Replication error rates for G.dGTP, T.dGTP, and A.dGTP mispairs and evidence for differential proofreading by leading and lagging strand DNA replication complexes in human cells

Eutherians intrinsically run a higher risk of replication deficiency

Females inherit two X chromosomes from each parent, but males inherit only one from the mother. The POLA gene encodes the catalytic subunit of DNA polymerase alpha (pol-alpha), synthesizing a short DNA primer after RNA priming for DNA chain elongation in eukaryotic DNA replication. The POLA gene is established in the X-added region (XRA) of an X chromosome, translocated from a second autosome about 105 million years ago (mya). Dosage compensation for the mammalian X chromosome is accomplished by the silencing of one X chromosome to equalize gene expression between the male and female. We eutherians must replicate our DNA using pol-alpha expressed from a 'single copy' of genes, whose expression is probably reduced when chromosome translocation occurs. Spontaneous mutation occurring on the 'single' POLA gene, which decreases its replication fidelity, probably accounts for the increase of nucleotide substitution rates more effectively than in other organisms that possess the POLA gene on an autosome pair. Moreover, translocation of the POLA gene from an autosome to the X chromosome might reduce expression of pol-alpha, resulting in promotion of chromosome rearrangement. Therefore, the X-linked POLA gene possibly contributes to greater diversification of eutherian mammals.

Duplications between direct repeats stabilized by DNA secondary structure occur preferentially in the leading strand during DNA replication

To ascertain a leading or lagging strand preference for duplication mutations, several short DNA sequences, i.e. mutation inserts, were designed that should demonstrate an asymmetric propensity for duplication mutations in the two complementary DNA strands during replication. The design of the mutation insert involved a 7-bp quasi inverted repeat that forms a remarkably stable hairpin in one DNA strand, but not the other. The inverted repeat is asymmetrically placed between flanking direct repeats. This sequence was cloned into a modified chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) gene containing a -1 frameshift mutation. Duplication of the mutation insert restores the reading frame of the CAT gene resulting in a chloramphenicol resistant phenotype. The mutation insert showed greater than a 200-fold preference for duplication mutations during leading strand, compared with lagging strand, replication. This result suggests that misalignment stabilized by DNA secondary structure, leading to duplication between direct repeats, occurred preferentially during leading strand synthesis.

Strand asymmetry patterns in trypanosomatid parasites

The genome organization of kinetoplastid parasites is unusual, with chromosomes containing several long regions of polycistronically transcribed genes. The regions where the direction of transcription switches have been hypothesized to contain origins of replication and possibly also centromers and promoters. We report that overall strand asymmetry patterns can be observed in Trypanosoma cruzi and Trypanosoma brucei with optima on strand-switch regions. The base skews of T. cruzi and T. brucei divergent strand-switches show patterns analogous to those for bacterial origins of replication, but they differ from those of Leishmania major. Bias in codon usage and the trypanosomatid unidirectional gene clusters predict most of this skew, but fail to properly explain the same trend in intergenic regions, as does the current knowledge of regulatory sequences.

Origins of spontaneous mutations: specificity and directionality of base-substitution, frameshift, and sequence-substitution mutageneses

Spontaneous mutations are derived from various sources, including errors made during replication of undamaged template DNA, mutagenic nucleotide substrates, and endogenous DNA lesions. These sources vary in their frequencies and resultant mutations, and are differently affected by the DNA sequence, DNA transactions, and cellular metabolism. Organisms possess a variety of cellular functions to suppress spontaneous mutagenesis, and the specificity and effectiveness of each function strongly affect the pattern of spontaneous mutations. Base substitutions and single-base frameshifts, two major classes of spontaneous mutations, occur non-randomly throughout the genome. Within target DNA sequences there are hotspots for particular types of spontaneous mutations; outside of the hotspots, spontaneous mutations occur more randomly and much less frequently. Hotspot mutations are attributable more to endogenous DNA lesions than to replication errors. Recently, a novel class of mutagenic pathway that depends on short inverted repeats was identified as another important source of hotspot mutagenesis.

