Distinctive roles of the two ATP-binding sites in ClpA, the ATPase component of protease Ti in Escherichia coli

Expression and function of clpS and clpA in Xanthomonas campestris pv. campestris

ATP-dependent proteases (FtsH, Lon, and Clp family proteins) are ubiquitous in bacteria and play essential roles in numerous regulatory cell processes. Xanthomonas campestris pv. campestris is a Gram-negative pathogen that can cause black rot diseases in crucifers. The genome of X. campestris pv. campestris has several clp genes, namely, clpS, clpA, clpX, clpP, clpQ, and clpY. Among these genes, only clpX and clpP is known to be required for pathogenicity. Here, we focused on two uncharacterized clp genes (clpS and clpA) that encode the adaptor (ClpS) and ATPase subunit (ClpA) of the ClpAP protease complex. Transcriptional analysis revealed that the expression of clpS and clpA was growth phase-dependent and affected by the growth temperature. The inactivation of clpA, but not of clpS, resulted in susceptibility to high temperature and attenuated virulence in the host plant. The altered phenotypes of the clpA mutant could be complemented in trans. Site-directed mutagenesis revealed that K223 and K504 were the amino acid residues critical for ClpA function in heat tolerance. The protein expression profile shown by the clpA mutant in response to heat stress was different from that exhibited by the wild type. In summary, we characterized two clp genes (clpS and clpA) by examining their expression profiles and functions in different processes, including stress tolerance and pathogenicity. We demonstrated that clpS and clpA were expressed in a temperature-dependent manner and that clpA was required for the survival at high temperature and full virulence of X. campestris pv. campestris. This work represents the first time that clpS and clpA were characterized in Xanthomonas.

Modular and coordinated activity of AAA+ active sites in the double-ring ClpA unfoldase of the ClpAP protease

Understanding of how ClpA and other double-ring AAA+ enzymes perform mechanical work is limited. Using site-specific cross-linking and mutagenesis, we introduced ATPase-inactive AAA+ modules at alternating positions in individual ClpA rings, or in both rings, to investigate potential active-site coordination during ClpAP degradation. ClpA variants containing alternating active/inactive ATPase modules processively unfolded, translocated, and supported ClpP degradation of protein substrates with energetic efficiencies similar to, or higher than, completely active ClpA. These results impact current models describing the mechanisms of AAA+ family enzymes. The cross-linking/mutagenesis method we employed will also be useful for answering other structure-function questions about ClpA and related double-ring enzymes.

ClpA is a hexameric double-ring AAA+ unfoldase/translocase that functions with the ClpP peptidase to degrade proteins that are damaged or unneeded. How the 12 ATPase active sites of ClpA, 6 in the D1 ring and 6 in the D2 ring, work together to fuel ATP-dependent degradation is not understood. We use site-specific cross-linking to engineer ClpA hexamers with alternating ATPase-active and ATPase-inactive modules in the D1 ring, the D2 ring, or both rings to determine if these active sites function together. Our results demonstrate that D2 modules coordinate with D1 modules and ClpP during mechanical work. However, there is no requirement for adjacent modules in either ring to be active for efficient enzyme function. Notably, ClpAP variants with just three alternating active D2 modules are robust protein translocases and function with double the energetic efficiency of ClpAP variants with completely active D2 rings. Although D2 is the more powerful motor, three or six active D1 modules are important for high enzyme processivity, which depends on D1 and D2 acting coordinately. These results challenge sequential models of ATP hydrolysis and coupled mechanical work by ClpAP and provide an engineering strategy that will be useful in testing other aspects of ClpAP mechanism.

ATP hydrolysis inactivating Walker B mutation perturbs E. coli ClpA self-assembly energetics in the absence of nucleotide

E. coli ClpA is an AAA+ (ATPase Associated with diverse cellular Activities) chaperone that catalyzes the ATP-dependent unfolding and translocation of substrate proteins for the purposes of proper proteome maintenance. Biologically active ClpA hexamers contain two nucleotide binding domains (NBD) per protomer, D1 and D2. Despite extensive study, complete understanding of how the twelve NBDs within a ClpA hexamer coordinate ATP binding and hydrolysis to polypeptide translocation is currently lacking. To examine nucleotide binding and coordination at D1 and D2, ClpA Walker B variants deficient in ATP hydrolysis at one or both NBDs have been employed in various studies. In the presence of ATP, it is widely assumed that ClpA Walker B variants are entirely hexameric. However, a thermodynamically rigorous examination of the self-assembly mechanism has not been obtained. Differences in the assembly due to the mutation can be misattributed to the active NBD, leading to potential misinterpretations of kinetic studies. Here we use sedimentation velocity studies to quantitatively examine the self-assembly mechanism of ClpA Walker B variants deficient in ATP hydrolysis at D1, D2, and both NBDs. We found that the Walker B mutations had clear, if modest, effects on the assembly. Most notably, the Walker B mutation stabilizes the population of a larger oligomer in the absence of nucleotide, that is not present for analogous concentrations of wild type ClpA. Our results indicate that Walker B mutants, widely used in studies of AAA+ family proteins, require additional characterization as the mutation affects not only ATP hydrolysis, but also the ligand linked assembly of these complexes. This linkage must be considered in investigations of unfolding or other ATP dependent functions.

