarily their convenience. Single pharmacological tests typically address only a single pathway in the complex physiological regulation of GH secretion and are therefore characterized by lower sensitivity, specificity and reliability than combined pharmacological tests or physiological tests. In spite of the high levels of sensitivity, specificity and reliability, physiological tests require considerably more effort to perform, from the physician as well as from the child. Therefore, a need for an alternative, convenient, physiological GHST still remains. Oral ingestion of dietary protein is convenient in practice and may induce more physiological stimulation of GH secretion, hence may be a promising valuable addition to the existing GHSTs in GH deficiency.

Diagnosis of adult GH deficiency

The current guidelines for the diagnosis of adult GHD are mainly based on the statements from the GH Research Society Consensus from Port Stevens in 1997. It is stated that diagnosis of adult GHD must be shown biochemically by provocative tests within the appropriate clinical context. The insulin tolerance test (ITT) was indicated as that of choice and severe GHD defined by a GH peak lower than 3 microg/L. The need to rely on provocative tests is based on evidence that that the measurement of IGF-I as well as of IGFBP-3 levels does not distinguish between normal and GHD subjects. Hypoglycemia may be contraindicated; thus, alternative provocative tests were considered, provided they are used with appropriate cut-off limits. Among classical provocative tests, arginine and glucagon alone were indicated as alternative tests, although less discriminatory than ITT. Testing with the combined administration of GHRH plus arginine was recommended as an alternative to ITT, mostly taking into account its marked specificity. Based on data in the literature in the last decade, the GRS Consensus Statements should be appropriately amended. Regarding the appropriate clinical context for the suspicion of adult GHD, one should evaluate patients with hypothalamic or pituitary disease or a history of cranial irradiation, as well as those with childhood-onset GHD are at obvious risk as adults for severe GHD. Brain injuries (trauma, subarachnoid hemorrage, tumours of the central nervous system) very often cause acquired hypopituitarism, including severe GHD. Given the epidemiology of brain injuries, the important role of the endocrinologist in providing major clinical benefit to brain injured patients who are still undiagnosed should be underscored. From the biochemical point of view, although normal IGF-I levels do not rule out severe GHD, very low IGF-I levels in patients highly suspected for GHD (i.e. patients with childhood-onset, severe GHD or with multiple hypopituitarism acquired in adulthood) can be considered as definitive evidence for severe GHD; thus, these patients would skip provocative tests. Patients suspected for adult GHD with normal IGF-I levels must be investigated by provocative tests. ITT remains a test of reference but it should be recognized that other tests are as reliable as ITT. Glucagon as classical test and, particularly, new maximal tests such as GHRH in combination with arginine or GH secretagogues (GHS) (i.e. GHRP-6) have well defined cut-off limits, are reproducible, able to distinguish between normal and GHD subjects. Overweight and obesity have confounding effect on the interpretation of the GH response to provocative tests. In adults cut-off levels of GH response below which severe GHD is demonstrated must be appropriate to lean, overweight and obese subjects to avoid false positive diagnosis in obese adults and false negative diagnosis in lean GHD patients. Finally, normative values of GH response to provocative tests may depend on age, particularly in the transitional age; the normative cut-off levels of GH response to ITT in this phase of life are now available.

A boy with "transient" growth hormone deficiency in prepubertal stage despite normal growth hormone secretion in childhood and after puberty

Transient growth hormone deficiency (GHD) is occasionally found in prepubertal individuals, and this phenomenon has been variously interpreted. Sex steroids enhance GH secretion; however, the cut-off values of provocative GH tests are not modified according to the physiological changes. Physiological changes in sex steroid levels are thought to cause the image of transient GHD. In addition, the reproducibility of provocative GH tests makes the interpretation complicated. We experienced a case of a boy with short stature who had undergone provocative GH tests at three different times: childhood (5 and 7 years old), before puberty (12 years old), and in adolescence (15 years old). Although the responses of GH in his childhood and adolescence were within the normal range, his prepubertal GH response was extremely low, as if he had "complete" GHD (peak GH: insulin test, 0.60 ng/ml; clonidine test, 0.78 ng/ml). No morphological changes were observed in the pituitary gland or hypothalamus on MRI. The level of insulin-like growth factor 1 was in the normal range for his age at this time. Here, we report the clinical course and endocrinological data of this case, and suggest that transient GHD is caused not only by the physiological effects of sex steroids but also by certain mechanisms that actively reduce GH secretion.

Subnormal serum insulin-like growth factor-I levels in young adults with childhood-onset nonacquired growth hormone (GH) deficiency who recover normal gh secretion may indicate less severe but persistent pituitary failure

CONTEXT

The unexpected observation of a normal GH peak in 22% of young adults with childhood-onset GH deficiency (GHD) and ectopic neurohypophysis has raised questions about the criteria defining GHD in young adults and whether patients with subsequent increases in GH secretion nonetheless have a subtle form of GHD.

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to determine the characteristics of patients with childhood-onset nonacquired GHD who recover normal peak GH secretion when adult height has been achieved.