Chemotherapeutically induced deletion of expanded triplet repeats

The number of neurodegenerative disorders associated with the expansion of DNA repeats, currently about 18, continues to increase as additional diseases caused by this novel type of mutation are identified. Typically, expanded repeats are biased toward further expansion upon intergenerational transmission, and disease symptoms show an earlier age of onset and greater severity as the length of the triplet repeat tract increases. Most diseases exhibit progressive neurological and/or muscular degeneration that can lead to total disability and death. As yet, no treatment exists for the genetic basis of any repeat disease. Given that the severity of these diseases is related to repeat tract length, reducing repeat lengths might delay the onset and reduce disease severity. Here, we test the hypothesis that the introduction of damage into DNA, which results in subsequent repair events, can lead to an increased rate of repeat deletion. Applying a sensitive genetic assay in Escherichia coli [Mut. Res. 502 (2002) 25], we demonstrate that certain DNA damaging agents, including EMS, ENU, UV light, and anticancer agents mitomycin C, cisplatin, and X-rays increase the rate of deletion of (CTG).(CAG) repeats in a length and orientation dependent fashion. In addition, oxidative damage to DNA also increases the deletion rate of repeats. These results suggest that a chemotherapeutic approach to the reduction in triplet repeat length may provide one possible rationale to slow, stop, or reverse the progression of these diseases.

Yeast origins establish a strand bias for replicational mutagenesis

To determine whether replicational mutagenesis in the yeast genome is influenced by the positions of active origins, a reporter gene was placed in two orientations at multiple locations within a 39,000 bp region of chromosome III possessing two strong origins. The frequency of mutations resulting from misincorporation of adenine opposite 8-hydroxyguanine in one strand and 6-hydroxylaminopurine opposite cytosine in the other strand differed by 3- to 10-fold, depending on the gene orientation and its distance from the origins. The observed patterns indicate that active origins establish a strand bias for mutations that is maintained over thousands of base pairs and results from lower nucleotide selectivity and/or less efficient proofreading or mismatch repair during leading strand DNA replication.

Effect of chromosome location on bacterial mutation rates

In previous comparisons of enterobacterial sequences, synonymous substitution rates were higher in genes closer to the replication terminus, suggesting that mutation rates increase with distance from the replication origin. In order to directly test for the effects of chromosomal location on the rates of point mutations, we assayed the reversion rates of two lacZ alleles inserted at four positions in the Salmonella enterica chromosome. Mutation rates at an intermediate locus were significantly higher than those at loci nearer to and farther from the replication origin. The higher reversion rates at this locus were neither the result of an overall increase in mutation rates produced by the insertion at this location nor a function of the mutations' immediate neighbors, but rather a regional effect. At all loci, regardless of chromosome location, T.A --> G.C transversions were more frequent than A.T --> G.C transitions during the exponential phase.

Ongoing evolution of strand composition in bacterial genomes

We tried to identify the substitutions involved in the establishment of replication strand bias, which has been recognized as an important evolutionary factor in the evolution of bacterial genomes. First, we analyzed the composition asymmetry of 28 complete bacterial genomes and used it to test the possibility that asymmetric deamination of cytosine might be at the origin of the bias. The model showed significant correlation to the data but left unexplained a significant portion of the variance and indicated a systematic underestimation of GC skews in comparison with TA skews. Second, we analyzed the substitutions acting on the genes from five fully sequenced Chlamydia genomes that had not suffered strand switch since speciation. This analysis showed that substitutions were not at equilibrium in Chlamydia trachomatis or in C. muridarum and that strand bias is still an on-going process in these genes. Third, we identified substitutions involved in the adaptation of genes that had switched strands after speciation. These genes adapted quickly to the skewed composition of the new strand, mostly due to C-->T, A-->G, and C-->G asymmetric substitutions. This observation was reinforced by the analysis of genes that switched strands after divergence between Bacillus subtilis and B. halodurans. Finally, we propose a more extended model based on the analysis of the substitution asymmetries of CHLAMYDIA: This model fits well with the data provided by bacterial genomes presenting strong strand bias.

DNA replication fidelity

DNA replication fidelity is a key determinant of genome stability and is central to the evolution of species and to the origins of human diseases. Here we review our current understanding of replication fidelity, with emphasis on structural and biochemical studies of DNA polymerases that provide new insights into the importance of hydrogen bonding, base pair geometry, and substrate-induced conformational changes to fidelity. These studies also reveal polymerase interactions with the DNA minor groove at and upstream of the active site that influence nucleotide selectivity, the efficiency of exonucleolytic proofreading, and the rate of forming errors via strand misalignments. We highlight common features that are relevant to the fidelity of any DNA synthesis reaction, and consider why fidelity varies depending on the enzymes, the error, and the local sequence environment.