Disaggregases, molecular chaperones that resolubilize protein aggregates

The process of folding is a seminal event in the life of a protein, as it is essential for proper protein function and therefore cell physiology. Inappropriate folding, or misfolding, can not only lead to loss of function, but also to the formation of protein aggregates, an insoluble association of polypeptides that harm cell physiology, either by themselves or in the process of formation. Several biological processes have evolved to prevent and eliminate the existence of non-functional and amyloidogenic aggregates, as they are associated with several human pathologies. Molecular chaperones and heat shock proteins are specialized in controlling the quality of the proteins in the cell, specifically by aiding proper folding, and dissolution and clearance of already formed protein aggregates. The latter is a function of disaggregases, mainly represented by the ClpB/Hsp104 subfamily of molecular chaperones, that are ubiquitous in all organisms but, surprisingly, have no orthologs in the cytosol of metazoan cells. This review aims to describe the characteristics of disaggregases and to discuss the function of yeast Hsp104, a disaggregase that is also involved in prion propagation and inheritance.

Linked domain architectures allow for specialization of function in the FtsK/SpoIIIE ATPases of ESX secretion systems

Among protein secretion systems, there are specialized ATPases that serve different functions such as substrate recognition, substrate unfolding, and assembly of the secretory machinery. ESX (early secretory antigen target 6 kDa secretion) protein secretion systems require FtsK/SpoIIIE family ATPases but the specific function of these ATPases is poorly understood. The ATPases of ESX secretion systems have a unique domain architecture among proteins of the FtsK/SpoIIIE family. All well-studied FtsK family ATPases to date have one ATPase domain and oligomerize to form a functional molecular machine, most commonly a hexameric ring. In contrast, the ESX ATPases have three ATPase domains, encoded either by a single gene or by two operonic genes. It is currently unknown which of the ATPase domains is catalytically functional and whether each domain plays the same or a different function. Here we focus on the ATPases of two ESX systems, the ESX-1 system of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and the yuk system of Bacillus subtilis. We show that ATP hydrolysis by the ESX ATPase is required for secretion, suggesting that this enzyme at least partly fuels protein translocation. We further show that individual ATPase domains play distinct roles in substrate translocation and complex formation. Comparing the single-chain and split ESX ATPases, we reveal differences in the requirements of these unique secretory ATPases.

Both ATPase domains of ClpA are critical for processing of stable protein structures

ClpA is a ring-shaped hexameric chaperone that binds to both ends of the protease ClpP and catalyzes the ATP-dependent unfolding and translocation of substrate proteins through its central pore into the ClpP cylinder. Here we study the relevance of ATP hydrolysis in the two ATPase domains of ClpA. We designed ClpA Walker B variants lacking ATPase activity in the first (D1) or the second ATPase domain (D2) without impairing ATP binding. We found that the two ATPase domains of ClpA operate independently even in the presence of the protease ClpP or the adaptor protein ClpS. Notably, ATP hydrolysis in the first ATPase module is sufficient to process a small, single domain protein of low stability. Substrate proteins of moderate local stability were efficiently processed when D1 was inactivated. However, ATP hydrolysis in both domains was required for efficiently processing substrates of high local stability. Furthermore, we provide evidence for the ClpS-dependent directional translocation of N-end rule substrates from the N to C terminus and propose a mechanistic model for substrate handover from the adaptor protein to the chaperone.

The molecular chaperone Hsp104--a molecular machine for protein disaggregation

At the Cold Spring Harbor Meeting on 'Molecular Chaperones and the Heat Shock Response' in May 1996, Susan Lindquist presented evidence that a chaperone of yeast termed Hsp104, which her group had been investigating for several years, is able to dissolve protein aggregates (Glover, J.R., Lindquist, S., 1998. Hsp104, Hsp70, and Hsp40: a novel chaperone system that rescues previously aggregated proteins. Cell 94, 73-82). Among many of the participants this news stimulated reactions reaching from decided skepticism to utter disbelief because protein aggregation was widely considered to be an irreversible process. Several years and publications later, it is undeniable that Susan had been right. Hsp104 is an ATP dependent molecular machine that-in cooperation with Hsp70 and Hsp40-extracts polypeptide chains from protein aggregates and facilitates their refolding, although the molecular details of this process are still poorly understood. Meanwhile, close homologues of Hsp104 have been identified in bacteria (ClpB), in mitochondria (Hsp78), and in the cytosol of plants (Hsp101), but intriguingly not in the cytosol of animal cells (Mosser, D.D., Ho, S., Glover, J.R., 2004. Saccharomyces cerevisiae Hsp104 enhances the chaperone capacity of human cells and inhibits heat stress-induced proapoptotic signaling. Biochemistry 43, 8107-8115). Observations that Hsp104 plays an essential role in the maintenance of yeast prions (see review by James Shorter in this issue) have attracted even more attention to the molecular mechanism of this ATP dependent chaperone (Chernoff, Y.O., Lindquist, S.L., Ono, B., Inge-Vechtomov, S.G., Liebman, S.W., 1995. Role of the chaperone protein Hsp104 in propagation of the yeast prion-like factor [PSI+]. Science 268, 880-884).

