Quantitative telomerase expression in glioblastomas shows regional variation and down-regulation with therapy but no correlation with patient outcome

Telomerase subunits expression variation between biopsy samples and cell lines derived from malignant glioma

Although scientific advances have recognised the prognostic power of telomerase activity in different cancers, as yet there has been no investigation regarding the expression variation of telomerase subunits in glioma tissues and cell lines. In this study, a recurrent anaplastic ependymoma and seven glioblastoma biopsy samples, four cell lines and four controls including two normal brain tissues were analysed for telomerase subunit expression profiles together with telomerase activity. Since telomerase activity is linked to tumourgenesis, the genes were analysed with respect to their expression variation. TEP1 was expressed in all glioma cell lines and 70% of glioblastoma tissues, in addition to the control brain tissues. Tankyrase was expressed in 85% of the glioblastoma tissues and was down-regulated in the recurrent anaplastic ependymoma tissue control cell lines. However, it was expressed in the control tissues. Dyskerin was expressed in all cell lines and tissues apart from U87-MG and NHA cells and the recurrent anaplastic ependymoma tissue. As expected, PARP1 and GAPDH showed constitutive expression throughout all cell lines and tissues since both are known to be housekeeping genes. hTERT was expressed in all glioma cell lines and tissues but was absent in the control cells and tissues. Telomerase activity was absent in IPDDC-A2 cells and 57% of the glioblastoma tissues. These results suggest that hTERT expression and not telomerase activity possibly represents a simple and reliable biological diagnostic tool.

hTERT immunopositivity patterns in the normal brain and in astrocytic tumors

Accumulating data about the impact of hTERT in astrocytic tumor carcinogenesis and recent evidence about its association with disease outcome prompt the evaluation of this molecule with methods applicable in routine pathology practice. In this study, we investigated hTERT protein expression with immunohistochemistry (IHC) and the NCL-hTERT antibody in 49 astrocytic tumors. Results were validated with the assessment of hTERT mRNA (relative quantification, identification of splice variants, in situ hybridization). Specific nuclear hTERT immunostaining patterns (IPs) were characterized as patterns As (single large dot) and Am (multiple dots) without nucleoplasm staining and pattern B (nucleoplasm staining with or without dots), corresponding to low and high relative hTERT expression values (P<0.0001). Low- and high-grade astrocytic tumors were found positive for hTERT in 74 and 85% of cases, respectively. Heterogeneity in the distribution of hTERT-positive cells was observed in all tumors. The prevailing nuclear IPs differed significantly between pilocytic astrocytomas (pattern As) and the rest of histologic types up to glioblastoma (patterns Am and B) (P<0.0001). The described nuclear IPs were also observed in non-neoplastic cells. Positive endothelial cells were found in astrocytic tumors of all grades, even when tumor cells showed no hTERT immunoreactivity. A subset of mature normal neurons was positive for hTERT (pattern As), suggesting a role for this molecule in neuronal maintenance in the adult brain. The nuclear hTERT IPs described here may reflect the functional status of non-neoplastic brain and neoplastic astrocytic cells and support the model of a continuum in the development of glioblastomas from diffuse fibrillary astrocytomas.

Telomerase activity is not a key determinant of sensitivity to standard cytotoxic drugs in human esophageal carcinoma cell lines

The aim of the present study was to investigate if basal telomerase activity levels may predict sensitivity to cytotoxic drugs in a panel of human esophageal carcinoma cell lines. The TRAPeze telomerase detection assay was used to investigate telomerase activity in the cell lines. Cytotoxic drug sensitivity for 20 standard cytotoxic agents was assessed using the fluorometric microculture cytotoxicity assay (FMCA). Telomerase activity was detected in all cell lines with a broad range of activity levels. Drug sensitivity also varied considerably between the cell lines. Except for a P value towards a correlation between mitoxantrone and telomerase activity (P=0.054), no statistically significant correlation was found between telomerase activity levels and sensitivity to investigated drugs, including key drugs such as cisplatin (P=0.9), 5-fluorouracil (P=0.8) and doxorubicin (P=0.54). We therefore conclude that basal telomerase activity level is not a key determinant of sensitivity to standard cytotoxic drugs in esophageal carcinoma cell lines.

mRNA quantification and clinical evaluation of telomerase reverse transcriptase subunit (hTERT) in intracranial tumours of patients in the island of Crete