Proofreading of DNA polymerase eta-dependent replication errors

Human DNA polymerase eta, the product of the skin cancer susceptibility gene XPV, bypasses UV photoproducts in template DNA that block synthesis by other DNA polymerases. Pol eta lacks an intrinsic proofreading exonuclease and copies DNA with low fidelity, such that pol eta errors could contribute to mutagenesis unless they are corrected. Here we provide evidence that pol eta can compete with other human polymerases during replication of duplex DNA, and in so doing it lowers replication fidelity. However, we show that pol eta has low processivity and extends mismatched primer termini less efficiently than matched termini. These properties could provide an opportunity for extrinsic exonuclease(s) to proofread pol eta-induced replication errors. When we tested this hypothesis during replication in human cell extracts, pol eta-induced replication infidelity was found to be modulated by changing the dNTP concentration and to be enhanced by adding dGMP to a replication reaction. Both effects are classical hallmarks of exonucleolytic proofreading. Thus, pol eta is ideally suited for its role in reducing UV-induced mutagenesis and skin cancer risk, in that its relaxed base selectivity may facilitate efficient bypass of UV photoproducts, while subsequent proofreading by extrinsic exonuclease(s) may reduce its mutagenic potential.

Evidence that error-prone DNA repair converts dibenzo[a,l]pyrene-induced depurinating lesions into mutations: formation, clonal proliferation and regression of initiated cells carrying H-ras oncogene mutations in early preneoplasia

Initiation of skin tumors in mice is associated with the formation of oncogenic mutations in the H-ras gene. Mice treated on the dorsal skin with the potent polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) carcinogen dibenzo[a,l]pyrene (DB[a,l]P) form papillomas carrying the H-ras codon 61 (CAA to CTA) mutations. These mutations are induced in early preneoplastic skin within 1 day after DB[a,l]P treatment (Oncogene 16 (1998) 3203-3210) and appear to be related to DB[a,l]P-Ade-depurinating adducts (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 92 (1995) 10422-10426). The rapid kinetics of mutation induction suggests that abasic sites generated from base depurination may undergo error-prone excision repair in pre-S-phase cells to induce these mutations. Analysis of mutations in the H-ras exon 1 and 2 region in DB[a,l]P-treated early preneoplastic skin indicated great changes in mutation spectra in the preneoplastic period. The initial spectra contained abundant A-->G mutations, which frequently occurred 3' to a putative conserved sequence (TGN-doublet). These mutations appeared to be induced initially as mismatched (G.T) heteroduplexes and then converted into double-stranded mutations by one round of replication. Unlike the A-->G mutations found in DB[a, l]P-treated skin (which forms 99% depurinating adducts), A-->G mutations found in anti-DB[a,l]P-diol epoxide-treated skin (forms 97% stable adducts) did not appear to be G.T heteroduplexes. These results, therefore, suggest that under these conditions, the repair errors occurred only from abasic sites but not from stable adducts. Initiated cells carrying specific oncogenic mutations, formed presumably by misrepair, underwent rapid clonal expansion and regression (transient clonoplasia). The multiplication of initiated stem cells during transient clonoplasia may be a factor determining the tumor-initiating potential of some PAH carcinogens.

Evidence from mutational specificity studies that yeast DNA polymerases delta and epsilon replicate different DNA strands at an intracellular replication fork

Although polymerases delta and epsilon are required for DNA replication in eukaryotic cells, whether each polymerase functions on a separate template strand remains an open question. To begin examining the relative intracellular roles of the two polymerases, we used a plasmid-borne yeast tRNA gene and yeast strains that are mutators due to the elimination of proofreading by DNA polymerases delta or epsilon. Inversion of the tRNA gene to change the sequence of the leading and lagging strand templates altered the specificities of both mutator polymerases, but in opposite directions. That is, the specificity of the polymerase delta mutator with the tRNA gene in one orientation bore similarities to the specificity of the polymerase epsilon mutator with the tRNA gene in the other orientation, and vice versa. We also obtained results consistent with gene orientation having a minor influence on mismatch correction of replication errors occurring in a wild-type strain. However, the data suggest that neither this effect nor differential replication fidelity was responsible for the mutational specificity changes observed in the proofreading-deficient mutants upon gene inversion. Collectively, the data argue that polymerases delta and epsilon each encounter a different template sequence upon inversion of the tRNA gene, and so replicate opposite strands at the plasmid DNA replication fork.

Strand symmetry around the beta-globin origin of replication in primates

Certain mutations are known to occur with differing frequencies on the leading and lagging strands of DNA. The extent to which these mutational biases affect the sequences of higher eukaryotes has been difficult to ascertain because the positions of most replication origins are not known, making it impossible to distinguish between the leading and lagging strands. To resolve whether strand biases influence the evolution of primate sequences, we compared the substitution patterns in noncoding regions adjacent to an origin of replication identified within the beta-globin complex. Although there was limited asymmetry around the beta-globin origin of replication, patterns of substitutions do not support the existence of a mutational bias between the leading and lagging strands of chromosomal DNA replication in primates.