DESIGN AND SETTING

We conducted a university hospital-based observational follow-up study.

PARTICIPANTS

Sixty-two patients with ectopic neurohypophysis (n = 24), isolated hypoplastic anterior pituitary (n = 14), or normal hypothalamic pituitary area (n = 24) on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) at the time of GHD diagnosis underwent reevaluation of the GH-IGF-I axis at a mean age of 16.8 +/- 1.6 yr.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Outcome measures included clinical and MRI findings and serum IGF-I and peak GH levels.

RESULTS

On retesting, peak GH exceeded 10 microg/liter in 31 patients (50%): six (20%) patients with ectopic neurohypophysis, 10 (32%) patients with initially isolated hypoplastic anterior pituitary, and 15 (48%) patients with normal MRI findings. Among these patients, serum IGF-I levels were significantly lower in patients with ectopic neurohypophysis than in those without structural abnormalities of the hypothalamic pituitary axis (n = 25), but patients without structural abnormalities also had significantly lower serum IGF-I levels than control subjects, after controlling for age, sex, and body mass index (mean serum IGF-I levels of 374 +/- 83 vs. 446 +/- 108 microg/liter; beta-coefficient = -72; P = 0.003).

CONCLUSIONS

The severity of the disease seems to have decreased over time in these patients, who may nonetheless present persistent pituitary failure. The natural history and clinical implications of these findings remain to be clarified. The possibility of a deterioration in the secretion of GH and other pituitary hormones later in life in a subset of these patients warrants the careful long-term follow-up of this population.

Growth hormone and the transition from puberty into adulthood

With modern growth hormone (GH) replacement algorithms, children with a diagnosis of growth hormone deficiency achieve at the end of pediatric GH treatment an adult height that is on the average in the normal range. Recent experience with GH replacement in young adults with childhood-onset growth hormone deficiency, however, has shown that these patients present with variable degrees of somatic immaturity. As childhood GH treatment is discontinued when final height is attained, attention moves to the phase of somatic development that follows the end of longitudinal growth, called ''transition'', which had been excluded previously from consideration for either pediatric or adult GH replacement. This article reviews the changes taking place during this phase of development and their relevance for the attainment of adult body maturation. The critical role of GH in this process is described.

Adult height in patients with permanent growth hormone deficiency with and without multiple pituitary hormone deficiencies

CONTEXT

It has been reported that patients with multiple pituitary hormone deficiencies (MPHDs) achieve a greater final height, compared with patients with isolated GH deficiency (IGHD). However, the outcome of patients with permanent GH deficiency (GHD) has not yet been reported.

OBJECTIVES

The objectives of the study were to evaluate and compare adult height data and the effect of spontaneous or induced puberty after long-term treatment with GH in young adults with either permanent IGHD or MPHD.

DESIGN AND SETTING

This was a retrospective multicenter study conducted in university research hospitals and a tertiary referral endocrine unit.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Thirty-nine patients with IGHD (26 males, 13 females) and 49 with MPHD (31 males, 18 females), diagnosed at a median age of 7.7 and 6.9 yr, respectively, were reevaluated for GH secretion after adult height achievement (median age 17.6 and 19.8 yr). The diagnosis of permanent GHD was based on peak GH levels less than 3 microg/liter after an insulin tolerance test or peak GH levels less than 5 microg/liter after two different tests. Fifteen subjects had idiopathic GHD and seventy-three had magnetic resonance imaging evidence of congenital hypothalamic-pituitary abnormalities. Height sd score (SDS) was analyzed at diagnosis, the onset of puberty (either spontaneous or induced), and the time of GH withdrawal.

RESULTS

The subjects with IGHD entered puberty at a median age of 12.6 yr (females) and 13.4 yr (males). Puberty was induced at a median age of 13.5 and 14.0 yr, respectively, in males and females with MPHD. Median height SDS at the beginning of puberty was similar in the IGHD and MPHD subjects. Total pubertal height gain was similar between patients with IGHD or MPHD. Median adult height was also not significantly different between IGHD and MPHD patients (males, 168.5 vs. 170.3 cm; females, 160.0 vs. 157.3 cm). The adult height SDS of the IGHD subjects was positively correlated with height at the time of diagnosis and with total pubertal height gain. Conversely, the adult height SDS of the MPHD subjects was positively correlated with both the duration of GH treatment and height SDS at the time of GHD diagnosis.

CONCLUSIONS

Adult height in patients with permanent IGHD and spontaneous puberty is similar to adult height in patients with MPHD and induced puberty.

Evaluation and treatment of adult growth hormone deficiency: an Endocrine Society Clinical Practice Guideline

OBJECTIVE

The objective is to provide guidelines for the evaluation and treatment of adults with GH deficiency (GHD).

PARTICIPANTS

The chair of the Task Force was selected by the Clinical Guidelines Subcommittee of The Endocrine Society (TES). The chair selected five other endocrinologists and a medical writer, who were approved by the Council. One closed meeting of the group was held. There was no corporate funding, and members of the group received no remuneration.