Telomerase is a reverse transcriptase that maintains telomeres by adding telomeric TTAGGG repeats to the ends of human chromosomes. The aim of this study was to evaluate quantitatively the mRNA expression of telomerase catalytic subunit (hTERT) in different types of intracranial tumours in relation to their histologic pattern and grade and correlate it with progression-free (PFS) and overall survival (OS) of patients. Human telomerase reverse transcriptase mRNA levels were estimated by the use of real time RT–PCR in 68 samples of intracranial tumours. It revealed statistical correlation between hTERT mRNA expression levels and the grade of the tumours (P<0.001). Patients having negative expression of hTERT mRNA had statistically longer PFS (P=0.031) and OS (P=0.047). Cox univariate regression analysis revealed that hTERT mRNA-positive patients had a high and statistically significant risk of relapse (hazard ratio (HR) of 2.24 and P=0.038). In the Cox multivariate regression model, the levels of hTERT mRNA were adjusted for tumour grade and patients age, and since there was statistically significant relationship between the levels of hTERT mRNA and the grade of the tumours (P=0.003 or P=0.006, respectively), hTERT mRNA levels could not be considered as an independent prognostic factor for PFS or OS.

Telomere length abnormalities occur early in the initiation of epithelial carcinogenesis

PURPOSE

Telomeres help maintain chromosomal integrity. Dysfunctional telomeres can cause genetic instability in vitro and an increased cancer incidence in telomerase knock out mouse models. We recently reported that telomere shortening was a prevalent alteration in human prostate, pancreas, and breast cancer precursor lesions. In the present study, we address whether the previous findings are broadly applicable to human epithelial cancer precursors in general.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

Surgical specimens of epithelial cancer precursor lesions from the urinary bladder, esophagus, large intestine, oral cavity, and uterine cervix were examined using a recently developed technique for direct in situ telomere length assessment in formalin-fixed human tissue specimens.

RESULTS

Widespread telomere length abnormalities were nearly universal (97.1% of cases) in the preinvasive stages of human epithelial carcinogenesis in all sites examined in this series, with telomere shortening the predominant abnormality (88.6% of cases).

CONCLUSIONS

Telomere length abnormalities appear to be one of the earliest and most prevalent genetic alterations acquired in the multistep process of malignant transformation. These findings support a model whereby telomere dysfunction induces chromosomal instability as an initiating event in many, perhaps most, human epithelial cancers. Together with previous findings from the prostate and pancreas, the percentage of intraepithelial neoplasia lesions showing telomere length abnormalities is 95.6%. The implications of these findings include the potential that telomere length assessment in situ may be a widely useful biomarker for monitoring disease prevention strategies and for improved early diagnosis.

Survivin in glioblastomas. Protein and messenger RNA expression and comparison with telomerase levels

CONTEXT

Survivin is a novel inhibitor of apoptosis that acts via a pathway independent of bcl-2. Little is known about its distribution in brain tumors or how it correlates with other biomarkers of malignancy, such as telomerase, an enzyme that plays a critical role in cellular immortalization and cancer biology.

OBJECTIVES

To assess survivin protein expression in gliomas and to compare expression with that of telomerase.

DESIGN

Immunohistochemical staining for survivin protein expression was performed using an antibody developed in our laboratory. Quantitative survivin messenger RNA (mRNA) levels were assessed by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction. In selected cases, survivin results were compared with quantitative telomerase values analyzed by polymerase chain reaction-based telomerase repeat amplification protocol (TRAP) assay. Twenty-five tumor tissue samples from 16 cases of glioblastoma multiforme (GBM; including multiple tissue samples in 6 patients), 2 grade II gliomas, 4 grade III gliomas, and 3 control temporal lobectomy specimens were studied.

RESULTS

Nuclear immunoreactivity for survivin protein and survivin mRNA were detectable in most glioma samples, regardless of grade. Glioblastoma multiforme demonstrated moderate protein expression and survivin mRNA levels compared to epithelial malignancies previously tested in our laboratory. Although the association of survivin mRNA with the levels of telomerase within the GBM cases did not reach statistical significance, most GBMs also expressed survivin. The quantitative score for survivin mRNA was higher in GBMs than in grade II and III gliomas (P =.02), after accounting for multiple specimens per patient.

CONCLUSIONS

Quantitative survivin mRNA analysis, but not immunohistochemistry, distinguished GBMs from lower grade gliomas. Mechanisms that promote both cell proliferation (telomerase expression) and cell survival (survivin expression) are often activated in GBMs.