Asymmetric substitution patterns: a review of possible underlying mutational or selective mechanisms

In the absence of bias between the two DNA strands for mutation and selection, the base composition within each strand should be such that A = T and C = G (this state is called Parity Rule type 2, PR2). At a genome scale, i.e. when considering the base composition of a whole genome, PR2 is a good approximation, but there are local and systematic deviations. The question is whether these deviations are a consequence of an underlying bias in mutation or selection. We have tried to review published hypotheses to classify them within the mutational or selective group. This dichotomy is, however, too crude because there is at least one hypothesis based simultaneously upon mutation and selection.

Fidelity and mutational specificity of uracil-initiated base excision DNA repair synthesis in human glioblastoma cell extracts

The fidelity of DNA synthesis associated with uracil-initiated base excision repair was measured in human whole cell extracts. An M13mp2 lacZalpha DNA-based reversion assay was developed to assess the error frequency of DNA repair synthesis at a site-specific uracil residue. All three possible base substitution errors were detected at the uracil target causing reversion of opal codon 14 in the Escherichia coli lacZalpha gene. Using human glioblastoma U251 whole cell extracts, approximately 50% of the heteroduplex uracil-containing DNA substrate was completely repaired, as determined by the insensitivity of form I DNA reaction products to cleavage by a combined treatment of E. coli uracil-DNA glycosylase and endonuclease IV. The majority of repair occurred by the uracil-initiated base excision repair pathway, since the addition of the bacteriophage PBS2 uracil-DNA glycosylase inhibitor protein to extracts significantly blocked this process. In addition, the formation of repaired form I DNA molecules occurred concurrently with limited DNA synthesis, which was largely restricted to the HinfI DNA fragment initially containing the uracil residue and specific to the uracil-containing DNA strand. Based on the reversion frequency of repaired M13mp2 DNA, the fidelity of DNA repair synthesis at the target was determined to be about one misincorporated nucleotide per 1900 repaired uracil residues. The major class of base substitutions propagated transversion mutations, which were distributed almost equally between T to G and T to A changes in the template. A similar mutation frequency was also observed using whole cell extracts from human colon adenocarcinoma LoVo cells, suggesting that mismatch repair did not interfere with the fidelity measurements.

Unequal fidelity of leading strand and lagging strand DNA replication on the Escherichia coli chromosome

We have investigated the question whether during chromosomal DNA replication in Escherichia coli the two DNA strands may be replicated with differential accuracy. This possibility of differential replication fidelity arises from the distinct modes of replication in the two strands, one strand (the leading strand) being synthesized continuously, the other (the lagging strand) discontinuously in the form of short Okazaki fragments. We have constructed a series of lacZ strains in which the lac operon is inserted into the bacterial chromosome in the two possible orientations with regard to the chromosomal replication origin oriC. Measurement of lac reversion frequencies for the two orientations, under conditions in which mutations reflect replication errors, revealed distinct differences in mutability between the two orientations. As gene inversion causes a switching of leading and lagging strands, these findings indicate that leading and lagging strand replication have differential fidelity. Analysis of the possible mispairs underlying each specific base pair substitution suggests that the lagging strand replication on the E. coli chromosome may be more accurate than leading strand replication.

Mismatched nucleotides may facilitate expansion of trinucleotide repeats in genetic diseases

We have studied the contribution of mismatch sequences to the trinucleotide repeat expansion that causes hereditary diseases. Using an oligonucleotide duplex, (CAG)5/(CTG)5, as a template-primer, DNA synthesis was carried out using either Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) or human immunodeficiency virus type I reverse transcriptase (HIV-RT). Both enzymes expanded the repeat sequence longer than 27 nucleotides (nt), beyond the maximum length expected from the template size. The expansion was observed under conditions in which extension occurs either in both strands or in one strand. In contrast, with another template-primer that contains a non-repetitive flanking sequence 5'-upstream of the repetitive sequence, the reaction products were not extended beyond the template size (45 nt) by these DNA polymerases. We then used mismatched template-primers, in which either 1, 2 or 6 non-complementary nucleotides were introduced to the repeat sequence that is flanked by a non-repetitive sequence. In this case, primers were efficiently expanded over the expected length of 45 nt, in a mismatch-dependent manner. One of the primers with six mismatches extended as long as 72 nt. These results imply that the misincorporation of non-complementary deoxyribonucleoside monophosphates (dNMPs) into the repeat sequence makes double-stranded DNA unstable and triggers the slippage and expansion of trinucleotide repeats by forming loops or hairpin structures during DNA synthesis.