EVIDENCE

Only fully published, peer-reviewed literature was reviewed. The Grades of Evidence used are outlined in the Appendix.

CONSENSUS PROCESS

Consensus was achieved through one group meeting and e-mailing of drafts that were written by the group with grammatical/style help from the medical writer. Drafts were reviewed successively by the Clinical Guidelines Subcommittee, the Clinical Affairs Committee, and TES Council, and a version was placed on the TES web site for comments. At each level, the writing group incorporated needed changes.

CONCLUSIONS

GHD can persist from childhood or be newly acquired. Confirmation through stimulation testing is usually required unless there is a proven genetic/structural lesion persistent from childhood. GH therapy offers benefits in body composition, exercise capacity, skeletal integrity, and quality of life measures and is most likely to benefit those patients who have more severe GHD. The risks of GH treatment are low. GH dosing regimens should be individualized. The final decision to treat adults with GHD requires thoughtful clinical judgment with a careful evaluation of the benefits and risks specific to the individual.

Growth hormone secretion in adult patients with thalassaemia

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Growth retardation and short stature are frequent clinical features of patients with beta-thalassaemia major. Dysfunction of the GH-IGF-1 axis has been described in many thalassaemic children and adolescents with short stature and reduced growth velocity. Several studies have demonstrated that recombinant GH treatment improves growth velocity in these patients, although response to the treatment is variable and not predictable. A reassessment of the GH-IGF-1 axis must be performed in young adults with childhood-onset GH deficiency (GHD), after attainment of final height, to select those who are candidates for replacement therapy as adults. To our knowledge there are no data available on retesting the GH-IGF-1 axis in adult thalassaemic patients with childhood-onset GHD. The aim of our study was to investigate GH secretion in adult thalassaemic patients with childhood-onset GHD.

DESIGN

We reassessed GH secretion in a group of adult thalassaemic patients in whom partial GHD had been diagnosed during childhood.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We performed an arginine plus GH-releasing hormone (GHRH) stimulation test in 16 thalassaemic patients (10 males, six females) with a mean age of 24.8 +/- 3.6 years. The cut-off level for GH response was set at 9 microg/l, according to the literature. Ferritin, IGF-1, liver enzymes and lipid levels were also determined.

RESULTS

We found persisting GHD in three patients, one patient had borderline values (GH peak = 10.4 microg/l), whereas the others had a normal response. These results are in accordance with the data on GH retesting in adult patients with idiopathic partial childhood-onset GHD.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that GH status should be retested in adult thalassaemic patients with childhood-onset GHD. If the diagnosis of adult GHD is established, GH treatment may be considered as it could contribute to improve heart function and bone mineral density, which are frequently impaired in adult thalassaemic patients.

Do all patients with childhood-onset growth hormone deficiency (GHD) and ectopic neurohypophysis have persistent GHD in adulthood?

Cerebral magnetic resonance imaging findings are of great value for the diagnosis of nonacquired GH deficiency (GHD), and ectopic posterior pituitary hyperintense signal (EPPHS) is a sensitive and specific indicator of hypopituitarism. It has been suggested that patients with childhood-onset GHD and EPPHS do not require additional investigation of GH secretion and should not be retested when adult height is achieved. This recommendation has never been validated through a systematic study. This study aimed to characterize the anterior pituitary function status of patients with EPPHS treated for GHD during childhood after completion of GH therapy when adult height had been achieved. Patients (n = 18; 15 males and three females) with childhood-onset GHD associated with ectopic neurohypophysis were treated with hGH (0.20 +/- 0.05 mg/kg.wk) for 9.9 +/- 4.0 yr (from 6.8 +/- 4.7 to 17.7 +/- 1.3 yr of age) with a mean height gain of 2.6 +/- 1.4 sd score. GH secretion was reevaluated by arginine insulin (n = 15) or propanolol glucagon (n = 3) test after 0.5 +/- 0.6 yr of GH withdrawal. At reevaluation, peak GH was more than 10 mug/liter in four patients (22%; range, 11.7-19.5 microg/liter; group I), between 5 and 10 microg/liter in three patients (17%; range, 7.3-9 mug/liter; group II), and less than 5 microg/liter in 11 patients (61%; range, 0-4.7 microg/liter; group III). A positive correlation was found between serum IGF-I and peak GH levels after attainment of adult height (P = 0.007). Only one of the seven patients who showed increased GH secretion ability in adulthood (groups I and II) demonstrated other hormonal deficiencies (gonadotropin and adrenal insufficiencies). Among the 11 patients with persistent severe GHD (group III), 10 (91%) of the 11 subjects were shown to have multiple pituitary hormone deficits after attainment of adult height. The structure of the hypothalamo-pituitary axis differs among groups [i.e. patients who showed increased GH secretion ability in adulthood (groups I and II) vs. those who remained severely GHD (group III)]. The location of the EPPHS was significantly different among groups (P < 0.003). The EPPHS was found at the median eminence in all but one of group III patients and along the pituitary stalk (proximal stalk) in all but one of group I and II patients. The pituitary stalk was visible and described as normal (n = 1) or thin (n = 6) in all group I and II patients, whereas the pituitary stalk was not visible even after enhancement in seven of the 11 group III patients (P < 0.02). The prevalence of anterior pituitary hypoplasia and the mean height gain sd score were similar in each group. In conclusion, only 61% of patients with childhood-onset GHD and EPPHS remained severely GHD, and thus suitable for GH therapy, in adulthood. Although the pathogenesis of anterior pituitary dysfunction remains unclear in patients with ectopic neurohypophysis, isolated GHD, location of EPPHS along the stalk, and visibility of the pituitary stalk on magnetic resonance imaging findings clearly represent important markers to predict a less severe form of the disease.

