Evolution of immunoglobulin light chains: cDNA clones specifying sandbar shark constant regions

Shark immune system: A review about their immunoglobulin repertoire

In the past few decades, the literature about the immune system of vertebrates has increased thanks to the research about new therapies and new biomolecules able to treat or eradicate many human autoimmune diseases. Researchers found that immunoglobulins (Igs) are the most versatile biomolecules able to recognize almost every existing epitope with their binding domains. Phylogenetically, the most recent vertebrates exhibit the greatest sequence diversification in their Igs to extend their ability to distinguish different antigens. Among cartilaginous fishes, the most ancient vertebrates on phylogenetic history, sharks possess four types of Igs with similar pathways to extend sequence diversity and binding domains variability. Their Ig new antigen receptor (IgNAR) represents one of the most versatile and small Ig type upon all other species. The shark species are fundamental sources of new therapeutic receptors lending a further step to treatments against several human diseases. The aim of this review is to analyze sharks Igs, focusing on IgNARs for each species.

Antibody Repertoires in Fish

As in mammals, cartilaginous and teleost fishes possess adaptive immune systems based on antigen recognition by immunoglobulins (Ig), T cell receptors (TCR), and major histocompatibility complex molecules (MHC) I and MHC II molecules. Also it is well established that fish B cells and mammalian B cells share many similarities, including Ig gene rearrangements, and production of membrane Ig and secreted Ig forms. This chapter provides an overview of the IgH and IgL chains in cartilaginous and bony fish, including their gene organizations, expression, diversity of their isotypes, and development of the primary repertoire. Furthermore, when possible, we have included summaries of key studies on immune mechanisms such as allelic exclusion, somatic hypermutation, affinity maturation, class switching, and mucosal immune responses.

Molecular characterization and expression analysis of complement component C9 gene in the whitespotted bambooshark, Chiloscyllium plagiosum

Complement system is known as highly sophisticated immune defense mechanism for antigen recognition as well as effector functions. Activation of the terminal pathway of the complement system leads to the assembly of terminal complement complexes (C5b-9), which induces the characteristic complement-mediated cytolysis. The lytic activity of shark complement involves functional analogues of mammalian C8 and C9. In this article, a full-length cDNA of C9 (CpC9) is identified from cartilaginous species, the whitespotted bambooshark, Chiloscyllium plagiosum by RACE. The CpC9 cDNA is 2263 bp in length, encoding a protein of 603 amino acids, which shares 42% and 43% identity with human and Xenopus C9 respectively. Through sequence alignment and comparative analysis, the CpC9 protein was found well conserved, with the typical modular architecture in TCCs and nearly unanimous cysteine composition from fish to mammal. Phylogenetic analysis places it in a clade with C9 orthologs in higher vertebrate and as a sister taxa to the Xenopus. Expression analysis revealed that CpC9 is constitutively highly expressed in shark liver, with much less or even undetectable expression in other tissues; demonstrating liver is the primary tissue for C9synthesis. To sum up, the structural conservation and distinctive phylogenetics might indicate the potentially vital role of CpC9 in shark immune response, though it remains to be confirmed by further study.

Binding of peptides to proteins: an exercise in molecular design

Peptides coupled to solid supports were systematically tested for binding activity with a polyreactive immunoglobulin light chain dimer by the methods of Geysen and colleagues. Once identified, peptides of progressively increasing affinity for the dimer were synthesized in milligram quantities and diffused into crystals of the protein. The three-dimensional structures of the peptide-protein complexes were determined by X-ray analysis and crystallographic refinement. Criteria for the design of ligands to fill the binding cavity in incremental stages could be formulated from the combined results of peptide scanning and crystallographic analyses. Histidine proved to be an important substituent in the binding series. It was possible to manipulate the properties of this amino acid residue to alter the structures and binding patterns of the ligands. For example, if two beta-alanine residues were added to the carboxyl end of a tetrapeptide ligand, the terminal carboxyl group formed an intramolecular ion pair with the imidazolium group (N-3) of histidine. This interaction was accompanied by cleavage of the intra molecular hydrogen bond between N-1 of histidine and the amide group of a glutamine side chain. The shape of the ligand shifted from a compact to an extended form and the mode of binding changed from a lock-and-key to an induced-fit type. The direction of entry of dipeptides of histidine and proline into the binding cavity (normally amino end first) could be reversed (carboxyl end first) by protonation of the histidine ring.

