Intramembrane proteolytic cleavage of a membrane-tethered transcription factor by a metalloprotease depends on ATP

Substrate engagement by the intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB

S2P intramembrane metalloproteases regulate diverse signaling pathways across all three domains of life. However, the mechanism by which S2P metalloproteases engage substrates and catalyze peptide hydrolysis within lipid membranes has remained elusive. Here we determine the cryo-EM structure of the S2P family intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB from Bacillus subtilis bound to its native substrate Pro-σK. The structure and accompanying biochemical data demonstrate that SpoIVFB positions Pro-σK at the enzyme active site through a β-sheet augmentation mechanism, and reveal key interactions between Pro-σK and the interdomain linker connecting SpoIVFB transmembrane and CBS domains. The cryo-EM structure and molecular dynamics simulation reveal a plausible path for water to access the membrane-buried active site of SpoIVFB, and suggest a possible role of membrane lipids in facilitating substrate capture. These results provide key insight into how S2P intramembrane metalloproteases capture and position substrates for hydrolytic proteolysis within the hydrophobic interior of a lipid membrane.

Alanine and glutamate catabolism collaborate to ensure the success of Bacillus subtilis sporulation

Sporulation as a typical bacterial differentiation process has been studied for decades. However, two crucial aspects of sporulation, (i) the energy sources supporting the process, and (ii) the maintenance of spore dormancy throughout sporulation, are scarcely explored. Here, we reported the crucial role of RocG-mediated glutamate catabolism in regulating mother cell lysis, a critical step for sporulation completion of Bacillus subtilis, likely by providing energy metabolite ATP. Notably, rocG overexpression resulted in an excessive ATP accumulation in sporulating cells, leading to adverse effects on future spore properties, e.g. increased germination efficiency, reduced DPA content, and lowered heat resistance. Additionally, we revealed that Ald-mediated alanine metabolism was highly related to the inhibition of premature germination and the maintenance of spore dormancy during sporulation, which might be achieved by decreasing the typical germinant L-alanine concentration in sporulating environment. Our data inferred that sporulation of B. subtilis was a highly orchestrated biological process requiring a delicate balance in diverse metabolic pathways, hence ensuring both the completion of sporulation and production of high-quality spores.

The role of site-2-proteases in bacteria: a review on physiology, virulence, and therapeutic potential

Site-2-proteases are a class of intramembrane proteases involved in regulated intramembrane proteolysis. Regulated intramembrane proteolysis is a highly conserved signaling mechanism that commonly involves sequential digestion of an anti-sigma factor by a site-1- and site-2-protease in response to external stimuli, resulting in an adaptive transcriptional response. Variation of this signaling cascade continues to emerge as the role of site-2-proteases in bacteria continues to be explored. Site-2-proteases are highly conserved among bacteria and play a key role in multiple processes, including iron uptake, stress response, and pheromone production. Additionally, an increasing number of site-2-proteases have been found to play a pivotal role in the virulence properties of multiple human pathogens, such as alginate production in Pseudomonas aeruginosa, toxin production in Vibrio cholerae, resistance to lysozyme in enterococci and antimicrobials in several Bacillus spp, and cell-envelope lipid composition in Mycobacterium tuberculosis. The prominent role of site-2-proteases in bacterial pathogenicity highlights the potential of site-2-proteases as novel targets for therapeutic intervention. In this review, we summarize the role of site-2-proteases in bacterial physiology and virulence, as well as evaluate the therapeutic potential of site-2-proteases.

Inhibitory proteins block substrate access by occupying the active site cleft of Bacillus subtilis intramembrane protease SpoIVFB

Intramembrane proteases (IPs) function in numerous signaling pathways that impact health, but elucidating the regulation of membrane-embedded proteases is challenging. We examined inhibition of intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB by proteins BofA and SpoIVFA. We found that SpoIVFB inhibition requires BofA residues in and near a predicted transmembrane segment (TMS). This segment of BofA occupies the SpoIVFB active site cleft based on cross-linking experiments. SpoIVFB inhibition also requires SpoIVFA. The inhibitory proteins block access of the substrate N-terminal region to the membrane-embedded SpoIVFB active site, based on additional cross-linking experiments; however, the inhibitory proteins did not prevent interaction between the substrate C-terminal region and the SpoIVFB soluble domain. We built a structural model of SpoIVFB in complex with BofA and parts of SpoIVFA and substrate, using partial homology and constraints from cross-linking and co-evolutionary analyses. The model predicts that conserved BofA residues interact to stabilize a TMS and a membrane-embedded C-terminal region. The model also predicts that SpoIVFA bridges the BofA C-terminal region and SpoIVFB, forming a membrane-embedded inhibition complex. Our results reveal a novel mechanism of IP inhibition with clear implications for relief from inhibition in vivo and design of inhibitors as potential therapeutics.