The impact of idiopathic childhood-onset growth hormone deficiency (GHD) on bone mass in subjects without adult GHD

OBJECTIVE

Despite seemingly adequate growth hormone (GH) treatment during childhood, children with GH deficiency (GHD) have reduced bone mineral density (BMD) at final height. The aim was to evaluate BMD and bone mineral content (BMC) in adults treated for idiopathic childhood-onset (CO) GHD, 18 years after stopping GH treatment.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Twenty-six (11 females) patients with idiopathic CO GHD participated. All patients but two had been treated for isolated GHD in childhood. The childhood diagnosis was established by an insulin tolerance test (ITT) and reassessed in adulthood by an ITT (N = 21) or arginine test (n = 5), revealing that 10 patients had GHD according to adult criteria. Accordingly, the patient group was divided into (1) patients who did not have persistent GHD in adulthood and (2) patients who did have persistent adult GHD. Twenty-six healthy subjects acted as age-, gender- and body mass index (BMI)-matched controls.

RESULTS

The patients who did not have persistent GHD had significantly lower IGF-I values and whole-body, femoral neck and lumbar spine BMD compared to controls [0.994 +/- 0.10 vs. 1.114 +/- 0.11 g/cm2 (P = 0.003), 0.842 +/- 0.12 vs. 0.962 +/- 0.11 g/cm2 (P = 0.006) and 1.026 +/- 0.14 vs. 1.127 +/- 0.13 g/cm2 (P = 0.004), respectively]. Femoral neck BMD was significantly reduced in the patients who had persistent GHD, compared to controls (0.842 +/- 0.09 vs. 0.938 +/- 0.11, P = 0.04). Significant correlations were observed between all bone variables and IGF-I in all subjects, whereas no correlations were observed between bone variables and GH peak levels in the 26 patients.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, we found that (1) patients with idiopathic CO GHD, who at retest in adulthood did not have GHD according to adult criteria, had reduced serum IGF-I and BMD/BMC compared to controls. (2) This observation was also made in the patients who did have persistent GHD in adulthood. The findings may reflect the fact that the present diagnostic criteria for adult GHD (i.e. response to the ITT) do not reflect the clinical consequences of disordered GH-IGF axis in CO GHD young adults who were treated with GH in childhood. Alternatively, despite seemingly adequate GH treatment in childhood an optimal peak bone mass in adolescence may never have been reached in either of the groups. (3) IGF-I levels correlated with clinical signs of the adult GHD syndrome. We believe that further studies on the indications and diagnostic procedures for GH treatment after cessation of linear growth are necessary.

Reevaluation of growth hormone deficiency during and after growth hormone (GH) treatment: diagnostic value of GH tests and IGF-I and IGFBP-3 measurements

Retesting of patients with growth hormone (GH) deficiency (GHD), especially those with idiopathic GHD, has yielded normalization of the results in several studies. The aim of this study was to reevaluate patients diagnosed as GHD at completion or reconfirm the diagnosis before completion of GH treatment by retesting with provocative tests, and to evaluate the value of IGF-I and IGFBP-3 levels in the diagnosis of GHD. Fifty (33 M, 17 F) patients with GHD (peak GH level <0.46 pmol/l (10 ng/ml]) in two pharmacological tests were retested and IGF-I and IGFBP-3 levels measured. The age of the patients at retest was 15.2+/-5.0 yr. Thirteen of 50 patients (26%) normalized their GH secretion. According to the initial diagnosis, 69% of those with partial GHD (peak GH level 0.32-0.46 pmol/l [7-10 ng/ml]), 43% with isolated GHD, 33% idiopathic and 11% of those with complete GHD (peak GH level <0.32 pmol/l [7 ng/ml]) normalized their GH level at retesting. None of the patients with multiple hormone deficiency and none with small pituitary on MRI normalized GH levels at retest. The sensitivities of IGF-I and of IGFBP-3 were 70% and 67%, respectively, and the specificities were 100%, when peak GH cutoff is taken as 0.46 pmol/l (10 ng/ml) for the diagnosis of GHD. The sensitivities of IGF-I and IGFBP-3 increased to 76.5% and 73.5% when the cutoff level for GHD is taken as 0.32 pmol/l (7 ng/ml). Those patients who normalized their GH levels at retest showed a satisfactory height velocity when GH therapy was discontinued. In conclusion, reevaluation of GH status may also be undertaken while patients are still on treatment as well as at completion of treatment, especially in patients with idiopathic, partial and isolated GHD, by retesting and by IGF-I and IGFBP-3 measurements. Lowering the cutoff level of GH peak at pharmacological tests to 0.32 pmol/l (7 ng/ml) will lower the number of false positive results in the diagnosis of GHD.

