Augmented DNA-binding activity of p53 protein encoded by a carboxyl-terminal alternatively spliced mRNA is blocked by p53 protein encoded by the regularly spliced form

p53 Isoforms: An Intracellular Microprocessor?

Normal function of the p53 pathway is ubiquitously lost in cancers either through mutation or inactivating interaction with viral or cellular proteins. However, it is difficult in clinical studies to link p53 mutation status to cancer treatment and clinical outcome, suggesting that the p53 pathway is not fully understood. We have recently reported that the human p53 gene expresses not only 1 but 12 different p53 proteins (isoforms) due to alternative splicing, alternative initiation of translation, and alternative promoter usage. p53 isoform proteins thus contain distinct protein domains. They are expressed in normal human tissues but are abnormally expressed in a wide range of cancer types. We have recently reported that p53 isoform expression is associated with breast cancer prognosis, suggesting that they play a role in carcinogenesis. Indeed, the cellular response to damages can be switched from cell cycle arrest to apoptosis by only manipulating p53 isoform expression. This may provide an explanation to the hitherto inconsistent relationship between p53 mutation, treatment response, and outcome in breast cancer. However, the molecular mechanism is still unknown. Recent reports suggest that it involves modulation of gene expression in a p53-dependent and -independent manner. In this review, we summarize our current knowledge about the biological activities of p53 isoforms and propose a molecular mechanism conciliating our current knowledge on p53 and integrating p63 and p73 isoforms in the p53 pathway.

Wild-type p53 in cancer cells: when a guardian turns into a blackguard

The tumor suppressor p53 controls a broad range of cellular responses. Induction of a transient (cell cycle arrest) or a permanent (senescence) block of cell proliferation, or the activation of cell death pathways in response to genotoxic stress comprise the major arms of the survival-death axis governed by p53. Due to these biological properties, inactivation of p53 is a crucial step in tumor development and progression, reflected by the high incidence of TP53 mutations in different types of human cancers. The remarkable potency of p53 in suppressing tumorigenic outgrowth has promoted the expectation that tumor cells expressing wild-type p53 (wtp53) should be more prone to elimination by cytotoxic treatments than tumor cells expressing mutant p53 (mutp53) with defunct wtp53 activities. However, recent findings yielded somewhat unexpected insights concerning the preponderance of the survival-promoting effects of wtp53 in cancer cells, a rather undesired property from the therapeutic point of view. In this commentary we will discuss the possibility that the developmentally established distinct patterns of wtp53 mediated responses in different tissues are an important factor in determining the ultimate outcome of cellular responses mediated by wtp53 in different types of tumor cells, with a particular focus on the divergent impact of wtp53 in malignant tumors of the central nervous system. We infer that a selective gain of pro-survival functions of wtp53 in cancer cells will confer a survival advantage that counteracts tumor therapy.

Spliced Isoforms of LIM-Domain-Binding Protein (CLIM/NLI/Ldb) Lacking the LIM-Interaction Domain

LIM-domain-binding proteins (CLIM/NLI/Ldb) are nuclear cofactors for LIM homeodomain transcription factors (LIM-HDs) and LIM-only proteins (LMOs). The LIM-interaction domain (LID) of Ldb is located in the carboxy-terminal region and encoded by the last exon (exon 10) of Ldb genes. It is known that the mammalian CLIM1/Ldb2 gene has a splice isoform, named CLIM1b, lacking the LID. However, little is known about the nature of CLIM1b or the evolutionary conservation of this type of alternative splicing in amphibians and teleost fish. Here, we demonstrate that splice isoforms lacking the LID are also present in the Ldb1 genes of mammals, chick, and Xenopus, as well as in fish paralog Ldb4. All these splicing variations occur in intron 9 and exon 10. We observed that Ldb4b (splice isoform lacking LID) is localized in the nucleus when expressed in mammalian culture cells, and binds to Ldb4a (splice isoform containing LID) but not directly to LIM proteins. However, Ldb4b binds to LMO4 via Ldb4a when coexpressed in culture cells. We also found that mouse Ldb1b lacks the ability to activate protein 4.2 promoter, which is stimulated by LMO2 and Ldb1. These findings suggest that splice isoforms of Ldb lacking LID are potential regulators of Ldb function.