Conserved Proline Residues of Bacillus subtilis Intramembrane Metalloprotease SpoIVFB Are Important for Substrate Interaction and Cleavage

Intramembrane metalloproteases (IMMPs) regulate diverse biological processes by cleaving membrane-associated substrates within the membrane or near its surface. SpoIVFB is an intramembrane metalloprotease of Bacillus subtilis that cleaves Pro-σK during endosporulation. Intramembrane metalloproteases have a broadly conserved NPDG motif, which in the structure of an archaeal enzyme is located in a short loop that interrupts a transmembrane segment facing the active site. The aspartate residue of the NPDG motif acts as a ligand of the zinc ion involved in catalysis. The functions of other residues in the short loop are less well understood. We found that the predicted short loop of SpoIVFB contains two highly conserved proline residues, P132 of the NPDG motif and P135. Mutational analysis revealed that both proline residues are important for Pro-σK cleavage in Escherichia coli engineered to synthesize the proteins. Substitutions for either residue also impaired the Pro-σK interaction with SpoIVFB in copurification assays. Disulfide cross-linking experiments showed that the predicted short loop of SpoIVFB is in proximity to the N-terminal pro-sequence region (Proregion) of Pro-σK. Alanine substitutions for N129 and P132 of the SpoIVFB NPDG motif reduced cross-linking between its predicted short loop and the Proregion more than a P135A substitution. Conversely, the SpoIVFB P135A substitution reduced Pro-σK cleavage more than the N129A and P132A substitutions during sporulation of B. subtilis. We conclude that all three conserved residues of SpoIVFB are important for substrate interaction and cleavage, and we propose that P135 is necessary to position D137 to act as a zinc ligand. IMPORTANCE Intramembrane metalloproteases (IMMPs) function in numerous signaling pathways. Bacterial IMMPs govern stress responses, including the sporulation of some species, thus enhancing the virulence and persistence of pathogens. Knowledge of IMMP-substrate interactions could aid therapeutic design, but structures of IMMP·substrate complexes are unknown. We examined the interaction of the IMMP SpoIVFB with its substrate Pro-σK, whose cleavage is required for Bacillus subtilis endosporulation. We found that conserved proline residues in a short loop predicted to interrupt a SpoIVFB transmembrane segment are important for Pro-σK binding and cleavage. The corresponding residues of the Escherichia coli IMMP RseP have also been shown to be important for substrate interaction and cleavage, suggesting that this is a broadly conserved feature of IMMPs, potentially suitable as a therapeutic target.

Channels modestly impact compartment-specific ATP levels during Bacillus subtilis sporulation and a rise in the mother cell ATP level is not necessary for Pro-σK cleavage

Starvation of Bacillus subtilis initiates endosporulation involving formation of mother cell (MC) and forespore (FS) compartments. During engulfment, the MC membrane migrates around the FS and protein channels connect the two compartments. The channels are necessary for postengulfment FS gene expression, which relieves inhibition of SpoIVFB, an intramembrane protease that cleaves Pro-σ^K , releasing σ^K into the MC. SpoIVFB has an ATP-binding domain exposed to the MC cytoplasm, but the role of ATP in regulating Pro-σ^K cleavage has been unclear, as has the impact of the channels on MC and FS ATP levels. Using luciferase produced separately in each compartment to measure relative ATP concentrations during sporulation, we found that the MC ATP concentration rises about twofold coincident with increasing cleavage of Pro-σ^K , and the FS ATP concentration does not decline. Mutants lacking a channel protein or defective in channel protein turnover exhibited modest and varied effects on ATP levels, which suggested that low ATP concentration does not explain the lack of postengulfment FS gene expression in channel mutants. Furthermore, a rise in the MC ATP level was not necessary for Pro-σ^K cleavage by SpoIVFB, based on analysis of mutants that bypass the need for relief of SpoIVFB inhibition.

Identification of L-Valine-initiated-germination-active genes in Bacillus subtilis using Tn-seq

Bacterial endospores can survive harsh environmental conditions and long-term dormancy in the absence of nutrients, but can rapidly germinate under favorable conditions. In the present study, we employed transposon sequencing (Tn-seq) to identify genes with previously uncharacterized roles in spore germination. Identified genes that encoded spore inner membrane proteins were chosen for study of defined mutants, which exhibited delayed germination in several assays in response to varying germinants. Significantly slowed release of DPA indicated that mutants were affected in Stage I of germination. Several mutants exhibited phenotypic traits consistent with failure of a GerA germinant receptor-mediated response, while others appeared to have a more general loss of response to varied germinants. Use of a gerA-lacZ transcriptional fusion and quantitative western blotting of GerAC allowed mutants to be classified based upon normal or decreased gerA transcription and normal or reduced GerA accumulation. Fourteen genes were identified to have newly described roles within Bacillus spore germination. A more complete understanding of this process can contribute to the development of better spore decontamination procedures.