Characterisation of immunoglobulin light chain cDNAs of the Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L.; evidence for three IgL isotypes

By screening a cDNA library and analysis of DNA produced by a combined 3'RACE/5'-anchored PCR, we have isolated three isotypes of IgL in the Atlantic salmon. Two of the isotypes were homologous to rainbow trout IgL1 and L2 sequences, while the third represents a previously uncharacterised salmonid IgL. The novel type 3 CL region is homologous to spotted wolffish c1 and yellowtail sequences, while the VL region is more similar to channel catfish F class than to any other fish VL sequences. Southern analysis indicates that the gene segments of all three isotypes are organised in multiple clusters. In addition, the VL gene segments of type 3 are arranged in opposite orientation relative to the JL and CL segments, while gene segments in type 2 clusters are all in the same orientation. Although transcripts of type 1 and 3 were readily found in the spleen and head kidney, only minute amounts of type 2 transcripts were seen. The majority of type 3 messages were truncated, suggesting that spliced and full-length transcripts of this isotype probably are present at a low level compared to type 1 transcripts. The uniqueness of the type 3 VLJL sequences suggests that this isotype offers additional diversity to the antigen-binding site of Atlantic salmon immunoglobulins.

Structural, antigenic and evolutionary analyses of immunoglobulins and T cell receptors

We have had the pleasure of collaborating with Allen Edmundson for the past 15 years on the structure, binding properties and evolution of immunoglobulins and T cell receptors. Among the most significant contributions of our joint efforts were: (1) the predictive use of structural features of immunoglobulin domains to model the three-dimensional structures of the immunoglobulin domains of human T-cell receptor alpha and beta chains as well as shark light chains and V(H) domains; (2) the finding that normal humans and other vertebrates express autoantibodies against combining site epitopes of their own T cell receptors; (3) the mapping of the peptide autoepitopes recognized in health, autoimmunity and retroviral infection; and (4) the determination that epitope recognition promiscuity is a characteristic property of the combining sites of IgM immunoglobulins ranging from those of sharks to those of humans. We briefly review the salient findings and status of these studies and indicate the future directions that we will pursue in their continuation.

Rearrangement of immunoglobulin genes in shark germ cells

The variable (V), (diversity [D]), and joining (J) region recombinases (recombination activating genes [RAGs]) can perform like transposases and are thought to have initiated development of the adaptive immune system in early vertebrates by splitting archaic V genes with transposable elements. In cartilaginous fishes, the immunoglobulin (Ig) light chain genes are organized as multiple VJ-constant (C) clusters; some loci are capable of rearrangement while others contain fused VJ. The latter may be key to understanding the evolutionary role of RAG. Are they relics of the archaic genes, or are they results of rearrangement in germ cells? Our data suggest that some fused VJ genes are not only recently rearranged, but also resulted from RAG-like activity involving hairpin intermediates. Expression studies show that these, like some other germline-joined Ig sequences, are expressed at significant levels only early in ontogeny. We suggest that a rejoined Ig gene may not merely be a sequence restricting antibody diversity, but is potentially a novel receptor no longer tied to somatic RAG expression and rearrangement. From the combined data, we arrived at the unexpected conclusion that, in some vertebrates, RAG is still an active force in changing the genome.

Junctional diversity in Xenopus immunoglobulin light chains

Xenopus cDNA sequences encoding the homolog of mammalian kappa (kappa) light (L) chains were isolated from isogenic tadpole and adult individuals to investigate whether there existed stage-specific immunoglobulin L chain expression and somatic diversification. In the course of these studies rearrangements to a sixth J(L) gene segment and a pseudogene (J(L)psi) were found, and it is suggested that the order of these gene segments with respect to the L chain constant (C) region exon is: J(L)6-J(L)1-J(L)2-J(L)3-J(L)4-J(L)5-J(L)psi-C(L). The cDNA junctional diversity was analyzed; few N and P regions were found and almost all the CDR3 were 9 codons in length. There were restricted patterns of recombination site resolution, and this is attributed to some constraint in JL coding end processing.

