Efficient insertion of odd-numbered transmembrane segments of the tetracycline resistance protein requires even-numbered segments

Lipids and topological rules governing membrane protein assembly

Membrane protein folding and topogenesis are tuned to a given lipid profile since lipids and proteins have co-evolved to follow a set of interdependent rules governing final protein topological organization. Transmembrane domain (TMD) topology is determined via a dynamic process in which topogenic signals in the nascent protein are recognized and interpreted initially by the translocon followed by a given lipid profile in accordance with the Positive Inside Rule. The net zero charged phospholipid phosphatidylethanolamine and other neutral lipids dampen the translocation potential of negatively charged residues in favor of the cytoplasmic retention potential of positively charged residues (Charge Balance Rule). This explains why positively charged residues are more potent topological signals than negatively charged residues. Dynamic changes in orientation of TMDs during or after membrane insertion are attributed to non-sequential cooperative and collective lipid-protein charge interactions as well as long-term interactions within a protein. The proportion of dual topological conformers of a membrane protein varies in a dose responsive manner with changes in the membrane lipid composition not only in vivo but also in vitro and therefore is determined by the membrane lipid composition. Switching between two opposite TMD topologies can occur in either direction in vivo and also in liposomes (designated as fliposomes) independent of any other cellular factors. Such lipid-dependent post-insertional reversibility of TMD orientation indicates a thermodynamically driven process that can occur at any time and in any cell membrane driven by changes in the lipid composition. This dynamic view of protein topological organization influenced by the lipid environment reveals previously unrecognized possibilities for cellular regulation and understanding of disease states resulting from mis-folded proteins. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein trafficking and secretion in bacteria. Guest Editors: Anastassios Economou and Ross Dalbey.

Lipids and topological rules of membrane protein assembly: balance between long and short range lipid-protein interactions

The N-terminal six-transmembrane domain (TM) bundle of lactose permease of Escherichia coli is uniformly inverted when assembled in membranes lacking phosphatidylethanolamine (PE). Inversion is dependent on the net charge of cytoplasmically exposed protein domains containing positive and negative residues, net charge of the membrane surface, and low hydrophobicity of TM VII acting as a molecular hinge between the two halves of lactose permease (Bogdanov, M., Xie, J., Heacock, P., and Dowhan, W. (2008) J. Cell Biol. 182, 925-935). Net neutral lipids suppress the membrane translocation potential of negatively charged amino acids, thus increasing the cytoplasmic retention potential of positively charged amino acids. Herein, TM organization of sucrose permease (CscB) and phenylalanine permease (PheP) as a function of membrane lipid composition was investigated to extend these principles to other proteins. For CscB, topological dependence on PE only becomes evident after a significant increase in the net negative charge of the cytoplasmic surface of the N-terminal TM bundle. High negative charge is required to overcome the thermodynamic block to inversion due to the high hydrophobicity of TM VII. Increasing the positive charge of the cytoplasmic surface of the N-terminal TM hairpin of PheP, which is misoriented in PE-lacking cells, favors native orientation in the absence of PE. PheP and CscB also display co-existing dual topologies dependent on changes in the charge balance between protein domains and the membrane lipids. Therefore, the topology of both permeases is dependent on PE. However, CscB topology is governed by thermodynamic balance between opposing lipid-dependent electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions.

Lipid-dependent membrane protein topogenesis

The topology of polytopic membrane proteins is determined by topogenic sequences in the protein, protein-translocon interactions, and interactions during folding within the protein and between the protein and the lipid environment. Orientation of transmembrane domains is dependent on membrane phospholipid composition during initial assembly as well as on changes in lipid composition postassembly. The membrane translocation potential of negative amino acids working in opposition to the positive-inside rule is largely dampened by the normal presence of phosphatidylethanolamine, thus explaining the dominance of positive residues as retention signals. Phosphatidylethanolamine provides the appropriate charge density that permits the membrane surface to maintain a charge balance between membrane translocation and retention signals and also allows the presence of negative residues in the cytoplasmic face of proteins for other purposes.

Mechanism and hydrophobic forces driving membrane protein insertion of subunit II of cytochrome bo 3 oxidase

Subunit II (CyoA) of cytochrome bo(3) oxidase, which spans the inner membrane twice in bacteria, has several unusual features in membrane biogenesis. It is synthesized with an amino-terminal cleavable signal peptide. In addition, distinct pathways are used to insert the two ends of the protein. The amino-terminal domain is inserted by the YidC pathway whereas the large carboxyl-terminal domain is translocated by the SecYEG pathway. Insertion of the protein is also proton motive force (pmf)-independent. Here we examined the topogenic sequence requirements and mechanism of insertion of CyoA in bacteria. We find that both the signal peptide and the first membrane-spanning region are required for insertion of the amino-terminal periplasmic loop. The pmf-independence of insertion of the first periplasmic loop is due to the loop's neutral net charge. We observe also that the introduction of negatively charged residues into the periplasmic loop makes insertion pmf dependent, whereas the addition of positively charged residues prevents insertion unless the pmf is abolished. Insertion of the carboxyl-terminal domain in the full-length CyoA occurs by a sequential mechanism even when the CyoA amino and carboxyl-terminal domains are swapped with other domains. However, when a long spacer peptide is added to increase the distance between the amino-terminal and carboxyl-terminal domains, insertion no longer occurs by a sequential mechanism.