Detection of specific immune response in sole (Solea senegalensis) against Photobacterium damselae subsp. piscicida antigens

The pathogenic bacteria Photobacterium damselae subsp. piscicida affects the development of Solea senegalensis culture. Vaccines made with inactivated cells have produced a relative protection against the sickness, however the administration of subcellular and purified antigens as vaccine could increase the effectiveness of the immune response. Thus, the aim of this work was the determination of antigens of P. damselae subsp. piscicida involved in the specific immune response of S. senegalensis. Fish were immunized by intraperitoneal injection (i.p.) with inactivated extracellular polymeric substances (ECP) and whole cells of P. damselae subsp. piscicida, and Freund's incomplete adjuvant. Two months later fish were boosted with the same antigens. Serum from fish was collected to determine by ELISA the title of antibodies against subcellular fractions of bacteria (ECP, capsule, outer membrane proteins, O antigen and formalized whole cells). Significant differences were found between control and immunized fish, but differences between first immunization and booster were only found for O antigen and capsule. Western blots derived from 2D-PAGE of ECP and Outer Membrane Proteins (OMP), using sole immunized serum, detected two high reactive antigens from ECP. Proteins were identified, by mass spectrometry, as ATP-dependent metalloprotease and Telurite resistance proteins. In the case of OMP, three antigenic proteins were detected and identified as Nrfa Y218f, Anti-oxidant AhpC/TSA, and a protein domain DNA binding heat shock related.

Evidence that regulation of intramembrane proteolysis is mediated by substrate gating during sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

During the morphological process of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis two adjacent daughter cells (called the mother cell and forespore) follow different programs of gene expression that are linked to each other by signal transduction pathways. At a late stage in development, a signaling pathway emanating from the forespore triggers the proteolytic activation of the mother cell transcription factor σ^K. Cleavage of pro-σ^K to its mature and active form is catalyzed by the intramembrane cleaving metalloprotease SpoIVFB (B), a Site-2 Protease (S2P) family member. B is held inactive by two mother-cell membrane proteins SpoIVFA (A) and BofA. Activation of pro-σ^K processing requires a site-1 signaling protease SpoIVB (IVB) that is secreted from the forespore into the space between the two cells. IVB cleaves the extracellular domain of A but how this cleavage activates intramembrane proteolysis has remained unclear. Structural studies of the Methanocaldococcus jannaschii S2P homolog identified closed (substrate-occluded) and open (substrate-accessible) conformations of the protease, but the biological relevance of these conformations has not been established. Here, using co-immunoprecipitation and fluorescence microscopy, we show that stable association between the membrane-embedded protease and its substrate requires IVB signaling. We further show that the cytoplasmic cystathionine-β-synthase (CBS) domain of the B protease is not critical for this interaction or for pro-σ^K processing, suggesting the IVB-dependent interaction site is in the membrane protease domain. Finally, we provide evidence that the B protease domain adopts both open and closed conformations in vivo. Collectively, our data support a substrate-gating model in which IVB-dependent cleavage of A on one side of the membrane triggers a conformational change in the membrane-embedded protease from a closed to an open state allowing pro-σ^K access to the caged interior of the protease.

Regulated Intramembrane Proteolysis is a broadly conserved mechanism for transducing information across lipid bilayers. In these signaling pathways a protease on one side of the membrane triggers the activation of a membrane-embedded protease that cleaves its substrate within or adjacent to the cytoplasmic face of the membrane. Site-2 metalloproteases (S2P) are the most commonly used intramembrane cleaving proteases in these pathways but the mechanism by which cleavage on one side of the membrane triggers intramembrane proteolysis remains poorly understood. Here, we provide evidence for a substrate-gating model in which an extracellular signaling protease triggers a conformational change in a S2P family member from a closed to an open conformation allowing its substrate access to the catalytic center of the enzyme.

Interaction of intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB with substrate Pro-σK

Intramembrane proteases (IPs) cleave membrane-associated substrates in nearly all organisms and regulate diverse processes. A better understanding of how these enzymes interact with their substrates is necessary for rational design of IP modulators. We show that interaction of Bacillus subtilis IP SpoIVFB with its substrate Pro-σ^K depends on particular residues in the interdomain linker of SpoIVFB. The linker plus either the N-terminal membrane domain or the C-terminal cystathione-β-synthase (CBS) domain of SpoIVFB was sufficient for the interaction but not for cleavage of Pro-σ^K Chemical cross-linking and mass spectrometry of purified, inactive SpoIVFB-Pro-σ^K complex indicated residues of the two proteins in proximity. A structural model of the complex was built via partial homology and by using constraints based on cross-linking data. In the model, the Proregion of Pro-σ^K loops into the membrane domain of SpoIVFB, and the rest of Pro-σ^K interacts extensively with the linker and the CBS domain of SpoIVFB. The extensive interaction is proposed to allow coordination between ATP binding by the CBS domain and Pro-σ^K cleavage by the membrane domain.