DNA sequence analysis of spontaneous mutagenesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

To help elucidate the mechanisms involved in spontaneous mutagenesis, DNA sequencing has been applied to characterize the types of mutation whose rates are increased or decreased in mutator or antimutator strains, respectively. Increased spontaneous mutation rates point to malfunctions in genes that normally act to reduce spontaneous mutation, whereas decreased rates are associated with defects in genes whose products are necessary for spontaneous mutagenesis. In this article, we survey and discuss the mutational specificities conferred by mutator and antimutator genes in the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The implications of selected aspects of the data are considered with respect to the mechanisms of spontaneous mutagenesis.

Mutations induced by 2-hydroxyadenine on a shuttle vector during leading and lagging strand syntheses in mammalian cells

An oxidatively damaged base, 2-hydroxyadenine (2-OH-Ade), was incorporated into a predetermined site of one of the strands {(+)- or (-)-strand} of the double-stranded shuttle vector, pSVK3, and the modified DNAs were transfected into simian COS-7 cells. The nucleotide sequences in which the modified base was incorporated were 5'-GTCGA*C and 5'-CTTA*AG (A* represents 2-OH-Ade). The former is the recognition site for the restriction enzyme SalI, and the latter is that for AflII. The DNAs replicated in the cells were recovered and were transfected again into Escherichia coli. The DNAs recovered from the COS-7 cells transfected with a plasmid containing 2-OH-Ade at either site of the (+)-strand (a template strand for lagging strand synthesis) formed colonies about 50%-70% as frequently as the unmodified DNA. This indicated that the base weakly blocked DNA replication during lagging strand synthesis. On the other hand, the base in the (-)-strand did not appear to affect the efficiency of leading strand synthesis in COS-7 cells. The mutation frequencies of 2-OH-Ade in COS-7 cells were 0.6%-0.1%, depending on the sequence and the strand location. Although the mutation spectra of 2-OH-Ade also differed with sequences and strands, the base elicited substitution and deletion mutations in mammalian cells, as in E. coli. These results indicate that 2-OH-Ade is mutagenic in eukaryotic cells as well as in prokaryotic cells.

Strand asymmetries in DNA evolution

The complementary strands of DNA differ with respect to replication and transcription. Both of these processes are asymmetric and can bias the occurrence of mutations between the strands: during replication, the discontinuous lagging strand undergoes certain errors at higher rates, and transcription overexposes the nontranscribed strand to DNA damage while targeting repair enzymes to the transcribed strand. While biases introduced during replication apparently have little impact on sequence evolution, the effects of transcription are observed in the asymmetric patterns of substitution in bacterial genes and might be influencing genome-wide patterns of base composition.

Asymmetries generated by transcription-coupled repair in enterobacterial genes

Although certain replication errors occur at different frequencies on each of the complementary strands of DNA, it remains unclear whether this bias is prevalent enough during chromosome replication to affect sequence evolution. Here, nucleotide substitutions in enteric bacteria were examined, and no difference in mutation rates was detected between the leading and lagging strands, but in comparing the coding and noncoding strands, and excess of C-->T changes was observed on the coding strand. This asymmetry is best explained by transcription-coupled repair on the noncoding strand. Although the vast majority of mutations are thought to arise from spontaneous errors during replication, this result implicates DNA damage as a substantial source of mutations in the wild.

Frequency and fidelity of translesion synthesis of site-specific N-2-acetylaminofluorene adducts during DNA replication in a human cell extract

We have previously analyzed the effects of site-specific N-2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF) adducts on the efficiency and frameshift fidelity of SV40-based DNA replication in a human cell extract (Thomas, D. C., Veaute, X., Kunkel, T. A., and Fuchs, R. P. P. (1994) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 91, 7752-7756). Here we use two sets of substrates to examine the probability of replication termination and error-free and error-prone bypass of AAF adducts. The substrates contained site-specific adducts at one of three guanines in a NarI sequence (5'-GGCGCC-3') placed within the lacZ alpha reporter gene and located on the template for either leading or lagging strand replication. The presence of the adduct at any position strongly reduces the efficiency of a single round of replication in a HeLa cell extract. Product analysis reveals preferential replication of the undamaged strand and termination of replication of the damaged strand occurring one nucleotide before incorporation opposite either a leading or lagging strand adduct. Products resistant to restriction endonuclease cleavage at the adducted site were generated in amounts consistent with 16-48% lesion bypass during replication. Most of this bypass was error-free. However, two-nucleotide deletion errors were detected in the replication products of DNA containing an AAF adduct in either the leading or lagging strand, but only when present at the third guanine position. Collectively, the data suggest that the replication apparatus in a HeLa cell extract generates a template-primer slippage error at an AAF adduct once for every 30-100 bypass events.