Clinical implications of quantitative real-time RT-PCR analysis of hTERT gene expression in human gliomas

The presence of telomerase activity in a glioma may be a predictor of its malignant potential. Activation of telomerase is regulated at the transcriptional level of the human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT). Here, we evaluated whether the amount of hTERT mRNA provides a molecular marker of glioma malignancy that would have clinical utility. We used a real-time RT-PCR to assess the number of hTERT transcripts in primary tumour samples derived from 70 glioma patients. Results were standardised by quantifying the number of ABL transcripts as internal control and expressed as hTERT/ABL ratio. The percentage of patients with detectable hTERT mRNA markedly increased with enhanced malignancy: low-grade gliomas expressed hTERT in one out of 14 cases (7.1%), anaplastic gliomas in four out of 13 cases (30.8%) and glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) tumours in 30 out of 43 cases (69.8%). The mean hTERT/ABL ratio was significantly higher in GBMs than in non-GBMs. Subdividing hTERT/ABL ratios as low (< pr = 25%) and high (>25%), we found that the overall survival among hTERT-positive GBMs was significantly worse in high hTERT expressors than in low hTERT expressors (P=0.0082). We conclude that the amount of hTERT mRNA may represent a diagnostic and prognostic indicator for GBM patients.

Immunohistochemical markers for prognosis of cerebral glioblastomas

Glioblastoma is the commonest neuroectodermal tumor and the most malignant in the range of cerebral astrocytic gliomas. The prognostic utility of various biological markers for glioblastomas has been broadly tested but the results obtained are regarded as controversial. In the present study, 302 glioblastoma specimens were studied to evaluate a possible association between clinical outcome and expression of some immunohistochemical variables. Furthermore, tumors examined were subdivided on the three cytological subsets--small-cell (SGB), pleomorphic-cell (PGB) and gemistocytic (GGB). Immunohistochemical variables differed between various subsets: the number of p53-positive tumors was found to be prevailed among the PGB, whereas the number of tumors with EGFR and mdm2 positivity was significantly greater in SGB. GGB contained significantly lowest mean proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) labeling index (LI), greater number of p21ras positive cases, and higher mean apoptotic index (AI). Survival time in patients with SGB, EGFR and mdm2-positivity and PCNA LI >40% was found to be significantly shorter, whereas presence of p21ras and AI >0.5% were associated with prolonged survival. Multivariate analysis revealed that survival time is associated with SGB, EGFR-positivity, and AI (p = 0.0023, p = 0.0035 and p = 0.0029 respectively). We conclude that although some immunohistochemical variables were found to be significant for glioblastoma outcome, they appear to be closely related to biology of single cytological subsets. Furthermore, these variables exhibited no prognostic value when they were analyzed within each cytological subset separately. Therefore, the glioblastoma subdivision on three cytological subsets proposed by us is carrying some element of rationality but, undoubtedly, requires further prospective studies.

Telomerase in cancer and aging

The telomere-telomerase hypothesis is the science of cellular aging (senescence) and cancer. The ends of chromosomes, telomeres, count the number of divisions a cell can undergo before entering permanent growth arrest. As divisions are being counted, events occur on the cellular and molecular level, which may either delay or hasten this arrest. As humans age, a particular concern is the accumulation of events that lead to the progression of cancer. Telomerase is a mechanism that most normal cells do not possess, but almost all cancer cells acquire, to overcome their mortality and extend their lifespan. This review aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the role of telomerase in cancer development, progression, diagnosis, and in the future, treatment. The ultimate goal of telomerase research is to use our understanding to develop anti-telomerase therapies, an almost universal tumor target.

Telomerase in human tumors: molecular diagnosis and clinical significance

Shortening of structures known as telomeres, which cap the ends of chromosomes, is postulated to limit the lifespan of human cells. Activation of telomerase, an enzyme that synthesizes telomeric DNA, is an essential step in cell immortalization. Telomerase is ordinarily inactive in most somatic cells, but can be detected in nearly all tumors. The activation of telomerase in malignant cancers seems to be an important step in tumorigenesis, whereby the cell gains the ability of indefinite proliferation. Due to the association between telomerase expression and malignancy, the enzyme is expected to be a useful tumor marker and a new anticancer therapeutic target. However, recent results scale down to some extent the initial enthusiastic expectations for telomerase as the ideal malignancy marker.