Bacillus subtilis Intramembrane Protease RasP Activity in Escherichia coli and In Vitro

RasP is a predicted intramembrane metalloprotease of Bacillus subtilis that has been proposed to cleave the stress response anti-sigma factors RsiW and RsiV, the cell division protein FtsL, and remnant signal peptides within their transmembrane segments. To provide evidence for direct effects of RasP on putative substrates, we developed a heterologous coexpression system. Since expression of catalytically inactive RasP E21A inhibited expression of other membrane proteins in Escherichia coli, we added extra transmembrane segments to RasP E21A, which allowed accumulation of most other membrane proteins. A corresponding active version of RasP appeared to promiscuously cleave coexpressed membrane proteins, except those with a large periplasmic domain. However, stable cleavage products were not observed, even in clpP mutant E. coli Fusions of transmembrane segment-containing parts of FtsL and RsiW to E. coli maltose-binding protein (MBP) also resulted in proteins that appeared to be RasP substrates upon coexpression in E. coli, including FtsL with a full-length C-terminal domain (suggesting that prior cleavage by a site 1 protease is unnecessary) and RsiW designed to mimic the PrsW site 1 cleavage product (suggesting that further trimming by extracytoplasmic protease is unnecessary). Purified RasP cleaved His₆-MBP-RsiW(73-118) in vitro within the RsiW transmembrane segment based on mass spectrometry analysis, demonstrating that RasP is an intramembrane protease. Surprisingly, purified RasP failed to cleave His₆-MBP-FtsL(23-117). We propose that the lack of α-helix-breaking residues in the FtsL transmembrane segment creates a requirement for the membrane environment and/or an additional protein(s) in order for RasP to cleave FtsL.IMPORTANCE Intramembrane proteases govern important signaling pathways in nearly all organisms. In bacteria, they function in stress responses, cell division, pathogenesis, and other processes. Their membrane-associated substrates are typically inferred from genetic studies in the native bacterium. Evidence for direct effects has come sometimes from coexpression of the enzyme and potential substrate in a heterologous host and rarely from biochemical reconstitution of cleavage in vitro We applied these two approaches to the B. subtilis enzyme RasP and its proposed substrates RsiW and FtsL. We discovered potential pitfalls and solutions in heterologous coexpression experiments in E. coli, providing evidence that both substrates are cleaved by RasP in vivo but, surprisingly, that only RsiW was cleaved in vitro, suggesting that FtsL has an additional requirement.

Role of CBS and Bateman Domains in Phosphorylation-Dependent Regulation of a CLC Anion Channel

Eukaryotic CLC anion channels and transporters are homodimeric proteins composed of multiple α-helical membrane domains and large cytoplasmic C-termini containing two cystathionine-β-synthase domains (CBS1 and CBS2) that dimerize to form a Bateman domain. The Bateman domains of adjacent CLC subunits interact to form a Bateman domain dimer. The functions of CLC CBS and Bateman domains are poorly understood. We utilized the Caenorhabditis elegans CLC-1/2/Ka/Kb anion channel homolog CLH-3b to characterize the regulatory roles of CLC cytoplasmic domains. CLH-3b activity is reduced by phosphorylation or deletion of a 14-amino-acid activation domain (AD) located on the linker connecting CBS1 and CBS2. We demonstrate here that phosphorylation-dependent reductions in channel activity require an intact Bateman domain dimer and concomitant phosphorylation or deletion of both ADs. Regulation of a CLH-3b AD deletion mutant is reconstituted by intracellular perfusion with recombinant 14-amino-acid AD peptides. The sulfhydryl reactive reagent 2-(trimethylammonium)ethyl methanethiosulfonate bromide (MTSET) alters in a phosphorylation-dependent manner the activity of channels containing single cysteine residues that are engineered into the short intracellular loop connecting membrane α-helices H and I (H-I loop), the AD, CBS1, and CBS2. In contrast, MTSET has no effect on channels in which cysteine residues are engineered into intracellular regions that are dispensable for regulation. These studies together with our previous work suggest that binding and unbinding of the AD to the Bateman domain dimer induces conformational changes that are transduced to channel membrane domains via the H-I loop. Our findings provide new, to our knowledge, insights into the roles of CLC Bateman domains and the structure-function relationships that govern the regulation of CLC protein activity by diverse ligands and signaling pathways.