Indications and strategies for continuing GH treatment during transition from late adolescence to early adulthood in patients with GH deficiency: the impact on bone mass

GH plays an important role in longitudinal bone growth and maturation during childhood and adolescence. However, GH has important metabolic functions other than bone growth, which become more apparent during young adulthood, when growth has been completed. Indeed, GH deficiency (GHD) in adult life is a recognized clinical syndrome which includes symptoms such as increased central adiposity, decreased lean body mass, reduced bone mineral density (BMD), increased atherogenic risk, cerebrovascular and cardiac morbidity and mortality, and reduced quality of life. As approximately one quarter of the children with GHD should continue GH administration in adulthood, it is important to reconfirm GHD at the end of growth in order to select patients with severe GHD who need to resume GH therapy with an appropriate age-related dosage. Some evidence indicates that most peak bone mass (PBM) is achieved by the end of adolescence but small increases in BMD continue during the period of transition from late adolescence to young adulthood. Some young adults with GHD show a persistent increase of lumbar BMD after the completion of growth even after discontinuation of treatment suggesting a spontaneous progression towards lumbar PBM or a continuing effect of the treatment. The data indicates that adolescents with GHD who do not reach lumbar PBM at the time of discontinuation of GH treatment can achieve a BMD lower than their genetic potential if they are not treated during the transition to young adulthood.

Is growth hormone stimulation testing in children still appropriate?

The diagnosis of growth hormone deficiency (GHD) historically has relied on measurement of growth hormone (GH) concentrations following stimulation, usually with a non-physiologic provocative agent. Despite the use of more specific GH assays, the peak concentration of GH below which a child is considered GH deficient has risen. We examine the pitfalls associated with GH stimulation tests, specifically, the lack of reliability and accuracy of these tests, and their inability to predict who will benefit from GH therapy. We recommend that GH stimulation tests no longer routinely be used for the diagnosis of GHD in children.

Transition from paediatric to adult endocrinology: hypopituitarism

For patients at the transition stage between childhood and adulthood, cooperation between paediatric and adult endocrinologists is essential for optimum care. Evaluations of patients in transition consist of retrospective assessments of what happened in childhood combined with prospective planning for treatment and follow up into adult life. Successful transfer of patients in transition from paediatric to adult care should follow a general sequence tailored to local circumstances. First, all patients with GH deficiency and their families should be informed by their paediatric endocrinologist about the long term consequences of GH deficiency in adulthood and the potential need for life-time GH replacement therapy. Second, retesting will be needed for evaluating hypothalamic pituitary function, re-evaluation of the need for replacement therapy for other pituitary hormone deficits, measurement of fasting lipid concentration and assessment of skeletal integrity. Third, the patient and physicians should consider the option of attending an out-patient clinic having both a paediatric and an adult endocrinologist. Regardless, the wishes of the patient should be respected as much as possible. It is essential that those patients who had childhood-onset GH deficiency and who were treated with GH be followed throughout adult life.

High risk of adrenal insufficiency in adults previously treated for idiopathic childhood onset growth hormone deficiency

The aim was to reevaluate a group of adults treated for idiopathic childhood onset GH deficiency (GHD) after 18 yr without GH treatment. Twenty-six (11 females) patients participated. All but two had isolated GHD. Childhood diagnosis was established by insulin tolerance test (ITT). The patients were retested with an ITT to evaluate adult GH status. In five patients, an arginine and a synacthen test were performed instead of an ITT. Eleven of 25 patients had a subnormal cortisol response to ITT or synacthen. Ten patients had a GH peak less than 3.0 microg/liter (0.5. +/- 0.5 microg/liter), whereas 16 patients displayed a normal GH response (12.3 +/- 10.6 microg/liter) after ITT. IGF-I values were decreased in the patients with a pathological retest as well as in patients with a normal GH response compared with controls (P < 0.005). In 26 idiopathic childhood onset GHD patients, 44% of the patients had developed adrenal insufficiency; 38.5% had persistent GHD in adulthood, using the same test in both childhood and adulthood. Patients having a normal GH test had decreased IGF-I levels, compared with controls, indicating impaired function of a seemingly normal GH axis. It is imperative that pituitary axes other than the GH axis are tested at regular intervals, even in the absence of GHD in adulthood.