Roles of the N-domains of the ClpA Unfoldase in Binding Substrate Proteins and in Stable Complex Formation with the ClpP Protease

The hexameric cylindrical Hsp100 chaperone ClpA mediates ATP-dependent unfolding and translocation of recognized substrate proteins into the coaxially associated serine protease ClpP. Each subunit of ClpA is composed of an N-terminal domain of approximately 150 amino acids at the top of the cylinder followed by two AAA+ domains. In earlier studies, deletion of the N-domain was shown to have no effect on the rate of unfolding of substrate proteins bearing a C-terminal ssrA tag, but it did reduce the rate of degradation of these proteins (Lo, J. H., Baker, T. A., and Sauer, R. T. (2001) Protein Sci. 10, 551-559; Singh, S. K., Rozycki, J., Ortega, J., Ishikawa, T., Lo, J., Steven, A. C., and Maurizi, M. R. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 29420-29429). Here we demonstrate, using both fluorescence resonance energy transfer to measure the arrival of substrate at ClpP and competition between wild-type and an inactive mutant form of ClpP, that this effect on degradation is caused by diminished stability of the ClpA-ClpP complex during translocation and proteolysis, effectively disrupting the targeting of unfolded substrates to the protease. We have also examined two larger ssrA-tagged substrates, CFP-GFP-ssrA and luciferase-ssrA, and observed different behaviors. CFP-GFP-ssrA is not efficiently unfolded by the truncated chaperone whereas luciferase-ssrA is, suggesting that the former requires interaction with the N-domains, likely via the body of the protein, to stabilize its binding. Thus, the N-domains play a key allosteric role in complex formation with ClpP and may also have a critical role in recognizing certain tag elements and binding some substrate proteins.

Crystal structure of ClpX molecular chaperone from Helicobacter pylori

ClpX, a heat shock protein 100 chaperone, which acts as the regulatory subunit of the ATP-dependent ClpXP protease, is responsible for intracellular protein remodeling and degradation. To provide a structural basis for a better understanding of the function of the Clp ATPase family, the crystal structures of Helicobacter pylori ClpX, lacking an N-terminal Cys cluster region complexed with ADP, was determined. The overall structure of ClpX is similar to that of heat shock locus U (HslU), consisting of two subdomains, with ADP bound at the subdomain interface. The crystal structure of ClpX reveals that a conserved tripeptide (LGF) is located on the tip of ClpP binding loop extending from the N-terminal subdomain. A hexameric model of ClpX suggests that six tripeptides make hydrophobic contacts with the hydrophobic clefts of the ClpP heptmer asymmetrically. In addition, the nucleotide binding environment provides the structural explanation for the hexameric assembly and the modulation of ATPase activity.

D1 ring is stable and nucleotide-independent, whereas D2 ring undergoes major conformational changes during the ATPase cycle of p97-VCP

The 97-kDa valosin-containing protein (p97-VCP) belongs to the AAA (ATPases associated with various cellular activities) family and acts as a molecular chaperone in diverse cellular events, including ubiquitinproteasome-mediated degradation. We previously showed that VCP contains a substrate-binding domain, N, and two conserved ATPase domains, D1 and D2, of which D2 is responsible for the major enzyme activity. VCP has a barrel-like structure containing two stacked homo-hexameric rings made of the D1 and D2 domains, and this structure is essential for its biological functions. During ATPase cycles, VCP undergoes conformational changes that presumably apply tensions to the bound substrate, leading to the disassembly of protein complexes or unfolding of the substrate. How ATPase activity is coupled with the conformational changes in VCP complex and the D1 and D2 rings is not clear. In this report, we took biochemical approaches to study the structure of VCP in different nucleotide conditions to depict the conformational changes in the ATPase cycles. In contrast to many AAA chaperones that require ATP/ADP to form oligomers, both wild type VCP and ATP-binding site mutants can form hexamers without the addition of nucleotide. This nucleotide-independent hexamerization requires an intact D1 and the down-stream linker sequence of VCP. Tryptophan fluorescence and trypsin digestion analyses showed that ATP/ADP binding induces dramatic conformational changes in VCP. These changes do not require the presence of an intact ATP-binding site in D1 and is thus mainly attributed to the D2 domain. We propose a model whereby D1, although undergoing minor conformational changes, remains as a relatively trypsin-resistant hexameric ring throughout the ATPase cycle, whereas D2 only does so when it binds to ATP or ADP. After ADP is released at the end of the ATP hydrolysis, D2 ring is destabilized and adopts a relatively flexible and open structure.

Roles of individual domains and conserved motifs of the AAA+ chaperone ClpB in oligomerization, ATP hydrolysis, and chaperone activity

ClpB of Escherichia coli is an ATP-dependent ring-forming chaperone that mediates the resolubilization of aggregated proteins in cooperation with the DnaK chaperone system. ClpB belongs to the Hsp100/Clp subfamily of AAA+ proteins and is composed of an N-terminal domain and two AAA-domains that are separated by a "linker" region. Here we present a detailed structure-function analysis of ClpB, dissecting the individual roles of ClpB domains and conserved motifs in oligomerization, ATP hydrolysis, and chaperone activity. Our results show that ClpB oligomerization is strictly dependent on the presence of the C-terminal domain of the second AAA-domain, while ATP binding to the first AAA-domains stabilized the ClpB oligomer. Analysis of mutants of conserved residues in Walker A and B and sensor 2 motifs revealed that both AAA-domains contribute to the basal ATPase activity of ClpB and communicate in a complex manner. Chaperone activity strictly depends on ClpB oligomerization and the presence of a residual ATPase activity. The N-domain is dispensable for oligomerization and for the disaggregating activity in vitro and in vivo. In contrast the presence of the linker region, although not involved in oligomerization, is essential for ClpB chaperone activity.

