Should We Re-Examine the Status of Lymphocyte Alloimmunization Therapy for Recurrent Spontaneous Abortion?

Allogeneic lymphocytes immunotherapy in female infertility: Lessons learned and the road ahead

The endometrium is an essential tissue in the normal immunologic dialogue between the mother and the conceptus, which is necessary for the proper establishment and maintenance of a successful pregnancy. It's become evident that the maternal immune system plays a key role in the normal pregnancy's initiation, maintenance, and termination. In this perspective, the immune system contributes to regulating all stages of pregnancy, thus immunological dysregulation is thought to be one of the major etiologies of implantation failures. Many researchers believe that immune therapies are useful tactics for improving the live births rate in certain situations. Lymphocyte immunotherapy (LIT) is an active form of immunotherapy that, when used on the relevant subgroups of patients, has been shown in multiple trials to dramatically enhance maternal immunological balance and pregnancy outcome. The primary goal of LIT is to regulate the immune system in order to create a favorable tolerogenic immune milieu and tolerance for embryo implantation. However, there are a plethora of influential factors influencing its therapeutic benefits that merit to be addressed. The objective of our study is to discuss the mechanisms and challenges of allogeneic LIT.

Association of CD200 expression in paternal lymphocytes with female Th1/Th2 balance and pregnancy establishment at immunotherapy of recurrent spontaneous abortion

PROBLEM

We hypothesized that expression of transmembrane glycoprotein CD200 on paternal lymphocytes used for pre-gestational lymphocyte immunotherapy (LIT) of recurrent spontaneous abortion (RSA) can suppress the pro-inflammatory Th1-type immunity required for successful implantation. To reveal the association between CD200 expression, female immune background after LIT, and pregnancy establishment, we have performed this work.

METHOD OF STUDY

Pre-gestational alloimmunizations were given to 37 women using paternal peripheral blood leukocytes, combined with additional alloimmunizations in case of pregnancy. Lymphocyte phenotypes were determined by flow cytometry. Cytokines produced by mitogen-stimulated female peripheral blood cells were estimated by FlowCytomix™ technology.

RESULTS

We have shown that 78.4% (29/37) of women became pregnant within 12 menstrual cycles after pre-gestational LIT. Pregnancy establishment depends on the intensity of CD200 expression, which is significantly higher on the CD200⁺ lymphocytes administered to women who later did not achieve pregnancy (P < .05). The expression of CD200 negatively correlates with the ratios of Th1/Th2 cytokines produced by female peripheral blood cells (P < .05) and positively correlates with the frequency of female circulating regulatory T cells after LIT (P < .05). The ROC analysis showed that the intensity of CD200 expression and the Th1/Th2 ratios are the significant predictors of pregnancy establishment after pre-gestational LIT (P < .05 and P < .01, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Elevated CD200 expression on allogeneic lymphocytes most likely suppresses the pro-inflammatory Th1-type immunity needed for successful embryo implantation. Therefore, a personalized approach of LIT should be applied to avoid negative effects of such immunomodulation on pregnancy establishment.

Regulatory mechanisms of endometrial decidualization and pregnancy-related diseases

Endometrial decidualization is one of the earliest changes by which the uterus adapts to pregnancy. During this period, the endometrium undergoes complex changes in its biochemistry, physiology, and function at various levels, providing a suitable microenvironment for embryo implantation and development. Favorable decidualization lays an essential foundation for subsequent gestation, without which pregnancy failure or pregnancy complications may occur. The interaction between pregnancy-related hormones and cytokines produced by embryonic and uterine cells is known to be essential for decidualization, in which some transcription factors also play pivotal roles. Increasing evidence has revealed the importance of metabolism in regulating decidualization. Here, we summarize and discuss these crucial elements in decidualization and the relationship between decidualization and pregnancy complications. A better comprehension of these issues should help to improve the prediction of pregnancy outcomes and the use of appropriate intervention.