Biogenesis and Topology of the Transient Receptor Potential Ca2+ Channel TRPC1

The TRPC ion channels are candidates for the store-operated Ca(2+) entry pathway activated in response to depletion of intracellular Ca(2+) stores. Hydropathy analyses indicate that these proteins contain eight hydrophobic regions (HRs) that could potentially form alpha-helical membrane-spanning segments. Based on limited sequence similarities to other ion channels, it has been proposed that only six of the eight HRs actually span the membrane and that the last two membrane-spanning segments (HRs 6 and 8) border the ion-conducting pore of which HR 7 forms a part. Here we study the biogenesis and transmembrane topology of human TRPC1 to test this model. We have employed a truncation mutant approach combined with insertions of glycosylation sites into full-length TRPC1. In our truncation mutants, portions of the TRPC1 sequence containing one or more HRs were fused between the enhanced green fluorescent protein and a C-terminal glycosylation tag. These chimeras were transiently expressed in the human embryonic cell line HEK-293T. Glycosylation of the tag was used to monitor its location relative to the lumen of the endoplasmic reticulum and thereby HR orientation. Our data indicate that HRs 1, 4, and 6 cross the membrane from cytosol to the ER lumen, that HRs 2, 5, and 8 have the opposite orientation, and that HR 3 is left out of the membrane on the cytosolic side. Our results also show that the sequence downstream of HR 8 plays an important role in anchoring its C-terminal end on the cytosolic side of the membrane. This effect appears to prevent HR 7 from spanning the bilayer and to result in its forming a pore-like structure of the type previously envisioned for the TRPC channels. We speculate that a similar mechanism may be responsible for the formation of other ion channel pores.

Reversible topological organization within a polytopic membrane protein is governed by a change in membrane phospholipid composition

Once inserted, transmembrane segments of polytopic membrane proteins are generally considered stably oriented due to the large free energy barrier to topological reorientation of adjacent extramembrane domains. However, the topology and function of the polytopic membrane protein lactose permease of Escherichia coli are dependent on the membrane phospholipid composition, revealing topological dynamics of transmembrane domains after stable membrane insertion (Bogdanov, M., Heacock, P. N., and Dowhan, W. (2002) EMBO J. 21, 2107-2116). In this study, we show that the high affinity phenylalanine permease PheP shares many similarities with lactose permease. PheP assembled in a mutant of E. coli lacking phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) exhibited significantly reduced active transport function and a complete inversion in topological orientation of the N terminus and adjoining transmembrane hairpin loop compared with PheP in a PE-containing strain. Introduction of PE following the assembly of PheP triggered a reorientation of the N terminus and adjacent hairpin to their native orientation associated with regain of wild-type transport function. The reversible orientation of these secondary transport proteins in response to a change in phospholipid composition might be a result of inherent conformational flexibility necessary for transport function or during protein assembly.

Mutational and sequence analysis of transmembrane segment 6 orientation in TetA proteins

The packing orientations of the 8 transmembrane (TM) segments that line the central, aqueous transport channel within tetracycline resistance proteins (TetA) have been established. However, the orientations of the remaining 4 segments, TMs 3, 6, 9, and 12, located at the periphery, and away from the transport channel, have not yet been determined. In this study, the packing orientation of TM6 within the class C TetA protein encoded by plasmid pBR322 was evaluated by substitution mutagenesis and analysis of sequence conservation and amphipathicity. The combined data support a model in which the conserved and polar face of the TM6 alpha-helix containing Asn170 and Asn173 orients towards channel-lining TM segments, and the relatively non-conserved and hydrophobic face of TM6 points towards membrane lipids.

Mutational analysis of tetracycline resistance protein transmembrane segment insertion

The tetracycline resistance proteins (TetA) of gram-negative bacteria are secondary active transport proteins that contain buried charged amino acids that are important for tetracycline transport. Earlier studies have shown that insertion of TetA proteins into the cytoplasmic membrane is mediated by helical hairpin pairs of transmembrane (TM) segments. However, whether helical hairpins direct spontaneous insertion of TetA or are required instead for its interaction with the cellular secretion (Sec) machinery is unknown. To gain insight into how TetA proteins are inserted into the membrane, we have investigated how tolerant the class C TetA protein encoded by plasmid pBR322 is to placement of charged residues in TM segments. The results show that the great majority of charge substitutions do not interfere with insertion even when placed at locations that cannot be shielded internally within helical hairpins. The only mutations that frequently block insertion are proline substitutions, which may interfere with helical hairpin folding. The ability of TetA to broadly tolerate charge substitutions indicates that the Sec machinery assists in its insertion into the membrane. The results also demonstrate that it is feasible to engineer charged residues into the interior of TetA proteins for the purpose of structure-function analysis.

Understanding the insertion of transporters and other membrane proteins

Recent studies show that transporters integrate into the lipid bilayer using topogenic sequences present throughout the entire polypeptide chain. These topogenic sequences can act in unpredictable ways with new translocation/stop transfer activities. In addition, a new membrane-insertion pathway has been identified in bacteria with homologs in mitochondria and chloroplasts.

Functional importance and local environments of the cysteines in the tetracycline resistance protein encoded by plasmid pBR322

The properties of the cysteines in the pBR322-encoded tetracycline resistance protein have been examined. Cysteines are important but not essential for tetracycline transport activity. None of the cysteines reacted with biotin maleimide, suggesting that they are shielded from the aqueous phase or reside in a negatively charged local environment.