Hexamerization of p97-VCP is promoted by ATP binding to the D1 domain and required for ATPase and biological activities

The 97-kDa valosin-containing protein (p97-VCP or VCP), a hexameric AAA ATPase, plays an important role in diverse cell activities, including ubiquitin-proteasome mediated protein degradation. In this report, we studied dissociation-reassembly kinetics to analyze the structure-function relationship in VCP. Urea-dissociated VCP can reassemble by itself, but addition of ATP, ADP, or ATP-gamma S accelerates the reassembly. Mutation in the ATP-binding site of D1, but not D2, domain abolishes the ATP acceleration effect and further delays the reassembly. Using hybrid hexamers of the wild type and ATP-binding site mutant, we show that hexameric structure and proper communication among the subunits are required for the ATPase activity and ubiquitin-proteasome mediated degradation. Thus, ATP-binding site in D1 plays a major role in VCP hexamerization, of which proper inter-subunit interaction is essential for the activities.

ATP-dependent hexameric assembly of the heat shock protein Hsp101 involves multiple interaction domains and a functional C-proximal nucleotide-binding domain

Members of the Hsp100 family of heat stress proteins are present in species throughout the bacterial, plant, and fungal kingdoms. Most Hsp100 proteins are composed of five domains that include two nucleotide-binding domains required for their ATP-dependent oligomerization. Mutations within the first but not the second nucleotide-binding site disrupt self-assembly of bacterial Hsp100, whereas the reverse is true for yeast Hsp104. We have examined the functional requirements for oligomerization of plant Hsp101 and have found that Hsp101 resembles Hsp104 in that it assembles into a hexameric complex in an ATP-dependent manner. Self-assembly of Hsp101 involves at least three distinct interaction domains located in the N-proximal domain and in the first and second nucleotide-binding domains. The interaction domain in the second nucleotide-binding domain included the Walker A motif, and mutations within this element disrupted self-assembly of Hsp101. In contrast, mutations affecting conserved residues of the Walker A motif within the first nucleotide-binding site did not affect self-assembly. No interaction between Hsp101 and Hsp104 was observed. These results suggest that plant Hsp101 self-assembly involves multiple evolutionarily diverged interaction domains as well as an evolutionarily conserved requirement for a functional C-proximal nucleotide-binding site.

Roles of the two ATP binding sites of ClpB from Thermus thermophilus

As a member of molecular chaperone Hsp100/Clp family, TClpB from Thermus thermophilus has two nucleotide binding domains, NBD1 and NBD2, in a single polypeptide, each containing WalkerA and WalkerB consensus motifs. To probe their roles, mutations were introduced into the WalkerA or WalkerB motifs of each or both of the NBDs. The results are as follows. 1) For each of the NBDs, the ability of nucleotide binding is lost by mutations in the WalkerA motif but is retained by mutations in the WalkerB motif. 2) Each NBD has a casein-stimulatable small basic ATPase activity that is lost when the WalkerB motif is mutated. 3) TClpB assembles into a uniform 580-kDa oligomer when ATP is present at 55 degrees C, and only the mutants in the WalkerA motif in NBD1 fail to assemble, indicating that ATP binding to NBD1 but not hydrolysis is necessary and sufficient for the assembly. 4) Chaperone function of TClpB was lost when the WalkerA motif in each of the NBDs was mutated. Mutants in the WalkerB motifs of each NBD retained some chaperone activity.

Importance of two ATP-binding sites for oligomerization, ATPase activity and chaperone function of mitochondrial Hsp78 protein

The yeast mitochondrial chaperone Hsp78, a homologue of yeast cytosolic Hsp104 and bacterial ClpB, is required for maintenance of mitochondrial functions under heat stress. Here, Hsp78 was purified to homogeneity and shown to form a homo-hexameric complex, with an apparent molecular mass of approximately 440 kDa, in an ATP-dependent manner. Analysis of its ATPase activity reveals that the observed positive cooperativity effect depends both on Hsp78 and ATP concentration. Site-directed mutagenesis of the two putative Hsp78 nucleotide-binding domains suggest that the first nucleotide-binding domain is responsible for ATP hydrolysis and the second one for protein oligomerization. Studies on the chaperone activity of Hsp78 show that its cooperation with the mitochondrial Hsp70 system, consisting of Ssc1p, Mdj1p and Mge1p, is needed for the efficient reactivation of substrate proteins. These studies also suggest that the oligomerization but not the Hsp78 ATPase activity is essential for its chaperone activity.