Antibodies of sharks: revolution and evolution

The combinatorial immune response is restricted to jawed vertebrates with cartilaginous fishes being the lowest extant species to have the mechanism for diversification and an extensive panoply of immunoglobulins, T-cell receptors and MHC products. Here, we review the molecular events of the "big bang" or rapid evolutionary appearance of the functionally complete combinatorial immune system coincident with the appearance of ancestral jawed vertebrates, suggesting that this event was catalyzed by horizontal transfer of DNA processing systems. We analyze the nature and extent of variable and constant domain diversity among the distinct immunoglobulin sets of carcharhine sharks focusing upon the lambda-like light chains and the mu and omega heavy chains. The detection and isolation of natural antibodies from the blood of unimmunized sharks illustrates a surprising range of recognition specificities and the existence of polyspecificity suggests that the antibody-forming system of sharks offers unique opportunities for studies of immunological regulation. Although the homologies between shark and mammalian immunoglobulins are unequivocal, major differences in segmental gene organization present challenges to our understanding of basic immunological phenomena such as clonal restriction.

A new high molecular weight immunoglobulin class from the carcharhine shark: implications for the properties of the primordial immunoglobulin

All immunoglobulins and T-cell receptors throughout phylogeny share regions of highly conserved amino acid sequence. To identify possible primitive immunoglobulins and immunoglobulin-like molecules, we utilized 3' RACE (rapid amplification of cDNA ends) and a highly conserved constant region consensus amino acid sequence to isolate a new immunoglobulin class from the sandbar shark Carcharhinus plumbeus. The immunoglobulin, termed IgW, in its secreted form consists of 782 amino acids and is expressed in both the thymus and the spleen. The molecule overall most closely resembles mu chains of the skate and human and a new putative antigen binding molecule isolated from the nurse shark (NAR). The full-length IgW chain has a variable region resembling human and shark heavy-chain (VH) sequences and a novel joining segment containing the WGXGT motif characteristic of H chains. However, unlike any other H-chain-type molecule, it contains six constant (C) domains. The first C domain contains the cysteine residue characteristic of C mu1 that would allow dimerization with a light (L) chain. The fourth and sixth domains also contain comparable cysteines that would enable dimerization with other H chains or homodimerization. Comparison of the sequences of IgW V and C domains shows homology greater than that found in comparisons among VH and C mu or VL, or CL thereby suggesting that IgW may retain features of the primordial immunoglobulin in evolution.

Immunoglobulin light chain class multiplicity and alternative organizational forms in early vertebrate phylogeny

The prototypic chondrichthyan immunoglobulin (Ig) light chain type (type I) isolated from Heterodontus francisci (horned shark) has a clustered organization in which variable (V), joining (J), and constant (C) elements are in relatively close linkage (V-J-C). Using a polymerase chain reaction-based approach on a light chain peptide sequence from the holocephalan, Hydrolagus colliei (spotted ratfish), it was possible to isolate members of a second light chain gene family. A probe to this light chain (type II) detects homologs in two orders of elasmobranchs, Heterodontus, a galeomorph and Raja erinacea (little skate), a batoid, suggesting that this light chain type may be present throughout the cartilaginous fishes. In all cases, V, J, and C regions of the type II gene are arranged in closely linked clusters typical of all known Ig genes in cartilaginous fishes. All representatives of this type II gene family are joined in the germline. A third (kappa-like) light chain type from Heterodontus is described. These findings establish that a degree of light chain class complexity comparable to that of the mammals is present in the most phylogenetically distant extant jawed vertebrates and that the phenomenon of germline-joined (pre-rearranged) genes, described originally in the heavy chain genes of cartilaginous fishes, extends to light chain genes.