A unified (but in fact not fully testable) model of preeclampsia triggering

In this summary of my presentation in the last Reunion workshop I discuss a few assertions on preeclampsia, then turn on a (not fully testable) model where an embryonic defect in expression of embryo/ placental regulatory proteins results in complement activation, itself responsible for a down regulation of the T regs activity, resulting in a very early lack of complete down regulation of the preimplantation decidual inflammation, causing in the post implantation stage a low grade but chronic inflammatory state.

[Anti-TNFα therapy and its implication in gynecology and obstetrics]

Anti-TNFα treatments have modified the medical care, the course and the quality of life of the patients with autoimmune rheumatic, cutaneous or bowel inflammatory diseases. On the other hand, these treatments may have potential severe side effects during pregnancy (congenital malformations, fetal infections). Actually, many pregnancies have been reported during anti-TNFα exposures, with good maternal and neonatal outcomes. The introduction or the discontinuation of these treatments will always have to be discussed with the specialist of the chronic disease and, ideally, during a preconceptional counselling. In gynecology, anti-TNFα drugs may offer a new safe and effective approach to treating patients with recurrent miscarriages or unexplained or failed in vitro fertilization cycles. On the other hand, these treatments significantly increase the risk for serious infections or viral reactivations and may promote gynaecological malignancies. An adapted gynaecological survey is necessary.

Fetal rejection: infertility and immunity

Defective reaction toward fetal alloantigens could result in both recurrent spontaneous abortions (RSAs) and recurrent early pregnancy failures (REPFs), the latter existing in couples with unexplained infertility and multiple failures of implantation after in vitro fertilization embryo transfer. Immunological mechanisms leading to RSA and REPF seem to be different, although both syndromes probably have a genetic background that has not been identified so far. Despite the fact that antiphospholipid syndrome is a well-established cause of repeated pregnancy loss, the role of different autoantibodies existing in RSA and REPF patients needs to be elucidated. Immunotherapy is believed to correct the detrimental immune reactions; however, its real effectiveness and safety for the treatment of distinct forms of pregnancy loss need to be reconsidered.

Human Leukocyte Antigen May Predict Outcome of Primary Recurrent Spontaneous Abortion Treated with Paternal Lymphocyte Alloimmunization Therapy

PROBLEM

Recurrent spontaneous abortion (RSA) is defined by at least three consecutive abortions in otherwise healthy couples. Paternal lymphocyte alloimmunization therapy (PLAT) is an effective therapy for RSA in some cases, but there are no predictive markers about the effectiveness of PLAT.

METHOD OF STUDY

Forty-two consecutive cases with primary RSA treated by PLAT and 23 controls were the subjects. Polymorphisms of human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-E, HLA-G, HLA-A, HLA-B, HLA-C and HLA-DRB1 were investigated by sequenced based typing. Promoter polymorphism and a 14 bp ins/del polymorphism in exon 8 were also investigated for HLA-G.

RESULTS

Thirty-eight RSA wives became pregnant within 1 year after PLAT. Among them, 27 obtained babies (succeeded PLAT cases), while 11 again aborted with no detectable chromosomal abnormalities in the aborted fetuses (aborted PLAT cases). The frequencies of HLA-G*010401, A*2402, B*5201, and DRB1*1502 were significantly increased in the aborted cases than those in the succeeded cases or controls. Of note, HLA-G*010401 was found in all aborted cases whereas it was found in 51.9% of succeeded cases (odds ratio = 21.4, P = 0.006, P(c) = 0.03), and the presence of HLA-G*010401 could predict the abortion after PLAT with sensitivity and specificity of 100% and 48.1%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Human leukocyte antigen testing may be useful for predicting effectiveness of PLAT in RSA.

The Th1/Th2 paradigm: still important in pregnancy?

The enunciation of the T helper 1/T helper 2 (Th1/Th2) paradigm in pregnancy has represented a major step forward in our understanding of physiological and pathologic materno-foetal relationship. However, recent developments in studies of the implantation process and in the emergence of the uterine vascular bed and its control by natural killer cells and cytokines suggest that one must go beyond this hitherto useful scheme. In this review, we replace the emergence of the paradigm in its historical context and then emphasises what it does explain and what it no longer account for. A final reappraisal of the paradigm is suggested.