Roles of the two ClpC ATP binding sites in the regulation of competence and the stress response

MecA targets the competence transcription factor ComK to ClpC. As a consequence, this factor is degraded by the ClpC/ClpP protease. ClpC is a member of the Clp/HSP100 family of ATPases and possesses two ATP binding sites. We have individually modified the Walker A motifs of these two sites and have also deleted a putative substrate recognition domain of ClpC at the C-terminus. The effects of these mutations were studied in vitro and in vivo. Deletion of the C-terminal domain resulted in a decreased binding affinity for MecA, a decreased ATPase activity in response to MecA addition and decreased degradative activity in vitro. In vivo, this deletion resulted in a failure to degrade ComK and in a decrease in thermal resistance for growth. Mutation of the N-terminal Walker A box (K214Q) caused a drastically decreased ATPase activity in vitro, but did not interfere with MecA binding. In vivo, this mutation had no effect on thermal resistance, but had a clpC null phenotype with respect to competence. Mutation of the C-terminal Walker A motif (K551Q) caused essentially the reverse phenotype both in vivo and in vitro. Although binding to MecA was only moderately impaired with 2 mM ATP, this mutant protein displayed no response to 0.2 mM ATP, unlike the wild-type ClpC and the K214Q mutant protein. The ATPase activity of the K551Q mutant protein, induced by the addition of MecA plus ComS, was decreased about 10-fold but was not eliminated. In vivo, the K551Q mutation showed a partial defect with respect to competence and a profound loss of thermal resistance. Sporulation was reduced drastically by the K551Q and less so by the K214Q mutation, but remained unaffected by deletion of the C-terminal domain. Although the evidence suggests that the functions of the two ATP-binding domains overlap, it appears that the N-terminal nucleotide-binding domain of ClpC is particularly concerned with MecA-related functions, whereas the C-terminal domain plays a more general role in the activities of ClpC.

Structure-function analysis of the zinc-binding region of the Clpx molecular chaperone

The ClpX heat shock protein of Escherichia coli is a member of the universally conserved Hsp100 family of proteins, and possesses a putative zinc finger motif of the C(4) type. The ClpX is an ATPase which functions both as a substrate specificity component of the ClpXP protease and as a molecular chaperone. Using an improved purification procedure we show that the ClpX protein is a metalloprotein complexed with Zn(II) cations. Contrary to other Hsp100 family members, ClpXZn(II) exists in an oligomeric form even in the absence of ATP. We show that the single ATP-binding site of ClpX is required for a variety of tasks, namely, the stabilization of the ClpXZn(II) oligomeric structure, binding to ClpP, and the ClpXP-dependent proteolysis of the lambdaO replication protein. Release of Zn(II) from ClpX protein affects the ability of ClpX to bind ATP. ClpX, free of Zn(II), cannot oligomerize, bind to ClpP, or participate in ClpXP-dependent proteolysis. We also show that ClpXDeltaCys, a mutant protein whose four cysteine residues at the putative zinc finger motif have been replaced by serine, behaves in similar fashion as wild type ClpX protein whose Zn(II) has been released either by denaturation and renaturation, or chemically by p-hydroxymercuriphenylsulfonic acid.

The chaperone function of ClpB from Thermus thermophilus depends on allosteric interactions of its two ATP-binding sites

ClpB belongs to the Hsp100 family and assists de-aggregation of protein aggregates by DnaK chaperone systems. It contains two Walker consensus sequences (or P-Loops) that indicate potential nucleotide binding domains (NBD). Both domains appear to be essential for chaperoning function, since mutation of the conserved lysine residue of the GX(4)GKT consensus sequences to glutamine (K204Q and K601Q) abolishes its properties to accelerate renaturation of aggregated firefly luciferase. The underlying biochemical reason for this malfunction appears not to be a dramatically reduced ATPase activity of either P-loop per se but rather changed properties of co-operativity of ATPase activity connected to oligomerization properties to form productive oligomers. This view is corroborated by data that show that structural stability (as judged by CD spectroscopy) or ATPase activity at single turnover conditions (at low ATP concentrations) are not significantly affected by these mutations. In addition nucleotide binding properties of wild-type protein and mutants (as judged by binding studies with fluorescent nucleotide analogues and competitive displacement titrations) do not differ dramatically. However, the general pattern of formation of stable, defined oligomers formed as a function of salt concentration and nucleotides and more importantly, cooperativity of ATPase activity at high ATP concentrations is dramatically changed with the two P-loop mutants described.

Subunit interactions influence the biochemical and biological properties of Hsp104

Point mutations in either of the two nucleotide-binding domains (NBD) of Hsp104 (NBD1 and NBD2) eliminate its thermotolerance function in vivo. In vitro, NBD1 mutations virtually eliminate ATP hydrolysis with little effect on hexamerization; analogous NBD2 mutations reduce ATPase activity and severely impair hexamerization. We report that high protein concentrations overcome the assembly defects of NBD2 mutants and increase ATP hydrolysis severalfold, changing V(max) with little effect on K(m). In a complementary fashion, the detergent 3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-1-propanesulfonate inhibits hexamerization of wild-type (WT) Hsp104, lowering V(max) with little effect on K(m). ATP hydrolysis exhibits a Hill coefficient between 1.5 and 2, indicating that it is influenced by cooperative subunit interactions. To further analyze the effects of subunit interactions on Hsp104, we assessed the effects of mutant Hsp104 proteins on WT Hsp104 activities. An NBD1 mutant that hexamerizes but does not hydrolyze ATP reduces the ATPase activity of WT Hsp104 in vitro. In vivo, this mutant is not toxic but specifically inhibits the thermotolerance function of WT Hsp104. Thus, interactions between subunits influence the ATPase activity of Hsp104, play a vital role in its biological functions, and provide a mechanism for conditionally inactivating Hsp104 function in vivo.