Re-assessment of growth hormone secretion in young adult patients with childhood-onset growth hormone deficiency

OBJECTIVE

Patients with childhood-onset GH deficiency (coGHD) need retesting in late adolescence or young adulthood to verify whether they need to continue GH treatment. For this purpose the Growth Hormone Research Society (GRS) recommends the insulin tolerance test (ITT), or as an alternative the arginine + growth hormone releasing hormone test (ARG + GHRH test) as a diagnostic tool in adolescents and adults. However, there are no standardized cut-off levels based on normal GH secretion for determining GHD vs. GH sufficiency in young adults for the ITT, the ARG + GHRH test or the pyridostigmine + GHRH (PD + GHRH) test, a further new GH stimulation test.

PATIENTS AND MEASUREMENTS

We studied 43 patients (28 with organic coGHD, 15 with idiopathic coGHD; 30 males, 13 females; aged 20.4 years, range 16.2-25.4; body mass index 23.5, range 16.3-35.8) using the ARG [0.5 g/kg intravenously (i.v.)] + GHRH (1 micro g/kg i.v.) test, the PD (120 mg orally) + GHRH (1 micro g/kg i.v.) test and the ITT (0.1 IU/kg i.v.) and compared these data with the results of 40 healthy age- and weight-matched volunteers.

RESULTS

The GH response in patients was significantly lower than in healthy controls: ARG + GHRH test, 0.8 micro g/l (interquartile range 0.3-2.6) vs. 51.8 micro g/l (32.6-71.2) in controls (P < 0.0001); PD + GHRH test, 0.9 micro g/l (0.3-1.9) vs. 40.4 micro g/l (27.1-54.4) in controls (P < 0.0001); ITT, 0.1 micro g/l (0.0-0.8) vs. 20.3 micro g/l (14.7-31.7) in controls (P < 0.0001). In the ARG + GHRH test we found a diagnostic sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 97.5% for a cut-off range from 15.1 to 20.3 micro g/l, in the PD + GHRH test a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 97% (cut-off range 9.1-13.1 micro g/l) and in the ITT a sensitivity and specificity of 100% each within a cut-off range from 2.7 to 8.8 micro g/l.

CONCLUSION

There were no marked differences in sensitivity and specificity in young adults among ARG + GHRH test, PD + GHRH test and the ITT in assessing GH secretion. Because of the lack of side-effects, the ARG + GHRH test is the recommended method for re-evaluation of coGHD in young adults when pituitary GHD is suspected. Furthermore, in adult patient groups where organic pituitary coGHD is common, the ITT may be completely replaced by the ARG + GHRH test. Because of the predominance of hypothalamic GHD in childhood, the ITT is commonly performed for the re-evaluation of patients with childhood-onset GHD because of its mechanism of GH stimulation. The present results confirm the high discriminatory capability of the ITT in young adults.

Results of early reevaluation of growth hormone secretion in short children with apparent growth hormone deficiency

OBJECTIVE

To test the hypothesis that normalization of the growth hormone (GH) response to stimulation in patients with GH deficiency (GHD) and normal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the hypothalamic-pituitary area might occur earlier than at attainment of final height.

STUDY DESIGN

Prepubertal children with short stature (21 boys and 12 girls; age, 5.2-10 years), in whom a diagnosis of GHD was based on a GH response <10 microg/L after 2 pharmacologic tests (clonidine, arginine, or insulin hypoglycemia), and normal MRI of the hypothalamic-pituitary area were studied. After 1 to 6 months, all children underwent reevaluation of GH secretion by means of one of the provocative tests previously used. During that time, none of the children received GH therapy or entered puberty.

RESULTS

A GH response > or =10 microg/L after retesting was found in 28 patients, and a GH response <10 microg/L was found in 5. In 9 patients, the peak GH response at diagnosis was <7 microg/L to both tests used. In 8, the GH response at retesting was > or =10 microg/L and was 9.0 microg/L in the remaining child.

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest that patients with pathologic GH responses to provocative tests but normal MRI should be reevaluated and followed up before a diagnosis of GHD is firmly established.

Diagnosis and management of growth hormone deficiency in adults

In adults, GHD is a clinical syndrome that occurs in patients with pituitary or hypothalamic disease. It may be asymptomatic or present with relatively nonspecific constitutional symptoms. Most patients have abnormal body composition, consisting of increased fat mass and decreased lean mass. Life expectancy is significantly decreased in hypopituitary patients with GHD, with cardiovascular disease a common cause of death. Treatment with growth hormone reverses abnormalities in body composition and may reduce cardiovascular risk factors; however, the long-term treatment outcomes regarding mortality, the incidence of cardiovascular disease, bone fractures, tumor development, and recurrence are not known. Longer prospective clinical studies are needed. The major manufacturers of growth hormone have initiated postmarketing surveillance databases to monitor the safety of growth hormone treatment.