Crystallographic and biochemical characterization of the dimeric architecture of site-2 protease

Regulated intramembrane proteolysis by members of the site-2 protease family (S2P) is an essential signal transduction mechanism conserved from bacteria to humans. There is some evidence that extra-membranous domains, like PDZ and CBS domains, regulate the proteolytic activity of S2Ps and that some members act as dimers. Here we report the crystal structure of the regulatory CBS domain pair of S2P from Archaeoglobus fulgidus, AfS2P, in the apo and nucleotide-bound form in complex with a specific nanobody from llama. Cross-linking and SEC-MALS analyses show for the first time the dimeric architecture of AfS2P both in the membrane and in detergent micelles. The CBS domain pair dimer (CBS module) displays an unusual head-to-tail configuration and nucleotide binding triggers no major conformational changes in the magnesium-free state. In solution, MgATP drives monomerization of the CBS module. We propose a model of the so far unknown architecture of the transmembrane domain dimer and for a regulatory mechanism of AfS2P that involves the interaction of positively charged arginine residues located at the cytoplasmic face of the transmembrane domain with the negatively charged phosphate groups of ATP moieties bound to the CBS domain pairs. Binding of MgATP could promote opening of the CBS module to allow lateral access of the globular cytoplasmic part of the substrate.

Complex Formed between Intramembrane Metalloprotease SpoIVFB and Its Substrate, Pro-σK

Intramembrane metalloproteases (IMMPs) are conserved from bacteria to humans and control many important signaling pathways, but little is known about how IMMPs interact with their substrates. SpoIVFB is an IMMP that cleaves Pro-σ(K) during Bacillus subtilis endospore formation. When catalytically inactive SpoIVFB was coexpressed with C-terminally truncated Pro-σ(K)(1-126) (which can be cleaved by active SpoIVFB) in Escherichia coli, the substrate dramatically improved solubilization of the enzyme from membranes with mild detergents. Both the Pro(1-20) and σ(K)(21-126) parts contributed to improving SpoIVFB solubilization from membranes, but only the σ(K) part was needed to form a stable complex with SpoIVFB in a pulldown assay. The last 10 residues of SpoIVFB were required for improved solubilization from membranes by Pro-σ(K)(1-126) and for normal interaction with the substrate. The inactive SpoIVFB·Pro-σ(K)(1-126)-His6 complex was stable during affinity purification and gel filtration chromatography. Disulfide cross-linking of the purified complex indicated that it resembled the complex formed in vivo Ion mobility-mass spectrometry analysis resulted in an observed mass consistent with a 4:2 SpoIVFB·Pro-σ(K)(1-126)-His6 complex. Stepwise photobleaching of SpoIVFB fused to a fluorescent protein supported the notion that the enzyme is tetrameric during B. subtilis sporulation. The results provide the first evidence that an IMMP acts as a tetramer, give new insights into how SpoIVFB interacts with its substrate, and lay the foundation for further biochemical analysis of the enzyme·substrate complex and future structural studies.

High-Throughput Genetic Screens Identify a Large and Diverse Collection of New Sporulation Genes in Bacillus subtilis

The differentiation of the bacterium Bacillus subtilis into a dormant spore is among the most well-characterized developmental pathways in biology. Classical genetic screens performed over the past half century identified scores of factors involved in every step of this morphological process. More recently, transcriptional profiling uncovered additional sporulation-induced genes required for successful spore development. Here, we used transposon-sequencing (Tn-seq) to assess whether there were any sporulation genes left to be discovered. Our screen identified 133 out of the 148 genes with known sporulation defects. Surprisingly, we discovered 24 additional genes that had not been previously implicated in spore formation. To investigate their functions, we used fluorescence microscopy to survey early, middle, and late stages of differentiation of null mutants from the B. subtilis ordered knockout collection. This analysis identified mutants that are delayed in the initiation of sporulation, defective in membrane remodeling, and impaired in spore maturation. Several mutants had novel sporulation phenotypes. We performed in-depth characterization of two new factors that participate in cell–cell signaling pathways during sporulation. One (SpoIIT) functions in the activation of σ^E in the mother cell; the other (SpoIIIL) is required for σ^G activity in the forespore. Our analysis also revealed that as many as 36 sporulation-induced genes with no previously reported mutant phenotypes are required for timely spore maturation. Finally, we discovered a large set of transposon insertions that trigger premature initiation of sporulation. Our results highlight the power of Tn-seq for the discovery of new genes and novel pathways in sporulation and, combined with the recently completed null mutant collection, open the door for similar screens in other, less well-characterized processes.

Transposon sequencing enables the recovery of virtually all previously characterized genes required for the differentiation of the bacterium Bacillus subtilis into a dormant spore and identifies 24 new ones.