Function of alternative splicing

Alternative splicing is one of the most important mechanisms to generate a large number of mRNA and protein isoforms from the surprisingly low number of human genes. Unlike promoter activity, which primarily regulates the amount of transcripts, alternative splicing changes the structure of transcripts and their encoded proteins. Together with nonsense-mediated decay (NMD), at least 25% of all alternative exons are predicted to regulate transcript abundance. Molecular analyses during the last decade demonstrate that alternative splicing determines the binding properties, intracellular localization, enzymatic activity, protein stability and posttranslational modifications of a large number of proteins. The magnitude of the effects range from a complete loss of function or acquisition of a new function to very subtle modulations, which are observed in the majority of cases reported. Alternative splicing factors regulate multiple pre-mRNAs and recent identification of physiological targets shows that a specific splicing factor regulates pre-mRNAs with coherent biological functions. Therefore, evidence is now accumulating that alternative splicing coordinates physiologically meaningful changes in protein isoform expression and is a key mechanism to generate the complex proteome of multicellular organisms.

p53 protein variants: structural and functional similarities with p63 and p73 isoforms

Since its discovery in 1979, many studies have reported that the p53 tumour suppressor protein could be expressed in the form of products smaller than those predicted by the full-length amino-acid sequence. These products differ from full-length p53 in their N- or C-terminal regions, but generally conserve the central, DNA-binding domain. They appear to be expressed at rather low levels and to be restricted to particular cell types and/or physiological circumstances, suggesting that they play very narrow and specific roles. Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain their timely occurrence, including alternative splicing, internal initiation of translation or proteolytic cleavage. A precise assessment of the various 'p53 isoforms' reveals striking similarities with several isoforms of the p53 homologous proteins p63 or p73, suggesting that regulated production of specific, N- or C-terminal variants may be a 'trademark' of all family members. In this review, we summarize the published evidence on the structure, mode of production, expression and function of the p53 isoforms, and discuss their properties in the light of recent data on the structure and function of p63/p73 isoforms.

Links between tumor suppressors: p53 is required for TGF-beta gene responses by cooperating with Smads

The p53 tumor suppressor belongs to a family of proteins that sense multiple cellular inputs to regulate cell proliferation, apoptosis, and differentiation. Whether and how these functions of p53 intersect with the activity of extracellular growth factors is not understood. Here, we report that key cellular responses to TGF-beta signals rely on p53 family members. During Xenopus embryonic development, p53 promotes the activation of multiple TGF-beta target genes. Moreover, mesoderm differentiation is inhibited in p53-depleted embryos. In mammalian cells, the full transcriptional activation of the CDK inhibitor p21(WAF1) by TGF-beta requires p53. p53-deficient cells display an impaired cytostatic response to TGF-beta signals. Smad and p53 protein complexes converge on separate cis binding elements on a target promoter and synergistically activate TGF-beta induced transcription. p53 can physically interact in vivo with Smad2 in a TGF-beta-dependent fashion. The results unveil a previously unrecognized link between two primary tumor suppressor pathways in vertebrates.

DNA binding and 3'-5' exonuclease activity in the murine alternatively-spliced p53 protein

In this study we show that the naturally occurring C-terminally alternative spliced p53 (referred to as AS-p53) is active as a sequence-specific DNA binding protein as well as a 3'-5'-exonuclease in the presence of Mg2+ ions. The two activities are positively correlated as the sequence-specific DNA target is more efficiently degraded than a non-specific target. In contrast, a mutated AS-p53 protein that is deficient in DNA binding lacks exonuclease activity. The use of modified p53 binding sites, where the 3'-phosphate is replaced by a phosphorothioate group, enabled the inhibition of DNA degradation under the binding conditions. We demonstrate that AS-p53 interacts with its specific DNA target by two distinct binding modes: a high-affinity mode characterized by a low-mobility protein-DNA complex at the nanomolar range, and a low-affinity mode shown by a high-mobility complex at the micromolar range. Comparison of the data on the natural and the modified p53 binding sites suggests that the high-affinity mode is related to AS-p53 function as a transcription factor and that the low-affinity mode is associated with its exonuclease activity. The implications of these findings to a specific cellular role of AS-p53 are discussed.