Optimizing gh therapy in adults and children

Until the advent of modern neuroradiological imaging techniques in 1989, a diagnosis of GH deficiency in adults carried little significance other than as a marker of hypothalamo-pituitary disease. The relatively recent recognition of a characteristic clinical syndrome associated with failure of spontaneous GH secretion and the potential reversal of many of its features with recombinant human GH has prompted a closer examination of the physiological role of GH after linear growth is complete. The safe clinical practice of GH replacement demands a method of judging overall GH status, but there is no biological marker in adults that is the equivalent of linear growth in a child by which to judge the efficacy of GH replacement. Assessment of optimal GH replacement is made difficult by the apparent diverse actions of GH in health, concern about the avoidance of iatrogenic acromegaly, and the growing realization that an individual's risk of developing certain cancers may, at least in part, be influenced by cumulative exposure to the chief mediator of GH action, IGF-I. As in all areas of clinical practice, strategies and protocols vary between centers, but most physicians experienced in the management of pituitary disease agree that GH is most appropriately begun at low doses, building up slowly to the final maintenance dose. This, in turn, is best determined by a combination of clinical response and measurement of serum IGF-I, avoiding supraphysiological levels of this GH-dependent peptide. Numerous studies have helped define the optimum management of GH replacement during childhood. The recent requirement to measure and monitor GH status in adult life has called into question the appropriateness of simplistic weight- and surface area-based dosing regimens for the management of GH deficiency in childhood, with reliance on linear growth as the sole marker of GH action. It is clear that the monitoring of parameters other than linear growth to help refine GH therapy should now be incorporated into childhood GH treatment protocols. Further research will be required to define the optimal management of the transition from pediatric to adult GH replacement; this transition will only be possible once the benefits of GH in mature adults are defined and accepted by pediatric and adult endocrinologists alike.

Evaluation of growth hormone secretion after completion of therapy

BACKGROUND

Growth hormone (GH) reserve in young adults previously diagnosed as having GH insufficiency, who were treated with human (h)GH replacement in childhood needs confirmation in adulthood.

METHODS

Nine patients (seven males, two females; two empty cella, one hypoplasia of the hypophysis and six with idiopathic GH deficiency) diagnosed as having GH insufficiency by the insulin tolerance test (ITT) and dopamine stimulation test in childhood (mean age 12.8+/-2.6 years) were retested at completion of linear growth (mean age 21.0+/-3.0 years), 4.6+/-1.6 years after discontinuation of hGH therapy.

RESULTS

At the initial diagnosis, seven had complete and two had partial GH deficiency. At diagnosis, the mean peak GH response to ITT and dopamine was 4.8+/-4.08 and 3.4+/-2.9 mU/L, respectively. At retesting, the mean GH response to ITT and dopamine stimulation was 3.5+/-2.5 and 3.3+/-3.1 mU/L, respectively (P=0.91 and 0.96, respectively). During hGH therapy, mean height velocity increased from 3.5+/-1.9 cm/year at diagnosis to 9.9+/-3.64 cm/year during the first year (P=0.002). One of nine children diagnosed as having GH insufficiency who was treated with hGH replacement had normal growth hormone secretion at completion of linear growth.

CONCLUSIONS

All GH-insufficient children should be retested after completion of their hGH treatment and linear growth to identify those who are truly GH insufficient and who may benefit from GH therapy in adulthood.

Retesting young adults with childhood-onset growth hormone (GH) deficiency with GH-releasing-hormone-plus-arginine test

Within an appropriate clinical context, severe GH deficiency (GHD) in adults has to be defined biochemically by provocative testing of GH secretion. Patients with childhood-onset GHD need retesting in late adolescence or young adulthood to verify whether they have to continue recombinant human GH treatment. GHRH + arginine (GHRH+ARG) is the most reliable alternative to the insulin-induced hypoglycemia test (ITT) as a provocative test for the diagnosis of GHD in adulthood, provided that appropriate cut-off limits are assumed (normal limits, 16.5 microg/L as 3rd and 9.0 microg/L as 1st centile). We studied the GH response to a single GHRH (1 microg/kg iv) + ARG (0.5 g/kg iv) test in 62 young patients who had undergone GH replacement in childhood, based on the following diagnosis: 1) organic hypopituitarism with GHD (oGHD) In = 18: 15 male (M), 3 female (F); age, 26.8+/-2.2 yr; GH peak < 10 microg/L after two classical tests]; 2) idiopathic isolated GHD (iGHD) [n = 23 (15 M, 8 F); age, 23.0+/-1.5 yr; GH peak < 10 microg/L after two classical tests]; and 3) GH neurosecretory dysfunction (GHNSD) [n = 21 (10 M, 11 F); age, 25.1+/-1.6 yr; GH peak > 10 microg/L after classical test but mGHc < 3 microg/L]. The GH responses to GHRH+ARG in these groups were also compared with that recorded in a group of age-matched normal subjects (NS) [n = 48 (20 M, 28 F); age, 27.7+/-0.8 yr]. Insulin-like growth factor I levels in oGHD subjects (61.5+/-13.7 microg/L) were lower (P < 0.001) than those in iGHD subjects (117.2+/-13.1 microg/L); the latter were lower than those in GHNSD subjects (210.2+/-12.9 microg/L), which, in turn, were similar to those in NS (220.9+/-7.1 microg/L). The mean GH peak after GHRH+ARG in oGHD (2.8+/-0.8 microg/L) was lower (P < 0.001) than that in iGHD (18.6+/-4.7 microg/L), which, in turn, was clearly lower (P < 0.001) than that in GHNSD (31.3+/-1.6 microg/L). The GH response in GHNSD was lower than that in NS (65.9+/-5.5 microg/L), but this difference did not attain statistical significance. With respect to the 3rd centile limit of GH response in young adults (i.e. 16.5 microg/L), retesting confirmed GHD in all oGHD, in 65.2% of iGHD, and in none of the GHNSD subjects. With respect to the 1st centile limit of GH response (i.e. 9.0 microg/L), retesting demonstrated severe GHD in 94% oGHD and in 52.1% of iGHD. All oGHD and iGHD with GH peak after GHRH+ARG lower than 9 microg/L had also GH peak lower than 3 microg/L after ITT. In the patients in whom GHD was confirmed by retesting, the mean GH peak after GHRH+ARG was higher than that after ITT (3.4+/-0.5 vs. 1.9+/-0.4). In conclusion, given appropriate cut-off limits, GHRH+ARG is as reliable as ITT for retesting patients who had undergone GH treatment in childhood. Among these patients, severe GHD in adulthood is generally confirmed in oGHD, is frequent in iGHD, but never occurs in GHNSD.