When starved of nutrients, the bacterium Bacillus subtilis differentiates into a dormant spore that is impervious to environmental insults. Decades of research have uncovered over 100 genes required for spore formation. Molecular dissection of these genes has revealed factors that act at every stage of this developmental process. In this study, we used a high-throughput genetic screening method called transposon sequencing to assess whether there were any sporulation genes left to be discovered. This approach identified virtually all of the known sporulation genes, as well as 24 new ones. Furthermore, transposon sequencing enabled the discovery of two new sets of mutants in which the sporulation process was either delayed or accelerated. Using fluorescence microscopy, we determined the developmental stage at which each mutant was impaired and discovered mutants that are delayed in initiation of sporulation, or defective in morphogenesis, cell–cell signaling, or spore maturation. Our findings exemplify the utility of transposon sequencing to uncover new biology in well-studied processes, suggesting that it could similarly be used to identify novel genes required for other aspects of bacterial physiology, such as natural competence, stationary phase survival, or the responses to cell envelope stress and DNA damage.

Regulated proteolysis in bacterial development

Bacteria use proteases to control three types of events temporally and spatially during the processes of morphological development. These events are the destruction of regulatory proteins, activation of regulatory proteins, and production of signals. While some of these events are entirely cytoplasmic, others involve intramembrane proteolysis of a substrate, transmembrane signaling, or secretion. In some cases, multiple proteolytic events are organized into pathways, for example turnover of a regulatory protein activates a protease that generates a signal. We review well-studied and emerging examples and identify recurring themes and important questions for future research. We focus primarily on paradigms learned from studies of model organisms, but we note connections to regulated proteolytic events that govern bacterial adaptation, biofilm formation and disassembly, and pathogenesis.

Biochemical and structural insights into intramembrane metalloprotease mechanisms

Intramembrane metalloproteases are nearly ubiquitous in living organisms and they function in diverse processes ranging from cholesterol homeostasis and the unfolded protein response in humans to sporulation, stress responses, and virulence of bacteria. Understanding how these enzymes function in membranes is a challenge of fundamental interest with potential applications if modulators can be devised. Progress is described toward a mechanistic understanding, based primarily on molecular genetic and biochemical studies of human S2P and bacterial SpoIVFB and RseP, and on the structure of the membrane domain of an archaeal enzyme. Conserved features of the enzymes appear to include transmembrane helices and loops around the active site zinc ion, which may be near the membrane surface. Extramembrane domains such as PDZ (PSD-95, DLG, ZO-1) or CBS (cystathionine-β-synthase) domains govern substrate access to the active site, but several different mechanisms of access and cleavage site selection can be envisioned, which might differ depending on the substrate and the enzyme. More work is needed to distinguish between these mechanisms, both for enzymes that have been relatively well-studied, and for enzymes lacking PDZ and CBS domains, which have not been studied. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Intramembrane Proteases.

Function of site-2 proteases in bacteria and bacterial pathogens

Site-2 proteases (S2Ps) are a class of intramembrane metalloproteases named after the founding member of this protein family, human S2P, which control cholesterol and fatty acid biosynthesis by cleaving Sterol Regulatory Element Binding Proteins which control cholesterol and fatty acid biosynthesis. S2Ps are widely distributed in bacteria and participate in diverse pathways that control such diverse functions as membrane integrity, sporulation, lipid biosynthesis, pheromone production, virulence, and others. The most common signaling mechanism mediated by S2Ps is the coupled degradation of transmembrane anti-Sigma factors to activate ECF Sigma factor regulons. However, additional signaling mechanisms continue to emerge as more prokaryotic S2Ps are characterized, including direct proteolysis of membrane embedded transcription factors and proteolysis of non-transcriptional membrane proteins or membrane protein remnants. In this review we seek to comprehensively review the functions of S2Ps in bacteria and bacterial pathogens and attempt to organize these proteases into conceptual groups that will spur further study. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Intramembrane Proteases.

Residues in conserved loops of intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB interact with residues near the cleavage site in pro-σK

Intramembrane metalloproteases (IMMPs) control critical biological processes by cleaving membrane-associated proteins within a transmembrane segment or at a site near the membrane surface. Phylogenetic analysis divides IMMPs into four groups. SpoIVFB is a group III IMMP that regulates Bacillus subtilis endospore formation by cleaving Pro-σ(K) and releasing the active sigma factor from a membrane. To elucidate the enzyme-substrate interaction, single-cysteine versions of catalytically inactive SpoIVFB and C-terminally truncated Pro-σ(K)(1-126) (which can be cleaved by active SpoIVFB) were coexpressed in Escherichia coli, and proximity was tested by disulfide cross-linking in vivo. As expected, the results provided evidence that catalytic residue Glu-44 of SpoIVFB is near the cleavage site in the substrate. Also near the cleavage site were two residues of SpoIVFB in predicted conserved loops; Pro-135 in a short loop and Val-70 in a longer loop. Pro-135 corresponds to Pro-399 of RseP, a group I IMMP, and Pro-399 was reported previously to interact with substrate near the cleavage site, suggesting a conserved interaction across IMMP subfamilies. Val-70 follows a newly recognized conserved motif, PXGG (X is a large hydrophobic residue), which is in a hydrophobic region predicted to be a membrane reentrant loop. Following the hydrophobic region is a negatively charged region that is conserved in IMMPs of groups I and III. At least two residues with a negatively charged side chain are required in this region for activity of SpoIVFB. The region exhibits other features in IMMPs of groups II and IV. Its possible roles, as well as that of the short loop, are discussed. New insights into IMMP-substrate interaction build toward understanding how IMMPs function and may facilitate manipulation of their activity.