Subunit interactions influence the biochemical and biological properties of Hsp104

Point mutations in either of the two nucleotide-binding domains (NBD) of Hsp104 (NBD1 and NBD2) eliminate its thermotolerance function in vivo. In vitro, NBD1 mutations virtually eliminate ATP hydrolysis with little effect on hexamerization; analogous NBD2 mutations reduce ATPase activity and severely impair hexamerization. We report that high protein concentrations overcome the assembly defects of NBD2 mutants and increase ATP hydrolysis severalfold, changing V(max) with little effect on K(m). In a complementary fashion, the detergent 3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-1-propanesulfonate inhibits hexamerization of wild-type (WT) Hsp104, lowering V(max) with little effect on K(m). ATP hydrolysis exhibits a Hill coefficient between 1.5 and 2, indicating that it is influenced by cooperative subunit interactions. To further analyze the effects of subunit interactions on Hsp104, we assessed the effects of mutant Hsp104 proteins on WT Hsp104 activities. An NBD1 mutant that hexamerizes but does not hydrolyze ATP reduces the ATPase activity of WT Hsp104 in vitro. In vivo, this mutant is not toxic but specifically inhibits the thermotolerance function of WT Hsp104. Thus, interactions between subunits influence the ATPase activity of Hsp104, play a vital role in its biological functions, and provide a mechanism for conditionally inactivating Hsp104 function in vivo.

Heptameric ring structure of the heat-shock protein ClpB, a protein-activated ATPase in Escherichia coli

The heat-shock protein ClpB is a protein-activated ATPase that is essential for survival of Escherichia coli at high temperatures. ClpB has also recently been suggested to function as a chaperone in reactivation of aggregated proteins. In addition, the clpB gene has been shown to contain two translational initiation sites and therefore encode two polypeptides of different size. To determine the structural organization of ClpB, the ClpB proteins were subjected to chemical cross-linking analysis and electron microscopy. The average images of the ClpB proteins with end-on orientation revealed a seven-membered, ring-shaped structure with a central cavity. Their side-on view showed a two-layered structure with an equal distribution of mass across the equatorial plane of the complex. Since the ClpB subunit has two large regions containing consensus sequences for nucleotide binding, each layer of the ClpB heptamer appears to represent the side projection of one of the major domains arranged on a ring. In the absence of salt and ATP, the ClpB proteins showed a high tendency to form a heptamer. However, they dissociated into various species of oligomers with smaller sizes, depending on salt concentration. Above 0.2 M NaCl, the ClpB proteins behaved most likely as a monomer in the absence of ATP, but assembled into a heptamer in its presence. Furthermore, mutations of the first ATP-binding site, but not the second site, prevented the ATP-dependent oligomerization of the ClpB proteins in the presence of 0.3 M NaCl. These results indicate that ClpB has a heptameric ring-shaped structure with a central cavity and this structural organization requires ATP binding to the first nucleotide-binding site localized to the N-terminal half of the ATPase.

Concurrent chaperone and protease activities of ClpAP and the requirement for the N-terminal ClpA ATP binding site for chaperone activity

ClpA, a member of the Clp/Hsp100 family of ATPases, is both an ATP-dependent molecular chaperone and the regulatory component of ClpAP protease. We demonstrate that chaperone and protease activities occur concurrently in ClpAP complexes during a single round of RepA binding to ClpAP and ATP-dependent release. This result was substantiated with a ClpA mutant, ClpA(K220V), carrying an amino acid substitution in the N-terminal ATP binding site. ClpA(K220V) is unable to activate RepA, but the presence of ClpP or chemically inactivated ClpP restores its ability to activate RepA. The presence of ClpP simultaneously facilitates degradation of RepA. ClpP must remain bound to ClpA(K220V) for these effects, indicating that both chaperone and proteolytic activities of the mutant complex occur concurrently. ClpA(K220V) itself is able to form stable complexes with RepA in the presence of a poorly hydrolyzed ATP analog, adenosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate), and to release RepA upon exchange of adenosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate) with ATP. However, the released RepA is inactive in DNA binding, indicating that the N-terminal ATP binding site is essential for the chaperone activity of ClpA. Taken together, these results suggest that substrates bound to the complex of the proteolytic and ATPase components can be partitioned between release/reactivation and translocation/degradation.