The C-terminus of mutant p53 is necessary for its ability to interfere with growth arrest or apoptosis

The ability to suppress wild type p53-independent apoptosis may play an important role in the oncogenicity of p53 mutant proteins. However, structural elements necessary for this activity are unknown. Furthermore, it is unclear whether this mutant p53 mediated inhibition is specific to the apoptotic pathway or a more general suppression of the cellular response to stress. We observed that an unmodified C-terminus was required for the suppression of apoptosis by the p53 135(Ala to Val) oncogenic p53 mutant. It was also required for the novel activity of G2 arrest suppression, the predominant response at low levels of genotoxic stress. These observations are consistent with a model whereby mutant p53 suppressive activity is not specific to the apoptotic pathway, but rather increases the threshold of genotoxic stress needed for a DNA damage response to occur. Furthermore, these observations indicate that it may be possible to selectively kill mutant p53 expressing cells based on the lower sensitivity of their growth arrest response.

Generation of oscillations by the p53-Mdm2 feedback loop: a theoretical and experimental study

The intracellular activity of the p53 tumor suppressor protein is regulated through a feedback loop involving its transcriptional target, mdm2. We present a simple mathematical model suggesting that, under certain circumstances, oscillations in p53 and Mdm2 protein levels can emerge in response to a stress signal. A delay in p53-dependent induction of Mdm2 is predicted to be required, albeit not sufficient, for this oscillatory behavior. In line with the predictions of the model, oscillations of both p53 and Mdm2 indeed occur on exposure of various cell types to ionizing radiation. Such oscillations may allow cells to repair their DNA without risking the irreversible consequences of continuous excessive p53 activation.

p53-dependent apoptosis is regulated by a C-terminally alternatively spliced form of murine p53

It is now well accepted that the p53 C-terminus plays a central role in controlling the activity of the wild-type molecule. In our previous studies, we observed that a C-terminally altered p53 protein (p53AS), generated by an alternative spliced p53 mRNA, induces an attenuated p53-dependent apoptosis, compared to that induced by the regularly spliced form (p53RS). In the present study we analysed the interrelationships between these two physiological variants of wild-type p53, and found that in cells co-expressing both forms, in contrast to the expected additive effect on the induction of apoptosis, p53AS inhibits apoptosis induced by p53RS. This inhibitory effect is specific for p53-dependent apoptosis and was not evident in a p53-independent apoptotic pathway induced by growth factor deprivation. Furthermore, the expression of p53AS in transiently transfected cells caused both inhibition of apoptosis and inhibition of the p53RS-dependent transactivation of a number of p53 target genes. These results suggest that expression of an alternatively spliced p53 form may serve as an additional level in controlling the complexity of p53 function by the C-terminal domain.

Species-specific regulation of alternative splicing in the C-terminal region of the p53 tumor suppressor gene

Alternative splicing occurs in the C-terminal region of the p53 tumor suppressor gene between two alternative 3' splice sites in intron 10. This alternative splicing event has been detected in murine cells, but not in rat or human tissues. In this paper, we have characterized the pattern of p53 alternative splicing in cell lines from five different species. Our results confirm that p53 alternative splicing is species-specific, being detected only in cell lines of rodent origin. Using transient transfection assays, we have established that the rat p53 gene undergoes efficient alternative splicing in both mouse and rat cell lines, thus demonstrating that it has all the necessary cis -acting sequences to be alternatively spliced. In contrast, we were unable to detect any usage of the human alternative 3' splice site under the same experimental conditions. Thus, the low levels or absence of alternatively spliced p53 mRNA in rat and human cell lines seems to be the result of different mechanisms. Our results support the hypothesis that there are species-specific mechanisms implicated in the regulation of p53 activity.