Features of Pro-σK important for cleavage by SpoIVFB, an intramembrane metalloprotease

Intramembrane proteases regulate diverse processes by cleaving substrates within a transmembrane segment or near the membrane surface. Bacillus subtilis SpoIVFB is an intramembrane metalloprotease that cleaves Pro-σ(K) during sporulation. To elucidate features of Pro-σ(K) important for cleavage by SpoIVFB, coexpression of the two proteins in Escherichia coli was used along with cell fractionation. In the absence of SpoIVFB, a portion of the Pro-σ(K) was peripherally membrane associated. This portion was not observed in the presence of SpoIVFB, suggesting that it serves as the substrate. Deletion of Pro-σ(K) residues 2 to 8, addition of residues at its N terminus, or certain single-residue substitutions near the cleavage site impaired cleavage. Certain multiresidue substitutions near the cleavage site changed the position of cleavage, revealing preferences for a small residue preceding the cleavage site N-terminally (i.e., at the P1 position) and a hydrophobic residue at the second position following the cleavage site C-terminally (i.e., P2'). These features appear to be conserved among Pro-σ(K) orthologs. SpoIVFB did not tolerate an aromatic residue at P1 or P2' of Pro-σ(K). A Lys residue at P3' of Pro-σ(K) could not be replaced with Ala unless a Lys was provided farther C-terminally (e.g., at P9'). α-Helix-destabilizing residues near the cleavage site were not crucial for SpoIVFB to cleave Pro-σ(K). The preferences and tolerances of SpoIVFB are somewhat different from those of other intramembrane metalloproteases, perhaps reflecting differences in the interaction of the substrate with the membrane and the enzyme.

The site-2 protease

The site-2 protease (S2P) is an unusually-hydrophobic integral membrane protease. It cleaves its substrates, which are membrane-bound transcription factors, within membrane-spanning helices. Although structural information for S2P from animals is lacking, the available data suggest that cleavage may occur at or within the lipid bilayer. In mammalian cells, S2P is essential owing to its activation of the sterol regulatory element binding proteins (SREBPs); in the absence of exogenous lipid, cells lacking S2P cannot survive. S2P is also important in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress response, activating several different membrane-bound transcription factors. Human patients harboring reduction-of-function mutations in S2P exhibit an array of pathologies ranging from skin defects to neurological abnormalities. Surprisingly, Drosophila melanogaster lacking S2P are viable and fertile. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Intramembrane Proteases.

Structural and mechanistic principles of intramembrane proteolysis--lessons from rhomboids

Intramembrane proteases cleave membrane proteins in their transmembrane helices to regulate a wide range of biological processes. They catalyse hydrolytic reactions within the hydrophobic environment of lipid membranes where water is normally excluded. How? Do the different classes of intramembrane proteases share any mechanistic principles? In this review these questions will be discussed in view of the crystal structures of prokaryotic members of the three known catalytic types of intramembrane proteases published over the past 7 years. Rhomboids, the intramembrane serine proteases that are the best understood family, will be the initial area of focus, and the principles that have arisen from a number of structural and biochemical studies will be considered. The site-2 metalloprotease and GXGD-type aspartyl protease structures will then be discussed, with parallels drawn and differences highlighted between these enzymes and the rhomboids. Despite the significant advances achieved so far, to obtain a detailed understanding of the mechanism of any intramembrane protease, high-resolution structural information on the substrate-enzyme complex is required. This remains a major challenge for the field.