New insights into the ATP-dependent Clp protease: Escherichia coli and beyond

Proteolysis functions as a precise regulatory mechanism for a broad spectrum of cellular processes. Such control impacts not only on the stability of key metabolic enzymes but also on the effective removal of terminally damaged polypeptides. Much of this directed protein turnover is performed by proteases that require ATP and, of those in bacteria, the Clp protease from Escherichia coli is one of the best characterized to date. The Clp holoenzyme consists of two adjacent heptameric rings of the proteolytic subunit known as ClpP, which are flanked by a hexameric ring of a regulatory subunit from the Clp/Hsp100 chaperone family at one or both ends. The recently resolved three-dimensional structure of the E. coli ClpP protein has provided new insights into its interaction with the regulatory/chaperone subunits. In addition, an increasing number of studies over the last few years have recognized the added complexity and functional importance of ClpP proteins in other eubacteria and, in particular, in photosynthetic organisms ranging from cyanobacteria to higher plants. The goal of this review is to summarize these recent findings and to highlight those areas that remain unresolved.

Mutational analysis of the two ATP-binding sites in ClpB, a heat shock protein with protein-activated ATPase activity in Escherichia coli

The 93 kDa ClpB (ClpB93) is a heat shock protein and has a protein-activated ATPase activity. To define the role of the two ATP-binding sites in ClpB93, site-directed mutagenesis was performed to replace Lys212 or Lys611 with Thr or Glu. All of the mutant proteins hydrolysed ATP at a higher rate than that seen with ClpB93 at ATP concentrations up to 2 mM. However, ClpB93 carrying mutations in both of the ATP-binding sites could not cleave ATP. Thus any of the two ATP-binding sites seems to be capable of supporting the ATPase activity of ClpB93. The ATPase activities of both ClpB93/K212T and ClpB93/K212E were gradually decreased when ATP concentrations were increased above 2 mM, unlike those of ClpB93, ClpB93/K611T and ClpB93/K611E, which showed a typical saturation curve. Furthermore ADP inhibited ATP hydrolysis by ClpB93/K212T and ClpB93/K212E more effectively than that by the latter proteins, suggesting that the mutations in the first ATP-binding site result in an increase in the affinity of ADP for the second site in ClpB93. In addition, all of the purified ClpB93 and its mutant forms behaved as an oligomer of 400-450 kDa on a Sephacryl S-300 gel-filtration column, whether or not ATP was present. Thus the binding of ATP to either of the two sites seems not to be essential for oligomerization of ClpB93. Although a low-copy plasmid carrying clpB93 could rescue the sensitivity of a clpB-null mutant cell at 52 degreesC, none of the plasmids carrying the mutations in the ATP-binding sites could. Furthermore, incubation at 52 degreesC resulted in a gradual loss of the ATPase activity of ClpB93 carrying the mutations in either of the two ATP-binding sites, but not of the parental ClpB93, indicating that the mutant proteins have a greater tendency to denature at this temperature than the parental ClpB93. These results suggest that both of the ATP-binding sites in ClpB have an important role in maintaining the thermotolerance of the protein and hence in the survival of Escherichia coli at high temperatures.

The ATPase activity of Hsp104, effects of environmental conditions and mutations

Hsp104 is crucial for stress tolerance in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and both of its nucleotide-binding domains (NBD1 and NBD2) are required. Here, we characterize the ATPase activity and oligomerization properties of wild-type (WT) Hsp104 and of NBD mutants. In physiological ionic strength buffers (pH 7.5, 37 degreesC) WT Hsp104 exhibits Michaelis-Menten kinetics between 0.5 and 25 mM ATP (Km approximately 5 mM, Vmax approximately 2 nmol min-1 microg-1). ATPase activity is strongly influenced by factors that vary with cell stress (e.g. temperature, pH, and ADP). Mutations in the P-loop of NBD1 (G217V or K218T) severely reduce ATP hydrolysis but have little effect on oligomerization. Analogous mutations in NBD2 (G619V or K620T) have smaller effects on ATPase activity but impair oligomerization. The opposite relationship was reported for another member of the HSP100 protein family, the Escherichia coli ClpA protein, in studies employing lower ionic strength buffers. In such buffers, the Km of WT Hsp104 for ATP hydrolysis decreased 10-fold and its stability under stress conditions increased, but the effects of the NBD mutations on ATPase activity and oligomerization remained opposite to those of ClpA. Either the functions of the two NBDs in ClpA and Hsp104 have been reversed or both contribute to ATP hydrolysis and oligomerization in a complex manner that can be idiosyncratically affected by such mutations.

Stress induction of the Bacillus subtilis clpP gene encoding a homologue of the proteolytic component of the Clp protease and the involvement of ClpP and ClpX in stress tolerance