Development of an immune system

Minimally, an immune response is an induced cellular and/or humoral defense mechanism specific for the challenging agent. The system is a cognitive one inasmuch as a second stimulus with the same antigen can specifically induce either an enhanced response (memory) or diminished response (tolerance). The cells responsible for the initial antigen-specific recognition in higher vertebrates are clonally restricted T and B lymphocytes. Accessory cells are necessary for the processing and presentation of antigen, and physiologic mediators (cytokines) are essential for proliferation, interaction, and regulation of the system. Although it now appears that the recombination mechanisms essential for the anticipatory immune response occurred late in the deuterostome stream leading to vertebrates, molecules required for cell adhesion and regulation are widely spread in phylogeny. Their emergence must have preceded the divergence between ancestral protostomes and deuterostomes. Genetic mechanisms underlying the generation of diversity in the light and heavy chains of antibodies of mammals may be quite distinct in primitive vertebrates, particularly elasmobranchs, the ancestors of which diverged from those of mammals more than 400 million years ago. Despite this, clonal selection of antigen receptors of lymphocytes is most probably universal within the vertebrates. There is no need to force induced recognition in protostomes (e.g. insects) or lower deuterostomes (e.g. echinoderms) into mammalian models of immunity.

Cell surface recognition and the immunoglobulin superfamily

Immunoglobulins serve as humoral recognition and effector molecules and as antigen-specific cell surface receptors on B and T cells. These molecules are constructed according to a characteristic domain pattern. Variable and constant domains diverged from one another early in vertebrate evolution, and they are joined by a "switch peptide" specified by the joining gene segments. Peptides specified by J-gene segments are strongly conserved in evolution in comparison among Ig light chains and T-cell receptors. Molecules less strongly related to Ig domains have been assembled into an Ig "superfamily" where the identities to classical IgC or V domains are < or = 20%. Among these are cell surface adhesion molecules, receptors for cytokines, and Fc receptors. Moreover, MHC antigens have an Ig-like membrane-proximal domain significantly related to IgC regions. We will analyze putative evolutionary relationships among canonical Igs and members of the Ig superfamily using highly conserved sequences from light and heavy chains of primitive vertebrates (e.g., the sandbar shark) as prototypes to ascertain similarities between Ig-related molecules of vertebrates and invertebrates.

Isolation of a shark immunoglobulin light chain cDNA clone encoding a protein resembling mammalian kappa light chains: implications for the evolution of light chains

The time of emergence of immunoglobulin kappa and lambda light (L) chains in evolution is unknown. An L chain cDNA clone was isolated from the nurse shark (Ginglymostoma cirratum), a cartilaginous fish, whose predicted variable (V) region amino acid sequence has up to 60% sequence identity to mammalian V kappa domains. Genomic analyses suggest a cluster-type gene organization for this L chain locus, similar to the shark lambda-like immunoglobulin L chain loci rather than mammalian kappa loci. We propose that divergence of the ancestral L chain into isotypes likely occurred before the emergence of elasmobranchs 400-450 million years ago. Similarities in gene organization between the two isotypes in sharks may reflect the gene organization utilized by the ancestral L chain.

Genomic clone for sandbar shark lambda light chain: generation of diversity in the absence of gene rearrangement

While the general structure of immunoglobulin chains has remained relatively unchanged throughout evolution, the organization of the genes encoding these molecules differs substantially. To understand how the rearranging immunoglobulin system arose, it is necessary to examine living representatives of the most early vertebrate phyla. Elasmo-branches, which include the sharks, skates, and rays, are the most primitive phylogenetic class of vertebrates from which immunoglobulin DNA sequences have been obtained. In the sandbar shark (Carcharhinus plumbeus), the genes are arranged in individual clusters in which a single variable (V), joining (J), and constant (C) region gene, along with upstream regulatory elements, span a distance of approximately 4.4 kb or approximately 5.8 kb. We report the complete sequence of a genomic clone encoding sandbar shark lambda light chain. A unique finding of our study is that the V and J genes are fused in the germ line. Three additional clones have been shown by DNA sequencing to also have fused V and J genes. The four clones have complementarity-determining regions 3 of various lengths and amino acid sequence variability similar to the products of rearranged genes. Furthermore, analysis by polymerase chain reaction technology revealed an additional 26 genomic clones demonstrating fusion of the V and J segments. Therefore, VJ fusion is the prominent organizational feature of sandbar shark immunoglobulin light chain genes. This finding raises questions concerning the necessity of recombination to produce an antibody repertoire capable of reacting against a diverse array of antigens.