Quantitative growth hormone secretion and final adult height

OBJECTIVE

The relationship of quantitative GH secretion to height, growth velocity and puberty is complex and has been the subject of extensive study in children. This study was designed to relate quantitative GH secretion to final height.

SUBJECTS

Twenty tall (> 183 cm, 90th centile for adult height) and 20 short (< 166 cm, 10th centile) postpubertal men who had recently completed linear growth (age range 18-27 years).

MEASUREMENTS

GH dynamics were studied on four occasions; insulin (0.15 units/kg, iv)-induced hypoglycaemia and GHRH (100 mg, iv) with and without the anticholinesterase, pyridostigmine (120 mg orally). Spontaneous nocturnal GH secretion was assessed by 20 minute sampling from 2100 h until 0600 h. GH was measured by IRMA. Analysis was by comparison of peak GH response and area under the curve (AUC). GH profiles were further analysed using the 'pulsar' programme.

RESULTS

The mean height in the tall group was 187.7 cm (range 183-197) compared to 163.5 cm (range 160-166) for the short group. No difference existed between groups in the GH response to hypoglycaemia or GHRH with and without pyridostigmine. Area under the curve, pulse number, length and amplitude for spontaneous nocturnal GH secretion showed no significant difference between the tall and short subjects. Serum IGF-I (mean 230.5 +/- 15. 4 vs. 230.6 +/- 18.9 microg/l) did not differ between the groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Quantitative GH secretion does not appear to be an important determinant of final height in healthy individuals.

Diagnosis of severe growth hormone (GH) deficiency in young adults who received GH replacement therapy during childhood

Between 20% and 87% of young adults who had completed growth hormone (GH) therapy in childhood for a putative diagnosis of GH deficiency (GHD) had normal GH responses to provocative tests when they were retested. Patients with isolated idiopathic GHD were more likely to exhibit normal GH responses at retest in young adult life than were patients with multiple pituitary hormone deficits. When determining which patients should receive GH therapy in adult life, those who have isolated GHD should undergo two tests of GH status, while those with multiple anterior pituitary hormone deficits require only one test. Most information is available for the insulin tolerance test, the arginine stimulation test and the glucagon stimulation test, but more recent methods, such as GH-releasing hormone in combination with pyridostigmine, are showing promise in the investigation of GHD. In young adults with childhood-onset GHD, the serum concentration of insulin-like growth factor I is a useful marker of GH status, and can be used in conjunction with a GH provocative test. The choice of GH provocative test should ultimately depend on the experience and policy developed at the centre performing the assessment. Whichever tests are chosen, each should be validated in subjects known to have hypothalamic-pituitary disease as well as in normal individuals.

Conditions spanning paediatric and adult endocrine practice--the adult perspective

Close liaison between paediatric and adult endocrinologists is essential for optimum care in a variety of clinical conditions. The increasingly recognized importance of growth hormone deficiency (GHD) in the adult is a further indication for maintaining long-term follow-up of patients with isolated GHD, which remains demonstrable when linear growth is complete, in addition to those patients presenting in childhood with evidence of structural pituitary disease and anterior pituitary failure. Additional areas in which liaison is desirable include congenital adrenal hyperplasia, precocious puberty, gonadal dysgenesis and other disorders of primary and secondary sexual development, thyroid dysfunction, diabetes mellitus, inherited neoplasia syndromes and those conditions, for example Cushing's syndrome, which present in childhood but are more common in adult clinical endocrine practice. In this brief review, the diagnostic spectrum of the paediatric/adult interface is described and the rationale for an integrated approach to treatment and follow-up is outlined.