The Bacillus subtilis clpP gene, encoding the proteolytic component of the Clp or Ti protease, was cloned and sequenced. The amount of clpP-specific mRNA increased after heat shock, salt and ethanol stress, as well as after treatment with puromycin. Two transcriptional start sites upstream of the clpP structural gene were identified, preceded by sequences resembling the consensus sequences of promoters recognized by sigmaA and sigmaB transcriptional factors of the B. subtilis RNA polymerase respectively. Transcription initiation occurred predominantly at the putative sigmaA-dependent promoter in exponentially growing cells and was induced under stress conditions. After exposure to stress, initiation of transcription also increased at the sigmaB-dependent promoter, but to a lesser extent, indicating that clpP belongs to a double promoter-controlled subgroup of class III general stress genes in B. subtilis. In a sigB mutant strain, clpP remained heat and stress inducible at the sigmaA-dependent promoter. BgaB-reporter gene fusions, carrying either the sigmaA- or the sigmaB-dependent promoter, showed a higher bgaB induction at the sigmaA-dependent promoter, whereas a significantly lower level of induction was measured at the sigmaB-dependent promoter. The sigmaA-dependent promoter appeared to be crucial for the heat-inducible transcription of clpP. A CIRCE (controlling inverted repeat of chaperone expression) element, the characteristic regulation target of class I heat shock genes such as dnaK and groESL, was not found between the transcriptional and translational start sites. Mutants lacking either the proteolytic component ClpP or the regulatory ATPase component ClpX were phenotypically distinct from the wild type. Both mutants produced chains of elongated cells and exhibited severely impaired growth under stress conditions and starvation. Comparison of two-dimensional protein gels from wild-type cells with those from clpP and clpX mutant cells revealed several changes in the protein pattern. Several proteins, such as GroEL, PpiB, PykA, SucD, YhfP, YqkF, YugJ and YvyD, which were found preferentially in higher amounts in both clpP and clpX mutants, might be potential substrates for the ClpXP protease.

Biochemical characterization of a molecular switch involving the heat shock protein ClpC, which controls the activity of ComK, the competence transcription factor of Bacillus subtilis

Development of genetic competence in Bacillus subtilis is controlled by the competence-specific transcription factor ComK. ComK activates transcription of itself and several other genes required for competence. The activity of ComK is controlled by other genes including mecA, clpC, and comS. We have used purified ComK, MecA, ClpC, and synthetic ComS to study their interactions and have demonstrated the following mechanism for ComK regulation. ClpC, in the presence of ATP, forms a ternary complex with MecA and ComK, which prevents ComK from binding to its specific DNA target. This complex dissociates when ComS is added, liberating active ComK. ClpC and MecA function as a molecular switch, in which MecA confers molecular recognition, connecting ClpC to ComK and to ComS.

Mutational analysis of the ATP-binding site in HslU, the ATPase component of HslVU protease in Escherichia coli

HslU is the ATPase component of the ATP-dependent HslVU protease in Escherichia coli. To gain an insight into the structure and function of HslU, site-directed mutagenesis was performed to generate a mutation in the ATP-binding site of the ATPase (i.e., to replace the Lys63 with Thr). Unlike the wild-type HslU, the mutant form (referred to as HslU/K63T) could not hydrolyze ATP or support the ATP-dependent hydrolysis of N-carbobenzoxy-Gly-Gly-Leu-7-amido-4-methyl coumarin by HslV. The wild-type HslU (a mixture of monomer and dimer) formed a multimer containing 6-8 subunits in the presence of either ATP or ADP, indicating that ATP-binding, but not its hydrolysis, is required for oligomerization of HslU. However, HslU/K63T remained as a monomer whether or not the adenine nucleotides were present. Furthermore, ATP or ADP could protect HslU, but not HslU/K63T, from degradation by trypsin. These results suggest that the mutation in the ATP-binding site results in prevention of the binding of the adenine nucleotides to HslU and hence in impairment of both oligomerization and ATPase function of HslU.

A hemoglobin-based blood substitute: transplanting a novel allosteric effect of crocodile Hb

Recombinant DNA technology has enabled the large scale production of human hemoglobin in bacteria and yeast. This has opened up a way to produce a hemoglobin-based blood substitute which could replace conventional blood transfusion in some situations. Using our understanding of the structure-function relationships and evolutionary history of hemoglobin it has been possible to improve the oxygen transport properties of the molecule and solve a number of problems associated with the use of natural hemoglobin as a cell-free blood substitute.

Purification and characterization of the heat shock proteins HslV and HslU that form a new ATP-dependent protease in Escherichia coli

The hslVU operon in Escherichia coli encodes two heat shock proteins, HslV, a 19-kDa protein homologous to beta-type subunits of the 20 S proteasomes, and HslU, a 50-kDa protein related to the ATPase ClpX. We have recently shown that HslV and HslU can function together as a novel ATP-dependent protease, the HslVU protease. We have now purified both proteins to apparent homogeneity from extracts of E. coli carrying the hslVU operon on a multicopy plasmid. HslU by itself cleaved ATP, and pure HslV is a weak peptidase degrading certain hydrophobic peptides. HslU dramatically stimulated peptide hydrolysis by HslV when ATP is present. With a 1:4 molar ratio of HslV to HslU, approximately a 200-fold increase in peptide hydrolysis was observed. HslV stimulated the ATPase activity of HslU 2-4-fold, but had little influence on the affinity of HslU to ATP. The nonhydrolyzable ATP analog, beta,gamma-methylene-ATP, did not support peptide hydrolysis. Other nucleotides (CTP, dATP) that were slowly hydrolyzed by HslU allowed some peptide hydrolysis. Therefore, ATP cleavage appears essential for the HslV activity. Upon gel filtration on a Sephacryl S-300 column, HslV behaved as a 250-kDa oligomer (i.e. 12-14 subunits), and HslU behaved as a 100-kDa protein (i.e. a dimer) in the absence of ATP, but as a 450-kDa multimer (8-10 subunits) in its presence. Therefore ATP appears necessary for oligomerization of HslU. Thus the HslVU protease appears to be a two-component protease in which HslV harbors the peptidase activity, while HslU provides an essential ATPase activity.