Phylogeny of immunoglobulin heavy chain isotypes: structure of the constant region of Ambystoma mexicanum upsilon chain deduced from cDNA sequence

An RNA polymerase chain reaction strategy was used to amplify and clone a cDNA segment encoding for the complete constant part of the axolotl IgY heavy (C upsilon) chain. C upsilon is 433 amino acids long and organized into four domains (C upsilon 1-C upsilon 4); each has the typical internal disulfide bond and invariant tryptophane residues. Axolotl C upsilon is most closely related to Xenopus C upsilon (40% identical amino acid residues) and C upsilon 1 shares 46.4% amino acid residues among these species. The presence of additional cysteines in C upsilon 1 and C upsilon 2 domains is consistent with an additional intradomain S-S bond similar to that suggested for Xenopus C upsilon and C chi, and for the avian C upsilon and the human C epsilon. C upsilon 4 ends with the Gly-Lys dipeptide characteristic of secreted mammalian C gamma 3, human C epsilon 4, and avian and anuran C upsilon 4, and contains the consensus [G/GT(AA)] nucleotide splice signal sequence for joining C upsilon 4 to the transmembrane region. These results are consistent with the hypothesis of an ancestral structural relationship between amphibian, avian upsilon chains, and mammalian epsilon chains. However, these molecules have different biological properties: axolotl IgY is secretory Ig, anuran and avian IgY behave like mammalian IgG, and mammalian IgE is implicated in anaphylactic reactions.

A cluster type organization of the loci of the immunoglobulin light chain in Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua L.) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss Walbaum) indicated by nucleotide sequences of cDNAs and hybridization analysis

Antibody screening and colony hybridization of cDNA libraries have been used to isolate clones of the immunoglobulin light (IgL) chain from Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua L.) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss Walbaum). Sequence analysis shows dissimilarities in the constant part of the molecule (CL) within each species. Comparisons of the amino acid sequences of the constant parts of the IgL chains show a 55% identity between the two teleost species. When compared with other species the highest similarities are found to the constant domain of the IgL chain from mammals (30%-37%), but the teleost IgL chain can be classified neither as kappa nor lambda. The VL domain in Atlantic cod and rainbow trout is also more similar to those of mammals than to those of other animal species, but no difference between kappa and lambda was noticed. Genomic Southern blots hybridized with fragments coding for the constant part of IgL gave several bands larger than 2 kilobases and a similar pattern was obtained with fragments coding for the variable part. These results show that the locus of the IgL chain has a multiple organization in teleost fish and that the locus has an organization similar to that of sharks. Several of the cDNA clones isolated from both the head kidney and the spleen represent nonrearranged or nonspliced mRNA, and northern blot analysis shows that such transcripts are present in both the head kidney and the spleen.

Complete sequence of a cDNA clone specifying sandbar shark immunoglobulin light chain: gene organization and implications for the evolution of light chains

A full-length cDNA clone specifying sandbar shark (Carcharhinus plumbeus) immunoglobulin light chain has been isolated and sequenced. By alignment with human lambda chains, the leader, framework, complementarity-determining, joining, and constant regions are clearly identified in the shark light chain. Approximately 40-50% identity is shared between the human and shark sequences in the variable and constant regions. We have performed sequence comparisons of the individual segments and constructed phylogenetic trees for the variable region. These studies identify the shark protein as a lambda chain. In addition, the sandbar shark light chain is only distantly related to that of horned shark (Heterodontus francisci) [Shamblott, M. J. & Litman, G. W. (1989) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86, 4684-4688], demonstrating that the long evolutionary time of divergence among shark species has led to the generation of substantial differences in sequence. The positions of the variable, joining, and constant gene segments in 14 genomic clones have been mapped. The segments are linked in individual clusters (variable, joining, constant) occupying 3-7 kilobases. Cluster arrangement can be grouped into two patterns based upon spacing between the genes in the individual clones. This arrangement is fundamentally different from that observed in higher vertebrates.