Immune cells in uteroplacental tissues throughout pregnancy: a brief review

In a brief introduction, this review states why the presence of immune cells at the interface poses problems for an immunologist (Medawar paradigm). Different types of placentation are then discussed, and the various interactions with leukocytes, the extreme being with the equids where a certain degree of 'attack' is often seen. The limits of animal models when dealing with the human situation are emphasized. It is then stated why the various phases of pregnancy are different, and an analysis made of the cellular movements at the implantation, peri-implantation, immediate post-implantation and resorption windows in rodents. Details of the cellular components involved are given, as are hints for the human situation. The Th1/Th2 paradigm is described, with clinical examples, and its limits. Thus, the newly appraised dual role of natural killer (NK) cells is discussed, with examples in rodents and in humans (pre-eclampsia, implantation failure, abortion systems). Clinical data on the IL-12/IL-18/NK tripod and implantation failure in humans are detailed.

Reduced uterine indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase versus increased Th1/Th2 cytokine ratios as a basis for occult and clinical pregnancy failure in mice and humans

PROBLEM

Indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) expression in fetal trophoblast and decidual antigen-presenting cells has been proposed to inactivate maternal T cells and thereby prevent rejection of the "fetal allograft" in early pregnancy. Psychic stress has been proposed to cause miscarriages as well as infertility, at the same time in pregnancy when blockade of IDO causes loss, but the suggested mechanism of stress-triggered loss has been an increased ratio of pro-rejection Th1-type cytokines to anti-rejection Th2/3 cytokines. Could stress act by reducing IDO expression?

METHODS

Using DBA/2-mated A/J mice where stress causes early pregnancy failure, we examined the role of stress in reducing IDO versus increasing Th1/Th2 ratio in deciduas. IDO loss was also examined in human decidua associated with pregnancy failure.

RESULTS

A post-implantation sonic stress increased the pregnancy failure rate, increased the Th1/Th2 ratio, but did not reduce IDO. IDO was reduced, and Th1/Th2 ratios increased in A/J mice pre-immunized against paternal DBA/2 antigens, and concomitant stress increased these effects. The rate of pregnancy failure was not further increased consistent with recent discoveries of factors that limit the impact of Th1 cytokines at the feto-maternal interface. In deciduas from spontaneous miscarriage patients, IDO(+) cell frequencies were low in only 30% of patients. CD3(+) T-cell numbers and percentage terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT)-mediated dUTP-digoxigenin nick end-labelling (TUNEL)(+) apoptotic T cells were increased, but the level of IDO did not correlate with likelihood of apoptosis.

CONCLUSIONS

Loss of an allogeneic embryo in early pregnancy is more likely to be due to a high Th1/Th2 ratio than loss of putative protection by IDO.

T cells in normal pregnancy and recurrent pregnancy loss

This review focuses on the possible role of T cells in successful pregnancy and in unexplained recurrent abortion. The functions exhibited by Th1 and Th2 cells have suggested, perhaps in a simplistic way, that Th1-type cytokines, which promote allograft rejection, may compromise pregnancy, whereas the Th2-type cytokines, by inhibiting Th1 responses, promote allograft tolerance and therefore may improve fetal survival. However, Th1 cytokines are not always detrimental for pregnancy development. Th1 cytokines, depending on their time of expression, stage of gestation and relative concentrations, could have a positive role in successful pregnancy. Other cytokines (LIF, M-CSF) produced by T cells seem to be important for the maintenance of pregnancy. Hormones present in the microenvironment of the decidual T cells could be responsible, at least in part, for the cytokine profile of the T cells. Indeed, progesterone is a potent inducer of Th2-type cytokines (e.g. IL-4 and IL-5), LIF and M-CSF production by T cells, whereas relaxin induces T cells to produce IFNgamma. Of course, the success of pregnancy depends on many mechanisms induced by different type of cells. Th2 cells could be one of these.