Identification and characterization of five intramembrane metalloproteases in Anabaena variabilis

Regulated intramembrane proteolysis (RIP) involves cleavage of a transmembrane segment of a protein, releasing the active form of a membrane-anchored transcription factor (MTF) or a membrane-tethered signaling protein in response to an extracellular or intracellular signal. RIP is conserved from bacteria to humans and governs many important signaling pathways in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Proteases that carry out these cleavages are named intramembrane cleaving proteases (I-CLips). To date, little is known about I-CLips in cyanobacteria. In this study, five putative site-2 type I-Clips (Ava_1070, Ava_1730, Ava_1797, Ava_3438, and Ava_4785) were identified through a genome-wide survey in Anabaena variabilis. Biochemical analysis demonstrated that these five putative A. variabilis site-2 proteases (S2Ps(Av)) have authentic protease activities toward an artificial substrate pro-σ(K), a Bacillus subtilis MTF, in our reconstituted Escherichia coli system. The enzymatic activities of processing pro-σ(K) differ among these five S2Ps(Av). Substitution of glutamic acid (E) by glutamine (Q) in the conserved HEXXH zinc-coordinated motif caused the loss of protease activities in these five S2Ps(Av), suggesting that they belonged to the metalloprotease family. Further mapping of the cleaved peptides of pro-σ(K) by Ava_4785 and Ava_1797 revealed that Ava_4785 and Ava_1797 recognized the same cleavage site in pro-σ(K) as SpoIVFB, a cognate S2P of pro-σ(K) from B. subtilis. Taking these results together, we report here for the first time the identification of five metallo-intramembrane cleaving proteases in Anabaena variabilis. The experimental system described herein should be applicable to studies of other RIP events and amenable to developing in vitro assays for I-CLips.

Cystathionine β-synthase (CBS) domains 1 and 2 fulfill different roles in ionic strength sensing of the ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter OpuA

The cystathionine β-synthase module of OpuA in conjunction with an anionic membrane surface acts as a sensor of internal ionic strength, which allows the protein to respond to osmotic stress. We now show by chemical modification and cross-linking studies that CBS2-CBS2 interface residues are critical for transport activity and/or ionic regulation of transport, whereas CBS1 serves no functional role. We establish that Cys residues in CBS1, CBS2, and the nucleotide-binding domain are more accessible for cross-linking at high than low ionic strength, indicating that these domains undergo conformational changes when transiting between the active and inactive state. Structural analyses suggest that the cystathionine β-synthase module is largely unstructured. Moreover, we could substitute CBS1 by a linker and preserve ionic regulation of transport. These data suggest that CBS1 serves as a linker and the structured CBS2-CBS2 interface forms a hinge point for ionic strength-dependent rearrangements that are transmitted to the nucleotide-binding domain and thereby affect translocation activity.

Recent progress in Bacillus subtilis sporulation

The Gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis can initiate the process of sporulation under conditions of nutrient limitation. Here, we review some of the last 5 years of work in this area, with a particular focus on the decision to initiate sporulation, DNA translocation, cell-cell communication, protein localization and spore morphogenesis. The progress we describe has implications not only just for the study of sporulation but also for other biological systems where homologs of sporulation-specific proteins are involved in vegetative growth.

New insights into S2P signaling cascades: regulation, variation, and conservation

Regulated intramembrane proteolysis (RIP) is a conserved mechanism that regulates signal transduction across the membrane by recruiting membrane-bound proteases to cleave membrane-spanning regulatory proteins. As the first identified protease that performs RIP, the metalloprotease site-2 protease (S2P) has received extensive study during the past decade, and an increasing number of S2P-like proteases have been identified and studied in different organisms; however, some of their substrates and the related S1Ps remain elusive. Here, we review recent research on S2P cascades, including human S2P, E. coli RseP, B. subtilis SpoIVFB and the newly identified S2P homologs. We also discuss the variation and conservation of characterized S2P cascades. The conserved catalytic motif of S2P and prevalence of amino acids of low helical propensity in the transmembrane segments of the substrates suggest a conserved catalytic conformation and mechanism within the S2P family. The review also sheds light on future research on S2P cascades.

Hierarchical evolution of the bacterial sporulation network

Genome sequencing of multiple species makes it possible to understand the main principles behind the evolution of developmental regulatory networks. It is especially interesting to analyze the evolution of well-defined model systems in which conservation patterns can be directly correlated with the functional roles of various network components. Endospore formation (sporulation), extensively studied in Bacillus subtilis, is driven by such a model bacterial network of cellular development and differentiation. In this review, we analyze the evolution of the sporulation network in multiple endospore-forming bacteria. Importantly, the network evolution is not random but primarily follows the hierarchical organization and functional logic of the sporulation process. Specifically, the sporulation sigma factors and the master regulator of sporulation, Spo0A, are conserved in all considered spore-formers. The sequential activation of these global regulators is also strongly conserved. The feed-forward loops, which are likely used to fine-tune waves of gene expression within regulatory modules, show an intermediate level of conservation. These loops are less conserved than the sigma factors but significantly more than the structural sporulation genes, which form the lowest level in the functional and evolutionary hierarchy of the sporulation network. Interestingly, in spore-forming bacteria, gene regulation is more conserved than gene presence for sporulation genes, while the opposite is true for non-sporulation genes. The observed patterns suggest that, by understanding the functional organization of a developmental network in a model organism, it is possible to understand the logic behind the evolution of this network in multiple related species.