Regulation of the p53 protein by protein kinase C alpha and protein kinase C zeta

The C-terminal of p53 (amino-acids 368-383) represses the DNA binding activity of p53. In vitro, phosphorylation of this region by Protein Kinase C (PKC) is associated with increased DNA binding activity. However, whether PKC can directly modulate p53 function in vivo is not known. Here, we demonstrate that cotransfection of p53 with either PKC alpha or PKC zeta increases p53's transcriptional activity. Mutagenesis of p53 indicates that serine 371 is the major site for phosphorylation by PKC alpha in vitro. Mutation of serine 371 caused a small decline in p53 activation by PKC alpha and PKC zeta. However, the alternatively spliced murine p53, which lacks the PKC phosphorylation sites, still demonstrated increased transcriptional activation when cotransfected with either PKC alpha or PKC zeta. The results indicate that phosphorylation of p53 by PKC in vitro does not correlate with the ability of PKC to upregulate p53's transcriptional activity in vivo.

Activities and response to DNA damage of latent and active sequence-specific DNA binding forms of mouse p53

The mouse p53 protein generated by alternative splicing (p53as) has amino acid substitutions at its C terminus that result in constitutively active sequence-specific DNA binding (active form), whereas p53 protein itself binds inefficiently (latent form) unless activated by C-terminal modification. Exogenous p53as expression activated transcription of reporter plasmids containing p53 binding sequences and inhibited growth of mouse and human cells lacking functional endogenous p53. Inducible p53as in stably transfected p53 null fibroblasts increased p21(WAF1/Cip-1/Sdi) and decreased bcl-2 protein steady-state levels. Endogenous p53as and p53 proteins differed in response to cellular DNA damage. p53 protein was induced transiently in normal keratinocytes and fibroblasts whereas p53as protein accumulation was sustained in parallel with induction of p21(WAF1/Cip-1/Sdi) protein and mRNA, in support of p53as transcriptional activity. Endogenous p53 and p53as proteins in epidermal tumor cells responded to DNA damage with different kinetics of nuclear accumulation and efficiencies of binding to a p53 consensus DNA sequence. A model is proposed in which C-terminally distinct p53 protein forms specialize in functions, with latent p53 forms primarily for rapid non-sequence-specific binding to sites of DNA damage and active p53 forms for sustained regulation of transcription and growth.

DNA binding specificity of proteins derived from alternatively spliced mouse p53 mRNAs

The mouse p53 gene generates two alternative splice products encoding p53 protein and a naturally occurring protein (p53as) with changes at the C-terminus. In p53as the negative regulatory region for DNA binding and PAb421 antibody binding site are replaced, and p53as is constitutively active for sequence-specific DNA binding. Using the technique of randomized synthetic oligonucleotide in cyclic amplification and selection of targets, we have found that p53as and p53 proteins have the same DNA binding specificities but that these specificities frequently diverge from the consensus of two copies of PuPuPuCATGPyPyPy. The importance of tetranucleotide CATG was confirmed but there was a less rigorous requirement for patterns of flanking or intervening sequences. In particular, the three purines upstream and three pyrimidines downstream of CATG are not required for p53 or p53as binding, 29 or more intervening nucleotides are tolerated, and one CATG is sufficient where adjacent nucleotides contain a region of homology with certain previously reported non-consensus p53 binding sequences. These results suggested further definition of the non-consensus motifs, and database searches with these uncovered additional candidate genes for p53 protein binding. We conclude that p53as and perhaps other activated forms of p53 exert their effects on the same genes and that differential activities of p53 protein forms are not due to inherently different sequence selectivities of DNA binding.