Adverse effects of intradermal allogeneic lymphocyte immunotherapy: acute reactions and role of autoimmunity

BACKGROUND

Immunotherapy with allogeneic lymphocytes was introduced as a therapeutic option for selected infertile couples in different centres worldwide 20 years ago. It has been suggested for other indications as well, e.g. for pregnant women at risk of a child with Rhesus-D haemolytic disease, or as a vaccine which might reduce the receptiveness for HIV-1 infection. Here we report on our experience on adverse side-effects of intradermal lymphocyte immunotherapy (LIT) for infertile couples using partner's lymphocytes.

METHODS

Prospective 4 week follow-up of all couples from 2000 to 2003 for acute reactions (feedback 2687/3246 [corrected] 83%). All couples treated between 1996 and 2002 received questionnaires after 2-3 years (feedback 1914/3041, 63%).

RESULTS

Local reactions predominantly consisted of redness and itching for approximately 2 weeks. Systemic reactions could be attributed to LIT in 6-8%. Blisters at the injection sites were characteristic of LIT but not dependent on the HLA class I mismatch status between cell donor and host. The incidence of autoimmune disease was 0.1%. Four patients developed thromboembolism in pregnancy which was not ascribed to antiphospholipid syndrome.

CONCLUSIONS

Acute side-effects are comparable to those reported after intradermal vaccination for infectious diseases. Specific risks for anaphylaxis, autoimmune or graft versus host disease were not detected.

The Placental Immunomodulatory Cytokine Regeneration and Tolerance Factor is also Expressed by Both Human Cycling and Early Pregnant Endometrium

PROBLEM

Regeneration and tolerance factor (RTF) has been recently suggested to contribute to the control of fetal-ablating immunity at the maternal-fetal interface through the induction of T helper 2 (Th2)-dominated response. The protein consists of a membrane-associated domain and an extracellular portion which is proteolitically cleaved to yield a soluble peptide. In humans, it has been shown to be expressed by invading cytotrophoblasts and decidual lymphoid cells, to be increased on peripheral blood B lymphocytes during a normal gestation and on circulating natural killer cells during unsuccessful pregnancies. However, the expression of RTF in other cell types and, specifically, in non-hematopoietic maternal cells of the human uterus has not been characterized in detail. Thus, we have specifically studied the expression and modulation of the cytokine in human endometrium obtained in different phases of the cycle and in early pregnancy.

METHODS

The 20 kDa extracellular domain of RTF has been localized by immunohistochemical method and Western blot analysis. Levels of RTF messenger RNA (mRNA) in basal and stimulated conditions have been evaluated by semiquantitative reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

The extracellular domain of RTF could be detected in both the glandular epithelium and stroma with diffuse distribution in both cycling endometrium and first trimester decidua. Both cycling and pregnant endometrium expressed the gene for RTF but mRNA levels resulted significantly increased in secretory phase-endometrial stromal cells when compared to proliferative phase samples. Inflammatory cytokines, interleukin-1beta and tumour necrosis factor alpha were able to directly increase endometrial RTF mRNA expression.

CONCLUSION

These results indicate that RTF is constitutively expressed at endometrial and decidual level and its up-regulation during the secretory phase of the cycle may be relevant in mediating some immune-related aspects of uterine physiology.

Shall We properly Re-examine the Status of Allogeneic Lymphocyte Therapy for Recurrent early Pregnancy Failure?

PROBLEM

How to evaluate immunological therapy advocated for recurrent spontaneous abortion and implantation failure. I was invited to comment on the opinion article of Chaouat (AJRI December 2003).

METHODS

A critical examination of key beliefs and application of the principles of evidence and logic utilizing current data.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Although rationale has no bearing on efficacy of proposed treatments and is not sufficient justification for routine practice, insufficient attention to data concerning patient selection, insufficient attention to treatment methodology, and lack of full disclosure in some clinical trials needs to be corrected. A more systematic collection of follow-up data is needed.