Complex formation between p53 and replication protein A inhibits the sequence-specific DNA binding of p53 and is regulated by single-stranded DNA

Human replication protein A (RP-A) (also known as human single-stranded DNA binding protein, or HSSB) is a multisubunit complex involved in both DNA replication and repair. Potentially important to both these functions, it is also capable of complex formation with the tumor suppressor protein p53. Here we show that although p53 is unable to prevent RP-A from associating with a range of single-stranded DNAs in solution, RP-A is able to strongly inhibit p53 from functioning as a sequence-specific DNA binding protein when the two proteins are complexed. This inhibition, in turn, can be regulated by the presence of various lengths of single-stranded DNAs, as RP-A, when bound to these single-stranded DNAs, is unable to interact with p53. Interestingly, the lengths of single-stranded DNA capable of relieving complex formation between the two proteins represent forms that might be introduced through repair and replicative events. Increasing p53 concentrations can also overcome the inhibition by steady-state levels of RP-A, potentially mimicking cellular points of balance. Finally, it has been shown previously that p53 can itself be stimulated for site-specific DNA binding when complexed through the C terminus with short single strands of DNA, and here we show that p53 stays bound to these short strands even after binding a physiologically relevant site. These results identify a potential dual role for single-stranded DNA in the regulation of DNA binding by p53 and give insights into the p53 response to DNA damage.

The murine C'-terminally alternatively spliced form of p53 induces attenuated apoptosis in myeloid cells

The onset of p53-dependent apoptosis results from the accumulation of damaged DNA. Recently, it was shown that the C' terminus of the p53 protein plays a central role in sensing damaged DNA. In our present study, we examined the role of the C' terminus in the induction of apoptosis. A temperature-sensitive (ts) mutant of the alternatively spliced form of p53 (p53AS-ts) and the ts mutant of the regularly spliced form (p53RS-ts) were used to generate series of stable clones with increasing amounts of p53 protein. Apoptotic patterns induced by either the regularly spliced p53 product (p53RS) or a C'-terminally alternatively spliced p53 product (p53AS) were compared. We found that although both forms of p53 induced apoptosis following expression of the wild-type protein conformation, the kinetics were different. Apoptosis induced by the p53AS protein was attenuated compared to that induced by p53RS. The delay in the manifestation of the apoptotic features following p53AS expression was in agreement with a delay in the regulation of the expression of apoptosis-related genes. The observation that p53 with an altered C' terminus is still capable of inducing apoptosis suggests that the actual onset of the apoptotic process most probably involves structural domains other than the C' terminus of the p53 molecule. However, the fact that the apoptotic activity mediated by the p53AS product was slower than that mediated by the p53RS product suggests that the C' terminus indeed exerts a certain control on the apoptotic activity of the p53 molecule.

The XPB and XPD DNA helicases are components of the p53-mediated apoptosis pathway

The molecular pathway of p53-dependent apoptosis (programmed cell death) is poorly understood. Because p53 binds to the basal transcription-repair complex TFIIH and modulates its DNA helicase activities, we hypothesized that TFIIH DNA helicases XPB and XPD are members of the p53-mediated apoptotic pathway. Whereas transfer of a wild-type p53 expression vector by microinjection or retroviral infection into primary normal human fibroblasts resulted in apoptosis, primary fibroblasts from individuals with xeroderma pigmentosum (XP), who are deficient in DNA repair and have germ-line mutations in the XPB or XPD gene, but not in the XPA or XPC gene, have a deficiency in the apoptotic response. This deficiency can be rescued by transferring the wild-type XPB or XPD gene into the corresponding mutant cells. XP-D lymphocytes also have a decreased apoptotic response to DNA damage by adriamycin, indicating a physiologically relevant deficiency. The XP-B or XP-D mutant cells undergo a normal apoptotic response when microinjected with the Ich-L, and ICE genes. Analyses of p53 mutants and the effects of microinjected anti-p53 antibody, Pab421, indicate that the carboxyl terminus of p53 may be required for apoptosis. Direct microinjection of the p53 carboxy-terminal-derived peptide (amino acid residues 319-393) resulted in apoptosis of primary normal human fibroblasts. These results disclose a novel pathway of p53-induced apoptosis.

p53: puzzle and paradigm

Collapse